I love that they question the logistics of the heaven/hell question more than trying to come up with the answer, like 'can we speak to brids' or 'are they actually birds', hahaha, I've never heard this question asked with birds as the door guards, so that's a fun twist, haha I think the answer to that (assuming you only get to ask one question) is to ask something like, "If I ask the other bird what's behind their door, what will they say?" And whatever the answer is, is what's behind the door of the bird you're asking
The answer will be the opposite, right? Say you're asking about the door to heaven, if you ask the truth bird what the other bird will say, they will truthfully say that the liar bird will say it's hell. If you ask the liar bird, they will lie that the truth bird will say it's hell. So either way, you'll get the answer "hell" when it's heaven. And vice versa. EDIT: Oh, you're saying it'll be behind the door of the bird you're asking, which is already the other door than the other bird's. Heh. Yeah, gotcha. I feel like not too long ago, I came across this classic question in another context and someone had a take on it that I hadn't considered yet, but I don't remember what that was.
@@Phagocytosis Yeah, I think that's another answer as well! It just requires the extra step of knowing that it's the opposite answer, but I mean, you still end up knowing which door is which, so it would still be a win, lol And yeah, I'm sure there's other ways to interpret it that I haven't come across! I'm not sure I would ever remember it though, I always have to work this out in my head and then double check the answer every time, cuz it really does confuse me, haha
Wow i have connection.. i know this is a long time ago, but i am in hospital and has missed HAT CHAT and the bois so very very much, but for some magic has happened and i have a connection, so i am binging on the bois while i can. Thank you boys, these are very much need in hard times at the moment.
I think the second hypothetical is the riddle of the Sphinx (just googled - it isn’t). And I think you can only ask one question. So you just ask ‘would the other bird say the door behind you leads to heaven’ if it is the truthful bird it has to tell you what the deceitful bird would say which would be a lie. And the lie bird would lie. So whatever they say you can go with the opposite. If they yes - go to the other door. If they say no go through the door.
Italy doesn't exist in the Mushroom Kingdom. And Pratt is a good voice actor, I don't get the outrage. His shirt was a "don't tread on me" shirt, which admittedly has been cooped by far right but is a slogan older than our country so it's not definitive of anything nefarious by a long shot.
You ask Bird 1 "Would bird 2 tell me your door leads to heaven?" If Bird 1 says "yes" you know Bird 1's door leads to hell. B/C if Bird 1 is the liar, Bird 2 would be the truth teller and would actually tell you B1's is the hell door. If B1 is the truth teller, we know B2 would be lying when it tells you "yes."
I thought the same thing about Sex Education, but I think the point is to model healthy thinking and communication about feelings and problems to young people
Pretty sure they've all watched the movie Labyrinth...and then completely forgotten the scene with the 2 talking doors. It's called the knights and knaves problem, there are 3 solutions. Ask one what the other would say, ask one a provable truth, or ask one if both are liars (or truth tellers).
If it was a catastrophe I would go for the 70 % chance to save everyone. If it was something like a mission to Mars or beyond I would probably opt to sacrifice the 10 people to keep the mission going. Really depends on the circumstances^^
Crist Pratt wearing the Confederate flag is fine. You got to remember the Conferencey, wasn't formed to defend slavery, the south at that time thoght the US government had to much power over what the southern states did, so they formed a confederacy. Its mearly southern pride, but the rest of the world dosen't get it.
I'd ask the lying bird "is hell a good place?" If they answer yes, you know they're lying and the cannot answer "no" because that's the correct answer.
To each bird: "hello, my name is *my name*. What is my name?"
I love that they question the logistics of the heaven/hell question more than trying to come up with the answer, like 'can we speak to brids' or 'are they actually birds', hahaha, I've never heard this question asked with birds as the door guards, so that's a fun twist, haha
I think the answer to that (assuming you only get to ask one question) is to ask something like, "If I ask the other bird what's behind their door, what will they say?" And whatever the answer is, is what's behind the door of the bird you're asking
The answer will be the opposite, right? Say you're asking about the door to heaven, if you ask the truth bird what the other bird will say, they will truthfully say that the liar bird will say it's hell. If you ask the liar bird, they will lie that the truth bird will say it's hell. So either way, you'll get the answer "hell" when it's heaven. And vice versa.
EDIT: Oh, you're saying it'll be behind the door of the bird you're asking, which is already the other door than the other bird's. Heh. Yeah, gotcha.
I feel like not too long ago, I came across this classic question in another context and someone had a take on it that I hadn't considered yet, but I don't remember what that was.
@@Phagocytosis Yeah, I think that's another answer as well! It just requires the extra step of knowing that it's the opposite answer, but I mean, you still end up knowing which door is which, so it would still be a win, lol
And yeah, I'm sure there's other ways to interpret it that I haven't come across! I'm not sure I would ever remember it though, I always have to work this out in my head and then double check the answer every time, cuz it really does confuse me, haha
Wow i have connection.. i know this is a long time ago, but i am in hospital and has missed HAT CHAT and the bois so very very much, but for some magic has happened and i have a connection, so i am binging on the bois while i can. Thank you boys, these are very much need in hard times at the moment.
Thank you for using my fingle! Genre was Hardstyle and im glad that Smith fell in love with it ;)
You say: if i ask the other bird whether his door goes to heaven, what will he say?
Nah, this is where you just use your gut feeling though innit.
@@drayzorn Thank you for reminding me of this legendary Karl response!
@@jwj1283 I’ve got a letter for God
Fantastic podcast lads!
12:41 damn it Ross! Took me three rewinds to make sure it’s not my phone vibrating.😆
I think the second hypothetical is the riddle of the Sphinx (just googled - it isn’t). And I think you can only ask one question. So you just ask ‘would the other bird say the door behind you leads to heaven’ if it is the truthful bird it has to tell you what the deceitful bird would say which would be a lie. And the lie bird would lie. So whatever they say you can go with the opposite. If they yes - go to the other door. If they say no go through the door.
That jingle so heavily reminded me of Scooter.
Trott out here just killing everything.
i'm sorry but that intro song is a banger
Italy doesn't exist in the Mushroom Kingdom.
And Pratt is a good voice actor, I don't get the outrage. His shirt was a "don't tread on me" shirt, which admittedly has been cooped by far right but is a slogan older than our country so it's not definitive of anything nefarious by a long shot.
Dont tread on me is considered a revolutionary war era slogan if I remember correctly.
@@Khronogi it is, which originated prior to the foundation of the United States.
You ask Bird 1 "Would bird 2 tell me your door leads to heaven?"
If Bird 1 says "yes" you know Bird 1's door leads to hell. B/C if Bird 1 is the liar, Bird 2 would be the truth teller and would actually tell you B1's is the hell door. If B1 is the truth teller, we know B2 would be lying when it tells you "yes."
I remember this question from the RSK podcast, it was excruciating to hear Karl work this one out lol
Bird is the word.
I thought the same thing about Sex Education, but I think the point is to model healthy thinking and communication about feelings and problems to young people
Cumbia cumbia cumbiaaa! 0:00
The Mario movie wasn't out of the blue lol
Oh my god, that Bigfoot story was ridiculous, 11 feet?? Even if I was a Bigfoot believer I would be skeptical of that, hahaha, but what a story!
Aren't the Mario Bros from New York with Italian roots?
Question 1 and 3 are exactly the same thing presented in a differernt format.
Pretty sure they've all watched the movie Labyrinth...and then completely forgotten the scene with the 2 talking doors. It's called the knights and knaves problem, there are 3 solutions. Ask one what the other would say, ask one a provable truth, or ask one if both are liars (or truth tellers).
If it was a catastrophe I would go for the 70 % chance to save everyone.
If it was something like a mission to Mars or beyond I would probably opt to sacrifice the 10 people to keep the mission going. Really depends on the circumstances^^
Sex Education is the best Netflix original since House of Cards. I generally avoid teen shit but it's just so much more.
it isn't though. it's trash like the rest of it
Do a collaboration with Survivorman Les Stroud when you go do your Bigfoot hunting.
Trott what you got against Pratt?
Crist Pratt wearing the Confederate flag is fine.
You got to remember the Conferencey, wasn't formed to defend slavery, the south at that time thoght the US government had to much power over what the southern states did, so they formed a confederacy.
Its mearly southern pride, but the rest of the world dosen't get it.
So you either kill 10 for sure or have 30% chances of killing 100? I'd not risk it, kill 10. Utilitarianism, per the train-based ethics question.
I'd kill everyone so I'm the only survivor and I can live off their ass meat.
@@unknownmemoirs gonna be hard to eat all that meat before it goes
I'd ask the lying bird "is hell a good place?" If they answer yes, you know they're lying and the cannot answer "no" because that's the correct answer.
Couldn’t you just ask if you’re dead? How else would you get there if they say no they lie