Do Robbie and Cecilia End Up Together? | Final Scene | Atonement | Screen Bites
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.ย. 2024
- The real truth is that Cecilia and Robbie were never reunited: Robbie died of septicaemia at Dunkirk on the morning of the day he was to be evacuated, and Cecilia died months later in a bombing at central Balham tube station during the Blitz.
Atonement (2007) SYNOPSIS: On July 15, 1988 -- the day of their college graduation -- two people from opposite sides of the tracks begin a lifelong friendship. Emma (Anne Hathaway), an idealist from a working-class family, wants to make the world a better place. Dexter (Jim Sturgess), a playboy, thinks the world is his oyster. For the next 20 years, the two friends reunite on the 15th of each July, sharing dreams, tears and laughter -- until they discover what they've been searching for, each other.
Watch the full movie here: www.uphe.com/m...
Welcome to Screen Bites. The ultimate place for cross overs, mashups, clips, trailers, exclusives behind the scenes, singalongs and so much more! There's nowhere else like this for film fans on TH-cam.
Don't forget to subscribe at / @screenbites
#Atonement #JamesMcAvoy #KeiraKnightley #SaoirseRonan #AcademyAwards #Oscars #OscarsNominations #Romance #Drama #MovieClips
Really great choice to have Briony have the same hair throughout her life. Its like a visual representation that a huge part of her is still that little girl.
It's funny--that ruined it for me. It suspended disbelief too much--no one has the same hairstyle their whole life.
@@SongbirdCollageArts Clearly, you've never met my Aunt Bonnie
@@SongbirdCollageArts tbh i know a few people who had almost the exact hairstyle their entire life
And that tiny hint of red hair left towards the bottom.
more like she is stuck
My heart aches knowing how much people suffered and died during these wars…..and how many soulmates never got the chance to be together again……it makes me appreciate the blessing we have now…
My mother had a serious beau who died in WWII. Don't know which branch of service, or which theater. My father survived four years in the Pacific; they married more than a decade after the war's end. My best friend's father survived the Normandy invasion, I think Omaha Beach. Both men came home with what is now called PTSD.
Yes, we do have many blessings in the West. But I think this decade is going to be the worst since the Great Depression and WWII. Enjoy what we have.
Yeah but peace makes humanity forget it
Imagine if ww3 just broke out
It's gonna be more terrifying than any war that human kind even imagined
@@anonymouspeace5876, you have to enjoy your life, hugs people that you love, tell good words to people. Believe me, we are here in Ukraine understand it. I saw this movie when I was young, I do remember how much I crying in the cinema after this unbelievable story. I never know that I would check every morning my lovely person is he was online ... because he is in the frontline. Unbelievable, bloody, unprovoked war. Horrible.
A lot of people are lonely nowadays anyways, especially men
I need a romance movie with Keira Knightley and James McAvoy where they end up together happily ever after, please.
Same 😭
They have great GREAT chemistry. Was surprised cuz they are an unexpected pair for me.
A tear falls!
I read the book when it first came out, and the ending was devastating. But in the book she is sitting in her room after her birthday party and the revelation is all in her mind. I thought there was no way they could pull it off in the movie. But by having her doing an interview they found the perfect solution. And Atonement is one of the few movies that lived up to the book
I just finished reading the book yesterday. I love this movie so much and I wanted to see how much it differed from the book. For the most part its very similar except for the interview aspect. This story is heartbreaking and beautiful and definitely leaves its mark.
@@DreamingOfDisaster when I saw it in theaters I went with my then-wife and her sisters. They tried to get me to tell them how it ended because they like happy endings. I kept telling them I didn’t remember. They didn’t believe me (back then I had a mind like a steel trap). I didn’t back down.
I've never read the book, but this movie is just beautiful and poignant. I don't think there was anyway an adaptation could have topped this
Cecilia's death is hinted at earlier when we find out she lived in a tiny flat in Balham, though most people outside the UK would not know about this location being where the tube station flooded from a bombing. But agreed, it's a devastating ending nonetheless
@@krabbykat9918I definitely recommend it if you haven't read it yet. I'm still amazed how author wrote about Briony was hitting some nettle with a stick and in her mind she was winning championships. I was immediately brought back to when I was a kid and was playing similarly winning awards and such.
It really do amaze me how author remembered how kid's mind work because I had flashbacks when I was reading it
HONESTLY the most heart-wrenching ending l've ever seen or read in a story.
Some things are unforgivable. This story just hits that home.
In my mind, Robbie and Cecilia lived happily ever after. I only hope to find love like that some day
That is the point. It is a story, you can choose to believe it.
In the book Briony does not say what really happened in an interview like this, so her giving Robbie and Cecilia their happy ending kind of works, because in the minds of the readers, they really survive and live happily ever after.
If they had survived and met each other, there would be no need for atonement!The beautifully written story is all about emotions.I like the way Cecilia softly says”Robbie come back I will wait for you”.That is tear jerker.
Only in the movies. It's part of the fantasy.
Con un final feliz
I hate Saoirse Ronan and Benedict Cumberbatch for this film, their act honestly broke my heart. The casts are so talented that I could really hate the characters
Hate the characters not the actors
Yep, it was strange feeling when i was watching him became a hero. I used to refuse watching Dr. Strange movie. But I had to, before watching the End Game. 😭 I know it's just an acting and it was amazing of them to delivered such an emotion to the audience. They're both great actors ✨
Fax
The acting is why you need to love them. Bc they did so well
God this movie broke my fucking heart
fax
She should feel that way, she did prevent it. Brat didn't give them happiness, she gave them heartache and misery
Mature wise people forgive.
@@EmilyGloeggler7984 that's one of the most naive and incorrect things I've ever read. In the context of this movie/book their lives were completely destroyed and they died because a selfish little brat decided she knew it all with not one shred of evidence.
@@felicitymorris5548 See above.
@@TaxingIsThieving 🤣
What she did was utterly wrong and horrifying, but she was also 13 and far from capable of truly grasping the consequences of her actions by forethought alone. I blame much more every adult that chose to believe her because it was convenient, and then turned a blind eye when it was obvious they had the wrong guy as to not stir the pot. Briony was NOT the only person that helped destroy Robbie and Cecilia’s lives, but she was the youngest and the only one that actually regretted what she did.
Shattering film. Flawless acting. Brilliant cinematography. Heart wrenching score.
This movie really rips your heart out and stomps on it 😪
A little imaginary girl. Thinking that her sister couldn’t possibly want Robbie. It had to be by force. It had to be build up like one of her novels. But.. she knew even then she made a mistake. But she was too much in need of drama. She could have said she was mistaken at any time. It she didn’t. I’m glad she felt guilty for life. She deserved to. It’s one thing to be in shock over the adult world of one’s sister, and not know about desire yet. It’s another of framing Robbie of child r*pe. But she spun her stories and I suppose she did do them one kindness in the end. Although they were not alive to know about it, so to me it feels like she just wanted to rid herself of her guilt.
Robbie was so sweet. His whole life ruined by a little girls fantasies.
She was also jealous because I think she liked Robbie too
@@dreamsteddybearsmaster Oh, she definitely did! She literally drowns herself just so he would save her. I honestly think she never really got over him, those feelings always lingered inside her. She could have told the truth at any point but chose not to and this poor man was labeled a SA for the rest of his life. You could say that Robbie was always going to be drafted to the war but we don't know that, she made it a sure thing with her accusation.
The most heart breaking film I have EVER watched. The first time I saw it I said I would never watch it again. Many years later I watched it again and then remembered why I said I would never watch it again. 😔
its so sad bc robbie was supposed to be evacuated the next day 😭😭 if he made it just a few more hours, they wouldve been reunited and who knows maybe she will not die in a few months if they were together idk
Definitely they would be married and far from the war
Afraid not. With septicemia/sepsis, he was doomed regardless. A few hours would not have mattered; probably not even a few days. The only antibiotic available in 1940, the year of the Dunkirk evacuation, was sulfa/sulfonamide, which is not preferred for sepsis. Pencillin, derivatives of which are used for sepsis, wasn't available until a few years later, and the other classes of antibiotics effective for sepsis were developed later. Nor would the advanced modern ICU treatments which help people survive sepsis have been available 80 years ago.
Even with modern antibiotics and critical care treatment, sepsis kills about 270,000 Americans yearly. Antibiotics are much more likely to be effective early in the course of the disease, and should be started as soon as sepsis is suspected. My father died 25 years ago of sepsis, though he had been getting IV antibiotics for several days immediately prior to his death; someone I knew died last year of sepsis while in the hospital. Admittedly, they were both old and in poor underlying health, but even today, young, healthy people with sepsis who get prompt treatment for the condition can still die. (Most people treated will survive.)
@@marysueeastereggSorry for your loss
Some stories just break you in half, and this is one of them.
vanessa redgrave is absolutely amazing in this scene. 5 minutes of screentime and she pins the whole movie together. and even though she did cause all this heartbreak and tragedy in a sense, you can't help but feel so, so bad for her. she was just a child, acting in a moment of childish spite. and really there was absolutely nothing she could do after that; the dice were cast and there was just no chance for her, or anyone, to take it back. then for her to live a whole life carrying that burden of guilt... she's the third victim in the tragedy.
Vanessa Redgrave was a perfect choice for Older Brioney.
She could read the phone book and still entice us all.
I enjoyed the movie ad then the book.Watched the movie more than once
She is the perfect choice for almost any role she was casted in. Even as Anne Boleyn in A Man for All Seasons. for example, she is in that for like a minute and does not have any lines, but she is mesmerising and effective.
Oh did this ending break my heart Robbie and Cecelia dying during the war and Briony never being able to apologize for what she did so sad 😢
If you watched the movie, you would already know BOTH Robbie and Cecilia died before they could get married.
Just one story out of hundreds of loves that never reunited during the Great war
The Second World War
how is it that my heart breaks again and again everytime i watch or even think of this film.even the music is heartbreaking .great film indeed .
the lie she told when she was 13 destroyed and took happiness from 2 people who should have more time to spend together. imagine if that did not happen Robbie could have become a doctor and the both of them could have a happy life together
Because she was jealous of her sister and infatuated with Robbie
Of all things that could have killed him in the war, it breaks my heart that it was an infection in the trenches
Infections killed lots of people in wars
What trenches?
Unforgivable that she did not confess the truth at any point in her life.
This is like a two part film--it was done brilliantly. It's beautifully shot and tremendously sad. Truly.
There are just things that I couldn't understand from the police's point of view in taking the word of a child without researching it further. I mean...that's my conundrum and I guess, part of the point . It made me angry--not at Briony, but at the adults.
I think briony's character was heavily delusional about her perspective even till the end she thinks she did good by making them (robbie and cee) happier in the book's ending.... Even tho she was pretty much guilty for what she did but not totally.
Oh yeah! She said, "final act of kindness". That's a total delulu.
So bittersweet. I cry every time I see this movie. Always make amends with your family because you never know when it's your time or their time.
One of my favourite films, heartbreaking but I love it.
How sad because she really rob them of their happiness no matter how she puts in the book that was not the real ending and I think she died feeling guilty and the other two!!! People are that evil!! always great movie very real👏🏼🇬🇧😭
Love how this was only uploaded recently! But please edit the synopsis!
This movie broke my heart
Robbie's face at his death just breaks me. He couldnt close his eyes to rest because of the pain. He died suffering :( while holding onto the last pieces of comfort that he has
People get falsely accused a lot, and if the police get it in their heads that they've got their guy then nothing will stop it...can go as far as tampering with evidence or making up evidence. It's such a sad reality, with real consequences. As much as I wish Cecilia and Robbie a happy ending, i appreciate the truth of such a lie being represented.
*LOOKING AT YOU AMBER HEARD AND JANE LEOPOLD CASSIDY. JANE YOU RUINED MY LIFE AND ABUSED AND GROOMED ME AND TRIED TO FORCE ME TO HATE MY DAD BUT I HATE ●YOU● AND ALWAYS WILL*
Gut-wrenching ending. Amazing film.
movie will be seen by next generations
No they didn't end up together! That stupid girl stole their chance of ever finding happiness. They both died! I just hate that little sister and was heartbroken when I found out what really happened to the couple.
thats why the movie is called Atonement. The book the sis wrote is atonement for what she did to them.
A very surface level way of looking at this story.
I wonder what happened to the letter Cecilia wrote him. And I wonder if she knew that Robbie died months before.
I always wonder that too, I hope she didn't because that would have been devastating!
"That I never saw them in that year. That my walk across London ended at the church on Clapham Common, and that a cowardly Briony limped back to the hospital, unable to confront her recently bereaved sister. "
She knew about it.
The ending of this film has stuck with me. I’ve quoted it in a book I’m working on at the moment.
Him hallucinating by the wounds reminds me of jacob's ladder🤔
I dont know why but i really enjoy the pain i feel when watching tragic love story. When the man die i dont know why i really enjoy that feeling of sadness and pain. Anyone could explain?
Even utter despair from a love lost, is better than not having loved at all. It speaks to you, because it quite literally shows you what having lost your own love feels like.
@@shetravels8542 thanks for the information i apreciated it
Same..idek why
You’re an emotional cutter . That’s what we are buddy
1:23 - Very sad detail, he died with his eyes open. He wasn't able to go to sleep and die in a state of relaxation... he died while conscious and in pain.
unbelievable movie
Thank you for cutting the ending out. I haven’t watched the movie, I’ve been thinking should I or shouldn’t. And now I know that I will never watch this movie! I hate unhappy endings. I have enough bad things in our lives to also look at it in movies
This movie is heartbreaking.
I watched this film once - a good few years ago, I absolutely could never watch it again, it rips your heart out and mine is already quite permanently bruised... I couldn't actually bear to watch anything like this.
(Despite the fact that I love James McAvoy which basically makes the whole thing even worse)
i couldn't get through the movie even once. i love james mcavoy and i've been watching through a lot of his filmography but had been avoiding atonement, despite also loving keira knightley and joe wright, because i knew how that movie ends. today i finally tried watching it and i only got about half-way through. my little heart just couldn't bare the pain.
Romance in real life:
Broke my heart
It’s her atonement. Not their happiness. But she was a child and children aren’t fully capable of understanding the consequences of their acts.
A fairytale ending because it was a fantasy, imagination that they ended up together.
The only movie that really broken my heart to pieces... 😢
This may be the best book I have ever read. Certainly the most haunting and memorable. Good film adaptation.
My heart is breaking because of the sad ending of their relationship... Here, in Ukraine, i see such things all the time and understand that I or my love - we can be next each moment....😢
It is always make me cry
I watched this movie for the first time today and it destroyed me 😭
That lil brat was such a mess😭
The truth sadness about love and life, indeed…How slandered, jealousy and war could ruin others, even regret could not have paid for it all lifetime
I think the synopsis in the description is for One Day (2011).
yes they do end up
together
This scene reaaly broke me 😭 and after i finished this movie , I was not even over it ,I watched NORMAL PEOPLE ,God literraly the worst mistake I literally again cried for days. These two film and series will always be my favourite and have a special place in my heart and taught me many things ❤
Your synopsis is from an entirely different film.
Yeah right. Wtf is that about? Lol
@@jakemac1396 this is in the actual film wdym
@@EiyaTV the explanation of the film didn't match the movie playing when that was typed. I don't know if they fixed it since or not
Yeah the synopsis is of the movie "One Day"
too sad, I was shocked because I thought it would be a good ending..
First time I saw this movie I was on the verge of tears when they showed that Robby died.
One of the worst fears a man can face is to be blamed for a crime he didn’t commit. Especially one that is an act against women or children.
The man’s life was ruined is every single way because of a crazy girl’s immaturity. This happens so much in these days, and there doesn’t seem to be any consequences for the women that do this type of disgusting behavior.
Ah, the Redgraves.
This is a real gut punch. But it really shows the realism of what cldve been if she didn't make a false accusation.
Please can someone edit a happy ending to this movie that I can watch instead of this one 😂😭
Please fix the synopsis- totally different movie....
Jesus this movie hurt..
An entire generation of good, honest men turned to fodder. It's not fair.
This shows how the war destroyed so many lives Benedict’s character was rich and profited from the war so his life was fine even though he was the villain it shows how life can be so brutally indifferent to what is right and wrong
Did you watch the movie, read the Book?
It was Not the War that Killed Robbie and Cicila. Briony Killed them.
Briony Lied and got Robbie arrested. He spent many years in Prison.
Robbie would have gotten his college degree and would have been an officer in the War instead of a lowly Private on the front line. Robbie was killed because of the danger he was constantly in by being a Private in the Infantry the Most Dangerous occupation in the War.
Cecilia and Robbie would have gotten married long before the war. She would have lived a completely different life. She wouldn't have been killed in the Subway.
Briony was as EVIL a Character as has ever been written.
I don’t think the point of the book and movie is to hate briony I think it was both briony and the war I don’t think briony was completely evil it was a misunderstanding of a young girl she was evil in a way yes but she felt remorse which is why she put them in a book she was sorry for what she did but couldn’t change it in real life The real villain is the chocolate millionaire he was an adult and knew briony wasn’t telling the truth but he didn’t admit that he did it the war ruined a lot of lives including officers so I think it was a mixture of war briony and chance it shows how life isn’t always fair even to good people..that’s just my thoughts on it
Did Paul Marshall get aressted after that?
I don’t think so, it said in the book that Briony’s book wouldn’t be published until the Marshalls died as per the publisher.
This is when Hollywood was still putting out incredible Oscar worthy films. Before the woke garbage.
Define woke?
@@prettimama2010 your momma.
@@prettimama2010 2020-2024 Biden Error 👎 anyways back to the film 💔🥹
Hollywood?
Why wasnt she in the subway too?
I'm an adult and I think I'm mature but I'll never forgive that horrible little girl!!! Not only did he irreparably destroy the life of a very sweet, kind, good and very much in love with Cecila, but he destroyed his sister's life out of "jealousy" (let's admit it, he had a crush on Robbie). Liar, envious and coward until the end and beyond, (unfortunately I lent the book and they didn't give it back to me), the ending with the interview only made me even more angry: totally cowardly not to admit and invent an end of convenience while those two soul mates are death in an atrocious way without being able to see each other again and love as it was right !!! I cried every time Robbie said (or thought) "our future can start again" , and Cecilia; "... it completely devastated me !!! I would like Joe Writh (I think ) the director to do it again but by making Robbie go home to Cecilia . And I have to agree with those who spoke of septicemia : in 2006 (coincidentally when the film I contracted septicemia and I'm alive by chance and due to the skill of the doctors, but I was practically already half dead Robbie couldn't have survived .... not in 1940 ... I deluded myself that at least in the end they could find each other in Heaven .... I just conclude by saying that both James McAvoy and Keira were very good , they gave me (especially James ) such deep and intense emotions that I could not stop crying .. nor sleep ....
Теперь в сто раз трагичнее воспринимаются военные сюжеты. Какой кошмар, какая боль.
Why Was Cecilia In There... Hasn't She Got A Home
During the Blitz, usually citizens went to air raid shelters. Balham Station was one of them. During the Blitz, a semi-armour-piercing fragmentation bomb fell on the road above Balham and killed 64 people. Cecilia, had she existed, would have been killed alongside them.
@@albinpepe9057 Oh.. I Got It. Thank You Very Much.
Yeah and also she disowned her family after what they did to Robbie I believe
Yes, change the ending so you dont look like an absolute raging khunt
After Wurhering Heights such a terrible ending either in a movie or a book
No
I was suspended living in a shelter for having manicure instruments that I kept open not hidden. I was forced to live in a dormant environment that was formally a mortuary. I slept on a hard floor and when the room quote unquote was filled, we slept in the hallway. What's its like being homeless, hopeless and abandoned
Statement, mine
Have you lived my life?
6.6.2022
6.16.22
Harvest
Similarities
Synchronization