Maxmud Xareed , did you even read my comment? Let me help you: I said _if_ I would be a follower of people. Did I say, I am not studing myself? No I did not.
Then u would be following the guy with the least amount of credibility in the Islamic world. He has no credibility for a reason. Islam was designed specifically to not have the same issues of Christianity. It was designed to be a conservative religion and Shabir is doing mental gymnastics to change it. Real Muslims see through that. Hence no followers.
So far as the modern day scholars of Islam I have learned,you are best of them Dr Shabir.May Allah Bless You and Let the Quran Speak team for doing true Dawah to Muslims as well as Non-Muslims ! Ameen !
I am a recent revert and I love the Quran but I can say hadiths have greatly damaged my imaan.. I love God, this no one can take away from me InshAllah, but I am now having a lot of moral conflicts with Islam as it is understood by the majority who place a major importance on Hadith. May Allah guide us
raquel My dear sister. Don't be afraid to hesitate and have moral conflicts. Don't you ever feel guilty. That shows that you are sincere. The Holy Quran is our main source. Have patience and seek knowledge and understanding and depend on Allah. He is the best Guide.
Salam sister, Don't be upset, the main source is Quran and every law comes from it. God will judge us upon his words ie Quran, and not on hadiths. Islam is a simple religion and many generations lived without knowing one hadith.... Read Quran often and ponder on it and Allah will grant you peace inchallah. salam.
Welcome dear sister! Your heart will allow you to discern - when you're confronted by things that are abrasive to your heart, just know them as likely to be false and trust in Allah to guide you through your intentions to please Him and be your best self. Quran is the reference, and if you ever find anything in Quran that you struggle with - persist in the quest for knowledge, insha Allah, Allah will always resolve your doubts and provide you with deep understanding. And please don't overburden yourself early on - remember the Prophet PBUH was teaching tawhid for 10 years before even introducing the disciplines of the path.
ishq noor thank you for your words ishq, and everyone else who had replied to my comment. I am trying I really am but there are some things I am really struggling to comprehend. I do not wish to become a cherry picking Muslim, I know this is hypocritical, but I often times feel that it is the only way to keep me on this path. I just wish more Muslim, scholars in particular, spoke about this struggle. These are doubts that are rooted in feeling that I feel are comprehensively valid based on basic human morale, e.g. certain controversial Hadith and ayahs, and coming from a catholic background I often times feel the same shaming, for having questions and uncertainties, that strayed me away from Christianity. I trust Allah and I just pray anyone with this struggle doesn't lose faith in Him due to the pain and confusion of this dunya..
i think the best option is to always keep it simple. If you are certain theres a lord then you should be certain that the quran is his spoken work. If your uncertain you need to do you own research/studies to find out for yourself. Its a miracle and it speaks for itself. any other additives should be based on your capacity if your willing to put the pressure on yourself. There is a quote from the quran" Allah wants ease for you and does not seek to burden you"
So glad that I've found this videos to clarify so many things that been pushed in radical way to people. I truly believe and love Allah so much and practicing islam best of my abilities. But i have so many doubts about those scholars who are so certain that everything recorded in hadit is 100% true which most of them are not said from our prophet s.a.s. Allah knows best
Many are talking as Dr. Shabir Ally is renouncing the Hadith; He's not. He is simply saying hadith are collected and verified by human wisdom; which can be flawed as human him/her self is flawed. There is no need to be getting judgmental or emotional on it. I agree with him.
The reason We find Hadith so problematic and Quran so authentic is another proof of the divine origin and preservation of the Quran. Hadith is on the other hand a historical account of the Prophet's sayings and does contain things that people invented on their own and hence problematic.
Hadith is not a scripture or the Scripture of Islam. Qur'aan is THE Scripture of Islam. Qur'aan is the authority and is obligatory on all Muslims. Hadith is just a collection of tales, stories and unsubstantiated narrations collected by men from Central Asia. Those men never sat in the company of the Prophet or his companions or even in the company of their grand children. Many of the ahaadith are ridiculous and absurd. They do not stand correct under the scrutiny of Qur'aan. Any hadith that does not stand correct under the scrutiny of Qur'aan should be discarded and trashed. Instead of Hadith, Muslims should read, study and understand Qur'aan.
SO DOES QURAN SAY HOW TO PRAY NAMAZ?IT SAYS PRAY NAMAZ BUT DOESNT TELL A PERSON HOW TO.SAME WITH HAJJ & ZAKAH QURAN SAYS ITS OBLIGATORY BUT DOESNT TELL YOU HOW TO.SO A PERSON HAS TO GO TO HADITH
two of the five pillars of islam are from the hadiths. so when muslims pray 5 times a day they are blindly following muhammad or whoever wrote the hadith. if the hadiths are made up stories then the origins & history of islam didn't exist as the muslim narrative claims. the Qur'an is just a mix of ancient beliefs, religions, cultures, superstitions, rituals etc. it's full of contradictions and 100% is not from god, an angel, or a prophet. it was created to justify & support invasions, aswell as brainwash people into being controlled by a powerful empire. every popular religion was either created or spread by a powerful empire. what better place to create a prophet, holy city & new religion, than mecca which had no history.
@@asavlogsalltruthrevealed7483 idk about you, but us muslims learn how to pray by watching how our parents/elders, and the people around us did it, its passed down generations after generations
@@abdulmuhammad7379 that's a bunch of B.S. How can it have been created by a powerful empire? It was channeled by one man alone and he was persecuted because of it by the ruling people of his city. You've lost the plot.
@Dr Shabir Ali: May Allah guide you and bless you for your many kindnesses: Is there a program or video where you address discriminating between well accepted hadith and those of questionable origin. I like your balanced approach to using the hadith to counsel interpretation of the Quran rather than as a behavioral code of itself. Is there a line one can draw between what are the most dependable hadith and which are questionable? Thanks in advance.
"Bismillahir rahmaniir Rahiim!" Hadith is forbidden even on Prophet Muhammad pbuh in Quran 69;44-46. It caused the division of the One Ummah into sects also forbidden in Quran 30:32; 42;14-15; 43;64-65; 45;17, 28 because of varied opinions of men. Islam is the Quran Alone, complete, perfect, clear, in detail, nothing to add, alter nor delete, it being Sealed against corruption, change or alteration. Please don't mislead innocent people of your belief in hadiths. Masha'allah! Subhanallah! Alhamdulillah! Allahu'akbar!
The Quran makes it clear that we have to follow the teachings of the Prophet (S.A.W). "And let those who oppose the Messenger's commandment beware lest some fitnah befall them or a painful torment be inflicted on them." (24:63) "He who obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah; but those who turn away - We have not sent you over them as a guardian." (4:80) We can not pick and choose which teachings to follow based on how "problematic" they are for us. We follow the Quran and Sunnah in their entirety because we are instructed to by Allah (S.W.T). Also, I have to point out the leaps in logic that this man is making. Just because a verse in a Quran tells of a group of people who owned a dog, suddenly the saliva of a dog is not impure? The Prophet (S.A.W) set certain conditions for which we can own a dog. Ibn Umar narrated that the Messenger of Allah said: "whoever keeps a dog, two Qirats will be detracted from his reward each day, except a trained hunting dog, or a dog for herding livestock." Did this conditions apply before the Quran was revealed to the Prophet (S.A.W) (meaning, did these conditions apply to the followers of Allah before us) we do not know. But it is clear that for us Muslims, these are the conditions for owning a dog. The Prophet (S.A.W) also made it clear that the saliva of a dog is impure. Abu Hurairah narrated that the Prophet (S.A.W) said: "To purify one's vessel licked by a dog, he should wash it seven times, the first time with dust." As for what he said regarding usury, I'd like to share this hadith narrated by Abu Juhaifa: "The Prophet (ﷺ) forbade the use of the price of blood and the price of a dog, the one who takes (eats) usury, the one who gives usury, the woman who practises tattooing and the woman who gets herself tattooed." The one who takes usury and the one who gives usury. Where's the misunderstanding? It was also narrated by Abdullah bin Masud that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) cursed the one who consumes usury, the one who pays it, those who witness it and the one who writes it down. Sorry for the long post, just had to point this out.
So you also differentiate between mwattar and non mwattar hadiths. There is no way to justify that all hadith can be truly attributed to The Holy Prophet PBUH.
Very informative particularly the discussion on interest. From this i see that my understanding of interest was incorrect. I hope to see a longer discussion on interest as it relates to the Mu'min living in a modern capitalist society in a future show.
The founders of this chain have noble aspirations but the irony is that there is a hadith that predicts that there will be a time when Muslims will no longer want to follow the Hadiths and the Sunnah and will claim to restrict themselves to the Qur'an. Anyone with discernment must understand that renouncing to the hadith will result in the collapse of Islam. The faith of those who follow the Qur'an alone would not be translated into clear actions and would remain on a conceptual level, closer to philosophy than to the great religion of Islam that embraces real life in all its details and complexity. The example of the hadith prohibiting interest, either taken or given, mentioned by Dr Shabir, clearly shows that without hadith Muslims will start behaving like non-Muslims in almost any field, arguing that the Qur'an doesn't explicitly prohibit what they are doing.
NO! i don't like this at all!. don't compromise your religion because you need a house! God is the one who gives and takes. Ask God for help and stay true to his commands, don't interpret in a way that works best for you but as well be at the risk of being wrong. Let God give to you. There are many halal loans you can look for. The interest/loaning system is flawed and against humanity, to its core!
Dr. Shabir needs to be a little more careful and clarify more when debunking hadith, particularly the hadith on riba (interest rates and loans/mortgages): it's a saheeh hadith that is to be taken for granted and not only the taker of the interest is very sinful but the one who gives and witnesses as well. Why? Because it's not only about the poor giving more money to the rich, but it's also about the poor supporting the corrupt banking system based on riba, and there is a verse in the Quran clearly prohibiting muslims to aid anyone in sinful matters such as supporting the corrupt banking system with your riba payments. Moreover, there is a hadith that says that eating or giving or witnessing riba is so much sinful it is 40 times worse than adultery. Imagine how bad it is now in the eyes of Allah and set your priorities straight. Muslims are above all supposed to conduct jahd, i.e. put effort in following their religion, not adjusting to the corrupt systems and supporting them with their penny. Be very cautious: you are not allowed to take a loan/mortgage from a non-islamic bank in any circumstance, so you need to look for other options, and there are enough of them.
I love this Channel also. Now for the comment from the sister in the video, she mentioned that the dog issue is a smaller one, perhaps she feels this way because as she said she is afraid of dogs. My feeling is that she doesn't have a clear understanding of what dogs are all about so considers it a small issue. So please to this channel, the dog issue is in fact huge and I would like more deep facts about this topic, why you may ask ? Because there horrible neglect towards dogs in muslim countries because of this weak hadiths and we cannot just let it go. Muslims need to step up to the realization that we have to be kind to dogs on the streets and provide them with food and water and not just say they are dirty street animals. PLEASE ENOUGH IS ENOUGH.......DO SOMETHING FOR ALLAH'S CREATURES. being a good Muslim is being kind towards all animals on earth.
Bcoz in quran how to pray namaz what actions to perform and what to speak is not mentioned we have to get knowledge from hadith not all hadiths are true bur some aretrue
Mmm... Need the hadist to guide us about how to pray?.. 200 years after prophet died then the hadist compiled.. I wonder those lives during that 200 years, how they pray? How to pray was taught by out beloved prophet directly to all his companions where in turn kept on teaching to all Muslims passing down generation...
@@nazree1975 guidance comes from Allah and there is none who can guide better than Allah and He gives plenty to His grateful servants ...I do not worship Muhammad because I am commanded by Allah not to associate anything with Him ...Muhammad is dead and Allah lives ,
@@vakilahmad8085 I agree with you- it is the Quran that is the Hadith that we need. My only question is, was the knowledge of how to perform Salah passed down from generation to generation??
@@Oshianis salaat was being performed before Muhammad and can be dated back to Abraham...it can be performed any way as said in Quran, you can read it sitting , standing, or laying down or with others who worship Allah ...Sunni and Shia both politicise salaat ...salaat is for God alone and not for Muhammad or Ali or anyone else ...Allah is full of wisdom and He made commandments in Quran on purpose to lead people out of darkness...if you look for guidance outside of Gods book , know that you have exchanged guidance for error ....read quran ...
The problem is not the Hadith, what I see and come acrossed many times is that, many of us are not equipped with Islamic knowledge. We rely on 'words of mouth', and when one is ignorant about Islamic and Arabic knowledge, one is easy to get confused and become the easy target of Satan. Learn your Deen in depth and in sincere way, and by Allah the TRUTH will be clear to you. Don't just rely on what this Brother is saying but rely with self-sacrificed Islamic studies under proper Sheikhs, who are well rounded in all fields of Islamic Laws.
bad advice. don't listen to any muslim because their interpretations always different and incorrect. would you rather hear stories of islam from someone who reads books on islam, or hear it directly from allah, muhammad & his companions??. just read the tafsirs & hadiths because it's impossible to understand the Qur'an without the context. once muslims read the evil teachings from muhammad they will soon realise he was a false prophet
I request Dr. Shabbir to clarify the following : during the times of Prophet (PBUH) dogs would inside masjid e Nabawi and nobody had any problem with it. Please clarify.
Dear Dr. Shabir you are an awesome person. I love listening to you and the way how you explain the very complex topics related to our religion. However, with regards to Hadith, I am just wondering why we have to have one Coran and 1000th of Hadiths. Is it not enough to have the Coran the WORD of GOD as the most important book only and NOT the Hadith which is based on comments and opinions of human beings who think they understand and interpret the Coran better. Somehow I do have the feeling that the Hadith plays a much more important role in Islam than the Coran does, a fact which is quite frightening.
As a Muslim you are instructed to follow the Quran and the authentic Sunnah. By rejecting the Sunnah you become a disbeliever and reject your faith. Please learn more on Islam and speak with a knowledgeable sheik in your community.
Shabir Ali my brother beware of introducing logic to this community. You will be condemned and branded a kaafir quicker then you can imagine my friend.
Threatening or warning for what. Truth from allah is truth from Allah. And we should not be fearing people's opinions. Our beloved prophet pbuh had more fear for God than man. That's a lesson we can all take.
Where I come from I see lots of very beutiful mosques being built every year and around it are shanties/ huts where very poor people , people who may not even afford one meal a day live, so I ask you brothers and sisters in Islam..do we have our priorities right? Kann a hungry and homeless Person concentrate in worship?
Im a big fan of the shaykh, but on the dog issue I differ. According to all narrations from the Ahlul Bayt which we have, is that the dog, all of the dog, if wet, is impure and najis. If the dog is not wet then that impurity will not contaminate you. Hence, the dog is impure and more so the mouth and saliva which is always wet.
there is a hadith were muhammad tells his companions not to write about him. so hadiths contradict other hadiths. same with the Qur'an, it's full of contradictions
Very disappointed with this segment. I do respect your views on most things. However, I was surprised to hear you actually skirting the topic of discussion. The saliva of dogs example? Was that all you could think of as problematic Hadith? Didn’t expect this from you.
I am afraid I will have to disagree with you dear brother! Even if you have to buy a house, you can wait and buy it when the time is right! What's the rush? Getting credit from the bank only supports the system of Kufr. Moreover, we are all tenants of dunya for I will not buy one for myself Insha'Allah even though I may be as old as you.
Hasan Yildiz the Hadith about the 5 people involved in interest is authentic. We have to guard ourselves against interest. That is his opinion and based on any usul of Fiqh. Caution Caution Caution fellow Muslims
@@hasanyildiz9364 Getting credit from the bank only supports the system of Kufr. That's what you wrote. So it is not a silly question. Your comment is worthless like you.
In some parts of the West, namely US, Canada, UK, etc., even average regular houses are so expensive, you need $1 million to buy a house. Preventing Muslims from taking out a loan to purchase a house, means they pay more money in rent (in some areas mortgage payments are cheaper than rent), which pays the mortgage of their landlords, which still pays for that interest. This keeps Muslims artificially poor compared to others who can get into property ownership earlier.
I respect Dr. Shabbir for his knowledge, but disregarding sahih hadiths and calling it a balanced approach is so wrong. It's picking and choosing as ones liking.
Anything that is contradictory with Quran can't be authentic simple is that. We have follow both Quran & Hadiths. But we can not follow those Hadiths which are contradictory with Quran. Quran is reserved by Allah himself. Hadiths can be manipulated because it is not reserved by Allah himself.
I am a Christian and I strive to respect all other religions, in particular knowledgeable scholars such as Dr. Ally, but I really can't relate to such things as the saliva of dogs, or similar that seem to be FAQ or more than just details of the doctrine. My question is: how those kind of things are supposed to be of any use to an individual living in XXI who is willing to build a personal relationship with the Lord?
@Yotchat Margui So you cherry-pick those that are authentic? Who has discernment about that? And who decides who is entitled? As far as I know many of those that are problematic are still accounted to be authentic in a way. I am sorry but your answer seems to me quite vague and without any references.
I'm not sure I agree with his view on interest payments. If you are giving interest you are knowingly contributing to making the rich richer. Think about it if there was no demand from people accepting loans with interest then it would not be profitable for banking institutions to lend with interest
Then your only option is to rent a house, the renter more than likely has a house on a buy-to-let mortgage, so you're still making the rich richer, and you're still enabling someone else to partake in interest.
As Salaam Alaakum. Dogs are not Haram, they can be used for Hunting ,and protecting ,and guiding a blind person, and not for pets. RIBA IS HARAM , Period.
@@abdiganisugal825 I think he means the Giving of it. Because the Qur’an forbids Taking (eating) interest and is defending against the greedy. I’m no expert may Allah continue to give me more knowledge. But this is my interpretation. Because I don’t understand how GIVING internet voluntarily can be beneficial to anyone.
Shabir Ally You have to stop following self written hadith and books. Allaah ❤❤❤The Alknown has strictly forbidden us in The Qo'raan The Perfect Word of Allaah ❤❤❤ The Almighty. They add things to The Word of Allaah❤❤❤ The Most Loved. This is SHIRK.
Please Dr Shabbir, Please advise how to get rid of Hadith in this last revelation from God. So many contradict the Quran and thus making people turn into fanatics and extreme in worship and quite distant with living in this world. Why is hadith apart of this religion so much.
Yes, quranites are on a dangerous road. Because there is no prohibition of cremation in the Qur'an, they think its ok to cremate your dead. Quran comes first, yes. But authentic hadith is also important.
Suz Mia Your answer is Saudi Arabia and Wahhabism... they appointed themselves the modern guardians of the faith and used their petro-riches to peddles around the world fake Ahadeeth supporting their fake corrupt and violent version of Islam. This has caused enormous confusion within Islam and complete misrepresentation of Islam to non muslims.
Serious problems with shabir ally's views and in his 3rd way. There are different levels of Munkireen Hadith. Unfortunately shabbir ally falls in one of these categories. his knowledge of Hadith seems to be very poor and is giving opinions where he is out of depth. Beware of the erroneus 3rd way he is suggesting. Deen is complete and not in need of his 3rd way which has sprung up after 1400y. probably Imam Malik said beware of the thing in Deen that you don't have a precedent in .
This man makes little sense, if there's a "conflict" in your opinion but the hadith is saheeh, then are you saying the prophet has lied and not to take it over Qur'an?!
the People of the cave were not muslims eventhough they were people of the book but they have different rulings than the Muslims.. they dont do the shalat the way we do etc etc .. so its not wise to take example from generations before the coming of Rasulullah which were the Jews and Christians and apply it to God’s rulings that came with his Prophethood..
Really?! They were Muslims so much so that Allah Subhanehu Teala mentioned their name in Quran. Get your facts right! All the Prophets and the ones who follow them were Muslims.
@Yotchat Margui They were a bunch of youngsters who worshipped only the one and only God (Allah). So they escaped from their people and sheltered themselves in a cave and slept there about 309 years. Finally, when it was safe for them to show up, the one and only God (Allah) awakened them. Some narrations mention that they were Christians,but not the Christianity of today's world for sure. Because today's Christianity is corrupted by Trinity nonsense which invalidates itself.
@Yotchat Margui There is a chapter named after them in Quran . However, their numbers, religion and so on were not mentioned in it. They were mentioned to focus on the oneness of Allah and how these youngsters were on the straight path.
Because Eastern viewpoint has failed many many times. Why do you not just admit it! Whose idea was dividing ourselves into sects and many Cemaat?! Even though there is a strict order in Quran not to do so!
The worst problem is HADITH AND NOT QURAN PUTTING MUSIC 🎶 AND MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS IN THE SAME CATEGORY AS INTOXICANTS AND OBVIOUS other transgressions that are PLAINLY STATED IN THE BOOK 📖 WHICH MAKES THINGS CLEAR! And this issue has apparently been going on FOR OVER A THOUSAND YEARS NOW! JUST LIKE MUSLIMS WHENEVER TRYING TO MAKE A POINT OF THE MAGNIFICENCE OF OUR LORD AND HIS PERSPICUOUS BOOK! AS A MATTER OF FACT; THE QURAN ITSELF IS MUSICAL! AND I BEING MUSICALLY INCLINED AM ABLE TO REMEMBER VERSES OF THE QURAN BY DECIPHERING ITS “MELODY”! Lest I forget; sometimes I play the melody of a verse like”wa huwal lazee khallakal Laila wannahaara washamsa wal qamara kullun fee falikini yahsbahoon”. That verse was unintelligible for me to repeat, and then very difficult for me to remember, until I deciphered it’s MUSICAL MELODY! NOT RYHTOM OR WORDS! I can learn to memorize any verses, but without the music of it, even other Muslims wouldn’t like it, or even recognize what I was saying! AS SALAMU ALAIKUM WA BARAKATU.
The next time..u will say....i could not feel God..until i put a statue of a man on wall and then i realy felt God in me....religiin is not about what u fèel...its about lows and its guidance...
So..dr shabir..what u are trying to teach the umma is....we read the quran and do what is says without consulting the hadith????and we only go for hadith what we didnt get from the quraan???is it not the hadith that expalins in details about the verses???is not that if we let everyone to have his opinion on what he understood in the verses then every one will have his own opinion????then where will be the guidance????any ways..people like u were mentioned as well..the people of opinions..be ware of them.....u miss guide people dr shabir.....
Salam alaikum brother shaber the problem is not in the Hadith its in us and the way we interprete the Quran and Hadith the methdology can only be correct if one has knowledge and its correct understanding we all know that some Ahadith are week and some r even false. Giving intrest .the hadith that u mentioned is saheeh its in acordence with the Quran if some one wants to know ask me and i will reply. 2 resemblence with jews and christains its not in normal clothes rather its in mantality On top of every Alim is another Alim May Allah widen our chests so we can see clearly Ameen
exactly. to follow only part of islam & reject the rest is just creating your own islam. most muslims are ignorant to whst islam actually teaches because they are only willing to follow the specific teaching that they like. either muslims have to admit thd Qur'an, tafsirs, hadiths are corrupt, or they must admit they follow satan
@@onlineteacher9171 So you say that Allah is the God to all mankind. Okay Is Allah the God of the Bible? Is Allah words are eternal and they can not be. Change? You tell me
@Yotchat Margui Why is it that Allah the God of the Bible 1. Calls jesus his Son 2. Allah calls jesus his Son and God 3 Allah the God of the Bible calls jesus the final Messenger to bring the word of God to mankind. But muhammad teaches the opposite of what the Bible teaches. So either Allah is mistaken or muhammad is mistaken.
@Yotchat Margui Ya the same the quran is corrupted by muhammad who is not a true prophet of God No muslims has been able to prove that muhammad is a prophet using the Torah and the injeel
@Ketah's Little Bubble u think its funny LOL but u no damn well Islam is not fair to woman, man will get 72 virgins on top of his earthly wife..now proof me wrong!!!! atleast tell me what u going to get in heaven as a woman..let me see the surah too proof ur right ok LOL
@@freddytorres3609 may peace be upon you. 1) only martyrs will get 72 virgins in Jannah. Not every Muslim that dies. Just the martyrs. 2) the verse that talks about the pure spouse, actually says THEY will get pure spouses. It didn't say men will get pure spouses. Men AND women will get pure spouses. 3) if you actually knew how we are supposed to treat our women according to the Qur'an and Hadiths, you'd want to change your gender to a female if you're a male. Because husbands owe their wives basic rights AND much more, whereas the wife owes her husband basic rights and if she wants, more. (Depends on her love for the husband)
You guys do great work but I can’t believe this “dr” and Muslim doesn’t know Quran! The Quran NOT HADITH CLEARLY says interest is unlawful surah 2:275. So please don’t mislead our Ummah to pacify a “modern “ life.
It is not clear at all. 2:275 says riba is prohibited and there is much discussion about the definition of riba - is it all interest or is is usury - exploitation of the indebted poor. Caliph Umar remarked after the prophets death that he regretted that the prophet did not explain what he meant by riba.
In Islam the veil is to protect a woman's beauty and to keep them modest so men are not swayed by them so easily, but don't take my shaky word for it and research, there are tons of vids in this on TH-cam! Select the right ones!!
Shabir Ally is a coward. He once agreed to debate the Christian Prince but backed out of the debate at the last minute after reading the Christian Prince's book. The Christian Prince would chew Shabir up and spit him out in a debate that is why Shabir ran away....
![ปฏิเสธไม่ไหว (Crush on you) - LIPTA feat. No One Else [TEASER MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VC689EgdSIw/mqdefault.jpg)
![ค้างคืนโรงเก็บกระสวยอวกาศร้างกลางทะเลทราย [Around The World Ep. 3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/E5bWZQhABJE/mqdefault.jpg)
If I would be a follower of people, I'd say I'd follow Dr. Shabir. Your reasoning and clear vision of Islam is so refreshing. Thank you again.
sister don't be a fun or a follower anyone .study islam by yourself also see my comment above it is a response to shabir ali
Maxmud Xareed , did you even read my comment? Let me help you: I said _if_ I would be a follower of people. Did I say, I am not studing myself? No I did not.
I also recommend that you check out Adnan Ibrahim and Hassan Farhan Al-Maliki.
Then u would be following the guy with the least amount of credibility in the Islamic world. He has no credibility for a reason. Islam was designed specifically to not have the same issues of Christianity. It was designed to be a conservative religion and Shabir is doing mental gymnastics to change it. Real Muslims see through that. Hence no followers.
So far as the modern day scholars of Islam I have learned,you are best of them Dr Shabir.May Allah Bless You and Let the Quran Speak team for doing true Dawah to Muslims as well as Non-Muslims ! Ameen !
Listen to a person named ghamdi...
I am a recent revert and I love the Quran but I can say hadiths have greatly damaged my imaan.. I love God, this no one can take away from me InshAllah, but I am now having a lot of moral conflicts with Islam as it is understood by the majority who place a major importance on Hadith. May Allah guide us
raquel My dear sister. Don't be afraid to hesitate and have moral conflicts. Don't you ever feel guilty. That shows that you are sincere. The Holy Quran is our main source. Have patience and seek knowledge and understanding and depend on Allah. He is the best Guide.
Salam sister,
Don't be upset, the main source is Quran and every law comes from it. God will judge us upon his words ie Quran, and not on hadiths. Islam is a simple religion and many generations lived without knowing one hadith.... Read Quran often and ponder on it and Allah will grant you peace inchallah. salam.
Welcome dear sister! Your heart will allow you to discern - when you're confronted by things that are abrasive to your heart, just know them as likely to be false and trust in Allah to guide you through your intentions to please Him and be your best self. Quran is the reference, and if you ever find anything in Quran that you struggle with - persist in the quest for knowledge, insha Allah, Allah will always resolve your doubts and provide you with deep understanding. And please don't overburden yourself early on - remember the Prophet PBUH was teaching tawhid for 10 years before even introducing the disciplines of the path.
ishq noor thank you for your words ishq, and everyone else who had replied to my comment. I am trying I really am but there are some things I am really struggling to comprehend. I do not wish to become a cherry picking Muslim, I know this is hypocritical, but I often times feel that it is the only way to keep me on this path. I just wish more Muslim, scholars in particular, spoke about this struggle. These are doubts that are rooted in feeling that I feel are comprehensively valid based on basic human morale, e.g. certain controversial Hadith and ayahs, and coming from a catholic background I often times feel the same shaming, for having questions and uncertainties, that strayed me away from Christianity.
I trust Allah and I just pray anyone with this struggle doesn't lose faith in Him due to the pain and confusion of this dunya..
i think the best option is to always keep it simple. If you are certain theres a lord then you should be certain that the quran is his spoken work. If your uncertain you need to do you own research/studies to find out for yourself. Its a miracle and it speaks for itself. any other additives should be based on your capacity if your willing to put the pressure on yourself. There is a quote from the quran" Allah wants ease for you and does not seek to burden you"
I believe in one rule - whatever contradict Quran is invention no matter it's in Bukhari or usool kaafi
And whatever that does not contradict Quran MAY ALSO be fabricated. Remember that.
Can anyone plz guide me on keeping pants, trousers etc above ankle??
I love this channel, so much clarity and peacefulness, thank you!
shabir ally needs to do a long video on understanding hadith. please for the sake of Allah do it.
So glad that I've found this videos to clarify so many things that been pushed in radical way to people.
I truly believe and love Allah so much and practicing islam best of my abilities. But i have so many doubts about those scholars who are so certain that everything recorded in hadit is 100% true which most of them are not said from our prophet s.a.s.
Allah knows best
Many are talking as Dr. Shabir Ally is renouncing the Hadith; He's not. He is simply saying hadith are collected and verified by human wisdom; which can be flawed as human him/her self is flawed. There is no need to be getting judgmental or emotional on it. I agree with him.
Very inspiring series Sister Aisha and Dr. Shabir Ally. Thank you.
Dr Shabir, you are unfettered by powerful sectarian religious and other interests, and that makes you 1000% more credible and sincere.
The reason We find Hadith so problematic and Quran so authentic is another proof of the divine origin and preservation of the Quran.
Hadith is on the other hand a historical account of the Prophet's sayings and does contain things that people invented on their own and hence problematic.
I agree.
Its great and much awaited discussion. Keep up the good work. JazakAllah 👍
I'm just so inspiring by Dr.Shabir Alley ,that I wish to convey his interpretation to many more ❤️.
Dr Shabbir is so humble and knowledgeable
Thank you for this very informative teaching!
Alhamdulillah, just watch this May Allah SWT bless Dr Shabir Ally. Thank you verymuch for the simple teaching and understanding for layman like me.
Hadith is not a scripture or the Scripture of Islam. Qur'aan is THE Scripture of Islam. Qur'aan is the authority and is obligatory on all Muslims.
Hadith is just a collection of tales, stories and unsubstantiated narrations collected by men from Central Asia. Those men never sat in the company of the Prophet or his companions or even in the company of their grand children.
Many of the ahaadith are ridiculous and absurd. They do not stand correct under the scrutiny of Qur'aan.
Any hadith that does not stand correct under the scrutiny of Qur'aan should be discarded and trashed.
Instead of Hadith, Muslims should read, study and understand Qur'aan.
SO DOES QURAN SAY HOW TO PRAY NAMAZ?IT SAYS PRAY NAMAZ BUT DOESNT TELL A PERSON HOW TO.SAME WITH HAJJ & ZAKAH QURAN SAYS ITS OBLIGATORY BUT DOESNT TELL YOU HOW TO.SO A PERSON HAS TO GO TO HADITH
@@asavlogsalltruthrevealed7483 oH
two of the five pillars of islam are from the hadiths.
so when muslims pray 5 times a day they are blindly following muhammad or whoever wrote the hadith.
if the hadiths are made up stories then the origins & history of islam didn't exist as the muslim narrative claims.
the Qur'an is just a mix of ancient beliefs, religions, cultures, superstitions, rituals etc.
it's full of contradictions and 100% is not from god, an angel, or a prophet.
it was created to justify & support invasions, aswell as brainwash people into being controlled by a powerful empire.
every popular religion was either created or spread by a powerful empire.
what better place to create a prophet, holy city & new religion, than mecca which had no history.
@@asavlogsalltruthrevealed7483 idk about you, but us muslims learn how to pray by watching how our parents/elders, and the people around us did it, its passed down generations after generations
@@abdulmuhammad7379 that's a bunch of B.S. How can it have been created by a powerful empire? It was channeled by one man alone and he was persecuted because of it by the ruling people of his city. You've lost the plot.
@Dr Shabir Ali: May Allah guide you and bless you for your many kindnesses: Is there a program or video where you address discriminating between well accepted hadith and those of questionable origin. I like your balanced approach to using the hadith to counsel interpretation of the Quran rather than as a behavioral code of itself. Is there a line one can draw between what are the most dependable hadith and which are questionable? Thanks in advance.
One of the greatest Muslim scholar of modern time Dr.Shabir. These hadiths are making our lives miserable and stupid.
"Bismillahir rahmaniir Rahiim!"
Hadith is forbidden even on Prophet Muhammad pbuh in Quran 69;44-46. It caused the division of the One Ummah into sects also forbidden in Quran 30:32; 42;14-15; 43;64-65; 45;17, 28 because of varied opinions of men. Islam is the Quran Alone, complete, perfect, clear, in detail, nothing to add, alter nor delete, it being Sealed against corruption, change or alteration.
Please don't mislead innocent people of your belief in hadiths.
Masha'allah! Subhanallah! Alhamdulillah! Allahu'akbar!
The Quran makes it clear that we have to follow the teachings of the Prophet (S.A.W).
"And let those who oppose the Messenger's commandment beware lest some fitnah befall them or a painful torment be inflicted on them." (24:63)
"He who obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah; but those who turn away - We have not sent you over them as a guardian." (4:80)
We can not pick and choose which teachings to follow based on how "problematic" they are for us. We follow the Quran and Sunnah in their entirety because we are instructed to by Allah (S.W.T).
Also, I have to point out the leaps in logic that this man is making.
Just because a verse in a Quran tells of a group of people who owned a dog, suddenly the saliva of a dog is not impure?
The Prophet (S.A.W) set certain conditions for which we can own a dog.
Ibn Umar narrated that the Messenger of Allah said: "whoever keeps a dog, two Qirats will be detracted from his reward each day, except a trained hunting dog, or a dog for herding livestock."
Did this conditions apply before the Quran was revealed to the Prophet (S.A.W) (meaning, did these conditions apply to the followers of Allah before us) we do not know. But it is clear that for us Muslims, these are the conditions for owning a dog.
The Prophet (S.A.W) also made it clear that the saliva of a dog is impure.
Abu Hurairah narrated that the Prophet (S.A.W) said: "To purify one's vessel licked by a dog, he should wash it seven times, the first time with dust."
As for what he said regarding usury, I'd like to share this hadith narrated by Abu Juhaifa:
"The Prophet (ﷺ) forbade the use of the price of blood and the price of a dog, the one who takes (eats) usury, the one who gives usury, the woman who practises tattooing and the woman who gets herself tattooed."
The one who takes usury and the one who gives usury. Where's the misunderstanding?
It was also narrated by Abdullah bin Masud that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) cursed the one who consumes usury, the one who pays it, those who witness it and the one who writes it down.
Sorry for the long post, just had to point this out.
So you would follow hadith that contradict entire topics in the Quran?
@@hyrunnisa997 Give me an example of a mutawatir hadith that contradicts the Quran.
@@alidhia8146 Please provide the relevant texts so we can study this matter further.
So you also differentiate between mwattar and non mwattar hadiths. There is no way to justify that all hadith can be truly attributed to The Holy Prophet PBUH.
Shabir is so white he almost looks like a pope! ;) Actually I wish he was the pope of Islam! keep up the good job.
It is nice and natural.
Compare to others who apply agly henna redish color
@@didasinan9669 Moreover, they do it for the sake of so called sunnah!
How poor ummah we are! 😥
Dr. Shabir Ally, May Allah bless you . I'm really blessed to have come across you. Please come to Fiji Islands in the South Pacific.
I don't believe in any Hadith that goes against the Quran and doesn't have any alternate explanation.
Very informative particularly the discussion on interest. From this i see that my understanding of interest was incorrect. I hope to see a longer discussion on interest as it relates to the Mu'min living in a modern capitalist society in a future show.
The founders of this chain have noble aspirations but the irony is that there is a hadith that predicts that there will be a time when Muslims will no longer want to follow the Hadiths and the Sunnah and will claim to restrict themselves to the Qur'an. Anyone with discernment must understand that renouncing to the hadith will result in the collapse of Islam. The faith of those who follow the Qur'an alone would not be translated into clear actions and would remain on a conceptual level, closer to philosophy than to the great religion of Islam that embraces real life in all its details and complexity. The example of the hadith prohibiting interest, either taken or given, mentioned by Dr Shabir, clearly shows that without hadith Muslims will start behaving like non-Muslims in almost any field, arguing that the Qur'an doesn't explicitly prohibit what they are doing.
respect to this imam
NO! i don't like this at all!. don't compromise your religion because you need a house! God is the one who gives and takes. Ask God for help and stay true to his commands, don't interpret in a way that works best for you but as well be at the risk of being wrong. Let God give to you. There are many halal loans you can look for. The interest/loaning system is flawed and against humanity, to its core!
Dr. Shabir needs to be a little more careful and clarify more when debunking hadith, particularly the hadith on riba (interest rates and loans/mortgages): it's a saheeh hadith that is to be taken for granted and not only the taker of the interest is very sinful but the one who gives and witnesses as well. Why? Because it's not only about the poor giving more money to the rich, but it's also about the poor supporting the corrupt banking system based on riba, and there is a verse in the Quran clearly prohibiting muslims to aid anyone in sinful matters such as supporting the corrupt banking system with your riba payments. Moreover, there is a hadith that says that eating or giving or witnessing riba is so much sinful it is 40 times worse than adultery. Imagine how bad it is now in the eyes of Allah and set your priorities straight. Muslims are above all supposed to conduct jahd, i.e. put effort in following their religion, not adjusting to the corrupt systems and supporting them with their penny. Be very cautious: you are not allowed to take a loan/mortgage from a non-islamic bank in any circumstance, so you need to look for other options, and there are enough of them.
I love this Channel also. Now for the comment from the sister in the video, she mentioned that the dog issue is a smaller one, perhaps she feels this way because as she said she is afraid of dogs. My feeling is that she doesn't have a clear understanding of what dogs are all about so considers it a small issue. So please to this channel, the dog issue is in fact huge and I would like more deep facts about this topic, why you may ask ? Because there horrible neglect towards dogs in muslim countries because of this weak hadiths and we cannot just let it go. Muslims need to step up to the realization that we have to be kind to dogs on the streets and provide them with food and water and not just say they are dirty street animals. PLEASE ENOUGH IS ENOUGH.......DO SOMETHING FOR ALLAH'S CREATURES. being a good Muslim is being kind towards all animals on earth.
I'm with you on this stance. It's sad and bewildering how one can dismiss outright with abject contempt simply for their God-given attributes.
Yes the content and the explanations are really good
When Allah tells you in Quran to take Quran as only hadith then why you guys keep wanting to go to other books ?...
Bcoz in quran how to pray namaz what actions to perform and what to speak is not mentioned we have to get knowledge from hadith not all hadiths are true bur some aretrue
Mmm... Need the hadist to guide us about how to pray?.. 200 years after prophet died then the hadist compiled.. I wonder those lives during that 200 years, how they pray? How to pray was taught by out beloved prophet directly to all his companions where in turn kept on teaching to all Muslims passing down generation...
@@nazree1975 guidance comes from Allah and there is none who can guide better than Allah and He gives plenty to His grateful servants ...I do not worship Muhammad because I am commanded by Allah not to associate anything with Him ...Muhammad is dead and Allah lives ,
@@vakilahmad8085 I agree with you- it is the Quran that is the Hadith that we need. My only question is, was the knowledge of how to perform Salah passed down from generation to generation??
@@Oshianis salaat was being performed before Muhammad and can be dated back to Abraham...it can be performed any way as said in Quran, you can read it sitting , standing, or laying down or with others who worship Allah ...Sunni and Shia both politicise salaat ...salaat is for God alone and not for Muhammad or Ali or anyone else ...Allah is full of wisdom and He made commandments in Quran on purpose to lead people out of darkness...if you look for guidance outside of Gods book , know that you have exchanged guidance for error ....read quran ...
You should work together with Javed Ahmad Ghamidi’s Institute, Almawrid, to segregate Sahee hadiths ...
I also agreed
The problem is not the Hadith, what I see and come acrossed many times is that, many of us are not equipped with Islamic knowledge. We rely on 'words of mouth', and when one is ignorant about Islamic and Arabic knowledge, one is easy to get confused and become the easy target of Satan. Learn your Deen in depth and in sincere way, and by Allah the TRUTH will be clear to you. Don't just rely on what this Brother is saying but rely with self-sacrificed Islamic studies under proper Sheikhs, who are well rounded in all fields of Islamic Laws.
bad advice.
don't listen to any muslim because their interpretations always different and incorrect.
would you rather hear stories of islam from someone who reads books on islam, or hear it directly from allah, muhammad & his companions??.
just read the tafsirs & hadiths because it's impossible to understand the Qur'an without the context.
once muslims read the evil teachings from muhammad they will soon realise he was a false prophet
I request Dr. Shabbir to clarify the following : during the times of Prophet (PBUH) dogs would inside masjid e Nabawi and nobody had any problem with it. Please clarify.
I too have many questions to ask. Where to write them??
Dear Dr. Shabir you are an awesome person. I love listening to you and the way how you explain the very complex topics related to our religion.
However, with regards to Hadith, I am just wondering why we have to have one Coran and 1000th of Hadiths. Is it not enough to have the Coran the WORD of GOD as the most important book only and NOT the Hadith which is based on comments and opinions of human beings who think they understand and interpret the Coran better.
Somehow I do have the feeling that the Hadith plays a much more important role in Islam than the Coran does, a fact which is quite frightening.
Marc Laumann to the wahhabi denegerates certainly which explains their idiocy and why they make a perfect tool to soil the faith that is Islam
As a Muslim you are instructed to follow the Quran and the authentic Sunnah. By rejecting the Sunnah you become a disbeliever and reject your faith. Please learn more on Islam and speak with a knowledgeable sheik in your community.
I agree with Dr Shabir ally’s view Hadith should only be excepted on their merit.
Let us take all the books of Shia and Sunni, lay them out by facts and their relationships.
Shabir Ali my brother beware of introducing logic to this community. You will be condemned and branded a kaafir quicker then you can imagine my friend.
Ahmed Mohamed Muslims should not dare anyone except God.
Threatening or warning for what. Truth from allah is truth from Allah. And we should not be fearing people's opinions. Our beloved prophet pbuh had more fear for God than man. That's a lesson we can all take.
As they did to Ebu Haneefah!
Where I come from I see lots of very beutiful mosques being built every year and around it are shanties/ huts where very poor people , people who may not even afford one meal a day live, so I ask you brothers and sisters in Islam..do we have our priorities right? Kann a hungry and homeless Person concentrate in worship?
Im a big fan of the shaykh, but on the dog issue I differ. According to all narrations from the Ahlul Bayt which we have, is that the dog, all of the dog, if wet, is impure and najis. If the dog is not wet then that impurity will not contaminate you. Hence, the dog is impure and more so the mouth and saliva which is always wet.
You dont differ with the Shayk. You differ with Allah (swt). The shayk recounted the Quran…therefore you disagree with Allah (swt)
Why is there hadiths if the Quran is complete, perfect, clear & in detail Words of Allah swt? Is hadith not against Quran 7:3 & 69:44-46?
there is a hadith were muhammad tells his companions not to write about him.
so hadiths contradict other hadiths.
same with the Qur'an, it's full of contradictions
Very disappointed with this segment. I do respect your views on most things. However, I was surprised to hear you actually skirting the topic of discussion. The saliva of dogs example? Was that all you could think of as problematic Hadith? Didn’t expect this from you.
Perfect!!
I am afraid I will have to disagree with you dear brother!
Even if you have to buy a house, you can wait and buy it when the time is right!
What's the rush?
Getting credit from the bank only supports the system of Kufr.
Moreover, we are all tenants of dunya for I will not buy one for myself Insha'Allah even though I may be as old as you.
Hasan Yildiz the Hadith about the 5 people involved in interest is authentic. We have to guard ourselves against interest. That is his opinion and based on any usul of Fiqh. Caution Caution Caution fellow Muslims
@@TheDrRow The silliest question ever! Not even worth of answering...
@@hasanyildiz9364 Getting credit from the bank only supports the system of Kufr. That's what you wrote. So it is not a silly question. Your comment is worthless like you.
@@kanig5256 Says the almighty and worthy person, not to mention the arrogance!
In some parts of the West, namely US, Canada, UK, etc., even average regular houses are so expensive, you need $1 million to buy a house. Preventing Muslims from taking out a loan to purchase a house, means they pay more money in rent (in some areas mortgage payments are cheaper than rent), which pays the mortgage of their landlords, which still pays for that interest. This keeps Muslims artificially poor compared to others who can get into property ownership earlier.
All Hadiths are problematic! Quran only!
all the 27 Arabic Quran's are problematic.
rejecting hadiths doesn't save Islam from embarrassment and certain destruction
shoubouhats that's all that i hear in this video
How to be a quranist 101
"O you prophet, why do you prohibit what God has made lawful for you, seeking to please your wives? God is Forgiver Merciful. 66:1
I respect Dr. Shabbir for his knowledge, but disregarding sahih hadiths and calling it a balanced approach is so wrong. It's picking and choosing as ones liking.
Anything that is contradictory with Quran can't be authentic simple is that.
We have follow both Quran & Hadiths.
But we can not follow those Hadiths which are contradictory with Quran.
Quran is reserved by Allah himself.
Hadiths can be manipulated because it is not reserved by Allah himself.
I am a Christian and I strive to respect all other religions, in particular knowledgeable scholars such as Dr. Ally, but I really can't relate to such things as the saliva of dogs, or similar that seem to be FAQ or more than just details of the doctrine. My question is: how those kind of things are supposed to be of any use to an individual living in XXI who is willing to build a personal relationship with the Lord?
@Yotchat Margui So you cherry-pick those that are authentic? Who has discernment about that? And who decides who is entitled? As far as I know many of those that are problematic are still accounted to be authentic in a way. I am sorry but your answer seems to me quite vague and without any references.
Very nice
Masha Allah.
The Qur'an is error proof because its the exact words from Allah. But the Hadith can be subjected to human error just like the Bible.
Did this dude just say that if we follow hadith we will become radical?🤣
as someone who live in Islamic country since small you guys really have a hard time
"Problematic hadith" - Dr. Shabbir Allys copyrighted phrase. :-)
what is more ? hadith book or quran ??? which book is real islam ???
AL QURAN IS THE REAL BOOK OF ISLAM.NOT THE HADITH
@@zahirshah388 Quran is mainly written by Hadith ,you should know that as a muslim
Dr. Shabir, I am concern about your thoughts. Do you have an issue of authentic Hadewych?
There is no authentic Hadith there sound Hadiths
I'm not sure I agree with his view on interest payments. If you are giving interest you are knowingly contributing to making the rich richer. Think about it if there was no demand from people accepting loans with interest then it would not be profitable for banking institutions to lend with interest
Then your only option is to rent a house, the renter more than likely has a house on a buy-to-let mortgage, so you're still making the rich richer, and you're still enabling someone else to partake in interest.
Please could you work with tariq jameel and tariq maosod from pakistan.
Tariq Jameel is not a scholar,
As Salaam Alaakum. Dogs are not Haram, they can be used for Hunting ,and protecting ,and guiding a blind person, and not for pets. RIBA IS HARAM , Period.
what if AUTHENTIC hadiths forbid any transaction with interest rate ? can we just ignore it and say .. well its not in the quran
The prohibition of riba is in the Qur'an. Surah Baqarah Ayah 275.
@@abdiganisugal825 I think he means the Giving of it. Because the Qur’an forbids Taking (eating) interest and is defending against the greedy. I’m no expert may Allah continue to give me more knowledge. But this is my interpretation. Because I don’t understand how GIVING internet voluntarily can be beneficial to anyone.
Assalam... Brilliant..
Iet me go full.. Then comment. Sorry
Shabir Ally
You have to stop following self written hadith and books. Allaah ❤❤❤The Alknown has strictly forbidden us in The Qo'raan The Perfect Word of Allaah ❤❤❤ The Almighty. They add things to The Word of Allaah❤❤❤ The Most Loved. This is SHIRK.
saliva of dog on clothing or vessel?
Plz add captions in English
Dogs licking my face = no funnnn :D
As Salaam Alaakum. Riba is Haram even in the previous scriptures. Muslims need, their own banks.
Please Dr Shabbir, Please advise how to get rid of Hadith in this last revelation from God. So many contradict the Quran and thus making people turn into fanatics and extreme in worship and quite distant with living in this world. Why is hadith apart of this religion so much.
Suz Mia Don't be fooled and become a dumb quranite. You are on a very risky path.
Fools are the ones who Place the Hadith above the Quran.
Yes, quranites are on a dangerous road. Because there is no prohibition of cremation in the Qur'an, they think its ok to cremate your dead. Quran comes first, yes. But authentic hadith is also important.
Suz Mia Your answer is Saudi Arabia and Wahhabism... they appointed themselves the modern guardians of the faith and used their petro-riches to peddles around the world fake Ahadeeth supporting their fake corrupt and violent version of Islam. This has caused enormous confusion within Islam and complete misrepresentation of Islam to non muslims.
Diane Winchester what??? 😂 just stop please..
Serious problems with shabir ally's views and in his 3rd way. There are different levels of Munkireen Hadith. Unfortunately shabbir ally falls in one of these categories. his knowledge of Hadith seems to be very poor and is giving opinions where he is out of depth. Beware of the erroneus 3rd way he is suggesting. Deen is complete and not in need of his 3rd way which has sprung up after 1400y. probably Imam Malik said beware of the thing in Deen that you don't have a precedent in .
This man makes little sense, if there's a "conflict" in your opinion but the hadith is saheeh, then are you saying the prophet has lied and not to take it over Qur'an?!
He never said the prophet lied and of course you are not to take hadith over Quran.
Prophet didn't lied.
Allah reserved Quran.
It is widely known as All Hadiths are not real.
There are lots of Hadiths.
Strong,Medium & weak.
Satan is a pure Spirit as such he can not drink nor eat. They are not created of matter.
Annoying😡😡why talking so slowly n silently?? I cant hear anythinh
iPhone 12 Pro Max has great audio..maybe invest in it 😀
the People of the cave were not muslims eventhough they were people of the book but they have different rulings than the Muslims.. they dont do the shalat the way we do etc etc .. so its not wise to take example from generations before the coming of Rasulullah which were the Jews and Christians and apply it to God’s rulings that came with his Prophethood..
Really?!
They were Muslims so much so that Allah Subhanehu Teala mentioned their name in Quran.
Get your facts right!
All the Prophets and the ones who follow them were Muslims.
@Yotchat Margui They were a bunch of youngsters who worshipped only the one and only God (Allah).
So they escaped from their people and sheltered themselves in a cave and slept there about 309 years.
Finally, when it was safe for them to show up, the one and only God (Allah) awakened them.
Some narrations mention that they were Christians,but not the Christianity of today's world for sure.
Because today's Christianity is corrupted by Trinity nonsense which invalidates itself.
@Yotchat Margui Of course, at least a few centuries ago.
@Yotchat Margui There is a chapter named after them in Quran . However, their numbers, religion and so on were not mentioned in it.
They were mentioned to focus on the oneness of Allah and how these youngsters were on the straight path.
So he’s looking at #Islam from western viewpoint and trying to relate accordingly ?
Because Eastern viewpoint has failed many many times.
Why do you not just admit it!
Whose idea was dividing ourselves into sects and many Cemaat?!
Even though there is a strict order in Quran not to do so!
Yes! I knew it! Mortgaged house here I come!!
interesting
The worst problem is HADITH AND NOT QURAN PUTTING MUSIC 🎶 AND MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS IN THE SAME CATEGORY AS INTOXICANTS AND OBVIOUS other transgressions that are PLAINLY STATED IN THE BOOK 📖 WHICH MAKES THINGS CLEAR! And this issue has apparently been going on FOR OVER A THOUSAND YEARS NOW! JUST LIKE MUSLIMS WHENEVER TRYING TO MAKE A POINT OF THE MAGNIFICENCE OF OUR LORD AND HIS PERSPICUOUS BOOK! AS A MATTER OF FACT; THE QURAN ITSELF IS MUSICAL! AND I BEING MUSICALLY INCLINED AM ABLE TO REMEMBER VERSES OF THE QURAN BY DECIPHERING ITS “MELODY”! Lest I forget; sometimes I play the melody of a verse like”wa huwal lazee khallakal Laila wannahaara washamsa wal qamara kullun fee falikini yahsbahoon”. That verse was unintelligible for me to repeat, and then very difficult for me to remember, until I deciphered it’s MUSICAL MELODY! NOT RYHTOM OR WORDS! I can learn to memorize any verses, but without the music of it, even other Muslims wouldn’t like it, or even recognize what I was saying! AS SALAMU ALAIKUM WA BARAKATU.
The next time..u will say....i could not feel God..until i put a statue of a man on wall and then i realy felt God in me....religiin is not about what u fèel...its about lows and its guidance...
lady is confused understandably
He is educated and still believes that Muhammad , had true revelation from God? Strange
Does not he see many contradictions in Muhammad teaching?
Diakon Franciszek care to explain?
So..dr shabir..what u are trying to teach the umma is....we read the quran and do what is says without consulting the hadith????and we only go for hadith what we didnt get from the quraan???is it not the hadith that expalins in details about the verses???is not that if we let everyone to have his opinion on what he understood in the verses then every one will have his own opinion????then where will be the guidance????any ways..people like u were mentioned as well..the people of opinions..be ware of them.....u miss guide people dr shabir.....
I didn't like this video.
Salam alaikum brother shaber the problem is not in the Hadith its in us and the way we interprete the Quran and Hadith the methdology can only be correct if one has knowledge and its correct understanding we all know that some Ahadith are week and some r even false.
Giving intrest .the hadith that u mentioned is saheeh its in acordence with the Quran if some one wants to know ask me and i will reply.
2 resemblence with jews and christains its not in normal clothes rather its in mantality
On top of every Alim is another Alim
May Allah widen our chests so we can see clearly Ameen
You thug what type of balance of approach you are talking about.
Scriptures can't be half truth or to be half followed.
exactly. to follow only part of islam & reject the rest is just creating your own islam.
most muslims are ignorant to whst islam actually teaches because they are only willing to follow the specific teaching that they like.
either muslims have to admit thd Qur'an, tafsirs, hadiths are corrupt, or they must admit they follow satan
He speaks in a nice manner, but don't be fooled
Allah is the God of the muslins only
All reglion have there own God
Allah is God entire Mankind
@@onlineteacher9171
So you say that Allah is
the God to all mankind.
Okay
Is Allah the God of the Bible?
Is Allah words are eternal and they can not be. Change?
You tell me
@Yotchat Margui
Why is it that Allah the God of the Bible
1. Calls jesus his Son
2. Allah calls jesus his Son and God
3 Allah the God of the Bible calls jesus the final Messenger to bring the word of God to mankind.
But muhammad teaches the opposite of what the Bible teaches.
So either Allah is mistaken or muhammad is mistaken.
@Yotchat Margui
Ya the same the quran is corrupted by muhammad who is not a true prophet of God
No muslims has been able to prove that muhammad is a prophet using the Torah and the injeel
@Yotchat Margui
Okay prove to me that muhammad is a prophet of God using the TORAH
24 muslims have failed
follow jesus he is the Savior and Messiah ....problem soloved
@Ketah's Little Bubble spelling?? its call typing fast!!...now go cook for ur husband u and the other 3 wives!!! LOL
@Ketah's Little Bubble u think its funny LOL but u no damn well Islam is not fair to woman, man will get 72 virgins on top of his earthly wife..now proof me wrong!!!! atleast tell me what u going to get in heaven as a woman..let me see the surah too proof ur right ok LOL
@@freddytorres3609 may peace be upon you.
1) only martyrs will get 72 virgins in Jannah. Not every Muslim that dies. Just the martyrs.
2) the verse that talks about the pure spouse, actually says THEY will get pure spouses. It didn't say men will get pure spouses. Men AND women will get pure spouses.
3) if you actually knew how we are supposed to treat our women according to the Qur'an and Hadiths, you'd want to change your gender to a female if you're a male. Because husbands owe their wives basic rights AND much more, whereas the wife owes her husband basic rights and if she wants, more. (Depends on her love for the husband)
You guys do great work but I can’t believe this “dr” and Muslim doesn’t know Quran! The Quran NOT HADITH CLEARLY says interest is unlawful surah 2:275. So please don’t mislead our Ummah to pacify a “modern “ life.
Watch the video again carefully.
It is not clear at all. 2:275 says riba is prohibited and there is much discussion about the definition of riba - is it all interest or is is usury - exploitation of the indebted poor. Caliph Umar remarked after the prophets death that he regretted that the prophet did not explain what he meant by riba.
Why cover your hair?
@@nonsensem09 maybe she wants to understand the meaning behind it :)
@@nonsensem09 Nope it's not an obligation for men!
Where did bring up this ruling!?
Becouse..mary mother of jesus covered her hair.....and the nuns in churches cover their hairs too....
In Islam the veil is to protect a woman's beauty and to keep them modest so men are not swayed by them so easily, but don't take my shaky word for it and research, there are tons of vids in this on TH-cam! Select the right ones!!
Shabir Ally is a coward. He once agreed to debate the Christian Prince but backed out of the debate at the last minute after reading the Christian Prince's book. The Christian Prince would chew Shabir up and spit him out in a debate that is why Shabir ran away....
Shabir is a coward and ran away from the Christian Prince.
Give proof
@@abdiganisugal825 look it up on TH-cam...there is a video all about it.
@@abdiganisugal825 all mosques faced Petra for the first 100 years of Islam. Islam is a false religion and Muhammad was a false prophet.
why there is female host in this show??
whatever..but he is doing Dawa and voilating one very important principle of Islam
Which principle?
Because it is halal
Blessed you have confused talmudic Judaism with Islam
How do we know there are not others behind the camera?