Is the Apple LED Cinema Display better than the Apple Studio Display??
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 มิ.ย. 2024
- In today's video we take a look at everything the Apple LED Cinema display from 2010 has to offer and compare it to the new Apple Studio Display. Hope you enjoy!
Timestamps:
0:00 - Intro
1:42 - The Screens
3:59 - Sound
4:55 - Direct Sound Comparison
5:59 - iSight vs. CenterStage
6:23 - Built-in Mics
7:00 - Dimensions
11:07 - Repairability
12:32 - Mac Compatibility
14:04 - Windows Compatibility
14:51 - The Stands
15:18 - Value $$
18:21 - Final thoughts
🌎 Check out my website!
www.taylorcbrauer.com
📸 Follow me on Instagram!
/ taylorcbrauer
🐦 Follow me on Twitter!
/ taylorcbrauer
Music from Epidemic Sound:
epidemicsound.com - บันเทิง
this guy is chill asf
Thank you!
I just bought the old display in PERFECT LIKE NEW condition through eBay and LOVE IT, paid $700 for the condition and do not regret it. Yes, I know what I could have bought new for $700, and I did buy a DELL high end 27" that is a great monitor, but I like using the old Apple which is almost as good. I am running them on M1 minis. Your review is spot on, and you are so good at this, get right to the issues, no screwing around, good for you. I wish you all the best young man. Whatever you do you will be successful.
Thanks, Vivian! I really appreciate the kind words. Congrats on the display! If you paid for something and you love it, it’s totally worth it. Have a great rest of your week.
$700?? Thats way overpriced for the past 5 years they’ve sold for $250 or less.
You got robbed.
I bought a 27-inch Thuderbolt display a few months ago, and it really does hold up. I managed to snag one for about $150 on the facebook marketplace, and it's definitely one of the best purchases ive made this year.
Congrats, that's awesome! Hope it lasts you many years to come.
I have one of the LED with thunderbolt. How do you connect this to IMAC with only usb-c?
@@TaylorBrauer
Thanks for a great video! I just picked up a used one in flawless condition and I couldn’t have been happier!
Yw! Congrats on the find.
FANTASTIC OVERVIEW - THANK-YOU!
YW!
You have a really good TH-cam channel! You have a simple non pretentious style to your videos looking forward to more in the future from your channel :)
Thanks, Jeff. I really appreciate the kind words. Have a great day!
Great comparison, thanks.
Yw! Have a great day!
Great video, man! I'm trying to connect my Led cinema displays with minidisplayport to my mac studio with m1max, do you know if it's possible? Ive tried a couple of adapters but they don't seem to work. Appreciate the time and love you put into this, good luck!
Thanks, Diego! Glad you enjoyed. It should be possible to connect it. Have you tried the adapter I use in the video connecting to my laptop? th-cam.com/video/SzZHdyRJkws/w-d-xo.html
Great video. Love the cinema led display so much. I also have the Cinema HD 30“ one. They both look great and have great colors ❤ thank you for this comparison
Yw! The 30" is epic. Hang on to that one.
I'm doing the old and the new setup with my M1 Max except with the 2011-16 thunderbolt display model. The thunderbolt display works perfectly with the apple tb3-tb2 adapter and my M1 Max. Looking forward to receiving the studio display sometime this year hopefully. lol
That's awesome! Love the fact that you got the thunderbolt display working with your m1 max. It's a great display that will still be great for years to come. Let us know what you think of the Studio Display when you eventually get it.
Thx dude! Awesome content 👌🏽
Yw. Glad you enjoyed.
Thanks you very much for such a nice review! I have owned this Cinema display since 2010, and I love it. Now I would like to connect it to my m2 iPad Pro. What is the best usb c to mini display adaptor you can recommend me in the market right now? Thanks in advance!
Yw! I have one linked somewhere.
Thanks for this detailed vid. The red laser in the middle of the video was cool and appropriated.
You're welcome! Glad you enjoyed. Have a great day, Mathieu.
I am rocking the same two monitors, the studio display connected to my MacBook Pro 14 and the Cinema Display connected to my work PC Laptop. The problem after some PC updates, my sound on the Cinema display is glitchy, I now have have to connect my Logitech Brio webcam straight to the docking station instead of back of the monitor and I had to unplug the USB from the monitor to the docking station. The sound still works through the mini DP connection. Still working with this workaround.
I have experienced similar issues and have just appreciated it for the display aspect. I wish the extras held up with time but port tech has advanced so much it's understandable that it can't keep up.
Great video. Can you point me to your video on how to connect the Thunderbolt Display to a pc? Thanks!
I have this video where I connect the display to a PC. th-cam.com/video/gYpdnPn_vEg/w-d-xo.html
Great analysis. Your videos are super on point, thoughtful, and well-delivered. Looking forward to more!
Thanks, John. I really appreciate that. Have a great day!
Great comparison!
My cinema display always turns on first when I have logged on. If the Mac is still on log in screen and I haven't typed in password the apple cinema display is black. Is it perhaps a setting och does the display need an update?
Thanks!
Can't say for sure, but from what you describe, it sounds like it's waking quickly and sleeping when not in use. So, could just be a normal power function of the monitor. Maybe find some more research to get a better determination and let us know what you find out.
Great Video Taylor. For the old one, from 2010 it comes with An 3 external calle one usb one for charging and the other one as small box. What is the name of that cable? I have An adapter that gets hmdi but not that small square
Thank you! That's mini DisplayPort.
@@TaylorBrauer thanks fo the reply. I have the Display led. The old one, I have a question. is it ok that the display get warm especially in the bottom part? Hope you have one to give me an answer
@@ivanzq21 My display also gets warm.
Excellent video! congratulations!
Thank you!
Great work, can this cinéma display worked with MacBook pro 14 m2?
I'm not sure but I was think it would work.
I believe that for the sound test, you need to place the mic, where your head would normally be! But gray comparison over all, thank you! Very helpful
Thanks for the feedback. Glad you liked it!
The unbeatable advantage of the 2022 model is the one-cable-approach via USB-C. I love it just plugging in my M1 MBA with one cable and I can start working. Speakers, webcam, mics and display make the 2022 model perfect.
Loving the one cable connection. It's the first monitor I've owned with that design and all monitors should be like that.
Nailed it Tailor !
Thank you!! Glad you enjoyed.
Super in-depth review.
Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed it.
Is Apple Thunderbolt Display really work well together with M1 Mac? I have read that this display has flickering issue. Is this error fixed in latest updates?
I can't speak for the experience with the Thunderbolt display as I have the Cinema Display with a MiniDP connector but the Cinema Display works great with no flicker.
Thumbs up, Taylor. Totally professionally done!!
I really appreciate that, thank you!
Thunderbold Display has also a cooling System
Thx Taylor. New subscriber. Your videos super helpful and what I’m looking at right this minute today 0:46 0:47 0:48
Thank you! I really appreciate the support.
Thw cinema display seems to have a significant reflections compare to studio displays?
Apple Cinema Display has one advantage over the thunderbolt display or Studio Display for me - the former is compatible with my Windows-based laptop, while the latter does not even using a thunderbolt dock station, so I can use the same monitor for both my Macbook Pro 13" and Dell Laptop from work.
Great video!
Thank you!
My current setup is a 2013 trash can Mac Pro with 1 LED Cinema Display and 1 Thunderbolt Display. I still see myself on the trash can for a year or two, but I'll eventually replace it with a new Mac Mini. I'll be re-using these two displays on the new system when I do, though! I don't need super crazy resolution for what I do (audio editing and Vectorworks); these displays look great and all the extra ports come in handy. Is the new Studio Display better? Of course. But unless you're deep into serious video or graphics production, it's definitely not worth the hefty price tag. Nice video!
Thanks RT! The trash can is such a cool Mac. Make the most of what you got and probably by the time you’re ready to make a new purchase there will be new, shiny stuff out. Have a great weekend!
I recently bought a used Thunderbolt Display over the new Studio Display because of the nice APPLE logo on the bottom bezel ;-?) Not really of course, it was all about cost. For what I paid I could buy 8 of these TBDs for the price of 1 Studio Display. Positives; still that beautiful solid APPLE design and OS compatibility, the ports, surprised how good it looks for photography and videos, and sound is also surprisingly good. Yes, it was a compromise, the SD is better is every way. But, this will be fine as a practical and usable option. For what is does and the price difference, I’m happy.
It's a great display. Glad you found one you are happy with. That's what matters most out of a product. Enjoy, Robert!
Would the thunderbolt 2-3 adapter work with this display ?
Not sure on that one, y’all. The display requires a lot of bandwidth and it would be interesting to see if something like that would work to use a pre-2016 Mac with the Studio Display.
great vid ..
ty!
I still have two Apple Thunderbolt displays hooked up to an iMac. I've thought about trading them in for the new Studio display but the huge price tag just isn't worth it for how similar the two models are and how great the Thunderbolt displays still are in 2022
They are pretty hard to beat. Do you think something like the Pro XDR at $3000 would beat them?
@@TaylorBrauer Question, why don't you just get a $500 4k displays instead of the Cinema Display? Specs wise those should beat the Cinema Display while still cheap and modern.
That's always an option and for this video I'm just narrowing my scope to only Apple branded monitors.
iMac (Retina 5K, 27-inch, Late 2015 is there a way I can add my apple Mac lap top to this display 27-inch (5120 × 2880)
Should i buy cinema display for gaming?
There’s probably displays with much higher refresh rates and more accurate colors for around the same price as a Cinema Display. Modern gaming monitors are pretty sweet. Def make some comparisons on your own before you commit.
My only problem for me is the 12ms response time in the cinema display i think it will be very blurry ? do you feel that the mouse pointer movement & windows movement blurry ?
With everyday use it's fine. Gaming isn't going to be smooth but that's about it.
@@TaylorBrauer have you tested something like that with the cinema display ?
th-cam.com/video/YD-N5ixNl8U/w-d-xo.html
Just got a LED Cinema Display for $50 look forward to using it
Wicked deal! Enjoy!
when you sleep your macbook and press any buttion, that monitor instantly wakes up??
Hey…
I’m having some low range bass distortion on my studio display speakers. Out of the box!
Vocals and most audio sounds terrific but when the bass kicks in a few songs, the thump sounds like a torn drum 🥁 even at half volume.
The same songs at same settings are sounding amazing on my 24” M1 iMac.
These displays are not even available on display at the physical stores, where I live, to go and double check if it’s widespread or something that’s normal.
Could you please check on your studio display?
Apple Music Equaliser
Preamp in neutral
Rock setting
Apple Music preferences
Sound enhancer
Slider at 3/4th
Thanks indeed 🥃
Oh no! I tried those settings on mine, although I didn't set the preamp, and to my ears, the bass sounds rich and punchy.
@@TaylorBrauer thanks so much for your reply. Thanks indeed. I’ll try to deselect preamp and check once again.
🥃
I just have ONE question..why can't we get a switch to switch between using two Macs and ONE monitor??? Studio display, Thunderbolt Display, Pro XDR or otherwise??? Does it exist??
There's KVM switches that accomplish that I'm sure. Where to start...I have no idea.
@@TaylorBrauer I've been looking everywhere for the last few days and am finding NOTHING. The same would be for folks using all the new monitors too... there's only ONE input on all these new apple monitors. All kinds of KVM switches.. most have display port or hdmi outputs and that doesn't not play with thunderbolt. I just kinda can't believe no one else is using more than one Mac at a time. I switch back and forth between two Macs all the time, but have so far only had pc type monitors with multiple inputs. anyways.. just thought it was REALLY strange issue!
I've own two 27" displays in 2017 -2019 and they worked great on my 2015 15" MBP. Recently got a maxed out m1 air and it eplaced my 2017 5k maxed iMac and for this display. Honestly, still great In 2024. I might get a studio display, if my recently purchased 3rd thunderbolt goes out or if I say fkit. Right now, I'm happy and can it wait for my M3MBP16" to arrive and hook it up. FYI haven't had to use any software for volume & brightnesss😎
That's awesome. They've really worked out for you for a long time. The specs might be a bit dated but they are still great build quality. Congrats on the new MBP!
I can't seem to get my thunderbolt display to work with my MacBook pro M1 Pro? I have the thunderbolt 3 to thunderbolt 2 adaptor, but no luck - any tips?
Not sure, Chris. Perhaps experiment with different cables and see which one works. Sometimes these older devices just act a bit finicky with newer hardware.
@@TaylorBrauer Yeah, its a weird one. i am using all apple cables and connectors, and have tired a few but nothing. I think it might be software related maybe?
@@chrisdunderdale I have M2 Pro and it works perfectly. You might have a bad cable?
@@ghost-user559 it’s really weird, because it works fine with my MBP 2013 with TB2, and I’ve tried 2 different TB3 -> TB2 adaptors with no luck. I’m giving up and buying an LG superfine
Well, I am only a student who doesn’t have cash for the new Studio Display. So the old Thunderbolt is still a great deal for me!
That's awesome, it's still an amazing display. Wishing you the best in your studies, JungleGhost!
İm still using apple thunderbolt cinema display 27 and im great with that
That's great! Those displays have really stood the test of time.
@@TaylorBrauer yessss
Cute
I have two TB displays. Together they cost a third of the price of the studio display. I can daisy chain them. They have thunderbolt 2, and 10 Gigabit Ethernet
Nice! That's a great setup. The daisy chaining feature is something I wish the Studio Display had.
@@TaylorBrauer going to purchase a 2013 Mac Pro soon. My dream setup from 2013 is now affordable in 2022 lol
@@MFEeee Hell yeah, Mike! The Mac Pro was and still is a beautiful machine. Let us know how you like it when you get it.
@@TaylorBrauer will do! Thank you!
Just a reminder if you‘re using the LED Cinema Display as a secondary monitor with newer iMac and also for the Mac Mini (mostly the newer ones with the TB3 and TB4 input) it also counts with MacBooks.
It doesn‘t work using the TB3 to TB2 adapter while the Mini DisplayPort needs power delivery. Which could be the reason that the Mini Displayport to USB C aren‘t powerful enough in order to show the display.
So to getting working the display. You need a Dockingstation. That the LED Cinema Display can show the screen thru the dock. However they are not cheap, it costing like 130 to 400 bucks. Depending on the qualities and brands. It‘s somewhat pricey to get the Dockingstation.
Some few Dockingstation has a Mini Displayport input or if it doesn’t, you could technically use a DisplayPort to Mini DisplayPort Adapter if the Dockingstation has only the Standard DisplayPort.
If you‘re using the Thunderbolt Display, you don‘t need a Dockingstation if you‘re straight up using a Thunderbolt adapter.
But nice comparision btw. I could think the Mac Studio looks smooth to the resolution of the display. But i‘ll prefer the LED Cinema Display, because they aren‘t expensive and it‘s timelessly usable atleast. So i‘m happy to getting the 27 inch LED Cinema Display by using it.
Update: you don‘t need actually a Dockingstation.
You can actually use a HDMI to Displayport adapter (with the USB for power delievery) then plugging a Display to Mini Displayport adapter and then you have a working Cinema Display.
Source th-cam.com/video/JJ4xQuhH5Qo/w-d-xo.html
If you plan to build a dual monitor setup with old Thunderbolt displays, you should take into account that the devices almost all have different brightness levels due to their age. Over the last few years I've had about 7 Thunderbolt displays and the brightness has been between 3,900 (almost yellow image) and 5,900 (pretty good white) lux. Apparently the displays burn out over the years depending on how heavily they're used. I measured 6,500 lux during the iMac 5K DIY monitor conversion.
That makes sense. The 2011 iMac I have has really yellowed. Eventually these older displays will be really hard to find.
@@TaylorBrauer There is a similar problem with the Retina iMacs from 2014 and later. For my DIY 5K display, I had to buy several old iMacs until I found a model without a pink edge (yellow/pink/brown edge on a white background), ghosting/burn in, dust between the display panel and the glass...
@@kyrbies Jeez, sounds like finding one in good condition can be a challenge. Thanks for sharing and I'll look out for those things if I decide to look for a retina iMac.
Cinema's stand is still much more elegant than studios awkward stand design.
And as soon as the future 27" whatever imac shows up, the studio display is history.
Agreed on the Cinema stand. Love the curves in the stand and the enclosure.
I really hope there is a 27" iMac in the future.
Having the mic too close to the monitor makes the Studio Display sound “phasey”. Being that it has more speakers, at that distance you are going to have that problem.
Apple needs to make a “Studio Display Air” at $999. They are leaving so much money on the table from regular users who think (and rightly so) that $1,600 for a monitor is absurd.
That would be really cool to see. They do such a good display that it would be nice if they really had some compeling options that didn't cost a kidney. Having a tandem OLED standalone display for $1600 might be worth it though.
Not too many differences in my opinion. For most users the $200 cinema display seems like enough
The Cinema display is very appealing still.
I have several Cinema Displays and love the quality and value.
One thing I never quite understood. The 5K iMac's default screen resolution setting is 2560x1440 so is anyone really using the 5K? Looking to maybe get a M2 mac mini with and old Thunderbolt display if the 27 inch iMac is truly extinct now.
It's true the OS will tell you it's 2560x1440 but it's scaling a 5k image to 2560x1440. It's not reducing pixel count, it's increasing UI sizing. 1:1 scaling of 5k on 27" you'd have to be really close to see anything as the whole UI would be tiny.
@@TaylorBrauer Thanks for the explanation. I've set my iMac to 5K and couldn't see anything and thought who uses this?
I would rather just get a 5K iMac Pro. Best speakers, best webcam, best microphone quality. And the computer is inside of the display.
I just got an LED cinema display for free from a friend who said it didn't work. Got a mini DisplayPort to USB-C adapter and it worked just fine for my laptop, feel like I scammed my friend since it'll make a nice second monitor for my laptop while I"m home.
Oh wow, that’s pretty awesome. Enjoy!
Cost=good / specs=bad = Cinema Display decent
I love my Cinema Display. In my opinion it’s better looking and definitely Steve Jobs era Apple.
The design language is so timeless. The display was so ahead of it's time in every aspect.
@@TaylorBrauer I definitely agree! The display still looks modern even for today.
The Studio Display has a 5K display and an iPhone 11 inside. It also has the expensive Thunderbolt technology and the faster transfer speed of the three USB-C ports (10 Gbit/s). That explains the price.
Short answer: No, of course not. 😂
Long answer: Absolutely not unless your Mac is too old to have USB-C, then sure, kind of hard to say the new one is better when you can't even plug it in.
So, your dad bought himself a lot of gear and you pose with it as it was yours? 😅
lol, nah man. idk where you got that idea.
@@TaylorBraueri think it’s best to just ignore this types of comments. Great review, was curious about the cinema monitor and found your channel! You are doing a good job reviewing stuff, keep it up!
@@voikuvoics Thank you! I'll keep at it.
The right pricing for the Studio display should be around $799 in my opinion… If Apple can offer an iMac at 1299$, I don't understand why it can't offer just a plain monitor at 799$.
Agreed. 799 would be awesome!
@@TaylorBrauer we would also had the pleasure to see more setups consisting exclusively of Apple products 'cause someone who would buy a base model Mac Mini wouldn't want to spend 1599$ just for a monitor and since iMac is stuck at M1 and most people will not choose an iMac right now, I think that Apple should offer at least the screen of the iMac 24" without all the computing staff for a cheaper price…
Great video!
Thanks, T!