They admitted in the developer commentary that Wheatley's eyelids wouldn't be physically possible. In the game, they got around this by compressing (as in, the opposite of stretching) the parts hidden by the ring.
i found this out on my own, by opening GCFScape and going through the commentary in the vo folder, and yeah, they admit that, i didnt extract ALL the files tho, so no link
Then that means portal 1 cores are possible right? A portal 1 core has no eye lids Which means that if u remove the portal 2 cores eyelids it will just be a portal 1 core
The yellow actuating cylinder rod structure is called a Stewart Platform. Pretty cool. It not only moves the ring around the eye forward and backward, but also tilts and turns it additionally. I guess a single cylinder would not support all that freedom. Some small details that I found interesting are the light blue plastic tips of the y-axis rotator and the two nubs on them. springs? magnets? To keep the eye in a stable position between the rotators? It also has a little nub on top to keep it in place in the shell where it slides into the slits on each axis. It's really satisfying to watch when you look at a cores animation. I love to look at the tiny details. Also, the rail structure that combines inner and outer shell to keep it in place, so that only z-axis rotation of the shells is possible. The only thing that is actually a mistery is that the optic element moves independent of the eye-ring and is not connected to the Stewart platform. There is nothing to explain it.
I've spent hours in the model viewer just admiring the mechanical detail, and trying to figure out if some of this stuff is possible. Just some things I noticed: - The eyelids are impossible as they're portrayed in-game. As others have already said, the devs admitted they had to 'cheat' by making them compress inside the eye casing. - The eye display can move as if it was attached to a ball socket, but is not actually attached to anything. - The rails that move on the Y and Z axis also move with the eye casing, possibly to stabilize it or something. The problem is that they both intersect at the same point on the back of the core, meaning that they clip through each other. So overall, building a game-accurate core is impossible. But with some creative liberty, you can make it work.
-cranial caps and it contains proven preservatives, deep penetration agents and gas and odor control chemicals, that will deodorize and preserve putrid tissue.
@@dkskcjfjswwwwwws413 yes, that's what I ment by AI modules, it would have been easier to program in a limit Glados's personality using the machinery that's already there rather than make a new device to do it.
@@samuraijackoff5354 they could easily be built, and be a lot smaller than they are portrayed in game, they'd actually ba about as big as a standard mobile phone. Putting something that small into a roughly one meter sphere is very impractical.
@@warriorcast8567 glados never was an AI to begin with, they actually transfered a human brain personality into a robot. The cores where programmed to affect said brain, similar as a peacemaker is meant to affect the heart.
1:48 These arent rubber cylinders! they are hydraulic cylenders that allow the core to move its eye and close surrounding areas outwards. They also help stabalize the core and keep it together.
I’ve been working on a mars rover to help my entry into nasa I have like 20 servos so I was going to make something cool I sound like Wheatley and I adore the space core so I was contemplating voicing it as if Wheatley and the space core cot merged because glados knew it would be the perfect torture
as a person who made a core, named it Hendrix, enfused it with an Alexa so I can ask it anything. and put it on a track so it can go were I tel it too, AND be a security camera. I can say, cores are 100 percent possible.
@darkbluediamond3618 that was three years ago, dude. i sadly lost Hendrix in a housefire and never got around to making a new one😭 but i wouldn't use Alexa for the new one.
Some guy's been working on an animatronic Wheatley for a while now. So far it looks pretty good, and stays at least about as close to the game as it can.
1:42 that arrangement is called a "Stewart platform", and gives it 6 dof of movement. It is likely the actuation source for the eye's pitch and yaw. It seems quite overkill tho since it's only using 2 of the 6 available axes. Perhaps redundancy?
Yes gels are and if u mean the portal gun itself yes and rlly working yes but the portals wloud be with radiations.Theres a video on the yt about portals
the portal 1 cores could work.... simply beinga ball inside a little "cage" with the handles holding it together.... the core itself having some wheels inside the shell to turn around with.. but uh, just have to make sure they cant go too far or the theels would jump out.... and get stuck outside the 2 sides... if that is accounted for it would 100% be possible I think Grady form Aperture desk jobs move in a similar way
It’s extremely easy to make a Portal 1 core. Step 1: Get gyroscopes and a computer. Step 2: Enclose them in a spherical assembly with the eye light and plug. Step 3: Attach the side plates. Step 4: Add the handles to hold the side plates on. May need to be reinforces since they are the only contact points.
I think the reason why Aperture designed it's robots with personalities, flexability, and vaguely lifeform-esque appearances is to make them appear more friendly and "human" to the test subjects, workers, and scientists with better communication as a result.
Don't forget garnishes such as: Fish shaped crackers, Fish shaped candies, Fish shaped solid waste, Fish shaped dirt, Fish shaped ethyl benzine. Pull and peel licorice, Fish shaped volatile, organic compounds and sediment shaped sediment.
Cave Johnson, founder of Apature, specifically mentioned that the cores' shells were made of asbestos. Not aluminium. Not being horrible, just stating what the cores were made of.
You do realize that when he was saying that the enrichment spheres are made of asbestos, he means the underground enrichment spheres, right? Like the big spherical buildings the tests are contained in, built within the old salt mines. He never mentions the personality spheres.
With the portal 1 core, other than the obvious cable in the back clipping, it may be possible. The outer casing (where the handles are) could be electrically connected to the main body via wireless charger style devices. This casing contains motors to move the actual core. The inside of the core would contain a gyroscope, along with the tech that it would need to compute things as well as run the eye. Going back over this, we can actually remove the motor and settle with wheels and brakes instead. The gyroscope could be the main movement. Either way, the Portal 1 core is entirely possible.
lots of extremely accurate animatronics have been made for the cores, and if you managed to upload an ai that could control the mechanics and move itself you would basically have a core
Nahh, smartphones can already run on-device AI's, without any external computing, considering a cores "eye" wich i suppose would be where the computer is is the size of a small pc its very possible
In terms of actually functionality? No, a dinky little spring cant safely stop your fall from any reasonable height. Most definitely from a construction standpoint, just look at prothetic running legs
Hmm. I might give this a shot. I read somewhere in the comments that Meet the Cores 2 has an eye assembly, so I'll look at that as well. Time to learn how to build stuff I guess? Of course Portal is the thing that gets me deeper into one of my hobbies, lol.
The real question is: what's the main power source? Which kind of battery a core should need for last that long? They seems to have a very small housing for batteries and processors
People have made Wheatley animatronics, that you can control, but someone needs to make a Core that can speak, and do things on its own without someone Controlling it.
Mechanically it would be a curiosity. Electronically the canon dimensions of the electronics needed for fully functioning AI are tiny iirc and would be infeasible.
This is likely expensive to make. Custom pcb even chips for the best result, custom lcd screen for it is rounded(not cheap to cut), machined metal casing, codes, camera behind the lcd for actual functionalities, speakers, the connector( customise it) if produce one only, crazy expensive, even millions of them will still be expensive. I am starting to work on it to bring it to real life, full scale. But it will be crazily expensive and hard to build.( maybe cause you a Tesla car)
Shorter answer: Yes. Someone already made it, looks so fucking similar, aswell as it rotates and even talks. Of course, pre-recorded shit. But we already saw AI fit into a head. Copy it, paste it, done.
![[SFM] Portal/2: Is GLaDOS Possible?](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/y3hyetVSWhA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[SFM] Portal/2: Is GLaDOS Possible?](/img/tr.png)
![[SFM] Portal/2: Turrets - Are they possible?](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/79UG7fkZPRI/mqdefault.jpg)
They admitted in the developer commentary that Wheatley's eyelids wouldn't be physically possible. In the game, they got around this by compressing (as in, the opposite of stretching) the parts hidden by the ring.
I've seen someone make a live model of Wheatley that somehow does it, so it can be done, just maybe not identically to how it looks in the game.
th-cam.com/video/6__rQSXZcFM/w-d-xo.html
i found this out on my own, by opening GCFScape and going through the commentary in the vo folder, and yeah, they admit that, i didnt extract ALL the files tho, so no link
Then that means portal 1 cores are possible right?
A portal 1 core has no eye lids
Which means that if u remove the portal 2 cores eyelids it will just be a portal 1 core
they could be possible by making them turn
The yellow actuating cylinder rod structure is called a Stewart Platform. Pretty cool. It not only moves the ring around the eye forward and backward, but also tilts and turns it additionally. I guess a single cylinder would not support all that freedom. Some small details that I found interesting are the light blue plastic tips of the y-axis rotator and the two nubs on them. springs? magnets? To keep the eye in a stable position between the rotators? It also has a little nub on top to keep it in place in the shell where it slides into the slits on each axis. It's really satisfying to watch when you look at a cores animation. I love to look at the tiny details. Also, the rail structure that combines inner and outer shell to keep it in place, so that only z-axis rotation of the shells is possible. The only thing that is actually a mistery is that the optic element moves independent of the eye-ring and is not connected to the Stewart platform. There is nothing to explain it.
yup yup! very fascinating!!
the claw that held the PotatOS : is it possible ??
I'd say so, I think it looks like a fairly basic robotic arm, even simpler, really.
I saw someone who made the robot arm that trolls the Captcha, it looked the same as the one from the game.
Buttons,cubes,claws,spheres.They are the simpliest things to be maked its just a button a box and a sphere andd a claw nothing much
Well it should since its just a plastic stick
@@linuxguardian8596 it might actually be metal
MEET THE CORES 2 HAS AN EYE ASSEMBLY SHOWN
it is fan made
Okacha_06 it’s good enough to be official
@@okacha_0632 We are all aware. But tbh it's the best we got so...
@@zigmund767 good enough to be offical? Are you stupid???
That's not canon
I've spent hours in the model viewer just admiring the mechanical detail, and trying to figure out if some of this stuff is possible.
Just some things I noticed:
- The eyelids are impossible as they're portrayed in-game. As others have already said, the devs admitted they had to 'cheat' by making them compress inside the eye casing.
- The eye display can move as if it was attached to a ball socket, but is not actually attached to anything.
- The rails that move on the Y and Z axis also move with the eye casing, possibly to stabilize it or something. The problem is that they both intersect at the same point on the back of the core, meaning that they clip through each other.
So overall, building a game-accurate core is impossible. But with some creative liberty, you can make it work.
2:13 1 (18.25-ounce) package chocolate cake mix 1 can prepared coconut-pecan frosting 3/4 cup vegetable oil 4 large eggs 1 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips 3/4 cup butter or margarine 1 2/3 cup granulated sugar 2 cups all-purpose flour Fish-shaped crackers Fish-shaped candies Fish-shaped solid waste Fish-shaped dirt Fish-shaped ethylbenzene Pull-and-peel licorice Fish-shaped volatile organic compounds and sediment-shaped sediment Candy-coated peanut butter pieces (shaped like fish) 1 cup lemon juice Alpha resins Unsaturated polyester resin Fiberglass surface resins and volatile malted milk impoundments 9 large egg yolks 12 medium geosynthetic membranes 1 cup granulated sugar An entry called: "How to Kill Someone with Your Bare Hands" 2 cups rhubarb, sliced 2/3 cups granulated rhubarb 1 tbsp. all-purpose rhubarb 1 tsp. grated orange rhubarb 3 tbsp. rhubarb, on fire 1 large rhubarb 1 cross borehole electromagnetic imaging rhubarb 2 tbsp. rhubarb juice Adjustable aluminum head positioner Slaughter electric needle injector Cordless electric needle injector Injector needle driver Injector needle gun Cranial caps
apparently this is what the “cake” is
I have to say this cake tastes kinda strange
-cranial caps and it contains proven preservatives, deep penetration agents and gas and odor control chemicals, that will deodorize and preserve putrid tissue.
-and it contains proven preservatives, deep penetration agents and gas and odor control chemicals, that will deodorize and preserve putrid tissue.
they are definitely possible, however due to the amount of space they take up they would be pretty impractical for data storage/AI modules.
Im pretty sure they were meant to control glados better
@@dkskcjfjswwwwwws413 yes, that's what I ment by AI modules, it would have been easier to program in a limit Glados's personality using the machinery that's already there rather than make a new device to do it.
Over the years our phones and computers have been getting smaller and smaller. We’ll just need time.
@@samuraijackoff5354 they could easily be built, and be a lot smaller than they are portrayed in game, they'd actually ba about as big as a standard mobile phone. Putting something that small into a roughly one meter sphere is very impractical.
@@warriorcast8567 glados never was an AI to begin with, they actually transfered a human brain personality into a robot. The cores where programmed to affect said brain, similar as a peacemaker is meant to affect the heart.
I love how the newer looking core just starts chanting ingredients for a cake.
The older newer one
That's the old model from Portal 1. Not the new one.
older one?
1:48
These arent rubber cylinders! they are hydraulic cylenders that allow the core to move its eye and close surrounding areas outwards. They also help stabalize the core and keep it together.
They are used for the face, not the actual eye itself.
theyre rubber you idiot
I’ve been working on a mars rover to help my entry into nasa I have like 20 servos so I was going to make something cool I sound like Wheatley and I adore the space core so I was contemplating voicing it as if Wheatley and the space core cot merged because glados knew it would be the perfect torture
Good luck dude
Good luck with the Rover! I hope you get into Nasa, they could use someone like you :)
as a person who made a core, named it Hendrix, enfused it with an Alexa so I can ask it anything. and put it on a track so it can go were I tel it too, AND be a security camera. I can say, cores are 100 percent possible.
show core
@darkbluediamond3618 that was three years ago, dude. i sadly lost Hendrix in a housefire and never got around to making a new one😭 but i wouldn't use Alexa for the new one.
Some guy's been working on an animatronic Wheatley for a while now. So far it looks pretty good, and stays at least about as close to the game as it can.
Volt?
the second ones are the goofy little brothers
When I make a Core:
ITS ALIVE! ITS ALIVE!
yes
LIVE MY CREATION, LIVE, LIIIIIIVVVVEEE!!!!
now we can launch it to space!
@@evilriceplate2590 if it even likes space
@@sirentrap5621 we kidnapped an astronaut and scan their brains against their will and then we have something like space core
The first versions ones are very much possible the outer shell is just a brace for the center which is most likely rotated using weights
1:42 that arrangement is called a "Stewart platform", and gives it 6 dof of movement. It is likely the actuation source for the eye's pitch and yaw. It seems quite overkill tho since it's only using 2 of the 6 available axes. Perhaps redundancy?
I am actually designing a core after this video it will be made👌🏻
aye mate, if you do be sure to make a video and hit me up uwu
@@TetherAnimations9999 I will thank you I'm currently working on it
@@GERG1986 so how's it going?
@@КаналВорона-в9д it's going well but it's a trial and error process, in other words not so good.
@@GERG1986 glad to know it's at least going
Good luck with it
*G R A N U L A T E D S U G A R*
Portal Gun and Gel: Is it possible?
Yes gels are and if u mean the portal gun itself yes and rlly working yes but the portals wloud be with radiations.Theres a video on the yt about portals
no.
I think Gels just ruin the physics. Because idk how did they find a thig that makes you bouncy?
@@teadrinkingwarlock5101 Well, with feet.
@@Blinsick well, yes. I mean, what is Bouncy Gel made of? We already know that Conversion Gel is made of moon rocks.
the portal 1 cores could work.... simply beinga ball inside a little "cage" with the handles holding it together.... the core itself having some wheels inside the shell to turn around with.. but uh, just have to make sure they cant go too far or the theels would jump out.... and get stuck outside the 2 sides... if that is accounted for it would 100% be possible
I think Grady form Aperture desk jobs move in a similar way
Yea I was thinking that too
Wheatley is going in my room and I'm going to make a remote controlled rail for him
wow you had 200 when this vid came out but now look at you you have grown so much in just a year or so
It’s extremely easy to make a Portal 1 core.
Step 1: Get gyroscopes and a computer.
Step 2: Enclose them in a spherical assembly with the eye light and plug.
Step 3: Attach the side plates.
Step 4: Add the handles to hold the side plates on. May need to be reinforces since they are the only contact points.
I think the reason why Aperture designed it's robots with personalities, flexability, and vaguely lifeform-esque appearances is to make them appear more friendly and "human" to the test subjects, workers, and scientists with better communication as a result.
Don't forget garnishes such as:
Fish shaped crackers, Fish shaped candies, Fish shaped solid waste, Fish shaped dirt, Fish shaped ethyl benzine.
Pull and peel licorice, Fish shaped volatile, organic compounds and sediment shaped sediment.
Cave Johnson, founder of Apature, specifically mentioned that the cores' shells were made of asbestos. Not aluminium. Not being horrible, just stating what the cores were made of.
You do realize that when he was saying that the enrichment spheres are made of asbestos, he means the underground enrichment spheres, right? Like the big spherical buildings the tests are contained in, built within the old salt mines. He never mentions the personality spheres.
With the portal 1 core, other than the obvious cable in the back clipping, it may be possible.
The outer casing (where the handles are) could be electrically connected to the main body via wireless charger style devices. This casing contains motors to move the actual core. The inside of the core would contain a gyroscope, along with the tech that it would need to compute things as well as run the eye.
Going back over this, we can actually remove the motor and settle with wheels and brakes instead. The gyroscope could be the main movement. Either way, the Portal 1 core is entirely possible.
People are actually making portal cores, sure no personality but still cool!
Well you see there’s this one guy called: Mr. Volt
lots of extremely accurate animatronics have been made for the cores, and if you managed to upload an ai that could control the mechanics and move itself you would basically have a core
Thanks for this I needed to know if they are possible
Also the portal 1 cores are possible
2:30. Ment to look good and more of an attachment than an independent device.
It’s very posibal but it’s the nearal network that you have to worry about it would take so many processers
Nahh, smartphones can already run on-device AI's, without any external computing, considering a cores "eye" wich i suppose would be where the computer is is the size of a small pc its very possible
Are the long fall boots possible?
In terms of actually functionality? No, a dinky little spring cant safely stop your fall from any reasonable height.
Most definitely from a construction standpoint, just look at prothetic running legs
one big change for the cores are the fact they are now more robotic than a sphere
This type of concept of an AI robot that can talk to you is already kinda a thing in the form of Alexas and Google Homes.
Hmm. I might give this a shot. I read somewhere in the comments that Meet the Cores 2 has an eye assembly, so I'll look at that as well. Time to learn how to build stuff I guess? Of course Portal is the thing that gets me deeper into one of my hobbies, lol.
its not the frame you're worried about, its the AI part.
The real question is: what's the main power source? Which kind of battery a core should need for last that long? They seems to have a very small housing for batteries and processors
Its not the battery, all Aperture devices can run on 1.1v.
@@---pj1xz at least.
probably in the bucket.
Mr Volt got a working core.
People have made Wheatley animatronics, that you can control, but someone needs to make a Core that can speak, and do things on its own without someone Controlling it.
And now i can't understand... were are they taking their electric circuits, processor, and other)
literally everyone whos made a animatronic core: am i joke to you
Why the first wheatley looks like a eye balls its kinda creepy
Mechanically it would be a curiosity. Electronically the canon dimensions of the electronics needed for fully functioning AI are tiny iirc and would be infeasible.
And one man really crafting Wheatley...
Cores maybe, Portal Device absolutely impossible!
There is?
you just aren't thinking with portals.
@Jesus Galvez In that case, they are probably destroying their own universe.
@Jesus Galvez They probably take that from another universe.
In the future they will be possible
This is likely expensive to make. Custom pcb even chips for the best result, custom lcd screen for it is rounded(not cheap to cut), machined metal casing, codes, camera behind the lcd for actual functionalities, speakers, the connector( customise it) if produce one only, crazy expensive, even millions of them will still be expensive. I am starting to work on it to bring it to real life, full scale. But it will be crazily expensive and hard to build.( maybe cause you a Tesla car)
Aperture devices make Apple look like Dell.
Fun fact, the is someone buolding weathly irl with all the movements
It’s possible from a mechanical standpoint, though the full on personality would be a problem to make though..
I didnt know how slow a ready I was until I tried to keep up with this video.
Oh hey look somebody just finished their wheatly irl
wow that was pretty cool
Yes, infact somebody has made one.
the perfect chaneel
I know there’s toys about them so that’s a big step
3 years later the portal 1 cores get remastered in portal with RTX now its 4 years later and yeah thats it
Technical you can make a portal 1 core because you can just attach the sides magnetically and put a gyroscope I the middle
Inner module is a gyro I think. It makes most sense that that’s how it moves
0:10 what is the name of that song
Idk but i think i heard this song from portal 1
Diversity vents, are they possible
But no, The eyelids dissapear when they detract.
Yes they are with some slight modifications
I like blue old core its kinda cute
There's a VR game of Portal that shows you the assembly of a core (or the face of Atlas the test subject android)
So these things are POSSIBLE
Have you seen how many people have made irl cores before
1:55 these do exist in real life
for the people saying its impossible to make an aperture science core
Some one has made wheatley into a real thing
I've seen someone make a really realistic (mostly workin) Wheatley puppet thing
If someone just sand paper with the core shell and spill galime on them It will definitely broke
The 2d core however would be impossible to stand
Looks like my question was anwsered before I commented it
I think someone tried to make Wheatley
People can make A.I. nowadays, So yes it is likely possible with the A.I.
you should make a paint gun video or a gel video
Yeah someone made one
The first game's cores are probably more possible just put some wheels on the side, it couldn't do that but it would work
Somebody actually made two versions of a core but I forgot the channel name
I think the portal 1 cores are (slightly) possible it seems like the handles hold it together
What is that boot-up sound you use? It sounds really satisfying and I'd love to use it in some of the stuff I make
Hmm, thanks In my future, It like Alexa, Siri, google, something like that, but a bit Smart and annoying
is the mechanism on the portal gun that lets you pick things up possible?
Slow down your texts, I can’t read them fast enough ;-;
Portal 2 cores are almost 100% possible to build to scale
Portal 1 cores, brain hurts trying to figure out hiw they work on the inside and out
1:10 how would that work?
glados, is it possible?
Atlas and pbody are they possible?
Well in Portal 2 the dev commentary states that the eyelids are impossible, so no?
Cores are just ball robot
we know? the devs put their own official structure into it which seems more impossible so
Nevermind it can do a 360 sideways
Mr Volt is making wheatley i think
is egg with legg possible
Is the elavator and test door possible from portal two
Someone made Wheatley
Not the same construction though. Still impressive
Is Portal 1 GLaDOS possible?
Shorter answer: Yes. Someone already made it, looks so fucking similar, aswell as it rotates and even talks. Of course, pre-recorded shit. But we already saw AI fit into a head. Copy it, paste it, done.
Are portal gun possible?
can you make the text stay on screen longer? some people can't read super fast.
Maybe se mr volt he has quite the suprise