'Take Care of Maya' trial
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ต.ค. 2023
- Lawyers and the judge discuss items in a $220 million case against Johns Hopkins All Children’s Hospital featured in the Netflix documentary ‘Take Care of Maya’ without the presence of a jury, who adjourned after watching two video depositions, including one from social worker Catherine Bedy. bit.ly/46izs2T
Kathy Beaty making the statement of sexual websites is completely inappropriate that is child abuse it is mental torcher to the innocence of the child regardless of her maturity. Accusing her of doing something so ridiculous is totally uncalled for if anything it was Kathy Beaty who was acting pervertedly by making these accusations 🤬
The accountability software they tried using on Josh Duggar could have been installed I highly doubt a ten year old child would know how to get around it , if they're so worried about a ten year old accessing porm ! The kid is laying in bed all day that makes it child abuse .
Yeah bc it’s impossible that kids exposed to adult content early in life go on adult sites 🙄 the denial of CSA while accusing Beaty of SA is contradictory.
You can tell this child is sick and she also looks like she's suffered mentally as well!😢 I hope she gets the justice she truly deserves!❤
❤
Conversion disorder, her symptoms aren't fake, but they aren't real either.
What if her sickness and suffering is a result of psychological manipulation by her parents?
What the hospital and Cathy beauty done took her mother away from her simple
@@kevinhornbuckle that's exactly what conversion disorder can be
I cried a lot watching this on Netflix. I couldn't believe this is happening, just couldn't understand how an institution supposed to help this family destroyed their lives . The hospital staff who separated Maya and her family during the most crucial time of her health for the money they could get from the bills they charged. So funny, the doctors refute diagnosis of the previous doctors but bill her of the same illness...... funny....nurses and doctors who are so arrogant , feeling stupidly brilliant not considering that Maya's mom is also a nurse, who knew the health problems of her beloved child and should be the one to take good care of her. And huh, the judge who didn't allow the mother to hug her child. .......😢😢😢They killed her, they left her no choice, the whole family is devastated. Everyone could see the struggle of this family. Justice for this family! What else to prove of the injustice done?
Now they are confusing the father of the dates , a very poor strategy!
I agree with you 100%. That mother was put in a bad place don't want to make people think she was doing such stuff to that little girl her own child. Well all the time she was looking for answers because she herself had never seen nothing like what her child was going through in the hospital's before. Those Hospital people are just like the ones that crucified Jesus. God have mercy on their souls.😢
I don't understand why this judge makes jokes about the evidence that they asked to put in. This isn't a laughing matter your honor.😢
She looks so tired. I hope she doesn't relapse with all this stress!
I believe she is in relapse. Stress is a preciopitor
@@msjulsflyes I heard that too. That's why some of the time she cannot be in Court. Dad is very concerned about her right now.
I am wondering why the risk management staff at the hospital can inflict photos of a half naked child and the staff social worker seems to be fine to say that she was just doing what she was told with no regard to social worker standards of care.
CYA is no excuse for traumatizing a minor child in their custody.
There is no social worker standard of care.
@@katiestoddard7164 do tell, I have been held to them in my experience but would appreciate your input.
She is such a sweet girl. Im so sorry about your mother. And all the agony and pain these people have caused you all. Im praying for you your dad and brother.
Bless her heart. She looks exhausted. She has bags under her eyes 😢
The Lawyer representing the hospital needs to turn to them and say, just look at this traumatised child in front of you. You need to take ownership and admit you failed her.
Candour comes to mind.
Maya has the sweetest smile! I loved seeing her dancing on her bed! She looked soooo happy! ❤ Peace and love to you sweet one.
But journals are acceptable in homicide cases and suicides!!
I found articles that report an arrest of Catherine Bedy and a colleague of hers in 2007 for abusing a patient. It's horrific.
Where?
I hope this woman gets punished
I found it and read it… horrific !!!!!
Charges later dismissed. Child recanted his allegations
Just Google her name arrest and 2007.
@sharynkoren2054 wonder why 🙄 This woman is disgraceful
When you need Maya to smile rewind to the beginning. I pray she knows her mom only hopes for her to feel that everyday.its beautiful and its real!
Miss Bety should get locked away for a long long time. She is very shrewd.
Do I hear the judge getting a soul?! Wow. Prayers work!
That social worker is heartless and controlling!!!
JH let Bedy do what she wanted to do based off the duties in her so called position. She basically overrode her authority in her job position and hide behind DCF putting the burden of blame on them and JH Risk Management…she dropped names like a hot potato. But no one else was all up in Maya’s business on the 7th Flr but her. Smh
As a pedi nurse, this breaks my heart! No child should’ve gone through this. Someone should’ve advocated for her during the time in the hospital. Like was there a doctor or nurse that didn’t agree with what was going on that could’ve fought for the betterment of her care ? Being a child in the hospital alone and secluded is horrible 😢 I just want to give this girl a hug. This is why nursing is so much more than just a job that pays the bills. You have to really pay attention to your patients & advocate for them at all times. I’m not understanding how this slipped through the cracks. I know each person that walked into her room knew the back story so why was nothing done for her ? I don’t care I would’ve put anyone in their place if needed no matter the role they played. This makes me mad . Fight for your kids ❤ even if no one else will. Her mom was in the right because clearly you can see the type of people the child had advocating for her in the hospital. You can be nice & sweet as a nurse but you also have to stand up for your kid too. I see you & I hear you Maya 💗💗💗💗💗
Nurses & all hospital personnel are on the same team. It's not about the kids best interest . This isnt the first child going through this😢
Dr Elliot should be struck. The abuse this child went thru and the loss of her Mum - coz of the hospital, in my opinion - is sickening. We must stop this from happening again. How can we help this family? 🎉❤
@kkkookie37 if they win... but if they lose, it should be an outrage to everyone especially those who are vulnerable with a sick child.
Oh my goodness i sure wish that the defense lady would just sit down. She is soooo annoying. Justice for Maya and her family !!
This just makes me so sad. 😢 The trial is wearing on her...
Is it Kathy Beaty seating in the back in the brown suit smiling and having good time?????
Just reading each one of her notes makes me feel so sad. To think RIGHT NOW there’s other children out in this evil world who are suffering and alone. I pray God helps and protects each one of them and or any child being harmed.
I haven’t seen this story before so I’m not sure what’s happening or going on but by reading those notes. That tells me something is going on at this hospital and unable to have family and friends around. Why?
Omg listening to that recording killed me. Her little sad scared voice. Wow. So sad.
Did the mom die from all of this? Broken heart?
Oh wow they finally got to go to trial. Congrats to the family for finally getting here. It's absolutely egregious what happened with Maya and then her mother.
Godbless u maya and family 👪 stay strong Godbless yee all my heart is breaking for yee im praying the jury gets this right for u and family prayers 🙏 to all
Maya looks as if she wants to break out into tears. I feel very sorry for her. She is just a child stil.
Praying for you Maya❤❤
That lady just pisses me off but now acts like it’s not my fault blah blah blah
She is a piece if work! Oh God and DCF/Suncoast let her loose on children. I couldn't want her to take care of a cactus
@@sharynkoren2054That’s for damn sure!
And yet she still is a counselor through CVS
Maya is a good artist. Really good drawings and pretty, mature handwriting 😊
These hospital lawyers are pure evil too. They should be equally appalled with the content of these calls.
But Kudos to the Judge for ultimately admitting some of them.
She is SO STRONG 🧡🧡🧡
That phone call is very important once again that girl was held in prison .The hospital put people in place that made serious mistakes.Come on guys
It wasnt the hospital it was DCF/Suncoast. She was not an employee of the hospital
She said she worked for the hospital then
@@callie_5117 no DCF,/Suncoast never JH. BTW, Dr. Smith also worked for DCF/Suncoast. The Kowalski's settled with Dr. Smith, DCF/Suncoast for $2.5M.
Appears Suncoast should clean house and get rid of these types if people
@@callie_5117 She worried AT the hospital, her employer was DCF/Suncoast.
Her paycheck never came from JH. It was an assignment which she testified to in her deposition
People listening to her conversations with her lawyer are in appropriate.
So wish the plaintiff’s attorney would formulate his questions in a more cohesive manner. It would certainly cut down on objections and move the case along. He is looking unprepared before the jury. I hope Maya prevails.
I feel like they have a winning case but that attorney is not able to present the facts. I think everyone is frustrated with him. Imagine how the jury feels. If they lose, it will be from an inadequate legal team. I think the judge is trying to help him and he still can't manage to do it.
It s like he has language, speaking and focus problems. Formulating questions , complete a sentence. Maybe nervous in court. Tv cameras and lots at stake. In interview with that Kathy Bety he is very clear and good. She was not right in mind, telling Maya she would adopt her, !!!!????? Just sick. Poor Beata and the kids. So sad and disgusting treatment of a family. A sick child with pain kept from family, friends and school. For 3 months!!!!! Like a prisoner. Not allowed to hug her mom???? That just evil. Like Beata wrote to the jugde: your heart is ice cold . It really was and the Sally and. Kathy too. And others at the hospital too. Cruel towards Beata. She became desperate. Tradegy. Then send a bill???? The CPS should pay the bill. They kept her there. USA !!!! So sad they were not in Poland or Europe. Poland is not like back then. Lots of specialists in modern Europe. Free healthcare for children here in Scandinavia
Attorney Anderson is a well-known recognizable civil trial attorney known for high profile cases.
He is well known for winning Iron-44.
This should be a criminal case!!!! Let's not forget the delay getting this to court. Sit down old man b\c ur making a fool of yourself!
Look at this child...yes sometimes she smiles but the look on her face will tell you how she feels inside. Her life will never be the same.
It should be. When doctors knowingly lie or put their own best interests above a patients, especially a child, it should be criminal. There is no need to lie. If a doctor truly believes that a child is being abused then report it, but be willing to admit you are wrong when the evidence doesn't match up. Instead so many doctors who report abuse act like they have to prove they were right even if it means lying.
@@trirunner2520 unfortunately working 14 yrs in pediatrics and in ER doctors do not always want to get involved......truth...
If you look at Maya..she looks like she cries all day everyday, her ears are not pierced no jewelry no makeup..she looks like she is scared and in pain sitting in her clothes. Poor soul. The judge made her smile. Please smile more sweet child 😢❤
This family has been waiting for years to get to court. I do not understand why the father - or any of the other witnesses - would not have reviewed all of his notes, etc., to refresh his memory on such complex matters all these years later knowing he'd need to testify. I'm not saying he should have committed dates to memory but having a more refreshed memory would have aided the testimony, IMO.
Never heard of CRPS before this.
I have this horrible incurable disease. It has destroyed much of my life. I sued a well known health food store where a damaged door fell onto my foot fracturing it & the nails sticking out of the bottom of the door went into the top of my foot. Then I fell back slamming my left hand into a hard countertop to break the fall. That was the end of my life as I knew it. My muscles are wasting away & it can spread to the other hand & foot. My foot has black marks across my toes & the rest of my foot up to 1/2 way up my calve is purple & dark red & mottled. It is one of the worst pain syndromes there is. Constant pain. Some people's hearts give out because of the unrelenting pain & stress to the body.There are so many symptoms that it takes pages to even list them & describe them. My left hand always wants to curl inward like a lobster claw & so do the toes on my right foot. When I sleep I wake up from my hand being totally clenched & my foot curling forward. If I straighten out my hand quickly, the tendons are pulled. Once I was getting out of my car, straightened my fingers & screamed from a tendon being pulled in the middle of my hand. I was doubling over sobbing. There was a big lump there & I had to get an injection in the middle of my hand. I did not leave my house for 3 months after that because I was so worried that it would happen again & I would end up screaming around people in a store or somewhere else in public.There are muscle contortions so violent that my toes were almost fractured & my entire foot jerked all the way sideways to the point of almost snapping./breaking. That is just some of the issues people with CRPS live with. I won't do Ketamine infusions. One of my best friends died after receiving one. Also, it causes some people to have complete psychotic breaks.
@@cheatednomore6430oh my God. My heart hurts reading your words. 😢you deserve all the blessings 🙌
@@YIKESMF Thank you for your kind words 💜 It means alot to me 🙌
Heartbraking seeing Mayas words : " I want to sleep in my own bed"!
This judge is trying to take center stage. He seems so immature.
Can’t believe this is happening in America they should get every cent and then some
Mr Kowalski has incredible patience and self control.
Loved seeing Maya’s sweet smile.
I absolutely cannot believe how instantly Mayas journal had me cry in a quick second when i saw the picture of her family drawn.
Poor dad. He is unfamiliar with how his testimony was supposed to be used right now to get this evidence in, so it made it harder for the lawyer to extract the necessary information. He did great! Dont get me wrong! And im POSITIVE this is all very overwhelming. But if he was more familiar with what was needed from him (better prepared by his lawyer), this all would have gone more smoothly. And i cant really even blame the lawyer. They dont know which piece of evidence will require a hearing and which will be admitted on its face. They dont have time to prep him on everything.
I am going to look into this case now, this girl looks SICK and is in a dark hole in her own head why would they put her through court😢 ...I know nothing though I just know a clip from netflix. She looks very sad, now I am intrigued
I agree. Putting her through this trial is hell and might cause another flare. She stated she stays away from her house as much as possible. I couldn't live there either, going into the garage where her mother hung herself would give me permanent depression. He should have bought a new house with the $5M he already received and get a new start for all of them
Didn't know he got 5 mil. Then YES he certainly should move and make sure his kids are involved in the decision making.
That's why she stays away it's the horrible treatment she went through from that monsters hospital that they put her beautiful mother through when now we all no she didn't have that Monchoushau disease its the hospital social worker who had this disease she wanted maya
@sharynkoren2054 He's a good man. When they prevail he will make sure they have a new start.
@@ajsbpelq good...a new start will be beneficial to all
❤❤❤❤ 😢hang in there sweetheart
She didnt like blood pressure because she was in pain and feeling lonely
This case breaks my heart!! This poor child, mother and family all together!!! I hope she gets as much justice legally possible.. her life will ALWAYS be FOREVER changed from what this hospital and CPS lady (monster) has done to her.. let alone the loss of her mother.. i just cannot wrap my head around the fact of this happening or being a possibility!! How did it get this far!??! Turns my stomach.. what a strong girl and family!! I don't think I could've been put through this level of torment with my own children either.. That poor mother blaming herself even though she knew the truth!! Prayers for this family!!🙏🏻🥺😢😭
ALL these redundant, monotone attorneys are unprofessional & borderline rude. They all seem to be annoyed to be there.
The abuse continues.
They would have me all confused with the dates and what was being said, what Meya said and back to dates. I would be all turned around. The dates then not the dates. What was said not what was said but the date. The date something was said then not the date only what was said. Geeze 🤯🤯🤯
This is extremely sad. I can say I never had issues with John Hopkins all children’s hospital in St. Petersburg with my daughter. They were always so amazing.
Sadly, Maya has a condition they didn't believe. She needed treatment they thought was abusive. I'm glad you had a good experience, count yourself lucky!
The lawyer representing the hospital wearing the light brown suit looks so annoyed and exhausted having to sit through this trial maybe he needs to retire 😆
This courtroom seems an absolute shambles. Nobody seems to be ready with anything. So much wasted time shuffling paper and fiddling with kaptops. No wonder lawyers get rich on hourly billing.
The tall, dark defense attorney looks and sounds like "Robert" in tv show " Everybody loves Raymond" just an observation.
I just heard about this case, how horrific! I am commenting on an inaccurate statement that was made on the video. The victims family, specifically the daughter Rhonda, didn’t want the death penalty given. She actually got on the stand and said that. She said her mother would not have wanted a punishment of death either.
She didn’t like bp bc it hurts CRPS patients!
Do you think the hospital should have started a high dose ketamine infusion or other pain meds without ever getting a blood pressure?
@@susanwhalls6230they were never going to give it to her.
Trying to minimize witnesses
Praying for Maya❤
Is all hearsay and that's not how things work unfortunately Mr Kowalski! The Social Worker can very well sue these people for defamation of character. Unless you can show "receipts" it's all bla bla bla
He can't remember dates, says he wrotes his notes right away, but no dates, says look in his journal...but they are not there...sure Jan..
It is much easier to move around in water as you are much lighter.
Can someone please be kind enough to answer my question as other Attorneys not affiliated with this trial has me confused with their analysis. I thought Miss Beatty has her own Company or Private practice as works like a freelance journalist for an example. So why are they saying she works for the hospital? Does she get paid by the hospital? And lastly if she was asked by a Dr. @ the hospital to come & give her expert opinion whether or not Maya's Mother has Munchhousen by Proxy why isn't Miss Beatty being sued? And is she the person who is reporting what's happening with the Mother to the Judge? Our Medical System here isn't privatized so it gets a little confusing. I'm sure I've missed some testimony. The questions the Jurors asked tells me she will win. I don't know if the jury can adjust the sum if they don't agree with the amount or not? Thank you, Ontario, 🇨🇦
I agree 💯with Attorney Anderson. UNLESS THE JUDGE WANTS TO DISREGARD MAYAS Testimonies.
The judge is not going to let them get away with what they did to this family
Nice to Maya smile
Did he just say “the journal that I made up”?
You can see the grief on her i hope she wins the case 🙁
No she did not, she interrupted the Calls, with no alerts prior.
Jack isn't the brightest bulb
I'm sure she'll win some amount of money if not all but the hospital is likely to Appeal the verdict then it can drag out for years. Because if a lower Court says their verdict stands they can appeal this all the way to the Supreme Court! If that happens the Defense will most likely offer to settle out of Court for less but cover all Attorneys fees & Court costs & still she will walk away with millions & if that does happen she'd be best to accept it the stress & years it could take would be unbearable. Ontario, 🇨🇦 Unless this is a case to which they can't file an Appeal!
I despise this Judge.
Maya sound a bit drugged during the second phone call.
Please don’t put as live when you’re not showing live content
Pop's ain't fast enuf!
I love this judge..you can't trump his card!!!
No sound?
Interesting glitch??
Suncoast, Cathy Bedy settled with them. Bedy was so inappropriate. I get that. But, I don't get what JHAC did that was wrong.
Who wrote it? It’s not a 10 yrs printing
Omg 😱😳
OMG
Is she still not allowed to get ketamine infusions
No she's not allowed to this day if correct
I thought I heard that part of the final decision was that Maya could not recieve Ketamin treatments at all anymore. I want to know why and who made that decision...the Judge?
She doesn’t need ketamine. Her mom was giving her enough to kill someone. It is not a drug for children. Her mother obtained prescriptions by fraud and wanted the hospital to do surgery and put a port by her spine for ketamine. Obviously, the hospital had major concerns.
@msjulsfl link and not correct. You are assuming.
Jack said the Judge said she couldn’t get anymore infusions of ketamine, if Dad allowed it he was breaking court order , then Maya would be removed from his custody.
The most bias judge, disgusting!!!!
This is so crap, im getting so mad i want to turn it off, I don't understand how these things can't come in?
WORST JUDGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
He's disgusting. Totally biased. Makes me sick!!!!
he looks very annoyed at having to do HIS JOB!!!
Seriously!🙄@@SanDy-qq4gc
I do t like the bloodpressure machine either. It s very hurtful and tight. For a child in pain even worse. This jugde is so strange. Something off, not sympathetic personality. Not nice. Stupid jokes in a serious trial.
Awful judge imo.
Judge is extremely biased
In who’s favor
This judge looks evil.
I hope he reads this, awful man.
@@Suzanne2909 Me too, although he looks like the vindictive type -- likely to take out his frustration on others.
First world country?😂😂😂😂
JH was wrong, DcF was wrong @ Maya’s mom was wrong. I’ve taken care of plenty of patients with horrible diagnoses including crps that aren’t belligerent and abusive to hospital staff
Her moms attitude and demands were detrimental
@@sharynkoren2054absolutely, I’m not saying JH is right, they should kicked them out when she became belligerent ( they wanted to leave). Someone else wants/needs the bed
@@susanwhalls6230 when a transfer was in the works for Maya to go to Demours Beata turned it down because it said Beata had Factitious (Munchausen) and was afraid if losing her job. Nemours had a pain management center for children with CRPS. Was she protecting herself or trying the best for Maya?
Her mom did nothing wrong.
Her mother was a nurse and a good one. I'm a nurse and as a nurse you become very protective of loved ones and friends when in the ER and you feel no one is listening. Some of the staff, I'm sure got their feathers ruffled. That put a whole new spin on what's written in the notes. I've seen this...I worked ER. Any other day she may have gotten a more compassionate dr. they all have different personalities.... just like all of us.
I really hope these people get justice they deserve From what I watched on Netflix this is horrific put yourself in their place 🦘🐨🦘
It wasn't the hospital_ it was DCF/Suncoast. She was not employed by JH
The hospital was advising DCF throughout the entire case. The courts/judge was dependent on the hospital's evaluation and opinion. That being said this court case is based on a few days Maya was held in the hospital prior to the courts shelter order and the acts of hospital staff outside of the court orders. It's a very nuanced case that is going to take months to complete.
I thought that lady specifically said she worked for jh at the time.
@@callie_5117 Yes Cathi Bedy did work directly for JHACH. I don't know all the details but she was arrested for child abuse herself before working at JHACH.
It was the hospital that wrote all the records , and made the recommendations to the Judge . The Judge was advised by the staff . The hospital petitioned the court , the hospital called State DCS