As a native New Yorker, I say this is a great video. Rule number 1 in NYC: Do Not Block Anything! New Yorkers are on the go 24/7 and we do not like to be held up by people. Walk like you are on a mission. Get in and get out.
Agreed. Never block the way! And although it's not mentioned in the video--when walking around town, always look down and watch where you're walking. Tourists have a habit of looking up--and for good reason as the towers can be amazing. However, the locals all watch the pavement they walk on so as not to step in or on anything undesirable.
As a lifetime New Yorker let me say that the advice in this video is a 100% spot on. Everyone should use the subway and everyone should be vigilant when doing so.
@@lightishot7378 As you should in any large city. The fact is that millions of people move through NYC each and every day and do it safely. That said, it's always wise to be aware of your surroundings anywhere you go.
I grew up in CT just over the NY state border and was about 45 mins outside NYC, but was born in Texas and have now lived in Texas for the last 20yrs. I don't necessarily think new yorkers are rude, but much more matter of fact with people. And I agree y'all are just in a rush and busy.
Another "Don't": Don't stand near the track. If there is a wall, stand with your back against it until the train is in front of you. If there is no wall, stand with your back against a column and be aware of people around you. This can avoid your being pushed off the platform.
Two tips: 1) If you’re flying into JFK and staying in Midtown Manhattan, you can take the AirTrain to Jamaica station, where you can take the LIRR to the city. It costs a little more but it’s a lot faster 2) If you’re coming to NYC in the summer, consider taking the NYC Ferry! If you’re staying in the city, taking the ferry to Rockaway Beach is a great way to see the FiDi skyline and a completely different part of the city!
I take the NYC subway every day. I wish you could take the points from this video and engrave them on a plaque at every subway entrance. Excellent job Mark!
Perfect! As a longtime New Yorker, I love it that you advised people to NOT BLOCK! I love the tourists in NY, but it is irksome to be held up by silly behavior. Would suburbanites appreciate random chatter or delays during their commute to work? I love your videos--I just went to Amsterdam, and I am planning Prague, Vienna, Budapest (pronounced “boo-duh-pesht” per Wolter's World!), Krakow and Warsaw. I watch all of your relevant videos before I travel. 👏👏👏👏👏👏❤❤❤❤🙋♀
I'm a native New Yorker and I'm loving this series! Another note about not talking to random people on the subway. Crime is up, so that's another reason you kinda want to keep to yourself on the subway.
Always look at the seat before sitting. Especially on rainy days. some jerks will set a wet umbrella on it and leave a puddle behind. On hot days the ac can sometimes leak on seats too so always look before sitting.
I'm glad you mentioned not to make eye contact with people. It's so underrated but a lot of my European friends just don't understand how easy they can get into a fight if they stare or take pictures without people's permission here 😬😬😬
I wish people visiting CA East Bay cities would respect that! But spoiled rich kids have to have everything they want here in uc city and just HAVE to take our picture.
Most of these apply to every metro/underground system. Not everywhere has the rule about standing on the right on escalators like in NY and London, but the rest apply, always let people off first, don't talk to people, don't block people, have your ticket/card ready before going to the barriers/gates, don't block the doors etc
I live in Montréal where we also have the habit of standing on the right, but I once knew someone who worked for the maintenance of the escalators and he was pissed by this habit. Having everyone standing on only one side of the escalator breaks it 😅
@@mypradasatthecleanerss I lived in Hong Kong for a bit, and everyone just stands on both sides on the MTR escalators, which was irritating as someone from London. And when I visited Singapore they all stand on the left and walk on the right, so it's the same thing but the other way round
I learned about the right side of the escalator when I was in London for the first time, I might have been 14 I think. People got so mad at me for standing on the left side and I was like 'what? I have never even used subway before why are you mad?' Since then I always stand on the right side even when it's an elevator that leads to the coffee shop or grocery store. Learned the hard way lol
Further advice - it is easier to look up at the directional signs in the stations than down at your phone's app. Millions were spent standardizing the signs and other wayfinding tools. Each station payment area had detailed large wall maps showing the neighborhood and area bus lines which you can transfer to for free.
Brilliant point! The wayfinding signs are really quite excellent. Some of the stations are really confusing--especially at large transfer stations like Times Square--and the MTA spent a lot of good effort simplifying the way. Those signs are clear and accurate. Use them!
Exactly. I remember visiting in 2008 and 2011 and we relied on the map, the printed notices and the great signage all over the Stations. Got around just fine. Recently though, I visited in 2021 and some trains were a little hard to find in "big" local stations. I remember having such a hard time finding the R train in Jay St and it was literally the most hidden away set of stairs I've ever seen.
@@mentonerodominicano Yeah, that particular station is a good news / bad news story. The R was the Metrotech Station, and the A/F was the Jay Street/Borough Hall Station. Some years ago, the MTA decided to introduce an in-station connection, allowing passengers to transfer between the A/F and R lines. Great idea. Unfortunately, finding one line from the other is a bit of a rat maze. The signs work, but it's not as straightforward as anyone would like.
Thank you Mark for making this video of the NYC Subway. Thank you for pointing out the things that you were supposed to do and not to on the Subway. I work for the New York City Subway as a motorman and I see a lot of tourists here riding the train I also will point out do not be afraid to ask the conductor in the middle or the train operator right in front of the train if you need any help. And do not be afraid to use the Subway you are in good hands with fellow New Yorkers, the police that patrol on the Subway and employees like myself!! Thank you!! I'm a huge fan of your channel and hopefully your tips and guides will help me and my future trips in the world!!
Yes, New Yorkers will never start up a random conversation, but they'll absolutely help you if you're lost. And the MTA employees are really good at helping passengers. Not only the motorman and conductor, but now the "token booth" clerks are deployed in the stations offering assistance to anyone who asks. These are really good resources--don't overlook them.
And disabled, which as a disabled person like myself, still not everyone did. But I guess not many visibly disabled people you see with wheelchairs and walkers etc. on the subway because it’s true what Mark said, NYC isn’t totally ADA accessible. I found out the hard way and ended up having to leave my mobility walker in my room for the rest of my trip. Because even though I can’t do a-lot of walking without getting out of breath and having to take sit down breaks to rest my back, which tends to ache, it was a lot more tiring for me to carry my walker up and down stairs all the time than that. And of course it’s true, most New Yorkers just stay focused among themselves and barely interact, so therefore I barely got offered any help, so I mostly was having to carry it a lot by myself, and it was even more tiring than going without my walker 😞 That was the only unfortunate part of my trip. I ended always finding somewhere to sit and have my breaks. Although I have seen people in wheelchairs in NYC and I wonder how do they even make it around there. 😅 I didn’t even see no wheelchair spaces in the subway either. 😢
If you are traveling late at night or on weekends, don't forget to check the service change bulletins. Nothing is worse than trying to get somewhere and finding out you can't because routine track maintenance is going on that weekend.
Yeah, like trying to get to work on the dntown R at 28th st. in the 1980s. Pay token, wait..... no train, no warning, leave, rush down to 23rd st., get different train, maybe get to work on time.
Another don’t here that I learned from my visit to NYC: Don’t tap off upon exiting the subway at your destination! Subway fare is $2.75 flat, no matter how close or far you travel. I once did that, not realizing that we only tap in to pay the fare when entering, so therefore, I actually ended up paying the fare double when I thought I had to tag off at my destination 😂 I was in that habit because I live here in the Bay Area, and trains here, fare does vary upon distance, so we do tag on and tag off, but that isn’t the case in NYC I now found out a little late 😂 So save yourself that extra $2.75 to use when you actually are getting back on the train and don’t make the same mistake I did 😅
It's been awhile since I used BART, but isn't the tap off point before the turnstile and effectively blocks you from leaving? In NY you can only tap off after you're on the other side so I would think this is instinctual for people not to do it.
If the train is very crowded, decide which door you plan to exit from, but don't stand in the doorway. I have never been unable to get off a train, no matter how crowded. Other people are doubtless also exiting, and they can run interference for you. Also, passengers tend to make room for people trying to exit. A couple of "excuse me's" really helps.
About 90% of these apply to the London Underground too - biggest differences are the line colour (London has set colours for lines, NYC goes by letter/number) and the fact that all London Underground stations can access both directions. As a Londoner visiting NYC, I’ve definitely made the mistake of ending up going the wrong way and couldn’t figure out how to go the other way!!
The train lines in Toyko looks way more confusing at first and I'm from New York but after being there for a few days it got a lil more easier to navigate and understand the map.
I've also negotiated Londons Underground. I will say- I didn't want to be that guy and have to ask commuters questions. But, I had no choice. I needed a straight answer once in a while. I found that MOST Londoners were helpful and friendly. Same as anywhere, keep it short, state your point, problem or concern early and - remember, the locals have shit to do. If you want someone to take you by the hand to your destination- try Kerry, Ireland.
@@kennyworth007 The same is true in NYC. If you're lost or need help, ask a local. Locals will NEVER start a random conversation, but if asked for directions or help, they'll gladly give it. And as you said--keep it short and get to the point quickly. "Excuse me. How do I get to xx?" is usually a good way to begin.
Bless you! 😂 As a native NYer this is an essential video. We welcome tourists and if you're lost or need help most of us will be happy to help. But subway etiquette is essential because the stereotype is true, we are always in a rush, mainly because the subway system never runs right. Nobody likes the subway so knowing the rules will make things a lot easier for everyone. ❤
I was visiting NYC a few years ago. My friend ask me before we got in the subway “are you claustrophobic?” I’m not but I can see how people who are might not like the subway
One thing I found handy when I travel is a compass. When you get out of the subway you need to know which is south and which is north,especially in Manhattan with building everywhere. I have a mini one in my pocket and one on my iPhone.
Lived in NYC for 15 years. The best method I found to orient myself when emerging from the subway was to look for a landmark skyscraper and have a concept as to whether it should be north, south, east or west of you (e.g., you get off at 50th and Lex, look for the Empire State Building or Roc Center...south and west). Admittedly, this may not work in the outer boroughs, but in the city, it is a surefire compass-less way of telling direction.
I never felt I needed a compass. Remember that most of the subway was built with the cut-and-cover method, which means the trains are not very deep in the ground--they're usually just one level under the street. Also remember that *most* Manhattan trains run under the Avenues--so they travel uptown or downtown. It's usually easy to remember which direction your train was traveling so if you can picture the direction of train travel when you get above ground, you can use that to orient yourself to north or south.
These are all great tips! So true! I’m an Aussie and whenever I visit nyc I see tourists making so many of these mistakes. I did lots of research before I went for the first time so I wouldn’t stuff up lol. The subway is great. I was so scared the first time I used it but it gif me literally everywhere, particularly when I didn’t feel like walking. I just got a bit lost sometimes when exiting, getting out at wrong exit haha. So many of my friends have wasted money on taxis in nyc purely cos they were scared to Take subway. Subway is the best :) always love your vids
@@bettyh8005 I actually paraphrased that from a song by The Cramps called "Don't Eat Stuff Off the Sidewalk." Sample lyrics: Let me give you some advice Don't eat stuff off the sidewalk Don't eat stuff off the sidewalk You don't need it so don't eat it No, don't eat stuff off the sidewalk No matter how good it looks You better go by the book Leave it there, don't you dare
My biggest don’t: Don’t hop in to a car when the doors are closing. It’s not like an elevator, the doors will close on you. I’ve seen peoples purses and bags get caught and they never get those back
For trips to the airport, you can take a train to JFK. It is the air train. The air train is is on the mezzanine level at Jamaica, Queens. It is a big terminal for the LIRR (Long Island Railroad) for point East and West. It's quicker to get into the city at certain times or you can can take the E&J underground in the same station for the subway it's called Sutphin. Tourists usually get off on the wrong Sutphin stop by taking the F instead of The E. It's not that bad if they do it just means you're about 4 blocks further away.
One thing I noticed is that the subway entrances have green globe lights at the staircases. I walked around a bit looking for the entrance to one before I realized I could look for these
I think it's green=you can buy a fare card here, yellow=you can enter if you already have a fare card (no longer an issue with OMNY payment), and red=exit only.
@@Hal10034 close…it’s green = 24/7 attended, yellow = part time attended, red = closed/exit only. with the introduction of metrocards and removal of attendants they no longer need the three colors so it’s red = exit only and green = open 24/7
Not all the stations are handicap friendly, usually marked on maps which ones are. Don't use the subway during usual rush hours, some trains get VERY packed especially through Manhattan and some parts of outer boroughs.
All really good tips for visitors. Couple others: make sure you know direction to hold your metro card when you Swipe to not hold others up behind you, and if you are on the wrong side of platform and Swipe you'll need to wait 15 minutes to Swipe again in the same station. And of course, if seats are full and you have the ability to easily stand please give up your seat for those who need the seat.
Great work. As a former NYer (left for PA in 1989), and someone who continued to work in/around NYC until retirement last year, this was really well done. My only add would be to your point about express trains connecting to local ones... just be somewhat aware of the safety of the area in which you're transferring from one to the other. In really problematic areas, it might be better to spend the extra time on the local rather than being on a platform waiting to transfer (especially at night). Usually anywhere in Manhattan is okay, but some of the areas in the outer boroughs might be less so.
Actually, @wolter should make a video about express and local service. That's a concept somewhat unique to the NYC subway and could be a video in its own right. It's not a difficult concept, but for the newbie, it can be a bit confusing at first.
Prior to the pandemic, I was going to New York about once a year. One thing you didn't mention is the occasional pan handler...or the performers, usually around the Times Square stations, who burst into the car with a boom box and say "It's Showtime!!!!!!" and proceed to do a choreographed dance or whatever.
What a great video!!! as a New Yorker i can say you were spot on with every single point mentioned. Us New Yorkers are always on a rush... because we don't want to miss the train LOL! I need this in writing! :)
If someone misses an express train, you WILL NOT be delayed 1 hour. At the most 15 minutes. Express trains run just as often as local. One thing you didn't mention was NOT TO STOP on a stairwell. So many people do this and create an immediate traffic jam. Otherwise, your video was excellent. You are practically a local! KUDOS.
@@Moonflowers11 Are we talking about the LIRR? And you can be 5 hours late if you miss your flight out of JFK. He is talking about the Subway, not the train. Did you even watch the video? Did you read the title of the video? The Don'ts of the NY Subway. Are you lost?
@@ovh992 Native New Yorker here. I'm never lost on the subway, streets or train. People maybe connecting with a train after they're on the express train.
Hey Mark, are you ever going to do a “Dont’s of Visiting Cedar Point” video? If so I can think of somethings that really upset other park goers or tips that could help others maximize their trip.
Doors don’t open automatically. Just have to wait until we conductors confirm that the train is fully in the station before we open up the doors. Some train operators don’t always put us at the proper stop position. That’s what the conductor indication board (zebra board) is for
Regarding the doors. I'm so uaed to them being automatic when I've been to NYC and DC that I almost missed my train when on the Minneapolis light rail recently because you have to tap a spot on the door for it to open when getting on or off.
"Don't stand in the way/block people" from my own personal experience, is also a good suggestion for walking on London sidewalks. Spent a week in London, and that was a point of contention for me
100% correct. Do not listen to google because they will show you the long way. Ask the people waiting to help you. No taxi unless you are drunk. Each train has a buddy and they go in the same direction. One local and one express. You can also drink the water. Great filtration system.
Your advice is 100% correct, but, with all due respect, I believe your video will scare off a lot of folks, particularly first-time visitors from small towns who are already overwhelmed by the enormity of NYC. You do touch on the benefits of using the subway, but the majority of that is at the end of your piece. I'm admittedly quibbling over style; I just think a little more encouragement can be a good thing. Thank you for your channel.
My mother breaks most of these rules in ever city she goes to. It’s cringe inducing 😢 the amount of times she asked someone with headphones on for directions 😭
All good advice but visitors should know the subway is usually uneventful and very easy. And while we NYers are often rushed and busy, we will generally help you if you’re lost or confused about transit. The only time I’ve brushed anyone off is if they approach with a pissed off or entitled attitude as if I’m personally responsible for their confusion.
Railcar doors do not open automatically. They are opened and closed manually by the conductor operating the doors control. However, I do agree with you that people should refrain from holding subway car doors, obstructing doorways and occupying extra seats with personal items and outstretched thighs. That striped block at the conductor's position is called the "conductor's board." I am a railroad buff.
One "don't" that I'm surprised wasn't mentioned: Don't lean against the doors! Train doors have safety sensors, like elevator doors. Putting weight against the doors can fool the sensors, and cause the door to open while the train is in motion. This has been true on every transit train that I have ridden. Modern technology may be solving this problem. But, not every train car is new.
l don't remember myself beginning to talk to anybody on the subway; but others have several times begun talking to me. As to the NYC subway's disabled-unfriendliness, this is legendary; buses are better for this. By the way, there are also many places where it "pays" to pay for a ride without traveling on the subway, as in many places there are interesting artworks, views or historic features which can be seen.
If you drop your iphone on the tracks, decide just how real your love for your mobile device is before going down to the tracks. Getting hit by trains hurts. A lot.
I feel like you're timing me perfectly lol my husband and I are going to new York next week for vacation. We're from Chicago so we know city rules and etiquette but it's still a different ball park so tips are always good. Thank you ❤
I’m a NYer. Prior to 2020 I’d ride the train at 2 in the morning. No fears! Now I will not take a train. There’s too much random violence. Tourists do not know which trains are safe and which are terrible. Best not to take a train and wear comfortable sneakers
Lived my whole life here and I've seen quite a few "New Yorkers" who absolutely need to watch this video. Particularly that etiquette section. When youre standing in front of the doors, exactly how do you board the train when we can't get off 🤔
The bag thing omg. Nyc subways get PACKED and the worst is when you can’t sit down because someone has bags in the way. Put it on your lap or between your knees.
Most of your Subway trips will be uneventful. Kids like 10-ish years old take the subway by themselves. You'll probably be fine if you are even remotely street smart. If you take the Subway enough you will see some crazy stuff, but do as New Yorkers do, ignore it. If you mind your business and don't draw attention to yourself you'll be able to get through almost any crazy scenario on the subway. Worst case scenario, you can always change cars at your next stop.
Good advice. But when I used to ride the BART 4 yrs. ago, I would sometimes have short, great conversations with people. But I did miss the live music in the NYC subway stations.
Very important, especially nights and weekends when there are service changes for construction, keep an eye out for posted service changes and listen for announcements. Sometimes trains will only make all stops in one direction, so you have to overshoot and then backtrack, and other times, trains will be rerouted along a parallel line, or even turned into a different train mid-trip and you can end up somewhere very different from where you intended. It doesn't happen super often, but often enough you really should pay attention, especially if you are traveling outside of midtown/downtown.
Another great New York advice video! Especially the don't talk to or make contact with people in the subway one. Instant indication you don't live there is if you don't completely mind your own business no matter what when you're on the train.
I'm from Brooklyn. Sometimes people mind their own business too much. I drive a city bus. It breaks my heart the shit people look the other way on- but go full on Karen about. ''Excuse me, Sir- I think that man in the back of the bus might be dead. He hasn't moved in 30 minutes. I would have said something, but, I can't be late for work."
The don’t about making eye contact lol! As a NYer, I can verify this is true haha. And the earbuds in the ears are a silent indication saying, don’t talk to me
As a lifetime New Yorker, I wholeheartedly agree with and support this video. It never ceases to amaze me how many tourists always stop and congregate at the top of the subway stairs or escalator.
omg i have family in flushing and when we'd take the train in and have to take a subway out to them on weekends, there's no express. it's like an hour long. not too many express trains on the weekends.
For everyone scared to ride the subway 1) don't after 10 pm then and 2) find the most crowded car and hop in. Worst case (VERY low) you'll get pickpocketed. But you CERTAINLY won't get assaulted without someone stepping in. Worst case you have to hear a homeless sales pitch. And that's what an iPod is for
I'm from that area and I don't understand the PA system either. LOL. I think Charlie Brown's teacher works there after retiring from her teaching job. Cheers.
A lot of this is just good subway/metro etiquette in general. As a DC local, I can say most of those points apply either directly or in a very similar way to the metro here.
On 2 separate occasions during my NYC visit I got on the wrong A train and went allllll the way up to the top of the island. Shame on me for not paying attention
Tell me about it! Especially when they're doing construction on tracks and may have to take a shuttle bus or connect to a different train line depending what train you're on since the train is only going to stop at a certain point. I'm from New York btw.
Big Fan and a NYC Transit Supervisor A few points of information 1- Train Operator is in front of the train...operating, many people like to say "Driving the train" 2- Conductor is in the middle of the train opening and closing the doors, also makes station announcements on the older trains We love your videos❤
Conductors are always helpful when you need directions on what train to take or transfer when you’re lost. It happens when trains get rerouted and you need an alternative route.
"Don't manspread" - Well, this should be a common advice for every country, city and transportation. And the reason why I prefer to sit next to other women and hate to let a man sit next to me (I use a bag to avoid it :D).
He said more than once if a train is empty, or there’s a fairly crowded train with a few empty seats, do not sit in those places. But he never says why. I asked my partner who was born and raised in NYC and he said it is either because there is some sort of terrible smell, vomit, or offending odor from another passenger that would prompt you to stand, instead of sit.
WOW 😮I'm Overwhelmed Just Trying To Remember all This For Visiting From Arkansas 35 never rode one seems interesting tho.. We Truly Got it Made in Arkansas No Subways No Bad Traffic compared to New York Bless Y'all 🙏🏾💯
Glad that most of these rules is more or less the same when I was in Tokyo, these are nice rules to follow I'm definitely ready for my nyc trip next week
It took a few days for me to learn how to use the subway. it's too bad transit systems in other cities can't be as user frienfly, The trains run so often you don't need a schedule.
Even as an urbanite the different entrances did catch me when I first used the subway. Metro etiquette is pretty universal wherever you go but it's standard in other systems that every station entrance is universal, so walking into a subway entrance and seeing you can't get to your platform from there was a surprise!
As a native New Yorker, I say this is a great video. Rule number 1 in NYC: Do Not Block Anything! New Yorkers are on the go 24/7 and we do not like to be held up by people. Walk like you are on a mission. Get in and get out.
Yes! The number one thing that annoys me is people who get off the escalator or through the turnstile and just stand there in front of it! Ugh ! 😴
Agreed. Never block the way! And although it's not mentioned in the video--when walking around town, always look down and watch where you're walking. Tourists have a habit of looking up--and for good reason as the towers can be amazing. However, the locals all watch the pavement they walk on so as not to step in or on anything undesirable.
May I ask the best places to stay as a first time visitor?
As a lifetime New Yorker let me say that the advice in this video is a 100% spot on. Everyone should use the subway and everyone should be vigilant when doing so.
Don’t ask the MTA about the second avenue subway
should be vigilant here period
@@lightishot7378 As you should in any large city. The fact is that millions of people move through NYC each and every day and do it safely. That said, it's always wise to be aware of your surroundings anywhere you go.
His advice is rock solid. These things annoy the hell out of me, and many New Yorkers are way more guilty of them than the tourists
As a lifelong New Yorker, I just want to say that we aren't rude. We are just in a rush!
Some bad apples out there 👀
@@kiroto7429 alot… gotta be mindful
@@kiroto7429 Of course there are bad apples out there--just as there are bad apples in any town or village anywhere on earth.
Gotta get them ripe again
I grew up in CT just over the NY state border and was about 45 mins outside NYC, but was born in Texas and have now lived in Texas for the last 20yrs. I don't necessarily think new yorkers are rude, but much more matter of fact with people. And I agree y'all are just in a rush and busy.
Another "Don't": Don't stand near the track. If there is a wall, stand with your back against it until the train is in front of you. If there is no wall, stand with your back against a column and be aware of people around you. This can avoid your being pushed off the platform.
Yes!!! So important
This!!!
Especially when a certain demographic is close by.
It can also avoid you falling off the platform by accident, which is much more common than being pushed.
@@zigman8550 the homeless/visually unwell
Two tips:
1) If you’re flying into JFK and staying in Midtown Manhattan, you can take the AirTrain to Jamaica station, where you can take the LIRR to the city. It costs a little more but it’s a lot faster
2) If you’re coming to NYC in the summer, consider taking the NYC Ferry! If you’re staying in the city, taking the ferry to Rockaway Beach is a great way to see the FiDi skyline and a completely different part of the city!
Financial District, not Fidi. Please don't act like these acronym obsessed realtors. The area has a name.
I take the NYC subway every day. I wish you could take the points from this video and engrave them on a plaque at every subway entrance. Excellent job Mark!
Perfect! As a longtime New Yorker, I love it that you advised people to NOT BLOCK! I love the tourists in NY, but it is irksome to be held up by silly behavior. Would suburbanites appreciate random chatter or delays during their commute to work? I love your videos--I just went to Amsterdam, and I am planning Prague, Vienna, Budapest (pronounced “boo-duh-pesht” per Wolter's World!), Krakow and Warsaw. I watch all of your relevant videos before I travel. 👏👏👏👏👏👏❤❤❤❤🙋♀
I'm a native New Yorker and I'm loving this series! Another note about not talking to random people on the subway. Crime is up, so that's another reason you kinda want to keep to yourself on the subway.
As a native Londoner I find it amazing how our rules are almost identical but for the tube 😅
Crime is up because of leftist in office. Vote left = get crime.
Always look at the seat before sitting. Especially on rainy days. some jerks will set a wet umbrella on it and leave a puddle behind. On hot days the ac can sometimes leak on seats too so always look before sitting.
I'm glad you mentioned not to make eye contact with people. It's so underrated but a lot of my European friends just don't understand how easy they can get into a fight if they stare or take pictures without people's permission here 😬😬😬
I wish people visiting CA East Bay cities would respect that! But spoiled rich kids have to have everything they want here in uc city and just HAVE to take our picture.
Most of these apply to every metro/underground system. Not everywhere has the rule about standing on the right on escalators like in NY and London, but the rest apply, always let people off first, don't talk to people, don't block people, have your ticket/card ready before going to the barriers/gates, don't block the doors etc
NYC is kind of dirtier though
Why would you not walk on the left and stand on the right?? As a Londoner this makes no sense. What y’all doing clogging up the escalators ?
I live in Montréal where we also have the habit of standing on the right, but I once knew someone who worked for the maintenance of the escalators and he was pissed by this habit. Having everyone standing on only one side of the escalator breaks it 😅
@@mypradasatthecleanerss I lived in Hong Kong for a bit, and everyone just stands on both sides on the MTR escalators, which was irritating as someone from London. And when I visited Singapore they all stand on the left and walk on the right, so it's the same thing but the other way round
I learned about the right side of the escalator when I was in London for the first time, I might have been 14 I think. People got so mad at me for standing on the left side and I was like 'what? I have never even used subway before why are you mad?'
Since then I always stand on the right side even when it's an elevator that leads to the coffee shop or grocery store. Learned the hard way lol
Further advice - it is easier to look up at the directional signs in the stations than down at your phone's app. Millions were spent standardizing the signs and other wayfinding tools. Each station payment area had detailed large wall maps showing the neighborhood and area bus lines which you can transfer to for free.
Brilliant point! The wayfinding signs are really quite excellent. Some of the stations are really confusing--especially at large transfer stations like Times Square--and the MTA spent a lot of good effort simplifying the way. Those signs are clear and accurate. Use them!
Exactly. I remember visiting in 2008 and 2011 and we relied on the map, the printed notices and the great signage all over the Stations. Got around just fine. Recently though, I visited in 2021 and some trains were a little hard to find in "big" local stations. I remember having such a hard time finding the R train in Jay St and it was literally the most hidden away set of stairs I've ever seen.
@@mentonerodominicano Yeah, that particular station is a good news / bad news story. The R was the Metrotech Station, and the A/F was the Jay Street/Borough Hall Station. Some years ago, the MTA decided to introduce an in-station connection, allowing passengers to transfer between the A/F and R lines. Great idea. Unfortunately, finding one line from the other is a bit of a rat maze. The signs work, but it's not as straightforward as anyone would like.
Thank you Mark for making this video of the NYC Subway. Thank you for pointing out the things that you were supposed to do and not to on the Subway. I work for the New York City Subway as a motorman and I see a lot of tourists here riding the train I also will point out do not be afraid to ask the conductor in the middle or the train operator right in front of the train if you need any help. And do not be afraid to use the Subway you are in good hands with fellow New Yorkers, the police that patrol on the Subway and employees like myself!! Thank you!! I'm a huge fan of your channel and hopefully your tips and guides will help me and my future trips in the world!!
Yes, New Yorkers will never start up a random conversation, but they'll absolutely help you if you're lost. And the MTA employees are really good at helping passengers. Not only the motorman and conductor, but now the "token booth" clerks are deployed in the stations offering assistance to anyone who asks. These are really good resources--don't overlook them.
DO Give up your seat for the elderly
…and for pregnant women. Such a nice thing.
And disabled, which as a disabled person like myself, still not everyone did. But I guess not many visibly disabled people you see with wheelchairs and walkers etc. on the subway because it’s true what Mark said, NYC isn’t totally ADA accessible. I found out the hard way and ended up having to leave my mobility walker in my room for the rest of my trip. Because even though I can’t do a-lot of walking without getting out of breath and having to take sit down breaks to rest my back, which tends to ache, it was a lot more tiring for me to carry my walker up and down stairs all the time than that. And of course it’s true, most New Yorkers just stay focused among themselves and barely interact, so therefore I barely got offered any help, so I mostly was having to carry it a lot by myself, and it was even more tiring than going without my walker 😞 That was the only unfortunate part of my trip. I ended always finding somewhere to sit and have my breaks. Although I have seen people in wheelchairs in NYC and I wonder how do they even make it around there. 😅 I didn’t even see no wheelchair spaces in the subway either. 😢
@@Chanelly93 yes it's unfortunate NYC is not more Ada friendly. Hopefully you were still able to enjoy your time here.
Definitely. For pregnant, disabled or elderly.
Yes as the elderly I agree with this comment.
If you are traveling late at night or on weekends, don't forget to check the service change bulletins. Nothing is worse than trying to get somewhere and finding out you can't because routine track maintenance is going on that weekend.
Yeah, like trying to get to work on the dntown R at 28th st. in the 1980s. Pay token, wait..... no train, no warning, leave, rush down to 23rd st., get different train, maybe get to work on time.
Another don’t here that I learned from my visit to NYC: Don’t tap off upon exiting the subway at your destination! Subway fare is $2.75 flat, no matter how close or far you travel.
I once did that, not realizing that we only tap in to pay the fare when entering, so therefore, I actually ended up paying the fare double when I thought I had to tag off at my destination 😂 I was in that habit because I live here in the Bay Area, and trains here, fare does vary upon distance, so we do tag on and tag off, but that isn’t the case in NYC I now found out a little late 😂 So save yourself that extra $2.75 to use when you actually are getting back on the train and don’t make the same mistake I did 😅
It's been awhile since I used BART, but isn't the tap off point before the turnstile and effectively blocks you from leaving? In NY you can only tap off after you're on the other side so I would think this is instinctual for people not to do it.
If the train is very crowded, decide which door you plan to exit from, but don't stand in the doorway. I have never been unable to get off a train, no matter how crowded. Other people are doubtless also exiting, and they can run interference for you. Also, passengers tend to make room for people trying to exit. A couple of "excuse me's" really helps.
About 90% of these apply to the London Underground too - biggest differences are the line colour (London has set colours for lines, NYC goes by letter/number) and the fact that all London Underground stations can access both directions. As a Londoner visiting NYC, I’ve definitely made the mistake of ending up going the wrong way and couldn’t figure out how to go the other way!!
The train lines in Toyko looks way more confusing at first and I'm from New York but after being there for a few days it got a lil more easier to navigate and understand the map.
I've also negotiated Londons Underground. I will say- I didn't want to be that guy and have to ask commuters questions. But, I had no choice. I needed a straight answer once in a while. I found that MOST Londoners were helpful and friendly. Same as anywhere, keep it short, state your point, problem or concern early and - remember, the locals have shit to do. If you want someone to take you by the hand to your destination- try Kerry, Ireland.
@@kennyworth007 The same is true in NYC. If you're lost or need help, ask a local. Locals will NEVER start a random conversation, but if asked for directions or help, they'll gladly give it. And as you said--keep it short and get to the point quickly. "Excuse me. How do I get to xx?" is usually a good way to begin.
Lifelong native NYer here, this is all completely accurate. Impressed with how much detail went into this!
Bless you! 😂 As a native NYer this is an essential video. We welcome tourists and if you're lost or need help most of us will be happy to help. But subway etiquette is essential because the stereotype is true, we are always in a rush, mainly because the subway system never runs right. Nobody likes the subway so knowing the rules will make things a lot easier for everyone. ❤
Glad to help 😀
I was visiting NYC a few years ago. My friend ask me before we got in the subway “are you claustrophobic?” I’m not but I can see how people who are might not like the subway
One thing I found handy when I travel is a compass. When you get out of the subway you need to know which is south and which is north,especially in Manhattan with building everywhere. I have a mini one in my pocket and one on my iPhone.
Lived in NYC for 15 years. The best method I found to orient myself when emerging from the subway was to look for a landmark skyscraper and have a concept as to whether it should be north, south, east or west of you (e.g., you get off at 50th and Lex, look for the Empire State Building or Roc Center...south and west). Admittedly, this may not work in the outer boroughs, but in the city, it is a surefire compass-less way of telling direction.
I never felt I needed a compass. Remember that most of the subway was built with the cut-and-cover method, which means the trains are not very deep in the ground--they're usually just one level under the street. Also remember that *most* Manhattan trains run under the Avenues--so they travel uptown or downtown. It's usually easy to remember which direction your train was traveling so if you can picture the direction of train travel when you get above ground, you can use that to orient yourself to north or south.
These are all great tips! So true! I’m an Aussie and whenever I visit nyc I see tourists making so many of these mistakes. I did lots of research before I went for the first time so I wouldn’t stuff up lol. The subway is great. I was so scared the first time I used it but it gif me literally everywhere, particularly when I didn’t feel like walking. I just got a bit lost sometimes when exiting, getting out at wrong exit haha. So many of my friends have wasted money on taxis in nyc purely cos they were scared to Take subway. Subway is the best :) always love your vids
Here's a "don't" of traveling on the subway: Do not eat anything off the subway floor, no matter how good it looks.
THAT made me LOL!
@@bettyh8005 I actually paraphrased that from a song by The Cramps called "Don't Eat Stuff Off the Sidewalk." Sample lyrics:
Let me give you some advice
Don't eat stuff off the sidewalk
Don't eat stuff off the sidewalk
You don't need it so don't eat it
No, don't eat stuff off the sidewalk
No matter how good it looks
You better go by the book
Leave it there, don't you dare
Unless you're the famous NYC subway pizza rat! lol
Did you learn this from experience?🤣
My biggest don’t: Don’t hop in to a car when the doors are closing. It’s not like an elevator, the doors will close on you. I’ve seen peoples purses and bags get caught and they never get those back
Not just bags. People get severely injured or even killed this way.
For trips to the airport, you can take a train to JFK. It is the air train. The air train is is on the mezzanine level at Jamaica, Queens. It is a big terminal for the LIRR (Long Island Railroad) for point East and West. It's quicker to get into the city at certain times or you can can take the E&J underground in the same station for the subway it's called Sutphin. Tourists usually get off on the wrong Sutphin stop by taking the F instead of The E. It's not that bad if they do it just means you're about 4 blocks further away.
Super presentation! You covered every mistake I’ve made or witnessed in years of visiting NYC and even provided a soupçon of new-to-me information.
this video applies for most subways and skytrains like in Vancouver too. people need this!!!
I was going to say the same thing. These are pretty standard rules this side of India.
One thing I noticed is that the subway entrances have green globe lights at the staircases. I walked around a bit looking for the entrance to one before I realized I could look for these
I think it's green=you can buy a fare card here, yellow=you can enter if you already have a fare card (no longer an issue with OMNY payment), and red=exit only.
@@Hal10034 close…it’s green = 24/7 attended, yellow = part time attended, red = closed/exit only. with the introduction of metrocards and removal of attendants they no longer need the three colors so it’s red = exit only and green = open 24/7
red = exit only or closed, green = open 24/7…
These exact rules apply to our subway in Montreal.
Also London. The stand on the right rule applies to most rapid transit systems.
This is so true I go for a vacation there at least every two years and the subway is awesome. Yeah, you should follow these hints 😊
In China getting on the subway is wild...they seem to not understand letting others off first. A constant struggle.
I understand them. People walk slow as hell as if other people have all day to wait on them
Lmao I love this it’s a “how to not get yelled at by a New Yorker on the subway” list
Not all the stations are handicap friendly, usually marked on maps which ones are.
Don't use the subway during usual rush hours, some trains get VERY packed especially through Manhattan and some parts of outer boroughs.
All really good tips for visitors. Couple others: make sure you know direction to hold your metro card when you Swipe to not hold others up behind you, and if you are on the wrong side of platform and Swipe you'll need to wait 15 minutes to Swipe again in the same station.
And of course, if seats are full and you have the ability to easily stand please give up your seat for those who need the seat.
Great work. As a former NYer (left for PA in 1989), and someone who continued to work in/around NYC until retirement last year, this was really well done. My only add would be to your point about express trains connecting to local ones... just be somewhat aware of the safety of the area in which you're transferring from one to the other. In really problematic areas, it might be better to spend the extra time on the local rather than being on a platform waiting to transfer (especially at night). Usually anywhere in Manhattan is okay, but some of the areas in the outer boroughs might be less so.
Same here. Retired from TA a year I dont miss it.
Actually, @wolter should make a video about express and local service. That's a concept somewhat unique to the NYC subway and could be a video in its own right. It's not a difficult concept, but for the newbie, it can be a bit confusing at first.
These also aply to the Viennese public transport and actually for public transportation in general!
Wolter is the Milquetoast Captain!
Prior to the pandemic, I was going to New York about once a year. One thing you didn't mention is the occasional pan handler...or the performers, usually around the Times Square stations, who burst into the car with a boom box and say "It's Showtime!!!!!!" and proceed to do a choreographed dance or whatever.
💀💀💀
What a great video!!! as a New Yorker i can say you were spot on with every single point mentioned. Us New Yorkers are always on a rush... because we don't want to miss the train LOL! I need this in writing! :)
If someone misses an express train, you WILL NOT be delayed 1 hour. At the most 15 minutes. Express trains run just as often as local. One thing you didn't mention was NOT TO STOP on a stairwell. So many people do this and create an immediate traffic jam. Otherwise, your video was excellent. You are practically a local! KUDOS.
Many of the trains on the Long Island Railroad only run every hour especially off peak. So you can make someone an hour late if you slow them down.
@@Moonflowers11 Are we talking about the LIRR? And you can be 5 hours late if you miss your flight out of JFK. He is talking about the Subway, not the train. Did you even watch the video? Did you read the title of the video? The Don'ts of the NY Subway. Are you lost?
@@ovh992 Native New Yorker here. I'm never lost on the subway, streets or train. People maybe connecting with a train after they're on the express train.
Hey Mark, are you ever going to do a “Dont’s of Visiting Cedar Point” video? If so I can think of somethings that really upset other park goers or tips that could help others maximize their trip.
Doors don’t open automatically. Just have to wait until we conductors confirm that the train is fully in the station before we open up the doors. Some train operators don’t always put us at the proper stop position. That’s what the conductor indication board (zebra board) is for
Regarding the doors. I'm so uaed to them being automatic when I've been to NYC and DC that I almost missed my train when on the Minneapolis light rail recently because you have to tap a spot on the door for it to open when getting on or off.
"Don't stand in the way/block people" from my own personal experience, is also a good suggestion for walking on London sidewalks. Spent a week in London, and that was a point of contention for me
100% correct. Do not listen to google because they will show you the long way. Ask the people waiting to help you. No taxi unless you are drunk. Each train has a buddy and they go in the same direction. One local and one express. You can also drink the water. Great filtration system.
Your advice is 100% correct, but, with all due respect, I believe your video will scare off a lot of folks, particularly first-time visitors from small towns who are already overwhelmed by the enormity of NYC. You do touch on the benefits of using the subway, but the majority of that is at the end of your piece. I'm admittedly quibbling over style; I just think a little more encouragement can be a good thing. Thank you for your channel.
I would say, start by riding a few bus routes, then work up to the subway. Have a subway map with you as you roam around.
My mother breaks most of these rules in ever city she goes to. It’s cringe inducing 😢 the amount of times she asked someone with headphones on for directions 😭
Dude, that is one seriously good video that merits a 💯.
I rode on the subways for many years and will say you are 100% spot on.
Lived in New York for many years and this is very good advice!
All good advice but visitors should know the subway is usually uneventful and very easy. And while we NYers are often rushed and busy, we will generally help you if you’re lost or confused about transit. The only time I’ve brushed anyone off is if they approach with a pissed off or entitled attitude as if I’m personally responsible for their confusion.
Railcar doors do not open automatically. They are opened and closed manually by the conductor operating the doors control. However, I do agree with you that people should refrain from holding subway car doors, obstructing doorways and occupying extra seats with personal items and outstretched thighs. That striped block at the conductor's position is called the "conductor's board." I am a railroad buff.
One "don't" that I'm surprised wasn't mentioned: Don't lean against the doors! Train doors have safety sensors, like elevator doors. Putting weight against the doors can fool the sensors, and cause the door to open while the train is in motion.
This has been true on every transit train that I have ridden. Modern technology may be solving this problem. But, not every train car is new.
l don't remember myself beginning to talk to anybody on the subway; but others have several times begun talking to me. As to the NYC subway's disabled-unfriendliness, this is legendary; buses are better for this. By the way, there are also many places where it "pays" to pay for a ride without traveling on the subway, as in many places there are interesting artworks, views or historic features which can be seen.
it's nice to meet you and socializing did does and/or PROBABLY will VARY
If you drop your iphone on the tracks, decide just how real your love for your mobile device is before going down to the tracks. Getting hit by trains hurts. A lot.
I feel like you're timing me perfectly lol my husband and I are going to new York next week for vacation. We're from Chicago so we know city rules and etiquette but it's still a different ball park so tips are always good. Thank you ❤
It used to be a mad rush getting on and off a subway car until the City ran a PR campaign and people actually followed it.
I’m a NYer. Prior to 2020 I’d ride the train at 2 in the morning. No fears! Now I will not take a train. There’s too much random violence. Tourists do not know which trains are safe and which are terrible. Best not to take a train and wear comfortable sneakers
Lived my whole life here and I've seen quite a few "New Yorkers" who absolutely need to watch this video. Particularly that etiquette section.
When youre standing in front of the doors, exactly how do you board the train when we can't get off 🤔
The bag thing omg. Nyc subways get PACKED and the worst is when you can’t sit down because someone has bags in the way. Put it on your lap or between your knees.
Most of your Subway trips will be uneventful. Kids like 10-ish years old take the subway by themselves. You'll probably be fine if you are even remotely street smart. If you take the Subway enough you will see some crazy stuff, but do as New Yorkers do, ignore it. If you mind your business and don't draw attention to yourself you'll be able to get through almost any crazy scenario on the subway. Worst case scenario, you can always change cars at your next stop.
Bingo!
Good advice. But when I used to ride the BART 4 yrs. ago, I would sometimes have short, great conversations with people. But I did miss the live music in the NYC subway stations.
Same in most cities with a subway (except the lettering and numbering, but every city has their own system of labeling trains).
Very important, especially nights and weekends when there are service changes for construction, keep an eye out for posted service changes and listen for announcements. Sometimes trains will only make all stops in one direction, so you have to overshoot and then backtrack, and other times, trains will be rerouted along a parallel line, or even turned into a different train mid-trip and you can end up somewhere very different from where you intended. It doesn't happen super often, but often enough you really should pay attention, especially if you are traveling outside of midtown/downtown.
YES. to not Standing on the left on escalators or blocking train doors.
Another great New York advice video! Especially the don't talk to or make contact with people in the subway one. Instant indication you don't live there is if you don't completely mind your own business no matter what when you're on the train.
I'm from Brooklyn. Sometimes people mind their own business too much. I drive a city bus. It breaks my heart the shit people look the other way on- but go full on Karen about. ''Excuse me, Sir- I think that man in the back of the bus might be dead. He hasn't moved in 30 minutes. I would have said something, but, I can't be late for work."
@@kennyworth007 yes it's very true that it does have the horrible side effect of making us all more inhuman too
Just been over there ots like lesson after lesson
The don’t about making eye contact lol! As a NYer, I can verify this is true haha. And the earbuds in the ears are a silent indication saying, don’t talk to me
As a lifetime New Yorker, I wholeheartedly agree with and support this video. It never ceases to amaze me how many tourists always stop and congregate at the top of the subway stairs or escalator.
WOW! I've lived in NYC for 9 years - these tips are all things I've had to learn on my own through trial and error. Superb video!! :]
Man i just love you😃😍✨️you are so cool😎👍🏽
omg i have family in flushing and when we'd take the train in and have to take a subway out to them on weekends, there's no express. it's like an hour long. not too many express trains on the weekends.
NOTE: "You May See Peoples BODY PARTS, Occasionally, From Time To Time!" Wholey LOL! ! Dude You are a Riot and Great At Explaining Stuff! Cheers!
For everyone scared to ride the subway 1) don't after 10 pm then and 2) find the most crowded car and hop in. Worst case (VERY low) you'll get pickpocketed. But you CERTAINLY won't get assaulted without someone stepping in. Worst case you have to hear a homeless sales pitch. And that's what an iPod is for
lol a homeless sales pitch
I'm from that area and I don't understand the PA system either. LOL. I think Charlie Brown's teacher works there after retiring from her teaching job. Cheers.
A lot of this is just good subway/metro etiquette in general. As a DC local, I can say most of those points apply either directly or in a very similar way to the metro here.
On 2 separate occasions during my NYC visit I got on the wrong A train and went allllll the way up to the top of the island. Shame on me for not paying attention
My old neighborhood, Inwood.
Everything up to 5:08 applies to the DC Metro too for anyone visiting DC.
The empty cars are usually indicating a car with malfunctions, or have been used in lieu of a real bathroom
I lived in NYC for 20 years, and your advice is 100% spot on.
Don't get too mad when the subway confuses the heck out of you. The local trains and the express trains and the switching tracks will drive you crazy.
Tell me about it! Especially when they're doing construction on tracks and may have to take a shuttle bus or connect to a different train line depending what train you're on since the train is only going to stop at a certain point. I'm from New York btw.
@Amari's Perspective That also happen to me,I'm not from New York,just had some frustration with the Subway all 10 or so times I've been.
true for every city.
True
Great video this coming from a native New Yorker and transit worker
"You'll see body parts occassionally..." Ummm... attached or detached from the bodies?
Big Fan and a NYC Transit Supervisor
A few points of information
1- Train Operator is in front of the train...operating, many people like to say "Driving the train"
2- Conductor is in the middle of the train opening and closing the doors, also makes station announcements on the older trains
We love your videos❤
Conductors are always helpful when you need directions on what train to take or transfer when you’re lost. It happens when trains get rerouted and you need an alternative route.
Don’t knock on the conductors or train operators door asking “ where’s the rest room” …there are none even in most stations
Which stations to avoid is the question I would have.
Most of these pointers apply to every day activity, everywhere in the world. Simply put, think of others.
"Don't manspread" - Well, this should be a common advice for every country, city and transportation. And the reason why I prefer to sit next to other women and hate to let a man sit next to me (I use a bag to avoid it :D).
Depending on the time of day and how far you are going the difference between the express and local is less than 5mins.
Grew up on Long Island and knew most of this, but I had no clue about the zebra stripe part!
He said more than once if a train is empty, or there’s a fairly crowded train with a few empty seats, do not sit in those places. But he never says why. I asked my partner who was born and raised in NYC and he said it is either because there is some sort of terrible smell, vomit, or offending odor from another passenger that would prompt you to stand, instead of sit.
WOW 😮I'm Overwhelmed Just Trying To Remember all This For Visiting From Arkansas 35 never rode one seems interesting tho.. We Truly Got it Made in Arkansas No Subways No Bad Traffic compared to New York Bless Y'all 🙏🏾💯
im a new yorker... thank you for making this for people.
That was a great presentation!
Sounds like advice for the Stockholm subway here in Sweden too. 👍👍
Vancouver, Canada area guy here, many of these are just common courtesy, regardless of city.
Using apple pay for each journey was super easy - and I think its as effective as getting a card unless you use the subway a TON
Glad that most of these rules is more or less the same when I was in Tokyo, these are nice rules to follow I'm definitely ready for my nyc trip next week
Whew. I don’t have talk to people, on the subway. I’m not a talker. Thanks for the tips.
It took a few days for me to learn how to use the subway. it's too bad transit systems in other cities can't be as user frienfly, The trains run so often you don't need a schedule.
Even as an urbanite the different entrances did catch me when I first used the subway. Metro etiquette is pretty universal wherever you go but it's standard in other systems that every station entrance is universal, so walking into a subway entrance and seeing you can't get to your platform from there was a surprise!