Beeindruckende Interpretation von Bruckners letzter und leider unvollendeten Sinfonie. Nach den ätherisch verklingenden Akkorden des Adagios frage ich mich immer was danach für Musik noch kommen kann aber wenn man sich mit dem unvollendeten Finale beschäftigt und sich einige Aufnahmen, die es inzwischen davon gibt, anhört ist es schon spannend zu hören, was Bruckner für gewaltige Ideen hatte und vor allem wie das Finale erst klingen würde, wenn Bruckner es noch selbst hätte vollenden können. Das NDR Elbphilharmonie Orchester beweist seine langjährige Bruckner-Kompetenz seit Günter Wand und Manfred Honeck ist ein kluger Gestalter dieser gewaltigen Sinfonie. Danke an den NDR für diese Aufnahme.
I'm overwhelmed by this performance. The silence at the end of the unfinished work shows a great sense of respect and admiration for Brucker's masterpiece: dem lieben Gott.
Superb. Maestro Honeck is one of the world's very best conductors. It is a privilege to see him leading the NDR Elbphilharmonie in this exquisite performance of the Bruckner masterwork. Many thanks for sharing.
Thanks for the heads up. This is an unusually fine performance. It has weight, texture, vibrancy, detail, transparency, and sensitivity, without getting bogged down in a muddy tempo that loses the line.
I much enjoyed the fiery and passionate scherzo movement. Bruckner wrote some very impressive scherzo movements, there power and momentum are unmatched in the classical world.
Wunderschöne Aufführung dieser unvollendeten doch in einem Sinne perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut vereinigten und perfekt entsprechenden Tönen aller Instrumente. Der zweite Satz klingt echt lebhaft und auch beweglich. Im Kontrast klingt der dritte Satz besonders schön und echt tiefempfunden. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im gut analysierten Tempo und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Wahrlich hörenswert!
I appreciate your comments, but you have to understand that they these days tend to be like AI-generated, even if they are not. They all follow the same schema, and we have to look for small details that differ. This said with appreciation, from one music lover to another. One example of your writing is that you always talk about "der intelligente und geniale Dirigent" in all of your comments. With this said, best greetings to you, my music friend!
I was fortunate enough to see this performance live. The energy in the concert hall was soo intense! It was totally amazing. Manfred Honeck and the NDR Elbphilharmonie Orchestre nailed this piece!
Wow, that sounds great, @simonvoigt8578! Hope to see you again at our concerts! Meanwhile stay connected with us through our website and social media channels for more - ev. #NDR #ManfredHoneck #AntonBruckner #NDRElbphilharmonieOrchestra
I am so grateful to be able to listen to this wonderful music with this great orchestra under Manfred Honeck at my home in northern Sweden. Thank you NDR Klassik!
I am so grateful that I have had the opportunity to listen to Bruckner music , he is one of the three Bs for me ( Bach, Beethoven and Bruckner) . The most spiritual of all
Thank you! We are very pleased that you enjoyed the performance. It was a special evening for all of us and we are proud to be able to present Bruckner's last symphony under the masterful baton of Manfred Honeck. Greetings to Canada! ❤🎶
What a wonderful way to start the day on the east coast of Canada! An amazing performance, with superb playing and masterful conducting. Enjoying it over breakfast. Thank you for posting!
Hi, @dorisstaedtler9944! Das freut uns natürlich! Kennen Sie schon unsere historischen Aufnahmen mit Maestro Günter Wand? Bleiben Sie mit uns verbunden - hier oder auf über unsere Webseite: -> www.ndr.de/bruckner 🤩 #ManfredHoneck #AntonBruckner #NDRElbphilharmonieOrchester #GuenterWand
@@NDRKlassik I´ve got all nine symphonies conducted by Günter Wand. Obviously Wand was born to show us the beauty and majesty of Bruckner`s music"- Honecks performance seems to come very close to him.
Wow, just wow! Bruckner`s music just gives me goosebumps. This is the sound of eternity! -Das ist eine außergewöhnlich tolle Aufführung! Dachte immer, daß keiner mehr an Günter Wand herankommt, aber das hier... 😍
Desde Cutral Co, Argentina, en el desierto Patagónico... Voy silbando a veces a Bruckner por las calles. Quizás sea el único habitante que lo silbe... Creo que la música de Bruckner es afin con mi espíritu
Gran maestro, un batuta en las alturas de Carlos Kleiber. Manfred Honeck necesita más reflectores y más orquestas, es el mejor director orquestal de la actualidad.
The best live Bruckner sinfonie nr 9 I ever heard. I have to say it. And what a wonderful orchestra, under Manfred Honecks baton. This will be an eternal gem for me,
This is an outstanding performance. It just so sad Bruckner never got a chance to finish this. I know Sir Simon Rattle recorded this with the B. F. Orchestra with a finished ending. I don't know if I'm all that thrilled with that ending. I just know I have enjoyed this performance immensely. More so than Rattles. It's good, but not as good as this. Thank you so much for uploading Magnificent performance.
Yes, I have read that Bruckner worked on a 4:th movement until the day he died. But in my opinion I am almost glad he never finished it. For me this third movement is the perfect ending of a life with music.
He composed a fourth movement but didn't finish it, I think. After his death many people took Papers from the movement as a gift. So the movement was scattered all over the world.
This scherzo is perhaps the most amazing scherzo I ever heard. With its rhytmic thundering it challenges all what a scherzo is for me. But I have come to love it. Listen at 24:32.
Thanks for your appreciation of this incredible scherzo! Don't forget to stay connected with us through our website and social media channels for more. #NDR #ManfredHoneck #AntonBruckner #NDRElbphilharmonieOrchestra
이글을 보는 분이 한국어를 모르신다면 구글 번역기를 사용하시길 추천드립니다 우선 이연주는 아주 아주 찬란한 브루크너 9번 해석의 성취입니다 Jochum, Wand, Karajan 와 어깨를 나란히 하는 수준의 연주입니다. 특히 3악장의 해석에 깊은 공감을 느낍니다 Jochum, Wand, Karajan의 Bruckner를 다시 듣게 되는것 같아 너무 기쁩니다 참고로 지금 연주하고 있는 NDR 몇명 멤버는 Gunter Wand의 DVD에서도 본것 같은데, 같은 분들이신가요?
Herzlichen Dank für den Kommentar! Es kann gut sein, dass manche Musiker:innen schon unter Maestro Wand zu erleben waren. Haben Sie denn jemanden wiedererkannt? Bleiben Sie mit uns verbunden - hier oder auf über unsere Webseite (mit dem Übersetzer?): -> www.ndr.de/bruckner 🤩 #ManfredHoneck #AntonBruckner #NDRElbphilharmonieOrchester #GuenterWand
@@NDRKlassik It seems that the female horn player who performed in the 2000 performance of Bruckner's Symphony No. 8 is still participating in this performance in 2024. th-cam.com/video/Hk04chBNMW0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=HarSdFT9WRD-b7Mc&t=4244
Very well spotted! That's our Principal Hornist Claudia Strenkert! We are lucky to have her with us since 1997!! www.ndr.de/orchester_chor/elbphilharmonieorchester/orchester/Claudia-Strenkert,claudiastrenkert101.html
Fin à 62 minutes ... Tempos BEAUCOUP TROP rapides !!! Les trois premiers mouvement devraient s'étendre au moins sur 65 à 70 minutes ... Ainsi du 1ermouvement qui ne dure QUE 24'27"" ... lors qu'il devrait durer 27 à 28 minutes ... Bruckner spécifie bien "Feierlich - Misterioso" ...
In the today published "Paavo Järvi and the Tonhalle-Orchester Zürich" it also ends at 62 minutes. Maybe it has been popular lately to play it a little bit faster?
Jochum did the first movement in under 23 minutes. Furtwängler is under 24 minutes. Schuricht with BRSO also under 24 Skrowaczewski also under 23 Van Beinum under 24. Dohnyani also under 23 Haitink under 24 Kubelik under 24 I can keep going. Honeck’s tempos are well within historic norms. Especially when one regards the side of the interpretive spectrum that treats Bruckner as a modern symphonist rather than as a mystic. Our French friend hasn’t heard much Bruckner methinks.
...this guy sort of looks like Bernie Madoff! Does he have several millions of Euros in his suitcase in the hotel? ...or even a girl on the side? ....hmmmm....
OMG, wish I was there! One of the greatest symphonies played in the greatest concert hall!
Thank you - much appreciated!
Beeindruckende Interpretation von Bruckners letzter und leider unvollendeten Sinfonie. Nach den ätherisch verklingenden Akkorden des Adagios frage ich mich immer was danach für Musik noch kommen kann aber wenn man sich mit dem unvollendeten Finale beschäftigt und sich einige Aufnahmen, die es inzwischen davon gibt, anhört ist es schon spannend zu hören, was Bruckner für gewaltige Ideen hatte und vor allem wie das Finale erst klingen würde, wenn Bruckner es noch selbst hätte vollenden können. Das NDR Elbphilharmonie Orchester beweist seine langjährige Bruckner-Kompetenz seit Günter Wand und Manfred Honeck ist ein kluger Gestalter dieser gewaltigen Sinfonie. Danke an den NDR für diese Aufnahme.
Wir danken für diesen Kommentar und freuen uns, dass Bruckners Neunte so viel Anklang findet. ☺️
I'm overwhelmed by this performance. The silence at the end of the unfinished work shows a great sense of respect and admiration for Brucker's masterpiece: dem lieben Gott.
Thank you for watching and your kind words - much appreciated!
Silence is the greatest compliment an audience can give an orchestra.
Superb. Maestro Honeck is one of the world's very best conductors. It is a privilege to see him leading the NDR Elbphilharmonie in this exquisite performance of the Bruckner masterwork. Many thanks for sharing.
Thanks for the heads up. This is an unusually fine performance. It has weight, texture, vibrancy, detail, transparency, and sensitivity, without getting bogged down in a muddy tempo that loses the line.
@@OuterGalaxyLounge Glad you enjoyed it.
Thank you - also for sharing it further!! We couldn't agree more on Manfred Honeck!
I much enjoyed the fiery and passionate scherzo movement. Bruckner wrote some very impressive scherzo movements, there power and momentum are unmatched in the classical world.
Wunderschöne Aufführung dieser unvollendeten doch in einem Sinne perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut vereinigten und perfekt entsprechenden Tönen aller Instrumente. Der zweite Satz klingt echt lebhaft und auch beweglich. Im Kontrast klingt der dritte Satz besonders schön und echt tiefempfunden. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im gut analysierten Tempo und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Wahrlich hörenswert!
I appreciate your comments, but you have to understand that they these days tend to be like AI-generated, even if they are not. They all follow the same schema, and we have to look for small details that differ. This said with appreciation, from one music lover to another. One example of your writing is that you always talk about "der intelligente und geniale Dirigent" in all of your comments. With this said, best greetings to you, my music friend!
Praise the Lord, this is absolutely beautiful and spiritual music. 💛🎼🌟
I was fortunate enough to see this performance live. The energy in the concert hall was soo intense! It was totally amazing. Manfred Honeck and the NDR Elbphilharmonie Orchestre nailed this piece!
Wow, that sounds great, @simonvoigt8578! Hope to see you again at our concerts! Meanwhile stay connected with us through our website and social media channels for more - ev.
#NDR #ManfredHoneck #AntonBruckner #NDRElbphilharmonieOrchestra
Bruckner's unfinished masterpiece. I was lucky enough to see Honeck do it with the NSO at the Kennedy Center last week, and it was incredible.
I am so grateful to be able to listen to this wonderful music with this great orchestra under Manfred Honeck at my home in northern Sweden. Thank you NDR Klassik!
I am so grateful that I have had the opportunity to listen to Bruckner music , he is one of the three Bs for me ( Bach, Beethoven and Bruckner) . The most spiritual of all
Amazing performance.
Beautiful string playing, pacing, expression and poise.
Simply love it.
Blew me away.
Thank you from Canada.
❤❤❤
Thank you! We are very pleased that you enjoyed the performance. It was a special evening for all of us and we are proud to be able to present Bruckner's last symphony under the masterful baton of Manfred Honeck. Greetings to Canada! ❤🎶
Love the silence at the end of the piece while the music echoes and dies away.
So do we! 😊
40 seconds of silence until the first coughs broking the magics
What a wonderful way to start the day on the east coast of Canada! An amazing performance, with superb playing and masterful conducting. Enjoying it over breakfast. Thank you for posting!
Happy to hear that! Greetings to the beautiful Canadian east coast!
@@NDRKlassik Just perfect timing for when you posted the video!
Grande 9 di Bruckner.Direttore e orchestra STREPITOSI.Grazie dal profondo dell'anima.
Grazie mille ed è un grande piacere per noi.
The great climax of the slow movement- perfectly judged. Thanks so much for this outstanding performance, and best wishes from Boston.
Thank you for listening! Much appreciated!!
Ich liebe❤Bruckner
Hi, @dorisstaedtler9944! Das freut uns natürlich! Kennen Sie schon unsere historischen Aufnahmen mit Maestro Günter Wand? Bleiben Sie mit uns verbunden - hier oder auf über unsere Webseite: -> www.ndr.de/bruckner 🤩
#ManfredHoneck #AntonBruckner #NDRElbphilharmonieOrchester #GuenterWand
@@NDRKlassik I´ve got all nine symphonies conducted by Günter Wand. Obviously Wand was born to show us the beauty and majesty of Bruckner`s music"- Honecks performance seems to come very close to him.
In the last, I love that all audiences keeping lingering emotions of the music with conductor.
He just conducted Brucker 9 in Washington with the National Symphony last week. It was extraordinary.
Beautiful piece and the sound quality is amazing!
Thank you for sharing this 🙏
Thank you very much! We are pleased that you like our recording and the sound so much. 🎶 ☺️
The first movement is not of this world... Many thanks for the orchestration, and the sharing !
Our pleasure! And thank you for commenting!
Grazie per Bruckner
Wow, just wow! Bruckner`s music just gives me goosebumps. This is the sound of eternity! -Das ist eine außergewöhnlich tolle Aufführung! Dachte immer, daß keiner mehr an Günter Wand herankommt, aber das hier... 😍
Honeck's bruckner 9th brought me to tears
Thank you for this touching comment!
Esta sinfonía es una de las glorias de la humanidad. Hermosa ejecución. Y no habría estado mal incluir el actual cuarto movimiento. ¡Gracias!
Con mucho gusto! Gracias!
Desde Cutral Co, Argentina, en el desierto Patagónico... Voy silbando a veces a Bruckner por las calles. Quizás sea el único habitante que lo silbe...
Creo que la música de Bruckner es afin con mi espíritu
Splendid performance inheriting
the great tradition of Gunter Wand.
Thank you! Stay tuned for more, ... Bruckner & Wand -> www.ndr.de/bruckner 🤩
#ManfredHoneck #AntonBruckner #NDRElbphilharmonieOrchestra #GuenterWand
Gran maestro, un batuta en las alturas de Carlos Kleiber. Manfred Honeck necesita más reflectores y más orquestas, es el mejor director orquestal de la actualidad.
The best live Bruckner sinfonie nr 9 I ever heard. I have to say it. And what a wonderful orchestra, under Manfred Honecks baton. This will be an eternal gem for me,
We are truly honored by this compliment - thank you very much!
This is an outstanding performance. It just so sad Bruckner never got a chance to finish this. I know Sir Simon Rattle recorded this with the B. F. Orchestra with a finished ending. I don't know if I'm all that thrilled with that ending. I just know I have enjoyed this performance immensely. More so than Rattles. It's good, but not as good as this. Thank you so much for uploading Magnificent performance.
Yes, I have read that Bruckner worked on a 4:th movement until the day he died. But in my opinion I am almost glad he never finished it. For me this third movement is the perfect ending of a life with music.
He composed a fourth movement but didn't finish it, I think. After his death many people took Papers from the movement as a gift. So the movement was scattered all over the world.
@@Hannes1896 I didn´t know! His fourth movement scattered all over the world. What a pity!
@@staffanolofsson8201You are right.
You are welcome! Thank you for commenting! Stay tuned for more. 🤩
#ManfredHoneck #AntonBruckner #NDRElbphilharmonieOrchester #GuenterWand
Fantástica 🍀 🍀🍀
Grazie!!
Diese Musik ist wie wenn jemand beim Träumen gestört wird🌈 und dann weiter träumt
Was für ein schönes Bild! Dann wünschen wir weiter ein traumhaftes Hörvergnügen mit unserer Aufnahme von Bruckners Neunter. 🤩
Excellent imagination
This scherzo is perhaps the most amazing scherzo I ever heard. With its rhytmic thundering it challenges all what a scherzo is for me. But I have come to love it. Listen at 24:32.
Thanks for your appreciation of this incredible scherzo! Don't forget to stay connected with us through our website and social media channels for more.
#NDR #ManfredHoneck #AntonBruckner #NDRElbphilharmonieOrchestra
Der zweite Satz ist eine Revolution, nicht weniger und nicht mehr. So ein Scherzo habe ich noch nie gehört!!!
Awesome, thank you so much!!
Exactly the same for me. Bravo
굉장한 긴장감, 확실한 통제력... 와우!
Very beautiful performance 😍And what kind of hall is it?
Thank you! That's the Elbphilharmonie Hamburg! The NDR Elbphilharmonie Orchstra's residence. 🤩
Doktor Frankenstein
이글을 보는 분이 한국어를 모르신다면 구글 번역기를 사용하시길 추천드립니다
우선 이연주는 아주 아주 찬란한 브루크너 9번 해석의 성취입니다
Jochum, Wand, Karajan 와 어깨를 나란히 하는 수준의 연주입니다.
특히 3악장의 해석에 깊은 공감을 느낍니다
Jochum, Wand, Karajan의 Bruckner를 다시 듣게 되는것 같아 너무 기쁩니다
참고로 지금 연주하고 있는 NDR 몇명 멤버는 Gunter Wand의 DVD에서도 본것 같은데, 같은 분들이신가요?
Herzlichen Dank für den Kommentar! Es kann gut sein, dass manche Musiker:innen schon unter Maestro Wand zu erleben waren. Haben Sie denn jemanden wiedererkannt?
Bleiben Sie mit uns verbunden - hier oder auf über unsere Webseite (mit dem Übersetzer?): -> www.ndr.de/bruckner 🤩
#ManfredHoneck #AntonBruckner #NDRElbphilharmonieOrchester #GuenterWand
@@NDRKlassik It seems that the female horn player who performed in the 2000 performance of Bruckner's Symphony No. 8 is still participating in this performance in 2024.
th-cam.com/video/Hk04chBNMW0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=HarSdFT9WRD-b7Mc&t=4244
Very well spotted! That's our Principal Hornist Claudia Strenkert! We are lucky to have her with us since 1997!! www.ndr.de/orchester_chor/elbphilharmonieorchester/orchester/Claudia-Strenkert,claudiastrenkert101.html
Fin à 62 minutes ... Tempos BEAUCOUP TROP rapides !!! Les trois premiers mouvement devraient s'étendre au moins sur 65 à 70 minutes ... Ainsi du 1ermouvement qui ne dure QUE 24'27"" ... lors qu'il devrait durer 27 à 28 minutes ... Bruckner spécifie bien "Feierlich - Misterioso" ...
In the today published "Paavo Järvi and the Tonhalle-Orchester Zürich" it also ends at 62 minutes. Maybe it has been popular lately to play it a little bit faster?
The longest I can find on TH-cam is Leonard Bernstein, 74 minutes! But I myself find this tempo very nice! Greetings!
@@staffanolofsson8201 76'50" Munich Philharmonic Orchestra, Sergiu Celibidache,
Munich, September 1995
Jochum did the first movement in under 23 minutes.
Furtwängler is under 24 minutes.
Schuricht with BRSO also under 24
Skrowaczewski also under 23
Van Beinum under 24.
Dohnyani also under 23
Haitink under 24
Kubelik under 24
I can keep going. Honeck’s tempos are well within historic norms. Especially when one regards the side of the interpretive spectrum that treats Bruckner as a modern symphonist rather than as a mystic.
Our French friend hasn’t heard much Bruckner methinks.
@@mishibird Thank you mishibird! Quite imposing!
...this guy sort of looks like Bernie Madoff! Does he have several millions of Euros in his suitcase in the hotel? ...or even a girl on the side? ....hmmmm....
在台灣，一邊聽一邊喝著酒，彷彿與神同在，到最後，醉了～
To be with God to this music is quite an experience, I believe! Hope you are sober now.