Dear Fadi thank you for bringing Jay to us, I deem he's the father of religious historical data his research is wonderful ,true n impartial, love you two from Pakistan, God bless you guys ♥️👍♥️
I love jay to bits but he makes me nervous every time he pops one of his questions waiting for an answer . It reminds me of when I was back at school and the teacher singled me out for an answer 😂
Interestingly, my wife asked me when I was telling her about the Hajj, where the Muslim Heaven was. I said there are seven domed heavens 500 years apart and atop them eight giant mountain goats and atop them Allah. She then said why do they pray to a place rather than Allah? I think she has a point. Isn't praying towards a building, no matter how holy it is, a lot like praying to an idol?
@jk McGregor What have you been smoking JK. I have to say I can see a difference. I had a Muslim tell me God had to have had sex to create a biological human being. Now you want to tell me because God sent his only begotten son to Earth that is the same as Sunni referring to Allah as a being with two right hands, maybe one eye or multi eyes - they're are not sure, as well as a missing shin. I think you have been kissing the wall a little too much. As far as his codex goes for the NT you chase your tale or is it tail. One in the same I guess a little like Jesus and God. and I shall persevere with Uthman's codex.
@jk McGregor Funnily enough I shall do what I want and say what I want. I shall question and critique.I do not see Jews or Christians out there beheading teachers who are explaining freedom of speech. If Christians and Jews were doing the same thing then they would incited my ire but they are not. If I was living in the time of Richard 1st he might be getting my wrath. So if you as a Jewish person want to claim there are similarities between the son of God being human, therefore, God is human, because basically that is what Muslims are saying, then be my guest.
I am watching all your videos. Really worthy and truth finding videos. Pls discuss about revelation differences between Christianity and Islam so that people will get to know the truth.
Wonderful revelations! Just love it! So fascinating! Thank you both and of course the Great Dan Gibson for revealing to us such marvelous truths about the Nabateans and Muhammad.
@@valerieousmane9656 what proof u have apart from fake empty tomb He was never born nor existed it's a fabricated character Mohammed was rapist terrorist sex addict and mass murder
When coupled with the development of language and early historical information on the foundations of Islam, it reveals a pattern of manipulation of the development of the Qur'an and the historicity of the narrative toward what is presented today by the adherents. Overall the lack of Islamic Scholarly work in linguistics, archaeology, historical chronology in written materials reveals the 14th century (CE) truncation of learning taken by Islamic scholars after the Mongol invasion into the land of the two rivers and the Levant. Their mantra, This is our story. We know it. You can not show otherwise; is falling apart as academic focus is placed on it. Stones can not lie and Li-Dar can reveal what lies below the surface of the landscape with roads, tracks, foundational parts of builds or rivers and lakes. Even skeptical academic accept that there was a historical person Jesus. Using the same level of criteria it can not be said of Mohammad at this point. The adherents of the Islamic story truly must use extra amounts of persuasive faith to hold their narrative in the light of what is now being placed out in the open for all to see being backed by provable work that can be independently verified.
No wonder the Saudis would not let archaeologists do digs where they are building the sky scrapers in Mecca but they were happy for the Chinese to do a dig south of .Jeddah at the ancient port of Al-Serrian. Why would the Saudis give the go ahead for this and not for a dig at Mecca. My guess is the answer is rather obvious?
Unfortunately non of the Islamic scholars or followers have so much of intelligence to understand what dan Gibson has discovered and the facts dr jay smith and al fadi is revealing .
Correct! Muslims have believed their Imams so much so that they can't recognize truth when confronted with it. They are so accustomed to their crooked plumb-line that when they see a straight line it looks crooked to them. So unfortunate indeed.
It's thoroughly crushing to any man to find out in the midst of his career when he's up to his eyeballs in debt that what he is teaching is completely fraudulent. If the truth became known he would lose his teaching position and his house. So he fights viciously to maintain the status quo and to suppress the new ideas that prove him wrong. This is universal throughout history. Those who embrace most new ideas are those who have nothing at stake financially or reputation-wise in the status quo. This is true in any area of endeavor whether education, religion, business, or government. New ideas always produce what's called The Semmelweis Reflex in the majority.
@Johnny Saville - it seems that they have little interest in archaeology. Instead they seem to expend a lot of effort to destroy historical buildings, statues, and artifacts.
Documenting Movement on video that could reform billion people is awesome to see taking place and knowing all this work you all have done can one day be looked back upon so that its no confusion of what whre when and how it came to pass.
Flourish said some great stuff, also, go to a libray and read some more general books on the history and location of your intrest, study. make notes and maybe join a local archeology club to learn some techniques. studying theology might help with the christian aspect.
@@tomjeff1743 : But the algorithm never sends Judeochristian ads, weird? Looks like it is another kind of JIHAD from The Armies of JIHAD that believes more on their power of fighting than in a GREAT GOD that never needs bloody helpers. Even King David was rebuked by GOD for shedding innocent blood. Now we understand that Nabateans were Merchants and The Great Harlot of REVELATIONS match Petra, "The Mother of Settlements", and the mother of The Armies of JIHAD with its pagan religion blending marketing and militarism, ads & JIHAD... wgt
@@jamessheffield4173 It is easy to write articles and have it posted in the media like Facebook, Twitter, TH-cam, Instagram but to have it published by a refutable printing company for a refutable Bookstore that's what the Muslim scholars need - but couldn't because Dan Gibson's findings based on archaeology and historical facts are not equivocal.
La ilaha illallah Muhammadur rasullullah There is no God but Allah and Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wasallam is the last and final messenger of Allah subhanahu wa taala.
Whilst Isaac's descendants formed the 10 tribes of ancient Israel, as God promised, Ishmael's descendants formed the 12 desert tribes outside Canaan. One of them were the Nabateans, supposedly an ancient desert tribe descended from Nebayoth the eldest son of Ishmael.
If they were seting up qiblas in china etc they were probably aimed not at the tombs but at the kaaba that was there at the time. When the bkackstone was moved to Mecca by Zubayr in the 690s the qibla seems to have tracked it.
King David’s one wife was a Nabathian ,if my memory is correct it is Abiegail,who was the wife of a rich Nabath,when Nabath died David married Abiegail ,their sons name is Chileab
@@conociendoelislam85 You mean Israelite! No such thing as Israeli. The name was coined in 1948 and it is for Jews who immigrated to Palestine. Israelites were Semites, Israelis are a mixture of both, Semitic and Non-Semitic Jews.
@@JupiterMoon777 really? dont you know history?... Israelites were there even before the wor arab exists... I mean, history told us that Israel was a nation before Sargon II took ten north tribes to assyria
# God bless U sir.El Fayed & Sir.Jay S..Thanks Hod Almighty in Ur Life w anointing of Fire for His Gods Kingdom!.In the lighty name of JESUS CHRIST..AMEN!..✝️♥️🌍💥📖🕊💦🌅🌈♥️🙏🙏
Allah gave wealth and power to alot of nations which had beautiful ways of living. We all prayed to Allah one god. Then they lost there ways after years and years, because the shaytaan deceives ppl and made these nations worship idols and these powerful ppl had too much power they actually thought they was gods. Some even challenged Allah like the nation of the giants. There is no worthy or worship besides Allah, so he destroyed all these nations. That's why there's so many unanswered questions of these nations and places. These mysterious buildings and places. Allah got rid of these nations because of losing there ways. I'm not saying I'm right it's what I have listened and been taught. But always Allah knows best.
The Nabateans were the Baluchi traders, who you find all over the middle east, and the series of ertughul they were the traders upto mesopotamia and aleppo,led by Suleiman shah .
i hope we are getting confused with quran's address and our invented names,there were always believers and anti believers and the course of rejects plight and there remains which are a grim reminder for the inquiring mind very soon we too are to be a thing of past,as were our elders.
Dear Jay Smith! You made a big Historical mistake! And I cannot understand how you could possibly missed a big point if you researched and investigated the early history of Islam both scientifically and historically and of course with no Bias! As you know more than 80% of Muslims population are Sunna and only 19% are Shia! The day the Prophet Mohammad was born can be considered as a big bang of Muslims history and the day Mohammad Died is the Big-Big bang because all the evidences show us after Mohammad everything is changed! The book, the man, and the Prophecy of Mohammad For about 1300 years there was and unsolved problem in Shia history, and this is all about the Hossein Ibn Ali, the second son of Ali ibn Abi Talib (The son in law of Mohammad and his cousin, and the forth caliph) Hossein died in near of the KOFA (کوفه) in Iraq in the year 61 of Hijri. Means just before the ibn Zubair moved the Mecca from Petra to the southern area. As the history of Shia and Sunna claims Hossein Ibn Ali was in mecca and he left the Mecca toward the Kufa in 8th Dhul-Hijjah and arrived at 1th day of Muharram in Karbala (a place near the Kufa ), So it took 24 days for Hossein Ibn Ali to pass 1800 Kilometer with a big Caravan from Mecca to Karbala! But normally such caravan consisting of women and children and camels can pass 40-50 kilometers per day so The Caravan should be arrived at Karbala within 40-45 days not 24 days! But if we accept the Mecca in Petra the distance and timing exactly will fit! And this supports the Dan Gibson Theory that in the year of 69-70 Ibn Zubair destroyed the mecca in Petra and moved the black Stone. And if we accept the fact that the real and initial Mecca was in Petra accordingly we must accept that not the history books like SAHIH BUKHARI but also the Koran itself is distorted intentionally. This is not new to Shia Famous scholars like Sheikh Mofid and Majlesi, they declared this in their books that Koran is changed all of this that Dan Gibson and Jay smith trying to prove is what Shia tried to tell, that after the death of Prophet Mohammad some people denied Ali Ib Abitalib) the son in law of Mohammad (that was chosen by Mohammad as successor and the deputy after him to continue the real path of Muhammad. after then Ali Ibn Abi Talib stayed home and gathered the whole Koran as eye witness and primary source from Mohammad and tried to give it to Muslim Society but Umar denied and did not accept that Koran. Yeas you are right after Mohammad death the BIG BIG Bang occurred and everything was fabricated by some people. Why Jay Smith as researcher could possibly ignored this crucial part early Islam history!
@J DV Turks haven't migrated to west during the time of Nabeteans. They were still living in Central Asian steppes. They came to Anatolia during 11th century.
This's is only to defame Muslim's faith. Islam is what the Divine creator Allah says in Quran. Islam is not what the earthly created humans say do or write. From 610 to 632ce. Prophet Mohammed has offered namaz from all 360 degrees around the Kaba. A Muslim who has understood Quran in his language can never go astray.
go watch more videos by these man. May Allah reveal the truth to you, His Son has come for our sins and Mohammed was not a true prophet, go watch a video about Mohammed by this channel CIRA, please go watch. The Quran itself reverences the Bible, Torah and Gospel, go read them maybe, and not just the parts your iman told you to, the context aswell. Have a wonderfull day
Dan Gibson is a self-published contraversial figure. This Jay character crows about Christianity being superior to Islam without applying the same criteria. His talent is that his absolute conviction makes him sound authorative when is fact it's all rather shakey. His aim is to knock Islam and everything he says must be taken from that point of view.
what a nice observation and fact finding mission theory fascinating indeed from people who don't face jerusalem neither rome finding muslim qibla to be wrong? and yet they have accounts of nabateans being good merchants, very very good really ?and yet you/they missed JESUS pbhu accounts of who he really is some call him god or son of god or prophet till now its a crisis in christiandom and yes comes the big question do christians have a direction while praying?or were the oldest churches facing anywhere? A study on that would be appropriate especiallly coming from the followers of christ/paul @14:30 the expert doesn't know what is umrah ?guys fix your propaganda
It was named that later, the original inhabitants referred to it by its Nabatean Aramaic name. Do you think Minneapolis is Greek because the name is based on a Greek word? lol
We have PETRA in Kabylie from Algeria, Firmus and his sister done the big war with ROME. KYRIA was a sister of Fihmys do the war too, she us named Cirya bye ROME. I think that ate a rrlation between PETRA in Midleeast and Amazighe PETRA ftom North Africa. AMAZIGHS are the first crator of all civilisations like Egypte, Grecque, ...
@@khalidchaudhry1273 He is not lying , He maybe incorrect . You need to show factual evidence to show he is incorrect . To say he is a liar you need to prove he posted incorrect information intentionally .
BULLSHIT JESUS WILLINGLY SACRIFICED HIMSELF CRUCIFIED TO REDEEM THE SINS OF MANKIND. THE TRUE IS JESUS WAS ARRESTED BY STRATAGEM AND SENTENCED TO DEATH BY WAY OF CRUCIFIXION BY THE CHIEF PRIEST AND THE ELDERS OF THE JEWISH NATION. READ: MATTHEW 26:1-5 MARK 10:33 MATTHEW 26:38 Then saith he unto them, My soul is exceeding sorrowful, even unto death: tarry ye here, and watch with me. ACTS 2 : 22-24 22. Ye men of Israel, hear these words; Jesus of Nazareth, a man approved of God among you by miracles and wonders and signs, which God did by him in the midst of you, as ye yourselves also know: 23. Him, being delivered by the determinate counsel and foreknowledge of God, ye have taken, and by wicked hands have crucified and slain: 24. Whom God hath raised up, having loosed the pains of death: because it was not possible that he should be holden of it.
Rich Delarby You better repent and check if your name is written in the Book of Life. Anyone whose name is not found in the Book of Life will be thrown in the Lake of Fire together with all liars, sexually immoral, sorcerers, murderers, dishonest, cowards...also Satan, the Anti-Christ, the False prophet and apostates.
@@richdelarby9387 Rev 20:1-3 20 Then I saw an angel coming down from heaven, holding in his hand the key to the bottomless pit and a great chain. 2 And he seized the dragon, that ancient serpent, who is the devil and Satan, and bound him for a thousand years, 3 and threw him into the pit, and shut it and sealed it over him, so that he might not deceive the nations any longer, until the thousand years were ended. Rev 20:7-9 7 And when the thousand years are ended, Satan will be released from his prison 8 and will come out to deceive the nations that are at the four corners of the earth, Gog and Magog, to gather them for battle; their number is like the sand of the sea. Rev 20:10 ...and the devil who had deceived them was thrown into the lake of fire and sulfur where the beast (Anti-Christ) and the false prophet were, and they will be tormented day and night forever and ever. Rev 20:12-15 Then another book was opened, which is the Book of Life. And the dead were judged by what was written in the books, according to what they had done. 13 And the sea gave up the dead who were in it, Death and Hades gave up the dead who were in them, and they were judged, each one of them, according to what they had done. 14 Then Death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire. This is the second death, the lake of fire. 15 And if anyone's name was not found written in the Book of Life, he was thrown into the lake of fire. ESV
Dr Smith: Who were the Nabateans? Fadi: Please enlighten me about my history. As the sun shines out of your ass so everything comming out of it must be gold. Let me look in there as i am so lost.
Fadil will never admit Jesus pbuh is God even after his conversion to christianity he might please his viewers but it will eventually come out READ THIS QURAN CHAPTER MARY TO ALL MY BROTHERS AND SISTERS WHO HAVE NOT HEARD ABOUT THE STORY OF JESUS FROM AN ISLAMIC PERSPECTIVE a layman's challenge get rid of all pauls teaching from the bible and see what remains of christianity and furthermore FOR ALLAH north south east or west they all belong to HIM the LORD OF THE lords
Islam was a copy of talmud. Talmud took all story in other civilisation. You must to khnow that the origine if all civilisations are Amazighs from North Africa.
You r right they took not Only from kemet they took also from the axumite kingdom. Basically the arabian peninsula were ours the people living there were the same people like us called sabean. They took all the old culture from us and put it in their talmud
@@FLISSATimes-Kabyle rember Arabic were taken 85% of its Words from our language. All the Words used in quran is ours. Even the name mahammed is our the arabs know nothing about this. But We can tell them the etmology of each Words they used. And how it evolved
Whilst Isaac's descendants formed the 10 tribes of ancient Israel, as God promised, Ishmael's descendants formed the 12 desert tribes outside Canaan. One of them were the Nabateans, supposedly an ancient desert tribe descended from Nebayoth the eldest son of Ishmael.
![เขามัทรี - เอ็กซ์ ศุภกฤต - จอนนี่มิวสิค [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AS9ufKuQIVs/mqdefault.jpg)
Jay, I close my eyes as you narrate and find myself lost not only in your voice, but the tale. Wonderful historical account. Thank you both!
Dude! You didn't say "no homo".
ElficChannel I would’ve. If I were a man😂 ...or would I?🤔
@@CrossingJordan hahahaha happy Saturday my sister ☺️
@@CrossingJordan I do love his biker vibe though (no homo).
ElficChannel happy Saturday to you as well; and yes, I do love his “rebellious” look!
God bless you Mr Fadil and Mr Jay Smith..
Dear Fadi thank you for bringing Jay to us, I deem he's the father of religious historical data his research is wonderful ,true n impartial, love you two from Pakistan, God bless you guys ♥️👍♥️
Two fantastic narrators.
This is so interesting and informative thank you so much.
Two Amazing Scholars..
#Al Fadi & Dr. Jay Smith
WOW! This is absolutely incredible info. Fantastic!
These little videos are wonderful! Packed with information that's not only incredible, but easily digestible and great for sharing. Thanks! 🙏🏻❤️
I love jay to bits but he makes me nervous every time he pops one of his questions waiting for an answer . It reminds me of when I was back at school and the teacher singled me out for an answer 😂
teachers teaching fear is not so good. but i know this feeling very well myself hehe.
Interestingly, my wife asked me when I was telling her about the Hajj, where the Muslim Heaven was. I said there are seven domed heavens 500 years apart and atop them eight giant mountain goats and atop them Allah. She then said why do they pray to a place rather than Allah? I think she has a point. Isn't praying towards a building, no matter how holy it is, a lot like praying to an idol?
@jk McGregor What have you been smoking JK. I have to say I can see a difference. I had a Muslim tell me God had to have had sex to create a biological human being. Now you want to tell me because God sent his only begotten son to Earth that is the same as Sunni referring to Allah as a being with two right hands, maybe one eye or multi eyes - they're are not sure, as well as a missing shin. I think you have been kissing the wall a little too much. As far as his codex goes for the NT you chase your tale or is it tail. One in the same I guess a little like Jesus and God. and I shall persevere with Uthman's codex.
@jk McGregor What are you telling me this for. Tell someone who cares. I might have pegged you wrong but you have pegged me wrong as well.
@jk McGregor Funnily enough I shall do what I want and say what I want. I shall question and critique.I do not see Jews or Christians out there beheading teachers who are explaining freedom of speech. If Christians and Jews were doing the same thing then they would incited my ire but they are not. If I was living in the time of Richard 1st he might be getting my wrath. So if you as a Jewish person want to claim there are similarities between the son of God being human, therefore, God is human, because basically that is what Muslims are saying, then be my guest.
I've never heard of the Nabateans! So interesting to hear. Will definitely watch all upcoming videos and search for the old ones with Jay Smith
Yet your name is Petra! You never looked it up?
Very Useful information. Thank you.
GOD BLESS YOU brother AlFadi and Jay
I am watching all your videos. Really worthy and truth finding videos. Pls discuss about revelation differences between Christianity and Islam so that people will get to know the truth.
God bless Dan Gibson!
This explains it all. Thanks you guys!
Wonderful revelations! Just love it! So fascinating! Thank you both and of course the Great Dan Gibson for revealing to us such marvelous truths about the Nabateans and Muhammad.
Faith + Repentance = Salvation ! You must be Born Again with Holy Spirit 🤗 ! LORD JESUS IS ALMIGHTY GOD ❤️ ADONAI ❤️ in Flesh (Isaiah 9 : 6-7) !
Ur jesus itself is fake myth
@@sridharyg3769 proof of what you say????
@@valerieousmane9656 what proof u have apart from fake empty tomb
He was never born nor existed it's a fabricated character
Mohammed was rapist terrorist sex addict and mass murder
When coupled with the development of language and early historical information on the foundations of Islam, it reveals a pattern of manipulation of the development of the Qur'an and the historicity of the narrative toward what is presented today by the adherents. Overall the lack of Islamic Scholarly work in linguistics, archaeology, historical chronology in written materials reveals the 14th century (CE) truncation of learning taken by Islamic scholars after the Mongol invasion into the land of the two rivers and the Levant. Their mantra, This is our story. We know it. You can not show otherwise; is falling apart as academic focus is placed on it. Stones can not lie and Li-Dar can reveal what lies below the surface of the landscape with roads, tracks, foundational parts of builds or rivers and lakes. Even skeptical academic accept that there was a historical person Jesus. Using the same level of criteria it can not be said of Mohammad at this point. The adherents of the Islamic story truly must use extra amounts of persuasive faith to hold their narrative in the light of what is now being placed out in the open for all to see being backed by provable work that can be independently verified.
No wonder the Saudis would not let archaeologists do digs where they are building the sky scrapers in Mecca but they were happy for the Chinese to do a dig south of .Jeddah at the ancient port of Al-Serrian. Why would the Saudis give the go ahead for this and not for a dig at Mecca. My guess is the answer is rather obvious?
@Two right hands & a leg Mouse I believe you might be correct.
Islam is purely a manipulated story by madmen on an imaginary character by name Prophet Muhammad to make these madamens fallacies esp for Sex ....
Unfortunately non of the Islamic scholars or followers have so much of intelligence to understand what dan Gibson has discovered and the facts dr jay smith and al fadi is revealing .
"out of sight, out of mind".
Correct! Muslims have believed their Imams so much so that they can't recognize truth when confronted with it. They are so accustomed to their crooked plumb-line that when they see a straight line it looks crooked to them. So unfortunate indeed.
They don't want to know. Because it's like opening a Pandora box.
It's thoroughly crushing to any man to find out in the midst of his career when he's up to his eyeballs in debt that what he is teaching is completely fraudulent. If the truth became known he would lose his teaching position and his house. So he fights viciously to maintain the status quo and to suppress the new ideas that prove him wrong. This is universal throughout history. Those who embrace most new ideas are those who have nothing at stake financially or reputation-wise in the status quo. This is true in any area of endeavor whether education, religion, business, or government. New ideas always produce what's called The Semmelweis Reflex in the majority.
@Johnny Saville - it seems that they have little interest in archaeology. Instead they seem to expend a lot of effort to destroy historical buildings, statues, and artifacts.
thank you brother!! love love this
THANKS YOU!
Nabateans were not christian never be they were thamud people polytheist bedouin are nabateans
WOW, very interesting topic ,,,
Awesome info
Interesting discussion with facts.
May God bless you more in Jesus Name brothers
Al Fadi and J Smith
Gibson/Gibsons were/are genuinely genius people
Keep telling the truth brothers
Documenting Movement on video that could reform billion people is awesome to see taking place and knowing all this work you all have done can one day be looked back upon so that its no confusion of what whre when and how it came to pass.
God wondergully uses theskill and theknowledgde you have . Godbless you dearbrother AlFadiand Jay Smith!!
Any advice to start a career as an archeologist ? For the glory of Christ?
Look into the work of Bruce Gore. He's a Christian historian and has loads of research on archaeological artefacts from biblical times.
He also has a TH-cam channel.
Flourish said some great stuff, also, go to a libray and read some more general books on the history and location of your intrest, study. make notes and maybe join a local archeology club to learn some techniques. studying theology might help with the christian aspect.
Mudfossils. If you you truly mean what you say...
In Petra indian architect is also present in the form of eliphent pillars to show respect to lord ganesha.
Hindu gods are fiction characters created to tell stories but later hindus started to worship the characters. Hindu gods aren't real.
I'm a hindu too.
Excellent, exposing the fallacies of Prophet and how millions have been misguided under the spell of fake religion.
Praise Lord Jesus raise people like Dan Jay Al Fadi whose passion uveilling the truth.. thanks CIRA
Simply hilarious to again and again watch an Islamic commercial before getting to the important stuff.
It's the algorithm
@@tomjeff1743 : But the algorithm never sends Judeochristian ads, weird?
Looks like it is another kind of JIHAD from The Armies of JIHAD that believes more on their power of fighting than in a GREAT GOD that never needs bloody helpers.
Even King David was rebuked by GOD for shedding innocent blood.
Now we understand that Nabateans were Merchants and The Great Harlot of REVELATIONS match Petra, "The Mother of Settlements", and the mother of The Armies of JIHAD with its pagan religion blending marketing and militarism, ads & JIHAD...
wgt
Where is the peer reviewed article refuting Dan Gibson?
What's it called?
@@flourishomotola5306 As far as I know it doesn't exist which is very telling. Blessings.
@@jamessheffield4173 It is easy to write articles and have it posted in the media like Facebook, Twitter, TH-cam, Instagram but to have it published by a refutable printing company for a refutable Bookstore that's what the Muslim scholars need - but couldn't because Dan Gibson's findings based on archaeology and historical facts are not equivocal.
Another example how human history is being re-discovered.
Great 👍
Thank you very much. I found it very enlightening. The key aspect was the tombs and the visit to the tombs each year to wit the Hajj.
Many Hadiths talk about Muhammad eating grapes. Grapes didn't grow in the Hejaz.
@Samir Disco and name like mr. Disco makes you a real Muslim?
You find Allah in a disco of Saudi Arabia.
Nabatean vanished before the birth of Islam
That's nonsense. The Ghassanids were Nabateans and they existed even in 638 AD.
WORD!
Satan spelled backwards
Natas;
National Academy of Television Arts & Sciences
Anagrams arent as bad as your example seem to indicate. be aware it might decieve your path. funny how you found this one tho. have a blessed day
Thanks I took a Oath that’s Guaranteed.
La ilaha illallah Muhammadur rasullullah
There is no God but Allah and Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wasallam is the last and final messenger of Allah subhanahu wa taala.
YHWH is the Only True God.
Fadi is a classic example of how one man can destroy the entire religion.
Where is Ep 1?
Under a different name?
Whilst Isaac's descendants formed the 10 tribes of ancient Israel, as God promised, Ishmael's descendants formed the 12 desert tribes outside Canaan. One of them were the Nabateans, supposedly an ancient desert tribe descended from Nebayoth the eldest son of Ishmael.
If they were seting up qiblas in china etc they were probably aimed not at the tombs but at the kaaba that was there at the time. When the bkackstone was moved to Mecca by Zubayr in the 690s the qibla seems to have tracked it.
Thankyou broAlFadi andJay....
Interesting.😄
Second here.
First!! 😊😄
King David’s one wife was a Nabathian ,if my memory is correct it is Abiegail,who was the wife of a rich Nabath,when Nabath died David married Abiegail ,their sons name is Chileab
Oh yiu are so wrong...Naba was an israeli
@@conociendoelislam85 You mean Israelite! No such thing as Israeli. The name was coined in 1948 and it is for Jews who immigrated to Palestine. Israelites were Semites, Israelis are a mixture of both, Semitic and Non-Semitic Jews.
@@JupiterMoon777 really? dont you know history?... Israelites were there even before the wor arab exists... I mean, history told us that Israel was a nation before Sargon II took ten north tribes to assyria
# God bless U sir.El Fayed & Sir.Jay S..Thanks Hod Almighty in Ur Life w anointing of Fire for His Gods Kingdom!.In the lighty name of JESUS CHRIST..AMEN!..✝️♥️🌍💥📖🕊💦🌅🌈♥️🙏🙏
Allah gave wealth and power to alot of nations which had beautiful ways of living. We all prayed to Allah one god. Then they lost there ways after years and years, because the shaytaan deceives ppl and made these nations worship idols and these powerful ppl had too much power they actually thought they was gods. Some even challenged Allah like the nation of the giants. There is no worthy or worship besides Allah, so he destroyed all these nations. That's why there's so many unanswered questions of these nations and places. These mysterious buildings and places. Allah got rid of these nations because of losing there ways. I'm not saying I'm right it's what I have listened and been taught. But always Allah knows best.
so they are not a nomadic tribes as we know?
The Nabateans were the Baluchi traders, who you find all over the middle east, and the series of ertughul they were the traders upto mesopotamia and aleppo,led by Suleiman shah .
This is abig quation for rest of world
El-Choctaw-lord-De-CalifasMexicoAztlan Antz-that-crawls-on-the-ground MexiCali i
i hope we are getting confused with quran's address and our invented names,there were always believers and anti believers and the course of rejects plight and there remains which are a grim reminder for the inquiring mind very soon we too are to be a thing of past,as were our elders.
Kalahari
Dan Gibson has a high school diploma
Has anyone doubted it?
Dear Jay Smith! You made a big Historical mistake!
And I cannot understand how you could possibly missed a big point if you researched and investigated the early history of Islam both scientifically and historically and of course with no Bias!
As you know more than 80% of Muslims population are Sunna and only 19% are Shia!
The day the Prophet Mohammad was born can be considered as a big bang of Muslims history and the day Mohammad Died is the Big-Big bang because all the evidences show us after Mohammad everything is changed! The book, the man, and the Prophecy of Mohammad
For about 1300 years there was and unsolved problem in Shia history, and this is all about the Hossein Ibn Ali, the second son of Ali ibn Abi Talib (The son in law of Mohammad and his cousin, and the forth caliph)
Hossein died in near of the KOFA (کوفه) in Iraq in the year 61 of Hijri. Means just before the ibn Zubair moved the Mecca from Petra to the southern area.
As the history of Shia and Sunna claims Hossein Ibn Ali was in mecca and he left the Mecca toward the Kufa in 8th Dhul-Hijjah and arrived at 1th day of Muharram in Karbala (a place near the Kufa ),
So it took 24 days for Hossein Ibn Ali to pass 1800 Kilometer with a big Caravan from Mecca to Karbala!
But normally such caravan consisting of women and children and camels can pass 40-50 kilometers per day so The Caravan should be arrived at Karbala within 40-45 days not 24 days! But if we accept the Mecca in Petra the distance and timing exactly will fit!
And this supports the Dan Gibson Theory that in the year of 69-70 Ibn Zubair destroyed the mecca in Petra and moved the black Stone.
And if we accept the fact that the real and initial Mecca was in Petra accordingly we must accept that not the history books like SAHIH BUKHARI but also the Koran itself is distorted intentionally.
This is not new to Shia Famous scholars like Sheikh Mofid and Majlesi, they declared this in their books that Koran is changed
all of this that Dan Gibson and Jay smith trying to prove is what Shia tried to tell, that after the death of Prophet Mohammad some people denied Ali Ib Abitalib) the son in law of Mohammad (that was chosen by Mohammad as successor and the deputy after him to continue the real path of Muhammad.
after then Ali Ibn Abi Talib stayed home and gathered the whole Koran as eye witness and primary source from Mohammad and tried to give it to Muslim Society but Umar denied and did not accept that Koran.
Yeas you are right after Mohammad death the BIG BIG Bang occurred and everything was fabricated by some people.
Why Jay Smith as researcher could possibly ignored this crucial part early Islam history!
gibson khedab
Turks were NOT in near east during the time of Nabeteans. What are you talking about.
@J DV Turks haven't migrated to west during the time of Nabeteans. They were still living in Central Asian steppes. They came to Anatolia during 11th century.
This's is only to defame Muslim's faith.
Islam is what the Divine creator Allah says in Quran. Islam is not what the earthly created humans say do or write.
From 610 to 632ce. Prophet Mohammed has offered namaz from all 360 degrees around the Kaba.
A Muslim who has understood Quran in his language can never go astray.
go watch more videos by these man. May Allah reveal the truth to you, His Son has come for our sins and Mohammed was not a true prophet, go watch a video about Mohammed by this channel CIRA, please go watch. The Quran itself reverences the Bible, Torah and Gospel, go read them maybe, and not just the parts your iman told you to, the context aswell. Have a wonderfull day
Dan Gibson is a self-published contraversial figure. This Jay character crows about Christianity being superior to Islam without applying the same criteria. His talent is that his absolute conviction makes him sound authorative when is fact it's all rather shakey.
His aim is to knock Islam and everything he says must be taken from that point of view.
What facts are shaky
what a nice observation and fact finding mission theory
fascinating indeed from people who don't face jerusalem neither rome finding muslim qibla to be wrong?
and yet they have accounts of nabateans being good merchants, very very good really ?and yet you/they missed JESUS pbhu accounts of who he really is some call him god or son of god or prophet till now its a crisis in christiandom and yes comes the big question do christians have a direction while praying?or were the oldest churches facing anywhere?
A study on that would be appropriate especiallly coming from the followers of christ/paul
@14:30 the expert doesn't know what is umrah ?guys fix your propaganda
Petra is a Greek word which means Stone or Rock..the place is named Petra because it is Greek...nothing to to with Arabs .....
It was named that later, the original inhabitants referred to it by its Nabatean Aramaic name. Do you think Minneapolis is Greek because the name is based on a Greek word? lol
We have PETRA in Kabylie from Algeria, Firmus and his sister done the big war with ROME.
KYRIA was a sister of Fihmys do the war too, she us named Cirya bye ROME.
I think that ate a rrlation between PETRA in Midleeast and Amazighe PETRA ftom North Africa.
AMAZIGHS are the first crator of all civilisations like Egypte, Grecque, ...
Nabateans was jordania arabia not north african berber they located only in jordanian and saudi arabian jordanian are 99 % arabian or aravah in hebrew
Hold that under your hat .🤠.......🤔......
💐💐✝️❤️👍
Nabateans was arabian peninsula people talmud aad not ismael or isaax
9:10 jajajahahahahaha!!
This hired liar claims he did Umrah 100's of times.. I don't think he has got a clue what umra is if he did 100s of times which is impossible..
You are just ignorant. There are those who have than it more than 1000 times. Remember he is from Saudi Arabia.
@@kiraboisrael8850 Bullshit.. No one has done Umrah 1000 times or 100 times.. stop repeating lies of your boy friend..
@@khalidchaudhry1273 what does it matter ?
@@huckstirred7112 It shows that he is a liar and he is selling you BS and lies
@@khalidchaudhry1273 He is not lying , He maybe incorrect . You need to show factual evidence to show he is incorrect . To say he is a liar you need to prove he posted incorrect information intentionally .
The muslim pure monotheism versus christian roman paganism
BULLSHIT JESUS WILLINGLY SACRIFICED HIMSELF CRUCIFIED TO REDEEM THE SINS OF MANKIND.
THE TRUE IS JESUS WAS ARRESTED BY STRATAGEM AND SENTENCED TO DEATH BY WAY OF CRUCIFIXION BY THE CHIEF PRIEST AND THE ELDERS OF THE JEWISH NATION.
READ:
MATTHEW 26:1-5
MARK 10:33
MATTHEW 26:38
Then saith he unto them, My soul is exceeding sorrowful, even unto death: tarry ye here, and watch with me.
ACTS 2 : 22-24
22. Ye men of Israel, hear these words; Jesus of Nazareth, a man approved of God among you by miracles and wonders and signs, which God did by him in the midst of you, as ye yourselves also know:
23. Him, being delivered by the determinate counsel and foreknowledge of God, ye have taken, and by wicked hands have crucified and slain:
24. Whom God hath raised up, having loosed the pains of death: because it was not possible that he should be holden of it.
Why use such old translation. what are you even trying to say?
.mono loq... No academic value. Just narrative from loser or winner.
Fadil is a professional liar. He has never been muslim.
Rich Delarby ,nobody wants your opinion check your source from whom u get your sources Alfadi is Former Muslim
Rich Delarby You better repent and check if your name is written in the Book of Life. Anyone whose name is not found in the Book of Life will be thrown in the Lake of Fire together with all liars, sexually immoral, sorcerers, murderers, dishonest, cowards...also Satan, the Anti-Christ, the False prophet and apostates.
@@eldontalamisan7399 you re the LIES expert ! Dumbass !
@@richdelarby9387 Rev 20:1-3
20 Then I saw an angel coming down from heaven, holding in his hand the key to the bottomless pit and a great chain. 2 And he seized the dragon, that ancient serpent, who is the devil and Satan, and bound him for a thousand years, 3 and threw him into the pit, and shut it and sealed it over him, so that he might not deceive the nations any longer, until the thousand years were ended.
Rev 20:7-9
7 And when the thousand years are ended, Satan will be released from his prison 8 and will come out to deceive the nations that are at the four corners of the earth, Gog and Magog, to gather them for battle; their number is like the sand of the sea.
Rev 20:10
...and the devil who had deceived them was thrown into the lake of fire and sulfur where the beast (Anti-Christ) and the false prophet were, and they will be tormented day and night forever and ever.
Rev 20:12-15
Then another book was opened, which is the Book of Life. And the dead were judged by what was written in the books, according to what they had done. 13 And the sea gave up the dead who were in it, Death and Hades gave up the dead who were in them, and they were judged, each one of them, according to what they had done. 14 Then Death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire. This is the second death, the lake of fire. 15 And if anyone's name was not found written in the Book of Life, he was thrown into the lake of fire. ESV
@@eldontalamisan7399 You worship a portrait of a Hebrew man and you believe someone who worships the Creator will go to hell. Open your eyes.
Dr Smith: Who were the Nabateans?
Fadi: Please enlighten me about my history. As the sun shines out of your ass so everything comming out of it must be gold. Let me look in there as i am so lost.
Eddy Kane : Hi, i'm an imbecile that makes stupid comments
Fadil will never admit Jesus pbuh is God even after his conversion to christianity he might please his viewers but it will eventually come out
READ THIS QURAN CHAPTER MARY TO ALL MY BROTHERS AND SISTERS WHO HAVE NOT HEARD ABOUT THE STORY OF JESUS FROM AN ISLAMIC PERSPECTIVE
a layman's challenge get rid of all pauls teaching from the bible and see what remains of christianity
and furthermore FOR ALLAH north south east or west they all belong to HIM the LORD OF THE lords
Islam was a copy of talmud.
Talmud took all story in other civilisation.
You must to khnow that the origine if all civilisations are Amazighs from North Africa.
Nabateans are arabian peninsula jordania yemen canaanites are palestinian not berber amazigh
Les nabateen etait des ancestre arameen ils ont rien de berbere les jordanian est arabo hebreu
You r right they took not Only from kemet they took also from the axumite kingdom. Basically the arabian peninsula were ours the people living there were the same people like us called sabean. They took all the old culture from us and put it in their talmud
@@gedamnagran1656 Who are Kemet and axumite ?
@@FLISSATimes-Kabyle rember Arabic were taken 85% of its Words from our language. All the Words used in quran is ours. Even the name mahammed is our the arabs know nothing about this. But We can tell them the etmology of each Words they used. And how it evolved
THANKS NEWSGODNEWSBOSS INVISIBLE
Whilst Isaac's descendants formed the 10 tribes of ancient Israel, as God promised, Ishmael's descendants formed the 12 desert tribes outside Canaan. One of them were the Nabateans, supposedly an ancient desert tribe descended from Nebayoth the eldest son of Ishmael.