What If VIEWERS Voted on the Map after Napoleon
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2024
- #possiblehistory #ph #alternatehistory #alternatehistoryofeurope #Napoleonicwars #congressofvienna
Credit to Tigerstars video:
• The End of World War I...
Special thanks for helping make the video:
youtube.com/@CarmelandRoni?si...
Step into the shoes of history-makers in our unique video: 'I Let The VIEWERS Rewrite The Congress of Vienna.' Join us on an interactive journey as we invite our audience to reimagine and reshape the outcomes of this crucial historical event. Experience a dynamic exercise where viewers become the architects of an alternative Congress of Vienna, exploring the 'What If' scenarios that could have transformed the course of European diplomacy and borders. From reimagining alliances to envisioning redrawn maps, witness the creativity and insights of our engaged community as they influence the fate of nations. Dive into the captivating results as we unravel the consequences of these viewer-led decisions. Don't miss this one-of-a-kind exploration of history co-created by our viewers. Like, comment, and subscribe to our channel for more engaging historical exercises and collaborative explorations of pivotal moments in our world's past.
If you like the content please like, comment and subscribe, it helps smaller channels like mine to get noticed!
If you want to support the channel you can go to my Patreon or become a member! You will get early access to video's and will be allowed to suggest priority video subjects!
/ possiblehistory
Feel free to follow or join our social media platforms:
/ possiblehistory
/ possiblehistor1
/ discord
/ possible_history0
Possible Extra's a channel where we do not necessarily history related stuff, like podcasts and more!
/ @theobserverph
Data Animations made with flourish.studio
Most of our music by Beta Records. He's great, check him out!
Link: goo.gl/peHHCX
A lot of other music by Kevin McLoad. The Copyrightfree Music Creator
/ kevinmacleodarchive
I can tell that this peace treaty will certainly hold peace in Europe and ensure a long era of peace and development.
For sure!
Yes,truly a peace that will last for centuries.
Yea, this polish thing will bring peace to the whole East Europe, I hope no one will start a massive war there
@@kxmapperIf Russia is furious on they're old allies (Prussia and Austria), those two would want a buffor state to not start a war they're don't want, so because they're don't lost to much it's posible that weak Polish state would be in hold of Austrians and Prussians to prevent war in the east.
Altrought, there gonna be more Napoleonic wars, when his family seize rule over France and start war with new states, Netherlands and Germany. What can paradoxically make France bigger in our times.
@@kxmapper Poland was in Central Europe.
>Russia receiving barely nothing despite being on the winning side
>Independent Brittany and Catalonia
>Big Poland
>Abolishing the Papal States
Truly the most Reddit timeline possible.
And Prussia not getting shit, there you can see the 40% more average left wing mentality among redditors which probably spammed this video in their subreddits, circlejerking.
It’s like if Woodrow Wilson was at the Congress of Vienna
@@frankdecron1306 he would never want orthodox eastern slavs ruled by catholic western slavs like would end up with this large a poland.
I love how both Russia and Spain lose land even thought they bled themselves fighting Napoleon
not to mention the whole big prussia/austria
Humilliating Rusia AND France at the same time is the biggest mistake of this treaty
I cant wait for the Spanish-French-Russian alliance
Same
They'll get Smaller
I don't see France being angry. It felt its loss deeply by the occupation of half of the country and the economic collapse. The restored Bourbons would see themselves overly lucky they even got a whole France to rule over, not to talk about how France would be Europe's suspect from then on and in no position to make pretentions.
All I see is an incredibly successful repelling of Russia and France at the cost of acceptable concessions to Prussia, from the Austro-British perspective.
I don see spain in that alliance i mean the hated the french after they destroyed their country
@@Supermasist In our timeline Spain did not hate France. After all Louis was tertiary cousin with Fernando's father.
The MOMENT your audience voted to restore a full Poland-Lithuania i immediately became solid on the fact that anyone subscribed to this channel should NOT be allowed to be in a state apparatus of any country at any time
The fact Russia, for some unknown reason accepted this decision suggests that's for the best as well.
This absolutley could be the case but only if Poland was put in some sort of personal union under russia kinda like in our time line, and Austria gave up Galicia, because than, although techically loosing land they still control it under their Polish perosnal union and even gained land from Prussia and Austria.
That would either lead to Poland more loyal to Russia than in our timeline, since the matter of eastern occupided provinces was a big talking point or if the uprising still happens be a total disaster for Russia later on.
I would have just had independent poland with congress borders
I think this is mainly due to the affinity to Poland-Lithuania in althist circles.
I just went for repatriation of Poland. The worst i did was giving Brittany, Normandy and Hanover to the British.
@@MarylandbronyI think it's much more connected with the wave of anti-russian sentiment in the west after the war in Ukraine. It's reasonable but some what annoying when influencing things in such a anachronistic manner.
Russia and Spain were the two places were Napoleon lost yet they lose territory, as well as a massive reduction of France. I think the Vienna treaty's real accomplishment of a long peace will not occure in this timeline.
Well Spain kind of deserved it since before napoleon betrayed them they were staunch allies of napoleon. Russia were allies in the fourth coalition war but enemies both before and after that.
@@mappingshaman5280 I don't have the same opinion as you.
Every country was once allied to Napoleon in one way por another except for Portugal and the British.
The fact that Napoleon's invasion of Spain contributed to his demise is indeniable, regardless of their status before the invasion. So at least some compensation was deserved, specially after taking into account that the British (their own allies) destroyed the little industry Spain had at that moment while helping them against the french.
The problem is that they failed to catch the Congress zeitgeist and THEN rewrite it.
You can still come to different results
I think Spain got it even worse as they lost lands who were part of it since the Catholic Kings, or before if we consider Aragon to be a sort of proto-Spain.
@@Lucas24997 Spain came into existence after the Nueva Planta decrees.
god i hardly can imagine a timeline with as many angry great powers
Austria and Prussia probably would like this a lot
Imagine how much Tsar Alexander is screaming right now
@@Leo-ok3ujAustria? Not really, they failed most of their objectives with the exception of keeping Poland alive.
@@Leo-ok3uj austria got some lands in south germany but i highly doubt they would be content
@@gabrielpiccini4737 No, lol, I can easily imagine one. Who's angry here? Only Russia and Spain, whose voice doesn't count that much.
Who the hell gave Woodrow Wilson a time machine?
The 14 points plan wasn’t actually used
Czar: "What do you mean we gained NOTHING!?"
Ambassador: "The TH-cam congregation was very persuasive."
Czar: "I am not falling this! Our people died for Poland."
Ambassador: "But m'lord: Markiplier."
Czar: "Sigh, I guess I do have to obey Markiplier. He does... something on TH-cam."
The Czar and the ambassador where the same guy btw
@@Leo-ok3uj I know, but the other way would have required me to figure out what Markiplier actually does besides not smash Game Theory's Pokémon designs.
@@Leo-ok3uj which makes it better
@@regneva1957
You know what
Yeah, Alexander talking to himself like a caricature character sounds hilarious and a bit terrifyingly possible
Very funny that victor of the war actually looses land
I’m disappointed in this timeline already. Any universe that has a France in it is a timeline that needs improvements.
Bro is speaking fax🔥🔥🔥🔥
sorry sir, but i think you meant fr*nce, not france
I presume you're British 😂
Why does France no longer exist? You may have noticed recently when looking at a map that France appears to have been swallowed up by the ocean. But how did this happen?
@@bread2gDocudubery moment
When you hate the Hero of the Revolution, but the Russo-Ukrainian War more than 200 years later means the Russians must be punished here:
Is this what Reddit Renaissance enthusiast are usually like?
This is exactly what I was thinking about lmfao
I think a lot of them are just napoleon simps and therefore being anti russia of this time makes sense. They only hurt france because of the obsession with Catalonia and of course this is Dutch youtuber so Netherlands gets stuff.
@@dragon55017 What really sold it was the deference to ethnic unity with many of the divisions made. The French parts of France were kept by France, among other things, but almost every single instance where a state had control over an area that was not ethnically the same as the hegemon that controlled it, the state became independent or joined are large group of the same ethnicity. It reminds of things like "Free Palestine" and "Free Tibet" being supported in Western countries, with independence from a different group argued as a principle in and of itself, though there are other reasons to support those movements. Its literally the argument the Nazis made for annexing Austria and the Sudetenland.
I wonder if they are trying to accelerate the rise of ethnonationalism. Maybe not, as while alternate history can be pretty Alt-Right, this guy likely presents enough hints of being somewhat liberal that it would deter those elements.
@@lljkgktudjlrsmygilug You're the prime example of seeing what you want to see. Brittany was majoritarily French, Slesvig - Danish, Liège, Namur, Artois, Cambray, most of Luxembourg and French Hainaut were French; Iceland, Greenland and the Færoes spoke neither Norwegian nor Swedish, Hanover was kept under British PU, Norway remained in PU and this Poland has twice to thrice more non-Polish land than Polish. Meanwhile Provence, Avignon, Franche-Comté and Alsace were kept fully by France, Brescia, Bergamo, Istria and Dalmatia by Venice, Ragusa independent.
There are literally, hilariously and ironically more examples that contradict your point than ones that support it.
And moreover, even if they'd made it fully ethnical (which would've been impossible, further discrediting you), correlating the whole audience with Nazism is... something by which I question your intelligence.
@@genovayork2468 Two things.
1: You're right about the ethnicities part, and I will cope that I said something stupid because it was midnight. I also thought that a lot of those places leaned towards one ethnicity over the other, so that is a mistake of my own knowledge. An example would be Brittany, where jumped a few steps and assumed they must not have been properly French because they resisted the revolution. This likely drawing from ethnic separatism often occurring in societies with a major political realignment where a different central authority might take away the rights/privileges of a group, like in South Africa with the White population. I also thought the general French perspective towards Brittany was, to a lesser extent, similar to Algeria to late 20th century France, not as extreme though.
Do note that I believe that much of the audience that voted to screw over Russia as a prime directive, over-riding the ethnic claim I made. That is my actual belief, and I should have stated it.
2: For the Nazi bit, I don't think that all people who are Alt-Right are Nazis. I also don't think that the majority of the audience of these videos are either Alt-Right or Nazis, with them usually being no more than a third in the highest prevalence. Any attempt to determine how prevalent a group is obscured by a bunch of different factors, and that is the vibe I get. Mock me as much as you want for using "vibe". I'm Australian, so its part of my heritage.
I've been in quite a few alt-hist communities, though mostly viewing rather than commenting, for quite a few years, from TH-cam to Reddit and stretching from figures like WhatifAltHist and Mr Z to content creators who cover alt-hist who I'm pretty sure are progressive socialists. You will notice quite the overlap of people who are into alternate history and people who are Alt-Right, at least when it comes to those who are vocal and frequently comment. I don't blame the heads of these communities for actively fostering communities where these people frequent. Its just a matter of fact these communities attract the Alt-Right by virtue of their subject matter, like fitness videos. With that said, a content creator that is ambivalent to and especially those that actively supports logic that is amenable to far right politics leaves the doors wide open for them to flood in. On the inverse, those that actively use logic that is left-wing and those that actively make fun of right-wing logic (Such as PH in his parody of WhatifAltHist) have very few Alt Right fans. I've been on the WhatifAltHist subreddit lately and that place is filled to the brim with people who would get heavily downvoted in r/PCM for being too Far Right. Much of what many people in the sub say, with a high amount of upvotes, sounds identical in language and logic to stuff I have heard in actual self-proclaimed Far Right communities where people freely say what variant of fascism they are. I'm currently studying the rise of fascism, specifically Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy (more towards Italy) and what many in that sub say also aligns with actual fascist regimes, not just those in the modern day that ascribe themselves that title.
If I wasn't clear with that typed vomit I gave you, I don't think the audience of PH is Alt-Right or Nazis, and I think that the percentage of his audience that is fascist is very low. Of note, the first comment about the voters hating the Hero of the Revolution was a joke, especially since the question was likely interpreted by many to be a roleplay. I don't think the average viewer or voter in the poll of this channel would prefer absolute illiberal monarchy other the liberal absolutist state of Napoleon. I still stand by my claim about Russia though, and that the voters placed their own feelings about modern Russia into the making of this new Congress.
I loved when the viewers said "its writing time" and re writed all over the congress of vienna
Truly one of the alt history vids of all time
Nice! 🤣
And we’re about to rewrite all over Africa next!!!!
Evil Metternich be like "with this treaty I will guarantee a century of war across Europe"
These 2 videos are the reason why alternate/history channel viewers should not be given the power to vote on an alternate history scenario
the first 1 wasn't so bad atleast in the european part
@@matthiuskoenig3378 What? Tigerstar's? The outcome of his was miles worse!
@@genovayork2468 how so (for the europea part?)
@@matthiuskoenig3378 Germany gets Austria and the Sudetenland, it ends larger than it started, that alone makes it disgustingly worse. It has turbo Hungary.
Oh come on, it’s just in good fun, nobody thinks this would be a lasting and stable, let alone realistic peace deal. It’s just fun to see what a “democratic” peace deal would look like.
I get that Russia isn't the most popular nation in the West right now but damn
It's understandable but we all know what happens when you you go to far with humiliating and punishing a nation. Look at how hitler came to power.
This would just make for an earlier Crimean war, focused not on the ottomans,but on Poland.
Good, it makes my small polish heart proud
Yeah people are pretty dumb rn. Mindless hatred. 🤦♀️
@@planetmars408It’s not like Poland-Lithuania can do anything. Their entire system was flawed and they are now waiting to be chopped up again
Surely prussia and russia will respect the peace deal and dont invade poland 0,1 seconds after the congress
Prussia might not invade Poland,as those lands didn't have too much german population,but Russia certainly would, because they would be furious with the loss of Poland.
@@planetmars408 No, it wouldn't. It would cause ultimata by Austria and Prussia.
@@genovayork2468 pretty sure prussia would invade poland not help the poles
@@genovayork2468 Yea,it would be either as you said,or something similar to the Crimean War,but against Poland.
@@hadronox9268 Pretty sure you took that out of your
Even as Pole i think the more historically acurate would be russia keeps polish-lithuanian land before third partision of poland but instead austria gives galicia to poland to create a buffer state between them and russia
Lol, nope, Austria would never decrease its land to make a buffer, and you want Austria to do it against friendly Russia? Go to school some time. You profoundly need it if you think being Polish grants you credibility.
Yeah in 2 minutes into de the vid you already see a dumb decision based in nothingness
@@genovayork2468 actually you should go to School because, IT was one of Austrian propositions during congress of Vienna to create neutral Poland that couldnt declare war on anyone but would serve as buffer state like switzerland and yes they were willing to give Galicia to Poland if this idea would be approved but russians wanted full Control
@@PlayerPoker17 Austria would have done it if Russia had also ceded land to it, sunshine.
@@genovayork2468 you quickly went from austria would never to maybe if Russia, just cause you did no research if Russia allowed for Warsaw to remain Polish Austria would've given galicia for a buffer
So in conclusion: we should never be diplomats
Idk the WW1 peace settlement was okay in my opinion.
This one we were absolutely horrible though! 🤣
@@Wendeta-hq2cpMaybe EmperorTigerstar's audience is smarter
@@Kromiballmaybe his audience aren't onto sending Germans to Kazakhstan?
@@Kromiballnah the tigerstar one gave instambul to Greece and Austria and Sudetenland to Germany, they are equally dumb
@@Wendeta-hq2cpoh yeah okay the Germans gained land
"Democracy basically means of the people, for the people, by the people. But the people are Retarded" -Rajneesh Osho
Good riddance all the nations negotiating at the time were monarchies lol.
@@ambiguousdrink4067He is talking about the people is PH's audience who made this disgusting treaty, that, unlike said monarchies whoch brought an era of peace to Europe, the audience made the horrible treaty.
"I let the viewers pull as many Jenga pieces out of the tower as they like, and then I'll release a video next week talking about how unstable the tower is, and describing its collapse!"
Yeah, I can see Russia going all Spartan on Europe and telling them to come and take it. How many victorious nations would willingly agree to surrender any of their territory in a peace treaty.
This timeline was probably one where the Napoleonic Wars lasted several decades longer, causing the nation-state promoters to gain even more presence in the war-weary parliaments and courts of Europe.
@@charliekahn4205 except why would nation-state promoters give poland east-slavic regions? thats just creating anothe multi-ethnic empire
@@charliekahn4205 Ones who will be most angly is people of Russia. They literally carry this war and sacrifice much, both nobles and commoners, and at this point Russia was at peak patriotism, close to the lvl of WW2. And imagine people reaction to this weat fart of congress.
"you guys voted to restore Poland fully"
*doesn't give them Galicia-Lodomeria*
Literally what Austria wanted to do, doesn’t happen
The vote was to restore Poland-Lithuania to their 1792 borders, not their 1772 borders
You _have_ since watched the second part, right? That area does get returned when he gets into the post-Vienna alternate history.
@@gengarzilla1685 Brother this timeline was stillborn. There's nothing to alternate history over after a premise as stupid as this.
Interesting video! You should let TH-camrs to roleplay as a nation and rewrite the Congress of Vienna. Would be a very interesting idea, just a suggestion!
I like this idea actually
I like this idea, would love to see that :D
Yes!
In my opinion there is one major flaw with this treaty
They pissed off BOTH major problems, France and Russia
In my opinion for this to not immediately break down they should have given Russia everything they wanted to placate them so France is diplomatically isolated in their frustrations, at the very least they should have allowed the previous partition so the eastern flank is secured by two major powers
I actually think bolstering the Netherlands power further wasn't a bad idea for creating a buffer too, assuming belgium doesn't immediately break free and enlarged in this timeline
Edit: In all honesty I think good sense would have won out were it not for modern russia, it has colored peoples perceptions more negatively but that actually does expose something interesting
Can you imagine how much perceptions at the time were colored by so many years of war? Its astonishing the century of peace that followed and the leniency on the french in light of it
Its sad that modern day conflicts impact peoples opinion on the past, i too wondered if common sense existed after seeing the great cuck of '1815
The Short Peace.
Ultimately, I feel the lenient peace treaty for France IRL *was* the harshest punishment on their true enemy: Revolutionary Republicanism.
They didn't want to leave a mutilated and embarrassed kingdom and get a second wave of Liberal Revolts through Europe (and then they got them anyway).
Im sorry you saw only *one* major flaw with this treaty?
I love the idea of letting viewers choose how the video goes, would love to see a Crimean war and a Balkan war of this kind!
I would love to see the Balkan wars
Proves that making foreign affairs a democratic process is a terrible idea. I love it.
You concentrate on the voters and not on the youtuber who chose all the options.
@@genovayork2468 I haven't seen any problem with the options presented, did you?
@@omargerardolopez3294 Yes, I have quite a ranty comment.
Voters never decided the option that they should get presented, only voted for them.
So yes, this is a truly democratic process.
@@genovayork2468bro you have 302 comments complaining about this guy so we can’t find your rant just copy/paste it here
This feels like an EU4 peace deal with how it was all executed lol. Love it XD
I can definitely see the rationale behind this being "Let's punish everyone who was at any point even as much as tangentially friendly to Napoleon" 💀
Now I see the logic behind those decisions
They are stupid decisions, but at least now I understand why they did them
Napoleon haters coping
Real!
except poland was not punnished and they dirrectly fought for napoleon.
That is indeed the exception confirming the rule. Or it may be because the alternate history community has a PLC-boner for some reason unexplained.
@@Leo-ok3uj Napoleon haters who also hate the Russo-Ukrainian war being waged by Russia to be specific.
Denmark casually losing more than 90% of their land over the british bombing copenhagen for no reason:
This is a example on why giving the voices of the people is a bad idea.
>Signs this treaty
>Five minutes pass
>”The Franco-Russian alliance has declared war on Poland!”
*Franco-russian-spanish
I would definitely love to see more peace treaties discussed! Thanks for the amazing video!
I see a alliance between France Russia and Spain to reclaim their lost territories, with Britian opposing them with either Asutria or Prussia.
Or maybe Britian decides to go into more isolationsim after the treaty has been clearly a failure and lets the alliance have its way redeawing Europe as long as they dont go overboard
you might also just have austria, prussia and russia partision poland again.
@@matthiuskoenig3378 It all depends on how the alliances develop, both Austria and Prussia have expanded massively, and the would have to thread carefully if they want to keep their gains
@@matthiuskoenig3378I doubt it b/c Russia would want 100% of it back
I get the feeling this map would result in another major war within 2 years, if not immediately. Probably multiple all at once.
thought the borders were much worse.Personally I voted for the strangest things proposed,for example in my scenario Nice was a French exclave inside Sardinian Provence and the Pope would take Emilia but lose Marche and Romagna
if you could’ve made a video about this, you could’ve gotten much more participants. I’m a subscriber with notifications on, and i still never saw the google form
The Chaos of Vienna
Best idea ever, keep doing things like this!
This series seems awesome! Can’t wait for another one about WWII or something
This is going to be a great series!
So Rússia and Prussia que invade Poland probably
You can still have an era of goodwill if the thrones of Finland & Poland are given to the House of Romanov instead of being absorbed into the Russian Empire.
Poland was given as PU junior partner in our timeline.
@@genovayork2468 it was akin to a Dominion... untiol it wasn't.
That may…
As long as Alexander is not the king…
It may actually work and keep both russia happy and the states independent!
@@Leo-ok3uj What are you talking about lol?
1. Alexander maintained Polish independence all his reign. It was abolished 6 years after his death by Nikolai I.
2. Alexander not being its king means they are not in PU, but just with the same dynasty.
@@genovayork2468
1- Alexander spended his whole reign as king of poland removing every bit of autonomy, the reason his son was able to abolish it was because of everything Alexander did
2- The original comment never talked about a personal union, only about having the same dynasty in it
I already really liked this video concept but adding an alt history scenario about it later this week definitely makes it better, would personally love to see more of these in the future
I just found this channel and i am already in love with the content
I’m sure this won’t cause anyone….. TO DIE
> Be me, spanish
> See independent Catalonia
> Massive kek
> Russia gains nothing
> Second massive kek
> Harsher punishment to France
> Lol xd
> Abolishment of the Papal States
> Truly Reddit map
> Only changes outside of Europe are South Africa and Ceylon returning to the Netherlands
> At least something good
Day 11 of asking for what if everything went perfect for Romania
That would be cool not gonna lie. Greater Romania survives communism either as an ally or as an Axis power with Transnistria and West Banat.
That would be cool. A greater Romania having Tisa, west Banat and probably Transnistria
Also PH might make 2 timelines one where Romania joins the Axis and wins or the Allies
As a Romanian i can say this wold be wery nice
We created the Treaty of Versailles but in the Congress of Vienna
underrated channel. I love your content!
its like they colluded to piss off as many great powers as possible
When 1848 hits- forget the Republic. We are going to see a French Hitler. These are the exact conditions to create this mythical creature.
Amazing video man! Huge fan! Waiting for the perfect habsburgs videi🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😊😊😊😊😊
Another day another great video
Hannover not being given to Prussia triggers me so hard
Prussia being given literally anything (especially Schleswig-Holstein) triggers me so hard. At least there is hope of extremely angry Russia burning it to the ground for their betrayal
Be triggered then.
There will be no Austro-Prussian war though since Prussia is the definitive holder of Schleswig-Holsten, so I see this as an absolute win.
@@Wendeta-hq2cp You're profoundly in need of help if you think no war Austro-Prussian War would take place because of this.
@@genovayork2468
If it will be it sure won't happen over the Denmark annexed lands. Part of the reason Austria went to war with Germany was because Schleswig-Holsten was supposed to be administered by both Austria and Prussia, which in turn triggered Austria's wrath in response to Prussia locking them out of the North German Custom's union.
Also chill man.
i love this channel sm keep up the work!
I would like it if you made a short video telling people you would do this since I think a lot of people don’t regularly check the community tab.
i want another one of these!
A summary of the viewers' decisions:
-Russophobia
-Francophobia
-Catalonia and Brittany independent
-Possible History checks their analytics and finds a majority of their viewers are Dutch
-Slightly bigger-than-historical Prussia
-Possible History checks their analytics and finds a majority of their viewers are also Swedish
-Significantly more German Austria
-The Viewers embrace their inner Redditors and get rid of the Papal States
-The Ottomans stay perfectly still, and are therefore almost entirely ignored
Oh, don't forget heavy nostalgia for the deceased Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth.
@@gengarzilla1685 I'm not sure why I overlooked that
Dutch and swedes are huge map nerds, so I wouldn't be surprised.
We need a Victoria 2 mod for this scenario, it'd be a hilarious disaster.
No surprise the Dutch TH-camr's poll mega buffs the Dutch
3:57 Is very interesting because you can really see the outline of modern Germany from the independent states there, and i have to wonder, if that by giving almost all of what was previously Prussia to Poland, and leaving Austria out of Germany, that these are the reasons for the current Germany that we see today in our timeline.
Love this channel man! You deserve way more subscribers🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤
Nah, it's bad.
@@genovayork2468cool, then just go away? Probably better than insulting him in the comments...
@@juliandamen9804 Lol, sensible.
Say hello to Pacte revanchiste (tiny Pax Brittanica reference) with mad Russia and France. Peace for all times ensured!
P.S. You probably should've balanced options due to their popularity - maximalist PLC was supported only by 1/3 jf voters, so to keep majority it probablly should've been merged with more patritionist option.
never let the youtube rewrite your peace deals☠️
Great video !!!
You should do this with the Scramble for Africa
Bad ending for everyone.
Neat, we should do this to the aftermath of current wars
It's like an illustrated lesson on why direct democracy is a bad idea.
Now do a WW2 treaty! Also, I am excited to see what comes next so I hope you will be able to do more of this.
Oh god can’t wait to see the chaos that be considering how was made from this peace treaty alone
Dang Luxembourg is big but what if everything went perfect for them?
you should do this with the 30 Years' War next!
Things we can deduce from this video:
1) there are lots of Kaiserboos in your viewership
2) your viewership hates Britain, France and Russia (probably related to point 1).
Russia doesnt gain very much and in fact loses territory it had before the war?
Imagine if in the Peace Deal following WW2, the soviet Union had to give up Belarus and the US had to release California even though these two carried the allies, one in Europe, one in the pacific, because redditors said so
Any timeline where Corsica and Malta fall into (soon to be) Italian hands, can't be a bad timeline.
We've won.... But at what cost? Literally everything else...
Probably *_the_* only winner of the timeline, because the Dutch and Austrians were bound to collapse hard here.
I can smell the blood from the screen.
May God save the people of this timeline...
Please do more of these, I didn’t get to participate because life happens
Finally a video featuring the Netherlands me happy. Also can you add what if history went perfect for the Dutch?
>The Frankish Empire never collapses
>Dutch becomes the language of Western Europe
You should do if everything went perfect for Austria
Great video man!
The next one should be a Post-American civil war reconstruction decided by you video. It would be interesting to see how a modern and mostly non-American audience deals with dealing with both the former confederate states and the former slave population of the American south. Along with possible future goals of American expansion.
I thought a re-instated Poland would look like congress Poland, not before the partitions xDD
What could possibly go wrong?
A Part 2 or Something Like that would be cool
I can't wait for viewers rewrite the Treaty of Versailles!
...I'd be curious as to the nationality statistics of the poll voters because this "treaty" is a netherlands wet dream.
Not really, every Dutch speaker close to the French language border would know that adding even more French people would be a disaster
Do i get it right? Reddit thinks that Russia was ally of France?
This has got to be one of the treaties of all time, I can see this causing no problems whatsoever
You should to this agin it was really fun ❤
Democracy is a fun thing, this map caused:
- Lots of small states in Germany, more than in our timeline at least = easy prey to Austria, Prussia and maybe the UK
- Proud bavarians under Habsburg rule = Revolution in mountain region
- Great Poland = not only angry Russia, but also Prussia and Austria, leading to a 4th partition
- Small Denmark = annexed by Prussia or Sweden
- Great Lowlands = in case of a Belgian Revolution they would have more land and maybe put France in the confusion
- New italian states = easy prey for Sardinia and austrian resentment
I think by the 1890's WW1 already happened in this scenario.
1890s? More like the 1840s or 1850s.
Russia and France would most likely ally together against Europe and cause millions of deaths
This is such a nice idea to combine with alternate history especially! I am very excited for the video on Friday, will there be an uneasy alliance between France and Russia because of their mistreatment? Will revanchism in France grow, causing a new Napoleon to rise? Who knows, but this scenario has a lot of potential!
I would love to see an alternative history beyond this new congress of Vienna
I want to see the full dataset of this and what the 20th and 21st century look like.
Who is the Russian diplomat in this Universe??? Reverse Talleyrand?!?
Alexander must've REALLY messed things up this time.
3 ideas:
What if everything went perfect for the Polish-Lithuanian commonwealth? (like to see it end at ww1, but hard to predict)
What if everything went perfect for the Swedish Empire?
This one is a bit more out there, but it's something I'd like to see someone competent's take on, what if Bavaria or some other southern german state united the southern parts of germany.
oh there's so much to change for poland to even be functional by the start of the XVIII century
Now I want to see if we can "improve" upon the Treaty of Versailles.
A question I would like to see discussed in the follow up video is the Norwegian war of independence in 1814 and if Norway could get the support of a pissed of Russia to gain independence as Norway did historically try to get support but failed.
This is a great deal thanks guys🇳🇱🇳🇱
I'm super interested in these kind of videos , maybe next time 1914 treaties or 1945 ?
How would a full restoration of Poland realistically work though? What’s stopping to from being re-partitioned?
Absolutely nothing. All neighbors hate their guts except Austria which is "meh" at best and I'm pretty sure the Russian Tsar could annihilate Poland just by staring at it with a thousand yard "mfw all our patriots died for nothing" stare
@@seatray_real exactly, if anything, Russia would just take it all with little to no resistance. Prussia at this point was weaker than Russia.
Nothing, it's likely Russia will declare war the nanosecond the congress of Vienna ends
Nice seeing we, the Romagna's Asterix village, got forgotten even this time
Context?
Im not sure if he just didn't go over it in the video but i would think in this alternate peace deal they would go through with Metternich's original plan of giving all of Austrian Poland to Poland -Lithuania as a way to ease Russian tensions and strengthen the buffer state.