USMLE 🇺🇸 vs NEET PG 🇮🇳: The Truth About Which Is Tougher
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 เม.ย. 2023
- #shorts
As someone who's conquered both the NEET PG 🇮🇳 (AIR- 4480) and USMLE 🇺🇸 (Scores - 270's), I've got some insider info for ya! Seriously, the USMLE made me question my existence more times than I can count, while with the NEET PG? Well, let's just say I've never felt more like a human guinea pig! 🐹 But all jokes aside, both exams are challenging (one more than the other) and require a ton of hard work and dedication. 💪 So if you're preparing for either one, remember to take breaks, stay hydrated, and maybe consider investing in some stress balls!
🙋🏻♂️ Who am I?
My name is Manik Madaan, and I am currently a PGY-1 Resident Doctor in the USA 🇺🇸. I truly feel honored to teach and learn from medical students and grads all across the globe. This channel is dedicated to humans all across the world. I appreciate you stopping by & really really hope I've won your subscription, regards, and love 💖.
MY FREE ONLINE COURSE
💡 High-Intensity Learning - How to Learn Faster and Remember Everything Better
skl.sh/2QA9OoY
ZENOFUSMLE
📚 USMLE Xponential Advantage
zenofusmle.com
GET IN TOUCH
📸 Instagram - / _manikmadaan_
💌Email - manik5009@gmail.com
🕊Twitter - / zenofusmle
😎Discord - / discord - บันเทิง
You literally skipped the RESERVATION part 🗿
Neet pg mai bhi reservation hai kya 🗿🗿
@@Onlylurking_ bro .... 70% seats are frickinn reserved. .. NEET PG 2022 AIR 2 didn't get his choice specialty bcoz dermatologist seats are reserved in AIIMS 💀🗿
@@N423S bruh💀💀
@@N423S he will still get Derma not in his choice of college . In Usmle all competitive speciality spots are reserved for us grads in a way . You won’t get a dermatology seat if you need a visa . Forget about the institute , if you want anything outside of Ped psych IM FM Neuro Path then should not waste time for Usmle in short . You won’t get it no matter what .
@@Onlylurking_ 70% seats for reservation category..very difficult for students without reservation
Who cares which is tougher. Both exams require different prep that’s all. So just choose based on your interest.
Neet pg -
Fact based ,
Reservations ,
Once a year ,
19 subjects at once .
Usmle-
Concept based
Lengthy ,
Can postpone your steps ,
Steps are taken separately with separate set of subjects .
Stop glorifying the path to the same destination ! Enjoy the process !
Next exam-hold my beer bro😂
sure an exam that has been talked about occuring for so many years yet it does not happen
Next hasn't come yet while USMLE is the toughest exam which exist 😅
The match rates for U.S. citizen and non-U.S. citizen IMGs are 67.6% and 59.4%. ... Whereas only 21%students get a seat in NEETPG
Absolutely true.He being an Indian is talking like that without any common sense
This year of neet pg had around 2 lakhs aspirant and only rank below 10-12k get there desired seat...that's around 5 cents of people get a desired seat in government colleges.
@@user-rj4vn6gi7v nope they only get internal medicine radiology and neurology and psychiatry
The 60% match rate is for those who got at least an interview . Actual match rate is very less probably 30-35% or even less . Don’t mislead .
@@shubhamsarangpure also in Neet Pg it also depends on the state . In West Bengal for example even with 14k rank you can get anaesthesia in Kolkata from open category . Good luck getting anaesthesia in us , you just won’t even if you get 280 .
you are completely disregarding the fact that if you screw up the neet pg attempt, you lose an entire year. you just get 3.5 hours to prove your entire years' hardwork. i dont think the comparision is right here.
well if you're gonna fail both either way, then you're right, both are equally hard lol.
@@aravindnair3839 Bro which NEET PG are you giving...We are totally unaware of ?? As NEET PG given by us happens once in a year😅
@@aravindnair3839 are you kidding? check your facts !
Jo dono exam diye hain wahi baya sakta hai. Tune diya hai Kya ? Ushne diya hai eshliye bol Raha hai
@@BinayaPradhan69 mene dono exam nahi diya hai islie mene USMLE ke upar kuch comment nahi kia hai. lekin mene NEET dia hai aur iss bande se better rank b laya hun. islie i can comment on NEET exam. his rank in NEET is okayish as far as Open category student is concerned, nothing extra ordinary.
Usmle is more uncertain but neetpg is more difficult. For Usmle you have to study 5 subjects but for neetpg all 19 that too in great depth.
5 subjects??
@@nikkuchoudhary9960He is lying ,in Step 1 U need to learn Path,pharm,Ethics,Public Health,Biochem ,physio,Anatomy,Histo,Embroy,micro and many more
In Step2 u need EM,IM,FM,Surgery,ObGyn ,Peads Etc
Bro u must be kidding
How will u become a doctor anywhere in the world if u read only 5subs😂 will u tell the patient about rest that it was not in ur syllabus. Wtf r u on about? And who tf told u that u have to study only 5subs for usmle?😂😂😂 it's 3 steps, each exam of 8hrs duration brother.
5 subjects, you got to be joking????
In response to comments.....Neet pg AIR 1 will not be able to score even 250 in usmle step 2 ck with ZERO usmle preparation...... Just as manik was not able to score a top 100 neet pg rank with ZERO neet pg prep despite having such a high ck score, great knowledge and test taking skills. Both exams are very different and there's very little carry over. So in short, your neet pg prep will not give you great usmle score just as your usmle prep will not give you extra ordinary neet pg rank
I disagree totally. Please don't misleadI have done both, and was ranked 6 in NEETPG. Ended up doing residency in India and then scored 270 in both steps and now a faculty in a cardiology in a premier university in US. I would say to get an equivalent position NEETPG the process and the effort needed is much more
Can we change the specialty?
@@farazalam538 Depends on what you want to switch to, but certainly possible
So u did residency in India in internal medicine? Did u complete it? or u cleared usmle in the middle and took it up??
Depends on the specialty. Getting into Hypercompetitive specialties in USA as an IMG is way tougher than that of NEET PG in India
Is it better to attend uslme in third year or should I wait till final year
Kindly don't mislead......sir
If compared on the basis of toughness Neet pg is more tougher than usmle.....but usmle is a long process.....
@RYUGA PLAYS can't comment on the set rules.... right?
@@dreams45330i see. Is it impossible to get to US through usmle route? I hate this country tbh and want out no matter what.
@@dreams45330gosh...your english sucks..
And expensive
What is your name ?? I really have a urge to judge you@@aGenericBanana
Yeah neet rank around 4K but elected in USMLE maybe USMLE is easier 😅
He got 270s in Usmle. He went for neet pg without prepration, if he prepares dedicatedly for neet pg like he did for USMLE , he will be standing a great chance in neet pg to get under 200
He didn’t prepare for neet pg and still landed a decent rank.
Couldn’t say the same about you
Usmle costs 30L .needs 2 yrs of preperation .each step 8 hrs exam..if u don't match all the effort time n money gone
Bhai how would u know when u cannot even spell selected.
@@ryugaplays1934 for usce electives n stay in USA ,if don't match trying again next yr ..if interview is personal u have to fly a lot stay in hotels,it costs 35 L
Neet pg >>>> usmle coz of 70% reservation
AIR 2 in NEET PG doesn't get Dermatology in his college of choice and Dude says USMLE is tougher.... Good Joke
270 + in Usmles and still don't even get internal medicine in any university in USA , and that's not a joke
His choice of college was AIIMS D. And he didn’t get in. Due to reservation.
As long as we have reservation here,real merit students wil not get admission in pg
AIR 2 didnot get in derma because of reservation here..
@@akashmendha894 hi im actually looking into usmles and im confused about this fact. why arent seats guaranteed even if youve performed well in all the steps?
This is misleading. As an IMG your USMLE journey IS NOT OVER if you fail a step. Come on don’t say things which you know very well are not true
Yes
its practically over for all intents and purposes. why would PDs take any IMG who has FAILED a step? taking an IMG and having to sponsor them potentially for a visa, is a huge burden to begin with, so why would they take the risk and hire someone who has previously failed a step exam? the world isn't sunshine and rainbows and if you think your chances as an IMG at matching with failed usmle exams is not close to zero, then you're delusional
@@NO1xANIMExFAN my husband failed step 1 once.. and kept going. He failed step 2 the first time too. And he is now a final year resident in Psychiatry. The exact same field Manik is in. And he is not the only one. I have seen people who have failed multiple times, who have comr yo the US barely knowing English and taking 8+ years and multiple failed attempts to clear the exams who still matched.
So no I’m not delusional. I am someone who works with a lot of residents from all walks of life.
Why would PDs consider you ask? Because you can always have an explanation for why you failed the first time. As long as your CV and your PS show the kinda person you are, PDs will consider you.
If you are someone who failed and lack the capacity or knowledge to improve your CV that is a whole other story.
Then there is networking. You have no idea about the power of networking.
So don’t be an internet troll who goes around calling people labels like “delusional”. Please tell me how many hospitals and clinics and residents you have worked with in the US whose stories you personally know and then talk. Do not listen to misleading info like this.
He is good with a lot of info he provides
But completely wrong about average resident salaries, average cost of living, and about how scores are not the end of your USMLE journey
@@NO1xANIMExFANis that true even if you failed once ?
yes@@Propraj
application fees hi 16 lakh rupay hai 😂😂
Neet pg is more difficult,wtf you saying mate?
Lol wtf are you saying 🤣🤣🤣
Neet pg : scores ( i have friends who have cleared step 1 and 2 , they went for neet pg without preparation and got rank under 2000)
Usmle : scores + personality+ skills
It isn’t. Keep crying.
You just want an entitlement cuz u probably cant go for usmle u not smart enough.
Getting non surgical branches is very tough , getting surgical is moderately tough and non clinical is easy
NEET PG is the easier exam. It's the ratrace for seats that's the challenge.
Thats the most smartest comment ive heard so far rest all of the comments trying to be entitled oh hamara mushkil hai to sound relevant saying as if they cracked it or aced it, when its just a personal choice and can be financial aspect holding things back.
Indian pg has more patient exposure(as population is far more in india as compared to US) than US resident and working hours for indian residents are upto 15-18hr/day compared to US resident where work time limit is 48hr/week.
it's nothing like that ,rather USMLE is better ,if you somehow match then you have good life, you earn,whereas if you score less in NEET PG ,get ready to pay 110 k USD for a seat in your speciality, even pay is more given in USA than india.Also it doesn't matter if a country population is big or small, you would still get enough patient exposure in USA to become good doctor
It is 80 hr per work which translates to13 hrs /day
And no offense but US makes better doctors than india even with less patient exposures
Broo you are stupid , 48 hour a week ?? Who said you that
Again fake info by stupid Indians. US resident have 80+ hr work week.
Spreading fake info will take u nowhere.
Lmao how does more population necessarily mean better exposure??
Most Indians use private healthcare where medical students ain’t getting no exposure.
Did you just said that you paid 20 k dollars i.e , 12 lakhs as an examination fees !!! And still it has no surety.....
Bro got usmle pilled.
Usmle >
NEET UG LEFT THE CHAT
SELECTION RATE 0.1%😢❤️🔥❤️
lol everyone who has goes through neet pg has cleared neet ug so obviously thek know that pg entrance exam is tougher as you are competing against that .1 percent beta
@@khwaish1475there are more private seats then govt and there are fmge too , wtf are you talking
Around 2 lakhs aspirants..only a rank below 10k-12k get a desired seat +once a year exam+reservation+19 subjects in 3.5 hours...only 5 cents of people get desired seat in government colleges...still neet pg is easy????😂😂😂😂😂😂
sahi hai
This is comparison bro
Stick to Messi and football.
USMLE is tougher. Indians live in dilemma that everything they have is more difficult when it isn’t so.
In comparison usmle is more tough
Neet pg is easy for reservation candidate s..
Bro 20,000 dollars IS CRAZY
Thanks sir I'm in class 11 and preparing for neet UG . Your videos have broaden my perspective on this medical world
😂😂😂
Beth jao beta bohot zindagi dekhna baaki hai😂
@@medicoandneetmentorsanath6198 sahi kaha
Abhi tumhe hau 6-8 saal😂 UG pe dhyaan de lo
@@medicoandneetmentorsanath6198 how to sit?
Remember
this year 24 lakh
Last year 20 lakh
Competition is increasing
divide
seats/total candidates
less = tougher
simple
Those who.failed in neet pg .get selected in usmle
Is it really necessary to do research projects before appearing or after appearing for the usmle examination
Moral-go for neet pg
U world,all mcq come from there.neet pg has no fixed book/ question bank/ syllabus.usmle is lot easier.
whats u world
What about NEXT?
Can you break down....how did it cost $20000
I heard that we cannt get surgical branches there . is it true ??
You do not have any idea about neetpg
He qualified with under 5k rank. Pretty sure he knows
Is there disability reservation in USMLE exam also?
Sir I'm in 12th rn and wanna go abroad for job.... should I persue mbbs or bsc nursing....what will be more beneficial as per ur perspective ??
Clearing exams is an art
I agree NEET PG is easier if you exclude competitiveness, reservation, and the fact you are gonna lose an entire year. NEET PG is undoubtedly more competitive because US medical students are no match for Indian students, I have a lot of friends in America who got into medical school without clearing any near as tough exam as NEET. Most of them are actually private and you can get into medical through money and a decent HS score (MCAT isn't that tough either).
How much is total cost of USMLE Journey
Including everything ?
Brilliant
After clearing usmle.what is the college fee for residency.
I am scarred 😭
Now that they have made zero percentile eligibility for neet pg 2023, neet pg score is just bull shit. They have made a joke of Neet pg exam.
There can't be comparison between these .
Are bhai kaha se neetpg easy lagta hai aapko?. .. 😅
When you do usmle , neetpg is easy
Neet, Jee nhi hai jo world level pe stand karega bro
@@Ayushup2002 Bhai tu jee ki chaatna band karega?
Tere se waise bhi nhi hone waala.
And sir is talking about neet pg which has 19 subjects. 5 years of rigorous course asked in. 1 exam. The questions are not complicated but the preparation is 100* more rigorous than jee or neet ug.
Tere naam
Neetpg is just ratta stuff and i mean how can u even think about comparing neet tatty exam with the mighty usmle ..neetpg has now started improving a little bit by asking scenario based questions .Indian medical exams are all about ratta even pakistan has a better exam standard than india
The only thing that makes neetpg tougher is reservation & once a year thing otherwise it is 💩
Ya in Pakistan they ask about the incest between siblings and that requires a real brain to answer...
@@velcras4132 pakkaa tumse nhi hua hoga... koi nhi sabke baas ki baat nhi hoti
@@pany167 no fucktard i am already in 2nd year of my residency and btw i got 587 in neetpg in my first attempt with just 5 months study …poor u 😫
@@pany167 aur tumse usmle nhi hua hoga
Neet is more harder
AIIMS Inicet is the toughest medical entrance exam 🗿
Things have become different in Pakistan ! We have to do periphery for residency 😢
😂😂😂😂bro 😂😂😂 just try to pass Neet PG in your life
Both should not be compared
*more tougher*
3.5 hours deciding your future not a smart choice.
😂
Lol what a logic😂😂😂
Ganta 😂😊
so an img who failed a step will never match
Yeah, cause what Program would take a Student who couldn't pass a step ? That's literally the basic Criteria.
That's a lie.
No but It gets really really hard , So better not to fail it
Neet pg is the toughest…
Stay as a second class citizen
Sure ! Toh aiims kr lete woh kyu nhi hua considering usmle itna accha tha toh !
Aimms hai to india mai hi na ,
Its all about American dream
Because he didn’t prepare for neet pg. personal insults won’t change facts.
US 3rd grade medical college>>> AIIMS D
@@user-wn8sq2xk8z ek kaam kro Ilaaj bhi mat karao idhar se hum toh incompetent hai na
@@user-wn8sq2xk8z who is insulting…he is the one who comparing both of them are difficult I am just saying if pg that easy woh toh aise bhi clear ho jata since usmle is tough logic honey ! I am comparing neither insulting…..I don’t need to learn to respect from random strangers ! Preach at home pls
Kudos on ur rank in neet pg .You have got the rank since neet pg has changed pattern more towards USMLE although question are not lengthy .But MLE questions are unnecessary lengthy ,the actual question is just a few words . And NEET PG is an elimination exam not a qualifying exam. USMLE even with low score but good LOR reaearch u can get a residency . LOR and Interview are " firangi " sifarish .Atleast in NEET PG we get based on objective assessment not subjective interviews . Its actually unwise illogical to compare both exam .
I totally agree! USMLE is the toughest process to get through purely on merit. On the other hand, people in India cry over a 3 hour neet exam and also apply reservations, pay a ton of bribe money and what not crap politics to get a seat.
Young babbu maan
Usmle makes you a better doctor and the question stems are way harder compared to neet
While neetpg just tests who can cram the most 😂
What use is this system if you can't become a better doctor lol
One of my friends who gave neet pg only after step 1 prep got a 440
Shows how easy it is to get a good score in neet
Still he won't get a seat bro
@@shubhamsarangpure only after step 1 prep bro. When the weightage of pre clinical subjects in NEETPG is less than half.
@Prodigious147objective exams are easier than subjectives...so uni exams are tougher
So what... Not a useful video.. it is each one's preference..each one's choice.. no logic in comparison of any exam INICET NEETPG USMLE.. if someone likes to study or work in abroad they choose usmle that's it
U just proved you are a private medical graduate 😂
This is why im sticking to neetpg😂
Nice jacket sir
Bro is graduated from American Mc Donald's branch
@@ryugaplays1934 nope he can't😂 if he wants to practice in India, he should pass the MCI exam first and same goes with every other country.
U can't practice in any country without qualifying their licence exams even though you're graduated from the US.
@@randomguyonyourscreenu dumb he did mbbs in Bangalore he already have a licence here
And ya you can practice almost anywhere if you have cracked usmle you just need an interview
Chal
Neet pg is harder compared to usmle... Wtf u saying bro, 🙁
Bhai, kaunsi duniya mai hai tu na information kuch bhi bolna. Usmle full form nahi pata hogi
I agree with your point that USMLE is tougher.. Neet pg is competitive..Thats due to the less number of seats compared to huge number of applicants.. If we compare the standards of questions, I think USMLE questions are on a different level!
You are so negative.
😂 Conclusion:-USMLE is a waste of time and money
Bro jee advanced se world ka koi engineer exam
Compare karo
Baki university ke professor bhi nhi able to crack it
Neet to india me stand nhi karta world level pe to like chapter test hai
Tum jee ke chodo ko neet itna aasan lagta hai tab bhi neet students are able to get 99% easily in jee mains and top 5k in jee advanced.
Aukaat mein raha kro, abhi Oxford ke phd student ne 1hr mein physics 100% solve karli thi advanced ki.
@@user-wn8sq2xk8z acha 😀😀😀
Jee advanced sovle karne me kya oxford ke yek student ne solve kiya to kya kiya
Indias ke hajaro bachhe every year solve karte hai
Per tere neet ko koi bhi bord ka bachha solve kar lega
Are bhai o bol rha hai na neet tough nhi hai
Ab Tu check kar toughest exam in world
Secand toughest jee advaced neet india me top 10 pe bhi nhi aata
@@Ayushup2002 JEE advanced pass marks: 33%
Neet pass marks: 85%
Neet requires accuracy. Also, here sir was talking about neet pg not neet ug. But chutiye gawar jee waale bas validation lene aa jaate hain
@@Ayushup2002 bhosdike aise bol raha hai jaise jee mein 90% questions saare bacche solve kar lete hain.
Tumhare yahan 55-60% marks pe top 2000 rank aati hai
Neet mein top 2000 ke kiye 93% marks chahiye. And offline test if omr filling is also very hard and rank inflation is a massive issue. Jee advanced no doubt is tougher than neet if but competition and rank inflation makes neet ug just as hard to qualify.
@@Ayushup2002 India ke hajaro bacche har saal 18 mein se 6-10 questions hi solve kar paate hain.
Oxford ke student ne saare questions with perfect accuracy kiye the.
lol neet getting postponed again and again, and just 8 hours before the exam now🥲🥲😂😂
Ye bnda bas apna competition kam kr rha h aur kuch nhi😏😏
Babbu maaaaaan