What a thought-out flowing interpretation. I never found this piece interesting or beautiful, but hearing him play, I am inspired to practice to make it to a different level.
Did you notice the info posted in small letters (only if you look at the video on a desKtop; it does not show on phone)? The pianist is not Andras Schiff, but Paul Badura-Skoda.
Michael...so much feelin ah Schubert so much life. he is with God today...gbless u Dr and Schubert and thevwoeks u gave us while u were shortly on earth...amen...mike nyc
As Arial Herzog comments, No 3 performed convincingly , but differently, by Vladimir Horowitz. Nos 2, 3, & 4 are my top Schubert piano favourites, am currently struggling to perform # 4. Really brings home just how incredibly good these performances are by Maestro Andras, interpreted, I'm sure, precisely, no more, no less, as Schubert intended.
No. At the top, in the info, it says András Schiff very clearly. Further down it tells us what we can get on TH-cam Premium, and those recordings include Paul Badura-Skoda.
Ki lehet az a 14 személy, akinek ez a muzsika nem tetszik. Mert arra még gondolni sem akarok, hogy az előadásmóddal van bajuk! Az lehetetlen, mert az úgy tökéletes, ahogy van.
Although this is a perfect interpretation, I enjoy Grigory Sokolov’s interpretation better. It has more colours and nuances, for him every note is important, with Andras Schiff I do not get the same experience.
That’s exactly why I much prefer Schiff’s performance - I listen to Sokolov and I feel suffocated, he tries so hard to wring the profundity out of every note, and in the end I cannot understand the big picture of what the music is about. All I hear is Sokolov’s ideas, which may be interesting in isolation but what does it matter if the narrative of Schubert’s music is not brought out clearly? His pianism and musicianship are unquestionable and sometimes awe-inspiring but more often than not the heavy-handedness of his interpretations leaves me turning elsewhere.
Comparison between this interpretation and Sokolov's is not easy. Here we have only music, in Sokolov's videos we see him playing, his articulation, his facial expressions. I put some value in the latter, favoring Sokolov. But he also makes some unnecessary rubatos, and this version is cleaner, thus superior.
One of the most convincing impromptus among many. Magnificent Schubert who left us these unique pieces for eternity...
What a thought-out flowing interpretation. I never found this piece interesting or beautiful, but hearing him play, I am inspired to practice to make it to a different level.
Divine Schubert. Thanks Andras.
Listening to Andras play these works is like writing the word "perfect" with golden ink.
Charles Davis “the perfection itself is imperfection” - V.H
Did you notice the info posted in small letters (only if you look at the
video on a desKtop; it does not show on phone)? The pianist is not
Andras Schiff, but Paul Badura-Skoda.
You are not right, Kedimy. Look with attention
Kedimy Push on No.1 in C minor. There you will hear Paul Badura Skoda
@@kedimy It appears to be an artifact of youtube's licensing/ attribution algorithm. Correct title, wrong recording?
Je n'ai jamais ressenti autant d'émotions en écoutant du Schubert, ce pianiste est incroyable !
Musica sublime, eseguita con amore e competenza straordinarie❗💕😇👏🫂💙
Michael...so much feelin ah Schubert so much life. he is with God today...gbless u Dr and Schubert and thevwoeks u gave us while u were shortly on earth...amen...mike nyc
Such a different interpretation of number 3 than Horowitz but both masterpieces and by incredible artists.
Du très grand Schubert ! MERCI.
Sono rimasto senza parole...!!!!
I´d be prepared to give one year for work on no. 3 of these - and only that! My mother (may she rest in peace🥰) did it very well.
As Arial Herzog comments, No 3 performed convincingly , but differently, by Vladimir Horowitz. Nos 2, 3, & 4 are my top Schubert piano favourites, am currently struggling to perform # 4. Really brings home just how incredibly good these performances are by Maestro Andras, interpreted, I'm sure, precisely, no more, no less, as Schubert intended.
Inarrivabile.
I still think that maria pires is the one who gave the best interpretation to this piece of art
All a matter of taste, isn’t it?
I've not heard a more convincing interpretation than hers tbh....
Pires and Schiff. Both.
pires is better , for me
Pires version of no.1 is unparalleled......awe inspiring......redefined the piece for me.....
Bravo!
The word is Impromptus.
Andras Schiff und Vladimir Horowitz, die genialsten Interpreten Schubertscher Klaviermusik!
Thank you.
What year was this recorded? ❤🎶
The info says the pianist here is Paul Badura-Skoda (Austian artist, born 1927) and not Andras Schiff.
Jinho Chung Its correktly!
No. At the top, in the info, it says András Schiff very clearly. Further down it tells us what we can get on TH-cam Premium, and those recordings include Paul Badura-Skoda.
Impromptus
Ki lehet az a 14 személy, akinek ez a muzsika nem tetszik. Mert arra még gondolni sem akarok, hogy az előadásmóddal van bajuk! Az lehetetlen, mert az úgy tökéletes, ahogy van.
Спасибо
Although this is a perfect interpretation, I enjoy Grigory Sokolov’s interpretation better. It has more colours and nuances, for him every note is important, with Andras Schiff I do not get the same experience.
That’s exactly why I much prefer Schiff’s performance - I listen to Sokolov and I feel suffocated, he tries so hard to wring the profundity out of every note, and in the end I cannot understand the big picture of what the music is about. All I hear is Sokolov’s ideas, which may be interesting in isolation but what does it matter if the narrative of Schubert’s music is not brought out clearly? His pianism and musicianship are unquestionable and sometimes awe-inspiring but more often than not the heavy-handedness of his interpretations leaves me turning elsewhere.
I agree with you. I find Sokolov overly fussy at times. Relax 😂.
ludwigvontutti : I agree with you. Thank you for putting it so well.
Comparison between this interpretation and Sokolov's is not easy. Here we have only music, in Sokolov's videos we see him playing, his articulation, his facial expressions. I put some value in the latter, favoring Sokolov. But he also makes some unnecessary rubatos, and this version is cleaner, thus superior.
Horowitz is still the Best.