Now I want an episode that takes place in a nursing home called retirement of the daleks. It's a comic or book that involves Wilfred Mott getting a bunch of retirees to defeat a dalek plan to turn the elderly into secret agents.
Reminds me of the film Bubba Hotep. Not dr who, but features a mummy arising in a nursing home fought off by two elderly men who may or may not be Elvis and JFK. Starring Bruce Campbell
Geriatrics of the Daleks Day Care of the Daleks, Remembrance of the Daleks could all benefit from that treatment, with all three being parts of a story arc where some creepy dude in a wheelchair wants to create better robotic HCAs, builds a facility in Ledworth and ends up creating Mildred Ratched in robot form.
Most people give false names to the barista anyway, until Starmer makes it illegal. Would be quite amusing though to have a scene in a coffee shop with him and two companions with their names on the cups and with his just being 'The Doctor'
Drax revealed he was Theta Sigma aka Thete. This has popped up a couple times since, like the plinth in Five Doctors and River's graffiti addressed to him. and a Marvel Comics DW comic letter column.
Everyone also always misses another big thing with that episode. It’s called “The timeless Children” very intention wording. They may very well have implied that the Master is also one of those timeless children.
It's interesting how Peter Capaldi believes that once you've done the part, it's done. That rather flies in the face of the show's own history and even a lecture his Doctor gave to an audience. But there's a balance to be struck there. I don't particularly relish the idea of AI Doctors cropping up in some future equivalent of the anniversary specials. Once in a while is a novelty. Every other year is not.
I know it's been done with Eric Roberts already, but I've thought an American Master would be fun, especially if the Master were American just to irritate the Doctor.
Agreed on all counts except that I would have no problem if the Daleks were permanently wiped out (or even just never used again). They, like Star Trek's Borg, are scary and interesting on the surface but ultimately incredibly boring when you actually use them a lot. And the Daleks have been used A LOT. At least give us a few-even several-seasons without them before bringing them back.
Calling you out Elly! Ryan Gosling is Canadian, ironically born is London (Ontario). Let's clear the air here, the show was created by a Canadian, funded launch (and relaunch) by Canadians, and Canada is part of the Commonwealth... A Canadian 100% DESERVES an opportunity to portray the Doctor.
@@TheSegaStoner Australia is also a part of the Commonwealth!!! They should have people playing the Doctor too!!! They helped make the show in the 60's!!!
@@TheSegaStoner I hope these countries do get Acknowledged, in any way. Doctor Who wasn't just made by the UK in the Beginning, it was many different countries and now outside the UK they pay. They deserved to have someone represent them inside DW. And thr Toymaker was played by an American resently, why not other big Characters played by Non UK Please? Also I realized with Canda part of the Commonwealth, 1 show I loved was made by 3 and aired mostly in these 3 areas: Canda, UK, and Australia: Splatalot!!! It's mostly Candian, but the Hosts *depends where you live* and Some of the Defenders are your Nation!!!
Let me answer all of your concerns: HELL NO. The Doctor should ONLY EVER be played by someone from the British Isles. I’ll brook no argument on the subject. I have spoken.
For me, it depends on who plays The Doctor in this context. Patti Lupone, Anthony Rapp, Wilson Cruz or even Rita Moreno? Yes. But PLEASE no one from a primarily TV or movie background.
The show sucks now. I saw that space babies episode and my GOD the writing was God awful! Its sad but no point to the show since after capaldi. Show is just Woke propaganda now with shit writing. SPACE BABIES!? Like that was God awful!
@@dashtoroya2838 interesting. Ive always felt that way about capaldis and the 9 and 10 intro but the 7b intro ive always seen as a cool callback to the classic series. to each their own i guess
I already binge watch doctor who and would never Skip a single episode and couldn't imagine ever using the word filler to describe a show as unique as doctor who.
To satisfy fans, one option would be for him to become a new Doctor who happens to look a lot like The Third Doctor but with a very different personality (which includes the scheming nature of The Seventh Doctor, the abrasiveness of The Sixth Doctor, and The arrogance of The First Doctor). As the Curator said he might be revisiting a few of the old favorites, and this could be one of them.
9:38 I mean as an American I do recognize that Doctor Who is a British TV show, but still, it does feel weird that only one kind of person is allowed to play the Doctor (based on where they were born/raised?)- I don’t think it’s about the accent or where the actor is from, it’s about the actor themself, and how well they’d be able to portray the Doctor (though i do admit it would feel strange hearing the Doctor with an American accent, since I’m so accustomed to the Doctor being British or Scottish, etc.)
Well in universe he doesn't look human, we look Time Lord. If I'm remembering an audio drama right, the Time Lords literally tailored evolution and the timelines of certain races to make them resemble the Time Lords.
What if The Doctor's accent is due to his companion has that accent? Like maybe The 11th Doctor's relationship with Amy could have explained why The 12th Doctor has a Scottish accent. It could be something to do with the TARDIS' ability to translate languages, which would explain how Shakespeare and so on have MODERN British accents despite the fact that modern British accents only go back as far as the 18th century (or was it the 19th?), with British accents prior to that sounding more like modern American accents.
@@ZootLives the American accent (which one? Texan? New Jersey? Boston?) being the old English accent is a fallacy. The only similarity being they kept the rohtic r still used in the south west of England. In fact, Cornwall and Devon are the closest we have to that old English dialect
I mean Robert Picardo? (I mean he played a character called the Doctor :P - which i'm sure is known :), more so by this channel :D) - I think he'd be a good Doctor (as in Doctor Who) )
I agree with all of them. Except for a couple you’ve mentioned. 1 - I actually think having the tardis changing exterior for a couple episodes or more would actually be a cool premise. The Doctor could figure out why he/she can’t change it back to a police box. Obviously it doesn’t mean it’s going to be a permanent change because the police box is so iconic. 2- It’s always possible to have a Canadian or an American playing The Doctor. We’ve had a Canadian and an American Master in the TV movie. As long as they take a good amount of dialect classes to put on an accent. But it depends on the direction of the showrunner. It would give every actor who dreams of it, a chance. The show is always changing but never say never. As long as the Canadian/American performer doesn’t change The Doctor too much and keep to the formula, we should be safe for that. Non relative topic: it could be a risk but we shouldn’t have Earth Bound episodes all the time. It could get stagnant and the viewership could go down. The last season had a couple of episodes with alien planets, which was a breath of fresh air. Even if the aliens were human-like. Don’t get me wrong, being on Earth does make Doctor Who, Doctor Who. It would be nice though, to change the atmosphere more often.
Remember, the Master's TARDIS once appeared as a Greek/Roman style column in Classic Who in order to blend in, while the Doctor's was still the police box, and it made perfect sense, as the Master was overtly deceptive, as the Doctor was not.
@@DittoGTI I'm aware of that, but it still doesn't change the sense of it in my head. The Master used the circuit to deceive, while the Doctor didn't feel a need to fix it.
FYI, James Earl Jones signed the rights to his Vader recording sessions to Lucasfilm before his death specifically so that they may use them with AI to create any new Vader lines if needed should he pass on. The great man planned...
I'm just going to assume that the script writer for this video knows that Ryan Gosling isn't actually American. (He was actually born in London. Granted, that's London, Ontario, Canada.)
Concerning The Doctor's true name, they could take a tip from Mr. Mxyzptlk (MM) in the Superman comics. MM's real name can't be pronounced by humans, so he created a usable name for himself by turning a picture of a typewriter from a billboard advertisement into a real typewriter and then hit random letters to come up with the name MXYZPTLK. That became the name he uses when he pesters Superman in our dimension.
I see no problem with an American actor playing The Doctor. Matt Smith even said that he would love to see John Lithgow as The Doctor. The Doctor can literally be anybody, so why not an American, or an Australian, or an Indian for that matter!
I think it's a matter of time before we get a Doctor from America, Australia, Canada, or Ireland. Obviously, at first there'll be loads of outrage and complaint, but once we see it, and realize how wonderful they are we'll laugh at ourselves for ever doubting it.
At least make the first non-British Doctor someone with a stage background. Between that and her history on the West End, I could see Patti Lupone as The Doctor, preferably exclusive to Big Finish audio dramas.
I gotta somewhat disagree with number 2. It's understandable . don't get me wrong!, culture wise it would be different and clash but it's more or less you need the proper actor and designate a focus for the doctor incarnation they play as, there really isn't a base line of what defines the doctor other than a humble traveler from the stars. Giving an American actor could be good to bring a different flair to the role, I see RDJ's Sherlock Holmes type of role as a good example but only time will tell. Also, it's disney now so I kinda doubt they are gonna respect that.
The trouble with the Daleks is that there's no ideal resting period for them. When Resurrection of the Daleks came out, I was 11 and had only seen them in a new context once in five years (The Five Doctors), so it felt like a big deal. But five years to an 11 year old is roughly half a lifetime. At 51 it goes in the blink of an eye! So, rest them for ten years. And wake me for the second reel.
The biggest reason why revealing the Doctor's name would be a bad idea is because nothing that gets revealed would mean anything. There is absolutely no answer to the mystery of their name that would be remotely satisfying, or have any relative meaning to any viewer at all. The mystery literally doesn't mean anything outside of just existing for the sake of existing
Relax, Americans. Our British friends like to punch up every now and then, but don't let it rankle. Obviously, there are many actors from all over the world who could portray The Doctor brilliantly, but it doesn't matter. One of the great contradictions in Whodom is represented by the repeated message that the idea of nation-states is holding Humanity back, portrayed most excellently by a cabal of actors who all hail from one small island. The irony is almost charming.
I could never see Jon Pertwee in Sean Pertwee, until he posted those Halloween pics. But once I did see them I've wanted him to follow in his father footsteps so much!"
@@KarenOCallaghan-u5o His first scene in Gotham, I thought it WAS *JON* walking out of that fog into the alley! I know he's said he does not wish to recreate his father's iconic role, but did don the costume for that Gotham Hallowe'en party. (and Ben McKenzie wore that white wig and mustache for his comic counterpart of Gordon!)
I remember an interview that Verity Lambert gave when she said that seeing the Timelords and landing on Gallifrey decreased the Doctor's mystery and spoke about the benefits of not knowing the Doctor too much. In a way, if we ever have an episode where we meet the doctor's family members, it would feel as if we knew his name. Think about, imagine if we knew everything about the Doctor and the only reduced mystery we have is his name, we might as well what his name is. Yeah, like Colin Baker was humble. I would not mind a little de-aging on some of the surviving actors, provided it isn't too distracting.
That was the whole idea of the Carmel Masterplan, of which "Silver Nemesis" was a part. It was intended to restore the mystery to The Doctor because by that time much of The Doctor was known. In "Silver Nemesis" we got hints that The Doctor was far more than we've been shown, When the villain starts to hint at The Doctor's past, The Seventh Doctor looked to be afraid.
I wouldn't mind an American Doctor, obviously I'd like it to slowly shift, first the UK, then the UK and the Commonwealth, then UK, Commonwealth, and Europe, and *then* other international actors.
Actually, I would use CGI classic Doctors, but for animating lost episodes and Big Finish episodes. That's different from using CGI for appearances in new episodes, which might be alright for brief glimpses instead of stock footage like they've done many times, but I agree that using CGI for a significant appearance (more than a few seconds) isn't the right way to do it.
I think it'd probably be fine to have an american actor so long as the PART is still British. Like having Henry Cavill (a British actor) play the all-american Superman - who fights for "truth, justice and the american way". We've also had TWO British Spidermen. All three still play their parts as american, because that's the character. Especially in Superman's case - like the Doctor, he embodies characteristics of the country that created him, despite being an alien. It worked perfectly fine that way round so I don't see why the same can't be true in reverse, if you can find an american who can do a convincing enough accent.
@@gerryandersonisbestwe also had an English man play Batman cause Christian bale is English and that could explain his lisp when he was Bruce Wayne trying to cover the accent
I'd be fine with them changing the TARDIS from a police box if: 1.) It was only for 1 episode, probably the episode of a regeneration 2.) When it goes back to being the regular looking Police Box TARDIS they make a comment like "Ah. This is much better! It just felt OFF before, you know?"
They already did this with The Sixth Doctor. He got the Chameleon Circuit working, didn't like the results, returned the TARDIS to the Police Call Box form, and disabled the Circuit.
The Doctor Falls would have been a satisfying ending, it doesn't need to be an open ending. We can still have adventures with all the known incarnations and all the characters through spin offs and other media once the main show ends.
I do want to see what an "American" Time Lord would be like. Maybe name them "The Mechanic," basically an inventor. Someone who got bored of the upkeep of a facility on Galifrey and wanted to see what was out there to be invented. Or some BS like that. LOL
"An American Doctor would potentially be bigger, brasher, louder, elements that clash with the Doctor's default setting of humble traveler helping out wherever they can." That's a pretty big generalization you are making about over 300 million people.
The point being made is that American media production and British media production are fundamentally different. Having an American actor play The Doctor would bring in elements of American media production that would clash with the pre-existing style of the show. Just look at the TV movie.
Barry Morse, an American actor, did. He was the first actor to play Bond in a TV special of "Casino Royal" that also featured Peter Lorre as Le Chiffe. The special was included as a special feature on DVDs of the 1960s movie "Casino Royale" which starred David Niven as James Bond, Peter Sellers as James Bond, Woody Allen as Jimmy Bond, and basically renamed every British agent in the movie (including the women) "James Bond 007."
It would be funny as a one off episode if they did everything purposely wrong and the dr's entire mission that episode is fixing what is wrong/getting back to his normal self
As an American, I respectfully disagree with #2. My belief is that just as there are many accents and dialects of this planet, there has to be as many (if not more) on Gallifrey. With that being said, I wouldn't mind if the Doctor had any accent they hadn't used before (French, German, Italian, Ukranian, et al). They're still the Doctor and will do what's right.
As an American and second generation Whovian, I always connected with the idea that The Doctor could be anyone. Any race, gender, sexuality it doesn’t matter as long as The Doctor holds true to their core character traits. While I agree an American Doctor would definitely be weird at first, if they found the right person for the role who’s to say they couldn’t pull it off?
I've thought that although the core of The Doctor remains the same, the various personality aspects vary in how prominent they are. The Fourth Doctor combined aspects of his three previous personas, and The Sixth Doctor was the opposite of The Fifth Doctor.
When DW stories were multi-part serials (as in ClassicWho), releasing in a chunk makes more sense, so you can watch the story as a "movie" in one go, as opposed to NuWho, which are more singular stories (maybe a 2-parter thrown in)...
I've heard that The Ninth Doctor destroyed the Chameleon Circuit so that it would never work again. He did it because the TARDIS' Police Box Form had become a key part of Earth History.
A just phoned up Robin Whitehouse. "Eddow?", said a voice, sounding like he got a block'd up nose. It was Whitehouse. A then proceeded to take the mock out of Whitehouse, for a full harlf hour. A said lots, but it was mostly mocking his peg. Then, A threatened to tar and feather him. Whitehouse got mad. Suddenly, A heard a thud. "Oh no, oy'm having problem's breathing! ", A heard whitehouse screaming down the line, sounding like his nose totally block'd up. Then, suddenly, the line went dead. A hung up, laughing.
I thought the ending provided by World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls and Twice Upon a Time were good and a great way to end show, but then Chibnall and RTD then had to wreck it. Thankfully, we have so many more years of content to satisfy us (the audios, books and comics). And if you have a problem with Series 7B's opening titles, you have a problem with a lot of the show's history as every doctor from the Classic Series (apart from William Hartnell) had at least one point their faces in the opening titles.
I strongly agree with you on the first five, but I'm not so sure on the last five. Especially number One: Not yet, but eventually, with their, or their families permission, I think I'd like to see other Doctors return, even All Doctors return, IF the story (and the effects) are exemplary! And of the first five, I most strongly agree with number eight, The Doctor not being a divine being; just a really good Time Lord. As always thank you so very much all for the videos.
He's mangled this believed franchise into an obscene mess with his self-righteous virtue signalling and nonsensical inclusivity I couldn't care less about modern day politics I want it out of Doctor Who Despise me all you want, I don't care
@@SamuelBlack84 You want modern day politics out of Doctor Who? You must hate the Daleks, the Green Death, the Sun Makers, the Happiness Patrol, Aliens of London, World War Three, Gridlock, The Sound of Drums, the Last of the Time Lords, Oxygen
My alastor And I've been watching your videos for a very long time.But I have a question for you And a bit of a disagreement.I have watch doctor who my hole life I have Watched all the way from william heart now to The fifteen doctor. And my concern is Would you say that there should never be an american doctor Because , for the most aggressive , we got a lot of bad actors over here in america That can't do a british action at worth nothing But I'm an American and in the acting business myself and not performing live on the stage of a live band and it's been always one of my biggest dreams to be the Doctor from Doctor who 1 day if I ever got lucky. I just wish her. How do you put this. Would you please explain to me in a little bit more detail, please? And thank you, why an American actor should not ever have a chance at being a Doctor?
No multiverse please, at least not with Doctor. Maybe if they brought Dark Raven Productions on TH-cam with the multiverse and Second Empire stories with the daleks being actual soldiers/officers with feelings fighting
I reckon there is room for an alternate Tardis that is much smaller on the inside than it is on the outside. Imagine Scotland Yard turning up on some bleak windswept moor. Your protagonist goes in through the front door and finds themself in a closet.
The Doctor and the Master must be the same person! The reason there is so much affection and emnity between the two is they are in fact regenerations of each other. Yep, my fan fiction reigns supreme
I wrote my Doctor who book. Where the Master is the related to the Doctor but he’s become a slave to Rassilon who put the drums in his head to control him. It’s why he hears the heart beat of four, heart beat of a timelord. Rassilon controlling him. If you think about it Rassilon is quite a dominating headstrong villain and the Master seems to match that entirely all the way up to hurting the Doctor at any cost.
Or you can have The Master being the path that No. 14 ends up as after bi-generation. Then "The Doctor" is still pure but you can see what he could become should he fall
@@bawintermage8351 As well as a potential reason on why The Master is slightly insane and hearing drums. The "Drums" could be a byproduct of 14 being shot by The Toymaker. 14 still should have died there even with Bi-regeneration but didn't. Then they could have it so at some point The Master suppressed his older memories to try and deal with it which would both explain why the original version of The Master wasn't quite so insane (make it so this is shortly after he suppresses them) and why they seemed to get worse the more and more time they spent fighting The Doctor (The memories weren't removed and they would still technically be crossing time with their old selves)
As far as Americans doing British accents it used be standard in old Hollywood. Likewise you always had one or two bits doing southern accents. Most notably in gone with the wind
So the Doctor can be English and Scottish, but not American? How about Irish? African? Spanish? Sorry, I am an American, and I do prefer the Doctor being English, but to say that he should never be American is very pointed and basically tells American kids that they can never be the Doctor, which is odd when the Timeless Child shows that anyone can be. If the Doctor's accent can be influenced by his companions, then surely the Doctor can be American too.
An American Doctor with a Sontaran companion going around all of space and time shooting all their problems would be hilarious for all the wrong reasons.
He wouldn't shoot anything though, like? I'm American, unfortunately, and I think if you think an American Doctor would suddenly be gun-happy, you missed the point The Doctor, and really know nothing about Americans either. I do like the Sontaran Companion idea though, I could see some unknown scrawny American actor, probably young, as The Doctor, traveling around modern-day London with a Sontaran Companion, saving the universe with words and random office supplies, idk why people think that would be any different from what we get from Matt Smith or David Tennant, but ig Brits have some messed up generalized biases against Americans, so they think it would somehow be so drastically different. It really wouldn't be though.
Wrong. Early 80s, at the end of Tom Baker's era an American version of Doctor Who was planned. It was in pre-production had auditions and chosen an "actor" to play the Doctor and even a back up if their 1st choice became unavailable. Admittedly both choice have aged REALLY badly, being Michael Jackson and back up choice of Bill Cosby. Years some years before the TV Movie there were plans for a US Version.
The TARDIS Chameleon circuit should get a virus or maybe just partially fried by drop of some alien liquid. Then have a season where the Doctor has to defend the TARDIS at full size while repairing the circuit. Maybe a small Unit army has to come help to prevent any villiian from stealing tech
A number of years ago, Sean Pertwee posted a picture online of himself dressed as the Third Doctor for Halloween, and he looked amazing.
I cannot see Jeff Goldblum playing the Doctor. But I can see him playing a cool villain.
Who cares how little imagination you have?
Toymaker after NPH?
@@JoelGrant-yo8b Possible, or maybe another different villain.
@@jasonjimerson7046 The toymaker's brother? The god of reality?
@@jakesinclair69420 That could work.
Now I want an episode that takes place in a nursing home called retirement of the daleks. It's a comic or book that involves Wilfred Mott getting a bunch of retirees to defeat a dalek plan to turn the elderly into secret agents.
This would be an absolute hoot and I would buy it. Yeah retirees.
If they can even find someone that can live up to the late Bernard Cribbens, then yeah I can see that working.
lololol
Reminds me of the film Bubba Hotep. Not dr who, but features a mummy arising in a nursing home fought off by two elderly men who may or may not be Elvis and JFK. Starring Bruce Campbell
Geriatrics of the Daleks Day Care of the Daleks,
Remembrance of the Daleks
could all benefit from that treatment, with all three being parts of a story arc where some creepy dude in a wheelchair wants to create better robotic HCAs, builds a facility in Ledworth and ends up creating Mildred Ratched in robot form.
Doctor who's name will be revealed by a barista giving the Doctor their latte
It's Mark with a K. Barista writes Karc.
Most people give false names to the barista anyway, until Starmer makes it illegal.
Would be quite amusing though to have a scene in a coffee shop with him and two companions with their names on the cups and with his just being 'The Doctor'
Drax revealed he was Theta Sigma aka Thete. This has popped up a couple times since, like the plinth in Five Doctors and River's graffiti addressed to him. and a Marvel Comics DW comic letter column.
@@brainlock72 If I'm not mistaken, the 7th Doctor mentioned in "The Happiness Patrol" that Theta Sigma was a nickname.
@@retnavybrat yes, Theta Sigma was his university nickname. It is known.
I feel like the doctor and master being brothers would have made the timeless child more complicated
Not to mention 12 calling the Master his "man crush"
@@gamerwmcg lol
I want them to reveal that the Timeless Child is actually the Doctor's own final incarnations jumping back in time to the start of the Timelords.
@@gamerwmcg Also Missy literally kissing him on the lips.
Everyone also always misses another big thing with that episode. It’s called “The timeless Children” very intention wording. They may very well have implied that the Master is also one of those timeless children.
It's interesting how Peter Capaldi believes that once you've done the part, it's done. That rather flies in the face of the show's own history and even a lecture his Doctor gave to an audience. But there's a balance to be struck there. I don't particularly relish the idea of AI Doctors cropping up in some future equivalent of the anniversary specials. Once in a while is a novelty. Every other year is not.
I know it's been done with Eric Roberts already, but I've thought an American Master would be fun, especially if the Master were American just to irritate the Doctor.
I wonder if Eric Roberts' Master could have had a kid, if only to bring on Emma Roberts into the Doctor Who universe, but only as a villain.
Idk why it would irritate the doctor, he doesn't have a problem with America, he's been there a few times 😂
@@Squashedelica
The show has thrown more than a few elbows at America.
Agreed on all counts except that I would have no problem if the Daleks were permanently wiped out (or even just never used again). They, like Star Trek's Borg, are scary and interesting on the surface but ultimately incredibly boring when you actually use them a lot. And the Daleks have been used A LOT. At least give us a few-even several-seasons without them before bringing them back.
Calling you out Elly!
Ryan Gosling is Canadian, ironically born is London (Ontario). Let's clear the air here, the show was created by a Canadian, funded launch (and relaunch) by Canadians, and Canada is part of the Commonwealth... A Canadian 100% DESERVES an opportunity to portray the Doctor.
@@TheSegaStoner Australia is also a part of the Commonwealth!!! They should have people playing the Doctor too!!! They helped make the show in the 60's!!!
And so does an American, because if not for America, nobody ever would have had the idea for Canada...or something.
@@MarionBaggins I'm not anti-Australia by any means. Canada helped in the beginning as well :)
@@TheSegaStoner I hope these countries do get Acknowledged, in any way. Doctor Who wasn't just made by the UK in the Beginning, it was many different countries and now outside the UK they pay. They deserved to have someone represent them inside DW. And thr Toymaker was played by an American resently, why not other big Characters played by Non UK Please?
Also I realized with Canda part of the Commonwealth, 1 show I loved was made by 3 and aired mostly in these 3 areas: Canda, UK, and Australia:
Splatalot!!! It's mostly Candian, but the Hosts *depends where you live* and Some of the Defenders are your Nation!!!
Let me answer all of your concerns:
HELL NO.
The Doctor should ONLY EVER be played by someone from the British Isles.
I’ll brook no argument on the subject.
I have spoken.
I wouldn't rule out an American Doctor.
For me, it depends on who plays The Doctor in this context. Patti Lupone, Anthony Rapp, Wilson Cruz or even Rita Moreno? Yes. But PLEASE no one from a primarily TV or movie background.
#1: Allow Chris Chibnall to have anything to do with Doctor Who ever again.
Said no-one with a brain ever.
Do you mean not to have anything to do cause if not it don’t really make sense
Ain’t no way you’re still obsessively crying over Chibnall years later
Move on
The show sucks now. I saw that space babies episode and my GOD the writing was God awful! Its sad but no point to the show since after capaldi. Show is just Woke propaganda now with shit writing. SPACE BABIES!? Like that was God awful!
@Elotero947he’s anti piracy. Don’t pay any mind to him. He’s intellectually impaired.
Wait...wait.. do people hate the series 7b titles? Those are my fav of the new era? I want the doctors face back in the intros
^ this, 100%
Honestly same I wasn’t aware there was hate on those credits they’re some of my favourites
Apart from matt Smith's face the entire intro was horrible.
It felt they used some stock images from Google images and placed it at one go.
@@dashtoroya2838 interesting. Ive always felt that way about capaldis and the 9 and 10 intro but the 7b intro ive always seen as a cool callback to the classic series. to each their own i guess
@@juicebox_ryan3185the classic series was a wormhole, just like every other intro up until this one....
I already binge watch doctor who and would never Skip a single episode and couldn't imagine ever using the word filler to describe a show as unique as doctor who.
Sean Pertwee must be utterly sick to the back teeth of hearing him possibly taking over his father's part.
To satisfy fans, one option would be for him to become a new Doctor who happens to look a lot like The Third Doctor but with a very different personality (which includes the scheming nature of The Seventh Doctor, the abrasiveness of The Sixth Doctor, and The arrogance of The First Doctor). As the Curator said he might be revisiting a few of the old favorites, and this could be one of them.
9:38 I mean as an American I do recognize that Doctor Who is a British TV show, but still, it does feel weird that only one kind of person is allowed to play the Doctor (based on where they were born/raised?)- I don’t think it’s about the accent or where the actor is from, it’s about the actor themself, and how well they’d be able to portray the Doctor (though i do admit it would feel strange hearing the Doctor with an American accent, since I’m so accustomed to the Doctor being British or Scottish, etc.)
As someone in Britain I am offended that you said “Britain or Scotland”😂
JK
To me from a in-universe standpoint it is rather weird that the doctor only regenerates into british people. Or people from earth.
It's only a matter of time until we get a blue skinned Doctor with 5 eyes and 8 arms
Well in universe he doesn't look human, we look Time Lord. If I'm remembering an audio drama right, the Time Lords literally tailored evolution and the timelines of certain races to make them resemble the Time Lords.
What if The Doctor's accent is due to his companion has that accent? Like maybe The 11th Doctor's relationship with Amy could have explained why The 12th Doctor has a Scottish accent. It could be something to do with the TARDIS' ability to translate languages, which would explain how Shakespeare and so on have MODERN British accents despite the fact that modern British accents only go back as far as the 18th century (or was it the 19th?), with British accents prior to that sounding more like modern American accents.
@@ZootLives the American accent (which one? Texan? New Jersey? Boston?) being the old English accent is a fallacy. The only similarity being they kept the rohtic r still used in the south west of England. In fact, Cornwall and Devon are the closest we have to that old English dialect
He regenerates into people similar to his own time lord race; they are clearly as human-looking as Vulcans are.
I mean Robert Picardo? (I mean he played a character called the Doctor :P - which i'm sure is known :), more so by this channel :D) - I think he'd be a good Doctor (as in Doctor Who) )
I agree with all of them. Except for a couple you’ve mentioned.
1 - I actually think having the tardis changing exterior for a couple episodes or more would actually be a cool premise. The Doctor could figure out why he/she can’t change it back to a police box. Obviously it doesn’t mean it’s going to be a permanent change because the police box is so iconic.
2- It’s always possible to have a Canadian or an American playing The Doctor. We’ve had a Canadian and an American Master in the TV movie. As long as they take a good amount of dialect classes to put on an accent. But it depends on the direction of the showrunner. It would give every actor who dreams of it, a chance. The show is always changing but never say never. As long as the Canadian/American performer doesn’t change The Doctor too much and keep to the formula, we should be safe for that.
Non relative topic: it could be a risk but we shouldn’t have Earth Bound episodes all the time. It could get stagnant and the viewership could go down. The last season had a couple of episodes with alien planets, which was a breath of fresh air. Even if the aliens were human-like. Don’t get me wrong, being on Earth does make Doctor Who, Doctor Who. It would be nice though, to change the atmosphere more often.
If Daleks retire, a huge part of Doctor Who just dies.
I dunno. The Daleks have been done to death.
Davies said he wants them to not be evil anymore and will instead be nice and lecture everyone about the importance of being good 🙄
@@SamuelBlack84I doubt that is true at all
@@Grategous9 He said it in an interview
@@SamuelBlack84 He literally has never said that
Remember, the Master's TARDIS once appeared as a Greek/Roman style column in Classic Who in order to blend in, while the Doctor's was still the police box, and it made perfect sense, as the Master was overtly deceptive, as the Doctor was not.
The reason the Masters TARDIS looked that way is because the chameleon circuit isn't broken on the Masters TARDIS
@@DittoGTI I'm aware of that, but it still doesn't change the sense of it in my head. The Master used the circuit to deceive, while the Doctor didn't feel a need to fix it.
As an American I will make you eat your words when I play The Doctor
Let's do it together
FYI, James Earl Jones signed the rights to his Vader recording sessions to Lucasfilm before his death specifically so that they may use them with AI to create any new Vader lines if needed should he pass on. The great man planned...
Thats horrible actually
More like a great man was coerced to make a bad decision.
I'd much rather newer talent get a chance than that soulless slop
I'm just going to assume that the script writer for this video knows that Ryan Gosling isn't actually American. (He was actually born in London. Granted, that's London, Ontario, Canada.)
You can assume they don't know much at all since they started using AI to write scripts
This make him from the British Commonwealth so he could play The Doctor
The bigenerations make sense when you consider the multi Doctor episodes with the older Doctors being older.
Not all, Dr's 11 grew old in Trenzalore!
10:14 I love that you put a clip of the late Luke Perry in, when referring to American Doctors!! He was an amazing actor.
Luke Perry as Inspector Spacetime made me LOL for real. Good show.
Concerning The Doctor's true name, they could take a tip from Mr. Mxyzptlk (MM) in the Superman comics. MM's real name can't be pronounced by humans, so he created a usable name for himself by turning a picture of a typewriter from a billboard advertisement into a real typewriter and then hit random letters to come up with the name MXYZPTLK. That became the name he uses when he pesters Superman in our dimension.
hopefully the doctor doesn't become a god, i cant deal with space jesus again
I see no problem with an American actor playing The Doctor. Matt Smith even said that he would love to see John Lithgow as The Doctor. The Doctor can literally be anybody, so why not an American, or an Australian, or an Indian for that matter!
I think it's a matter of time before we get a Doctor from America, Australia, Canada, or Ireland. Obviously, at first there'll be loads of outrage and complaint, but once we see it, and realize how wonderful they are we'll laugh at ourselves for ever doubting it.
Want a Welsh doctor first.
I'm not sure why I got this idea, but I have become absolutely persuaded that we need a Jamaican Doctor.
@@brewster_4 Cillian Murphy
At least make the first non-British Doctor someone with a stage background. Between that and her history on the West End, I could see Patti Lupone as The Doctor, preferably exclusive to Big Finish audio dramas.
I gotta somewhat disagree with number 2.
It's understandable . don't get me wrong!, culture wise it would be different and clash but it's more or less you need the proper actor and designate a focus for the doctor incarnation they play as, there really isn't a base line of what defines the doctor other than a humble traveler from the stars. Giving an American actor could be good to bring a different flair to the role, I see RDJ's Sherlock Holmes type of role as a good example but only time will tell.
Also, it's disney now so I kinda doubt they are gonna respect that.
The trouble with the Daleks is that there's no ideal resting period for them. When Resurrection of the Daleks came out, I was 11 and had only seen them in a new context once in five years (The Five Doctors), so it felt like a big deal. But five years to an 11 year old is roughly half a lifetime. At 51 it goes in the blink of an eye! So, rest them for ten years. And wake me for the second reel.
The biggest reason why revealing the Doctor's name would be a bad idea is because nothing that gets revealed would mean anything. There is absolutely no answer to the mystery of their name that would be remotely satisfying, or have any relative meaning to any viewer at all. The mystery literally doesn't mean anything outside of just existing for the sake of existing
Unless the name is something absolutely crazy like Jesus Christ
Just like the Joker's origin.
Relax, Americans. Our British friends like to punch up every now and then, but don't let it rankle. Obviously, there are many actors from all over the world who could portray The Doctor brilliantly, but it doesn't matter. One of the great contradictions in Whodom is represented by the repeated message that the idea of nation-states is holding Humanity back, portrayed most excellently by a cabal of actors who all hail from one small island. The irony is almost charming.
The Daleks need to get a spin off.
I could never see Jon Pertwee in Sean Pertwee, until he posted those Halloween pics.
But once I did see them I've wanted him to follow in his father footsteps so much!"
When Sean Pertwee was on Brother Cadfile, I saw his resemblance to his father.
@@KarenOCallaghan-u5o His first scene in Gotham, I thought it WAS *JON* walking out of that fog into the alley! I know he's said he does not wish to recreate his father's iconic role, but did don the costume for that Gotham Hallowe'en party.
(and Ben McKenzie wore that white wig and mustache for his comic counterpart of Gordon!)
Because we need "Inspector Spacetime" 😆
So you’re ok with turning the male character of the Doctor into a woman, but you draw the line at the Doctor having an American accent…
political correctness will be the doom of the doctor
I remember an interview that Verity Lambert gave when she said that seeing the Timelords and landing on Gallifrey decreased the Doctor's mystery and spoke about the benefits of not knowing the Doctor too much. In a way, if we ever have an episode where we meet the doctor's family members, it would feel as if we knew his name. Think about, imagine if we knew everything about the Doctor and the only reduced mystery we have is his name, we might as well what his name is. Yeah, like Colin Baker was humble. I would not mind a little de-aging on some of the surviving actors, provided it isn't too distracting.
"if we ever have an episode where we meet the doctor's family members"
[coughSusancough]
That was the whole idea of the Carmel Masterplan, of which "Silver Nemesis" was a part. It was intended to restore the mystery to The Doctor because by that time much of The Doctor was known. In "Silver Nemesis" we got hints that The Doctor was far more than we've been shown, When the villain starts to hint at The Doctor's past, The Seventh Doctor looked to be afraid.
I wouldn't mind an American Doctor, obviously I'd like it to slowly shift, first the UK, then the UK and the Commonwealth, then UK, Commonwealth, and Europe, and *then* other international actors.
So no Snoop Dogg as The Doctor?
“Change on a regular basis” *shows 12 who didn’t change the sonic or the tardis*
Yea no thanks to CGI classic Doctors, that would feel even more disrespectful because they're still doing Doctor Who with Big Finish.
Actually, I would use CGI classic Doctors, but for animating lost episodes and Big Finish episodes. That's different from using CGI for appearances in new episodes, which might be alright for brief glimpses instead of stock footage like they've done many times, but I agree that using CGI for a significant appearance (more than a few seconds) isn't the right way to do it.
Thanks Ellie. It's always pleasant listening to you.
Id love an American doctor
I think it'd probably be fine to have an american actor so long as the PART is still British. Like having Henry Cavill (a British actor) play the all-american Superman - who fights for "truth, justice and the american way". We've also had TWO British Spidermen. All three still play their parts as american, because that's the character. Especially in Superman's case - like the Doctor, he embodies characteristics of the country that created him, despite being an alien. It worked perfectly fine that way round so I don't see why the same can't be true in reverse, if you can find an american who can do a convincing enough accent.
@@gerryandersonisbestWe've also had an Australian and an Irishman play James Bond.
@@gerryandersonisbestwe also had an English man play Batman cause Christian bale is English and that could explain his lisp when he was Bruce Wayne trying to cover the accent
OR and hear me out, they cast an American actor that loves and respects the Doctor Who IP 🤷♂️
I'd be fine with them changing the TARDIS from a police box if:
1.) It was only for 1 episode, probably the episode of a regeneration
2.) When it goes back to being the regular looking Police Box TARDIS they make a comment like "Ah. This is much better! It just felt OFF before, you know?"
They already did this with The Sixth Doctor. He got the Chameleon Circuit working, didn't like the results, returned the TARDIS to the Police Call Box form, and disabled the Circuit.
The Doctor Falls would have been a satisfying ending, it doesn't need to be an open ending. We can still have adventures with all the known incarnations and all the characters through spin offs and other media once the main show ends.
Peter Sellers, American?
the tardis thing can be like one episodes gimmic that the tardis just keeps becoming different boxs but permanently is just idiotic
6:36 Is nobody else going to mention the 'Also Starring Bernard Cribbins' detail at the top of the Daleks poster?!
Yeah, he was in the second Dalek movie, "Dalek's Invasion Earth".
It 10:27 reminds me of that ep of Community
The American inspector SpacetimI
Series 7 second title screen was awesome
I do want to see what an "American" Time Lord would be like. Maybe name them "The Mechanic," basically an inventor. Someone who got bored of the upkeep of a facility on Galifrey and wanted to see what was out there to be invented. Or some BS like that. LOL
I humbly request that Rule #1 be waived in the case of recreating the Lost Episodes.
"An American Doctor would potentially be bigger, brasher, louder, elements that clash with the Doctor's default setting of humble traveler helping out wherever they can." That's a pretty big generalization you are making about over 300 million people.
accurate tho
The point being made is that American media production and British media production are fundamentally different. Having an American actor play The Doctor would bring in elements of American media production that would clash with the pre-existing style of the show. Just look at the TV movie.
Somebody misunderstood the point
@@NootOfRosesblah blah blah yap Yap yap
“Every planet has a north.” Could every planet “have a North America”?
@9:06 well that's not fair
No American has played James Bond
Barry Morse, an American actor, did. He was the first actor to play Bond in a TV special of "Casino Royal" that also featured Peter Lorre as Le Chiffe. The special was included as a special feature on DVDs of the 1960s movie "Casino Royale" which starred David Niven as James Bond, Peter Sellers as James Bond, Woody Allen as Jimmy Bond, and basically renamed every British agent in the movie (including the women) "James Bond 007."
It would be funny as a one off episode if they did everything purposely wrong and the dr's entire mission that episode is fixing what is wrong/getting back to his normal self
As an American, I respectfully disagree with #2. My belief is that just as there are many accents and dialects of this planet, there has to be as many (if not more) on Gallifrey. With that being said, I wouldn't mind if the Doctor had any accent they hadn't used before (French, German, Italian, Ukranian, et al). They're still the Doctor and will do what's right.
I like the 7b title sequence AND 15s sonic screwdriver and I'm tired of pretending otherwise!
Russell T Davies watching this taking notes of what to do in the future
Hes just a joke now pushing a propaganda
As an American and second generation Whovian, I always connected with the idea that The Doctor could be anyone. Any race, gender, sexuality it doesn’t matter as long as The Doctor holds true to their core character traits. While I agree an American Doctor would definitely be weird at first, if they found the right person for the role who’s to say they couldn’t pull it off?
I agree!
I've thought that although the core of The Doctor remains the same, the various personality aspects vary in how prominent they are. The Fourth Doctor combined aspects of his three previous personas, and The Sixth Doctor was the opposite of The Fifth Doctor.
Nice Inspector Spacetime reference
Okay, I really don't get the hate for the Series 7B intro sequence. Is it the best one? No, but it's not THAT bad either.
When DW stories were multi-part serials (as in ClassicWho), releasing in a chunk makes more sense, so you can watch the story as a "movie" in one go, as opposed to NuWho, which are more singular stories (maybe a 2-parter thrown in)...
I think fixing the chameleon circuit for an episode could work, but it has to go back to normal by the end.
That did happen in Attack of the Cybermen.
I've heard that The Ninth Doctor destroyed the Chameleon Circuit so that it would never work again. He did it because the TARDIS' Police Box Form had become a key part of Earth History.
@@Solitaire001 Who was 9 again?
@@bigjake360t Christopher Eccelston.
@@Solitaire001 oh right. Thanks.
Give us a good enough story and they can do any of these
Ok, not the AI/CG one
Imagine Davison and his Season 19 companions having to fit it a normal sized police box
A just phoned up Robin Whitehouse.
"Eddow?", said a voice, sounding like he got a block'd up nose. It was Whitehouse.
A then proceeded to take the mock out of Whitehouse, for a full harlf hour.
A said lots, but it was mostly mocking his peg.
Then, A threatened to tar and feather him.
Whitehouse got mad.
Suddenly, A heard a thud.
"Oh no, oy'm having problem's breathing! ", A heard whitehouse screaming down the line, sounding like his nose totally block'd up.
Then, suddenly, the line went dead.
A hung up, laughing.
I thought the ending provided by World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls and Twice Upon a Time were good and a great way to end show, but then Chibnall and RTD then had to wreck it. Thankfully, we have so many more years of content to satisfy us (the audios, books and comics). And if you have a problem with Series 7B's opening titles, you have a problem with a lot of the show's history as every doctor from the Classic Series (apart from William Hartnell) had at least one point their faces in the opening titles.
No-one wrecked anything.
I strongly agree with you on the first five, but I'm not so sure on the last five. Especially number One: Not yet, but eventually, with their, or their families permission, I think I'd like to see other Doctors return, even All Doctors return, IF the story (and the effects) are exemplary!
And of the first five, I most strongly agree with number eight, The Doctor not being a divine being; just a really good Time Lord.
As always thank you so very much all for the videos.
Missy's flirting would be yucky if they made them siblings 😬
Russel T Davies will see this as a challenge
If Season 2 is released all at once, Ncuti is doing an American accent, and the TARDIS is a burger van… we accept full responsibility
He's mangled this believed franchise into an obscene mess with his self-righteous virtue signalling and nonsensical inclusivity
I couldn't care less about modern day politics
I want it out of Doctor Who
Despise me all you want, I don't care
@@SamuelBlack84 You want modern day politics out of Doctor Who? You must hate the Daleks, the Green Death, the Sun Makers, the Happiness Patrol, Aliens of London, World War Three, Gridlock, The Sound of Drums, the Last of the Time Lords, Oxygen
@@brewster_4 I don't want inclusivity
I don't want trans or gay crap in my programme
Keep that garbage to yourself
@@brewster_4 I don't want your politics
In theory the American doctor ship sailed the moment he had a regional accent
My alastor And I've been watching your videos for a very long time.But I have a question for you And a bit of a disagreement.I have watch doctor who my hole life I have Watched all the way from william heart now to The fifteen doctor. And my concern is Would you say that there should never be an american doctor Because , for the most aggressive , we got a lot of bad actors over here in america That can't do a british action at worth nothing But I'm an American and in the acting business myself and not performing live on the stage of a live band and it's been always one of my biggest dreams to be the Doctor from Doctor who 1 day if I ever got lucky. I just wish her. How do you put this. Would you please explain to me in a little bit more detail, please? And thank you, why an American actor should not ever have a chance at being a Doctor?
The to be continued never works unless it's a doctor who episode XD
WAIT! #1????? What do you call it on Day Of The Doctor & the time when Peter Capaldi met William Hartnell? Is that not AI?
In Day of the Doctor they used existing archive footage. When Capaldi met the 1st Doctor it was a recast.
Yes to the scrubs reference
No multiverse please, at least not with Doctor. Maybe if they brought Dark Raven Productions on TH-cam with the multiverse and Second Empire stories with the daleks being actual soldiers/officers with feelings fighting
I reckon there is room for an alternate Tardis that is much smaller on the inside than it is on the outside. Imagine Scotland Yard turning up on some bleak windswept moor. Your protagonist goes in through the front door and finds themself in a closet.
I think someone in the EU had a TARDIS that looked like a double-decker bus and actually was a bit smaller on the inside.
The Doctor and the Master must be the same person! The reason there is so much affection and emnity between the two is they are in fact regenerations of each other. Yep, my fan fiction reigns supreme
I wrote my Doctor who book. Where the Master is the related to the Doctor but he’s become a slave to Rassilon who put the drums in his head to control him. It’s why he hears the heart beat of four, heart beat of a timelord. Rassilon controlling him. If you think about it Rassilon is quite a dominating headstrong villain and the Master seems to match that entirely all the way up to hurting the Doctor at any cost.
Or you can have The Master being the path that No. 14 ends up as after bi-generation. Then "The Doctor" is still pure but you can see what he could become should he fall
@@RobertHinchey clever......Then that would explain both the affection and animosity between the Master and Doctor
@@bawintermage8351 As well as a potential reason on why The Master is slightly insane and hearing drums.
The "Drums" could be a byproduct of 14 being shot by The Toymaker. 14 still should have died there even with Bi-regeneration but didn't. Then they could have it so at some point The Master suppressed his older memories to try and deal with it which would both explain why the original version of The Master wasn't quite so insane (make it so this is shortly after he suppresses them) and why they seemed to get worse the more and more time they spent fighting The Doctor (The memories weren't removed and they would still technically be crossing time with their old selves)
@@RobertHinchey they've already explained why he hears the drums
As far as Americans doing British accents it used be standard in old Hollywood. Likewise you always had one or two bits doing southern accents. Most notably in gone with the wind
5:17 yes, Doctor Who has. Or rather, Torchwood has, with Jack’s evil brother Gray.
So the Doctor can be English and Scottish, but not American? How about Irish? African? Spanish? Sorry, I am an American, and I do prefer the Doctor being English, but to say that he should never be American is very pointed and basically tells American kids that they can never be the Doctor, which is odd when the Timeless Child shows that anyone can be. If the Doctor's accent can be influenced by his companions, then surely the Doctor can be American too.
I feel like if Doctor Who HAS to have an ending it should end with the 1st Doctor coming back.
An American Doctor with a Sontaran companion going around all of space and time shooting all their problems would be hilarious for all the wrong reasons.
He wouldn't shoot anything though, like? I'm American, unfortunately, and I think if you think an American Doctor would suddenly be gun-happy, you missed the point The Doctor, and really know nothing about Americans either. I do like the Sontaran Companion idea though, I could see some unknown scrawny American actor, probably young, as The Doctor, traveling around modern-day London with a Sontaran Companion, saving the universe with words and random office supplies, idk why people think that would be any different from what we get from Matt Smith or David Tennant, but ig Brits have some messed up generalized biases against Americans, so they think it would somehow be so drastically different. It really wouldn't be though.
Wait Disney owns doctor who?? I thought it was just a deal to put it on Disney+
I just thought the old doctors that were in tales of the tardis were the Bigenerated ones not separate from the bigenrated ones.
please, not the bloody Darlek's again!!
the Doctor's real name is Jeff
Wrong. Early 80s, at the end of Tom Baker's era an American version of Doctor Who was planned. It was in pre-production had auditions and chosen an "actor" to play the Doctor and even a back up if their 1st choice became unavailable. Admittedly both choice have aged REALLY badly, being Michael Jackson and back up choice of Bill Cosby. Years some years before the TV Movie there were plans for a US Version.
The TARDIS Chameleon circuit should get a virus or maybe just partially fried by drop of some alien liquid. Then have a season where the Doctor has to defend the TARDIS at full size while repairing the circuit. Maybe a small Unit army has to come help to prevent any villiian from stealing tech
I think Grant Gustin would be an amazing American Doctor Who.
Oh wow i just saw this post on google!
I feel like a doctor, who is an alien should be able to be american
I'm not pushing for CG reincarnation, but "it looks bad" is a criticism with an expiration date. ;)
I’d like to see a George Clooney time lord (not the doctor just another time lord)
Ya know if y'all keep gripping about how the daleks are over used that's just what will happen 6:11
Am i the only one who wants Rupert Grint as the doctor
Don't forget, never change the colour of the TARDIS and never change the tv theme.
The shape of the TARDIS shouldn't be changed either.