Every Single Difference Between the Deathly Hallows Book & Movie (Part 2): Harry Potter Explained
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ก.ย. 2024
- Patreon: / overview
Twitter: / movieflameprod
Personal Instagram: / morgan_ross18
TikTok: www.tiktok.com...
Facebook: / movieflame
Philosopher’s (Sorcerer’s Stone) Book vs Movie: • Every Single Differenc...
Chamber of Secrets Book vs Movie: • Every Single Differenc...
Prisoner of Azkaban Book vs Movie: • Every Single Differenc...
Goblet of Fire Book vs Movie: • Every Single Differenc...
Order of the Phoenix Book vs Movie: • Every Single Differenc...
Half-Blood Prince Book vs Movie: • Every Single Differenc...
Deathly Hallows Part 1: • Every Single Differenc...
Fanart:
Aberforth: www.deviantart...
Ariana Dumbledore: www.deviantart...
Albus Severus Potter: www.deviantart...
Hugo & Rose: www.deviantart...
Teddy Lupin: www.deviantart...
Travers: www.deviantart...
Dumbledore/Grindelwald/Aberforth Duel: www.deviantart...
Ted Tonks: www.deviantart...
Dirk Cresswell: www.hp-lexicon...
Snape vs. McGonagall: www.deviantart...
Ron & Hermione kiss: www.deviantart...
Fred’s Death: loquaciouslite...
Snape behind bush: www.artstation...
Lily on Swing: www.artstation...
Lily & Snape Meet James & Sirius: www.deviantart...
James saves Snape: www.deviantart...
Snape calls Lily Mudblood: www.artstation...
Snape apologizes to Lily: www.deviantart...
Snape Reading Lily’s Letter: www.deviantart...
Kreacher in Battle of Hogwarts: • Fire Green Screen
Teddy & Victoire: www.deviantart...
Music- By Ross Bugden • ♩♫ Sad and Emotional M...
I loved in the book how Harry kept calling Voldemort, Tom in the final battle, showing everyone that he was nothing special.
To make it way better once Harry called Voldemort Tom Voldemort tried to tell him that he hated that name and being known by that name yet Harry didn't care and just kept on continuing on. So badass! EEP! :)
To be fair he does call him that in the movie
@Gregory Marshall Also, two more additional changes should have been made. 1) It was important for everyone who was fighting to *bear witness to Voldemort's death,* otherwise they'd just have to take Harry's word for it! They should have kept the finale as the books did, Harry and Tom circling eachother in the Great Hall *surrounded by witnesses and spectators* as opposed to off on their own like in the movies, when Harry implored Tom to _"try a little love and remorse"_ as he's seen the frightening remains of Voldemort's mangled soul.
2) *Voldemort should have been killed as he did in the books;* nothing spectacular or noteworthy. He just fell backwards in a heap, limp and lifeless... Completely unremarkable. His worst fear was dying a mediocre death ☠️ which is precisely what we should have seen, as opposed to being "Thanos snapped" and crumbling into dust flying away in the wind.
Yeah it did got Harry in trouble too, the word "Voldemort" was jinxed which actually led to capture of the trio and the scene at Malfoy Manor happened. I guess this was the reason everyone called him "You-Know-Who"
Dumbledore also referred to Voldemort as Tom during their duel in Order of the Phoenix.
My favorite part of the battle was when Kreacher rallied the house-elf’s. I had tears in my eyes as he led them with no fear to help his master. Great job on all the videos.
Lol yes!!! Them taking arms against wizards was so beautiful!
So did I, I laughed with teary eyes as I visualized a bunch of house elves stabbing the death eaters shins and ankles😂
omg yes
The whole redemption of Kreacher saga was my favourite part of the book.
I thought this said Kreacher railed the house elves
I am seriously gonna miss this series . But really morgan we really appreciate your efforts in this series. Your channel is the best for a potterhead like me as you make the best harry potter videos.Thank you so much for this series
Big props for Helena Bonham Carter for NAILING Emma Watson's speech patterns and maneirisms to really make it seems like it was Hermione as Lestrange trying to act like her. She just rocked that.
the only positive thing I can say about this movie tbh
I agree with you. Helena Bonham Carter rocked as Bellatrix and totally made her character, genuinely ALIVE. Especially trying to act as a 17-year-old wearing your shoes and your clothing. It was awesome 👌
@@marianpyter5948 yikes
@@marianpyter5948 yikes
Now if only Emma Watson could also Act
Can’t believe this is the final episode of the series. Really gonna miss waiting for another episode. Thank you so much Morgan for putting so much time and effort into creating these amazing videos
Always
Always
"After all this time?"
"Always."
100%
Morgan: fantastic work
The fact that Griphook got away with the sword in the book brings to mind an image of him sitting comfortably,admiring the sword and it just disappears before his eyes when Neville pulls it out of that hat.
griphook dies in the book long before this
@@DittaDemon it's never said he does
which makes me think why don't they just focus on stealing the manky hat
Voldemort kills him in the movie as well and the sword vanishs and appears when neville needs it
@@acs7167 we’re talking about the books, not the movies
This was such a great and well put together series. Effort REALLY REALLY shows. Fantastic work!!
Hi-
Agreed!
Amazing video! Everything is explained perfectly! I love it!
Your that Guy that hates Skylanders
Hi
Biggest series mistakes:
-Not using Dobbys character enough in most of the movies
-Make Ron look bad and dumb frequently
the first one isnt too bad dobby looks ugly in the books
What about peeves 😭
what about the real essence of Ginny 🤔
The first one I can forgive since J.K. was writing the books while the movies were being made and would keep a lot of things secret from the filmmakers until she finished writing so there’s no way the filmmakers could’ve known how often Dobby would be used.
The second one is unforgivable and downright insulting however
@@someotherdude6626 the first one doesnt even matter cause of dobby not being neville got his scenes which is far better making his character grow and second one i absoulutely agree
I wish they kept Ron’s “He beat you!” scream that broke Voldemort’s silencing charm during Harry’s supposed death announcement.
But no how about they still ruin Ron
The movie did this time and time again, especially for Hermione. To make Hermione look better, the movies had her steal moments from harry, Ron, Parvati, Mr Weasley....lol
Ron’s scream of despair and rage over his best friends death was so powerful that it broke the most powerful wizards silencing charm like it was nothing! Meanwhile in the film its so annoying that i wanna rip my hair out that they always film Hermione closer to the camera and Ron in the background. Like piss off Kloves this isn’t your shitty fanfic
Omg I forgot about that! And in the epilogue where their kids are saying "why is everyone staring at us?" And him saying that "It's me, I'm incredibly famous"... lmfao
@@jomckellan Yup. It was Harry's idea to ride the dragon out of Gringott's, but the movie gave it to Hermione.
@@kenhollis6197 It’s a much more Book Harry thing to do too. Like in book 1 for example, ”There’s a giant troll that is about to kill us? Lets jump on it and do some troll rodeo!” It might be stupid but atleast it’s brave, just like riding a fucking dragon out of a bank.
I'm a 64 year old grandmother who read the books and watched the series with my children and grandchildren. You should be proud of the excellent work you did on this.
This is so lovely!
Definitely agreed.
I'd also like to add that the final lines from Peeves were absolutely hilarious. "...and Voldy's gone moldy..."
doesn't work in the film, "Voldy's disintegrated"
@@crosscourttennis1796 The disintegration is a fail on the film's part imo
@@Ori_Kohav obv
@@crosscourttennis1796 Besides, knowing his talent in improvising those poems, it's fair to assume that Peeves would come up with other fitting lines.
I love Ron's line at Peeves' song 😂
One thing they left out was longbottom grandmother showing up and asking were he is and leves to go find him and help him fight. Such a proud moment when I read it
Literally everyone: You have your mother's eyes.
David Yates: I.. Don't... Think so...
It still puzzles me why they kept her eyes dark brown, like couldn’t they have given her green (or at least light blue to match Daniel’s eyes) contacts, or perhaps chosen someone else to play young Lily if not.
Also David Yates: Harry + hermionie ferever!
@@tenkenroo That’s the reason why he and Kloves are incompetent idiots. Wow, what a way to piss off us book elitists………
@@scaranvostok3637 it’s not even about book elitists. It’s film continuity issues, too. He has characters mentioning his eyes are similar to his mother’s, but gives the mother in flashbacks dark brown eyes?
@@anonnyanonymous4800 Also there's an inconsistency about how Polyjuice potion changes voices too. And they omit George's lost ear part from DHP1 in DHP2.
Dude, I’m a 35 years old construction worker although it might not look, HP series were a big part of my life, as well as my partner and our teenage daughter. I have been listening to this movie vs book series for the past 6 days, going to and from my job, and I just wanted to thank you for the work you have done putting these together, this is absolutely awesome!
I met an 80 year old lady today at the gym (I'm 66) who recognized a tattoo I have from a 1904 Wizard of Oz book. We discussed HP. Good Fantasy is ageless!
I’m a 26 year old warehouse worker, former trucker
Same. It was my older sister and son (now aged 19) who got me into the series. My thirteen-year-old daughter is still obsessed with the HP universe, though she basically denounces the film series.
Share the same passion my friend
I'm a 39 and Still absolutely love Harry Potter ... I've read and reread the books many times and watched all the movies many times (in theaters when they first came out of course) ... And later as my kids got into it when younger
Can we all just appreciate that movie flame puts so much effort in each and every video?
Yea
He definitely does! :)
Absolutely always. We are blessed
By himself even
Sharing his feedback on if differences are either positive or negative for the characters just makes you appreciate what a fan with passion for the source material could do on a writers position for the film instead of a person with diploma and a high paycheck as a motivator
What I’m missing is that in the book Harry actually doesnt kill Voldemort but it’s more like he (in accident) kill’s himself.
The way Harry wins is much much stronger in the book. He talks to him and breaks down his worldview and this made Volde so angry he used the death curse which repelled and hit him back.
So Harry just placed a mirror but Volde decided to shoot and forgot about it.
Everything in the book is much more pronounced, characters, scenes, just everything.
Just the last part of the book was the best. All centaurs, parents of the students, elves came to fight voldemorts army. Golden
The book is much more realistic, in the movie it's all about that cringe determination of the american movie protagonists, that even if they are weaker, somehow they can battle strong enemies like death eaters and Voldemort himself.
@PrincessBonbon Oh, you're right, beside the writer, most of the heads in charge for the last movie are British. Then, I'm lost on why they did it that manner.
Break down his world view how? If you have hostile foreign elements gradually taking a greater and greater part of your society they will eventually come to dominate and destroy you. The "pure blood supremacists" were right the entire time. Dumbledore and Harry Potter doomed the wizarding culture to being absorbed and ultimately destroyed by the Muggles.
I'll always love hearing Mcgonagall's "Boom". I adore Maggie Smith and that was so great.
"I've always wanted to use that spell!" :D
It was a very nice pay-off to Seamus' running gag in the movies. The bridge explosion scene was a good addition and was really dope.
Not seeing Kreacher lead the house elves into the fight in the movie is such an underlooked thing by people and it's one of the things I dislike the most about the movie. It's such a small moment but pairing it with kreacher's tale makes it impact me much more
It is funny how much the deathly Hallows movies left out even after being divided into 2 parts. The total length of this video and the previous is about 1 hour 38 mins, 10 mins more than the order of Phoenix. But I still cant say I didn't love any of the Harry Potter movies
it annoys me how they can add things but they left so much that in the books
That's the problem with Deathly Hallows. They left so much important info out of Order of the Phoenix and Half Blood Prince, these two final films suffered. It all had to be either rushed or just crowbarred in.
@@ok-ie9sz The movies, (im talking specifically about GOF and HBP here) focused too much on the relationships and love.
@@zjean3417 I would say Half Blood Prince was the biggest offender here. Goblet of Fire sorta focused on relationships in the books, so I thought that could pass.
@@zjean3417, really? HBP definitely but GOF didn’t add any forced relationship drama. All the relationship drama was only in the Yule Ball scenes like in the book
There is one scene, that I absolutely hate and that's how lame was Voldemort's death compare to the book.
In the book it was a deep scene in the Great Hall, where Harry explains all Voldemort's mistakes to him in front of everyone (even tho flexing about his ownership of the Elder Wand, when everyone sees you, wasn't necessary). And Harry even tried to prevent him from making a fatal mistake.
This shows, that despite his reputation in Wizarding Britain and people's fear to the point of not saying his name, he was still a regular man, who can make missteps. And he dies just like a normal human being. Just a corpse and nothing else.
In the movie it was just another generic Avada Kedavra- Expelliarmus clash with no substance and witnesses. And Voldemort just got hit by Thanos Snap for no reason, like he is some epic dude.
It just showed how ironic and pointless Voldemort's ambition was. Just to die like a normal human being was the biggest insult he could get.
Exactly! He should've been proven to be really No.Big.Deal. like in the book. Instead, we get a version of Saruman being killed by Wormtongue in the LOTR books (have NOT seen those movies). It ruined Harry's character arc too-no "try some remorse" as you mentioned. And afterward there was no celebration, no everyone running to congratulate Harry, no going upstairs later and Harry wondering if Kreacher could bring him a sandwich; in the movie it was like they'd lost . . . total downer, but at least there was the epilogue.
I hated that they had Voldermort turn into ashes as he dies instead of falling over dead. The same with Bellatrix's death.
I think it’s just the opposite, the battle in the movie leading up to Voldemort’s final defeat was awesome! It was just as it was meant to be with Harry and Voldemort actually dueling around the castle they both called home, rather than Harry and Voldemort circling around each other waiting for the other to make a move while everybody gasped and pointed in the corners like really? and how insanely stupid was it that Harry told a hundred people that he was the master of the most powerful wand in existence? In the book it actually was just how you described, a generic Avada Kedavra-Expelliarmus clash with no substance and like Voldemort said, Harry didn’t win because he was a better wizard, he won because people greater than him had paved the way. The only reason he became the Elder wand’s master was purely by mistake, if not for that he would not have won the duel.
@@krisynthiagomez5883 You have a point there. It was more exciting to watch Harry and Voldermort duel in the movie better than in the book. Also I'd like to point out that it was better for Harry to snap the elder wand and throw it away than what he did in the book. That way no one would ever use it again.
To be straightforward:
The look on hagrid’s face in the movie when carrying Harry made me teary eyed. It’s chilling to see.
In the book, harry heard hagrid crying while carrying him thru the forest
I heard somebody said like Hagrid is the person to hold Harry (I know he wasn't the first person to hold him I just mean on screen) and that scene of him thinking Harry is dead in his arms is just hurting his his heart and he's think "I failed"
“In the novel the dragon doesn’t kill anyone but in the book it killed many people”
Me: _visible confusion_
Man do I love watching the book on TV
Never realized how funny Lucius saying "I don't know" in response to "How can you live with yourself?" was until this video haha
I just didn’t get what he had done…it bugged me until this…I haven’t read the book but bought it just to find out….when it isn’t even in there…🤦🏻♀️🤣🤣
@@be_a_bright_sparkle3687 he lost the battle of the department of mysteries and failed to get the prophecy & was blamed for letting Tom riddles diary get destroyed for basically putting it into Ginny’s cauldron for shits and giggles.
@@be_a_bright_sparkle3687 so essentially just fell out of favour with voldermort
@@bruhdon4748 pretty much yes
@@bruhdon4748 i mean he didn’t just do it for shits and giggles.
He actually had a reason. Arthur was doing raids for dark objects. If his daughter was found to be in possession of said dark object it wouldn’t put Arthur in a good position.
So it was mainly to discredit Arthur, and get rid of the diary in one fell swoop
32:52 (Lily meets James after she is sorted) - In the books, this wouldn't even be possible, as the sorting is always alphabetical by surname. Lily Evans would be sorted BEFORE James Potter.
And James was already wearing Gryfinndor tie 🤦♂️
@@harolda611 yea and Sirius
*Ron uses imperius Curse*
me: What's this?! They gave a character's part to RON!!? This really is the end isn't it?
What's wrong with Ron getting the moment?
@@Ryan79345 he’s just taking the mickey on the movies for always taking away things from Ron.
@@Ryan79345 his point is that it ISN'T a bad thing, just unexpected.
And the Maurader's map thing! But they took away the free the house-elves moment... that made a lot more sense for the kiss
@@lorena-pereira because him saying it while impacful wouldn't have resonated as strong since hermione never went on her mission to free the house elfs I'm not saying I wouldn't have appreciated it but the movie made sence for the movie book for book
In the memory where Snape berates Harry he's also told by Dumbledore that "you see what you expect to see, Severus". I think it's an indication that Snape shared that memory as a way of apologising to Harry. He may not ever have liked Harry but he respected him enough to share all those memories when he really only needed to share the one about him being a Horcrux. It's so sad how they basically glossed over that chapter when it's one of the best (if not the best) in the entire series.
The reason why Crabbe was not in this was because his actor got fired after being arrested for possession of an illegal substance during the film's production.
In 2011, the actor was captured on CCTV during the London riots, holding a petrol bomb in his hand. He was also seen drinking a bottle of stolen champagne.
That explains why Blaise was given a more prominent role in the later films, especially the finale.
@@grahamdamberger7130 And also the name Blaise. I heard that was intentional.
Damn! 😳
@@DezarasPrime Blaise Zabini was an actual character in the book, a Slytherin in Harry's year. i think his biggest role was in HBP where he was invited to the Slug Club, and him returning to his train compartment after the first Slug Club meeting was how Harry managed to sneak in (under the Invisibility Cloak) & overhear his conversation with Malfoy, Crabbe, Goyle & Pansy.
If Warner Brothers decides to do a reboot of the Harry Potter series I think this man should be the director. The passion this guy has for HP content is unlike anything tbh.
My disappointment that this series has ended is immeasurable..
You sir are a man of culture
...and my day is ruined.
@@joshuaxd65 you beat me to it good sir
Finally! The finale to a great series of differences between the Harry Potter novels vs the Hermione Granger movies.
Lmaaoo
LMAO
💀💀💀💀
Lmfao!
You may think this was a small transition from Philosophers stone to DH ,but we can't deny that a lot happened between these two videos
“ he touched his hand to his forehead like he had so many times before. The scar had not pained him for nineteen years. All was well.”
That’s it, that’s where the story ends, there is definitely not something called Harry Potter and the Cursed Child aka the only book I ever did not enjoy reading …. :’)
What's the cursed child? Idk what that is. That sounds fake. It's not real.!!!
The cursed child is a good book why do people hate it
@@pavanmeka6226 it has incomprehensible storytelling, poor character development, and ruins the original story.
@@anonnyanonymous4800 Thankfully it's not officially by Rowling (though I know she did contribute) and I don't care if she says it's canon. I disagree completely. In my mind, that thing doesn't exist. Lol
It's just like the avatar the last airbender movie - they're both a book/a movie that must not be named because it doesn't exist, it's just a mandela effect (is what I tell myself)
28:52 There is something more to it in the book that I always liked.
Harry at this moment was at a low point with no hope with all the death that he have seen in the fight and he could not conjure a Patronus and even welcomed being consumed by the dementors when Ron and Hermione's Patronus faded away.
But When Luna, Ernie and Seamus helped them with their own, Luna said "That's right, Harry. come on think of something happy" to which he replied vainly "Something happy?" Then Luna said "We're all still here,we're still fighting. Come on, now"
A great moment for Luna as she always had this demeanour even in the darkest times, also a call back to Harry teaching D.A. the Patronus charm, and now his "students" are teaching him how to do it again.
When Hagrid was carrying a limp and supposedly lifeless body of Harry back to the school grounds, he looked shocked and scarred for life (in the film, though he did sob in the book). I'd say this feeling of helplessness and shock is even worse to watch than tears.
I always wondering why Hagrid was a prisoner like how and why did the death eaters catch him? And why not just kill himw
@@zbanul10To lure Harry in
People: How much dumb do you want Ron to be?
Movie directors: Yes.
How OP you want Hermione to be?
@@scaranvostok3637 yes
Ron had no chance against grrl power.
How badass do you want Voldemort?
@@gamerstheater1187 No
6:03 this is where the book has one of my favorite lines. Harry thinks to himself as Bill walks away that "he was on his way to becoming just as reckless a godfather to Teddy Lupin as Sirius had been to him."
Bro pls make a video on "Every moment stolen from Ron Weasley in the Movies"
As you have often mention that Ron in books is different from Ron in the movies, So pls explain us in detail
Btw keep up with good work and congrats on 1.5 m subscribers
He said a month ago on Twitter he’ll make a separate vid on Ron’s character soon………
@@scaranvostok3637 My personal opinion people saying Ron Weasley was done dirty in the movies.. for someone who has read the books.. I completely disagree when people say that.. now when people say Ginny Weasley was done dirty in the films I completely agree! But Ron Weasley in films in my opinion he doesn’t get enough credit and people say he doesn’t have enough stand out moments or his character to shine I completely disagree so while yes I would of added more to his character but I think the performance by Rupert Grint made up for that because he played Ron Weasley so incredibly well and was still a great loyal friend to Harry and Hermione and he was the glue to the Trio and kept them together! I didn’t mind the comedy their added to his character it wasn’t just butt of jokes like Finn from the Star Wars sequel trilogy.. Ron in movies was fine really good just not perfect but you could say same thing about Harry and Hermione you can nitpick anything from any character in these movies.. just my opinion compare to some other books to movie adaptation Harry Potter was done perfect and I don’t think the TV series is going to capture that magic! Just my opinion 😊
I genuinely love the “Tell then how it happened that night.” scene, it shows the unification of 3 of the houses and it just makes Snape’s redemption foreshadowed as you can see him deflect McGonnagels spells onto the two Death Eaters. I don’t know why I love that scene so much, I just do.
That is a truly great scene, visually and emotionally.
@@hiddenechoes I know right!
After watching HP movies for many many times, that scene still gives me goosebumps. Specially with Maggie Smith, thinking that she is sick irl while shooting the film but still able to give an outstanding performance.. And Alan Rickman too.. 💕💕
"to the basement!" makes me cringe though.
I’m pissed about how they did Ron and Hermione’s kiss dirty.
IN THE BOOK:
Ron- Guys we’re forgetting the house-elves. they can’t die for us!
Hermione-(I’m gonna kiss the daylights out of this man) *proceeds to snog him finally*
Harry- Srsly both of you hold it in, there’s a frickin’ war going on here!!!!
IN THE MOVIE:
Ron and Hermione kiss out of nowhere awkwardly
I think they did it like that bc they cut out spew so hermione had no regards for house elves and other magical creatures
Weren't the only couple who's kiss got done dirty. Harry and Ginny's kiss in HBP and DH were both ruined. Someone doesn't know how to do kiss scenes and can't retain the context/reason for the kisses.
nah the movie one was better imo
Well, as much as I love the book version more keep in mind that Ron and Hermione just destroyed a Horcrux at the Chamber of Secrets and they had to celebrate by victory kissing each other so nothing wrong about that. :)
The movie's treatment of Bellatrix and Voldemort's deaths have bugged me all these years. They were in fact regular human beings, and they died as such. Why the disintegration treatment? I can only imagine it was because they didn't want to show more dead bodies for any extension of time.
Maybe that would have got it a higher age rating per dead body or mature subject, so they didn't want to risk it? Though I'm sure they could have found a way around it anyway.
I mean it could also show after all the torture and killing they did, their souls were unstable and barely clinging on. The second they died everything holding them together just came apart
9:04 “In the novel the dragon did not kill anyone, but in the book it killed many people”… we know what you meant tho 😉
Awesome job with this series!! Hate this is the last video but I’m sure you are very relieved lol!
*9:04
Yes, also the part about the thestrals and house elfs joining the battle (at 47:15) - he accidentaly said that was in the movie and not in the book, while it in actuality was the other way around.
Pls explain me
I thought I was the only who noticed lol
The hug in the movie was improvised by Ralph (Voldemort) so the reaction from Tom (Malfoy) was genuine, he was legit creeped out
I would be too ngl 😂
The fact that they made Snape's and McGonagall's duel in the movie as it should've been Voldemort and Harry's duel in the book always pissed me off.
Yes.The fight between Harry and Voldemort in the movie is so boring.
I do understand why they would change Harry and Voldemort's fight, audiences might have not likes seeing how it was in the book
In the movie it looked like they were dancing and snogging or something. And since when would Voldemort the fuckin Pureblood dictator supremacist fight like a dirty muggle??!
@@user-tsukiko2023 What bothered me the most, however, was the fact that the movie hints that when Neville kills Nagini, Voldemort dies almost immediately after because all of his horcruxes have been destroyed. When in the book it's not enough to destroy the horcruxes, but also Voldemort's own body. That's why in the book Voldemort kept dueling even after Nagini was dead.
@@dannyjorde2677 I don’t think so. Voldemort was still fighting strong after Nagini died. It was still the same as in the books, meaning the killing curse rebounded because Harry was the master of the Elder Wand.
Now, I'm actually fine with Harry and Voldemort's duel in the movie as I thought it added more tension. But I would've changed one little thing. Instead of landing in the courtyard like in the film, they instead crash into the Great Hall. They would then have their conversation just like in the book and it would pretty much end the same way.
What bothered me the most, however, was the fact that the movie hints that when Neville kills Nagini, Voldemort dies almost immediately after because all of his horcruxes have been destroyed. When in the book it's not enough to destroy the horcruxes, but also Voldemort's own body. That's why in the book Voldemort kept dueling even after Nagini was dead.
Your statement confuses me... Voldemort DOES continue dueling after Neville kills Nagini in the movie. He fires another killing curse at Harry after sensing that his last horcrux has been destroyed.
What bothers me is that they dueled in an empty courtyard instead of everyone in the battle. No one actually SEES Voldemort die...
@@nahor88 Lol you can barely call that "dueling". Voldemort dies almost instantly after Neville kills Nagini. In fact, if you look closely, Voldemort's arm begins to wither even before Harry gets to disarm him. The movie hints that when you destroy all the Horcruxes, Voldemort dies. And that's not how it works.
@@dannyjorde2677 I actually prefer it the way the movie did it. The whole point is that he has carved up his soul to make the horcruxes. His original body died when he failed to kill Harry the first time, so the only thing that would be sustaining him are the horcruxes at this point. Right?
The speech in the book is great. And I was disappointed it never made it to the film. But I still prefer the change.
@@intergalactic92 but there was still a piece of soul inside him, he needed to have a killing curse thrown at him to fully be destroyed, like how it was in the book
@@intergalactic92 You prefer it because you didn't understand how it worked in the book. You're wrong when you say that Voldemort lost his soul when he failed to kill Harry. That's not true, he SPLITED his soul once more when he did that, one part of his soul was attached to Harry, and Voldemort kept the other part. No one can live without at least a bit of soul inside them. That's why the movies messed it up, it's not enough to destroy the Horcruxes.
One of my favourite scenes is when Harry tells Dumbledore's Army he needs to go search for the diadem in the Ravenclaw common room, and Cho offers herself to be the one leading Harry, but then Ginny quickly stands up and says "LUNA CAN GO WITH HIM"
Ah yes the grand finale to the book and movie differences, thanks movie flame for bringing us up to speed about the differences we know the videos were hard to make and it wasn't easy
You didn't mention that in the book slughorn and Charlie weasley showed up with reinforcements. With what looked like friends and family of all those who stayed to fight along with hogsmeade residents.
When Harry snapped the wand, a few people including myself in the theater were in a bit of an uproar. The rest of the audience was looking at us confused. The few of us cornered each other outside and talked about it. Easiest way to tell who read the books. We just wanted him to fix his wand dammit. lol
It shows how many less people read the books
It’s implied that he did
@@CorporealNatural1 Or only a vocal minority of book readers were hot and bothered enough to make a stink
@@calebalwayswill7423 Yeah, I mean it’s annoying, but there’s no sense in making noise and disturbing others from watching because he didn’t do what you expected
@@CorporealNatural1 Yeah,the keypoint and foreshadowing given in the books were not there in the movies, Majority of it.
They changed Crab dying to Goyle dying from book to film because the actor who played Crab got in trouble with the law relating to Marijuana charges, so he had been cut from the films.
And they wanted someone to die who was part of Malfoy's "gang" so the only one left to use in the film was Goyle, since he was there since the first film, so the viewers grew to dislike him more.
One difference you didn't mention was that when Griphook asked for the sword, in the book they decided that their way round it would be to agree to let him have it but be careful to avoid saying exactly WHEN he could, whereas in the film Harry simply says 'I'm still working on that part'
It's the same as in HBP, where Harry makes the accusation against Draco. When asked to present evidence, in the movie he just says he knows, but in the book he explains all the facts that supports his theory. Another example of lazy writing.
It always bugged me that Ginny still went back to school (in the movie) despite how dangerous it was
"You have your mother's eyes"
Danial: blue eyes
Susie: brown eyes
He literally says this in the first 5 minutes of the video
@@CYBER_N0T I know that’s what I referenced
Interesting thing: although they didn't include the fact that the items in the vault also had the flagrante curse (that burns you), they did show them rubbing something on their hands after they get out of the water; which is supposed to be Essence of Dittany to help with the burns.
45:34 In the screenplay he did say something similar that he abandoned them and begged for death to which Ron replied "Liar" akin to "He beat you" from the book. But interestingly Ralph Fiennes did a fair share of improvising doing this scene resulting in the iconic laugh he made and the awkward Draco hug.
Also in the screenplay when Draco joined the death eaters, Ron shouted at him that Harry saved his life, which made his hesitant for a moment to walk to the other side. It didn't make it into the film and wasn't in the book for that matter, but it was an interesting thing to see.
I wonder why it was cut
I love the scene where Minerva is ordering Neville and Seamus to blow the bridge. Even though it's not in the book, the movies running joke of Mr. Finnigan blowing everything up is sooo damn good. 😂
22:56 Agreed, but the damage was already done and the filmmakers are trying their best the establish them as quickly as possible. Same with a deleted scene of the students marching towards the great hall and Harry is rushing through them to hold her hand.
But good thing that Harry's shoe laces were tight during all the action that happened during that day :"D
😂😂😀
Harry: Exists
Snape: “NO MEASURABLE TALENT AND HE SEEMS TO RELISH HIS FAME!!”
I think that we should all take a moment to appreciate the amount of time you have taken to create this series. The shear amount of time patience you had to create this is amazing. I’ve enjoyed watching this series and it even encouraged me to rewatch the films 🎥 and I am currently on Order of the Phoenix. Thank you so much for this it’s been great and I honestly love your video theories so it was an honour and privilege to subscribe to your Chanel. Keep calm and carry on being the amazingly Talented and powerful wizard you are. Xx
Morgan: “Fred dies off scene which is something I’ll never forgive the filmmakers for.”
Me, to no one: “THANK YOU! I HAVE FELT THE SAME WAY FOR YEARS!!!!”😂😂
The movies dishonered Fred by not showing his death
Plus the fact that he died laughing at Percy's joke was so touching. Died doing what he loved, with the brother he finally reconciled with.
After watching all these videos on the differences of the movies from the books I would love to see 100% re-creation of the books to see what it would look like but of course nowadays companies aren't good at making remakes and such so I honestly it's best to just leave this gem how it is
I’m seriously in love with these thumbnails of the book vs movie differences videos.
You really did something here: A very high-quality, short video series that's as timeless as the HP franchise itself. Congrats! I loved all of them so much!
51:23
Ginny: He will be alright
Harry: I know he will
J.K. Rowling: Little did you know :"D
There is no Cursed Child in Ba Sing Se
That’s one brainwashing I would take gladly
We don't acknowledge that none canon fan fiction here
Ah ja ze video game however DHv part 2 added that science instead
@@julial4569 here we are safe, here we are free
I can’t believe in the scene where Lily is killed they changed the clothes she was wearing in the original scene from the first film and they put the two scenes side by side in film 8, did voldy swap her clothing after he killed her? Lol
Hope you can do this type of videos with the Hunger Games series and Percy Jackson. That will be amazing, although a bit complicated.
Harry not being naked in Deathly Hallows Part 2 was obvious so it didn’t get an R Rating. Also love how Ralph Fiennes threw in the awkward hug just for the hell of it. BTW, WHY DIDN’T YOU INCLUDE VOLDY’S STUPID LAUGH!?!?!? xD
The drinking game is back
Thank you for your effort, i think everyone really appreciates it.
And it was very well put together.
Much love from Germany
Luckily not a lot of shots in this one :D
Thank you so much for this immense project! You've done the entire franchise a great service for years to come.
9:04-9:08 Had me do a double take. You said that in the "novel" the dragon didn't kill anyone, then you said that in the "book" he killed a lot.
Anyway, just a nitpick, great work on this series. :)
7:35 film movie
9:04 novel book
46:12 film film
After watching all these videos, I always thought of the unpopular opinion I had when talking about this franchise, which are:
1. I like that Harry destroyed the Elder Wand in the Movie than what happened to it in the book, as I thought that was a better idea with the whole thing of not getting anyone else the chance to have the wand and be powerful.
2. I don't like the idea that Harry became an auror, as I thought he was going to be a teacher instead after reading the 5th book. it would make sense with the idea of him not wanting power and instead taking a teaching life to have a calmer life, as well as the idea that Hogwarts was his home, and working there would make sense for wanting to take that position.
3. I actually wanted Harry to keep Fawkes after Dumbledore died. It had a perfect opportunity as Hedwig died in the 7th book, and having Fawkes help Harry would be a nice callback to the times that Fawkes helped him over the years. It could have also lead to some unique magic with Harry's wand as the wand was made out of Fawkes feathers, and would have been nice to see what could have been done with the two working together like Dumbledore before him.
Fully agree with you, but the 1. one imo is just a (minor) pothole/bad writing, considering Harry's character. Simply breaking it, especially after knowing that only the Elder Wand itself could repair a broken wand would be so easy and logical. Unless Deathly Hallows are similarly/stronger "protected" as Horcruxes are ofc, the Resurrection Stone works fine even after the Gaunt Ring as a Horcrux was destroyed after all. Harry should've at least tried though....
@@matt_9112 yep. In the book he uses the elderly wand to repair his own wand. He then buries the elderly wand with Dumbledore.
@Uchiha Sasuke yeah I know, that's what makes it worse kinda (also shouldn't Harry be kinda tired of fighting?)
You completely forgot before snape dies in the movie, he tries manipulating Voldemort into thinking the elder wand obeys him, but in the book he begs Voldemort desperately to bring Harry Potter to him (but really he wanted to reveal everything that was in his memories) and started getting panicky and impatient when Voldemort didn’t let him do this
Pretty much every comment is about the effort put into these videos and that's how you know that this channel is gold.
I love the addition of Voldemort letting Neville speak. You can see how infuriated Voldemort was when Neville ask him to say something. He tried to supress his anger and eventually let him, because the no - nosed bastard was happy that he killed Harry and said, "I'll let it slide".
This has been an amazing series! I'm a bit sad to see it end. It would be cool if you made another video combining the Part 1 and Part 2 videos of The Deathly Hallows into one complete video, for the full Deathly Hallows experience.
I haven’t watched the films in like months. Sad to see the series gone, it really was my replacement for the films lol, but i did wish if you talked about your opinion in the book more, but other than that (and some disagreements) this series is really fantastic. Morgan, you always were my favorite HP youtuber really, like your entire work is not matched at all really, i can’t imagine the dedication you took to make these vids, you’re probably never even going to see it really, but if you do, thank you 🙏.
The amount of dedication and hardwork you've put is something I can't even fathom to imagine.
Brilliant job, mate!
I'm watching this while having pizza.
A big fan of yours!
This series was epic, it felt like being in hogwarts and also reading all the 7 books. Morgan sir , you have put a lot of effort and it will pay off.
“But there’s a lot more that happened between these 2 scenes” and “this was made just for the film” was also amazing 🤩
10:27 Exactly. Also Harry at this point didn't know anything about the ghost of Ravenclaw or even her alias the grey lady as she was always shy, it wasn't until he asked Sir Nicholas at Hogwarts or when Luna suggested in the films.
One thing I think was a missed opertunity was, when harry and ginny kissed in the movie, she says "I know" but I think she should have said " good luck". It would have been a good form of symbolism, as that was the first thing she ever said to him.
Did Voldemort slap him really fast or was that an error?
I have to say this series was BRILLIANT! AND, I can't even imagine the amount of time and effort and hard WORK it took for you to accomplish this and do such a great job. Thank you so much for this wonderful gift you've given us. xo
Not me squealing for joy because I refreshed and found this 9 minutes after it uploaded 😭😭
Morgan’s dedication to this series shows when u notice that the pattern on the cover goes from the movie Harry on the left and the book Harry on the right and then book Harry on the left and movie Harry on the right and so on
You lucky Americans! You have the borgin and burks scene, the scene with Lockheart’s favourite colour being lilac and the scene of Ron with the skeleton of the Basilisk. I’ve seen the prop of the skeleton in the London studios and always wondered where it was from😄
Fun fact:
I know one of the people who were Emma Watson's acting doubles for the Deathly Hallows films. She was in charge of the Musical Theatre group I went to. During my last week there, I asked her if she knew at what points she appeared in the films, and she said the widescreen shot of the kiss in the Chamber with Ron was her, as well as a scene in Part 1 where she goes down to a river, and she says she knows it was her because she absolutely hated filming that scene so was very pleased it had made it into the final cut
I can't believe it is over. This series was a milestone in your channel, congrats !
Let's show Morgan some love🙌🏾 the amount of time and dedication into making these videos is awesome.
Now to the video, I think the film makers messed up with some scenes in the movie like Hermione(as Bellatrix) still using her voice, Cho, Luna, Dean and Ginny being at Hogwarts when the trio arrived, cutting out the invisibility cloth again and some good moments and giving us an average Prince's Tale.
Also, the battles in the book was better, don't let anyone tell you otherwise. And let me also add that the movie addition dragon killing Gringotts workers and the bridge blowing up were good
w'ere all talking about Morgan saying "A lot happens between these two scenes" which is hilarious, but what about "the book a film meet up again" he says that a lot lol
what bothered me the most is the fact that we cannot seen the epic scene students family, hogsmead pub's owner, and others citizen led by charlie weasley and slughorn join the fight. we cannot seen gwarp vs 2 giants. we cannot seen centaurs decided join the battle after seeing harry died. we cannot seen kreacher led goblins of hogwart join the battle with knife. and the last, standing applause from all the headmaster of hogwarts and dumbledore cried overjoy in headmaster room. well, i hope someday, HP get series so these detail can be filming. sorry for my bad grammar
For everything they changed, they really did put so much effort into making this adaptation faithful.
But it has a lot of adaptations problems. F*ck Yates and Kloves.
@@scaranvostok3637 I'll never forgive the butchering of Ginny.
@@bessieburnet9816 Hold my Ron too.
The worst parts of every movie are ALWAYS things the screen writers/director chose to put in themselves rather than stay true to the book.
Final battle with Voldemort, the teen cringe in HBP, GOF - pretty much the entire thing, and all the pseudo-romance between Harry and Hermione. They also chose to leave things out that were critical to the story. I get that they're long books, and stuff needs to be left out, but they really had to cut and change the pensive scenes? They had to make Dumbledore angry and miserable?
It was just lazy screen writing. They knew they would get away with it because HP fans would be loyal to the series and people would still watch because they were already invested from the films prior.
Sorry, I have to disagree. These films...especially the Deathly Hallow ones were more "inspired by" than faithful to the original books. They left plot holes the size of train tunnels because of the shortcuts they took.
Ginny’s scream for Harry rips me apart every time. I love the two of them.
I feel sorry for those who didn't read the books. They only know half the story and won't ever really fully understand the magic of Harry Potter's Story.
I love both the books and movies. I love the books more but all 8 movies are great too
Who's idea was it to have Voldemort give Draco that painfully awkward hug at the end there? 🤭🤣🤣
This was an amazing series. It was especially helpful to me since I read all seven books through the year and finished watching the film series, so this did a great job pointing out all the differences.
I'm so glad the filmmakers added Snape telling Harry about his mother's eyes.
Edit: I actually think Snape's death was done much better in the movie.
Tbf, Snape's last words in the book were "Look at me" heavily implying that he wanted to see Lily's eyes through Harry, as his final moment. In the movie, it's the same idea but they just made it way more direct.
These videos help with my anxiety more than you will ever know. Any time I'm struggling, this is my comfort, it always helps
So if Voldemort hadn't taken Harry's blood, he wouldn't have been able to harm him in Book 4, but having done so, he made it so Harry's protection endured. Bad luck Voldemort.