Its not intellectual arrogance. Its simple common sense. When 10 lakhs crores of loans/tax are written off for corporates, why dont you call it freebies ?
Tax waived off.. npa written off. Though written off, and not waived off, the money will not come back. Tax waived is around 4 lakh crores. We know ehst we talk. Just shutup man
@@krishvishal oh really! How much of written off is collected back ....Do you know when write off takes place what percentage of the Sum actually given to corporates are collected back?
Free Toilets in north and Free laptops for students in TN. THIS IS THE DIFFERENCE. It will take another 10 - 15 years for few states to reach Tamil Nadu's development
No 50 years may be after 2 generations. People beleive in divisive politics cannot grow. Kerala tamil nadu politics not based on religion language or race.
PTR is hundred times in brilliance and in performance than Modi and Sitaraman... Excellent speach by TN finance minister. A well educated and well known economist. We need leaders like him to counter false narratives. Indian leaders become arrogant. The power centers enjoy every thing free for life time. From air to airplanes. What about the poor.
@@iaf010 What is your problem in giving to the poor. How many thousands of children especially girls studied because of giving bicycles, laptops, school kit, school food etc.. Your leaders are lifelong enjoying with ordinary peoples money. From hair pin to personal airplanes with public money. Everything free... their food , servants, vechiles, fuels, gas any thing and everything . Do they pay for anything... Giving to the poor, what is your ego... That also people like you want to eat🙄🙄🙄🙄. Very sad. How many millions are living with out food, shelters, health care, with out any human rights and basic fecilities in my country country.
@@thambinelloore7795 I dont work hard and study to give to other people so they can live in the comfort of poverty. My family.also came from poverty - NOBODY paid for them, they didnt get preasure cookers, laptops, or mixer grinders or even free electricity. Why should these poor people get all these free things ?? They don't deserve them and its not MY job to provide these Parasites with even 1 extra paisa. Their lives or welfare has nothing to do with my life. Their prosperity or comfort is their Karma and their responsibility not mine.
If every state speaks in your manner,each of you talk highly of TN.I have visited TN,i see not much change.Most of your younger man are all outside the country in foreign lands working.Why no jobs in TN.
@@indirakrishnan4496 Thats the point. Its all about per hour earning. If they can find someone cheaper to do manual labour and earn more then its a smart move. Pure economics. Thats what free education has done to TN economy.
@@indirakrishnan4496 exactlyyyy !!! We TN PPL are working in abroad, because we are educated no matter what our social background is, no matter what our income is ... On other hand , we could see most of the North Indians in TN or other south states struggling for daily wages... That's a BIG difference, if you could understand... This is the difference between TN and north states... And as our FM said union govt or you should raise your standard or calibre before questioning us
PTR was right. These are the same idiots who said 2000 Rs bill has chips to track. Who will bring Black Money, where are the 2000 Rs Bills. The stopped printing from 2019.
Really. I was surprised when finally TN argues that it is legislature that decides and court has no says shows that they really don't have a case. Why do we need courts and police then in TN.
@@jotendrakumar2852 He didn't make a blanket statement. This is for the freebies argument. The govt got elected for this manifesto. It's not upto the courts to decide on where the govt gets to spend its money. They don't have jurisdiction to do so
@@jotendrakumar2852 did he speak generally? He was specific. U make no sense and speak nonsense. U have right to speak, pls use it to show other how stupid u r.. Now, please go feed mithai and celebrate release of 11 gang rapists...
Iam from chennai my income is less all i have in my life was my uncle at one day he got cardiac arrest and i addmitted him at hospital and diagnosed he has 3 blocks and the treatment would take more than 3 lakhs...which is a very huge money for me and made me feel broken.. Thn i came to know Kalaingar welfare scheme who saved us like a timely Angeles ❤️... Now tell me are they Freebies or Welfare???
They should provide these treatments in Government Hospitals itself..... When government paying money to private hospitals for their quality of treatment, then what is the need of government hospitals..... They should enhance quality of government hospitals.....
@@chandu7898 how asking counter questions helps you prove your point? Does not matter how much he pays to his maid … are you making any sense of what he is telling about the freebies culture and it’s harmful effects on the state/s??
मैंने तमिलनाडु फाइनेंस मिनिस्टर क्वालिफिकेशन और वर्क एक्सपीरियंस के बारे में जाना,,, मैं तो कहूंगा किस्मत वाला है तमिलनाड ऐसा फाइनेंस मिनिस्टर मिला है! from बिहार
A request to all South Indians. Whatever happens, never let BJP win in your States. We North Indians are paying the price, you better learn from our mistakes instead of committing one.
திரு .பழனிவேல் ராஜன் மிக பெரிய அறிவாளி என்பதில் எந்த மாற்றமும் இல்லை . மக்களுக்காக உழைக்கின்ற பாரம்பரிய குடும்பத்தில் பிறந்தவர் . குறிப்பாக பொருளாதாரத்தில் மிக தெளிந்தவர் . அவர் எங்கள் மாநிலத்தின் நிதியமைச்சர் என்பதில் பெருமை கொள்கிறோம் .
I don't know why termed him arrogance, bcz u don't have any answer to his question, can u call Federal FM arrogant, when she start to reply in arrogance, then why the slave godi media showing difference between TN FM and Federal FM. First u medias come out of the slavery.
The. TN Finance Minister Mr PTR views were brilliant he was extremely well prepared for the debate his opponents in the debate failed miserably to convey any worthwhile counter arguments his views were not arrogant - Lt Col Retd PS Gill Asr Pb
But our FM Nirmala Tai is best. When asked about price inflation of onions she replied, "I don't eat a lot of Onions".. can PTR sir give such intellectual answers?
India's present finance minister is acting like a school teacher lecturing others.... She should resign and we need one like Mr PTR as Finance minister
@@yagerone369 Your words for a pm of a country shows your education and pm is much more educated then you by mindset, knowledge, experience and your so called degree
@@bibhabsaha3251 hahaha.. pm is educated.. u can be stand up comedian... PM is a liar, period. Yes, i see the news about Gujrat model all the drugs, here alcohol is banned but only alcohol whereas poisonous alcohol is allowed, UP development is booming just like the the Bundelkhand expressway which never got damaged 7 days after inauguration. U speak about Karnataka, i guess u meant Bengaluru which is built from scratch by BJP. Also Janta party and INC never governed Karnataka. It's always BJP from beginning of Big bang, that has governed Karnataka..
The government under cm M K Stalin and his team is functioning marvelously in Tamil Nadu and they are expert specially in social engineering, best candidate for the PM of India
Dr.PTR explained very well. He is doing good job and as a finance minister he have right. BJP spoke person could not answer not even single question of Dr.PTR. Sorry, You can't win with him facts
Really. I was surprised when finally TN argues that it is legislature that decides and court has no says shows that they really don't have a case. Why do we need courts and police then in TN.
@@jotendrakumar2852 foolish .he says PPL elect and the state ministry decides to allocate fund what is good for PPL.we tamils don't complain.what is the problem with centre.
@@jotendrakumar2852 please try to understand that Constitution is the backbone of Democracy. As per constitution people choose who has to rule the country through election. And the leaders have power to run the country by following set of rules and regulations. If some government is not following constitution or rules, then court decide who is right and who is wrong. What Dr.PRT says is people given power to us. As per constitution, we can manage our own finance. We are managing our economy better than Union government in all aspects. Then why are you giving advise to us when you were doing very bad at it. Got it dear?
The beauty is when northern states are fighting against BJP from their dominance, here our Tamilan and Chetan are fighting with themselves on who defeated the BJP to the core 😜
I think Dr Palanivel Thyagarajan Tamil Nadu Finance Minister who is well educated leader and has good caliber explained the fact very well. He was right because in our country everyone has the right to take their own decisions and question the central government as well as state government. If someone shows their dissent towards prime minister and the central government and other state government is not crime. Dissent is essential for democracy. I think our honourable Prime Minister should respect the dissent and stop blaming the state governments who questions you and your government. We should respect the democracy.
Really. I was surprised when finally TN argues that it is legislature that decides and court has no says shows that they really don't have a case. Why do we need courts and police then in TN.
@@jotendrakumar2852 Courts and judges are not gods to determine and take decision on everything, they all come under constitution. And the same constitution give rights to the people elected person to act as he like .Court is not in top only people is & they will take decision at final
Ask union fm to answer it all. She is nothing in front of Dr PTR. Apart from this every one shd understand that PTR family legacy is very rich when compared to any politicians in India. Lord Ayyappan statu at Sabarimala was provided by his family. He is from such a dignitary family.
TN's per capita income is more than double the national average, and inflation is lower by 2.5%; the fiscal deficit of TN is 3.5%, while the union govt has 7%. Why do you assume somebody can tell me how to do my job better? The people will decide that -
@@Devgopal2024 உனக்கு அவ்வளவு தெயிரிம் இருக்குல நீதான் கேட்டுப்பாரேன் நீயே சொல்லு நிதி பற்றாக்குறை 3.5% , தேசிய நிதி பற்றாக்குறை 7% என்று சொல்லுராறு , நீங்க என்ன சொல்லவரீங்க, நான் +2 பாஸ், நீங்க mba பெயிலா?
This news channel and the moderator got insulted to the core by FM of TN. Now they called four to cry.... TN is performing and PM is just a gross failure.
Arrogance, my foot, BJP spokesperson should have answered what PTR questioned. It's BJP which. is always arrogant & sarcastic. Finance minister is a great example of arrogance & sarcasm when she said that she doesn't consume onions. Your track record is only destruction of the nation with schemes like demonitisation which you don't talk about.
PTR nailed it.... wish every Opposition ruled state should have minster like this to tear the real face BJP govt, kudos to PTR!! he rocked!! show your track record from any one state which they rule ha ha ha lol... wish 1:1 with PTR & Nirmala Sitaraman on these topics...
When Nirmala said "I don't eat Onions so I don't know about it's shortage". It's not arrogance? But asking why government is pressurizing is arrogance? GODI MEDIA stop your madness..
If DMK rules india just for next 10years then see the difference. Our unfortunate that DMK is not a national party, but we are fortunate that we live in TN under DMK government.
Other form of Freebies are Pension, DA of Govt Employees, Luxury plane of PM, Luxury cars of central ministers, discounted rate in Govt canteens, discounted food in MLA hostel, in PArlianment, free Train AC coach for MPs, Crores of pensions for the MLAs and MPS who is not in power and so on......., why not free rice for poors????? . If you don't have PHD no problem, but have some brain like PTR
Tamil Nadu is in the level to compete with the developed countries, not with other states of India. Dear BJPians, please develop your states and then advise us.
தமிழ்நாட்டில் கொடுக்ககூடிய இலவசங்கள் வடமானிகள் ஏன் கொடுப்பதில்லை என்று இப்போது வடமாநில மக்கள் பேச தொடங்கினார் இனி மத அரசியல் செய்வது கடினம் அதற்காக இந்த புதிய சட்டம்
DMK part of govt at the Center during Dr Manmohan singh was prime minister, His govt image was spoiled by DMK minister like Raja & Kanimozi both they were in Jail still they are on Bail. This is TN intectual political party spoiled the congress prospect & will never come to power in Center for 2 decade …..
Rahul.. if I said that in 1985 I had digital camera ,.. what would you call me ? liar or truthful person.. if I said .. sab ko 15 lakh aayega.. what would you call me , if I said I send drones to check the working of govt officer .. what would you call me .. now the greater question is do you have courage to call modi a liar or a fool ?
Please arrange a debate between PTR and FM Nirmala sitharaman . All citizens will understand the financial state of our country, when this meeting happens.
You first learn the meaning of arrogance.This is not arrogance,this is called intellect.Good reply PTR Sir,proud to be Tamilan.India needs more educated and intellectual people like you sir.
Its not intellectual arrogance. Its simple common sense. When 10 lakhs crores of loans/tax are written off for corporates, why dont you call it freebies ?
Do you know difference between Written off and Waived off?
@@krishvishal does the difference will bring back the money?
Tax waived off.. npa written off. Though written off, and not waived off, the money will not come back. Tax waived is around 4 lakh crores. We know ehst we talk. Just shutup man
@@krishvishal oh really! How much of written off is collected back ....Do you know when write off takes place what percentage of the Sum actually given to corporates are collected back?
@@krishvishal is there any? If it's legally done, it's waive off or else, it's write off.
I am from Jharkhand, I liked Dr. PTR's so called arrogance. We need more such educated ministers. Whole TN must be proud of him
Thank you so much dear
We are sir
100% sir....
Thank u
Yesss WE areeeee
Free Toilets in north and Free laptops for students in TN. THIS IS THE DIFFERENCE. It will take another 10 - 15 years for few states to reach Tamil Nadu's development
Rightly said,,👍
No 50 years may be after 2 generations.
People beleive in divisive politics cannot grow. Kerala tamil nadu politics not based on religion language or race.
@@karthickdevaraj8467 2 generations is 40 yrs!
As a north Indian now i become huge fan of PTR Thiagrajan
Not even a single negative comments against PTR among 1.7k . Huge respect.
The finance minister of TN is more intelligent than 4 of them combined.
Sorry not only 4 of them...better than all bjp leaders
Yes.....
@@mangalrajan5146 100% agreed bro
@@bulishfx yes..👍
@@mangalrajan5146 so trueee
Such a shameless BJP... Can't even answer the question asked and blabbering something else...
When they are wrong, how will they open their asshole mouth ?
We respect you comments sir ..Non if the bjp people is not having much sense like him. 🙏🙏🙏
Bjp is simply like wet crackers. 😀😀😀
Yes.shame
Dei nee yenna athi buthisaliya ptr mathiri pooda nee ore muttal avvan ore muttal
PTR is hundred times in brilliance and in performance than Modi and Sitaraman...
Excellent speach by TN finance minister. A well educated and well known economist. We need leaders like him to counter false narratives.
Indian leaders become arrogant.
The power centers enjoy every thing free for life time. From air to airplanes.
What about the poor.
Idiotic speech by a party that can only win by distributing pressure cookers and grinders
@@iaf010
What is your problem in giving to the poor. How many thousands of children especially girls studied because of giving bicycles, laptops, school kit, school food etc..
Your leaders are lifelong enjoying with ordinary peoples money. From hair pin to personal airplanes with public money. Everything free... their food , servants, vechiles, fuels, gas any thing and everything . Do they pay for anything... Giving to the poor, what is your ego... That also people like you want to eat🙄🙄🙄🙄. Very sad.
How many millions are living with out food, shelters, health care, with out any human rights and basic fecilities in my country country.
@@thambinelloore7795 I dont work hard and study to give to other people so they can live in the comfort of poverty.
My family.also came from poverty - NOBODY paid for them, they didnt get preasure cookers, laptops, or mixer grinders or even free electricity. Why should these poor people get all these free things ?? They don't deserve them and its not MY job to provide these Parasites with even 1 extra paisa. Their lives or welfare has nothing to do with my life. Their prosperity or comfort is their Karma and their responsibility not mine.
@@iaf010 fake id talks abt brainless party
@@iaf010 SHould tell those BIKSA collectors in the name of YAGNA for several thousands of years.
As a indian, we encourage such arrogance thoughts against the failure of union government
Shabaash PTR.
Great respect to Tamil Nadu Finance Minister for the outstanding articulated of finances and its government policies. 👍
TN has performed better than the Central government in every metric so, BJP and their government should stop giving advice to other people.
If every state speaks in your manner,each of you talk highly of TN.I have visited TN,i see not much change.Most of your younger man are all outside the country in foreign lands working.Why no jobs in TN.
@@indirakrishnan4496 no jobs in TN🤣...Your a fool for sure...
@@indirakrishnan4496 Thats the point. Its all about per hour earning. If they can find someone cheaper to do manual labour and earn more then its a smart move. Pure economics. Thats what free education has done to TN economy.
@@indirakrishnan4496 Most north indian youngster working in tamil nadu, so our youngster working abroad in It sector.
@@indirakrishnan4496 exactlyyyy !!! We TN PPL are working in abroad, because we are educated no matter what our social background is, no matter what our income is ... On other hand , we could see most of the North Indians in TN or other south states struggling for daily wages... That's a BIG difference, if you could understand... This is the difference between TN and north states... And as our FM said union govt or you should raise your standard or calibre before questioning us
PTR was right. These are the same idiots who said 2000 Rs bill has chips to track. Who will bring Black Money, where are the 2000 Rs Bills. The stopped printing from 2019.
Really. I was surprised when finally TN argues that it is legislature that decides and court has no says shows that they really don't have a case. Why do we need courts and police then in TN.
@@jotendrakumar2852 policies / legislation r decided by elected party. Court is ensure compliance on d same.
@@jotendrakumar2852 He didn't make a blanket statement. This is for the freebies argument. The govt got elected for this manifesto. It's not upto the courts to decide on where the govt gets to spend its money. They don't have jurisdiction to do so
@@jotendrakumar2852 If courts decide policy, why do you need Legislature?
@@jotendrakumar2852 did he speak generally? He was specific. U make no sense and speak nonsense. U have right to speak, pls use it to show other how stupid u r..
Now, please go feed mithai and celebrate release of 11 gang rapists...
Iam from chennai my income is less all i have in my life was my uncle at one day he got cardiac arrest and i addmitted him at hospital and diagnosed he has 3 blocks and the treatment would take more than 3 lakhs...which is a very huge money for me and made me feel broken.. Thn i came to know Kalaingar welfare scheme who saved us like a timely Angeles ❤️... Now tell me are they Freebies or Welfare???
💐💐💐
Dr. Kalaingar is the grace of TN
They should provide these treatments in Government Hospitals itself..... When government paying money to private hospitals for their quality of treatment, then what is the need of government hospitals..... They should enhance quality of government hospitals.....
They can't understand what's freebie . They're way backward than TN
They should increase the standard for the medical facilities in govt hospital...not give the money for you to give it to the private hospitals!
That's not arrogance..That's Intellectual power.
No ' Cloud theory ' no ' Gutter gas theory ' just straight to the point talk.
Hats of to you Dr PTR.
That's not arrogance.. It's logic by Expert person. Should not decide by a person whose education is less than 7th class.
That's not arrogance
It's called Self respect !
Well said👏👏👏
Who the hell is saying arrogant he doesn't know how to accept lost face
Yes arrogant is what shown by duo on power...one day you will pay for everything...god is there ... bookmark it
Ptr is a clown
@@Black-ti5bs don't be stupid our whole world will know that who's PTR
Not arrogance but boldness to speak out the fact , naked truth. I dream the day Dr. Thyagarajan becoming India's finance minister 👍
👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👌👌👌
.P.M.Modi does not know about Indian economy.He knows only Adhani and Ambani economy.
That day must come soon to tinker the economy of India severely damaged by BJP govt
Vengalidum 🤷
he should become pm of india.
Respect doubled for PTR Sir. Tamilnadu is Land of Intelligents and Hard working people. PTR Sir is a clear example..
Intelligent or over intelligent
@@sathya36 ur name indicates u r over intelligent lol..
@Krishnamurthy N how much you are paying for maid servant per month?
Land of tasmac addicts people from North capturing industrial districts. We know what we see on the ground.
@@chandu7898 how asking counter questions helps you prove your point? Does not matter how much he pays to his maid … are you making any sense of what he is telling about the freebies culture and it’s harmful effects on the state/s??
Jai PTR sir love from Karnataka..
मैंने तमिलनाडु फाइनेंस मिनिस्टर क्वालिफिकेशन और वर्क एक्सपीरियंस के बारे में जाना,,, मैं तो कहूंगा किस्मत वाला है तमिलनाड ऐसा फाइनेंस मिनिस्टर मिला है!
from बिहार
A request to all South Indians.
Whatever happens, never let BJP win in your States.
We North Indians are paying the price, you better learn from our mistakes instead of committing one.
Zero MP for BJP in loksabha and Rajyasabha from Tamilnadu, that's Tamilnadu
@@rajabs6185 yes.. This time also it wll b 0
Yes for sure we will do it. But please you people stop voting for this legally corrupt govt(electrol bonds) . We also suffer not only you.
We never do such stupidity
In fact we don't even need this advice, b'cas we are very well aware of it.. 😃
BJP needs to be educated in almost everything by TN. That is the current status. Full stop.
Really. I was surprised when finally TN argues that it is legislature that decides and court has no says shows that they really don't have a case.
@@jotendrakumar2852 u r surprised?? No wonder in it 😂😂😂😂
They certainly are and the gap of copying is just 25 years and do it when no one is watching!!
Yes!
@@jotendrakumar2852 Modi is a person who sells the country and eating shi**
PTR is a genius. Fools cant understand him. He is the treasure of TN. We love him.
How dare you call it arrogance? He speaks facts which was perhaps unquestioned earlier because of sheer incompetence .
திரு .பழனிவேல் ராஜன்
மிக பெரிய அறிவாளி என்பதில்
எந்த மாற்றமும் இல்லை .
மக்களுக்காக உழைக்கின்ற
பாரம்பரிய குடும்பத்தில் பிறந்தவர் .
குறிப்பாக பொருளாதாரத்தில்
மிக தெளிந்தவர் .
அவர் எங்கள் மாநிலத்தின்
நிதியமைச்சர் என்பதில்
பெருமை கொள்கிறோம் .
PTR is Right…
It is not arrogance, it is intelligence and the ignorant can't understand the difference.
Its self respect
What a reply
You call it arrogance, we Tamilians proudly call it as intelligence.
I don't know why termed him arrogance, bcz u don't have any answer to his question, can u call Federal FM arrogant, when she start to reply in arrogance, then why the slave godi media showing difference between TN FM and Federal FM. First u medias come out of the slavery.
yes
@@ahamedmohideen9875 thats the way BJP proppagands operates
😍😍😍😍👌👌👌👌
Yes yes yes yes yes 🙌
Nobody should comment on Modi or Amith Shah's statement. This is the definition of democracy by BJP
Even BJP supporters won't accept this. PTR is such a person.
"Arrogance of TN Finance minister"
உனக்கு நான் கால் மேல கால் போட்டு உட்கார்ந்தது தான் உன் பிரச்சினைனா அப்படி தான் டா உக்காருவேன்😎😎
Spot On
Yes
Super bro
😍🔥🔥🔥
PTR has intelligence arrogance bjp only have arrogance 🤷
It is better to say as idiotic arrogance.
JUST P0LETIC TALK don't talk rubbish.
We enjoy this intellectual arrogance of very high caliber!
Haha super
Lmao
People here saying it will take 15 years for other states which TN has achieved... But if BJP rules they would not have future.. A complety spolied
Self respect = Tamil Nadu.🔥
The. TN Finance Minister Mr PTR views were brilliant he was extremely well prepared for the debate his opponents in the debate failed miserably to convey any worthwhile counter arguments his views were not arrogant - Lt Col Retd PS Gill Asr Pb
When Hindutva loses its argument it will attack with name calling
Ptr is intelligent man
I salute you Sir, from the state of Tamilnadu
A true soldier will always be a true soldier 👍
We salute you and your views Sir! from Tamil Nadu the state of self-respect....
I think ptr is more deserved for indian finance minister
Don't tell in public forum, few people will pee in their pants😂😂
Very well,, the most capable FM for the Union Government.. But they don't deserve our PTR.. 😃
But our FM Nirmala Tai is best. When asked about price inflation of onions she replied, "I don't eat a lot of Onions".. can PTR sir give such intellectual answers?
@@yagerone369 sorry he can't, he can give facts and stats in detailed.. also he eats onion and garlic at Home 😂😂😂😂
@@yagerone369 he is not as intelligent as Ms. Nirmala as he eats lots of Onion :-(
Yes. Our finance minister is arrogant 😍😍 but not pickle seller
Nirmala
Ha.. ha..
@@UMESHKUMAR-ly6vg Nimmi 😂😂😂
@@AmericanTamilVibes let's respect her bro..
Never.@@solomonrajr204510
India's present finance minister is acting like a school teacher lecturing others....
She should resign and we need one like Mr PTR as Finance minister
That is not arrogance.....it's his education and great experience which none of these have..and education always matters...not acting.
PTR is absolutely right in his view.
Intellectual arrogance? Ok. Answer his questions why is tn is performing better than up Bihar and othe BJP states
That's becoz majority of ppl here are educated or intelligent and not uneducated/illiterate like PM..
@@yagerone369 Your words for a pm of a country shows your education and pm is much more educated then you by mindset, knowledge, experience and your so called degree
Modi made gujrat a industrial hub and up is on the same way , Karnataka and other states if you have eyes then you will able to see
@@bibhabsaha3251 hahaha.. pm is educated.. u can be stand up comedian... PM is a liar, period.
Yes, i see the news about Gujrat model all the drugs, here alcohol is banned but only alcohol whereas poisonous alcohol is allowed, UP development is booming just like the the Bundelkhand expressway which never got damaged 7 days after inauguration.
U speak about Karnataka, i guess u meant Bengaluru which is built from scratch by BJP. Also Janta party and INC never governed Karnataka. It's always BJP from beginning of Big bang, that has governed Karnataka..
@@bibhabsaha3251 Karnataka was a it hub even before Modi came. So what is the contribution of up in gdp. Is it greater than tn
PTR is on fire 🔥 it's not freebies. Its social welfare schemes. When money is given to corporates where is these people,
Which is termed as Economic Stimulus in economics!!
Super all are in fire to support the intelligence of a good administrator
Corporates have looted India, and are still looting by way of bank loans taken and not returned.
@@jayakumarpradeepam5142 Don't be so polite! pappan, chettu,marwadi and gujus corpo-rates had spoiled the enitre system to favour chinese
The government under cm M K Stalin and his team is functioning marvelously in Tamil Nadu and they are expert specially in social engineering, best candidate for the PM of India
He is taking tamilnadu in profit mode compared to other states than the bjp ruling state. Who the hell is he to question my minister.
Dr.PTR explained very well. He is doing good job and as a finance minister he have right. BJP spoke person could not answer not even single question of Dr.PTR.
Sorry, You can't win with him facts
Really. I was surprised when finally TN argues that it is legislature that decides and court has no says shows that they really don't have a case. Why do we need courts and police then in TN.
@@jotendrakumar2852 idiot.. if court interfere in this it also having rights to question tax collection and government expenditure
@@jotendrakumar2852 foolish .he says PPL elect and the state ministry decides to allocate fund what is good for PPL.we tamils don't complain.what is the problem with centre.
@@jotendrakumar2852 please try to understand that Constitution is the backbone of Democracy. As per constitution people choose who has to rule the country through election. And the leaders have power to run the country by following set of rules and regulations. If some government is not following constitution or rules, then court decide who is right and who is wrong.
What Dr.PRT says is people given power to us. As per constitution, we can manage our own finance. We are managing our economy better than Union government in all aspects. Then why are you giving advise to us when you were doing very bad at it.
Got it dear?
@@jotendrakumar2852 stop posting same comment everywhere please 🤣😂🥱🙄🙄🙄
Kerala 100% literacy bjp 0 seats.
Peace ☮️
Tamilnadu also Zero bjp seat
@@rajabs6185 Tamil Nadu BJP Vote percent 2.6%, Kerala 12%
Super
In TN when BJP contested without alliance they have got vote% below to NOTA...
The beauty is when northern states are fighting against BJP from their dominance, here our Tamilan and Chetan are fighting with themselves on who defeated the BJP to the core 😜
You call it arrogance, we Tamilians proudly call it as intelligence
It's not arrogance, it's self respect, tamilian s value for their language, culture,land,👍👍
India today , it isn’t Arrogance of Mr. PTR. Rather he showed mirror to BJP and BJP has no answer to the point raised by TN FM. Great going TN FM.
I think Dr Palanivel Thyagarajan Tamil Nadu Finance Minister who is well educated leader and has good caliber explained the fact very well. He was right because in our country everyone has the right to take their own decisions and question the central government as well as state government. If someone shows their dissent towards prime minister and the central government and other state government is not crime. Dissent is essential for democracy. I think our honourable Prime Minister should respect the dissent and stop blaming the state governments who questions you and your government. We should respect the democracy.
PTR spoke answer to the point
Give reply to his questions sir.
Really. I was surprised when finally TN argues that it is legislature that decides and court has no says shows that they really don't have a case. Why do we need courts and police then in TN.
@@jotendrakumar2852 Courts and judges are not gods to determine and take decision on everything, they all come under constitution. And the same constitution give rights to the people elected person to act as he like .Court is not in top only people is & they will take decision at final
@@jotendrakumar2852 stop copy pasting same response in every comment. R u frm BJP IT cell?
@@arunc4248 yes.. That idiot should b.. Becoz cannot write anything more..
@@arunc4248 i think he is a BoT bro.
Ask union fm to answer it all. She is nothing in front of Dr PTR. Apart from this every one shd understand that PTR family legacy is very rich when compared to any politicians in India. Lord Ayyappan statu at Sabarimala was provided by his family. He is from such a dignitary family.
Mr PTR should be FM of country . Narender Taneja is not educated
Ptr is rocking and Rahul and central govt not answered yet his questionnaire. Tamil nadu is far ahead from other states
How dare you call it as arrogance ? It’s basically your inability to answer
INEFFICIENT MEDIOCRE JOURNALISTS !
TN's per capita income is more than double the national average, and inflation is lower by 2.5%; the fiscal deficit of TN is 3.5%, while the union govt has 7%. Why do you assume somebody can tell me how to do my job better? The people will decide that -
This is too much for them to understand, 🤣
@@dinakar6502 hahahaha. Good one.
Do u know how much loan they ( TN govt ) borrowed in this one and half year ?
@@Devgopal2024 உனக்கு அவ்வளவு தெயிரிம் இருக்குல நீதான் கேட்டுப்பாரேன் நீயே சொல்லு நிதி பற்றாக்குறை 3.5% , தேசிய நிதி பற்றாக்குறை 7% என்று சொல்லுராறு , நீங்க என்ன சொல்லவரீங்க, நான் +2 பாஸ், நீங்க mba பெயிலா?
@@Devgopal2024 Why? Couldn't you get it from google?
These sanghis are laughable! PTR an economist by profession rocks!
This news channel and the moderator got insulted to the core by FM of TN. Now they called four to cry.... TN is performing and PM is just a gross failure.
Such a wonderful answer from PTR..his answers are 200% correct.. Happy to have him as our finance minister.!
You can't call him arrogant.
What he said that all were true.
And proudly I say he is more honest and more intelligent than other penalist.
Arrogance, my foot, BJP spokesperson should have answered what PTR questioned. It's BJP which. is always arrogant & sarcastic. Finance minister is a great example of arrogance & sarcasm when she said that she doesn't consume onions. Your track record is only destruction of the nation with schemes like demonitisation which you don't talk about.
PTR nailed it.... wish every Opposition ruled state should have minster like this to tear the real face BJP govt, kudos to PTR!! he rocked!! show your track record from any one state which they rule ha ha ha lol... wish 1:1 with PTR & Nirmala Sitaraman on these topics...
Same waiting for the day 😂
He can't come
When Nirmala said "I don't eat Onions so I don't know about it's shortage". It's not arrogance? But asking why government is pressurizing is arrogance? GODI MEDIA stop your madness..
TN FM is awesome. The debate needs to be on data, not on a few prescripted words.We need such arrogance to destroy this world of a few buffoons.
Salute to PTR, no answers for his questions, union exposed of it lies
If DMK rules india just for next 10years then see the difference. Our unfortunate that DMK is not a national party, but we are fortunate that we live in TN under DMK government.
Thanks for your comments
Time will make it.
Yes...If all the ministers are like PTR! But now DMK and BJP no difference!
முரசொலி பைத்தியம்.. அதான் ஒன்ற வருஷமா பாக்கறோமே, கேவல ஆட்சியை.. ரொம்ப koovaatha
True 🖤🔥😍
Very logical and blunt reply by DMK......BJP spokesperson is clueless and confused 🤔
Arrogance is the correct answer for any arrogant behaviour.
For India better future we want more arrogant like this...!
Well done PTR...!
Worst godi media.
Don’t mess with PTR … he will give you back right on your face.
If this is arrogance in your view.. well we are the most arrogant bunch that is there..
PTR answers and explanation wonderful...
Political arrogance has been replied with Intellectual arrogance. Well done PTR
Sir Ravindra Taneja do you have the guts to question the ruling party for all their wrong doings and you know it Mr Revindra Taneja.
Intellectuals walk the talk. Tamil nadu FM's rebuttal is very effective given the double standard being preach.
Ptr slammed on the servants of crony capitalist
Show the Ptr reply ? He literally killed u 😂
Other form of Freebies are Pension, DA of Govt Employees, Luxury plane of PM, Luxury cars of central ministers, discounted rate in Govt canteens, discounted food in MLA hostel, in PArlianment, free Train AC coach for MPs, Crores of pensions for the MLAs and MPS who is not in power and so on......., why not free rice for poors????? . If you don't have PHD no problem, but have some brain like PTR
👍👍👍👍❤
PTR CANN AFFORD TO BE
ARROGANT,BECAUSE HE
KNOWS WHAT HE IS DOING,
AND IT IS 100% RIGHT!
When asked about roof hitting onion price, fm said i dont eat onions, tats arrogance
That's the caliber of BJP ministers.
Tamil Nadu is in the level to compete with the developed countries, not with other states of India. Dear BJPians, please develop your states and then advise us.
Tamilnadu Finance Minister spoken correctly with valid points....
India knows who is ARROGRANCE??
We are so proud to have a Finance Minister PTR Sir 😀😇
தமிழ்நாட்டில் கொடுக்ககூடிய இலவசங்கள் வடமானிகள் ஏன் கொடுப்பதில்லை என்று இப்போது வடமாநில மக்கள் பேச தொடங்கினார் இனி மத அரசியல் செய்வது கடினம் அதற்காக இந்த புதிய சட்டம்
idhai aangilaththi sollungal sangikalukku konjamaavadhu puriyattum
I would want some one like Dr. PTR to be my next FM
DMK part of govt at the Center during Dr Manmohan singh was prime minister, His govt image was spoiled by DMK minister like Raja & Kanimozi both they were in Jail still they are on Bail. This is TN intectual political party spoiled the congress prospect & will never come to power in Center for 2 decade …..
@@ravindrakulkarni6277 Aap dus saal coma mein they kya?
Rahul.. if I said that in 1985 I had digital camera ,.. what would you call me ? liar or truthful person.. if I said .. sab ko 15 lakh aayega.. what would you call me , if I said I send drones to check the working of govt officer .. what would you call me .. now the greater question is do you have courage to call modi a liar or a fool ?
Anything related to development is called arrogance by northies, 🤣🤣 they only love caste and religion
P.T.R made me understand in 10 minutes what I couldn't make my SANGI friend understand for ten years🤣🤣
😂😂😂 la
🤣🤣🤣
Please arrange a debate between PTR and FM Nirmala sitharaman .
All citizens will understand the financial state of our country, when this meeting happens.
PTR rocks
You first learn the meaning of arrogance.This is not arrogance,this is called intellect.Good reply PTR Sir,proud to be Tamilan.India needs more educated and intellectual people like you sir.
free 15 lakhs Supriya jiii where is 15 lakhsssss I'm waiting
When PTR says what is right why you Rahul behave like child
He’s a Sangi
Because rahul is a pimp .. his owner is getting whiplashes without mercy, so he is crying 😂😂😂 கேள்விய கேளுடானா உருட்டிட்டு இருக்கான்
BJP doesn't have an answer to PTR's question on freebies. They are now facing heat from AAP, DMK and TMC..etc..
yes exactly ..
Salute to such a well-informed educated n bold finance minister
retired judges are getting free house ,..protection security personnel. .house hold help ..FREEBIES ..shame
North India media has to call men with moustache often to this kind of debate to get such a brilliant responses
You call it arrogent....we call it intelligence confident .. 🔥🔥🔥