Damn. Just learned of his departure from this dimension. An unfathomable loss. This 10 minute video is in the upper echelon of musical creativity, and us lucky ones will all be returning to it forever. Rest easy Casey Benjamin. 🖤
you aint lie brother. been listening to this for almost ten years now. This was my favorite thing in music for a long time. We truly lost a beutiful mind in Casey
I do not understand how people can say this man is a bad drummer. he is amazing. His off beat-ness sinks me into the grove rather than throwing me off. its just ever so slightly off. He has so much control and so much timing skills to pull off that kind of shit makes it so profoundly perfect.
I reckon the people knocking the drummer have little to no real knowledge of jazz. Not trying to be mean. Just pointing out that not everything in rhythm needs to be “4 on the floor” or suchlike.
The drummer is indeed playing off the beat. But, I think this is deliberate. Anyone familiar with the music of the late hip-hop producer J Dilla will understand what the drummer is doing.
Fantastic, inspiring. Those who say the drummer is off, listen closely, the keys are even more off. It's on purpose, the only one who's on beat is the bass. It creates these awesome tensions. Also how understated but powerful as a result.
Eric Sopanen I guess some don't comprehend its calls The Robert Glasper Experiment for a reason...and what an awesomely wonderful music experiment it is!
I was 5 feet away for this performance. Band was so tight. Musicians were so "in the moment." I was witness to a profoundly moving experience. They seemed to float away into the heavens. Watch Casey's face....ecstasy.
I love this so much. It sounds like the memory of a dream of a beautiful song, bounced off the surface of Mars, and received back on Earth, full of static, through a layer of low cloud in the night sky.
@@guydanielclotilde4861 Thanks Guy. I was wondering how to get friends to listen to these guys. Such an incredible piece of creativity. Made me try hard! I class myself lucky to live in the same world as them.
The snare is on time. Then he places the hi hat and kick sometimes a little behind and sometimes a little ahead creating tension as we’ll release. They’re playing in floating layers, going in and out of grooves. Can’t you feel it???
I love how they incorporated 3 different jdilla tracks in this. the beginning of the song was (HOLD TIGHT q-tip) , then they did (SHAKE IT DOWN) then ended with (THELONIOUS common) all produced by Jay Dee
i may be 58 years old, but i know neo-innovation & ultra talent when i hear it. dis it. herbie hancock's vocoder use from the 70s inspired this. bravo & brill rebirth!!
This is not for the entry level Jazz listener. If you look through the comments , the folks who are familiar with Jazz really appreciate and understand the greatness of this performance. It reminds me of when my friends were first introducing me to metal. I just didn’t get it. But, after finding a few songs I liked, I began to understand the more complex forms. I started to understand the changes and how the artists will build a song. Now I love metal and no matter how complex the patterns I can catch the vibe the musicians are going for. It’s no different with Jazz. It takes a familiarity with the genre sometimes to understand and appreciate what is going on. The ahead of the beat, behind the beat ebb and flow of what the drummer brings is virtuoso level. I’m a drummer and what he is doing takes sooooo much control and knowledge of soundscape. To the untrained ear it’s sounds wrong, but to those is us who have spent time with the legends and tried to play behind or ahead of the beat know this is genius level shit.
As an improvising musician, I know that if ever I think these guys are playing off tempo, it's because I've gotta do some work and understand how they are splitting the time so finely or playing cross rhythms. They offer us the chance to raise our listening to a higher level.
👍💯 Yes. U got to get in the music by feeling it & not try to label it. A good musician that feels his way can take one song / composition & play it in every style and genre known to man on planet Earth 🌎. How so❓ Bcuz music has no boundaries & no limitations except for those boundaries & limitations of which man ignorantly bestows upon it with human / man-made labels & analyzations. Every sound in the universe & beyond is music
what is so awesome about this is that each sound is playing its own independent melody but it is all gelled together as one. Robert Glasper is truly a musical genius.
5:49 My man Derrick referencing Keni Burke - Risin' To The Top! 8:26 too, Casey Benjamin referencing the backing vocals to the same track. I absolutely ADORE this rendition of this song because I keep on finding so many references after every listen! BIG UPS! There's even more but i'm not bothered to do it all lmao
Yessir! This joint spans musical time and genre, with the obvious ode to Nirvana. Anyone peep the nod Dilla with the intro drum pattern from "Hold Tight" sampled from "What Makes You Happy by KC & the Sunshine Band" and the main groove and chords coming from the same version of " Hold Tight" sampled from Cannonball Adderly's "An Expericence in E". Not to mention the bassist's movement from "Nautilus" and at 5:50 something vaguely reminiscent of Groove Theory or some mid 90's Post Acid-Jazz vibe. And of course that refrain to "Thelonious" or was it George Duke's "Vulcan Mind Probe" on the outro. A masterpiece in musical history of the past few decades. Salute
Lol. Man glad y'all felt it too. Yo Rob G, wherever you are in the ether, can i swap the cookie for a ticket to the sold out London Jazz Fest show at KoKo next month?😊
This is abstract music folks, real musicians who use all the increments that makes up a whole note. Primal thinking assumes that the drummer is off at times, wrong, those chops are deliberate and rather tight. The drummer is cold. There are also a lot of overlays going on including; poly rhythms, half-time, double -time and 6 over 4 timing.
RIP Casey. I saw you at the GroundUp Music Festival in Miami in February playing with Sput. He dedicated a song to Shaun Martin who was in a coma. He died this year too! Still trying to come to terms with this year. So many losses. 😭
HOW have I not heard this before now just tremendous..... huge Nirvana fan but also huge jazz fan and to see them combined in such a manner is just incredible....
The drummer is phenomenal. It’s deliberate of course…The pushing and dragging and fragmentation of the beat are what makes coming back to the straight ahead groove (second chorus) feel so good and make you bob your head. Love the free-form fast high hat on the second verse. So creative
First of all I absolutely love the original song but this here......... I loved how all the musicians came together and we're apart at the same time. Anyone thinking it sounds off has to listen a little closer. Sounds fantastic.
Amen the brother establishes a groove then dances all around it. What he is doing takes tremendous talent and a complete understanding of time and rhythm.
Host: Troy Nelson Audio Engineer: Kevin Suggs Cameras: Jim Beckmann, Scott Holpainen, Justin Wilmore & Patrick Richardson Wright Lighting Designer: Alex Belding Editor: Luke Knecht But: drums? bass? piano?
Who hasn't Robert Glasper collaborated with. So much talent. I would suggest the artist Sir. & Snoh Algebra. With do a great addition to such a variety of awesome repertoire of artists you have already .Bravo!
Oh noooo!!! This can’t be!😢😢😢 I fell in love with this form of artistry and Robert Glasper because of you Casey!🥹 I will be performing this exact project in 2 days!! My heart is heavy right now! Rest easy Casey until we meet again!!❤️❤️🙏🏽
Damn. Just learned of his departure from this dimension. An unfathomable loss. This 10 minute video is in the upper echelon of musical creativity, and us lucky ones will all be returning to it forever. Rest easy Casey Benjamin. 🖤
Nooooooooo
you aint lie brother. been listening to this for almost ten years now. This was my favorite thing in music for a long time. We truly lost a beutiful mind in Casey
Looked him up after I saw this tex, this whole energy and what he was on was another beautiful musical level
R.I.P Casey Benjamin 🙏🏽 gone but not forgotten 😢🙏🏽 1:23
RIP Casey, you were an inspiration and hero to me.
Shocked 😳 RIP Casey Benjamin. I loved your music style and your smile. 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
Glasper would never put up with a bad drummer. He's 100% intentional with every note.
You don't know what you're talking about.
I think that’s a complement to the drummer
I do not understand how people can say this man is a bad drummer. he is amazing. His off beat-ness sinks me into the grove rather than throwing me off. its just ever so slightly off. He has so much control and so much timing skills to pull off that kind of shit makes it so profoundly perfect.
Who says that? I think he's great.
drewbocop a lot of people on this video it seems which is a shame. hes amazing
I reckon the people knocking the drummer have little to no real knowledge of jazz. Not trying to be mean. Just pointing out that not everything in rhythm needs to be “4 on the floor” or suchlike.
He is nowhere near a jazz drummer, he's a gospel drummer
Daniel Cobar anybody who talks shit on his drum pattern has no knowledge of dilla. which means they get no respect from me lol
Not seeing anybody appreciate the creativity to hear nirvanas smell like teen spirit and to turn it into a jazz/ neo soul track. IN. SANE.
By far the most smells like cover i ever came acros
Illest tribute to Nirvana, and unites both Nirvana/rock fans and Jazz/Neo Soul/J Dilla fans
The Bad Plus do a great rendition, but this is so much more transformative.
@@47AdriRamiAKAETHG Dope comment!
This is argueably Robert's best track. Especially off of his Black Radio Album. Check out this version. th-cam.com/video/MpyG69Uc0tg/w-d-xo.html
Rest In Peace Casey!!! Your art and life will never be forget!!! You were a GIFT for all of us!!! Legend!!!
The drummer is indeed playing off the beat. But, I think this is deliberate. Anyone familiar with the music of the late hip-hop producer J Dilla will understand what the drummer is doing.
Comment of the day sir!! Thank you- (rip dilla)
If you didn’t catch it the keyboard player is wearing a JDilla tee haha
@@AdventurousInsight thats Robert Glasper
Isnt the point of jazz to play off key/beat? Dont be a hater
This is the comment I was looking for. Thank you.
Rest easy Mr. Casey Benjamin! 🙏🏾
Fantastic, inspiring. Those who say the drummer is off, listen closely, the keys are even more off. It's on purpose, the only one who's on beat is the bass. It creates these awesome tensions. Also how understated but powerful as a result.
Eric Sopanen yep, in jazz only the bass keeps the tempo, I had to retrain myself as a drummer in college when I started playing jazz
Eric Sopanen I guess some don't comprehend its calls The Robert Glasper Experiment for a reason...and what an awesomely wonderful music experiment it is!
Yeah explaining the concept of a 'pocket' to non musicians and even a lot of non drummers is not easy
so funny or sad that someone would hear this as not perfect in its own right
theyre all "on beat" its just the piano and vocals are operating across longer frames than the bass
If only we saw such performances on TV daily, if only such talent was pop culture.
Can't get enough of this one.
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
u can say that again hey
Ikr.
@@silas9805 that's that Dangelo, Jay Dilla, Quest Love, Smcmilz, timing !
Facts, lady!
I was 5 feet away for this performance. Band was so tight. Musicians were so "in the moment." I was witness to a profoundly moving experience. They seemed to float away into the heavens. Watch Casey's face....ecstasy.
yes u get it too nice
Te envidio, Julio :)
Ill cry if i was there colenburg man
You lucky son of a gun. I would sell my left nut to see these cats live !!!
You had to feel the energy and just nodded your head to the beat.......
I love this so much. It sounds like the memory of a dream of a beautiful song, bounced off the surface of Mars, and received back on Earth, full of static, through a layer of low cloud in the night sky.
Damn... That was beautiful
@@ebberz813 Thank you. I had to try my best for them!
@@guydanielclotilde4861 Thanks Guy. I was wondering how to get friends to listen to these guys. Such an incredible piece of creativity. Made me try hard! I class myself lucky to live in the same world as them.
Seriously poetic!❤
@@mawalls2001 Thanks Mawalls. I was highly motivated!
The snare is on time. Then he places the hi hat and kick sometimes a little behind and sometimes a little ahead creating tension as we’ll release. They’re playing in floating layers, going in and out of grooves. Can’t you feel it???
Like the image of floating layers. Perfect.
I love how they incorporated 3 different jdilla tracks in this. the beginning of the song was (HOLD TIGHT q-tip) , then they did (SHAKE IT DOWN) then ended with (THELONIOUS common) all produced by Jay Dee
thank you
That's some music history you're tuning into brother!
and (FUCK THE POLICE)
Well done young
Its insane
Honestly, Robert Glasper is a truly talented man,brilliant jazz pianist.
i may be 58 years old, but i know neo-innovation & ultra talent when i hear it. dis it. herbie hancock's vocoder use from the 70s inspired this. bravo & brill rebirth!!
11 years later and I still refer to this video as the best version in my opinion
I agree mate.
This is not for the entry level Jazz listener. If you look through the comments , the folks who are familiar with Jazz really appreciate and understand the greatness of this performance. It reminds me of when my friends were first introducing me to metal. I just didn’t get it. But, after finding a few songs I liked, I began to understand the more complex forms. I started to understand the changes and how the artists will build a song. Now I love metal and no matter how complex the patterns I can catch the vibe the musicians are going for. It’s no different with Jazz. It takes a familiarity with the genre sometimes to understand and appreciate what is going on. The ahead of the beat, behind the beat ebb and flow of what the drummer brings is virtuoso level. I’m a drummer and what he is doing takes sooooo much control and knowledge of soundscape. To the untrained ear it’s sounds wrong, but to those is us who have spent time with the legends and tried to play behind or ahead of the beat know this is genius level shit.
that drummer has got it going on
Absolutely.
YES.
Mark Kolenberg, have a gander my man
I think it's Chris Dave. Forgive me if I'm incorrect
Mark Colenburg as at 6:37
As an improvising musician, I know that if ever I think these guys are playing off tempo, it's because I've gotta do some work and understand how they are splitting the time so finely or playing cross rhythms. They offer us the chance to raise our listening to a higher level.
7 years ago no vids. Improvise me something I'll watch. I promise
Yes...simply amazing to the ear and the spirit. We get it! Highly Skilled Musical Geniuses. Listen...no textbooks needed! Ya know whatcha know!
👍💯 Yes. U got to get in the music by feeling it & not try to label it. A good musician that feels his way can take one song / composition & play it in every style and genre known to man on planet Earth 🌎. How so❓ Bcuz music has no boundaries & no limitations except for those boundaries & limitations of which man ignorantly bestows upon it with human / man-made labels & analyzations. Every sound in the universe & beyond is music
🤣
@@Daplin1Everytthing is improvised at some point.
what is so awesome about this is that each sound is playing its own independent melody but it is all gelled together as one. Robert Glasper is truly a musical genius.
THis aint neva aging! there's something so special about an RGE Live performance...RWP CB
This has been my drug for the last 3 months. Such a beautiful rendition.
hey hey are you here? Can we listen to this again? :)
charlie hunter trio come as you are check out this older jazz trio
WHAT THE HELL IS THIS?
ABSOLUTELY AMAZING.
Hope you're feeling better Kim
hey thats kim jong! hey there, Kim. any update on your nuke project? or movie hackings? lol peace love you kim ./.
북녘의 돼지도 즐기는 로버트 글래스퍼 익스페리먼트! 모두 즐겨용! (Even a pig of North Korea enjoys Robert Glasper`s music!)
I knew you was smart.
I'll take kim over Trump in my sleep. At least he's doing something besides tweeting all day.
RIP Casey ❤ (this will forever be my favorite live music video performance ever made)
5:49 My man Derrick referencing Keni Burke - Risin' To The Top!
8:26 too, Casey Benjamin referencing the backing vocals to the same track.
I absolutely ADORE this rendition of this song because I keep on finding so many references after every listen! BIG UPS!
There's even more but i'm not bothered to do it all lmao
HOLY FUCK drummer’s hat work on the second verse… dude is WORKIN’ and brings it down so controlled and softly.
This is beautiful. I've had this on repeat for weeks now. I wish Kurt could've heard this here on earth
+Jason Goforth Me too. I miss him.
Why? Neither of you knew him, just a media representation of him. Kurt would tell you both, “Stop Living in the past”
@Jason Goforth: you are so right! Blues know no boundaries, no colours. Kurt would be so proud indeed.
@@jnnxdamn you know what a deceased person would say! jog on will you
Yessir! This joint spans musical time and genre, with the obvious ode to Nirvana. Anyone peep the nod Dilla with the intro drum pattern from "Hold Tight" sampled from "What Makes You Happy by KC & the Sunshine Band" and the main groove and chords coming from the same version of " Hold Tight" sampled from Cannonball Adderly's "An Expericence in E". Not to mention the bassist's movement from "Nautilus" and at 5:50 something vaguely reminiscent of Groove Theory or some mid 90's Post Acid-Jazz vibe. And of course that refrain to "Thelonious" or was it George Duke's "Vulcan Mind Probe" on the outro. A masterpiece in musical history of the past few decades. Salute
Give this guy a cookie! You're my new best friend. Good ears.
Also RG is wearing a Jay Dee tee 😉😊
I LOOOVE your analysis ... you have a great memory + ear and are MAD thorough!! 🎼🎶🎹🎷🎸🎺🎤💿🎧
hell yeah
Lol. Man glad y'all felt it too. Yo Rob G, wherever you are in the ether, can i swap the cookie for a ticket to the sold out London Jazz Fest show at KoKo next month?😊
I wish I could help :-) he was here in DC at the Kennedy Center about two years back and I know until it was too late.
Artistically impressive..i can appreciate this all the way around. Drums and piano are killing it.
his version of this iconic song is such a beautiful blend of art forms. I think Kurt Cobain would've been proud.:-)
Jet Washington Dani Martín q bonita es la vida
Man, Derrick Hodge is such a beast
Bass man thump
Nice work
Yeah the brother is really cold!
the vocoder is so amazing
Art hitting me in the face. Thanks to the musicians who put this together. We need this!
I play this at least once a month and usually during dinner so my kids can absorb its greatness.
At 4:20 the bass line comes from Bob James' song "Nautilus"...this whole cover of Nirvana's classic song is amazing.
What an awesome drummer.
I think they showed Nirvana major love with this one. Dope!
Dam! That's a beautiful version of the song that plunged the world into the chaos we know as grunge rock. Is there a love button instead of like?
There is a "LOVE" button. It's called Purchase Robert Glaspers Music
@@MrPuncy got him
So slept on, this deserves way more views
I just totally love Robert Glasper Experiment!!
Whatever vocal effects he's using absolutely kills this for me.
I swear I watch this like once a week. Everything about it is so subtle and perfect.
RIP Casey Benjamin. A musical genius gone way too soon 💔
This is abstract music folks, real musicians who use all the increments that makes up a whole note. Primal thinking assumes that the drummer is off at times, wrong, those chops are deliberate and rather tight. The drummer is cold. There are also a lot of overlays going on including; poly rhythms, half-time, double -time and 6 over 4 timing.
The drummer is a friggin genius.
Lol if say anyone in this band is off tempo please just stick to guitar hero. This that real shit
This gives me goosebumps. Woah.
RIP Casey. I saw you at the GroundUp Music Festival in Miami in February playing with Sput. He dedicated a song to Shaun Martin who was in a coma. He died this year too! Still trying to come to terms with this year. So many losses. 😭
Black Radio is forever on rotation in my home. Fantastic performance. I really wish they would come to my area
HOW have I not heard this before now just tremendous..... huge Nirvana fan but also huge jazz fan and to see them combined in such a manner is just incredible....
The drummer is phenomenal. It’s deliberate of course…The pushing and dragging and fragmentation of the beat are what makes coming back to the straight ahead groove (second chorus) feel so good and make you bob your head. Love the free-form fast high hat on the second verse. So creative
4:21 BLOWN AWAY!!! Got some Bob James bass line in there. Superb
This will hit differently 😇
those fellas had the stagger swagger.... beautiful!
And for this gift, i'm truly blesssssseeddd
God, it's so soft and lovely and bubbly but it carries just as much energy as the original song. I love this so much
First of all I absolutely love the original song but this here......... I loved how all the musicians came together and we're apart at the same time. Anyone thinking it sounds off has to listen a little closer. Sounds fantastic.
I can't stop listening to this. It's beautiful. Just in pure awe
that synocpation...the vibe....funky dope
I keep coming back to that drum and bass intro.....that first minute simply does it for me and makes me want to be like let's see where this goes!
Rip Casey Benjamin revisiting this bc I need to calm down & catch a vibe
🔊🧘🏾♀️✨🛸
J Dilla drum cadence "Hold Tight" Fan-tas-tic Vol. II. Robert Glasper is the jazz equivalent.
good call..
Absolutely amazes me how talented they all are. This is true music....
Glasper The Great
Dope..great music,..Casey..I will miss your beautiful voice, what a loss to as all. We love your music Robert Glasper. The drummer kills everything.
SOOOOO much talent on that stage!!!!!!!!
This is dope! Life imitating art. I love the 'sampled' feel.
Here again to listen to the amazing beats of the drummer and his phenomenal groove. I never get tired of it.
WOOOOOOOOWWWWW!!!! I cant belive what i'm hearing.
Pure passion!!! Use your creation gift!!!!
heard them yesterday live. Twas amazing especially Mark Colenburg. Great band.
hes playing off beat intentionally. This is some of the most progressive drumming in the world right now. if you dont get it your ears are not ready.
Banging on the Ivories facts !!! It’s unfortunate if your ears can’t pick it up!!
Yep just like piano in "in case you forgot" on the Capitol records performance
*Capitol Studios* sorry
Amen the brother establishes a groove then dances all around it. What he is doing takes tremendous talent and a complete understanding of time and rhythm.
Yes
2020 still jammin to this!!!
The drum's is 🔥🔥🔥
words....just can't explain how this makes me feel ....UNBELIEVEABLE!!!!
6:54 bass playing "Rising To The Top" by Keni Burkes.
Rest East Legend.Watching from Lusaka,Zambia ,Africa🇿🇲🇿🇲🇿🇲🇿🇲
Amazing crew/version/flying ticket gift ❤
Host: Troy Nelson
Audio Engineer: Kevin Suggs
Cameras: Jim Beckmann, Scott Holpainen, Justin Wilmore & Patrick Richardson Wright
Lighting Designer: Alex Belding
Editor: Luke Knecht
But: drums? bass? piano?
gmafx they announce themselves at the end.
Rest in Paradise Casey!!🙏🏽🫶🏿🙌🏾🌻
This is so weird!! But I can't stop listening or moving my body to it!! WHAT IS THIS??
In love
Queen X Jazz Neo Soul fusion hun. At least I think so. ;)
Maricel Austria Lol thank you!
Queen X Also known as music.
This reaches new levels of inspiration. Phenomenal
So much love for this cover.
This is some damn funky stöff.....
Really digging this track. Same for the Jay-Dee shirt
Woooow!!! Amazing!! So glad to see korg ms 2000 in action here !!!!
Incredible work. Just imagine how that would be played by Prince. Impressed.
I never would've imagined that melody working in any other harmonic context but this definitely does it for me!
been listening to this every day
RIP Casey. Shocked to know about your passing.
What a brilliant artist your were.
Keep jamming up there Chief😢
Wow! Loving this!
I often sit and ponder about where we go after this realm.......
What an amazing rendition of an already amazing song! Best "cover" of this song I've ever heard!
Who hasn't Robert Glasper collaborated with. So much talent. I would suggest the artist Sir. & Snoh Algebra. With do a great addition to such a variety of awesome repertoire of artists you have already .Bravo!
Oh noooo!!! This can’t be!😢😢😢 I fell in love with this form of artistry and Robert Glasper because of you Casey!🥹 I will be performing this exact project in 2 days!! My heart is heavy right now! Rest easy Casey until we meet again!!❤️❤️🙏🏽
Everything is syncopated perfectly the drummer coming on first set the Rhythm he is definitely on time
drummer is a beast holy shit
That slayed this song. On some real ish. On your way to work, blast this song and watch how much production gets accomplished during the day. Salute 🫡
What a beautiful rendition!