It is no coincidence that you are speaking to this subject today. I am in the process of conversion after 40 years as a Baptist, and I was researching this very topic just last night! Praise be to the God of Heaven who hears our prayers and is faithful to respond!!!!
@@coolservantjesusswag2936 He has. I’ve made the choice, and I am meeting with my priest tomorrow to discuss the process of RCIA and entering the church this coming Easter. But please pray for me and my wife. She is not convinced, and it has caused difficultly in our marriage. I am patient and faithful that God will help her accept this. And she has been coming around to accepting my conversion. Please pray that she will continue to accept my new faith tradition, and that she may possibly do so herself!
Zero primary sources point to that. It’s a theory that survives because of Alan de la Roche, who is erroneously called “blessed” (he was never beatified), a man who fantasized about the BVM squeezing her breast milk into his mouth. He was a disturbed man who had many ideas and Dominic getting it from the BVM is one of them
The way of praying the rosary mentioned at 6:00 is still a tradition in Croatia, so in other central European countries other than Germany that was mentioned.
Fr Donald Callaway wrote a book about the rosary, people are always trying to make up rational excuses for divine things that have happened, that's our modernist church for you. Go listen to the talk that Fr Donald Callaway gives, he is with the Marian Fathers of the Immaculate Conception.
I love the Rosary videos of Bishop Barron. It would help you focus on the mysteries. Since, it shows paintings of the mysteries, all throughout the Hail Mary’s prayers. ✝️🙏🏻
Sorry Fr Gregory, completely wrong on this one. Fr Calloway has covered the origins of the rosary extensively in his book ‘Champions of the Rosary’ for anyone who is interested or you can just listen to any of his talks on TH-cam. The rosary has divine origins, given by Our Lady to St Dominic. Also worth mentioning St Louis de Montfort’s book, arguably the greatest book ever written on the rosary ‘The Secret of the Rosary’ who also defends its divine origins with St Dominic and Blessed Alan de la Roche. It’s extremely important that we do not deny its divine origins. Ave Maria!
I agree, and I think there's a real danger in removing Divine Intervention and Our Lady from the Rosary's origins. Sad a Dominican is preaching the prayer evolved on it's own. Ave Maria!
Sorry, but any Catholic historian knows that is a made up pious fable. Pious legends in the Church are edifying and not to be ridiculed, for miracles certainly happen, but you shouldn't deny history in order to cling to a version that you like better. The way the Holy Rosary developed as Fr Gregory explained is not opposed to the idea of a divine origin, for the Lord guideth his Church.
@kyrieeleison1243 You need to read 'Champions of the Rosary' by the holy and academic priest Fr. Donald Calloway. His scholarship refutes your impious position. Even Dr. Scott Hahn (a former teacher of Fr. Calloway) has commented on how well Fr. Calloway conducts his research - with incredible detail.
Even Fr Calloway talks of the early development of the rosary as described here. He even states that when the BVM appeared to St Dominic, she told him to preach her psalter which had already existed to some extent as just 150 Aves, which at the time were only the first half. The original mysteries selected were to refute the heresies of St Dominic's time. It started as a simple pious devotion but received Divine endorsement.
Thank you for this quick overview of roughly how the rosary developed. Fascinating. I'm new to Catholicism and learning all I can. A little disappointed that there are people squabbling about semantics in the comments here as well as in Protestant videos, but here we are. God bless and I hope Jesus returns soon. ❤
Remember the words of Christ. 🙏 Matthew 6:7-8 [7] “And when you pray, do not heap up empty phrases as the Gentiles do, for they think that they will be heard for their many words. [8] Do not be like them, for your Father knows what you need before you ask him. God bless you guys, whoever seeks to conform himself to the image of Christ is a brother of mine. 🙏
The book Champions of the Rosary by Fr. Donald Calloway covers that question pretty well. It's got a very solid history of the Rosary. Short answer is that there's a lot of evidence that St. Dominic got the mysteries from Our Lady, which is affirmed by many saints and popes.
I can disprove the trinity. The creeds say that the father, son, and hs are all “God”. It then says that they are not equal to each other. My question then is: are they all perfect? Yes So the father possesses ALL perfect attributes and no imperfect attributes. The son possesses all perfect attributes and no imperfect attributes. The hs possesses all perfect attributes and no imperfect attributes. So the father=all perfect attributes The son=all perfect attributes The hs=all perfect attributes Therefore father=son=hs Alhamdulillah for Islam!!
The holy trinity is One true God with three distinct persons is how the Catholic CMA church roughly defines it. They do have equal divinity. I don’t know where you heard it was labeled as unequal. That would be false. Hope that clarifies!
You're not understanding the distinction between person vs. nature. This was one of the many errors of Muhammad, the inventor of Islam and owner of s3x slaves.
Father, Son, Holy Spirit. Conscience, Speech, Life. God is a being that is unlike all creation. He has a conscience, meaning he is sentient. He can speak. He is a living being. Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
It is no coincidence that you are speaking to this subject today. I am in the process of conversion after 40 years as a Baptist, and I was researching this very topic just last night! Praise be to the God of Heaven who hears our prayers and is faithful to respond!!!!
I will pray that the Spirit leads you to his Holy Church. God bless.
You also found the video on time
@@coolservantjesusswag2936 He has. I’ve made the choice, and I am meeting with my priest tomorrow to discuss the process of RCIA and entering the church this coming Easter. But please pray for me and my wife. She is not convinced, and it has caused difficultly in our marriage. I am patient and faithful that God will help her accept this. And she has been coming around to accepting my conversion. Please pray that she will continue to accept my new faith tradition, and that she may possibly do so herself!
@@Wilkins325 very true, though TH-cam did notify me. But still, right time!!!
Well it's part of their video posted 2 weeks ago. Coincidence yes, technically it would be. God leading you to Christian speakers? Not a coincidence.
What about the Virgin Mary giving the rosary to St Dominic?
I got the same question...
Right, see: "Champions of the Rosary: The History and Heroes of a Spiritual Weapon," Fr. Donald Calloway, MIC
th-cam.com/video/dwVdYXyxln0/w-d-xo.html
Right?!
None gave st.Dominc any rosary
He just got it through dream
Zero primary sources point to that. It’s a theory that survives because of Alan de la Roche, who is erroneously called “blessed” (he was never beatified), a man who fantasized about the BVM squeezing her breast milk into his mouth. He was a disturbed man who had many ideas and Dominic getting it from the BVM is one of them
The way of praying the rosary mentioned at 6:00 is still a tradition in Croatia, so in other central European countries other than Germany that was mentioned.
Love the beard, Father Gregory!!! I’m sure you’ve gotten many compliments, and they are all warranted!!! Don’t lose it!!
You believe in Madjegore but don’t believe the intervention of the Blessed Virgin to St. Dominic for the Rosary?
I’m Orthodox, but even I believe the BVM gave the rosary to Dominic De Guzman
I was literally looking into this yesterday, what a great explanation! Thank you for clipping this!
I love listening to Father Gregory, sometimes twice and at .75 speed (I'm kinda slow).
You're not slow. He's a very quick speaker
@@pacempax5236 Peace & Good!
Fr Donald Callaway wrote a book about the rosary, people are always trying to make up rational excuses for divine things that have happened, that's our modernist church for you. Go listen to the talk that Fr Donald Callaway gives, he is with the Marian Fathers of the Immaculate Conception.
The rosary was developed from other pre-catholic practices for thousands of years.
I love the Rosary videos of Bishop Barron. It would help you focus on the mysteries. Since, it shows paintings of the mysteries, all throughout the Hail Mary’s prayers. ✝️🙏🏻
Love this explanation!
Sorry Fr Gregory, completely wrong on this one. Fr Calloway has covered the origins of the rosary extensively in his book ‘Champions of the Rosary’ for anyone who is interested or you can just listen to any of his talks on TH-cam. The rosary has divine origins, given by Our Lady to St Dominic. Also worth mentioning St Louis de Montfort’s book, arguably the greatest book ever written on the rosary ‘The Secret of the Rosary’ who also defends its divine origins with St Dominic and Blessed Alan de la Roche. It’s extremely important that we do not deny its divine origins. Ave Maria!
I agree, and I think there's a real danger in removing Divine Intervention and Our Lady from the Rosary's origins. Sad a Dominican is preaching the prayer evolved on it's own. Ave Maria!
Sorry, but any Catholic historian knows that is a made up pious fable. Pious legends in the Church are edifying and not to be ridiculed, for miracles certainly happen, but you shouldn't deny history in order to cling to a version that you like better. The way the Holy Rosary developed as Fr Gregory explained is not opposed to the idea of a divine origin, for the Lord guideth his Church.
@kyrieeleison1243 You need to read 'Champions of the Rosary' by the holy and academic priest Fr. Donald Calloway. His scholarship refutes your impious position. Even Dr. Scott Hahn (a former teacher of Fr. Calloway) has commented on how well Fr. Calloway conducts his research - with incredible detail.
Even Fr Calloway talks of the early development of the rosary as described here. He even states that when the BVM appeared to St Dominic, she told him to preach her psalter which had already existed to some extent as just 150 Aves, which at the time were only the first half. The original mysteries selected were to refute the heresies of St Dominic's time. It started as a simple pious devotion but received Divine endorsement.
@@seanmetz6616 We know all that. The key is St. Dominic was given a key revelation about the rosary.
Thank you for this quick overview of roughly how the rosary developed. Fascinating. I'm new to Catholicism and learning all I can. A little disappointed that there are people squabbling about semantics in the comments here as well as in Protestant videos, but here we are. God bless and I hope Jesus returns soon. ❤
How to be confident but not proud or like how to have confidence without Pride? (Pride is no 1 Deathly Sin)
Switched from Our Father to Hail Mary?
Anyone know the reference to the early ecumenical council reference he makes at 4:05?
Just in time. I had a protestant friend claiming the rosary had pagan origins
This was very interesting, and thanks for sharing.
Interesting, but not sure the song you mentioned was Anne Murray's
Really great. Thank you
What was that at 6:15?
I’m interested
Remember the words of Christ. 🙏
Matthew 6:7-8
[7] “And when you pray, do not heap up empty phrases as the Gentiles do, for they think that they will be heard for their many words. [8] Do not be like them, for your Father knows what you need before you ask him.
God bless you guys, whoever seeks to conform himself to the image of Christ is a brother of mine. 🙏
@@davidcatabui2018 I didn’t refer to anything as “empty phrases” I posted a quote from Matthew, who is quoting Christ.
Is it just a pius legend that the Blessed Mother gave the mysteries to St. Dominic?
The book Champions of the Rosary by Fr. Donald Calloway covers that question pretty well. It's got a very solid history of the Rosary. Short answer is that there's a lot of evidence that St. Dominic got the mysteries from Our Lady, which is affirmed by many saints and popes.
That’s what I thought. Since I hear either this origin of the rosary or the one Fr. Gregory said.
Thanks for the reply.
Just another thing Catholics do that we are told in the Bible not to do. Pattern Recognition.
Meditating on the life of Christ is
not vain
So, leaving them again, he went away and prayed for the third time, saying the same words.
Matthew 26:44
I’m sorry but you interrupted way too much here. He couldn’t get a single thought out fully.
I can disprove the trinity.
The creeds say that the father, son, and hs are all “God”. It then says that they are not equal to each other.
My question then is: are they all perfect?
Yes
So the father possesses ALL perfect attributes and no imperfect attributes.
The son possesses all perfect attributes and no imperfect attributes.
The hs possesses all perfect attributes and no imperfect attributes.
So the father=all perfect attributes
The son=all perfect attributes
The hs=all perfect attributes
Therefore father=son=hs
Alhamdulillah for Islam!!
Creed doesn't say that.
+Laus tibi Christe, Filii Dei+
The holy trinity is One true God with three distinct persons is how the Catholic CMA church roughly defines it. They do have equal divinity. I don’t know where you heard it was labeled as unequal. That would be false. Hope that clarifies!
You're not understanding the distinction between person vs. nature.
This was one of the many errors of Muhammad, the inventor of Islam and owner of s3x slaves.
Father, Son, Holy Spirit.
Conscience, Speech, Life.
God is a being that is unlike all creation.
He has a conscience, meaning he is sentient.
He can speak.
He is a living being.
Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
Isleeeeem 🤲🏻🕋