Mechanical is hella underrated, imo. The droning guitars, unnatural sounds, drum beat and overall vibe not only makes it feel hopeless and despairing, but genuinely powerful, intimidating, and industrial. It fits perfectly with the theme it's conveying, and it's tied with clay for me. Clay is much better, I feel, but for as amazing as it is, i feel as though it could have been more thematic. Anyways, nice video!
Dude are you really asking why specimen polygonal that appears in the *FLOWEY* boss why it's to creepy you either forgotten who flowey is and forgotten how creepy the final boss in the neutral route is or have never played the original undertale neutral route
Paper is pretty under appreciated. The laughing and the weird sounds and voices along with the beat are meant to really creep you out. And I feel like it really does a good job of putting that sentiment. It perfectly matches the phase. Polygonal is pretty overrated, but it does also have good things. It weirdly has the tone of desperation. it also kind of matches the overall shock factor of the phase. Mechanical is very underrated as it does a good job with its music. Also, that particular guitar part is just absolutely amazing. Clay is just a 10/10. It has one of the best riffs in the entire game. I really want them to make an extended version. Patchworked sounds kind of like a circus. I think it matches pretty well, but it just kind of makes me laugh when I hear it. Organic is just.. a heart beating along with a slightly unsettling background beat. It is not that much in terms of music, but it does a good job at being unsettling.
I like that part; it really captures the eerieness of the phase as the low notes drone from one headphone to the other, and back again. Really goes to show how much effort the UTY team put into the game, especially the entire flowey fight.
@@quentonfrancis2616 I do like that polygonal has its eerieness, but I feel it makes the phase WAY creepier than it has to be(those lil floweys are so scary... And the throbbing red...). But, I do like the eerieness of both songs, it's just that I feel organic does a better job.
Can I just say mechanical combined with the visuals and music makes my brain think of madness combat I dont know why also polygonal reminds a lot of those classic 3d games feels like something out of zelda it feels like a creepypasta
the musics i like more is in this order 1 paper: just wanted to be longer 2 mechanic: looks like apocalipse machine 3 organic: this phase is too short to hear the music if was longer. imagined this playing in the hospital in the room of somebody is close to die 4 clay
All of the specimens were kind of goofy except mechanical. A demented flower face made of paper or clay isn't that intimidating But a bullet is, and this flowers face is a gatling gun.
Im sorry, not to be rude or anything, but if your gonna roast organic then you should at least put it at last. You said good things about the other ones before this and then you start roasting it. How did that make sense???
For the previous two songs(polygonal and patchworked), I commented on how they fit. Organic, meanwhile, has a value to me that I can only explain with: it's the first specimen song I listened to. For the other two, I don't care about them along with the phases themselves. Organic, before I listened to the other specimen songs, was #1 in my ranking. Now that I've analyzed all the songs, I feel #4 is the highest spot to put organic in. And yes, the roasting was meant to kinda show how all the previous songs are really nothing compared to my top 3, in my opinion. I hope that answered your question, or at least gave you an idea of why I put organic where it is.
I think I can hear the first part of the lyrics at 3:14 :D Molding, shaping, (x2) Molding, molding, molding, scuplting Molding, shaping, (x2) Molding, molding, molding, scuplting
I think the first part has to be: "Let's play, let's play do-dodge the bullets!" "Let's play, let's play do-dodge the bullets!" And the second part I'm unaware of, but @coolman-kw1cc 's reply sounded the most likely: "Made with the clay, I can see. Made with the feeling of having fun."
1- Polygonal 2-Clay 3-Paper 4-Organic 5-Mechancal 6-Patchwork Im Sorry that clay isn't higher. I just think That Polygonal is Creeper and is more fiting
My ranking: 1. Clay (Hell yeah!) 2. Mechanical (Also hell yeah!) 3. Paper (Goes hard) 4. Organic (Fits the stage really well) 5. Patchworked (Bad) 6. Polygonal (Worst Undertale Yellow song in existence) Edit: WAIT I JUST REALIZED MY LIST IS THE SAME AS THE VIDEO LMAOOOOOOO
my list on how hard it was when i played it: 1. Patchworked (went insane) 2. Polygonal (same as patchworked) 3. Paper (it was actually hard) 4. Clay (the red parts kept disappearing) 5. Mechanical (wasn't that hard) 6. Organic (didn't take damage at all)
My list on how hard it was when i first played it: 1. Clay (the only one where i actually died) 2. Paper (it was kinda crazy) 3. Organic (the purple virus really made it difficult to dodge) 4. Polygonal (took damage but it wasn't really that hard) 5. Mechanical (a few saws caught me off guard, but other than that, it was easy) 6. Patchworked (i just stood behind the hands that were aiming in my direction)
the specimen songs are probably my least favorite songs in the entire game. They aren't bad music, they just aren't as good as the rest of the soundtrack.
![[SPOILERS] Undertale Yellow Specimen songs ranked](/img/n.gif)
I must say I'm happy that almost* everyone in the fandom agrees that Clay is the objectively best one
*OBJECTION!* I just like mechanical the best for some reason :|
Nah its in 3th
@@Tristanryan_Tnah mechanical goes 1st
Mechanical
Clay
The other ones
I like paper more
Polygonal being so low because it's "scary" means it did its job well.
Mechanical is hella underrated, imo. The droning guitars, unnatural sounds, drum beat and overall vibe not only makes it feel hopeless and despairing, but genuinely powerful, intimidating, and industrial. It fits perfectly with the theme it's conveying, and it's tied with clay for me. Clay is much better, I feel, but for as amazing as it is, i feel as though it could have been more thematic.
Anyways, nice video!
Blud, Polygonal being scary means that it fulfilled its job.
Yes, it did it's job well.
True, but music sucks
Dude are you really asking why specimen polygonal that appears in the *FLOWEY* boss why it's to creepy you either forgotten who flowey is and forgotten how creepy the final boss in the neutral route is or have never played the original undertale neutral route
Fact. If you beat mechanical specimen as fast as possible you even can’t listen specimen’s musical theme.
dang thats sad
@@dyatrite I checked it.
And for FLOWEYS neutral special, he is a gun.
Someone needs to make a mechnical extended but with The Gunshot sound effects, it adds to the song
Yeah lol
Paper is pretty under appreciated. The laughing and the weird sounds and voices along with the beat are meant to really creep you out. And I feel like it really does a good job of putting that sentiment. It perfectly matches the phase. Polygonal is pretty overrated, but it does also have good things. It weirdly has the tone of desperation. it also kind of matches the overall shock factor of the phase. Mechanical is very underrated as it does a good job with its music. Also, that particular guitar part is just absolutely amazing. Clay is just a 10/10. It has one of the best riffs in the entire game. I really want them to make an extended version. Patchworked sounds kind of like a circus. I think it matches pretty well, but it just kind of makes me laugh when I hear it. Organic is just.. a heart beating along with a slightly unsettling background beat. It is not that much in terms of music, but it does a good job at being unsettling.
Dude organic for me is the worst, since it GOES ACROSS THE EARS LIKE ITS IN YOUR HEAD WHEN YOU HAVE HEADPHONES OR AIRPODS ON
I like that part; it really captures the eerieness of the phase as the low notes drone from one headphone to the other, and back again. Really goes to show how much effort the UTY team put into the game, especially the entire flowey fight.
@@Bluespade24If like Organic eerie then why not like Polygonal eerie?
@@quentonfrancis2616 I do like that polygonal has its eerieness, but I feel it makes the phase WAY creepier than it has to be(those lil floweys are so scary... And the throbbing red...). But, I do like the eerieness of both songs, it's just that I feel organic does a better job.
Bro why isnt everyone talking about mechanical specimen its better than clay
The guitar at the end hard carries
Not gonna lie, mechanical is the worst in my opinion
But that’s just an opinion
A music opinion!
@@theshadowpriestess thanks for watching
because its not better
Weeeeelllll...
I love mechanical becuase it feels so... Well, mechanical. It alsoe gives off a sense of justice and i have a soft spot for breakcore so-
For some reason, the lyrics I hear from Clay are “Bu-buh-bu-buh-bu bu Bite the bullet” and “Maybe it’ll be fine, (unidentified lyrics here)”
It's just macdo commercial being stretched and twisted
i hear "made to forget, born to forget. today we'll bake some pie"
Wahoo ye h wahoo ye h bah baba bo EE EE wahoo ye h a a ::::::: they didnt want j schlatt (idk what it says after that)
We at least need to have someone isolate the lyrics for clay and paper at some point...
Then I can sleep happy.
Polygonal sounds like some sort of easter egg boss fight in an old early 2000's game
"okay so we need a short track for one of the flowey phases-"
*GlitchedPie making clay an absolute banger for no apparent reason*
FOR REAL
The best part starts around 10 seconds imo
The entire song tho, it is a BANGER through and through.
I feel like even polygonal is above the average in terms of game music
Undertale yellow really took Undertale's musical legacy at heart
i actually find organic more scary than the others, i can't tell why, but it's just... scarier..
Yes, with each passing second this theme becomes more and more disturbing, and the background noise becomes louder.
Can I just say mechanical combined with the visuals and music makes my brain think of madness combat I dont know why also polygonal reminds a lot of those classic 3d games feels like something out of zelda it feels like a creepypasta
pretty sure polygonal is based on those classic 3d games
Polygonal: YOU WANT FUN? FLOWEY SHOW YOU FUN!(either that or ocarina of time)
Mechanical: G U N
You've met a terrible fate
3:03 guitar voice crack
bro u guys need to listen to the clay specimen in the acoustic cover from the song, it goes even harder
the musics i like more is in this order
1 paper: just wanted to be longer
2 mechanic: looks like apocalipse machine
3 organic: this phase is too short to hear the music if was longer. imagined this playing in the hospital in the room of somebody is close to die
4 clay
If I was on my deathbed and I heard specimen organic, I would die a happy man
Mechanic = Wild West stereotypes + Ultrakill
1. Clay
2. Mechanical
3. Paper
4. Organic
5. Polygonal
6. Patchworked
Swap 5 and 6 to get my list lmao
Clay hits different
can we just agree that clay is the best specimen?
No
Yes@@Foxyerik13
@@LordNdeymar no
Yesnt, mechanical is top tier too
@@PaperMaskOnYT personally o think polygonal is the best and did not deserve to be that low
the clay voices are probably just jevil voicelines but HEAVILY edited
Does sound like him at times
All of the specimens were kind of goofy except mechanical.
A demented flower face made of paper or clay isn't that intimidating
But a bullet is, and this flowers face is a gatling gun.
Clay is not the best for me tbh.
I prefer organic (pls don't hate me)
And I can't believe that he put polygonal in the last bro
Bro wtf
Top 6 My Opinion
1. Clay
2. Mechanical
3. Polygonal
4. Paper
5. Patchworked
6. Organic
Patchworked on 3 and paper on 4 would be perfect
@@PaperMaskOnYT patchworked sounds like a walmart clay but i can still see your opinion
Mine
1. Patchedwork
2. Mechanical
3.Clay
4.Organic
5.Paper
6.polygonal
@@PaperMaskOnYT But Paper is already on four
Specimen polygonal sounds like PS1 action rpg boss fight
From my favorite to least favorite:
Mechanical, Clay, Organic (works well with its theming), Patchworked, Paper, Polygonal.
Im sorry, not to be rude or anything, but if your gonna roast organic then you should at least put it at last. You said good things about the other ones before this and then you start roasting it. How did that make sense???
For the previous two songs(polygonal and patchworked), I commented on how they fit. Organic, meanwhile, has a value to me that I can only explain with: it's the first specimen song I listened to. For the other two, I don't care about them along with the phases themselves. Organic, before I listened to the other specimen songs, was #1 in my ranking. Now that I've analyzed all the songs, I feel #4 is the highest spot to put organic in. And yes, the roasting was meant to kinda show how all the previous songs are really nothing compared to my top 3, in my opinion. I hope that answered your question, or at least gave you an idea of why I put organic where it is.
I think I can hear the first part of the lyrics at 3:14 :D
Molding, shaping, (x2)
Molding, molding, molding, scuplting
Molding, shaping, (x2)
Molding, molding, molding, scuplting
really i always was thinking it FUN FUN FUN FUN MADE WITH THE FEELING OF HAVING FUN
AFter them, I can hear
Made with the clay, I can see.
Made with the feeling of having fun
I think the first part has to be:
"Let's play, let's play do-dodge the bullets!"
"Let's play, let's play do-dodge the bullets!"
And the second part I'm unaware of, but @coolman-kw1cc 's reply sounded the most likely:
"Made with the clay, I can see.
Made with the feeling of having fun."
It looks like Clover has already heard enough of these horrors :)))
Clay has prunsep in it
Organic theme is horrible.its just a heartbeat moniter,
imagined you are dying and starts playing this music
3° best music
Why did it became the binding of issac.
THAT THE WHOLE POINT BUD IT SUPPOSED TO GIVE OFF THAT YOUR ON LIFE SURPORT ORGANIC IS A RETRIAL HEART IN THE SHAPE OF A FLOWER
1- Clay
2- Every other song
1,000- Organic
1- Polygonal
2-Clay
3-Paper
4-Organic
5-Mechancal
6-Patchwork
Im Sorry that clay isn't higher. I just think That Polygonal is Creeper and is more fiting
Awwwww man
@@Shrezin I'm sorry
@@Shrezin organic sucks
@@jillschwartzers9060 "Creeper"
1- Polygonal
2- Mechanical
3- Clay
4- Paper
5- Organic
6- Patchworked
0- Afterlife. Best of all
My Lil bro loves undertale, i told him About this fangame and.. well...................
polygonal is underrated
organic sounds good to deaf people
clay number one
patchwork is meh
paper is eminem
Mechanical?
polygonal is not underatted if you seen all this comment in here .-.
and yeah patchwork is mid we already got a your best friend remix with the phase 1 i dunno why we need ANOTHER ONE
Polygonal is OVERRATED
3:19 Says ( Made with blood )
No its made to forget born to forget today well make some pie
Dun, dun, Da! Dun, da, dun dadadadadada!
Finally some paper appreciation
mechanacal just sounds like flowey is having a stroke
Organic is underrated
#0 : AFTERLIFE (Meta Flowey)
Great, now rank MOTI’s lyrical versions
organic looks like super meat boy forever art style
For a person that has watched the 2 seasons of gravity falls I must say mechanical looks like the show tbh
The patchworked flowey reminds me of the movie coraline
patchworked is definitely the most kid friendly out of the specimens, in my opinion
Swap Paper and Mechanical and we have the same opinion!
My ranking:
1. Clay (Hell yeah!)
2. Mechanical (Also hell yeah!)
3. Paper (Goes hard)
4. Organic (Fits the stage really well)
5. Patchworked (Bad)
6. Polygonal (Worst Undertale Yellow song in existence)
Edit: WAIT I JUST REALIZED MY LIST IS THE SAME AS THE VIDEO LMAOOOOOOO
i really like polygonal
The polygonal one is supposed to be creepy bud and bro that song hits for me like it fits so well
the meatl specimen relly reminds me of horrortale tbh
My top 6
1 - Clay
2 - Patchwork (The doll thing one)
3 - Polygonal
4 - Paper
5 - Flowey But Gun (The Flowey with holes)
6 - Organic
HEY >:( Specimen patchworker its not bad but seriously you put the heart HIGHER?
The heart is literally just a drum beat with life support sounds, it SUCKS
@@gavinhenry9875 yea, i agree with that
organic good
My list is: (based on how hard it was)
1:Paper (yes.)
2:Polygonal
3:Mechanical
4:Organic
5:Clay
6:Patchworked
my list on how hard it was when i played it:
1. Patchworked (went insane)
2. Polygonal (same as patchworked)
3. Paper (it was actually hard)
4. Clay (the red parts kept disappearing)
5. Mechanical (wasn't that hard)
6. Organic (didn't take damage at all)
My list on how hard it was when i first played it:
1. Clay (the only one where i actually died)
2. Paper (it was kinda crazy)
3. Organic (the purple virus really made it difficult to dodge)
4. Polygonal (took damage but it wasn't really that hard)
5. Mechanical (a few saws caught me off guard, but other than that, it was easy)
6. Patchworked (i just stood behind the hands that were aiming in my direction)
imo clay is the hardest because of these freaking annoying blue and orange thingies
valid
it's supposed to be creepy
don't do organic like that 😭
Its not that scary bro chill
I was exaggerating my fear for polygonal.
It's not that scary, you're right, just tryin to make it funnier. Evidently, that failed.
@@Bluespade24 you should be exaggerating because i kid you not that one phase actually gave me nightmares
Polygon specimen is the best imo
Same😊
NO
the specimen songs are probably my least favorite songs in the entire game. They aren't bad music, they just aren't as good as the rest of the soundtrack.
*But clay-*
so this song th-cam.com/video/7igkrXICjLk/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Se0M2ozaGsnFLFCf is better than clay?????
@@Elon_sans this is not in Undertale Yellow.
But I like polygornal
Same here. For some reason hes only caring about the battle, not the music
Polygonal sucks idk what dimension ur in
You suck idk how you exist
stop hating on this comment just because they have a opinion grahhh
im just gonna say
polygonal is overrated as fuck
finally somebody who agrees that polygonal is the worst one
I bet a 5yr old made this
he got scared of the specimen polygonal
Im not 5 and this was coincidentally my exact same list
@@FireLordSSBU replying to a 6 month old comment is crazy 😭
1. Clay
2. Paper
3. Patchworked
4. Polygonal
5. Mechanical
6. Organic
Best list, yes
The fuck did Mechanical do to you?
@@Thestuffdoer its his opinion bozo
@@tonhunguyenngoctonhu-zl5cg How can I remove the right to have opinions?
@@Thestuffdoer You can't you idiot, the only ways are either convince them. Or deal with it
1. Mechanical
2. Paper
3. Polygonal
4. Patchworked
5. Clay
6. Organic
1. Paper
2. Polygonal
3. Clay
4.Patchwork
5. Organic
6. Mechanical
NOOOOO MECHANICAL SECOND
@ it used to be, but then MOTI’s BFF with lyrics came out and I moved Polygonal up many spots