Speaking as a professional sailor who's been living the life for ten years: This movie is 100% dead on accurate to what being a sailor is like. It's absolutely wonderful to the point that it's recommended viewing in the fleet I work in. I was working as an Oiler when I first saw this and the way the Fireman describes doing a watch is perfect.
You're not wrong either, I did an apprenticeship up on the lakes and sailed around the world on Car Carriers and and on a tug now, this movie really nails how Merchant Mariners talk amongst ourselves
10 years on the ore boats on the lakes. Started as an OS at 18 my senior year of high school. Some of these men were on the boats when I first started out. Makes me miss those wide eyed times hauling cable trying not to screw up. Those days made me who I am and taught me more than any college degree could.
I watch this movie as the twilight of my own sailing career has passed me by. It’s so accurate in the depictions of the ridiculous things you talk about while you build a bond that you didn’t know was possible. I miss the guys from the Lee Tregurtha every day.
i dont know, but to me this movie is way better than most, so what theres no real story line, the dialogues and the unpolitical correct scenes, i love this movie!! a breath of fresh air, thanks for posting!!
Star ships: 9:21 M/V Canadian Trader 9:43 SS Seaway Queen 11:56 M/V Stephen B. Roman 35:46 M/V Atomic 55:50 M/V Canadian Trader 56:17 M/V Ebony Ray??? (I'm not good with salties, lmk if I'm wrong) 56:51 once again, I'm not good with salties so lmk what ship this is 1:23:40 SS Algoriver "Mail boat" that keeps being mentioned is most likely the M/V J. W. Wescott
I used to own this film on DVD and really enjoyed it. Since losing my copy, I've looked online for years to replace it. I haven't seen it commercially available (even my copy was an Academy Screener). I like the shipboard scenes and representation of 'life aboard' more than the Garcia-led subplot or cuss-heavy dialogue. The main plot, like much D Mamet, is adventuresome, but many of the shotgun-blast, jabber-heavy, episodic encounters with shipmates (ostensibly meant to be sole shots at character development for cursory crew-members) fall short of typical Mamet charm and believability. The Tony Mamet/Forster interactions come off best, which is certainly a key intent of the piece, but I can't help feeling minor adjustments in the storytelling would have greatly improved the overall impact of the film. The cast is great, the acting is quite enjoyable and, though I'm not familiar with David Mamet's source material, perhaps still it's Mamet's own screen adaptation and Joe Montegna's freshman attempt at direction, or simply the Final Cut, that is at issue (I doubt like hell Mamet/Montegna ended up with Final Cut power). It's a very good film, but minor shifts in focus would have given this inland sea indie far more tonnage. As an aside, this film used the Seaway Queen to film the realistic, onboard scenes. After filming and a couple more years in layup in Toronto, the ship was towed to India for scrap. www.boatnerd.com/pictures/fleet/seaqun.htm
Damn I loved this movie, my dad was a boatman for some time, I think of him and miss him watching this excellent movie, your comments is so right on, thank you Mr. mcnarie
Nothing greatly HAPENIN here However, I took a lot of screenshots and they will be made into beautyfully ATHMOSPEHERIC DRAWINGS, Later to be made , maybe, into canvasses so in THAT.. Mamet WAS inspiring. Ps Note Men attempt to talk abt their interior Life But ...as there ain t much there in terms of Reflection...it all remains tentative. Any attempt at introspection ..doomed by their OBSEESION with genitals
My man trying to tell a story but keeps losing his train of thought , a story with no end. ahh wheres he now i dont know. Drinking dont talk about drinking. its going to be a long ship ride. out an back . silly. man this is some story. weak but the ship has got nuts all over. Sounds like old lady's repeating the same blah blah stuff an yak yak . ohh my lord really. Dang. Do what i say , not as i do.
If it's not to your taste then it's not to your taste, but I promise you the writing is sublime, just inarguably among the greatest scripts ever filmed. Now, if you don't like raw fish, the very best sushi in the world is gonna taste gross to you, and that's just the way of things.
Pretty lame except for the shipboard and ship shots. Poor plot and story development. Thankfully, a better movie is now in pre-production by a Canadian producer and film company although sadly, a steam powered lakeboat on the Canadian side no longer exists!
@@ausendundeinenacht1 women dont work on freighters and lakeboats, this movie is more interesting for ship enthusiasts and freighter hands and workers such as myself
An outstanding film if you've sailed on a merchant ship - it's one of those movies where it just gets it, but I can see how it would be boring and undriven to most. This is hands down a love letter to everyone's first trip on a working ship
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA Finals D1 | Fall | ยิงต้องโหด ให้เหมือนโกรธกันมาก่อน](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OnTdfGySmds/mqdefault.jpg)
Speaking as a professional sailor who's been living the life for ten years: This movie is 100% dead on accurate to what being a sailor is like. It's absolutely wonderful to the point that it's recommended viewing in the fleet I work in. I was working as an Oiler when I first saw this and the way the Fireman describes doing a watch is perfect.
GEEKY Geek
You're not wrong either, I did an apprenticeship up on the lakes and sailed around the world on Car Carriers and and on a tug now, this movie really nails how Merchant Mariners talk amongst ourselves
10 years on the ore boats on the lakes. Started as an OS at 18 my senior year of high school. Some of these men were on the boats when I first started out. Makes me miss those wide eyed times hauling cable trying not to screw up. Those days made me who I am and taught me more than any college degree could.
I watch this movie as the twilight of my own sailing career has passed me by. It’s so accurate in the depictions of the ridiculous things you talk about while you build a bond that you didn’t know was possible. I miss the guys from the Lee Tregurtha every day.
agreed, I can watch this movie over and over, thanks Luke, I'm a huge Hank Williams SR fan myself also, cheers!
Great dialogue. An immensely underrated movie.
i dont know, but to me this movie is way better than most, so what theres no real story line, the dialogues and the unpolitical correct scenes, i love this movie!! a breath of fresh air, thanks for posting!!
That's me in the bar scene with Andy Garcia. 🤣
Star ships:
9:21 M/V Canadian Trader
9:43 SS Seaway Queen
11:56 M/V Stephen B. Roman
35:46 M/V Atomic
55:50 M/V Canadian Trader
56:17 M/V Ebony Ray??? (I'm not good with salties, lmk if I'm wrong)
56:51 once again, I'm not good with salties so lmk what ship this is
1:23:40 SS Algoriver
"Mail boat" that keeps being mentioned is most likely the M/V J. W. Wescott
I used to own this film on DVD and really enjoyed it. Since losing my copy, I've looked online for years to replace it. I haven't seen it commercially available (even my copy was an Academy Screener).
I like the shipboard scenes and representation of 'life aboard' more than the Garcia-led subplot or cuss-heavy dialogue. The main plot, like much D Mamet, is adventuresome, but many of the shotgun-blast, jabber-heavy, episodic encounters with shipmates (ostensibly meant to be sole shots at character development for cursory crew-members) fall short of typical Mamet charm and believability. The Tony Mamet/Forster interactions come off best, which is certainly a key intent of the piece, but I can't help feeling minor adjustments in the storytelling would have greatly improved the overall impact of the film.
The cast is great, the acting is quite enjoyable and, though I'm not familiar with David Mamet's source material, perhaps still it's Mamet's own screen adaptation and Joe Montegna's freshman attempt at direction, or simply the Final Cut, that is at issue (I doubt like hell Mamet/Montegna ended up with Final Cut power). It's a very good film, but minor shifts in focus would have given this inland sea indie far more tonnage.
As an aside, this film used the Seaway Queen to film the realistic, onboard scenes. After filming and a couple more years in layup in Toronto, the ship was towed to India for scrap. www.boatnerd.com/pictures/fleet/seaqun.htm
+mcnarie PS- a big Thank You for posting this in its entirety. I hope one day to see it available for purchase.
Damn I loved this movie, my dad was a boatman for some time, I think of him and miss him watching this excellent movie, your comments is so right on, thank you Mr. mcnarie
I gotta tell ya, the captain looks kinda like Denis Hale (the sole survivor of the Morell)
Mamet is a genius at dialogue. And what a cast!.....
This movie captured the better and accurate parts of the life man.
50:32 the guy on the right lost that hand of war, but he took the cards
love this flick,got to live this life some, still vacation on Ontario,knew a couple of guys not to far away from the fellows portrayed.
Great film
Great movie. Thanks.
32:10 the best advice you could ever give a young man.
_Columbo under cover?_
34:52, 35:25, 55:51
Good movie. Underrated. The nice weather in the movie is a bit of a misrepresentation. Those lakers go through a lot of nasty weather even in summer.
Isn’t always bad. Saw some seas in June on Superior but saw some really nice days too
Mamet, Mamet, I say.
gigglianneee.. snow ball ))))))
What does w.a.y. chicago mean?
Nothing greatly HAPENIN here
However, I took a lot of screenshots
and
they will be made into beautyfully ATHMOSPEHERIC DRAWINGS, Later to be made , maybe, into canvasses
so
in THAT.. Mamet WAS inspiring.
Ps
Note
Men attempt to talk abt their interior Life
But
...as there ain t much there in terms of Reflection...it all remains tentative.
Any attempt at introspection ..doomed by their OBSEESION with genitals
Please consider clarity and spelling over typographical acrobatics.
Yes!!!!!!!!!
My man trying to tell a story but keeps losing his train of thought , a story with no end. ahh wheres he now i dont know. Drinking dont talk about drinking. its going to be a long ship ride. out an back . silly. man this is some story. weak but the ship has got nuts all over. Sounds like old lady's repeating the same blah blah stuff an yak yak . ohh my lord really. Dang. Do what i say , not as i do.
I watched about 30 mins but I just cannot get into this movie. I like several of the actors but the writing is terrible.
If it's not to your taste then it's not to your taste, but I promise you the writing is sublime, just inarguably among the greatest scripts ever filmed.
Now, if you don't like raw fish, the very best sushi in the world is gonna taste gross to you, and that's just the way of things.
Pretty lame except for the shipboard and ship shots. Poor plot and story development. Thankfully, a better movie is now in pre-production by a Canadian producer and film company although sadly, a steam powered lakeboat on the Canadian side no longer exists!
@@ausendundeinenacht1 and 5 cat videos later we have a...?
@@ausendundeinenacht1 women dont work on freighters and lakeboats, this movie is more interesting for ship enthusiasts and freighter hands and workers such as myself
An outstanding film if you've sailed on a merchant ship - it's one of those movies where it just gets it, but I can see how it would be boring and undriven to most. This is hands down a love letter to everyone's first trip on a working ship
This film nails the merchant marine banter perfectly
Alphena, Arthur M Anderson, Wilfred Sykes and a few others are still steam-powered my friend