Breath of the Wild VS Ocarina of Time (Comparison)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 พ.ค. 2024
- Breath of the Wild challenges Ocarina of Time for the throne of The Legend of Zelda Series! Welcome to our new series Game VS GAME!
Support the series on Patreon: / commonrealm
Subscribe to Commonwealth Realm!:
bit.ly/Commonrealm
Follow CR on twitter!
/ commonrealm
Big thanks for composing intro and transition Music:
to Cleffernotes
bit.ly/BreathSwitch - เกม
Game VS Game - Episode 2: Smash Melee vs Smash Wii U is now up!
Watch: th-cam.com/video/iGvOunY8bLY/w-d-xo.html&t
im exited for a more linear story in the dlc pack 2
Commonwealth Realm I
Commonwealth Realm 5:46 don't rub in salt😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭-MMMMMMIIIIIIIPPPPPPHHHHHAAAAAA-
Commonwealth Realm In my view I feel that breath of the wild kinda let me down. First off when I was fighting the yiga clan guys boss I had a harder time with his minions then the boss. And the Devine beasts were good well done. But ganon I was let down it was too easy. All you had to do was keep moving to the side or away from ganon then you can't loose. And if you slipped up, all you had to do was use a hearty food and get all your hearts back and some. Then with the dark beast ganon he can't even hit you so all you have to do is equip the light bow that you get from ganon then shoot the glowing spots from a distance away.
YAAAAAHHHHHH BotW BEAT OoT
I realized that the actual winner here is you and me, for being able to play these masterpieces!
Link this is beautiful
*facepalm*Well Who Is He...?
Stupid and corny dude please go somewhere else..
Link I wasted my time playing the boring and repetitive BotW.
Link you can talk!?!?!?!
OoT was the game that blew my mind. Nothing since has had the same impact.
I think if you played both for the first time now the BoTW is obviously light years ahead in graphics and world design.
But as a 12 year old in 1998, OoT was at the right place and right time for me.
The power of nostalgia. I felt that way myself. But when you look at the sheer numbers and the fact that I have been playing this game non-stop since its launch and still find new secrets and content, is what makes it the ultimate experience for me. It is incredibly close though, the ending of BotW was not on par with the rest of the game. And replacing the dungeons with divine beasts was a mistake.
Commonwealth Realm I would love to see Ocarina of Time remade/reimagined with the BotW engine. It seems a shame for all the development in that engine and for only one game to be made. Then it would have the best of both worlds.
I hpe there will be another Zelda game with extensive time travel.
Majors Mask was the exact same engine as OoT
@@ItsameAlex oot's time travel wasn't "exstensive", it was actually quite underutilized. If you want a zelda game where time travel is actually used to it's full potential play oracle of ages, that game had way better time traveling mechanics than oot.
I was an idiot and broke the ice blocks with arrows for vah ruta
gabecraft9's Channel Me too then I saw a video and was like 🤦🏻♂️
gabecraft9's Channel tbh I just deflected them with weapons. Lol.
Nice one. At first I didn't even know I was supposed to break them. XD
Same
The Immortal One same
After playing Ocarina all the way through for the first time this year, I can say that Ocarina is more "badass", if you will, hero game that tests the player through memorable dungeons and plot points that seem overwhelming at first but are so satisfying to beat and leave you feeling accomplished, like a hero. Breath of the wild is the adventurer's and tinkerer's game that brilliantly uses physics and elements to forge your own path in a sandbox like world. However, Ocarina does have some good exploration elements and BOTW has some good hero moments. Both do different things brilliantly.
All OoT is just nostalgia, that is the main reason people put it so highly. I first played it on the 3ds, so I didn’t get that feeling. Also, I have to give it to you, the bosses and dungeons in BotW suck. But, the immersive and giant world makes it way better than OoT for me.
@@accidentalgenius2976 the giant world isnt supplemented with anything truly rewarding. Weapon durability system is not good. Lack of enemy and dungeon variety and a good story is what will forever hold this game back from claiming the highest peak of the Zelda franchise. Im sorry.
@@sora3354 Ok
@@sora3354 that’s your opinion
@@accidentalgenius2976 Lmao. Ok. Well thats your opinion on Oot too.
Put OoT main quest, temples and bosses in Botw overworld and boom! Best game ever!
Maybe a little deeper story and some more settlements (Castle Town) and I agree.
Commonwealth Realm
Definitely more settlements!
Botw does have more villages and random houses but they're in ruins :(
If we could explore them in their former glory, it would be perfect!
The sidequests were very childish and in your face, like ''here's a sidequest''. The next Zelda should get inspiration from tales of symphonia.
Yes pls 🙂
Linksoer YES. Just imagine what Nintendo could do with their next big Zelda game. In BotW, they built an amazing world with fun exploration and great gameplay. But they really failed to deliver when it came to dungeons and story. If Nintendo learns from their mistakes, they could make the greatest game of all time.
*_Both great games, and I am glad both were introduced in my life 😃_*
Weege220/YTB omg your still here with bold font😶🌚
Alex VanManen *_Indeed ✌_*
Weege220/YTB
*_I'm glad that I know the Zelda series in general!_*
Mojtaba Mortada *Who doesn't 😃*
Mojtaba Mortada Zelda for dayz
To be honest even though the main story of botw is just his captured memories, i can feel the sadness.. Especially of those late champions.. Guess it was effective for me
Absolutely man
The story in BOTW may be all over the place, but if you piece it all together, you will find it to be an amazing story.
dude, when zelda cried in link's arms, I cried too, that shit was too powerful for me, oh it broke my heart.
I agree. OoT might have the technically better constructed story, BotW just had a better emotional impact to me and got me more invested in the characters.
People bitching about everything in the comments, it's very hard to compare two games with nearly a 20 years gap, technology changes, ideas change, both games are great and most importantly, very experimental, OOT set the bar for modern Zelda games, BOTW is a reinvention of the franchise, future games will probablh be even better, people simply gotta love them both
I am Alive No we do not have to love both. I hate one of them.
Sorry oot even back then had odd game design choices
I have to disagree about *OOT* set the bar for modern Zelda games, IMO Every Zelda game set the bar for something, for example *ALTTP* set the bar for Big Open world and traviling between Light and dark worlds that has never been seen before.
Nice, completely ignore the video's question to state the obvious.
You belong in the Nintendo fan base.
infinite weapon grind loop game play is a step backwards in evolution. this game is far from a masterpiece on most levels except the physics which aren't the greatest ever developed, mind you.
You CANT compare masterpieces together. You just cant
Kreacher Potter just did
Luuk Dikken :(((((
Kreacher Potter agreed
Botw is no masterpiece it´s amazing and really good but just a little overhyped cause it has its little issues imo.
Kreacher Potter only one is a masterpiece... I'll let you guys fight over which one
Ocarina of Time is the game that started my love for The Legend of Zelda series. ❤
wind waker for me
Twilight Princess for me.
My 1st Zelda game was ALBW. That started my love for LoZ. OoT was my 2nd Zelda game, and that made me love the series even more.
Original Nes Zelda hooked me from the get go.
I feel bad because Breath of the Wild for me
Ocarina was such a amazing game growing up and still holds up rather well
I don't personally think "no voice acting" constitutes a weakness, especially in a Zelda game.
I kind of have to disagree with the replay value of botw. The best moments in this game came from the sense of discovery and constantly finding new things while exploring. I just don't think that can be recaptured in another play through after one devotes hundreds of hours to the game only to start over. Fun video as always tho boys!
Johnny totally agree!!
Johnny I disagree. I beat the game with all the shrines, memories, and such and started a new file. I just recently beat the game again with the new file. you wouldn't believe the new discoveries I made simply by playing the game a different way and making different choices.
It all depends on how you play kinda like Skyrim. It have replayed Skyrim far to many times and I still haven't seen everything in that game. The same could easily go for Breath of the Wild.
Well to be honest I haven't started my round 2 yet with botw and likely won't until hard mode comes out but still, I feel like the addicting feeling of discovery I felt from the first play through just won't be as prevalent.
For me, BotW is easily one of the most replayable games of all time. I actually think replaying this game is more fun than continuing on the same save file forever.
I was initially a little bit sad when I first beat the game because I thought that would be it and I'd seen most of what the game had to offer, but when I started my second playthrough I ran off in a completely different direction from the plateau and was surprised how different my experience ended up being. Early game is super interesting too when everything's a bit more of a struggle and you aren't running around with an inventory full of 5-shot Lynel bows and 80 damage one-handers. I ran through locations I'd never seen/had forgotten even existed since I had usually skipped them by fast travelling.
Plus it was cool to re-experience a lot of the earlier story elements which I barely remembered because I hadn't seen them in 90+ hours of play. Playing through the game again helped me appreciate the game as a whole and I ended up liking its story a lot more, which felt a bit fragmented on my first playthrough with large spaces of time between each part.
I've since come back and done multiple playthroughs to try different things. Divine beasts in a completely different order, finding the memories in chronological order since I know where to find them now, doing a run where I went straight for Ganon after leaving the plateau, all sorts of things. I initially finished the game over 6 weeks ago now and I still find a reason to come back every day and play for at least a couple of hours, and very little of that is done on my original save file.
It's a tough one, but I have to go with Ocarina of Time.
Yea me too somthing about that LISTEN from Navi gets me everytime
@@HahnGFX it was sarcasm but thanks for basically saying why I like oot now fuck off
@@jeffpauljunior2163 why are u so pissed off 😂
For the better dialogue and story alone
It makes a better more interesting world than Breath
Ocarina of Time when I finished it was like I was saying goodbye to a lifelong friend
@Ivan Exell at least botw is getting a sequel in the same hyrule with the same link and Zelda. We never get to see the hyrule from oot again. And all the things you did in the game get left behind since link got sent to another timeline
Time to play majora’s mask :-)
@Ivan Exell what? No, I was just stating why it’s not as bad with botw
Ocarina of time was soooo good. Story wise and how it's executed is I think probably better in ocarina of time.
One thing I've found... BOTW feels too empty at times. Even in the towns, there's no one there, and because the story want as good, I didn't even want to talk to them. Heck, I barely wanted to fight anything because I know my guardian weapons will break.
Having grown up with OOT, imagine this. You're running along, you're in a dungeon, and your master sword runs out of energy. Now you're forced to use a tree branch too fight. That's why I avoid most things. Again, call me crazy.
Don't get me wrong, literally played BOTW for a week straight, but I can't help feeling like something's wrong, and I just can't put my finger on it.
i gues im not the only one. i agree with you all. breath of the wild it way too over hyped fpr what it is
This whole list is about legend of Zelda games that is way to hyped and get good ratings based on nostalgic or graphics
I went exploring the castle in botw and accidentally finished the game when I very easily beat Ganon on the first try. I was shocked because I thought it was a mini-boss, not the final boss. Anyway since I completed both games. I'll say OOT is a better game with very interactive NPCs that always have something relevant to say. BOTW NPC was depressingly boring and repetitive. BOTW has a nice open world but the towns and the NPCs in them are very few and boring.
*_I love this intro! :D For me both Games are majestic and and have shaped Gaming World more than any games. Those are not just Games, those Games are art._*
GameToon Well thats just my opinion ^^ I think BotW shaped gaming.
+GameToon I think it did, perhaps not in terms of graphics, artstyle or gameplay. But in terms of physics engine and AI it seriously changed the way I look at an open-world game. I can't think of any other open world games out there where the weather can impact the player in so many ways, or where the AIs are so great. Breath of The Wild's attention to detail is superior in comparison to any modern open world game.
Anyhting that's logical works.
Link Don't forget that you can go anywhere anytime after you've got the paraglider, and the only things hindering you are stamina, enemies and weather changes!
Visually, there is no comparison to make here... Oot was a clunky, poorly designed offense to the franchise. They should have let the same 4-year-olds who designed the gameplay do the art in finger-paints (then it might have been bearable to watch)...
BotW is everything that the original wanted to be, but couldn't do to technological restraints.
So many people out there have never played the first 3 console titles; they need to stop touting OoT as the "be-all-end-all" and start playing the games that truly represent the series!
Also, stop complaining about the "lack of story" in BotW. This is Nintendo's chance to say, "Sorry about 'Ocarina' and 'Majora.' Let's continue on the path that 'Wind Waker' began to carve and move on to something worthy of the franchise's history."
etymike OOT is exactly where it wants to be visually due to the 3DS remake. How is Botw the definitive OOT they are completely different. There is nothing wrong with people critiquing Botw's lack of story. We all know Nintendo could've done much better storywise. Why would Nintendo be sorry about two of it's "greatest hits" games? OOT was and still is a great game. Of course it's not going to be as advanced as Botw due to the technological advances in between the two games time. And why are you implying that OOT one the the highest rated games of all time isn't worthy of the franchise's history?
ive clocked 300 hours into breath of the wild and im STILL finding locations and quests i had no idea existed.
I played the game for 540 hours I still keep finding korok seeds
i have a total of 370 hours on my switch and 130 on my wii u
@@icefresh-nr1to how are you seeing how long you're playing
@@777sn2 somewhere in the settings of the Nintendo switch and Wii U tells you how much you been playing the games
@@thunder45728 thanks
I honestly fill Nintendo should just do a complete remake of Ocarina Of Time from the ground up. Imagine Hyrule town inside the castle completely alive with people talking, interactions with them all, and it being twice as bigger inside the town with a lot going on and a lot of mini games, and even a bar/pub to have drinks at before going to the castle. Imagine the same with the villages again with grass everywhere, fireflies and bugs crawling on the logs, and trees, just imagine this. Make the villages twice as big as well again with bars, pubs everywhere, and bring back the same bosses updated and more challenging. OOT is already the greatest Zelda game of all time with the best temples, best music of all Zelda games, and best bosses, I'd love to see it completely remade with the newest graphics, and more bigger areas.
The only problem I have with Breath of the Wild is that it doesn't have that "Zelda" feeling. The dungeons, the music, and the story just don't feel like a Zelda game.
Finnaly someone understands
I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE
There's no denying it's a great game, but I never found it great. I had so much trouble finding motivation to finish it because it didn't give me anything like what the other games had given me. It may have been my fault for going into the game thinking it would be anything like them, but if I didn't have those "Zelda game" expectations towards this game, then it' wouldn't have been a Zelda game to me
I dont care about that because its a good game
No.
I came into this skeptical. You guys did a good job of being objective with both games. It's so easy to have rose-tinted glasses for either newer things or nostalgia.
It took me 348 hours to 100% complete Breath of the Wild...I enjoyed playing Majora's Mask + Ocarina of Time more than BotW.
The thing is that you can play BotW differently everytime you begin a new save file. And that alone has to be commenced. You don't have to 100% BotW (actually I wouldn't recommend doing it). My mentality to this game, is to play as if I was living in Hyrule. Taking one day at a time and enjoying each moment to the fullest.
If you enjoyed ocarina and Majora's mask more then why did you play breathe of the wild for 348 hours??
@@commonwealthrealm You wouldn't recommend it because it's garbage. Its open world gameplay is repetitive and strewn about with unintelligent design choices. It isn't well put together for the most part. Korok seeds are full of repetitive puzzles, shrines are full of puzzles that can be solved in multiple ways, so the puzzles are in general simplistic because the game doesn't confine you to solve them like a real puzzle should. Cheesing puzzles is not good game design.
@@rpgfanatic9719 you do realize you are replying to a 4 year comment right?
LOL
Honestly I prefer Majora's mask over all of them... the story is amazing, the characters are interesting and grow more than in OoT and the sidequests mixed with the 3 day cycle that makes you want to end the apocalypse and save the people inside of the world knowing their stories and struggles. Not to mention the amazing mask collection and mask powers.
Ocarina of Time: Best songs
Breath of the wild : Best gameplay
Oot had a better story too tho
Better dungeons and bosses.
BOTW has better open world mechanics (especially when compared to other open world games), and it has a better art style.
I agree with Hero Of Time. Also Breath of the wild has a better story aswell. Ocarina has a great story but Breath of the Wild has a much more interesting story.
Playing BotW feels like such a tribute to the rest of the Zelda franchise too, especially OoT, though they missed a few opportunities like the lost woods theme. ClefferNotes made a brilliant piece of fan music for it.
I love OOT. And I've defended it for years from people trying to say it doesn't deserve it's praise.
But think BOTW is far superior. I'd gladly sacrifice a linear story for the ultimate level of freedom that BOTW gave us. It's not like the story in Zelda has ever been mind blowing anyway, especially in recent years.
As for dungeons, I don't miss longer dungeons one bit. A lot of the dungeon length is just padding and puzzles that are more tedious than challenging. Divine beasts are fast paced without much filler between puzzles. The only problem with Divine Beasts I have is that they all look the same, even in the boss department. Obviously this is something that's going to change in the next Zelda, but I hope they don't go back to dungeons that take 40 minutes to an hour.
Divine beasts were trash just totally forgettable!.. its been 20 years n still people fondly remember the Forest Temple, Spirit Temple, Water etc.. they were epic!!.. you think 20 years from now people will be talking about the divine beasts from Botw??.. yeah right
probably
You remember the Forest Temple because it had good atmosphere and good bosses. But from a level design standpoint it was pretty fucking awful. I'm not saying the Divine beasts are more memorable. But they're definitely more fun to play through from a gameplay standpoint. I don't have to slowly pushy blocks down corridors for five minutes just to make a staircase. And there's no backtracking because I forgot a key.
If the Divine Beasts weren't all aesthetically boring with bosses that were the same, you'd all be crowing about how Aonuma knocked it out of the park again. Personally I'd rather go through all four divine beasts than a single dungeon in any of the prior Zelda games.
lol seem to me that you do remember it fondly since everyone is still talking about the water temple that no one seem to like to this very day. I actually liked it because it was so fucking hard and that last key was a nightmare if you don't pay attention to everything around you. Big troll. ha ha behind the treasure box wow.
How can one be so wrong? You'd rather go through the worst dungeons the series has to offer over the much more unique, fun and creative dungeons in every other Zelda game? I'm sorry my friend but you've clearly been blindsided
I enjoyed BOTW but OOT holds a special place in my heart that hasn't been replaced...and probably never will.
Reese Anderson so, nostalgia
lee gaming no
I beat super mario galaxy when I was 7 loz can be pretty intense and scary at tines heck in tp there is blood
mixel XD that's good mixel
So, nostalgia?
I've always liked a story that is linear. I think ocarina is best for my style of play and desire of story mode. But that's all my preference. I don't mind side quests, but too much freedom is more frustrating for me when I'm trying to engage in a story of growth.
I actually completely agree. It destroys the story, the pacing, and the build-up, if you give the player complete freedom. Idk why “open world games” are so trendy- they kinda suck
A story needs to have a combination of linear requirements, and also freedom in the meantime. (OOT did this very well.) This gives the feeling of freedom, without allowing that freedom to destroy the story and make the game feel pointless.
BOTW should have used today’s graphics & power of the “Nintendo Switch”, to basically be a bigger version of OOT, with bigger dungeons, bigger open world, etc but still keeping linearity and great dungeon design. They blew it
Breath of the Wild wins objectively in a lot of these categories, but OoT simply was so much more *ahem* breathtaking in its time. I love BoTW, but honesty so many aspects weren't varied enough: bosses, towns, dungeons, sidequests, music... etc. OoT just was so much more memorable and wins.
The bosses and dungeons were completely different. Please don't judge them by similar names.
HeavyDonkeyKong uh, what? That's exactly my point. Different doesn't mean they can't be compared.
@Tim Braun - Definitely agree with you, well put.
Key words are in its time. They are incomparable masterpieces that are good in their own separate ways.
WTF u must be a ten year old anyone who’s played a good amount of the Zelda franchise knows a game with no musical instrument BOTW) and shitty dungeons is not the best Zelda no chance
oot is the better zelda, botw is the better game
Pixel 1606 finally. Someone understood.
Pixel 1606 thank you finally someone understand
agreeeeed
yeah both are the best
Well actually... breath of the wild is more of a zelda game than ocarina of time if we compare them to the original's idea...
I'm honestly on the other end when it comes to replayability. As someone who doesn't have the time to play games 24/7, I'm okay with getting games that are only worth playing through once. As long as that "once" is lengthy, entertaining and I can do it how I want. BotW and Fallout for example. And because I don't have the time for it, I just don't feel compelled to start those games again. OoT on the other hand, having played it since I was 10, I've restarted and beaten countless times. Yes, it's because of nostalgia. But if it wasn't as fun as it is nostalgic, I wouldn't do it. (Mario games, for example, remind you of how frustrating it was when replaying rather than how much fun it was.) BotW is lengthy and feels like regardless of how many times you play it and in the different ways, you just couldn't get that nostalgia hit done in a day or two. Which is why I think OoT is better.
How is BotW lengthy when just about everyone can beat the game in 2-3 hours if they chose so.
Vytlo because it takes hundreds of hours to play all of it.
yeah but that doesn't count as actually playing the game
I am with you on this. I am married, have kids, a full-time job and an acre, and I don't have time to play games like I used to have. BotW has taken me a long time, and that is because I simply don't have long stretches of time to devote to it. As such, I don't see myself playing it again before the sequel comes out. I am getting the new incarnation of Link's Awakening tomorrow, and I'll play through that one (I haven't played it, and can't see it taking any longer than it took me to beat A Link Between Worlds). I suspect that the sequel to BotW will take me quite a while to beat, and I don't see myself dwelling on either game more than once.
I can play Ocarina of Time and beat it in a few days, as I've done so many times now. The size, familiarity and relative of ease of some of the older games makes them re-playable. I am not young and these games aren't getting any easier, and I don't see myself playing them more than once. Twice at the absolute most if they're lucky.
The impact OoT had on Zelda is something that will never be seen again, a Masterpiece like no other. Botw is an excellent game, but OoT is just too big to compare against.
The impact it had on gaming in general dude
It was the first 3D action-adventure game and it is still amazing to this day
Nostalgia, BOTW has the same impact and more
@@imascrew6218 No it hasn't. BotW hasn't revolutionised open world gaming as much as OoT had 3D gaming (Z targeting was introduced for first time).
Oot is literally the base of every timeline of Zelda series!
@@imascrew6218man says "nostalgia" while he's affected by nostalgia
"You can even fight Gannon butt ass naked if you want!"
I laughed so hard at that 😂
I laughed so LOUD at that lmaoo😂🤣
Ganon is a boss done wrong in BotW.
ThunderGun2 hope it gets better with the DLC
Not at all, I don't think. A boss doesn't have to be difficult to be fun. I loved it because it was badass. It wasn't difficult at all but I enjoyed it a lot:-)
seriouslysoph i agree
ThunderGun2 *Calamity* Ganon was a great boss. He just needed more health. Dark Beast Ganon was terrible on the other hand. You can barely classify it as a boss fight. It's more like a victory lap.
Marc Sherman they could have at least made bokoblins on horses spawn
Hope you enjoy "Game VS Game" as we have put a ton of heart and love developing it! What next, Super Metroid VS Metroid Prime or Smash Bros Melee vs Smash Bros Wii U?
Commonwealth Realm melee vs smash for wii u
Best channel ever! Super Metroid vs Prime.
Commonwealth Realm Super Metroid vs Metroid Prime
(I prefer Super Metroid btw., though both are fantastic)
Commonwealth Realm super metroid vs prime
+Commonwealth Realm Super Metroid vs Metroid Prime sounds interesting!
*plays Zelda VR 2032 edition
“2032 wins but only narrowly against OOT!”
"its a tie....so botw wins slightly"
I'm personally not that big a fan of OoT's Hyrule Field. It may be because I'm not blinded by nostalgia when it comes to this as I was born not in the 90's but the early 2000's. The area is massive, yes, but the space is filled by very little interesting things. There's that weird plant thing and Lon Lon Ranch but besides that it's a bunch of empty space. And considering the visuals of most N64 games haven't held up well these days, it just looks muddy to me nowadays. Maybe I'm just spoiled by the visual splendor of some games today but I'm a hardcore fan of Super Mario 64 and I first played it when I was four and even I can say that it looks pretty ugly sometimes. And Hyrule field just doesn't compare to some of the overworlds in later 3D Zelda games. It's kind of a quality over quantity situation here, as the field is massive but doesn't have much to do in it.
I fully agree, I was also in that nostalgia camp until I realised what sort of evolution Breath of the Wild is for the franchise. 19 years of waiting for a successor was worth it!
Well gee, thanks for the heart!
IntenseAtom33 You are not blinded by nostalgia but you are blinded by Appeal to Novelty glasses.
Commonwealth Realm Now you are in the Appeal to Novelty camp, which is also a fallacy. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_novelty
Lol Joseph. Somebody is salty over there....
I was literally just like "I really wish there was a CR video to watch" then I clicked on TH-cam and this was here
The Legend Of Zelda Ocarina Of Time will always have a special place in my heart, I've enjoyed playing the game on NINTENDO 64, Game cube, and 3DS XL. My Favorite, the NINTENDO.
To me the winner is "Legend of Zelda"!!!!!
Dungeons: OOT > BotW
World: BotW > OOT
Combat: BotW > OOT
Story: OOT > BotW
Variety: BotW > OOT
Both games are some of my favorites of all time, but I like Breath of the Wild better.
Game Domain Agreed
Game Domain NPC's: BOTW > OOT ?! This must be a joke?
I heard about this thing called opinion. You might want to look it up.
In all honesty, when you look at the most memorable NPCs from each game, OOT has more memorable ones. However, BotW has a lot more, and many are creative, and have their own story.
it is a joke
Game Domain I heard about this thing called: quality over quantity.
I like how he just throws oot's soundtrack into the gameplay and world section for no reason
I haven't watched you guys in a while, but this game vs game videos reminds my why I love you guys. Your writing a cinematography is so much higher than anyone else on this style video.
The only places BotW beats OoT is in areas that OoT wasn't even capable of beating BotW because of technological limitations.
The truth is that OoT is a vastly more superior game. Its longevity, impact, music, story, and dungeons far outclass BotW. It's the game that literally invented z-targetting and pioneered 3d camera movement and open world gaming.
Not to mention, am I the only one that considers music to be a huge, important category? This is what I love about the final fantasy games as well. They truly focus on hiring fantastic composers and because of that, they end up selling sound track cds and sheet music for decades after ward. Ocarina of Time got that right. All of my favorite Zelda songs are in ocarina of time. Then again, a musical instrument is literally in the title of the game.
As a 32 year old man, who played OoT when it originally came out, I was blown away. Gaming was still mostly 2d gaming and side scroller stuff at the time and seeing this game blew my mind out of the water. Still to this day, ocarina is in my opinion, the greatest Zelda game of all time. Oh and Gannon is way better as a humanoid gerudo by the way. Especially one who politically manipulates the royal court into power. It's got a bit of Game of Thrones to it there.
Well... We can atleast agree that OoT was the BotW of it's time, right?
BUT... If I had one argument for OoT being the winner...
Saria's song. Best song in all of the LoZ franchise to me.
Specter the Spectator DAMN RIGHT SON
I prefer way more the botw’s Rito Village Theme
The only thing about Zelda BotW I`m actually pretty mad about is it not having themed dungeons. That could have made the game SO much better! Now I just hope that the winter DLC will have themed dungeons. Don't get me wrong, I like the shrines and the devine beasts but theyre just not a replacement for themed dungeons.
They wanted to change things up, and they did a good job, I think. Change isn't bad if thought-out strategically. For a while, repetition in Zelda was fine, but eventually it just becomes boring. BotW has great story, great graphics and is great interactively.
"You have to beat all prior dungeons"
Speedrunners: I beg to differ.
BotW vs OoT is simply quantity vs quality, you can hear the bias with this guy talking about how much there is to do in BotW but he fails to acknowledge the sheer simplicity and repetitiveness of it all.
As Nintendo has said the next Zelda will also be open world I think this next time around they will bring in the classic style dungeons and bosses along with the open world. They manage to nail that and they will once again have made the best game ever made.
My Name i wish the devine beast had classic temple elements, like the elephant couldve been a moving water temple
RinkuHeroOfTime Ruta IS a water temple...
but it does not really focus around water and water enemies.
I think Main quest should be valued higher than the others categories..... I at least play a game for the main quest, and OoT main quest is, by far, the best between the two....
Well, I don't think it's fair to compare them since the Main Quest in OoT is literally the entire game, while the Main Quest in BotW is, like, 3% of it.
Bruno Nakayasu Opinion. I love breaths story more.
Both are truly some of the greatest of all time, but I personally think Ocarina of Time is the better game. I found the gameplay to be outstanding. The dungeons were creative, challenging, fun and had you apply your knowledge of the game. The boss fights were also phenomenal. The final fight with Ganon was one of the best final bosses ever. The story mainly focuses on Link and Zelda and felt truly epic. I truly believe it to be better than any other Zelda game and still stands as one of the greatest video games ever.
Yep, been playing it since i was 6.
As a huge Fan of the Zelda Series, who absolutely loves both games. I feel like this is a Very Fair comparison. Well Done.
I'd love to see you tackle the issue between Smash 4 and Melee next.
Great idea for this video. I like it a lot, as a new-ish sub.
oh my goodness if you did smash 4 vs melee, you'd pick up so many new subs because both sides are so loyal.
DaemonDD There would be a lot of flame wars.
+Hylian Champion
then y?
Nostalgia is always a pretty good reason. I'd go a step beyond and say that Melee provided a superior single player experience over Smash 4, and the stage design was much more balanced overall.
But I personally prefer Smash 4 for everything else it has to offer, and I will say that Melee was my first ever Smash Bros game.
Hylian Champion thats fine. i dont have those memories because i was introduced to it like this
"hey guess what" "what?" "i just found a game like ssf2 on the wii" "really?" "yeah its called Brawl"
thats right, smash flash 2 is to me what melee is to most people
I fucking loved this video. Sory for my language I lust like all the editing, research and thought put into this video. Most youtube videos I watch don't look like this. most being short small skits that rarely look like they have been put lots of hard work in. You as a small channel (compared to others) are doing great and I wish you the best :)
It's these kind of words that motivates us to spend hour after hour to make something flow, function and ooze of quality. Thank you :)
I'm happy to make you feel that way! :)
Can we all agree that Attack on Divine Beast Vah Meadoh is one of the best sound tracks from the games ost
You can't say only some of the Sidequests aren't rewarding in BotW, MOST of them are extremely lacking in rewards. No heart pieces in the overworld or from sidequests kind of hurt the game imo.
Melee vs Sm4sh next please.
You got shrines for the Heart containers and stamina vessels. The side-quest are an economic incentive.
Commonwealth Realm I mean sure there is a small reward that is commonly rupees, but it is redundant and disappointing since you can just sell items like gems for more rupees than you will ever need.
The sidequests in BOTW are surprisingly hollow and barebones, not to mention extremely short. Honestly one of the worst parts of the game for me...
About 10 of the quests are literally [Talk to NPC] -> [Get Sidequest] -> [Talk to other NPC] -> [Sidequest complete]
Wat.
That's pathetic! I was expecting so much more!
I am fairly sure there are no side quests like that
Argon Hammer There's a sidequest where you dive into the water, and then swim back up
I can't believe it but, I think I like Ocarina of Time better.
The aspects in which Ocarina of Time is undoubtedly superior to Breath of the Wild are the same aspects that Breath of the Wild fails to deliver on, and those aspects are what make me love Zelda.
Majora's Mask is way better then either of them though.
Warren Valion majoras mask shouldn't even be in the same sentence as breath of the wild....sorry I respect your opinion but that was a dreadfully dull game for me....easily my least favorite zelda. glad u liked it though. botw and a link between world's and a link to the past are my top 3
Why?
What about those game is so appealing to you?
Same. The story and music in Ocarina is a complete feeling experience to me. Also the puzzles are better, the dungeons are better, and Ocarina just has a better feel to me. It feels like an actual world whereas Breath of the Wild doesn't due to its over abundance of Easter Eggs that shouldn't exist. Koroks, Romano Ranch, and the Twilight Mirror do not belong in the same world or story. The freedom of choice doesn't automatically make a better experience, it's how it's utilized so to me, freedom isn't an argument, it's simply a difference in gameplay elements being shown.
the groundbrraaking gameplay
I could kiss you right now.
You absolutely god damn right.
To me, Ocarina of Time is a satisfying experience that I'll remember forever, while Breath of the Wild is a engaging, but ultimately disappointing one.
Breath of the Wild's focus on freedom is one of its biggest flaws because of how the music and story is weakened to compensate for more freedom, and while their are certain benefits to this style it is not necessarily adding anything substantial in return with the open ended game play.
Y'all are forgetting the link: the faces of evil.
Sleeping on the wand of gamelon
Don’t mention the cursed triforce
just imagine how good Ocarina of Time would have been if they had today's technology. Be honest, they are too far apart in years to be a fair comparison.
It would definitely be amazing, but it would probably suffer the same way skyward sword did in that it was just too similar to the others. One of the biggest reasons oot got rated as high as it did was because it took the Zelda formula established in alttp and perfected it, and in 3D. If tp, ww, and SS had all released before oot, oot would have felt like just another Zelda game instead of THE Zelda game. Botw is sort of the oot of like alttp. It’s taken on a new form of Zelda, and it did it well. Botw 2 will most likely be like oot in that it will probably perfect the formula botw created. But if they do botw 5 more times in a row like they did with the other 3D Zeldas after oot, it will be the same SS situation all over again.
I see a lot of people hating in the comments because of the outcome of this specific episode, but take the outcome and nostalgia out of it. I love both of these games and have played both of them many times, but this series (or at least this episode) is a perfect setup for a good video game "war".
They had many different and equally important battles between the two games, and they weren't biased. They were legitimate reasonable conclusions to the battles between these two games. They didn't bash one game, they didn't say anything offensive unless you take serious offense to someone saying your favorite masterpiece is not as good as another masterpiece.
This video made a great argument for both games, and I loved the setup of how the video was made. I excitingly anticipate more episodes in this series, and you have gained my subscription and my support. Thanks for a great video, I enjoyed all 20+ minutes of it.
Landon BOTW was shit, literally the dungeons were ass. There was no ocarina whatsoever, none of the Zelda hallmark gadgets . Side missions extremely underwhelming rewards . The game was literally running around searching for shrines and finding nothing but empty fields and korok seeds give me a break
@@grindnshine5847 there's multiple towns in BOTW too, not just empty fields. You name it BOTW has it.
I haven’t played Breath of the Wild. I love the music in Ocarina of Time and Majora’s Mask. It was my favorite feature in both games. I’m worried Breath of the Wild will not have the same glorious music.
Wait... Breath of the Wild actually has MUSIC???
If you havent played yet, i can tell you it hasnt the same glorious music.
Oot soundtracks were an absolute masterpiece. Botw soundtracks come not even close. They are nothing which i would remember
Both games are legendary and epic ! So glad to have been able to play the both of them
Ohhh this was actually really really enjoyable and made some really good point. #Applauds
congrats on doing what may be considered a controversial comparison
Replayabilty tho i believe goes to ocarina it may be nostalgia talking but I've played through the game at least 10 times over the years to the point i can beat it in about 8 hours. the amount of value ive goten out of my ocarina cartridges is staggering
while botw i dont realy see picking up after its done. like ive already ran out of things todo and the plot-point and moment to moment gameplay loses its replay value after being completed i think twilight and windwaker also beat botw in this category
good video tho
Ocarina flows better and has a stellar soundtrack. When playing the game for the first time in 2013 it still felt modern and fresh. Due to the game being so captivating, I hand this one to Ocarina of time. Breath of the Wild is great too if you just want to mess around with great game mechanics, although it feels as if something's missing... oh yeah, great story and soundtrack
Ethan Bensinger The soundtracks for Breath of the Wild were fresh new and amazing. You people really need to stop being so darn nostalgic. I bet that in 10 years from now people will say that Breath of the wild's soundtracks are amazing and memorizable. Just like what happened to Ocarina of Time.
What are you talking about? the same riffs over and over again, with low energy and almost NO Feeling exist in BOTW. Here's a good point: Hateno village, the last REAL hylian settlement. It's track was completely repetitive and not well developed. I will give BOTW Only one better instance in soundtrack. And that's Hyrule castle.
Hey, I went ahead and actually Re-listened to the soundtrack, and I still feel entintled to my opinion, you cannot justify a LEGENDARY Series like the legend of zelda having this crap minimalist style. The exceptions are few and far between and most aren't real overworld themes you can hear anywhere else. Hyrule Fields OST is a DISGRACE. But I digress, my exceptions are Hyrule castle, Tarrey town. And Kass was the ONLY Reprieve out on Hyrule field from a boring minimalist soundtrack, and even HE is more repetitive than the song of storms.
BotW does have a great soundtrack when it's needed. Hearing looping music over and over in a open world wouldn't have worked.
But even the divine beasts lacked good soundtracks. There could have been different theme music in each reason, and don't bring up Goron city soundtrack. that could have been SO much better.. it was frankly pathetic. Akkala having it's own musical arrangment would have been sweet if it could have stood out.
Botw vs. Ocarina of Time?!? SOMEONE GET MY POPCORN
Tbf Botw is technically a spiritual successor of OoT made for a new generation
Eh, i think you guys are a bit biased towards Breath of The Wild since it has been literally just released. I disagree with a few main points of BTW being superior.
Vinícius Karaski I Agree, points like Voice acting and the exaggerated difficulty of bosses in botw seem bias
The voice acting is meh, even in the Japanese version. I mean I'm glad that its finally there, but they have some work to do with it.
And as for the bosses- I agree completely! The bosses in BOTW with the exception of Thunderblight Ganon were all jokes! I didn't die once on any of them! Truly disappointing...
TheMadMadman I know right? The voice acting could have been way better, imo zelda never needed it in the first place. And I guess he was considering the less skilled players when he said the bosses are hard, the ones who lose to Gohma 5 times.
+Lazarnephz I loved the difficulty in the beginning of the game- but after you gather some good weapons, better armor, cook some food, and receive some more stamina and heart containers, the game just gets pathetically easy! Looking forward to "hard mode" though...
Well, you might be right about considering the less-skilled players. I mean I just beat Dark Souls 3 in January and played BOTW in March so... that might have something to do with it. XD
I'll admit that I'm kind of disappointed in BOTW. I don't regret playing or buying it at all- but I was just expecting something a bit more well-rounded and complete, you know? Some of the decisions that were made in the making of this game were mind-boggling to be frank.
TheMadMadman Yeah, I remember I was told to power my self down by using sticks and weaker tools. I don't understand that logic at all. Yeah I hope hard mode is hard, Air dropped units, regeneration of enemy health, maybe silver enemies become gold.
I'm just naturally decent at games xD
Me too, it was all right. Haha I always think that when playing the game, why did they make so many questionable decisions?
I love this new series! Good job! And I'm say Super Metroid vs. Metroid Prime for the next one!
Both games are incredible BUT that feeling I got in 1998 with OOT is unmatched. Going from 2D to 3D was just such a massive leap!
Ocarina Of Time is without a doubt the best Zelda game ever made so far. Breath Of The Wild is close, but still can't compete to Ocarina Of Time. I don't think anyone in these comments reading this can dispute the fact that OOT has the best soundtrack and music of all Zelda games. The temple music, to the melodies you play with the ocarina and everything in between is perfect. I loved the Spirit Temple music, and Forest Temple etc... Just amazing, even the towns, villages. Also, the bosses are better designed of all these other Zelda game bosses and just look cooler in every way. However as OOT becomes more dated and more Zelda games come out, one might come out with a killer track, and cool bosses just like Ocarina did. So to me, OOT is still my favorite. Majora's Mask was a close contest but ultimately the bosses weren't as cool, the music wasn't as good except for Song Of Healing, and the lame mechanic of watching the cutscenes between switching masks and some other things overall just wasn't fun. Especially the 3 day cycle although you could slow it down, or reset it, still not fun having to do that.
Watching this video made me appreciate ocarina of time a lot more now. I always felt like it wasn’t as good as people said it was, mainly because I don’t have that much nostalgia forgiven 3-D version was the first one I played. But it actually succeeds were breath of the wild fails and I’m glad that I had the chance to play both of these amazing games.
People will judge people who favours Orcarina of time as “nostalgia” yes, it is nostalgic. But it’s just a better game.
Always will be, no other game will come close to it. Apart from majoras mask.
Could you do Breath of the Wild vs Twilight Princess vs Skyward Sword (as three different episodes)? That would be completely epic!
That is something that is very interesting now that I am finally playing BoTW, pacing in this game is a very hard subject, bc of the sheer scope of it. I am extremely glad to have played more open worlds and other zeldas to know that It would be extremely frustrating (for a fan) to not do things in certain orders... While the order of the dungeons is completely up to you, I personally have made my own "heroes journey" towards it, since... it is what feels right considering other zeldas that I have played, while I feel a lack of feedback from the world towards me I feel extremely free to interact with, which is definitely something I never really felt in other games since most of the time you are being guided through a story, while here I made my own path and my own story, while recollecting the memories of the hero that I did not have the chance to be.
Coming from someone who has played all zelda games except for skyward sword and the oracle games, Botw just doesn't have the magic and charm of other zelda games. it was fun to see a game like this but i hope that the franchise stays at its original 2d and 3d formulas.
As someone who played every Zelda game out there. Some twice or more
I agree
BOTW is probably my 3rd favorite game of all time
But man.. Does it feel like a backstab to the OG fans and the ones that fell in love with the series because of it's original Zelda game design..
BOTW is a disappointment of a Zelda game for me
But unfortunately.. Looking at it's sales
I doubt the Zelda teak will ever get back to the original Zelda game design :/
The Legend of Zelda Ocarina of TIme has the best Story Gameplay and replay Value.
I disagree with replay value
20:24 Maybe my sense of humor is awry but the way he said “Or, if you’re daring, take on Calamity Ganon butt ass neked with a stick” was hilarious
In my opinion zelda ocarina of time is better overall. All side quest in ocarina of time had a purpose where as breath of the wild you have all these side quest but rewarded with pointless items. Also the world in breath of the wild was huge I'll admit but it was really empty. In breath of the wild there are only really 3 side quests in the game the are a must to do. 120 shrines, master sword upgrade and upgrading your armour ( breath of the wild tunic I personally used ). In ocarina of time all side quests gave you useful items and upgrades every time. So in my opinion ocarina of time holds the more value to replay then breath of the wild
I cried when I finished OoT
Same I think. It's so damn emotional. The entire game.
My man.. I cry whenever I start OOT
That Title theme song is just.. Man
Hey Commonwealth Realm, had a little critiquing:
The typeface used to describe the positive and negatives is far too dynamic, making it hard to read. Something simple like helvetica would have been far easier on the eyes.
13:56 Says "Dungeons" again, when it's supposed to say "Bosses." Whoops!
Otherwise, pretty good video, good comparisons were made based on the games being quite different from one another. The franchise has really come a long way!
It's nice to see an actually fair and balanced comparison between these two games.
The inside of the Deku tree, the Dodongo cave and Jabu Jabu's interior can be considered dungeons I would say.
That was great. And the exact conclusion that I came too. I swear I sat down for hours trying to decide if BOTW really dethroned OOT. But I ultimately decided that it did. And it’s close.
give it a few years will probably change your mind
Twilight princess and majoras mask............................
Ocarina of time lasted 20 years and like 15 sequels
Botw 3 years 0 sequels
Watch how it ages badly
@@SDHVFS wtf? ocorina of time didn't have 15 sequels it had one. Majoras mask.
@@gromm1e I meant 15 games since oot release
I like the fact that the hero of time and the hero of the wild are battling the same antagonist in this case Ganon but in different forms.
Quick question,, in master mode, does your hyrule compendium stay the same or do u have to restart?
Great new series... Can you do Ocarina VS Majora's Mask?
I genuinely love them both.
I don't know, I think Ocarina is the winner for me. Maybe it's the nostalgia.
I agree with you.
Yeah it's nostalgia
It's not the nostalgia tbh
Great characters , great story, the game sits perfectly in the middle as not too long and not too short, the world and setting is vast and explorable but not overwhelmingly so like I believe botw is. You easily fall in love with the characters and you get to see those characters and how they change in the future, you feel sadness and regret when you learn they die and most importantly you have a drive to defeat ganon and a hatred for what he's done. The music is catchy and has tons of personality for the areas they're played in and I never get tired of listening. It's an incredible game that has withstood the test of time and I can't stand when people say it's only loved for nostalgic purposes. I only played the game on the 3ds remake just recently and I love it with all my heart.
Also adult link is buff and look way cooler than botw twink link.
It's my favorite Zelda game too I wish they'd remastered it for the switch it would be awesome !
People who have played only one , prefer that one without knowing the other
People who played both love both of them the same , you simply can't choose
Botw , ocarina of time , and twilight princess probably the top 3 of that magnificent world called Hyrule
I love how they reused the "Bosses" section of the script for OoT in the OoT vs Majoras video. Nice one guys
I prefer Twilight Princess
no debate
Ocarina of time is supreme best game ever
At the end it has Crushing, Crushing, and With a stick. It makes crushing crushing with a stick
4:16 Link: Ohh yea keep goin
Hyrule Castle isn't a dungeon, if you walk through the front gate of it you will be right at Ganon. Every other part of the castle is optional and can be skipped.
My Name you are not right at Ganon when you enter the front gate. Its takes a fair bit of exploration to get you too him.
My Name I think you missed the point of the game, which is you can do whatever you want when you want
My two Favorite Legend of Zelda series is *Legend of Zelda* and *A Link To The Past* and maybe *Twlight Princess*
The magic of OOT cannot be over stated. The galloping and music when you put the cartridge in, it set you up for something you’ll never experience again from a computer game
Im just going to say my piece. I think BOTW is better than OOT for quite a few reasons. and most were already stated here. but as far as gamplay functionality BOTW is more seamless than OOT. I remember more times yelling at Ocarina of Time about a jump button, or the weird movement problems, or even issues with aiming, than I have ever with Breath of the Wild. Most of the time when I mess up its a player issue and not a computer one. My only complaint as far as controls is I wish I had to press a or something to start climbing, but it not being required has gotten me out of more problems than in, so I cant really complain. I think OOT restrains are more with its controller than anything. OOT could have played so much nicer on a gamecube style controller, or Playstation style controller without question. and dont give me the bs about the controller being limited by power, it was nintendo trying to gimmick a controller and they almost had with the gamecube but ruined it with the Wii... this is my problem with nintendo, when they made the Wii and WiiU they thought gimmicks, not gameplay or enjoyability, or even their own IP. Skyward Sword and Twilight Princess for example would be much better with a upgraded Gamecube Controller than a Wiimote and Shitchuck, and everybody knows we may never see F-zero again and ARMS is pure bad news for Punch-out. Hell Im still wondering when I am going to get a Open World pokemon game that it needs and has been calling out for the last 10 years. Hell Kanto region alone made massively bigger and a bunch more things to do in bigger cities no longer relying on routes and instead of biomes would be amazing, however neither Game Freak nor Nintendo actually understand what the people want. All of my friends agree with me that right now the main reason to get a switch isnt zelda its Metroid. BOTW was the biggest sign of abandonment on how they screwed over millions of people before releasing a debatebly better console which looks great if it wasnt for the mistrust I have in nintendo at this point I would have already picked one up. *Rant over*