But it wasn't after the Destiel comment. He didn't look at the camera when Mary mentioned Destiel, he only did when she said "You can't spell subtext without S.E.X." So yes, he could be looking at the camera because of the Destiel implication, or he could simply be looking because of the joke (the subtext and sex one).
the best part about this episode was that jared and jensen were not allowed to see the girls rehearse singing carry on wayward son so sam and dean's reaction was their real reaction (:
Such a fun episode. I tear up every time I see Dean and Sam reacting to Carry On. Only Supernatural could do this episode. Your reaction was perfection!
You're absolutely correct: NO other show has the relationships, story, cast, and writers to pull off this epic episode....Buffy came closest with their similar episode, but didn't have the capability to go meta like this. Best episode of TV I've ever seen in my life!
21:04 Your face when your train of thought went back to Chuck 😆 Chef's kiss I absolutely and instantly loved this episode (I too appreciate a good meta story), and with every watch I love it a little more.
What makes it even better is that Jensen and Jared's expressions to the Carry on wayward son were real, like, they did not know that the performance was going to be there in the episode.
thank you so much for loving this as much as i do!!!! i know there are people who don't like it but to me it is all those things you said, its a celebration of the show, its fans and all these characters have been through. its a love letter from the show to its fans that hey we see you, we get you, and we love it too. and storywise it is exactly what those boys needed in this moment after all they have been through. plus the music was so good I actually had to get it. As for Chuck, well that's a whole other thing and i'm surprised you haven't gotten yet. well you probably have now since you are way far ahead of this now but yeah his appearance was like WHAT??? then it was putting it together for me. also i loved Sam thinking about Sastiel.... so they didn't just reference wincest and Destiel but also sastiel which isn't as popular. plus it was such a cute moment like Sam found it all so interesting.
This episode is one of my favorites to watch reactions to cause i like seeing people get emotional during the song and then lose their mind after with Chuck
I love your reaction videos so much. And just in case you really did want an answer regarding naming another show that has done what SPN has done, I nominate Stargate SG-1. Not only has SPN had a ton of Stargate actors on (Amanda Tapping, Michael Shanks, and a boatload of others), but I do wonder if some SPN episode ideas were inspired by SG. Like Stargate has meta episodes about the main characters being in a tv show within the tv show, much like SPN has the Carver Edlund book series. If you want something else to binge and react to, and you haven’t seen it already, SG-1 is 10 seasons, plus it has a 5 season spinoff, another 2 season spinoff, three movies, and a prequel. I think you’d be delighted with it as much as you are with Supernatural because the shows share so many of the same stylistic story-telling choices, with fantastic characters, all the tropes, and the serious, heavy drama is balanced with some hilarious meta and fourth wall breaks.
Definitely a love letter to the fans. Yes, this was absolutely Robbie! No one else could touch those subtleties like he does. Great reaction to one of my favorite episodes.
I thought that too about this episode, not many shows go this route of absolutely destroying the 4th wall and I loved every second of it!! When I rewatch episodes like this, it makes me regret not giving Supernatural a watch a lot sooner as I binge watched and finished the show from February to October of 2021. The legacy it had for 15 years (with more to come as it got more popular during 2020) really shows with these types of episodes. Happy 200th episode! Episode 300 is another AWESOME one that I can't wait for you to see in season 14. Fanfiction is definitely in my top 10 episodes for the series!
This is definitely in my top 5 favorite episodes lol This episode never fails to crack me up no matter how many times I watch lol Now just wait for the 300th episode, which you have about 5 more seasons for. Just keep in mind your assessment of the villain in the episode. You're definitely onto something with it.
That was so much fun! I couldn't stop giggling along with you. I just wish we had saw more of your reaction to I'll Just Wait Here Then. That one's my most favorite of the musical 😆 so much fun! Wonderful reaction as always Shelley!
Its mostly yt fault, it only allows 10 min of footage for copyright but I agree her full reaction its great and even she did a rewatch of the ep analyzing the meta of the episode, so good
Your reaction was perfect. It's amazing to me the in your face meta episodes that these pull off so flawlessly and to throw in a musical score on top of it. I don't know where you are at in the episodes right now, but I just want to remind you to watch the deleted scenes for the episode Executioner's song, I think you'll appreciate one of scenes.
Something I noticed on my last watch of this episode: It's not when Mary mentions Destiel that Dean looks at the camera, he only did so after she said "You can't spell subtext without S.E.X". Which means it might not have been the Destiel part he was mocking but the "joke" part.
I love the meta stories lol why they saying they too old if they know the books they know dean was born in seventies and Sam in eighties so by now they'd have to be old or getting there lol. Maybe they saying how they look but if they know what they've been through maybe it all physically aged them so they look older than they are lol which they don't but season after season you can tell they've seen tons of shot the more lines and bags that appear on their faces lol love every appearance of Chuck lol love all the singing lol they nailed carry on lol
And just cause you challenged me, "DC's Legends of Tomorrow" also managed to do some crazy episodes and play with meta in a way that almost feels to me like a SPN homage at times. I definitely think SPN is better, but "Legends" gets way with things most other shows can't, and it's hilarious!
:sound girl to Sam: don't touch anything - probably talking to Jared too. .. question re Chuck.. did he go to fashion camp? That was one big step up from the robe in season 5
@@HealthyDisrespectforAuthority first one has reenactments from 10x14, second has no direct spoilers but does have actors she hasnt seen yet. cant wait till she gets there and watch reactions to them. they are so good.
@@jillt5829 On Shelley's Patreon/Discord people can put in requests/edit requests for her watch which then go to poll if there's more than 4 a month... let's just say you won't be disappointed, if you're on her Patreon in May Shelley and y'all will be in for a treat...
Uhhh....well there was a show called Buffy......they kinda did it too.....but this was funny as hell. I Killed myself laughing when Dean looked at the camera.......
You get to keep your house. No Becky. The last you saw Chuck, he was typing. Watch the end of season 5 again, real close. Is Point of No Return still your favorite?
@@andiewfs_XIII I hope she didn't read your comment back when you posted it. HUGE spoilers much???? I can't stand when people comment stuff like this without spoiler warnings. It's beyond rude to the reactor.
probably cause i had a one year old in 2005 and wasn’t watching much TV. as the years went on, it seemed so daunting with how many seasons there are. it all worked out though since i get to do this!
Spoilers much??? It's freaking rude to Shelley if she read your comment back when you posted it....esp since shes repeatedly asked to please not leave spoiler comments.
Dean's stare directly into the camera after the Destiel comment wasn't scripted. Jensen did that himself.
That’s the BEST part… 😌😌🙏🙏
But it wasn't after the Destiel comment. He didn't look at the camera when Mary mentioned Destiel, he only did when she said "You can't spell subtext without S.E.X." So yes, he could be looking at the camera because of the Destiel implication, or he could simply be looking because of the joke (the subtext and sex one).
the best part about this episode was that jared and jensen were not allowed to see the girls rehearse singing carry on wayward son so sam and dean's reaction was their real reaction (:
@@enid5470 Hey!
Dean turning Cas's actor's tie inside out bcz Cas's tie was like that at the beginning, is something personal to me :))
And the Cas'actor/ress was adorable!
Loved when Jensen broke the 4th wall!
The greatest thing about Supernatural is you think you know what is going to come, but it just take you on a unexpected ride.
Such a fun episode. I tear up every time I see Dean and Sam reacting to Carry On. Only Supernatural could do this episode. Your reaction was perfection!
You're absolutely correct: NO other show has the relationships, story, cast, and writers to pull off this epic episode....Buffy came closest with their similar episode, but didn't have the capability to go meta like this. Best episode of TV I've ever seen in my life!
This is a love letter for fans episode
21:04 Your face when your train of thought went back to Chuck 😆 Chef's kiss
I absolutely and instantly loved this episode (I too appreciate a good meta story), and with every watch I love it a little more.
If you really had no idea on this episode, then yeah this is how you do a 200th episode. Awesome show. I was in awe when I watched this
What makes it even better is that Jensen and Jared's expressions to the Carry on wayward son were real, like, they did not know that the performance was going to be there in the episode.
thank you so much for loving this as much as i do!!!! i know there are people who don't like it but to me it is all those things you said, its a celebration of the show, its fans and all these characters have been through. its a love letter from the show to its fans that hey we see you, we get you, and we love it too. and storywise it is exactly what those boys needed in this moment after all they have been through. plus the music was so good I actually had to get it. As for Chuck, well that's a whole other thing and i'm surprised you haven't gotten yet. well you probably have now since you are way far ahead of this now but yeah his appearance was like WHAT??? then it was putting it together for me. also i loved Sam thinking about Sastiel.... so they didn't just reference wincest and Destiel but also sastiel which isn't as popular. plus it was such a cute moment like Sam found it all so interesting.
Fire episode. How are you not gonna mention how beautiful that rendition to the show song was.
This episode is one of my favorites to watch reactions to cause i like seeing people get emotional during the song and then lose their mind after with Chuck
I love your reaction videos so much. And just in case you really did want an answer regarding naming another show that has done what SPN has done, I nominate Stargate SG-1.
Not only has SPN had a ton of Stargate actors on (Amanda Tapping, Michael Shanks, and a boatload of others), but I do wonder if some SPN episode ideas were inspired by SG. Like Stargate has meta episodes about the main characters being in a tv show within the tv show, much like SPN has the Carver Edlund book series.
If you want something else to binge and react to, and you haven’t seen it already, SG-1 is 10 seasons, plus it has a 5 season spinoff, another 2 season spinoff, three movies, and a prequel. I think you’d be delighted with it as much as you are with Supernatural because the shows share so many of the same stylistic story-telling choices, with fantastic characters, all the tropes, and the serious, heavy drama is balanced with some hilarious meta and fourth wall breaks.
Definitely a love letter to the fans. Yes, this was absolutely Robbie! No one else could touch those subtleties like he does. Great reaction to one of my favorite episodes.
it was a beautiful tribute to the show!!!!!!! on to the 300th episode!!
I love this episode! It’s funny and touching and makes me laugh. ❤️. Their real reactions to Carry On My Wayward Son, are so good.
this episode was definitely amazingly special. Especially since Sam and Dean's reactions were the actors genuine expression.
Many shows have musical episodes. But this one is something different. Completely different and
super AWESOME!!!!! :)
This one and the Buffy version are the only musical episodes I actually like. This is so funny!
A love letter to the fans.
This reaction was more than I expected it to be and I loved every second lmao.
I thought that too about this episode, not many shows go this route of absolutely destroying the 4th wall and I loved every second of it!! When I rewatch episodes like this, it makes me regret not giving Supernatural a watch a lot sooner as I binge watched and finished the show from February to October of 2021. The legacy it had for 15 years (with more to come as it got more popular during 2020) really shows with these types of episodes. Happy 200th episode! Episode 300 is another AWESOME one that I can't wait for you to see in season 14. Fanfiction is definitely in my top 10 episodes for the series!
I really love the 200th episode, it was a love letter to the fandom and it was great. Emotional and beautiful.
Also fun fact ,, demon Dean was cut short because of the 200th episode which is bitter sweet
Nah that's the excuse, They could have done a flashback or something like that
Dean looking at "Mary" gets me every time
When?
Loved your reaction 🤣 yes this episode was written by Robbie Thompson 👍 he also wrote the lyrics to the songs 👌
This is definitely in my top 5 favorite episodes lol This episode never fails to crack me up no matter how many times I watch lol Now just wait for the 300th episode, which you have about 5 more seasons for.
Just keep in mind your assessment of the villain in the episode. You're definitely onto something with it.
OMG I love this episode and your reaction didn't disappoint!!!
Your experience is truly beautiful. I love watching you each week.
The level of self awareness has been bumped up a bar higher with this and I love it. 😂
That was so much fun! I couldn't stop giggling along with you. I just wish we had saw more of your reaction to I'll Just Wait Here Then. That one's my most favorite of the musical 😆 so much fun! Wonderful reaction as always Shelley!
Its mostly yt fault, it only allows 10 min of footage for copyright but I agree her full reaction its great and even she did a rewatch of the ep analyzing the meta of the episode, so good
You can watch her full reaction to the episode & even a rewatch of the episode on her Patreon
“-CasDean?
-SHUT YOUR FACE! GET IN THE CAR!”
Lmao love it!!! One of my favorite episodes I laugh I cry it’s one of the best and this show has alot!
Your reaction was perfect. It's amazing to me the in your face meta episodes that these pull off so flawlessly and to throw in a musical score on top of it. I don't know where you are at in the episodes right now, but I just want to remind you to watch the deleted scenes for the episode Executioner's song, I think you'll appreciate one of scenes.
she just watched episode 10 and yeah, the delated scenes will be in a video for the end of the season, along with the comic con before s11 :)
Yeah they full on forgot Adam for 5 years. Justice for Adam
Something I noticed on my last watch of this episode: It's not when Mary mentions Destiel that Dean looks at the camera, he only did so after she said "You can't spell subtext without S.E.X". Which means it might not have been the Destiel part he was mocking but the "joke" part.
I love the meta stories lol why they saying they too old if they know the books they know dean was born in seventies and Sam in eighties so by now they'd have to be old or getting there lol. Maybe they saying how they look but if they know what they've been through maybe it all physically aged them so they look older than they are lol which they don't but season after season you can tell they've seen tons of shot the more lines and bags that appear on their faces lol love every appearance of Chuck lol love all the singing lol they nailed carry on lol
The 300th episode is a real tear jerker.
I’ve been waiting like THE LONGEST TIME!!! for you to see this episode 😁👍🏻
I absolutely LOVE this episode. My fav of the whole series imo
And just cause you challenged me, "DC's Legends of Tomorrow" also managed to do some crazy episodes and play with meta in a way that almost feels to me like a SPN homage at times. I definitely think SPN is better, but "Legends" gets way with things most other shows can't, and it's hilarious!
Can't wait for your 300th reaction 😆 😆
I love this episode. It's amazing, and funny.
Love your reaction too funny, keep watching, so much more!
21:08 the complete 180° 😂😂😂
Justice for Adam
I have been waiting for you to react to this episode! All together now…
Ghoooooost…facers.
affirmative!
awesomeness: major
Wait until you see the 300th episode. You have so far to go.
200th episode supernatural
I love this episode SOOOOO much xD
:sound girl to Sam: don't touch anything - probably talking to Jared too.
.. question re Chuck.. did he go to fashion camp? That was one big step up from the robe in season 5
theres still spoilers in the hillywood parodies until about 10x14 i think for 1st and when season 13 starts for 2nd parody.
@@greatscott88 Right.. forgot the second one was later.. after this season, the first one is safe.
@@HealthyDisrespectforAuthority first one has reenactments from 10x14, second has no direct spoilers but does have actors she hasnt seen yet. cant wait till she gets there and watch reactions to them. they are so good.
Hilly and Hannah (Hillywood) aren’t in this episode. But both their SPN parodies are a must see when she’s at the right place in the series
@@jillt5829 On Shelley's Patreon/Discord people can put in requests/edit requests for her watch which then go to poll if there's more than 4 a month... let's just say you won't be disappointed, if you're on her Patreon in May Shelley and y'all will be in for a treat...
This was special as it is 200th episode from the series....
Oooooh Yeaaaaaaahhhhhh, Perhaps my Favorite episode. Enjoy
Uhhh....well there was a show called Buffy......they kinda did it too.....but this was funny as hell. I Killed myself laughing when Dean looked at the camera.......
Eh, wasn’t the same
My only regret is that I have but one thumbs up to give.
You get to keep your house. No Becky. The last you saw Chuck, he was typing. Watch the end of season 5 again, real close. Is Point of No Return still your favorite?
He disappeared and then Kevin showed up and cas said chuck must have been dead, he didn’t know chuck was god.
@@andiewfs_XIII I hope she didn't read your comment back when you posted it. HUGE spoilers much???? I can't stand when people comment stuff like this without spoiler warnings. It's beyond rude to the reactor.
@@paradoxgrl Agreed!
😁 es uno de mis episodios favoritos 😂
I feel like you missed Chuck disappearing into thin air in Swan Song? Or you forgot?
CASDEAN?
Chucky Cheese is back !
This is my favorite episode. At least non season 5 episode that is.
This one is for sure in my top but my favorite is in season 11 - along with second and third place.
Same for me definitely a great episode
Why didn't you watch this while it was coming out? Just curious. For instance, I avoided Buffy the Vampire Slayer purely because I hated the name.
probably cause i had a one year old in 2005 and wasn’t watching much TV. as the years went on, it seemed so daunting with how many seasons there are. it all worked out though since i get to do this!
Still prefer 100
I prefer 300 that was a tear runner and just awesome
That shit was cheesy and dramatic as fuck, but OF COURSE GOD (of all “people”) is going to give a kid, a good review😂
Spoilers much??? It's freaking rude to Shelley if she read your comment back when you posted it....esp since shes repeatedly asked to please not leave spoiler comments.
Well how could he be alive, did he said something in the show that makes sense now;)