We Vietnamese nod enthusiastically and chuckle secretly when we listen to western people telling us what we should do with China, as if we hadn't lived next to them for over 2 milliennia and had relations in all imaginable ways with them already, ha!
Yes, be wise. Beware of the divide-and-conquer strategy. The colonial powers used it 100 and 200 years ago, and still use it today. The aim is to leverage "divides", and set up neighbors against neighbors. If everybody fights, the imperialist _dividers_ who cannot be reached because of geographical distance, end up winning.
Then tell me how you will get your islands and sea back from China. There is a reason why China has invaded Vietnam dozens of times. Perhaps when Vietnam becomes a special economic zone of China you will realize too late that authoritarians with visions of grandeur are less trustworthy than chaotic liberal democracies. How strange that millions of Vietnamese choose to emigrate to the crummy United States instead of China. What do they know about China that you don't?
Do you remember the coup of 30 September 1965 when six Indonesian generals were murdered by communists and the Indonesian Conmunist Party became enemy number one? The Dutch left Indonesia in 1949.
@@arthurlincoln9093 read "the Jakarta method" then you'll know it was happened because CIA then learn about neocolonialism because even though Netherlands leave they still exploits Indonesian through their corporation
The 1997 Asian Financial Crisis where IMF 'forced' economic changes ahead of sovereignty in Indonesia, Thailand, South Korea and others still ring in our ears.
@@stevenzalany6112 Sure. George Soros the ruthless self proclaimed human rights defender, forex currency speculator who bet (shorted) against Asian currencies (Baht, ringgit and even the English Pound) destroying the economies in the process. I still remembered in 1997 when I was in Kuala Lumpur the devastating effects and how the then PM Mahathir spoke against him. These hedge fund speculators and IMF were (and are) basically vultures.
Also the Collapse of Free-Market Capitalism via the GLOBAL ECONOMIC & FINANCIAL CRISIS with a Made in the USA by Wall Street label on it as well, and is still FRESH on many nations minds as well.
Thank you so much for inviting Pr Pang and Kumada 先生. I had a great time enjoying their knowledge and pedagogy .I have myself been dealing and living in Asia and Asia pacific for decades and I am never tired of discovering true professional scholars in geopolitics in Asia .
Thank you for giving me 1 very important word , pedagogy. Well , I was just a average student in my younger days , And post formal school is very important , like your adding a vocabulary. Thank you .
So glad we're getting more voices from ASEAN finally. I've been waiting for this for years, because I knew how important this region is for the emerging multipolar world. Thank you for bringing on Mr & Mrs Pang, they represent how connected East and SE Asia is, both historically and today. 👍
The ASEAN block are a UNIQUE group of nations with a population 600 million and a combined GDP 2024 of 3.7 Trillion. Economically a robust group located in SE Asia, a unique blend of neutrality, trade with China / worldwide posing no threat to any external powees yet peaceful and forward looking to contribute. The world should let them prosper. Politically stable, economically progressive and consensually focused. A Microcosm of its own unique blend of the future.
I'm glad ASEAN never allowed itself to be pressured to change and become the EU. We are a different concept and time will show the different values it enables vs an EU-style organisation. Yes, it isn't able to do some things as well, but Eurocentrics only see that part rather than also the part where it can on the other hand, accomplish or be immune to entirely different things. Perhaps each type is suited to each region, as we organise according to the risks we perceive as the priority. Edit: I agree with John that decolonisation isn't done until our countries can restore the ways that we once related to one another before colonisation (except maybe Singapore, which arguably does not need this part), because those were sovereign decisions which were rooted in the logic and worldview of our own cultures. I'll give an example: in pre-colonial times, even though the region had wars just like any other in medieval periods, diplomatic relations between trading nations were fairly equal. Equal as in, even a country as large as China might marry their princesses to a Southeast Asian royal to seal a diplomatic relationship. However, when the Europeans came in to "trade", not a single one of them would have considered it as anything but beneath them to marry their royals to ours. And many of us have internalised that inferiority complex through the centuries of colonisation. Now, of course we're no longer in an era where we have to cement diplomatic relations with monarchic marriages anymore, and nobody is interested in reviving that, but recovering the worldview where we hold ourselves and our cultures as inherently equal to other nation-cultures, is part of finishing the decolonisation process. Edit 2: I think you can understand ASEAN's actions better if your culture is also comprised of the 'extended family'.
Fantastic discussion and cool choice of guests. Was interesting to hear the manner in which the fabric of relationships and culture was built over centuries. The recovery of mutual cooperation and overcoming Colonialism over the past decade - was thought provoking. Thanks Pascal for posting this!! I am baffled how you manage to choose such a diverse and intellectual powerhouses- in these posts. Wish just 1/10th of this quality and diversity of folks were featured in our press and think tanks here in the US. But I guess we have been fed with such freak shows by western media over the past 3 decades - it would be unthinkable to comprehend another perspective by our editors, directors and most viewers.
IMF told us Indonesian to stop building our own plane design. With those loan as hostage. We must did it to survive. As a technological Institute, that's a slap on my face that I cant ever forget.
This is so fascinating to hear, being here in NZ where it is still fully colonized as is Australia. So hope we can all stand up against the "western" powers. I am caucasian however i stand for the rights of indigenous of each country and the unfair practises that they have suffered
Looking at the utterance of the NZ leaders and the ones here in Australia I don't hold out a lot of hope. We have to build resistance to US hegemony together
@@jameslawrie3807people in AU and in NZ need to really wake up. We need to show them West is wanting war with China so lets give them facts and take action
Their is a huge difference between the NZ and the Australian indigenous, we welcome and enjoy the company of those from NZ , unfortunately we have to secure our homes , cars and property from our locals but have no control over our wallets that are emptied by those in Govt that hand out our earnings to those who don’t contribute to society
ASEAN represents Southeast Asia countries wisdom, intelligence, pragmatism. How they interact with each other to resolve problems, or mitigate issues from further escalations. There will always be issues. There is no need for colonialists & imperialists to be the police, and dictating the rules and how ASEAN should behave. Only through diplomacy, conversation, discussion to help resolve and/or mitigate problems.
Before watching this interview I saw a short video with a guy and a girl. "He asks: - Where are you from? - I'm from Texas. - replies the girl. - Can you tell me the names of 5 European countries? After thinking for a few seconds, the girl says. - Australia. - Some more? The girl thinks and responds. -That's all I got." Interviewees here made interesting comments about the ineffectiveness of the ridiculous discourse that Europeans and Americans use in southwest China to try to co-opt Asians. But we must remember that this same discourse is very efficient when used in Australia, a paradoxically non-Asian country in Asia. It's easy to laugh watching the video I mentioned at the beginning. But the truth is that that poor, ignorant girl from Texas is a victim of the American disinformation system. Australians are also victims of a similar disinformation system. Australia is located in Asia and harbors immense distrust, envy and aggression towards China and its partners in the region. The Australians bought Anglo/American nuclear submarines because according to them the country is afraid of being invaded by the Chinese. And yet for thousands of years China never showed any interest in colonizing Australia, it was the English who did this by transforming that island continent into a prison and enslaving the local native peoples.
Chinese fleets arrived in Africa earlier than the West, but they only brought back giraffes and ivory, while Western fleets sold African black people as slaves.
"Smart shaming" is ridicule and punishment of any deeper or critical thinking and knowledge. Who coined that expression? The Filipinos. They knew exactly. The Germans even have a hate-word for that. A guy who attempts to introduce critical remarks and arguments (especially since the pandemic) is called "Schwurbler". Yes there are some right-wingers who are critical about vaccines and there are classic anti-vaxxers. But the whole debate got out of control. It has become pseudo-religious and authoritarian. It became more important to crucify and cremate a witch or sorcerer (=heterodox) than to find common ground and solve a problem.
One must look at the demographics of the Aussie population. That's where the distrust or should I say fear of China comes from. The west has always held sway over most of the world with it's military for centuries during the colonisation. They treated the colonies as milking cows and the locals as inferior humans. That mentality has stayed.
@@yokfinlee376good point. But the racism and xenophobia are also deeply imbedded in Australian so called civil society at every level. It is so easy to utilise this against China politically.
Here's my analogies of the different nations.... 1. USA - Bully in a shrinking playground 2. China - The wise elder biding its time 3. EU - Family members prone to inbreeding and infighting 4. African countries - Still to be categorized 5. ASEAN - Good neighbors. Do not always agree but will work out the issues. 6. South America - Past victims of the bully. 7. Oceania - Can't decide if it wants to side with the West or East.
Historically you're right about Europe but the main current driver of division in Europe is the US who pretends to still be occupying Europe to maintain peace and stability while driving a wedge between the main natural eurasian trading partners through coups, color revolutions, extremism and war for nothing but the US maintaining global hegemony.
Africa - Cradle of humanity. Like the babe in the cradle filled to the bursting with youthful potentialities. Wild and uncouth like a rebellious youth suffering from the traumas of brutal abuses therefore deeply damaged but also with the resilience and vibrancy of youth. Behind it the wisdom of the ancients and before it the promise of a great overcoming.
@@Black_Sun_Dark_Star Concise Categorising, putting into a pigeonhole such a typically western mode of discourse. No wonder you found nothing for Africa. We Africans are not nothing.
Hopefully things may change for the better, since Joebama Buyden 82 has officially DROPPED out of the US Presidential Race, after losing support from major Democratic Allies and Donors. They supported his rival Donald Trump instead. Hopefully, things can change for the better after January 19, 2025. As for Joebama Buyden's Project Ukraine - I'm afraid that this conflict in Ukraine will end the same way the War in Afghanistan (aka the graveyard of empires) when Kyiv is finally captured and falls to the advancing Russian Forces. Then the EU & NATO may cease to exist and the US & the UK will be greatly weakened and bankrupt by these warmongering neocon LOSERS in DC after this is all said and done. Again - wars no longer works anymore, since the ones being attacked by these above warmongers now have the ability to FIGHT BACK against them now !!!
Its so unreal colonoalism is real. So our education lied about lots of things. Today, we can see actual disgusting parts of colonialism because of social media, especially in africa.
Colonialism is very real, but it is the past for most of the world. We should take away the lessons from that period of time, leave it behind and move on. Don't let it burden your future.
It's not too late to know what colonialism is . 50+ yrs ago , I started to question why colonialism have happen when the Spanish , Portuguese , Dutch, French English American s and Japanese. As a high school student , didn't know much then , luckily our school library has good collections of world history books , a fantastic high school tea her , a great librarian who like to engage on the books that I borrowed , and my cousin a great mentor . 1 good tip I learned from them , Don't just read the history as written from the mind and study of the author , the author could be lazy , or rushing to write the book , etc . They said READ BETWEEN the lines, Read BEHIND the lines , Turn the story upside down , Filter & Shake all the book lines , and come to your conclusion . Regarding colonialism from a high school student , Colonialism is conquest /conquer / & confiscate. Later years , It's the extraction of everything from the colonies , Resources like human and material resources . Taking them , and brainwashing them make them loyal and wanting to be a colonial slaves. Look at India , They loved being a colonial slaves .
@@enzoh7763 Getting to the bottom of things is what I like to do, especially with knowledge. Those were the days of "fast" territorial expansion and it has left an indelible mark in history. Let's move on from that.
Hahaha seen that interview too. And i laughed when i saw that diplomat face when Namibian minister said China always help us meanwhile European always give us trouble, and he tells how germany make it hard for Namibia diplomats go there just few weeks before. As Indonesian, we also got the same hypocrisy treatment. Europe banned our palm oil products in the name of deforestation and green movement. However when we banned raw nickel export to minimize emissions etc, they sue us. What hypocrite people
Thank you Dr Lottaz. 🕊 What a pleasure to hear from your estimed guests John Pang and Naoko Kumada. I hope that ASEAN continues to be a focus for future neutrality studies programs. I would be grateful to lean more from your guests about Myanmar and West Papua,.
Minute 9:45 Dr. Kumada is right. Cambodia and Laos were bombed extensively by the US in its UNDECLARED wars against them, as a side show of the big power war in Vietnam. Indeed, these nations were destroyed during OTHER PEOPLE'S WAR. Good insight.
Thailand used to be called the Coup Capital of the world because of the near-constant coups it was experiencing, mostly due to the imperialistic influence of certain western countries. The Philippines is a prime example that colonialism still clings on to power in Southeast Asia. The US will not abandon its Borgian objectives in Southeast Asia quietly. In fact, the Philippines is where the US perfected its colonialist policy under the guise of "benevolence". People still remember that it was President McKinley who formulated the US "Benevolent Assimilation" policy of assimilating everyone into the American culture, political structure and even language.
Don't talk as if other countries aren't influenced by Western culture! Your cellphone is brought by Western culture of democracy and freedom. So those aren't directly influenced by US similar to PH doesn't mean you aren't influenced by the US. Almost all countries in ASEAN thrive because of capitalism! Development is also indirectly brought by capitalism.
And unsurprisingly the religiosity of political leaders and public institutions in the Phillipines resembles the Godmerican state of rule by fear and division.
@@LarryfromPH other southeast Asian just salty about Philippines. Because french and Britain just see them as laborer that why there tradition is intact. Unlike Philippines Spain really erase Philippines tradition and input Spanish tradition that why we have Christianity and latin surname that why we also called the European in asia Then american came and reengineered our tradition to become more American . Little brother of America in Asia. Well they just jealous because we always chosen by other powerful country I don't if it is blessing or curse.
@@egielynabunda7888It's a curse. Look at the sins in Angeles City, unimaginable! And the hypocrisy of the Church, closing one eye to Angeles City which pontifying the usual daily.
thank you so much John, Naoko and Pascal. I've been fed with delicious insights and informatiion. Love your perspectives and analysis. Greetings from Thailand.
Observation…ASEAN’s patience with its members seems to recognize the “everlasting” of culture, while acknowledging the more transient struggles we all have with the current situations. All changes bring stresses. The major stresses for individuals are usually due to, loss of income, loss of a loved one, or changing one’s location etc. However, as time passes, we return to our normal way of dealing with our relationships. This is a very mature approach to life in general.
Victor Orban is currently the President of the useless EU and the un-elected warmongering neocon LOSERS in Brussels are all on the take from the current Joebama Buyden's administration whose expiration date is January 19, 2025. On January 20, 2025 hopefully a new and improved US President will be sworn-in to replace this current 82 year old Joebama Buyden who is stepping-down, and is NOT seeking re-election on July 22, 2024.
Hungaria needs the hard Hand of the EU!Taking the money from the EU but not wanting playing py the rules wont Work!Hungaria is doomed anyway,Not even the Help from the EU wont help much!
@@BrunoHeggli-zp3nl EU is already doomed, nothing but a bunch of yes men and women to the USA, paying 3 times more for usa gas, sending tens of billions to Ukraine 's corrupt regime, taking orders from USA to hurt their own enterprises, etc, EU is done for, but Hungary has the foresight saying no to being a puppet
The good thing is that the Empire USA is falling. The main reason is, the US forgott to invest in the economy, education, puplic tranportation, infrstructure., then they infest only in the Army and NATO. The downfall of the US is unstopable.. With the downfall of the USA also the NATO and the EU will falling.
Simply, there is a lot of people in Southeast Asia who are multilingual, particularly in Malaysia and Singapore, where, if they are inquisitive and would like to seek information and perspectives, they are equipped to read not only the Anglo-Saxon media, but also the the Chinese language, Bahasa and also Hindi/Tamil, which helps them weave through what's impartial and what's agenda-driven, if they actually try.
So good to hear we are on the same wave-length. USA is like a teenager who is still growing up. The Brits have always thought they are superior (the upper crust).
I came across your channel yesterday and was impressed with the content. It's so good to see our young folks waking up to this Tyranny and standing up. I am very proud of you. Subscribed.
Thank you Mr. Pang. Thank you Ms. Kumada. Thank you Pascal (Professor Lottaz). Your channel, your guests, your conduct, your knowledge deepen, broaden, fortify my knowledge, understanding, perspective world view. Best wishes. 🌞🖖🏼✌🏼
Alhamdulillah, John mentioned why we Malaysian accepting or leaning towards more to China. It is sad to see if our ASEAN is divided into 2, you know which countries that disagreed with the rest.
@@HenryKajana actually both Indonesia and Thailand have larger populations of ethnic Chinese than Malaysia. In fact in both countries the numbers double that of Malaysia.
@@borisnegrarosa9113 We're witnessing the decline of the US empire. US needs to give up its delusions of grandeur and agree to mutually beneficial cooperation with the rest the world.
Loved the interview! Everyone is obviously intelligence and know what they are talking about. There's no groundless random claims/statements about this and that. Everything was followed up with history, factual information. There are so much histories and knowledge to learn from listening to John and Naoko speak.
They Just Tell everybody what south east asians want to hear!The West is so bad,all the Problems are only from the West!Yes Sure China with the extremly fast ageing population is realy the Future and Europe and the US are doomed right?Thats why Most of the people immigrate to China and Not to Europe or the US right?Right?Hahaha
This is very interesting to me. Im a westerner whos been living in South East Asia for many years and marveling how Asia (especially China) has been moving boldly into the future, while the west clings on to the old ways and old beliefs. I think maybe the desparate attempts to paint China as backwards and dangerous is just the wests way to avoid moving forward themselves. I love Asia!
Australia hasn't been close to neutral to our Asian neighbours since 1996. Such a wasted chance to make friends and community among the nearby nations.
Interesting that you should mention the conflicts in East Timor and West Papua. There is a discussion to be had about Indonesia being a regional empire, holding onto places post - colonialism, despite them having claims to independence.
Communists literally murdered Indonesia into an artificial hegemony during 1945-1964.. killing most ethnic minority leaders, subjugating and crushing their Kingdoms. No surprise it is something they don't teach in Indonesian history books.
Thanks Pascal, Naoko and John for a great and enlightening discussion. I recall Karmala Harris' recent trip to convince the Vietnamese that they should take a more aggressive stance to China, you could literally see all of the Vietnamese officials biting their lips to keep themselves from laughing in her face. Why the hell would Vietnam want to pick a fight with their nearest neighbour of 1.3 billion people, and their most important trade partner. I think to try seal the deal the US offered them a few tens of millions of dollars in aid, which just seemed like an insult. As I was listening to your program I was sitting in Battambang, Cambodia, writing a research report on sustainable agriculture in ASEAN countries. The main point where I would disagree with your analysis is that whilst SE Asian countries are really starting to put the political beast of colonialism in its grave, economic colonialism is still quite strong, particularly in the plantations and mining sectors, but you know, the national governments also lean into these sectors for the foreign exchange, whilst throwing their own people and environment under the bus of bad terms of trade and externalization of production costs.
Southeast is leading the world to a new era of humanity evolution ! Where not only in technology, science and innovation but in the new philosophy of the growth of human conscious !
thank you very much to neutrality studies for your work, for your studies, for helping us to understand the historical reality free of rhetoric and propaganda, necessary foundations for the construction of a more educated and more aware society
The best stand against western hegemony was done by late Singapore founder and he said Singapore can never become a Christian country with their values because there is something special and beautiful about values from ancient Chinese and Indian culture. That sums up where Asia and Asean should stand for.
I think and would say that it was the Indochina Wars and the Indonesian Wars. Those didn't end until late 90s/early 2Ks. So there's still reconciliation coming around. With the Phillipines still being a quasi-colony of the US. The region is still in the decolonizing process. That said, ASEAN is much farther ahead than Africa is.
Asia, Southeast Asia in particular, is always a territory of peace until western colonizer moved in starting 16th century when China took the world center stance, and a strong and peace-loving China will continue to play a vital role to make peace as desirable as possible after China rise up again. I also believe ASEAN can be seem as a role model to the rest of world where “multipolarity” is a doable and salutary path forward thru peaceful co-existence first and become co-prosperous afterwards. The bottom line is we must learn from history that “conflict and bloodshed only happened as a result of failed diplomacy”, and rule #1 of diplomacy is “talk” to your adversary and #2 seeking acceptable compromise after understanding what your adversary’s concern.
That's because pre 16th century Southeast Asia had fuck all going for it. You can't start a war with another SeS nation if you can't even build a boat big enough to travel that far.
ASEAN essentially is a economic entity. Yes, over the decades, it evolves with some political integration in terms of political views. Yet, it never and should not aspire to be EU where it overrides national or local governments, breaching democratic principles. These EU Parliament who were not elected by the people of the countries of EU, yet their decisions are binding on member countries, robbing them of their national sovereignty. ASEAN does not interfere with the domestic politics and development of member countries.
The EU Parliament is elected by people across the EU, but it is not where the decision making power resides. The Commission is absolutely not a democratic organisation, the appointments are decided behind closed doors and rubber stamped by Parliament.
Thank you for the rich content and context to International relations in relation to Asia. Hope Brics incorporates other smaller Asian countries from ASEAN to work with Africa. We have similar histories and understanding of effects of colonialism to our countries. A new progressive global order can help develop our continents further. Thank you Dr Lottaz, Dr Pang and Dr Kumada ... keep up the amazing work.
It's just so wonderful, Learning at TH-cam University 🥰 I've gained so much Knowledge and Wisdom by finding so many Excellent Channels and Guests who communicate like Real people. Thank You.
@@SillyBillyOneHundreadMilly I recommend watching the tape again from Minute 23:17 on to get a sense of the different world view between the EU and ASEAN. It is followed by specific discussion on how ASEAN has dealt with Myanmar AFTER it was sanctioned and isolated by the West. Notably, Myanmar has never lost its membership in the ASEAN. Moreover, ASEAN is facilitating its return to the fold.
Hmm.... I question the non-alignment of Philippines, especially since it is one of the original signatories to the ASEAN pact. Also before the military took over, Myanmar was drifting towards the West with many instigators working within its borders. I witness their handiwork with the democratic government and the officials.
There are still US mercenary providing training and instigating war with the Myanmar gov happening. With these interferences Myanmar would be hard to reconcile. Time is what they have if they want a Myanmar gov or otherwise though their love for ASSK is a phenomenon 😅❤
@@Black_Sun_Dark_Star And the Chinese. West-aligned resistance groups are not as successful as Chinese-aligned groups since the military tookover. Most victories by the resistance in recent months are mainly by China-aligned groups and the military is now openly angry with China for this. China seems to play both sides actively though, while the West just talks without action.
@@annuwazdmz1131 You have to realize, the Chinese doesn't interfere with their government. Never have. They sold weapons but not instigate a power change or coup de tat. The Westerners are ACTIVE agents,both militarily and politically.
The Philippines' ruling class simply assumes it will be easiest for them to court US aid money to further stimulate the country's impressive growth versus any other regional power. US economic aid has dwindled ever since the 90s when the first Aquino administration shut down Clark AFB. Also, the territorial scuffles in the South China Sea are utilized to drive more opposition to China among the electorate compared to other SEA countries.
After WWII, US realise its beneficial to help other countries post war redevelopment and able to influence the politic in this countries. Soon US have foot print in almost every chaos in the world but there are never any military confrontation with a developed countries with a relatively advance military power. Even thou US involved in most war but never win any. As for South China Sea chaos, from historical US carrier fleet on the term of freedom of navigation will be sail through Strait of Taiwan to showcase their naval power to pressure China but now with China development of naval power strong enough to go against US. China drawn the sea border to keep the US out and in check with their long range aircraft carrier killer missile. Any Western involvement will not benefit ASEAN. Its mainly for their self interest or agenda. Hungry and Slovakia are never really treated as part of EU, while Serbia and Turkey application into EU are always lips service only.
Nice article However, to be exact, China crushed western hegemony. Now countries from all continents have options not be subjected to western oppression especially US
ASEAN has for the past 57 yrs shown to the whole what it means to live harmoniously peacefully as neighbors in the region, helping each other in trade & economic development for peace & prosperity together while respecting each other’s sovereignty and NOT to interfere with each other’s internal domestic matters. Differences if any are mutually discussed and settled amicably & pragmatically. Peace no war.
But Philippines is making a lot of noise about China over the S. China Sea issue and even allowed the US to build additional bases on their islands. Are they gearing up to fight China? They might turn out to be Ukraine 2.0
@@CoolCat-rw6pp Philippines have voted for their own President. If Philippines people r worried about being a puppet or become the next Ukraine / Afghanistan, it’s for them to voice their concerns & petition to their govt. Current Philippines people seems to forget what happened in Feb 1986 and why it happened.
I fully agree that global colonialism is finally coming to an end. Most global South countries are regaining back real sovereignty and independence. Western influence will remain but can no longer direct or subvert politically with the exception of some who will also continue to pay the high price.
Regarding wars in asean panelists forgot to mention the Japanese invasion and atrocities in Asean countries. How can this so-called experts forgot about this.
Indonesia's first president, Sukarno, together with Jawaral Nehru from India, were the initiators who had the foresight to rise from colonialism, peace and poverty in Asian and African countries at that time so they created theNon-Aligned Movement. But there are still many countries in Asia that still do not understand the good intentions of this aims until now like Malaysia.
LOL...yea...We ASEAN are so Non- Aligned, that we can't even do anything in Myanmar crisis, except condemn it, do meetings...do meetings...and more meetings, without doing anything except meetings....LOL.... I rather the philippines Join NATO or EU than waste time in ASEAN that can't do anything except play football and do meetings...
I like these neutral but variable/conversations on taboo independance and variability reflecting European energy variability moves in response to Russia.the east is going forwards whilst the west seem's to be going backwards in many way's,which must be discussed if the whole world can continue to look forward to a fair future regardless of super consolidated wealthy individual's drawing up there own future's in the guise of everyone's
Way too long. They are hell bent, hand on their God, they are supreme. Whatever iteration they come up with either through religion, civilization, democracy it is to justify their WH supremacy.
For anyone that is not particularly familiar with ASEAN I can recommend the following book. “The Asean Miracle” by Kishore Mahbubani dated 8 March 2017.
Hi Pascal, have a chat to Jerry Grey about the South China sea - or just watch his brief but succinct video for some background on the dispute and who is really the bully.
Can't we all just get along? Economic, political, and military neutrality needs to become a world standard for all nations. Neutrality Principles need to be clearly defined and widely promoted. Moreover, embracing the NON PARTISAN, (what's good for society as a wholel vis-a-vis the partisan "winner take all," approach is key to achieving peace and prosperity for all.
Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam, Indonesia etc. have played the delicate balancing act of maintaining relationship with the West (US led) & China (+Russia) since at least 50 years ago. We are not beginners. 😂😂😂 We attracted significant investment from both sides, continously for a few decades already. Japan is the third important actor, specifically for manufacturing transfactories invesment & economical aid. We are part of the fast growing APAC region.
Why not Bangladesh? Why not Sri Lanka? Because ASEAN was Asia centric, as the name implies. The member countries all face the Pacific. Adding the sub continent to Asia, and calling the whole area Indo Pacific, is a purely American invention, to bring India in to counter China. Frankly, if one accepts the Indo Pacific concept, one might as well add the Persian Gulf and beyond…
We Vietnamese nod enthusiastically and chuckle secretly when we listen to western people telling us what we should do with China, as if we hadn't lived next to them for over 2 milliennia and had relations in all imaginable ways with them already, ha!
Yes, be wise.
Beware of the divide-and-conquer strategy.
The colonial powers used it 100 and 200 years ago, and still use it today. The aim is to leverage "divides", and set up neighbors against neighbors.
If everybody fights, the imperialist _dividers_ who cannot be reached because of geographical distance, end up winning.
It's what I have said that the west doesn't understand the Asian mind
Yes, true.
In fact, China tried to invade Vietnam... twice!
Then tell me how you will get your islands and sea back from China. There is a reason why China has invaded Vietnam dozens of times. Perhaps when Vietnam becomes a special economic zone of China you will realize too late that authoritarians with visions of grandeur are less trustworthy than chaotic liberal democracies. How strange that millions of Vietnamese choose to emigrate to the crummy United States instead of China. What do they know about China that you don't?
Very well said. I totally agree.
Indonesia remember 97 98 crisis, we will never forget west.
Also the hypocrite of west on Gaza situation
65 to as is CIA move
Do you remember the coup of 30 September 1965 when six Indonesian generals were murdered by communists and the Indonesian Conmunist Party became enemy number one?
The Dutch left Indonesia in 1949.
@@arthurlincoln9093 read "the Jakarta method" then you'll know it was happened because CIA then learn about neocolonialism because even though Netherlands leave they still exploits Indonesian through their corporation
@@arthurlincoln9093those killings were orchestrated by cia, the rotten truth cannot be kept forever. We will never forget.
Even they were disgustingly proud of their own hypocrisy
The 1997 Asian Financial Crisis where IMF 'forced' economic changes ahead of sovereignty in Indonesia, Thailand, South Korea and others still ring in our ears.
Do you know George Soros ??
@@stevenzalany6112👿
@@stevenzalany6112 Sure. George Soros the ruthless self proclaimed human rights defender, forex currency speculator who bet (shorted) against Asian currencies (Baht, ringgit and even the English Pound) destroying the economies in the process. I still remembered in 1997 when I was in Kuala Lumpur the devastating effects and how the then PM Mahathir spoke against him. These hedge fund speculators and IMF were (and are) basically vultures.
@@stevenzalany6112 Gyorgy Schwartz
Also the Collapse of Free-Market Capitalism via the GLOBAL ECONOMIC & FINANCIAL CRISIS with a Made in the USA by Wall Street label on it as well, and is still FRESH on many nations minds as well.
How do American politians change a light bulb.
They hold the bulb and wait for the world to turn around them.🤣
LOL trust you to think of that one👍🤣
I love it. 😂😂😂😂
LOL
Holy shit that’s genius 😂
Who invented the light bulb?
Thank you so much for inviting Pr Pang and Kumada 先生. I had a great time enjoying their knowledge and pedagogy .I have myself been dealing and living in Asia and Asia pacific for decades and I am never tired of discovering true professional scholars in geopolitics in Asia .
Thank you for giving me 1 very important word , pedagogy.
Well , I was just a average student in my younger days ,
And post formal school is very important , like your adding a vocabulary.
Thank you .
Definitely NO to NATO!!
NATO is a terrorist organisation!
true, no matter how bad your government is, it would never be as bad as NATO
So glad we're getting more voices from ASEAN finally. I've been waiting for this for years, because I knew how important this region is for the emerging multipolar world. Thank you for bringing on Mr & Mrs Pang, they represent how connected East and SE Asia is, both historically and today. 👍
Europe thinking it is an American thinking....
Europe is under the thumb of America!
Dump, to be exact 😀
Europe, South Korea, and Japan are in a modern way colonies of the Usa !!!
EU🗜️🇪🇺 🔨🐛🌈♿🛐
And it all happened int he last 15 years.
@@tigersilberhannes9153 longer than that
The ASEAN block are a UNIQUE group of nations with a population 600 million and a combined GDP 2024 of 3.7 Trillion. Economically a robust group located in SE Asia, a unique blend of neutrality, trade with China / worldwide posing no threat to any external powees yet peaceful and forward looking to contribute. The world should let them prosper. Politically stable, economically progressive and consensually focused. A Microcosm of its own unique blend of the future.
I'm glad ASEAN never allowed itself to be pressured to change and become the EU. We are a different concept and time will show the different values it enables vs an EU-style organisation. Yes, it isn't able to do some things as well, but Eurocentrics only see that part rather than also the part where it can on the other hand, accomplish or be immune to entirely different things. Perhaps each type is suited to each region, as we organise according to the risks we perceive as the priority.
Edit: I agree with John that decolonisation isn't done until our countries can restore the ways that we once related to one another before colonisation (except maybe Singapore, which arguably does not need this part), because those were sovereign decisions which were rooted in the logic and worldview of our own cultures. I'll give an example: in pre-colonial times, even though the region had wars just like any other in medieval periods, diplomatic relations between trading nations were fairly equal. Equal as in, even a country as large as China might marry their princesses to a Southeast Asian royal to seal a diplomatic relationship. However, when the Europeans came in to "trade", not a single one of them would have considered it as anything but beneath them to marry their royals to ours. And many of us have internalised that inferiority complex through the centuries of colonisation. Now, of course we're no longer in an era where we have to cement diplomatic relations with monarchic marriages anymore, and nobody is interested in reviving that, but recovering the worldview where we hold ourselves and our cultures as inherently equal to other nation-cultures, is part of finishing the decolonisation process.
Edit 2: I think you can understand ASEAN's actions better if your culture is also comprised of the 'extended family'.
Philippine did obey USA
What is the difference between ASEAN and EU?
@SillyBillyOneHundreadMilly - (A.S.E.A.N) - is - (An - Association) - ✅️ ✅️ ✅️ ✅️ ✅️ - (Decision - Made) - is - Via - (Consensus) - 🎯🎯🎯🎯🎯 - (There) - is - (No) - (A.S.E.A.N) - (Parliament) - ❌️❌️❌️❌️❌️ - (The - EU) - 🇪🇺 🇪🇺 🇪🇺 🇪🇺 🇪🇺 - is - A - (Political - Union) - 🎯🎯🎯🎯🎯 - with - (1) - (Unitary - Parliament) - ✅️ ✅️ ✅️ ✅️ ✅️ - (Decision - Made) - By - (A - Vote) - By - (All - Members) - ✋️✋️✋️✋️✋️ -
@@SillyBillyOneHundreadMillyEU is colonizers meanwhile ASEAN was colonized by them
@@pritaf.s3637 Who did EU colonise?
Fantastic discussion and cool choice of guests. Was interesting to hear the manner in which the fabric of relationships and culture was built over centuries.
The recovery of mutual cooperation and overcoming Colonialism over the past decade - was thought provoking.
Thanks Pascal for posting this!!
I am baffled how you manage to choose such a diverse and intellectual powerhouses- in these posts.
Wish just 1/10th of this quality and diversity of folks were featured in our press and think tanks here in the US. But I guess we have been fed with such freak shows by western media over the past 3 decades - it would be unthinkable to comprehend another perspective by our editors, directors and most viewers.
IMF told us Indonesian to stop building our own plane design. With those loan as hostage. We must did it to survive.
As a technological Institute, that's a slap on my face that I cant ever forget.
This is so fascinating to hear, being here in NZ where it is still fully colonized as is Australia. So hope we can all stand up against the "western" powers. I am caucasian however i stand for the rights of indigenous of each country and the unfair practises that they have suffered
Looking at the utterance of the NZ leaders and the ones here in Australia I don't hold out a lot of hope.
We have to build resistance to US hegemony together
@@jameslawrie3807people in AU and in NZ need to really wake up. We need to show them West is wanting war with China so lets give them facts and take action
Their is a huge difference between the NZ and the Australian indigenous, we welcome and enjoy the company of those from NZ , unfortunately we have to secure our homes , cars and property from our locals but have no control over our wallets that are emptied by those in Govt that hand out our earnings to those who don’t contribute to society
Same. I'm a white American. I converted to Islam 9 yrs ago. Now I'm in Malaysia
ASEAN represents Southeast Asia countries wisdom, intelligence, pragmatism. How they interact with each other to resolve problems, or mitigate issues from further escalations. There will always be issues. There is no need for colonialists & imperialists to be the police, and dictating the rules and how ASEAN should behave. Only through diplomacy, conversation, discussion to help resolve and/or mitigate problems.
Well said!
Wrong!
ASEAN is the most successful group in the whole world Check with professor Mr Kishore Mubani
Before watching this interview I saw a short video with a guy and a girl.
"He asks:
- Where are you from?
- I'm from Texas. - replies the girl.
- Can you tell me the names of 5 European countries?
After thinking for a few seconds, the girl says.
- Australia.
- Some more?
The girl thinks and responds.
-That's all I got."
Interviewees here made interesting comments about the ineffectiveness of the ridiculous discourse that Europeans and Americans use in southwest China to try to co-opt Asians. But we must remember that this same discourse is very efficient when used in Australia, a paradoxically non-Asian country in Asia.
It's easy to laugh watching the video I mentioned at the beginning. But the truth is that that poor, ignorant girl from Texas is a victim of the American disinformation system. Australians are also victims of a similar disinformation system.
Australia is located in Asia and harbors immense distrust, envy and aggression towards China and its partners in the region. The Australians bought Anglo/American nuclear submarines because according to them the country is afraid of being invaded by the Chinese. And yet for thousands of years China never showed any interest in colonizing Australia, it was the English who did this by transforming that island continent into a prison and enslaving the local native peoples.
Chinese fleets arrived in Africa earlier than the West, but they only brought back giraffes and ivory, while Western fleets sold African black people as slaves.
"Smart shaming" is ridicule and punishment of any deeper or critical thinking and knowledge.
Who coined that expression? The Filipinos. They knew exactly.
The Germans even have a hate-word for that. A guy who attempts to introduce critical remarks and arguments (especially since the pandemic) is called "Schwurbler". Yes there are some right-wingers who are critical about vaccines and there are classic anti-vaxxers. But the whole debate got out of control. It has become pseudo-religious and authoritarian. It became more important to crucify and cremate a witch or sorcerer (=heterodox) than to find common ground and solve a problem.
That’s why the Europeans defined Australia to be in Oceania not in Asia.
Luckily Antarctica is not a “country’s property “
One must look at the demographics of the Aussie population. That's where the distrust or should I say fear of China comes from. The west has always held sway over most of the world with it's military for centuries during the colonisation. They treated the colonies as milking cows and the locals as inferior humans. That mentality has stayed.
@@yokfinlee376good point. But the racism and xenophobia are also deeply imbedded in Australian so called civil society at every level. It is so easy to utilise this against China politically.
Here's my analogies of the different nations....
1. USA - Bully in a shrinking playground
2. China - The wise elder biding its time
3. EU - Family members prone to inbreeding and infighting
4. African countries - Still to be categorized
5. ASEAN - Good neighbors. Do not always agree but will work out the issues.
6. South America - Past victims of the bully.
7. Oceania - Can't decide if it wants to side with the West or East.
Historically you're right about Europe but the main current driver of division in Europe is the US who pretends to still be occupying Europe to maintain peace and stability while driving a wedge between the main natural eurasian trading partners through coups, color revolutions, extremism and war for nothing but the US maintaining global hegemony.
Africa - Cradle of humanity. Like the babe in the cradle filled to the bursting with youthful potentialities. Wild and uncouth like a rebellious youth suffering from the traumas of brutal abuses therefore deeply damaged but also with the resilience and vibrancy of youth. Behind it the wisdom of the ancients and before it the promise of a great overcoming.
@@shaundudley4576 Too long. I would choose "Originals". Sounds more powerful and full of potential.
@@Black_Sun_Dark_Star Concise Categorising, putting into a pigeonhole such a typically western mode of discourse. No wonder you found nothing for Africa. We Africans are not nothing.
Hopefully things may change for the better, since Joebama Buyden 82 has officially DROPPED out of the US Presidential Race, after losing support from major Democratic Allies and Donors. They supported his rival Donald Trump instead. Hopefully, things can change for the better after January 19, 2025.
As for Joebama Buyden's Project Ukraine - I'm afraid that this conflict in Ukraine will end the same way the War in Afghanistan (aka the graveyard of empires) when Kyiv is finally captured and falls to the advancing Russian Forces. Then the EU & NATO may cease to exist and the US & the UK will be greatly weakened and bankrupt by these warmongering neocon LOSERS in DC after this is all said and done. Again - wars no longer works anymore, since the ones being attacked by these above warmongers now have the ability to FIGHT BACK against them now !!!
Fascinating. Wonderful. A new topic. Learning a lot. Merci Pascal
Its so unreal colonoalism is real. So our education lied about lots of things. Today, we can see actual disgusting parts of colonialism because of social media, especially in africa.
Colonialism is very real, but it is the past for most of the world. We should take away the lessons from that period of time, leave it behind and move on. Don't let it burden your future.
It's not too late to know what colonialism is .
50+ yrs ago , I started to question why colonialism have happen when the Spanish , Portuguese , Dutch, French English American s and Japanese.
As a high school student , didn't know much then , luckily our school library has good collections of world history books , a fantastic high school tea her , a great librarian who like to engage on the books that I borrowed , and my cousin a great mentor .
1 good tip I learned from them ,
Don't just read the history as written from the mind and study of the author , the author could be lazy , or rushing to write the book , etc .
They said READ BETWEEN the lines,
Read BEHIND the lines ,
Turn the story upside down ,
Filter & Shake all the book lines , and come to your conclusion .
Regarding colonialism from a high school student ,
Colonialism is conquest /conquer / & confiscate.
Later years ,
It's the extraction of everything from the colonies ,
Resources like human and material resources .
Taking them , and brainwashing them make them loyal and wanting to be a colonial slaves.
Look at India ,
They loved being a colonial slaves .
@@Black_Sun_Dark_Star What can be, unburdened by what has been
@@enzoh7763 Getting to the bottom of things is what I like to do, especially with knowledge. Those were the days of "fast" territorial expansion and it has left an indelible mark in history. Let's move on from that.
@@pr0newbie indeed
last year a german "diplomat" went to Namibia and complained to Namibian minister about the presence of too many chinese people in namibia!
Hahaha seen that interview too. And i laughed when i saw that diplomat face when Namibian minister said China always help us meanwhile European always give us trouble, and he tells how germany make it hard for Namibia diplomats go there just few weeks before.
As Indonesian, we also got the same hypocrisy treatment. Europe banned our palm oil products in the name of deforestation and green movement. However when we banned raw nickel export to minimize emissions etc, they sue us. What hypocrite people
That's typical Westerners attitude 😅
@@pritaf.s3637Gid Xhosen. Self Appointed, really. Said the Pinoy?!
Thank you Dr Lottaz. 🕊
What a pleasure to hear from your estimed guests John Pang and Naoko Kumada. I hope that ASEAN continues to be a focus for future neutrality studies programs. I would be grateful to lean more from your guests about Myanmar and West Papua,.
Minute 9:45
Dr. Kumada is right. Cambodia and Laos were bombed extensively by the US in its UNDECLARED wars against them, as a side show of the big power war in Vietnam.
Indeed, these nations were destroyed during OTHER PEOPLE'S WAR.
Good insight.
Thailand used to be called the Coup Capital of the world because of the near-constant coups it was experiencing, mostly due to the imperialistic influence of certain western countries. The Philippines is a prime example that colonialism still clings on to power in Southeast Asia. The US will not abandon its Borgian objectives in Southeast Asia quietly. In fact, the Philippines is where the US perfected its colonialist policy under the guise of "benevolence". People still remember that it was President McKinley who formulated the US "Benevolent Assimilation" policy of assimilating everyone into the American culture, political structure and even language.
Don't talk as if other countries aren't influenced by Western culture!
Your cellphone is brought by Western culture of democracy and freedom. So those aren't directly influenced by US similar to PH doesn't mean you aren't influenced by the US. Almost all countries in ASEAN thrive because of capitalism! Development is also indirectly brought by capitalism.
And unsurprisingly the religiosity of political leaders and public institutions in the Phillipines resembles the Godmerican state of rule by fear and division.
@@LarryfromPH other southeast Asian just salty about Philippines.
Because french and Britain just see them as laborer that why there tradition is intact.
Unlike Philippines Spain really erase Philippines tradition and input Spanish tradition that why we have Christianity and latin surname that why we also called the European in asia
Then american came and reengineered our tradition to become more American . Little brother of America in Asia.
Well they just jealous because we always chosen by other powerful country I don't if it is blessing or curse.
Go to Myanmar right now and see the horrors of people there...then come back here and tell me who is more Lucky...the philippines or Myanmar??....LOL
@@egielynabunda7888It's a curse. Look at the sins in Angeles City, unimaginable! And the hypocrisy of the Church, closing one eye to Angeles City which pontifying the usual daily.
thank you so much John, Naoko and Pascal. I've been fed with delicious insights and informatiion. Love your perspectives and analysis. Greetings from Thailand.
Thank you for having on John and Naoko. Asean is rising.
Observation…ASEAN’s patience with its members seems to recognize the “everlasting” of culture, while acknowledging the more transient struggles we all have with the current situations. All changes bring stresses. The major stresses for individuals are usually due to, loss of income, loss of a loved one, or changing one’s location etc. However, as time passes, we return to our normal way of dealing with our relationships. This is a very mature approach to life in general.
Such excellent guests! I look forward to the continuation of this discussion. Thank you Pascal.
Look at how EU treats Hungary's oban and compare that with how asean members treat each other, John really summed it up perfectly
Victor Orban is currently the President of the useless EU and the un-elected warmongering neocon LOSERS in Brussels are all on the take from the current Joebama Buyden's administration whose expiration date is January 19, 2025. On January 20, 2025 hopefully a new and improved US President will be sworn-in to replace this current 82 year old Joebama Buyden who is stepping-down, and is NOT seeking re-election on July 22, 2024.
If you recognize Oban for the man he is then you’d realize why he is treated the way he is.
@@SeanHogan_frijoleLol nope, you just want to show who is superior rather than doing discussion and solves the issues.
Hungaria needs the hard Hand of the EU!Taking the money from the EU but not wanting playing py the rules wont Work!Hungaria is doomed anyway,Not even the Help from the EU wont help much!
@@BrunoHeggli-zp3nl EU is already doomed, nothing but a bunch of yes men and women to the USA, paying 3 times more for usa gas, sending tens of billions to Ukraine 's corrupt regime, taking orders from USA to hurt their own enterprises, etc, EU is done for, but Hungary has the foresight saying no to being a puppet
The good thing is that the Empire USA is falling. The main reason is, the US forgott to invest in the economy, education, puplic tranportation, infrstructure., then they infest only in the Army and NATO. The downfall of the US is unstopable.. With the downfall of the USA also the NATO and the EU will falling.
They need not have to. They have a unlimited gigantic credit card: they can live off the hard work and resources of the rest of the world.
Then what?
only dictators fall apart... Democracy change leadership every 4 or 6 years....LOL....
Having a Lottaz thoughtfulness and understanding of the world naturally earns your channel a lottaz fans!🌏
Wow ,, i learn a lot from this video .
Specifically from Mr John Pang.
He articulate , very excellently, the spirit and essence of ASEAN .
It's really nice to hear SEA voices for once tho we prefer to be ignored and underrated in general 🤣
As ASEAN people yes I agree, we rather not being included in global dramas 😂😅
@@pritaf.s3637 IKR. We want to be keep out of the nonsense
I strongly agree. We keep low profile and we do things our way. Love thy neighbors.
Guess we love our role as middle child 😂
Simply, there is a lot of people in Southeast Asia who are multilingual, particularly in Malaysia and Singapore, where, if they are inquisitive and would like to seek information and perspectives, they are equipped to read not only the Anglo-Saxon media, but also the the Chinese language, Bahasa and also Hindi/Tamil, which helps them weave through what's impartial and what's agenda-driven, if they actually try.
They live it.
@youknowkbbaby different place, different culture... no way it's the same.
indonesian here, in my country itself we've so many ethnic language.
@youknowkbbabywe have less problems with genocide, femicide and unstable political revolutions 😂😂😂
excellent episode and very interesting. Keep up the great work. The world is changing. We need someone to tell the truth!
So good to hear we are on the same wave-length. USA is like a teenager who is still growing up. The Brits have always thought they are superior (the upper crust).
Minute 23: 17 Dr. Pang
The mind set of ASEAN is different from the EU mindset.
ASEAN does not need to apologize for not being an EU copycat.
I came across your channel yesterday and was impressed with the content. It's so good to see our young folks waking up to this Tyranny and standing up. I am very proud of you. Subscribed.
Really brilliant discussion! Please bring these two on again to talk about SE Asia, ASEAN and BRICS.
Thank you Mr. Pang. Thank you Ms. Kumada. Thank you Pascal (Professor Lottaz). Your channel, your guests, your conduct, your knowledge deepen, broaden, fortify my knowledge, understanding, perspective world view. Best wishes. 🌞🖖🏼✌🏼
Alhamdulillah, John mentioned why we Malaysian accepting or leaning towards more to China. It is sad to see if our ASEAN is divided into 2, you know which countries that disagreed with the rest.
Don't forget Malaysia has huge ethnic Chinese population
@@HenryKajana actually both Indonesia and Thailand have larger populations of ethnic Chinese than Malaysia. In fact in both countries the numbers double that of Malaysia.
Greetings from Australia
US wanted to make a fool out of China. But instead, the US made a fool of itself. Let that be a lesson.
How?
@@borisnegrarosa9113 China has the greatest manufacturing capacity. US has the greatest clown production capacity and the greatest national debt.
@@borisnegrarosa9113 We're witnessing the decline of the US empire. US needs to give up its delusions of grandeur and agree to mutually beneficial cooperation with the rest the world.
@@borisnegrarosa9113 How ? Are you playing dumb or just being ignorant ? 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
@@PerceivedREALITY999 Very well said 👍👍👍😍😍😍😍😍
Loved the interview! Everyone is obviously intelligence and know what they are talking about. There's no groundless random claims/statements about this and that. Everything was followed up with history, factual information. There are so much histories and knowledge to learn from listening to John and Naoko speak.
They Just Tell everybody what south east asians want to hear!The West is so bad,all the Problems are only from the West!Yes Sure China with the extremly fast ageing population is realy the Future and Europe and the US are doomed right?Thats why Most of the people immigrate to China and Not to Europe or the US right?Right?Hahaha
This is very interesting to me. Im a westerner whos been living in South East Asia for many years and marveling how Asia (especially China) has been moving boldly into the future, while the west clings on to the old ways and old beliefs. I think maybe the desparate attempts to paint China as backwards and dangerous is just the wests way to avoid moving forward themselves. I love Asia!
Australia hasn't been close to neutral to our Asian neighbours since 1996.
Such a wasted chance to make friends and community among the nearby nations.
Interesting that you should mention the conflicts in East Timor and West Papua. There is a discussion to be had about Indonesia being a regional empire, holding onto places post - colonialism, despite them having claims to independence.
The thing is the neocolonial country of Indonesia has the backing of China. After all Sukarno was himself a communist.
True
But they don't have the backing of China for their independence.. that is why the colonialism continues.
Communists literally murdered Indonesia into an artificial hegemony during 1945-1964.. killing most ethnic minority leaders, subjugating and crushing their Kingdoms. No surprise it is something they don't teach in Indonesian history books.
Indonesia is basically the dutch east indies 2.0, and to be honest most indonesians don’t really like china let alone oz (except maybe Balinese)
⚠️ the End of
Free Lunch for
Westerners ⚠️
Agreed No such thing as free lunch, what goes up will come down
Huge unlimited credit card they have.
Thanks Pascal, Naoko and John for a great and enlightening discussion.
I recall Karmala Harris' recent trip to convince the Vietnamese that they should take a more aggressive stance to China, you could literally see all of the Vietnamese officials biting their lips to keep themselves from laughing in her face. Why the hell would Vietnam want to pick a fight with their nearest neighbour of 1.3 billion people, and their most important trade partner. I think to try seal the deal the US offered them a few tens of millions of dollars in aid, which just seemed like an insult.
As I was listening to your program I was sitting in Battambang, Cambodia, writing a research report on sustainable agriculture in ASEAN countries. The main point where I would disagree with your analysis is that whilst SE Asian countries are really starting to put the political beast of colonialism in its grave, economic colonialism is still quite strong, particularly in the plantations and mining sectors, but you know, the national governments also lean into these sectors for the foreign exchange, whilst throwing their own people and environment under the bus of bad terms of trade and externalization of production costs.
Von Leyen is ridiculous. Brussel is ridiculous, it makes so many peoples sad. Even in Europe.
Wrong!
What IS wrong? Please, explaim
@@NoelleChanHinVon der Leyen isnt ridiculous at all!She is a strong clever woman who know what she is doing!Shes just buy the best!
Minute 24:17 onwards Dr. Pang explains the different mind set of ASEAN and the EU
There is no need to apologize for NOT being the EU
Southeast is leading the world to a new era of humanity evolution ! Where not only in technology, science and innovation but in the new philosophy of the growth of human conscious !
Bullshit!
thank you very much to neutrality studies for your work, for your studies, for helping us to understand the historical reality free of rhetoric and propaganda, necessary foundations for the construction of a more educated and more aware society
Very enlightening by the two respectable guest based on history and facts. Thank you.
The best stand against western hegemony was done by late Singapore founder and he said Singapore can never become a Christian country with their values because there is something special and beautiful about values from ancient Chinese and Indian culture. That sums up where Asia and Asean should stand for.
Christian mentality of "waiting for a miracle" completely contradicts Chinese hardworking ethics & discipline.
@@chanellover4491 Pardon, that's nonsense, no one talks about a Christian mentality of 'waiting for a miracle'.
Japan (south Korean and Filippinos included ) now seen as more of American puppy dogs rather than Asian powers . We Asian feel ashamed of it,
Monkey alpha😛😛😛😛😛
dont forget abt taiwan and hongkong which is used by the west against china
Filipinos can't shake off their deep-seated colonial mentality w/ their media & academia feedinng off the west3rn through
@@andi_LeeThe pride they have being associated with the Americans can be nauseating.
@@ZhenYae utub appeared to have deleted my comment
I think and would say that it was the Indochina Wars and the Indonesian Wars. Those didn't end until late 90s/early 2Ks. So there's still reconciliation coming around. With the Phillipines still being a quasi-colony of the US. The region is still in the decolonizing process. That said, ASEAN is much farther ahead than Africa is.
Asia, Southeast Asia in particular, is always a territory of peace until western colonizer moved in starting 16th century when China took the world center stance, and a strong and peace-loving China will continue to play a vital role to make peace as desirable as possible after China rise up again. I also believe ASEAN can be seem as a role model to the rest of world where “multipolarity” is a doable and salutary path forward thru peaceful co-existence first and become co-prosperous afterwards. The bottom line is we must learn from history that “conflict and bloodshed only happened as a result of failed diplomacy”, and rule #1 of diplomacy is “talk” to your adversary and #2 seeking acceptable compromise after understanding what your adversary’s concern.
That's because pre 16th century Southeast Asia had fuck all going for it. You can't start a war with another SeS nation if you can't even build a boat big enough to travel that far.
ASEAN essentially is a economic entity. Yes, over the decades, it evolves with some political integration in terms of political views. Yet, it never and should not aspire to be EU where it overrides national or local governments, breaching democratic principles. These EU Parliament who were not elected by the people of the countries of EU, yet their decisions are binding on member countries, robbing them of their national sovereignty. ASEAN does not interfere with the domestic politics and development of member countries.
The American Committee on United Europe was a OSS/CIA project now called the EU.
The EU Parliament is elected by people across the EU, but it is not where the decision making power resides. The Commission is absolutely not a democratic organisation, the appointments are decided behind closed doors and rubber stamped by Parliament.
The EU Parliament is elected by the people though.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_to_the_European_Parliament
Thank you for the rich content and context to International relations in relation to Asia. Hope Brics incorporates other smaller Asian countries from ASEAN to work with Africa. We have similar histories and understanding of effects of colonialism to our countries. A new progressive global order can help develop our continents further. Thank you Dr Lottaz, Dr Pang and Dr Kumada ... keep up the amazing work.
Mrs Kumada's topic of research is fascinating. Let's have a deep dive on this?
It's just so wonderful,
Learning at TH-cam
University 🥰
I've gained so much
Knowledge and Wisdom
by finding so many
Excellent Channels and
Guests who communicate
like Real people.
Thank You.
Thank you! I did not understand ASEAN before this dialogue.
Interesting to learn how ASEAN has dealt with Myanmar.
Especially after seeing how the EU is treating Hungary.
RESPECT for diversity is the key word.
How did they deal with it?
@@SillyBillyOneHundreadMilly
"they"? You mean the EU or the ASEAN?
@@shiulai5804 ASEAN
@@SillyBillyOneHundreadMilly The guests talked about it. My information came from them.
@@SillyBillyOneHundreadMilly
I recommend watching the tape again from Minute 23:17 on to get a sense of the different world view between the EU and ASEAN.
It is followed by specific discussion on how ASEAN has dealt with Myanmar AFTER it was sanctioned and isolated by the West.
Notably, Myanmar has never lost its membership in the ASEAN. Moreover, ASEAN is facilitating its return to the fold.
Except for Singapore (with a US base) and the Phillipines (having military affiliation with the US), other ASEAN countries opt for China.
What base?! 😊😊 in Singapore. If others want to brand Singapore as Chinese Centric then Singapore cannot possibly be on the US side.
Great interview thank all.
Hmm.... I question the non-alignment of Philippines, especially since it is one of the original signatories to the ASEAN pact. Also before the military took over, Myanmar was drifting towards the West with many instigators working within its borders. I witness their handiwork with the democratic government and the officials.
There are still US mercenary providing training and instigating war with the Myanmar gov happening. With these interferences Myanmar would be hard to reconcile. Time is what they have if they want a Myanmar gov or otherwise though their love for ASSK is a phenomenon 😅❤
@@tanharry7893 The Lady is an activist, but I wouldn't say she is a good politician. And not only US mercs, but also Brits too.
@@Black_Sun_Dark_Star And the Chinese. West-aligned resistance groups are not as successful as Chinese-aligned groups since the military tookover. Most victories by the resistance in recent months are mainly by China-aligned groups and the military is now openly angry with China for this. China seems to play both sides actively though, while the West just talks without action.
@@annuwazdmz1131 You have to realize, the Chinese doesn't interfere with their government. Never have. They sold weapons but not instigate a power change or coup de tat. The Westerners are ACTIVE agents,both militarily and politically.
The Philippines' ruling class simply assumes it will be easiest for them to court US aid money to further stimulate the country's impressive growth versus any other regional power. US economic aid has dwindled ever since the 90s when the first Aquino administration shut down Clark AFB. Also, the territorial scuffles in the South China Sea are utilized to drive more opposition to China among the electorate compared to other SEA countries.
ASEAN doesn’t include Bangladesh and Sri Lanka. It could be because culturally Bangladesh and Sri Lanka are more a part of subcontinent than ASEAN.
the fair thing i say, is that ASEAN are countries in South East Asia,, Not South Asia or East Asia
Brilliant interview 👏 Thank you.
After WWII, US realise its beneficial to help other countries post war redevelopment and able to influence the politic in this countries. Soon US have foot print in almost every chaos in the world but there are never any military confrontation with a developed countries with a relatively advance military power.
Even thou US involved in most war but never win any. As for South China Sea chaos, from historical US carrier fleet on the term of freedom of navigation will be sail through Strait of Taiwan to showcase their naval power to pressure China but now with China development of naval power strong enough to go against US. China drawn the sea border to keep the US out and in check with their long range aircraft carrier killer missile.
Any Western involvement will not benefit ASEAN. Its mainly for their self interest or agenda. Hungry and Slovakia are never really treated as part of EU, while Serbia and Turkey application into EU are always lips service only.
Thank you, fascinating and enlightening. I simply had no idea, I do now - at least a bit.
Nice article
However, to be exact, China crushed western hegemony. Now countries from all continents have options not be subjected to western oppression especially US
ASEAN has for the past 57 yrs shown to the whole what it means to live harmoniously peacefully as neighbors in the region, helping each other in trade & economic development for peace & prosperity together while respecting each other’s sovereignty and NOT to interfere with each other’s internal domestic matters. Differences if any are mutually discussed and settled amicably & pragmatically. Peace no war.
But Philippines is making a lot of noise about China over the S. China Sea issue and even allowed the US to build additional bases on their islands. Are they gearing up to fight China? They might turn out to be Ukraine 2.0
@@CoolCat-rw6pp Philippines have voted for their own President. If Philippines people r worried about being a puppet or become the next Ukraine / Afghanistan, it’s for them to voice their concerns & petition to their govt. Current Philippines people seems to forget what happened in Feb 1986 and why it happened.
@@CoolCat-rw6pp Yeah, like China can even reach Manila in sufficient numbers. What are they going to do? Swim from Shenzhen?
Thanks for making and uploading intelligent videos.
I fully agree that global colonialism is finally coming to an end.
Most global South countries are regaining back real sovereignty and independence.
Western influence will remain but can no longer direct or subvert politically with the exception of some who will also continue to pay the high price.
Hail Mary. Do they ever wonder why from across the Pacific they pray for different outcome...Gid saved Trump?! My...
EU wants ASEAN to be like them, US stooges and battering ram against US enemies🤣🤣🤣
Yes,and thats a good thing!
outstanding interview. 💖🙏
Thank you for sharing
ASEAN largest trading partner is China. Nothing else to say
asean largest 'interest owners' are still from west. 'interest' here means factories, ip, education system, medicine, etc. its a balance
Some say that Asian crisis was teallynUS economic attack vs.
potentially truly independent
économies.
Three talent, smart people
Excellent discussion
John should let Naoko finish her point before adding his point.He is going to get it later back home😂
The wife will have the last word.....
Some how I feel like the guest speakers are mocking Philippines for being the stupid ones in Asean.
It is what it is. Why would the Pinoy want to convince Asean to be recolonized by Westerners again in the form of the US led West.
Regarding wars in asean panelists forgot to mention the Japanese invasion and atrocities in Asean countries. How can this so-called experts forgot about this.
It's mostly focused on post WWII world order. Of course they know about Japanese occupation and atrocities.
Indonesia's first president, Sukarno, together with Jawaral Nehru from India, were the initiators who had the foresight to rise from colonialism, peace and poverty in Asian and African countries at that time so they created theNon-Aligned Movement. But there are still many countries in Asia that still do not understand the good intentions of this aims until now like Malaysia.
LOL...yea...We ASEAN are so Non- Aligned, that we can't even do anything in Myanmar crisis, except condemn it, do meetings...do meetings...and more meetings, without doing anything except meetings....LOL.... I rather the philippines Join NATO or EU than waste time in ASEAN that can't do anything except play football and do meetings...
Southeast Asia is countries in a circle....not easy to have direct conflict....
I like these neutral but variable/conversations on taboo independance and variability reflecting European energy variability moves in response to Russia.the east is going forwards whilst the west seem's to be going backwards in many way's,which must be discussed if the whole world can continue to look forward to a fair future regardless of super consolidated wealthy individual's drawing up there own future's in the guise of everyone's
This is the time and the place for the people of the world to unite and defeat western hegemony which has trampled upon the world for too long.
Way too long. They are hell bent, hand on their God, they are supreme. Whatever iteration they come up with either through religion, civilization, democracy it is to justify their WH supremacy.
If it were my wife and I speaking together publically, I'd yield my time for her to speak first, to reap the "rewards" later heh
For anyone that is not particularly familiar with ASEAN I can recommend the following book. “The Asean Miracle” by Kishore Mahbubani dated 8 March 2017.
Good point! I never realize the first debt trap to my country is not by Chinese but IMF.
Great sharing. Thanks.
Hi Pascal, have a chat to Jerry Grey about the South China sea - or just watch his brief but succinct video for some background on the dispute and who is really the bully.
Watching from Philippines new suscriber
Yes! Filipino Here Too!❤
How the ASEAN has dealt with its member, Myanmar, is a good illustration of its distinctiveness from the approach of the West. (Minute 28:36 )
Thank you Pascal for inviting John & Naoko....the A team of S.E. Asia...very important to hear more from them....please...
24:17 Dr. Pang explains the different minds set of ASEAN and the EU
Indeed. No need for the ASEAN to be a mini EU
Can't we all just get along?
Economic, political, and military neutrality needs to become a world standard for all nations.
Neutrality Principles need to be clearly defined and widely promoted.
Moreover, embracing the NON PARTISAN, (what's good for society as a wholel vis-a-vis the partisan "winner take all," approach is key to achieving peace and prosperity for all.
China wants world domination. They are not going to settle for "multipolarity". Belt and road was created for this.
Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam, Indonesia etc. have played the delicate balancing act of maintaining relationship with the West (US led) & China (+Russia) since at least 50 years ago.
We are not beginners. 😂😂😂
We attracted significant investment from both sides, continously for a few decades already.
Japan is the third important actor, specifically for manufacturing transfactories invesment & economical aid.
We are part of the fast growing APAC region.
Why not Bangladesh? Why not Sri Lanka? Because ASEAN was Asia centric, as the name implies. The member countries all face the Pacific. Adding the sub continent to Asia, and calling the whole area Indo Pacific, is a purely American invention, to bring India in to counter China.
Frankly, if one accepts the Indo Pacific concept, one might as well add the Persian Gulf and beyond…
More specifically, it is South East Asia centric. Bangladesh, India, Japan, etc are part of Asia, but not part of SEA.
@@PhiloSurfer Yes,,, key is SOUTH EAST ASIA countries only
To Bolster the Indian ego. Huge thang for Indians to be acknowledged by Master Ji.
SEA is stand for South East Asia.
@@vicolewevery Asia country can joint if you meet ASEAN requirement