The conductor sweats every note, that's what I call work ethic. How does a musician in a grand orchestra feel when he plays such delicate tunes, they can't allow themselves to drown in sentimentality and pathos, every expression of their trembling bodies has to be 100% accurate and yet convey the deepest emotions. And this is required of every and the last musician, they can't let themselves get carried away as a group neither, drifting from here to there. How does this organism breath with such controlled precision and yet create such stunning emotional movements, rising and falling, a sea of longing and torment.
Agreed. Every musician in this group possesses stunning emotional connection to the work. Lovely in every sense of the word. Deeply moving. Thank you for the beautiful summation of this profound piece of art.
I am part of a couple of orchestras. I cannot put into words what it is like. Very... transcendental, like you are a small part of a machine, not unnatural but rather organic. Like you are part of a bigger plan and you can see it all coming together around you. Like you matter and what you say matters, even if nobody understands it, they feel it, like you're speaking but not talking and somehow everyone knows. It makes you feel big and small at the same time; individual and part of a group. It's hard to explain.
I am 61 years of age and have only discovered this wonderful piece of music in the last couple of years ( since gaining access to utube ). The more I keep watching/ listening ,the more fonder and appreciative I find myself of it.
It really is an incredible piece of music. I had the privilege of watching the Royal Scottish National Orchestra perform this last night and it's an experience I'll never forget. It's so moving.
I’ve been listening to this piece for over 30 years and it’s never too late to start. Between this piano concerto and Rachmaninov’s second symphony, you’re in for a lifelong treat.
Both the soloist, and the orchestra are brilliant. I’ve heard this piece played a million times, I’ve even played it from within the orchestra, and there are things I hear in this live concert that I’ve never heard before. Wow!
Yes, I have played this (and Concerto nr 3) in the orchestra, I sat on second clarinet. I could only wish that the audience be seated inside the orchestra, because when performing this in the orchestra, you really notice all fantastic things that Rachmaninov has done in the orchestra parts, behind the soloist! The best concerto all times, and this second movement is the absolute high point!
It's one of the reasons why I love to hear this woman play. Some have criticized her tempo as "ponderously slow." My advice to those is to get some help for their ADD.
Bravo! Rachmaninoff was a genius when it comes to turning raw emotion into music. How can you not shed tears when listening to this concerto? This music ascends into Heaven.
this reminds me of the first clarinet lesson i ever had with a professional and he made me prioritize rhythm and this just reminded me of that amazing memory.
This is a tremendous concert, the performers and the pianist are great! I think this masterpiece has the power to translate beauty, tenderness and strengh! The third section for me is quite fantastic! Thanks, God to inspire human race to create and to perform such art's work. For me, music is always filling my soul - when sometimes, gray days insist on hiding Sun's light! People who loves music are not 'all by themselves'!
Hudba je cesta za krásou, vlévá do duše člověka touhu.. umocňuje mu radost z bytí, kdo vnímá je bohatý ať je v samotě nebo v objetí... pozdrav z České republiky... Ivan a něco od nás th-cam.com/video/7Sbqu4d25hg/w-d-xo.html
To me, the most haunting moment was when she turns her head towards the sound of the clarinet in the first few bars, just after the flute speaks; it is an eternal moment I'll never forget. Her response to this sound was perfect when the voice of her soul leaked from her fingers onto the keys. Thank you for such a wonderful recording.
One of my favorite things about her is how she interacts with the orchestra. She always engages with them and you get the sense that she's really listening to them and enjoying their playing, not just thinking about her next note. It's beautiful to see this kind of exchange and cohesion.
Ce concert est magnétoscopé chez moi car jamais je n’ai entendu meilleure interprétation que la tienne (c’est Khatia qui joue du ..... Khatia. Elle excelle tellement dans cette interprétation qu’elle à surpassé le maître. Ce jour là à Aix elle a mis la salle en 🔥 feu je n’oublie évidemment Le Maestro Gian Andrea qui est également dans l’excellence. 💔🌹💔🌹💔🌹💔👎💔🌹💔🌹🇫🇷🇮🇹🇫🇷🇮🇹
Alors là nous touchons au sublime ! Ce jour là à Aix la salle était en délire j’ai magnétoscopé ce concert et le regarde très très souvent merci Khatia mais merci aussi au Maestro Gian Andréa ils étaient en symbiose touslesdeux merci évidemment à l’ensemble orchestrale 💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟
J'aime beaucoup Rachmaninof je l'écoute souvent avant de dormir et je m'evade, avec le vent, la pluie l'orage, puis le calme revient un oiseau prend son envol et chante, la musique raconte son histoire
interprétation parfaite … c’est mon morceau tant aimé passage extraordinaire il décrit si bien magnifique pianiste magnifiques solistes magnifique orchestre et chef ….. MERCI ❤
This piece of music describes life as it joy in the deepest pain and the highest joy in that pain especially in this adagio. Curious to the person Rachmaninov who wrote this stunning piece of music. Stunning deep and beautiful.
Es una poesía musical. Kathia es bella elegante y refinada, las notas del piano emanan con acordes bellísimos, en que la pasión no falta, Con melodía llena de dulzura que me trasporta en el tiempo evocando recuerdos del ayer. Maravillosa interpretación propia de una virtuosa. Santiago de Chile..
Dear Sam, you always make my day joyful.We live in different countries with different culture and also on different continents, but the connection between us was possible because of the great gift for humanity--music.I have nice family/a daughter,a son and four grandchildren/.l am 68 years old but with "young heart and spirit"Four years ago I broke the joint between pelvis and thigh and after three operations l still can't walk normally But I don't feel unhappy --listen to music,read books, watch movies and TV, my friends visit me!I have been all over Europe, for six months lived in Dubai, but it 's a pity I will never visit your great, beautiful country! You are young, the life is Infront of you, so maybe one day you will visit Europe and Bulgaria--always welcome! It's a great pleasure for me to contact with you, every day I think for you,as you are my child! Take care!😘 Looking forward good news from you! Much love!🌞🔥💗🌟🎶🍀
@@dan_thepianoman4401 I wouldn't say similar. It's the same thing 1:40 Do you think they added the song here? Or did Celine Dion plagiarize Rachmaninoff?
@@Prod.Protonic True, in the sense that the song composer mistakenly thought Rach II was in the public domain. He ended up having to pay royalties to Rach's estate.
@@Prod.Protonic It was not plagiarized. It was used on purpose with every intention of everyone knowing where it came from. It was in public domain in US but not outside US. Rachmaninoff is given credit on song.
Lovely interpretation. I personally would have taken the coda a little quicker and powerful at the beginning but the whole piece is done very well. Bravo.
What Yo-yo Ma is calling projections are really cantilevers emanating from the sounds that actually reach the ear-drums. Largest cantilevers are in the silent pauses, deliberately put in by the composers.
There should be a law forbidding TH-cam to place ads in the middle of an Rachmaninoff concerto.
Commercials in the middle of Taylor Swift, fine. Rach? No. KHATIA? Never!
I just had an unstoppable ad of 15 secs for Tampax...
@@mikesierra8156 Get an ad blocker!
Are you too poor to pay for Premium?
The conductor sweats every note, that's what I call work ethic. How does a musician in a grand orchestra feel when he plays such delicate tunes, they can't allow themselves to drown in sentimentality and pathos, every expression of their trembling bodies has to be 100% accurate and yet convey the deepest emotions. And this is required of every and the last musician, they can't let themselves get carried away as a group neither, drifting from here to there. How does this organism breath with such controlled precision and yet create such stunning emotional movements, rising and falling, a sea of longing and torment.
Well spoken and an accurate assessment I'd say.
Agreed. Every musician in this group possesses stunning emotional connection to the work. Lovely in every sense of the word. Deeply moving. Thank you for the beautiful summation of this profound piece of art.
yes
I am part of a couple of orchestras. I cannot put into words what it is like. Very... transcendental, like you are a small part of a machine, not unnatural but rather organic. Like you are part of a bigger plan and you can see it all coming together around you. Like you matter and what you say matters, even if nobody understands it, they feel it, like you're speaking but not talking and somehow everyone knows. It makes you feel big and small at the same time; individual and part of a group. It's hard to explain.
@@roadscapehorror-talesofterror ça 😂qd❤ pas r
I am 61 years of age and have only discovered this wonderful piece of music in the last couple of years ( since gaining access to utube ). The more I keep watching/ listening ,the more fonder and appreciative I find myself of it.
It really is an incredible piece of music. I had the privilege of watching the Royal Scottish National Orchestra perform this last night and it's an experience I'll never forget. It's so moving.
I’ve been listening to this piece for over 30 years and it’s never too late to start.
Between this piano concerto and Rachmaninov’s second symphony, you’re in for a lifelong treat.
Try Rach 3
Both the soloist, and the orchestra are brilliant. I’ve heard this piece played a million times, I’ve even played it from within the orchestra, and there are things I hear in this live concert that I’ve never heard before. Wow!
Yes, I have played this (and Concerto nr 3) in the orchestra, I sat on second clarinet. I could only wish that the audience be seated inside the orchestra, because when performing this in the orchestra, you really notice all fantastic things that Rachmaninov has done in the orchestra parts, behind the soloist! The best concerto all times, and this second movement is the absolute high point!
Puxa! Como o pessoal é de tanta sensibilidade...tanto os músicos como os ouvintes. Desse jeito me sinto em casa. Que máximo!!! Música é coisa sagrada!
Del
The bit at 9:25 is almost too gorgeous. I love the tempo, I love hearing them hang onto every note.
that is a lovely description
It's one of the reasons why I love to hear this woman play. Some have criticized her tempo as "ponderously slow." My advice to those is to get some help for their ADD.
too pain...
9:11
Completely agree with you. Too beautiful to bear. I’d that can ever be said.
Living alone
I think of all the friends I've known
But when I dial the telephone
Nobody's home
All by myself
Don't wanna be
All by myself
Anymore 🥺
Eric Carmen
YESS LOL DID THEY TAKE IT FROM RACHMANIOV ACTUALLY?
@@whyamihere6596Yes!! ❤
This music is very addictive, played once is not enough!
agreed! it’s always stuck in my head
Ah -- the test of a true masterwork.
Bravo! Rachmaninoff was a genius when it comes to turning raw emotion into music. How can you not shed tears when listening to this concerto? This music ascends into Heaven.
Cette musique vient du Ciel
I love the way these pianists almost go into a trance when they play the second movement. How wonderful!
Her triplets are not only beautiful but also very accurate so when she accompanies the winds, everything is in place!!!
this reminds me of the first clarinet lesson i ever had with a professional and he made me prioritize rhythm and this just reminded me of that amazing memory.
This is a tremendous concert, the performers and the pianist are great! I think this masterpiece has the power to translate beauty, tenderness and strengh! The third section for me is quite fantastic! Thanks, God to inspire human race to create and to perform such art's work. For me, music is always filling my soul - when sometimes, gray days insist on hiding Sun's light! People who loves music are not 'all by themselves'!
Hudba je cesta za krásou, vlévá do duše člověka touhu.. umocňuje mu radost z bytí, kdo vnímá je bohatý ať je v samotě nebo v objetí... pozdrav z České republiky... Ivan a něco od nás th-cam.com/video/7Sbqu4d25hg/w-d-xo.html
💟💟💟💟
Loved your beautiful words, nearly as inspiring as the music itself!! It's good to know I'm not all by myself😉🙏
Loved your beautiful words, nearly as inspiring as the music itself!! It's good to know I'm not all by myself 😉🙏
Wonderfully stated Maria !
To me, the most haunting moment was when she turns her head towards the sound of the clarinet in the first few bars, just after the flute speaks; it is an eternal moment I'll never forget. Her response to this sound was perfect when the voice of her soul leaked from her fingers onto the keys. Thank you for such a wonderful recording.
One of my favorite things about her is how she interacts with the orchestra. She always engages with them and you get the sense that she's really listening to them and enjoying their playing, not just thinking about her next note. It's beautiful to see this kind of exchange and cohesion.
Wahou , tout a fait d'accord avec vous .On touche au sublime ♥️
Безумно рад и горд быть представителем великой русской культуры.😊❤
I miss you in ways not even words can understand.
I miss you too...
She manages to play and also look and see the Orchestra..........fantastic
It's always a good sign when you find the Korean and Russian alphabet in the commentaries.
I want to live in music forever, where if I were to die, I would die in music.
Боже, какая ангельская нежность, какая ЛЮБОВЬ!!!! Катенька, Вы - живое ЧУДО!!!! Я обожаю ВАС!!!!!
8:59 best moments of this piece are soon after this time mark
That's quite funny because thats also in the first movement after the 9th minute
@@sergei-prokofiev ooh, can you send the recording and timestamp?
@@Tbop3 just the word I needed to describe that heavenly moment :)
The TV director work on this is amazing!! He is bang on the bit. superb!!
LOVE OF MY LIFE!! Khatia Buniatishvili!!!
Music happens in the silence between notes
Я русская! И я счастлива читать ваши комментарии. Необыкновенная музыка! Столько нежности, трогательности, чувственности!!
9:25 wow
Totally agree !
Ce concert est magnétoscopé chez moi car jamais je n’ai entendu meilleure interprétation que la tienne (c’est Khatia qui joue du ..... Khatia. Elle excelle tellement dans cette interprétation qu’elle à surpassé le maître. Ce jour là à Aix elle a mis la salle en 🔥 feu je n’oublie évidemment Le Maestro Gian Andrea qui est également dans l’excellence. 💔🌹💔🌹💔🌹💔👎💔🌹💔🌹🇫🇷🇮🇹🇫🇷🇮🇹
Nunca voy a superar esta obra, la pasión de la interpretación es única... No me canso de escucharla.
მშვენიერია, უნიჭიერესი ხატია და რახმანინოვის გულშიჩამწვდომი მუსიკა.
Alors là nous touchons au sublime ! Ce jour là à Aix la salle était en délire j’ai magnétoscopé ce concert et le regarde très très souvent merci Khatia mais merci aussi au Maestro Gian Andréa ils étaient en symbiose touslesdeux merci évidemment à l’ensemble orchestrale 💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟
Восхитительное исполнение почти невесомые чувствительные пальчики, артистизм прочувствованный, это очень красиво
J'aime beaucoup Rachmaninof je l'écoute souvent avant de dormir et je m'evade, avec le vent, la pluie l'orage, puis le calme revient un oiseau prend son envol et chante, la musique raconte son histoire
interprétation parfaite … c’est mon morceau tant aimé passage extraordinaire il décrit si bien magnifique pianiste magnifiques solistes magnifique orchestre et chef ….. MERCI ❤
Perfect tempo
Goodness her control and passion!
This is what God had probably "in mind" when He created us.
Dear GOD our Father! In that perfect day!😍
Magnificent rendition. Full to the brim of emotion, stunning blend btw. the piano and the orchestra. Bravo !
Louis sent me here.
Lovely music, great to listen to before bed.
......carissima Khatia , quando ti vedo appari celestiale e poi la poetica musicale è inarrivabile !? Un abbraccio Jo albot
The soloist transmits the music and the conductor is magnificent
This is the only thing that can calm me down.
This piece of music describes life as it joy in the deepest pain and the highest joy in that pain especially in this adagio.
Curious to the person Rachmaninov who wrote this stunning piece of music. Stunning deep and beautiful.
Es una poesía musical. Kathia es bella elegante y refinada, las notas del piano emanan con acordes bellísimos, en que la pasión no falta, Con melodía llena de dulzura que me trasporta en el tiempo evocando recuerdos del ayer. Maravillosa interpretación propia de una virtuosa. Santiago de Chile..
Quite a fresh interpretation. The middle section is at a gallop, she rockets through. But I do like it :-)
agreed! she’s really feeling the music though the dynamics are amazing
Because I heard All by Myself before I heard this piece, I cannot hear this without the other in my head. I'm not complaining.
The music is magic. She is magic. A goddess playing music of the gods.
One thing I love about Khatia is how she seems to connect emotionally with tne orchestra.
Divin. Je dédie cette oeuvre à tous ceux qui souffrent en ce moment de par le monde , que cette musique apaise, apporte enfin la PAIX
Dear Sam, you always make my day joyful.We live in different countries with different culture and also on different continents, but the connection between us was possible because of the great gift for humanity--music.I have nice family/a daughter,a son and four grandchildren/.l am 68 years old but with "young heart and spirit"Four years ago I broke the joint between pelvis and thigh and after three operations l still can't walk normally
But I don't feel unhappy --listen to music,read books, watch movies and TV, my friends visit me!I have been all over Europe, for six months lived in Dubai, but it 's a pity I will never visit your great, beautiful country! You are young, the life is Infront of you, so maybe one day you will visit Europe and Bulgaria--always welcome! It's a great pleasure for me to contact with you, every day I think for you,as you are my child! Take care!😘 Looking forward good news from you! Much love!🌞🔥💗🌟🎶🍀
Just breathtakingly beautiful
Sono estasiata! Grazie 🙏! ❤️
Filming quite beautiful! A feast for the senses....
Idk but starting 8:59, my soul just calmed really down and felt sooo peaceful
Its like your mother hugs you and tell you that everything is going to be alright and all the pain is gone...
everything about this is beautiful
Un chef-d’œuvre
That Femme fatale playing that gorgeous music is too much to me.
Currently in love with this masterpiece
Great rendition! Some diferent from what I should listen, but really great rendition!
Le BONHEUR en musique 👌🏽🎹🎶😍
hermoso toooodooo!
Excelente interpretación de uno de los movimientos más bellos de la historia de la música. Un sentimiento único nos invade al escucharlo.
All by miself was taken from this masterpiece? Katia is not from this world, what a talent, what a way to feel the music, simply incredible !!
Yeah it was if you were asking. Extremely similar melody and chord structure
@@dan_thepianoman4401 I wouldn't say similar. It's the same thing 1:40
Do you think they added the song here? Or did Celine Dion plagiarize Rachmaninoff?
@@tomdomagalski3679 Eric carmen was the original singer. Rachmaninoff was credited in the music composition actually
I think they sampled “All by Myself” from this song
@@tomdomagalski3679Well, who was living earlier?
Beyond words!
RACHMANINOFF music from another world.
I love this master piece...
Beautiful
Maravilloso 😘😍
Fabulosa❤
Exquisite.
Exquisito y magnífica dirección e interpretación. Es sublime.
Sublime. Divino.
Ela é simplesmente divina.
Stupendo ♥️
The song "all by my self" from Eric Carmen in based on this one. Nice!
Plagiarised lol .
@@Prod.Protonic A good one
@@Prod.Protonic True, in the sense that the song composer mistakenly thought Rach II was in the public domain. He ended up having to pay royalties to Rach's estate.
@@Prod.Protonic It was not plagiarized. It was used on purpose with every intention of everyone knowing where it came from. It was in public domain in US but not outside US. Rachmaninoff is given credit on song.
საოცრებაა!❤️❤️🙏🌷
am proud of you my angel
beautiful.
Божественная!!!
Es un Fredy Mercury de música clásica! Una diosa de piano! No hay mas palabras para describir la belleza que crea por tocar el piano 😘😘😘🥰🥰🥰
Rachmaninov ein Vertreter der Romantik.
Es lebe die blaue Blume als Symbol der Romantik.
Amar es el arte de toda tu existencia. la.música es su mejor representación.
Beleza infinda em todos os sentidos!Grande júbilo vivenciar momentos assim!Gratidão!
Beautiful piece and So exquisitely played. It was The late Princess Diana’s favorite piece… and she could play it also
Hermosa obra, con un final celestial. El genio de Rachmaninof.
Don’t mind me, I’m just using this comment as a time stamp as I always want to come back to 8:55 every time I’m in my feelings 😌
vu cette grande artiste et charmante dame Khatia Buniatishvili à Royan les violons sur le sable :un régal !!!.🥰😍🤩
Sublime!!!
Rachmaninoff is easily top 5 composers
sublime
From 2:59 - 3:21 is undescribable beauty and pain.
Lovely interpretation. I personally would have taken the coda a little quicker and powerful at the beginning but the whole piece is done very well. Bravo.
Thats miracle
real great performance
if you just think:
this music sheet Rachmaninov wanted to be burned to ashes ...
Is that really true?
Is that really true?
Magnifique ❤❤❤Jean
연주도 외모도
어찌 이리 아름다우신가요
전 어쩌라구요
It sounds like heaven
magnifique
sensationell
I didn't notice the sound was turned off until it was at the end of performance. What was I thinking?!!!
Listening to this life is my dream
What Yo-yo Ma is calling projections are really cantilevers emanating from the sounds that actually reach the ear-drums. Largest cantilevers are in the silent pauses, deliberately put in by the composers.
Wow.