When I first saw this, I cheered when the old bellhop man appeared. He is the earthly host of The Giant, and you just knew he was there to help Cooper finally solve it.
Twin peaks is one of those shows where it’s absurdly brilliant, or just plain absurd. Either way you can’t take your eyes off it for one second, even if absolutely nothing is happening.
Dream logic. You feel there's an underlying structure, pattern, or sense to the events you're witnessing, but there's isn't; it's a phantom sensation. Most of Lynch's stuff runs on dream logic. It's really terrific how his stuff uncouples character and narrative from the linear conscious mind.
@@Sir_Roquefort He was also around and working on the show for the first 7 episodes of season 2 though. After that, Lynch and Frost started keeping their distance until the finale.
Cooper dreamed this sentence but didn't understand it. The elderly waiter delivers the line which draws Cooper's attention. But Leland Already KNOWS The Gum!!
I think it's just a sort of confirmation by the Giant to Cooper that Leland is the killer. It's basically a police lineup, with Briggs bringing the waiter in to point a finger at one of the suspects. Leland recognizes the gum, and Cooper recognizes the significance of that. And I think Leland is the only one who recognizes or remembers the gum because the gum has some kind of connection to Bob. I always imagined that when Bob first met Leland, when he was a boy, Bob shared that brand of gum with him to befriend him, before he began to abuse and eventually inhabit him. I'm speculating wildly of course, but literally the only times Leland ever mentions his childhood are when talking about Bob, and about this gum he likes. So I don't think it's an unreasonable connection to make. And the whole show is about cycles of abuse and how those who were themselves abused can become the abuser if that trauma isn't dealt with. So something coming back in style is just another parallel/metaphorical cycle.
@@kevinkuenn5733 There's a monstrous 4 and a half hour theory about the meaning of this whole show, I highly recommend it. Basically, Bob is a representation of violence as well as meaningless insertions of other things into film media, such as advertisements- based on The Arm's line "His name is Bob, eager for fun, he wears a smile, everybody run" as such a simple thing but very dangerous.
I think its foreshadowing the cycle of events that keep happening over and over again, each version driven by the lodges to maintain the same track and course of events.
You can tell this was after Lynch left. He would never tie up a loose end so tightly as this, going so far as to repeat the line it's referencing word for word. This spells things out for the audience far too plainly.
@@Thoracius Yeah, but it is still well-written. This is very clumsy, trying to make sense of something that was originally just supposed to be evocative and weird.
Completely disagree. This whole sequence felt quite poignant with its mysterious aura connecting all of the intangible things in Cooper's mind. We as the audience have already seen who killed Maddie, and this is about Cooper learning the truth. The fact that it all comes together with the killer blissfully unaware as he comments on something as innocuous as the gum makes it all the more chilling. WHERE is BOB? How close to the surface is BOB within him? Absolutely chilling.
I've always founded weird how the showed the killer for the audience before Cooper. Wasn't the hole point we finding out things alongside him? Also they took practically a filler episode for the town to find out Maddy's being killed. Imagine watching it in '92 and having to wait a hole week for shit to go down. Thank god the actors are so good, because if they depended only on the plot, this episode would be a total disaster.
Probably because it’s chilling to see a murderer cheerfully going about his day while everyone remains unaware of the dead body in his golf bag. ‘Fire Walk With Me’ even expands on this same divide between the whimsical and cosy portrait the Town tries to paint, vs the dark and horrifying underbelly that everyone wilfully ignores. Either that, or the showrunners wanted to dabble with that Columbo vibe, where you know who the killer is, but want to see how the detective is going to catch them out.
. . . varied sources of inspiration ○ within the Lynch commUNIT¥ ○ Maiden name of Judy Garland *□* "IT'S slipperY IN HERE." *○* love it all *. . .* @queen_peaks ( personally gave it a • verry biAsed • 8 . 5 )
When I first saw this, I cheered when the old bellhop man appeared. He is the earthly host of The Giant, and you just knew he was there to help Cooper finally solve it.
Twin peaks is one of those shows where it’s absurdly brilliant, or just plain absurd. Either way you can’t take your eyes off it for one second, even if absolutely nothing is happening.
To put it another way: “Brilliant! I have no idea what’s going on…”
👍
Dream logic. You feel there's an underlying structure, pattern, or sense to the events you're witnessing, but there's isn't; it's a phantom sensation. Most of Lynch's stuff runs on dream logic. It's really terrific how his stuff uncouples character and narrative from the linear conscious mind.
I'm currently at episode 3 of season 3, and goddamn if s3 isn't the weirdest thing I've seen, I don't know what is XD
It's true
There's nothing I love more than being abstract to the point of utter confusion. This show has my vibe all over it and I love it.
When he says this line, and it links all the way back to the beginning of the 1st season--
probably the best non-Lynch episode
I love this scene
That's my most favorite scene in the world
That scene you love is going to come back in style
Chekov's gum
Beautiful
@@jonnyc429 That pun you like is going to come back in style.
Mark Frost desperately trying to tie all the loose ends left by Lynch's surrealism.
Actually I’m pretty sure this was the last episode David lynch made before returning for episode 22.
@@halogalaxy5612 Nope, he left after episode 7. Neither Frost or Lynch were around for this.
He directed Season 2’s first two episodes and the finale.
@@Sir_Roquefort He was also around and working on the show for the first 7 episodes of season 2 though. After that, Lynch and Frost started keeping their distance until the finale.
well he did a good job
Top 10 Most Epic Moments of Twin Peaks
I think the Waiter/Giant is tempting Leland/Bob to take a gum “that will come back in style”.
Cooper dreamed this sentence but didn't understand it.
The elderly waiter delivers the line which draws Cooper's attention.
But Leland Already KNOWS The Gum!!
I think it's just a sort of confirmation by the Giant to Cooper that Leland is the killer. It's basically a police lineup, with Briggs bringing the waiter in to point a finger at one of the suspects. Leland recognizes the gum, and Cooper recognizes the significance of that.
And I think Leland is the only one who recognizes or remembers the gum because the gum has some kind of connection to Bob. I always imagined that when Bob first met Leland, when he was a boy, Bob shared that brand of gum with him to befriend him, before he began to abuse and eventually inhabit him.
I'm speculating wildly of course, but literally the only times Leland ever mentions his childhood are when talking about Bob, and about this gum he likes. So I don't think it's an unreasonable connection to make. And the whole show is about cycles of abuse and how those who were themselves abused can become the abuser if that trauma isn't dealt with. So something coming back in style is just another parallel/metaphorical cycle.
@@kevinkuenn5733 There's a monstrous 4 and a half hour theory about the meaning of this whole show, I highly recommend it. Basically, Bob is a representation of violence as well as meaningless insertions of other things into film media, such as advertisements- based on The Arm's line "His name is Bob, eager for fun, he wears a smile, everybody run" as such a simple thing but very dangerous.
I think its foreshadowing the cycle of events that keep happening over and over again, each version driven by the lodges to maintain the same track and course of events.
@@petersenior5432 And when Mike says only the gifted and the dammed can see him, he looks at the camera when he says the dammed.
*dramatic lightening
I love it lmao
This is deep. I don't know how but I'm sure its deep.
it is
Hail! Hail! The gang's all here.
I don’t even think my dad was a fan of Twin Peaks. But I remember like 20+ years ago he told me this quote?? Lol
Wow Bob Wow
God lived as a Devil dog
Stylish gum from a kind gentleman
Ah, Peepum's Nasty Gum. My favourite.
That girl you like is coming back
Oh in style
Nahhhh pregnant
I used to chew Hubba Bubba when I was a kid
Hubba Bubba. Bubble Yum. Fruit Stripe. Please, no Bazooka, thank you.
That Gum You Like Is Coming Back In Style!
I liked Big League Chew.
General Hammond 😮
wish the flashes stayed but this is fine
Electricity
You can tell this was after Lynch left. He would never tie up a loose end so tightly as this, going so far as to repeat the line it's referencing word for word. This spells things out for the audience far too plainly.
I felt the same.. you can tell Lynch wasnt around. Or Frost.
"Episode 16"
"Arbitrary Law" Tim Hunter *Mark Frost* & Harley Peyton & Robert Engels
🤔
Have you seen Blue Velvet? Everything is spelled out.
@@Thoracius Yeah, but it is still well-written. This is very clumsy, trying to make sense of something that was originally just supposed to be evocative and weird.
Completely disagree. This whole sequence felt quite poignant with its mysterious aura connecting all of the intangible things in Cooper's mind. We as the audience have already seen who killed Maddie, and this is about Cooper learning the truth. The fact that it all comes together with the killer blissfully unaware as he comments on something as innocuous as the gum makes it all the more chilling. WHERE is BOB? How close to the surface is BOB within him? Absolutely chilling.
GENERAL HAMMOND???
Yesss😊👍
where we come from the cherry pies are not what they seem smiling bag
This scene should have been done on scene 7 to end the whole season
The lightning represents the flashing lights of a TV right?
Excuse us
I've always founded weird how the showed the killer for the audience before Cooper. Wasn't the hole point we finding out things alongside him?
Also they took practically a filler episode for the town to find out Maddy's being killed. Imagine watching it in '92 and having to wait a hole week for shit to go down.
Thank god the actors are so good, because if they depended only on the plot, this episode would be a total disaster.
Probably because it’s chilling to see a murderer cheerfully going about his day while everyone remains unaware of the dead body in his golf bag. ‘Fire Walk With Me’ even expands on this same divide between the whimsical and cosy portrait the Town tries to paint, vs the dark and horrifying underbelly that everyone wilfully ignores.
Either that, or the showrunners wanted to dabble with that Columbo vibe, where you know who the killer is, but want to see how the detective is going to catch them out.
Shut up, mexican
👍👍👍👍👍👍
For David Lynch: th-cam.com/video/oqNEaBjmMMI/w-d-xo.html
. . . varied sources of inspiration ○ within the Lynch commUNIT¥ ○
Maiden name of Judy Garland
*□* "IT'S slipperY IN HERE." *○*
love it all
*. . .* @queen_peaks ( personally gave it a • verry biAsed • 8 . 5 )
Oh boy, a schizo post