@@HarryPotter-om7zg I don’t think it was her will to cut it down, she just had to do it to make it more radio friendly. Considering the battles she had to go through with her management because of switching to pop/adding pop elements, it wouldn’t be surprising
okay I kind of noticed that by my third listen too! i felt a connection but didn’t realize nothing new was the more honest lucky one, you’re totally right about that
i asked you guys over on twitter and we decided we'd keep this video chill, mostly raw and unedited. i kinda prefer that vibe for my taylor videos anyway and it seems you guys do too. hope you enjoy, i'm still :') and see u soon for the re-recordings and short film ahhhhh!!!
Girlllll the part where she says "you kept me like a secret, I kept you like an oath" as well as the punchline mentioning the age gap. I have cried 10 times and just wanted to relive my first time again, experiencing it with you ❤️ Always here to support you :')
Pretty sure Phoebe could sing the alphabet and make it sound like the most heartbreaking and devistating thing ever written. I think it’s her voice. There’s so much pain and sadness in her voice
Ive heard her voice for the very first time on Nothing New and the first second she sang i was devastated and all i could talk about is how melancholic and charming her voice is😭
Same with I Bet You Think Of Me. Specifically, the song reminds me of Betty. I feel like you could cross fade/transition from one to the other seamlessly.
The 10 minute version shows how happy she is with Joe: (let's talk about the comparison) All To Well 10 min - "They say all's well that ends well, but i'm in a new hell." Lover - "All's well that ends well to end up with you"
you're right! and I also noticed a similar parallel with her saying "you never called it what it was" in all too well, where she's hurt because of how the relationship is going, and her having a whole entire song called "call it what you want" where she's content in the relationship she's in and doesn't care what others call it
I listened to Nothing new this evening...and it broke my heart...I'm a 71yo Swiftie...and I cried for 1 hour after listening to it....I had to come away from the computer I was so upset.....I really really really hope that nobody actually feels the way Taylor sings about in this song...It's just so emotional...And I really hope that Taylor didn't feel that way...I can't think about it being possible
I think it's just something that all people with really strong vocational-forward personalities go through as a rite of passage. It's not that she felt worthless… but she did feel like she owed it to herself to do more than what she was doing. But really, such an irrational fear does not have a valid course of action. So you feel like time is ticking, because there's this emotional loop where you genuinely feel like you have to do something but then you realize there's nothing meaningful to do. Particularly so considering these thoughts usually come up at 1 am when you really should be sleeping.
i truly believe “Forever Winter” is about Jeff Lang (i believe that’s his name), her friend who overdosed and died during the red era. I think she knew he was suicidal and was trying her best to save him. It’s now to me one of her saddest songs…
@jimbob2427 Well it's that feeling of denial, like when you find out something bad happened (you're car got broken into) and you think about all the ways ypu COULD have stopped it even though you can't do any of that now. She wished he hadn't gone, and said "don't go," but it didn't matter because she wasn't in control of the situation
i actually think thats why taylor picked her specifically! the whole idea of a female artist moving into and then out of the spotlight as people inevitably get annoyed and tire of her the way the public always does with female artists. we’ve already seen it happen to others since she presumably wrote the song and im sure phoebe is always aware of her precarious position of public positivity yknow?
My two year relationship is over and this 10 minute version of all too well was the closure I needed. It ended through the phone and I couldn’t bare to think about him since it’s all too recent. He’s gone but music is here. It’s time to heal.
i’m sorry, he really sucks, especially if he broke up with you over phone, like who the hell does that, especially for a two-year relationship. i’m sorry, you’re too good for him anyways
Better Man with her voice and vocals hit me soooo much I literally almost flipped because of how good it is Better Man for sure is in the top of my vault list I think I haven’t ranked the vault yet
WE AREEEE ALL TO UNWELLL!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭 THIS ALBUM IS THE BESTTT, it's a masterpiece. I slept like a baby after listening to the album😭 All of songs gives me a warm hug from Taylor specially ALL TOO WELL 10 MINS VERSION AND NOTHING NEW (I sobbed) because I'm 22 rn and this song is so fucking relatable 😭🥺❤ and btw you look so beautiful! ❤
Nothing New completely broke me. I listened to it three times in a row and then had to turn the album off so I could pace around the house and cry for a bit before moving on to the other songs. I'm so glad you loved Nothing New and I'm also glad it didn't wreck you.
It staggers me to think that a line like "You kept me like a secret, but I kept you like an oath," the kind of lyric most writers dream of coming up with, was cut from the original. But that's what you can do if you're Taylor Swift: even your castoffs are genius.
I AM SO OBSESSED AAAAAAAAAAAAAW! can't believe how much i loved more all the tracks after this album, she's just insane. SO TALENTED. thank you caitlin
All Too Well 10 Minutes is the heart of the album not only because its really emotional but because every other song is based on ATW10 in some manner, usually directly referenced. 22 is a reaction to TMIK to try to feel better after the devastating break up.
From Mr Perfectly Fine to Me Superior Thinking in I Bet You Think About Me, Taylor truly has lived through all aspects of heartbreak to be where she is today ❤️
when i first listened to nothing new i couldnt stop thinking about how that song could easily fit in folklore and evermore and then i saw aaron desner produced the song. i think it might be my fave out of the vault tracks like come on...written by phoebe bridgers and taylor and produced by taylr and aaron desner thats a personal attack
Your dancing to Message In A Bottle is how I felt about this song I first time I heard it. I was like okay Taylor I like this little bop of a happy beat. It’s definitely one of those tracks I’ll put on if I need something to lift my spirits on a rough day. Something that makes me happy and dance a little. ❤️ Overall, 10 minute of All Too Well is pure gold!!!!💯
@@Sweepout i’m not caitlin lol, but i really liked the club beat. it helped me see the scene she was setting even more because the beat me feel like i was watching this at a club or a bar
I got out of my 1 & a half year relationship at the end of October. It’s been three weeks. When I tell you I managed to cry to Stay Stay Stay, you won’t even believe me. This is so healing for my heart though. I’m so grateful. Also I’m turning 22 next month, can’t believe I get the privilege to listen to 22 Taylor’s version on my birthday. 🤩
I think the most fucked up thing is that in a way we actually have Scott and Scooter to thank for this, had it not been for them screwing Taylor over she wouldn't have rerecorded Fearless and this and we wouldn't have got the Vault tracks and 10 minute ATW......
okay.. I'm going through something, something very... So imagine... bawled my eyes out when I heard the new lyrics. You know, when you can't explain your feelings cause they're a mess.. and then she gave us this version of the song with new feelings and situations to relate to. Even now, because we grew with her. And the fact that at 21 she could came up with these lyrics is insane, because 9-10 years later you can still relate to it and that's how HER ART could help us through like.. everything! It's insane, she's just so awesome!
" if you're just going through a breakup I'm so sorry." Well that felt like a personal attack, as if I haven't had enough of them listening to this album today
I always have to wait to listen to them with you to feel them fully. You take my swiftieness to another whole level. Thank you for sharing with us on each release. The emotion you feel, show in your eyes, that we can feel emulating from the video is just magnificent. Btw, Absolute Bop in Message in a Bottle…
Forever winter and I bet you think about me are my favorites!! Also, I feel like if you told me Message in a bottle was From the vault from 1989 I would totally believe it!
i was listening to these during the school day and Message in a bottle was what came one while i was walking from one class to another and i was FEELING that main character energy
25:25 thanking for saying sorry & bring concerned about us actually.. I had gone through the same level of breakup that felt like a really relatable song actually ❤️
I just need you to know that you made my DAY with this, and your reaction to the production and “what about your promises promises” on Babe was EXACTLY ME!!! This is incredible. You are incredible. Okay time to listen to the album again and cry, byeeeee! :)
I’m also in a pretty good place emotionally right now so this album didn’t break me lol but this was my first Taylor album so like I was just all round emotional bc of the full circle nature. Anyway, I absolutely adore your reactions! You bring so much joy!!! Thanks for sharing!!!
I love them all, but especially Forever Winter... Having only been a swiftie for a couple of years now and suffering from misogyny towards her before that, I always felt like before Lover, Taylor was this Republican girl who didn't want her image scattered so she just stayed out of heavy subjects. And then You Need to Calm Down dropped and I was like: okay, so she's pro-LGBT, that's awesome. But apparently, this showed that even in like 2011/2012, she has always been pro-LGBT, which makes her even more amazing than she already was!
This re-released album was so incredibly amazing. I am just so happy about it right now. Taylor is a genius! I liked most of the album actually. Especially the singles they were so much better than the originals. And the 10 minute song was sooo awesome beautifully written and produced and poggers. My other favorite vault songs were Nothing New, Message In A Bottle, Forever Winter, Run, and The Very First Night.
Okay, Ed showing up here for more REALLY makes me hope for Imogen Heap getting another song on 1989 (Taylor's Version). HOWEVER, I'm getting a vibe that Harry might show up on a vault song on 1989(TV).
Words cannot describe the hold this album has on me, also i know that Message in a Bottle NEEDED TO HAVE CARLY RAE JEPSEN I KEEP HEARING HER PRODUCTION ON IT ITS LIKE 1989+LOVER ERA ITS SO GOOD
when you started dancing during Babe while holding your drink, first of all mood, second of all i got *so much* anxiety cause i was so scared you were gonna spill caitlin you can't DO THAT to me
i would say...every lines or verse that was being cut out of all too well, that was the crime. but we're so glad it finally brought up to life and we all experience this together on this taylor's version.
Ahhhhh you cut out the saddest lyric from Nothing New! “I’ll say I’m happy for her then I’ll cry myself to sleep” it makes me think of Long Live “if you have children someday when they point to the pictures please tell them my name” she was SO scared of being forgotten and it BREAKS MY HEART.
Just watching this again hehe, one of my favs. Loved Message in a Bottle from the start and then got her as my surprise song at the Eras Tour and my Red pop self is complete.
curious fun fact: some people said that the outro of all too well ten minute version when she keep saying: “I was there I was there” it’s because he gaslightned her so much that she needs to remind herself that she’s not crazy and she was there and she remember everything all too well
i knew the CBBH connection w london but then u said it and i was like OH SHE HOPES THIS MESSAGE IN A BOTTLE FLOATS FROM NEW YORK TO LONDON BC HES NOT HERE i gasped
![เจ็บที่ยังฮัก - ม่อน วรวิทย์ [ Official Mv ] จอนนี่มิวสิค](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KALIGSRSjFs/mqdefault.jpg)
I really wish I was broken hearted so I could cry harder to this 😭 Guys I'm gonna bet a lover and break up with them before 1989 I swear
my feelings exactly
my relationship ended last week so this is like perfect timing
lmao wish i could relate, my life said one two bitch keep up, heres taylor LMAOOO
same 😭 i made like 3 of my friends fake break up with me so i could listen to all too well 10 minute version and pretend to feel something
You're gonna need a rebound for getaway car tv
i don’t understand how she kept the 10 minutes version of All Too Well away from us all this time
ITS A MASTERPIECE 😭
not a single lyric deserved to be cut i'm-
@@caitlinmariereacts i'm so mad at her but i love her so much but i hate her too but i adore her but i'm mad i'm not okay i need a wine a RED wine.💀🍷😭
@@HarryPotter-om7zg I don’t think it was her will to cut it down, she just had to do it to make it more radio friendly. Considering the battles she had to go through with her management because of switching to pop/adding pop elements, it wouldn’t be surprising
@@hskingdommm2597 Her past record label really held her bacl :/
@@caitlinmariereacts why would she cut "you kept me like a secret but I kept you like an oath" 😭
i thought the lyricism on all too well couldn’t get better but damn she really wrote a perfect 10 minute song
okay but yes this is exactly how i feel
Nothing New feels like a more brutally honest The Lucky One.
okay I kind of noticed that by my third listen too! i felt a connection but didn’t realize nothing new was the more honest lucky one, you’re totally right about that
yeah i thought it as the lucky one from the other girl’s perspective, like the girl before taylor
The Lucky One but so casually cruel in the name of being honest
Me listening to this one being 22 and knowing nothing about anything.
i asked you guys over on twitter and we decided we'd keep this video chill, mostly raw and unedited. i kinda prefer that vibe for my taylor videos anyway and it seems you guys do too. hope you enjoy, i'm still :') and see u soon for the re-recordings and short film ahhhhh!!!
Yes we needed a chill and personal video for this album especially ❤️
I LOVE YOU CAITLIN
respectfully you look so gorgeous maam!
Ahh!!! I couldn't wait to see your 10min all too well reaction ❤
i love this vibe
I can’t believe she didn’t release Message In A Bottle as a single, like it would’ve fit sooo good after she released 22
@AL That might be the reason. But we were still robbed 😤
message in a bottle would’ve been absolutely perfect on 1989, but it would’ve rocked on the original red album as a single!
@AL I can see that! Maybe it’s an Easter egg 👀 I don’t think so, but we never know with her
It actually has been serviced to US radio as a test, so that might happen still!
Because it's pure pop.
Girlllll the part where she says "you kept me like a secret, I kept you like an oath" as well as the punchline mentioning the age gap.
I have cried 10 times and just wanted to relive my first time again, experiencing it with you ❤️
Always here to support you :')
Just when you thought there couldn’t be more heartbreaking lyrics for this song, Taylor gave us a FEAST!!
One cry per minute of all too well 10 minutes lmao
Forever Winter, lyrically speaking, is absolutely devastating.
YES
:(
It hurts me the most tbh
i think it’s about her friend that died
i cant not cry to forever winter
Pretty sure Phoebe could sing the alphabet and make it sound like the most heartbreaking and devistating thing ever written. I think it’s her voice. There’s so much pain and sadness in her voice
Ive heard her voice for the very first time on Nothing New and the first second she sang i was devastated and all i could talk about is how melancholic and charming her voice is😭
Who else is getting folklore/evermore vibes from Nothing New? And guess what? It's been co-produced by Aaron Dessner. What a stunning song 💗
Same with I Bet You Think Of Me. Specifically, the song reminds me of Betty. I feel like you could cross fade/transition from one to the other seamlessly.
Heyy! Same thought!
Nothing new walked so mirrorball could run
@@OfficialDeanAdler they have the same chord structure but a different time signature
Nothing new is a MASTERPIECE . Can we talk about their voices together, like ??? perfection
Caitlin your hair looks so good. So happy that you're doing well. Sending lots of love
aw thank you so much
The 10 minute version shows how happy she is with Joe: (let's talk about the comparison)
All To Well 10 min - "They say all's well that ends well, but i'm in a new hell."
Lover - "All's well that ends well to end up with you"
Oh my gosh I didnt know this! I just got chillsssssss 🥺🥺🥺🥺
I knew she had the line somewhere but couldn’t remember where 🥰
you're right! and I also noticed a similar parallel with her saying "you never called it what it was" in all too well, where she's hurt because of how the relationship is going, and her having a whole entire song called "call it what you want" where she's content in the relationship she's in and doesn't care what others call it
also 'i'm in a new hell' Vs 'hell was the journey but it brought me heaven'
omg swifties one year ago are in for a RIDE😭🤣
our past selves would never believe You’re Losing Me exists.
We might be okay, but we are not fine at al- I’m joking, we are not fine, we are not okay, we are crying, throwing up and shaking it off
exactly
I listened to Nothing new this evening...and it broke my heart...I'm a 71yo Swiftie...and I cried for 1 hour after listening to it....I had to come away from the computer I was so upset.....I really really really hope that nobody actually feels the way Taylor sings about in this song...It's just so emotional...And I really hope that Taylor didn't feel that way...I can't think about it being possible
Omg 💖
😭😭😭
I think it's just something that all people with really strong vocational-forward personalities go through as a rite of passage.
It's not that she felt worthless… but she did feel like she owed it to herself to do more than what she was doing.
But really, such an irrational fear does not have a valid course of action. So you feel like time is ticking, because there's this emotional loop where you genuinely feel like you have to do something but then you realize there's nothing meaningful to do.
Particularly so considering these thoughts usually come up at 1 am when you really should be sleeping.
I love how Swifties come in all ages!
@@otterwithadarkside4422 Me to...Love being a Grandad Swiftie 💖💖
i truly believe “Forever Winter” is about Jeff Lang (i believe that’s his name), her friend who overdosed and died during the red era. I think she knew he was suicidal and was trying her best to save him. It’s now to me one of her saddest songs…
That’s so sad coz he left and now Taylor is forever winter…
wasn’t it about cory, the guy from glee who died of cancer?
I think this song was written after he passes. But I still get confused that she says “don’t go” when he already passed
@@chaigneau6981 no, he died after red and he died of an overdose not cancer
@jimbob2427 Well it's that feeling of denial, like when you find out something bad happened (you're car got broken into) and you think about all the ways ypu COULD have stopped it even though you can't do any of that now. She wished he hadn't gone, and said "don't go," but it didn't matter because she wasn't in control of the situation
she says "do you have all the space that you need" what if that's reference to "when you said you needed space.what?" from WANEGBT
AND THE INDIE CONCERT REFERENCE AHHHHHH
Message in a Bottle actually has me dancing around my room with my hairbrush as a microphone 😅 and I'm a grown ass adult.
same girl same
No one's ever too young or too old to go full on swiftie 🥳🥳
@@justshaa5173 of course😎
same it’s my in my top 3 or 4 vault tracks but they’re all so good it’s impossible to pick
Even though Nothing New was written years ago, it feels like it was written specifically with Phoebe in mind. Like she fits so well on the song
i actually think thats why taylor picked her specifically! the whole idea of a female artist moving into and then out of the spotlight as people inevitably get annoyed and tire of her the way the public always does with female artists. we’ve already seen it happen to others since she presumably wrote the song and im sure phoebe is always aware of her precarious position of public positivity yknow?
“you kept me like a secret and i kept you like an oath.” emotionally TORE ME APART
“if you just went through a breakup im so sorry” gee thanks
and no im not okay
🥺 i'm so sorry
@@anthonyd5002 I’m sorry. I hope you feel better.
My two year relationship is over and this 10 minute version of all too well was the closure I needed. It ended through the phone and I couldn’t bare to think about him since it’s all too recent. He’s gone but music is here. It’s time to heal.
i’m sorry, he really sucks, especially if he broke up with you over phone, like who the hell does that, especially for a two-year relationship. i’m sorry, you’re too good for him anyways
every single one song in this album is my favorite, i'm just so happy
I'm taking the weekend off to recover. Red has been my stan album of Taylor's for so long and those vault songs are SOFUCKINGILLEGAL!!!! 😭🧣🍂🍁❤
I dont know if I can explain how overwhelmingly joyful taylor saying f the patricary makes me
Caitlin's gonna be confused with Girl at Home when she hears it 😆
Better Man with her voice and vocals hit me soooo much I literally almost flipped because of how good it is Better Man for sure is in the top of my vault list I think I haven’t ranked the vault yet
I THOUGHT THE SAME THING ABOUT THE LONDON LINE IN MESSAGE IN A BOTTLE!!!! We're getting all the chapters of this story
The vault songs are just...perfect like...also Forever Winter is like probably one of my favourite Taylor songs now
WE AREEEE ALL TO UNWELLL!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭
THIS ALBUM IS THE BESTTT, it's a masterpiece. I slept like a baby after listening to the album😭 All of songs gives me a warm hug from Taylor specially ALL TOO WELL 10 MINS VERSION AND NOTHING NEW (I sobbed) because I'm 22 rn and this song is so fucking relatable 😭🥺❤
and btw you look so beautiful! ❤
Lol same!! And then when I woke up I felt like it was my birthday (??
"How can a person know everything at 18
But nothing at 22?" Damn Taylor come for my throat why don't you
Nothing New completely broke me. I listened to it three times in a row and then had to turn the album off so I could pace around the house and cry for a bit before moving on to the other songs. I'm so glad you loved Nothing New and I'm also glad it didn't wreck you.
The 10 minute version of "All too well" is already legendary. :-)
It staggers me to think that a line like "You kept me like a secret, but I kept you like an oath," the kind of lyric most writers dream of coming up with, was cut from the original. But that's what you can do if you're Taylor Swift: even your castoffs are genius.
Been waiting for this all day, and yes I'm still crying 😭😭😭
I AM SO OBSESSED AAAAAAAAAAAAAW! can't believe how much i loved more all the tracks after this album, she's just insane. SO TALENTED. thank you caitlin
10-minute All Too (un)Well had me sobbing on the floor. It’s probably the best thing she’s ever released. 😭
Adding that lyrics of All Too Well in the intro simplifies everything
All Too Well 10 Minutes is the heart of the album not only because its really emotional but because every other song is based on ATW10 in some manner, usually directly referenced.
22 is a reaction to TMIK to try to feel better after the devastating break up.
nothing new is so good, i’m so glad i had faith in it when the vault tracks were announced
Just hope there's no copyright issue with this because I just love vibing with you while watching your reactions over and over again ❤️
She changed “Girl at Home” and it sounds so good!
I broke with the "its supposed to be fun turning 21" too hahahaha cant wait to die again with the video 🤡
From Mr Perfectly Fine to Me Superior Thinking in I Bet You Think About Me, Taylor truly has lived through all aspects of heartbreak to be where she is today ❤️
I think ibytam is about the all too well guy, ther's the hint on the music video with the red scarf
Why nobody's talking about CAITLIN'S HAIR? LIKE SHE LOOKS GORGEOUS
when i first listened to nothing new i couldnt stop thinking about how that song could easily fit in folklore and evermore and then i saw aaron desner produced the song. i think it might be my fave out of the vault tracks like come on...written by phoebe bridgers and taylor and produced by taylr and aaron desner thats a personal attack
Your dancing to Message In A Bottle is how I felt about this song I first time I heard it. I was like okay Taylor I like this little bop of a happy beat. It’s definitely one of those tracks I’ll put on if I need something to lift my spirits on a rough day. Something that makes me happy and dance a little. ❤️
Overall, 10 minute of All Too Well is pure gold!!!!💯
First of all love the new Red, but also that outfit your wearing here is S E R V I N G! Such Red vibes too..
Also, how do you feel about the changes she made to Girl At Home?
@@Sweepout i’m not caitlin lol, but i really liked the club beat. it helped me see the scene she was setting even more because the beat me feel like i was watching this at a club or a bar
All Too Well 10 minutes version literally destroyed me to the core. I can't believe Jake really put her through all that shit😤
I got out of my 1 & a half year relationship at the end of October. It’s been three weeks. When I tell you I managed to cry to Stay Stay Stay, you won’t even believe me. This is so healing for my heart though. I’m so grateful. Also I’m turning 22 next month, can’t believe I get the privilege to listen to 22 Taylor’s version on my birthday. 🤩
omg i love you, im sure you’re gonna have a beautiful peaceful birthday 💜
Not Caitlin smiling at the beginning of the video when I expected her to be WORRIED, SCARED AND CRYING
I’m so in love with those last 2 minutes of all too well, I couldn’t have gone without that gorgeous fade out
Love that set-up Caitlin, makes me feel so cozy 🍂🧣❤️
I think the most fucked up thing is that in a way we actually have Scott and Scooter to thank for this, had it not been for them screwing Taylor over she wouldn't have rerecorded Fearless and this and we wouldn't have got the Vault tracks and 10 minute ATW......
True, guess there's always a silver lining in a cloud
going thru a breakup, this album is everything end explains every emotion thought and feeling to the core and cuts in so deep
im honestly waiting for the short film now- dylan o'brien is gonna kill it!!
I love how much of a swiftie you are it radiates
the way i can always count on this queen for daily content
okay.. I'm going through something, something very...
So imagine... bawled my eyes out when I heard the new lyrics.
You know, when you can't explain your feelings cause they're a mess.. and then she gave us this version of the song with new feelings and situations to relate to. Even now, because we grew with her. And the fact that at 21 she could came up with these lyrics is insane, because 9-10 years later you can still relate to it and that's how HER ART could help us through like.. everything!
It's insane, she's just so awesome!
Why is no one talking about how gorgeous Caitlin looks?
I'm not listening to All To Well 10 mins version until the short film comes out...
I'M DYING, I CAN'T WAIT ANYMORE
In the explicit version of I Bet You Think About Me it’s when none of that shit mattered
" if you're just going through a breakup I'm so sorry." Well that felt like a personal attack, as if I haven't had enough of them listening to this album today
i got broken up with today by the same person who broke my heart a couple months ago 💓💓 she did it just in time for this album so nice of her!!!
You Okay, bestie?
no!!!!! but thanks for asking
@@autisticz❤️ hope you get better soon, best wishes
when caitlin throws peace signs...you know its all over!
26:37 IT IS!! and to think we might see that reference in the short film just gives me chills
I can’t WAIT for you to hear Girl At Home!!! I think you’ll be surprised 😉
Run has references from Ed's song Photograph. The chain around the neck, photo in the pocket of jeans. Maybe it was written around the same time.
Nothing New is the best Vault Song, but I’m very biased because Punisher is my favorite album ever.
I always have to wait to listen to them with you to feel them fully. You take my swiftieness to another whole level. Thank you for sharing with us on each release. The emotion you feel, show in your eyes, that we can feel emulating from the video is just magnificent.
Btw, Absolute Bop in Message in a Bottle…
Forever winter and I bet you think about me are my favorites!!
Also, I feel like if you told me Message in a bottle was From the vault from 1989 I would totally believe it!
the way she released this just when i needed it, dealing with a breakup and this is so therapeutic
i was listening to these during the school day and Message in a bottle was what came one while i was walking from one class to another and i was FEELING that main character energy
25:25 thanking for saying sorry & bring concerned about us actually.. I had gone through the same level of breakup that felt like a really relatable song actually ❤️
honestly her reactions are giving a different life to the songs
I just need you to know that you made my DAY with this, and your reaction to the production and “what about your promises promises” on Babe was EXACTLY ME!!! This is incredible. You are incredible. Okay time to listen to the album again and cry, byeeeee! :)
taylor, ma’am how did you casually have all of these songs for so long 😭
I love that on babe you said ‘let’s see if she changes this one’ literally a second before “what about your promises promises” plays 😹❤️
forever winter stood out to me the most and im still in pain over it
I’m also in a pretty good place emotionally right now so this album didn’t break me lol but this was my first Taylor album so like I was just all round emotional bc of the full circle nature. Anyway, I absolutely adore your reactions! You bring so much joy!!! Thanks for sharing!!!
I love them all, but especially Forever Winter... Having only been a swiftie for a couple of years now and suffering from misogyny towards her before that, I always felt like before Lover, Taylor was this Republican girl who didn't want her image scattered so she just stayed out of heavy subjects. And then You Need to Calm Down dropped and I was like: okay, so she's pro-LGBT, that's awesome. But apparently, this showed that even in like 2011/2012, she has always been pro-LGBT, which makes her even more amazing than she already was!
10 Minute outro.
That is all.
LOVE-OO CAITLYNNNNN ❤👏🥳
This re-released album was so incredibly amazing. I am just so happy about it right now. Taylor is a genius! I liked most of the album actually. Especially the singles they were so much better than the originals. And the 10 minute song was sooo awesome beautifully written and produced and poggers. My other favorite vault songs were Nothing New, Message In A Bottle, Forever Winter, Run, and The Very First Night.
Okay, Ed showing up here for more REALLY makes me hope for Imogen Heap getting another song on 1989 (Taylor's Version). HOWEVER, I'm getting a vibe that Harry might show up on a vault song on 1989(TV).
THANK YOU SO MUCH AT LEAST WE’LL ALL JUST PASS AWAY TOGETHER
Words cannot describe the hold this album has on me, also i know that Message in a Bottle NEEDED TO HAVE CARLY RAE JEPSEN I KEEP HEARING HER PRODUCTION ON IT ITS LIKE 1989+LOVER ERA ITS SO GOOD
Yes Carly Rae Jepsen. That was my thought too!!!
Yes message in a bottle gives call me maybe vibes
Girl at Home (Taylors Version) really said 🤖
It sounds so 1989 now it sounds great
found you by your folklore reaction. grateful i stayed till then💗 don’t even get me started on red tv. ✨cried and vibed✨ the whole day
when you started dancing during Babe while holding your drink, first of all mood, second of all i got *so much* anxiety cause i was so scared you were gonna spill caitlin you can't DO THAT to me
i would say...every lines or verse that was being cut out of all too well, that was the crime. but we're so glad it finally brought up to life and we all experience this together on this taylor's version.
Ahhhhh you cut out the saddest lyric from Nothing New! “I’ll say I’m happy for her then I’ll cry myself to sleep” it makes me think of Long Live “if you have children someday when they point to the pictures please tell them my name” she was SO scared of being forgotten and it BREAKS MY HEART.
She took the scrapped part and made the moment I knew
OMG I was waiting fr ur reaction... I ahve been crying fr hours cz I was listening to my favs (obv including all too well) over n over again 😭
The very first night is amazing, definitely my fave
Just watching this again hehe, one of my favs. Loved Message in a Bottle from the start and then got her as my surprise song at the Eras Tour and my Red pop self is complete.
curious fun fact: some people said that the outro of all too well ten minute version when she keep saying: “I was there I was there” it’s because he gaslightned her so much that she needs to remind herself that she’s not crazy and she was there and she remember everything all too well
Yes here we go all these songs made me cry in some way
YESSS YOU QUEEN YOU ARE DOING IT
WE ARE HERE
i knew the CBBH connection w london but then u said it and i was like OH SHE HOPES THIS MESSAGE IN A BOTTLE FLOATS FROM NEW YORK TO LONDON BC HES NOT HERE
i gasped
Run is ‘tis the damn season part 2 and no one will change my mind
OMG i thought the same! It's so sad because after all that 'I won't ask you to wait', it's like he's saying that he's gonna wait for her anyways