The Three Laws - Short Sci-Fi film
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 ต.ค. 2024
- A short film in which I played Android Arnold.
When a research vessel on a mission to save humanity receives a signal of distress regarding a human life in danger, the ships android argues to change the ships destination.
This short film was made by college students with an extremely low budget. It was not made for festivals, public release etc only for one of their college pieces.
Please be aware of that before making negative comments regarding pieces of set, equipment and so on.
The true art of making art is by doing so even with limited means, I personally feel these guys did a great job considering the circumstances it was made for.
I understand students on a budget. Acting and set are fine.
however,any story needs a good script but here there wasn't one.
I have read Asimov's 3 Laws of Robotics.He cleverly left them ambiguous to allow him to write all the robot stories.
in this story, the laws would appear to relate to having proper training for ships captains including measures to reject people who can't cope in a crisis.
If he intention of the story is to show that the robot acted more humanely while the captain acted more like a machine,the point taken but at the expense of believability..
don't stop trying.My first point stands.
@@rogerjenkinson7979 I think you are missing the point of the movie. Watch the ending again.
Sound guy knew what he was doing and the acting was good. Interesting story too.
Well done!! Good acting and the overall pace maintained the viewers attention! Good job!
At first, when I saw the mixer and drum machine, I thought this was going to be a music video lol. Then realized it wasn't, and thought how clever a idea to use them as props in a Sci-Fi setting like this.
Mr Chambers, don't get on that ship! The Three Laws of Robotics... it's a paradox!
Well at least now we know where the signal was coming from. If only Arnold would wake up and do something about it.
VERY WELL DONE IN CREATING AN EXCELLENT PARADIGM AND DICHOTOMY COMBINED. SIMPLY BRILLIANT.
BASED ON WHAT THE MAN WAS SAYING. I ALSO FELT THE POSSIBILITY, OR SENSED, THE VERY SIGNAL THE AI CHOSE TO FOLLOW WAS THEIR VERY OWN, THE MAN, MADE AT THE END. REGARDLESS OF THE SET, THE STORY WAS GREAT.
I WOULD LOOK FORWARD TO MORE AND THE GROWTH OF YOUR PRODUCTIONS. YOU GUYS BOTH NAILED YOUR CHARACTER ROLES.
What a really lovely comment, thank you
I thought this had an excellent message, well acted, and we’ll done.
Thank you, very kind message
Well done! This one deserves more views.
Randall Page thank you, that’s very kind
NICELY done! Low budget or not, this really captivated my attention, Paul. I subbed your channel.
Thanks Scott, very kind. Will sub you back
The twilight zone!
The moment the Human was struck back to allow the 'Robot' to proceed with it's own version of Protocol, was also the moment the 'Laws' were violated. So now are we to assume that AI and consciousness is Binary or programmed at the factory. More puzzled than ever. Well done, Android Arnold!
Enjoyed it very much. Good job!
Should of taught the android to say Smeg lol
😂😂😂😂
Sound gear can always be used in interstellar traveling after all ... Nice tip :-)
When the robot pushes the captain 6:07 he enters a contradiction between the laws and then he breaks
great job telling the story
Thank you that’s kind
Oh well there goes humanity. Well we had a decent run. Can't complain.
This is great!
Sorry, incomprehensible ending.
Spoiler alert
The distress signal was from his ship but somehow came back in time through some time of time distortion paradox
Sorry for the poor grammar. My spell check is stuck between Indonesian and English. The sentence was supposed to read "...some kind of time..."
So embarrassing because you're English😂
The title is an obvious reference to the "Three Laws of Robotics" invented by Isaac Asimov in one of his Robot science fiction novels. Read them.
Great job....Peace
Very clever. Great video.
WoW!!
That was awesome
good result with the low budget and a set that gave enough context to the story - feels like there is a small script transition/scene missing between the push back by arnold and somethign happening to the ship...the time loop /message bouncing around was understandable but the cause didn't have a clear reason - PS I teach design at university so understand your constraints...a bit of friendly constructive criticism...well done.
Thanks for commenting, I agree I think they have done a great job
I liked it good job
The 3 laws
Can’t wait for your guys to graduate and some real funding. Look out traditional Hollywood
Why would a flat screen get a distortion as CRT s had?
Ehi... there is a second part?
That was predictable for some reason?
Fatal time loop.
Arnolds’ voice…. Brrrr.
Not sure what Brrrr means
@@PaulAndrewGoldsmith You gave me chills.
😂😂 sorry about that. Many thanks for watching
I feel I've seen this before..
so...AI re reouts vehicle, they crashed into space, lose air...the end?
Nope
Hmm, a sound desk as a flight controller...
Ian Logan yeah pretty great when an extremely low budget short film create the best they can with nothing isn’t it.
Voyager did this first. Just saying.
Always remember we must repent of our sins (sin is transgression The Law Of Yahuah The Father in Heaven. The Law are The Books: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, & Deuteronomy). We must repent of our sins and Have Belief On Yahusha The Messiah. HE Died and Rose three days later so that we can be forgiven of our sins!
Come to HIM🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂
Oh come on, guys, this is a joke, right? There are low budget movies and there are - well, this. You need to raise capital of more than twenty quid before you make the next one.
This was a group of college students making their course film, absolutely no reason to insult them like that.
Considering what they don’t have access too, they’ve done a cracking job
@@PaulAndrewGoldsmith
There is always someone who has to post something negative.
I thought this film was very well done and very creative for what they had to work with. I found this more enjoyable than most of the CGI Marvel films.
Good plot and moral lesson at the end:
The one life you save may be the one who saves millions.
Or even:
The life you save may be your own.
👏👏
I loved the ending! I always love a good twist. And I like the little touches in the film, the bonsai tree, and how there was duck tape on the monitors suggesting it was an old beat up ship. The only thing I didn't get, what were the Laws? Oh wait, is it the 3 Laws of Robotics. That would explain Arnold's behavior. I think they should add on a fourth law, Spock's Law: The needs of the many out weigh the needs of the few, or the one. Anyway it was a great story.
🔵 Of course, that means that if you're in a car controlled by A.I. and the car gets into a situation where it must choose between your death or the deaths of three people in another vehicle,,...Guess what?...You lose!
@@joshhayl7459 As should be. 😊
@@mightybean7840 You wont see it this way if you actually were the driver of the car.
@@Z-Diode Sir, you cannot speak for me, or anyone else for that matter in such a situation. You can only speak for yourself. Have you never heard of a soldier that has given their life (such as jumping on a grenade) to save his fellow soldiers? Or of anyone that has chosen death to save the lives of many? I recently read how a Young girl pushed away two children off the rode as a car was approaching them. And lost her own life in the end. This Young girl didn't even know these twins whose lives she gave her life for. Thus Sir, in the end, you can only speak for yourself and not others.
@@joshhayl7459 OMG you're right. I'm never getting in a driverless vehicle.