I don’t understand why they didn’t just put headphones on him and play music in his ears during his speech. It obviously wouldn’t have helped him speak normally but by the way they portrayed this scene, it would have allowed him to give the speech flawlessly. Thoughts?
Yeah, that's what I was thinking! But maybe they needed to show different sorts of tools he could use, and also that he could do it without distracting himself? And that he sort of overcame his stammer in some way? To show he did make progress. But yeah, I agree, it would've worked really well!
Well for one, it’s not very...orthodox and you can’t do it in public like in the beginning of the film when he was at that assembly or when he’s at that manufacturing company. Plus it doesn’t conquer the problem like he wants to. Also, it’s probably a lot harder to do in public in front of people or on radio broadcast versus just reading Shakespeare with one guy.
This scene was more to show Bertie that his problem can be cured and as he learned to trust Logue and talk to him as a friend, he conquered the painful past that made him a stammered. That’s why it’s such a beautiful movie because it’s not just a king, it’s a man overcoming his past with the help of a genuine friend!
@@我不知道-e9p As a stutterer myself i can say that it was his goal to eventually do it without the crutch of loud music in his ear. By not being able to hear himself talk it gets rid of his anxiety and excessive self-monitoring, which causes his stuttering. I tried it once and it worked. Another thing that worked for me is Paxil, an antidepressant (sedative), so it's definitely about teaching King George to manage his anxiety
Helen Bonham Carter was just as magnificent as the leading men.
Don't run from yourself ...at the end, you will still find yourself 😊
A wonderful scene.
I don’t understand why they didn’t just put headphones on him and play music in his ears during his speech. It obviously wouldn’t have helped him speak normally but by the way they portrayed this scene, it would have allowed him to give the speech flawlessly. Thoughts?
Yeah, that's what I was thinking! But maybe they needed to show different sorts of tools he could use, and also that he could do it without distracting himself? And that he sort of overcame his stammer in some way? To show he did make progress. But yeah, I agree, it would've worked really well!
Well for one, it’s not very...orthodox and you can’t do it in public like in the beginning of the film when he was at that assembly or when he’s at that manufacturing company. Plus it doesn’t conquer the problem like he wants to.
Also, it’s probably a lot harder to do in public in front of people or on radio broadcast versus just reading Shakespeare with one guy.
This scene was more to show Bertie that his problem can be cured and as he learned to trust Logue and talk to him as a friend, he conquered the painful past that made him a stammered. That’s why it’s such a beautiful movie because it’s not just a king, it’s a man overcoming his past with the help of a genuine friend!
@@我不知道-e9p As a stutterer myself i can say that it was his goal to eventually do it without the crutch of loud music in his ear. By not being able to hear himself talk it gets rid of his anxiety and excessive self-monitoring, which causes his stuttering. I tried it once and it worked. Another thing that worked for me is Paxil, an antidepressant (sedative), so it's definitely about teaching King George to manage his anxiety
I guess headphones weren't around that much in the 1940's
I am not crying...
You're crying...😭