Carlton Delistings.....Where Too Now? & What Does It Mean?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.ย. 2024
- 🙏 Join this channel!🙏
/ @pommyinoz
As always, we welcome you to comment below with any questions or talking points. Alternatively, you can email us directly at pommyinozyt@gmail.com.
💙JOIN THE CHANNEL💙
shorturl.at/qzDUV
🏆 JOIN ME ON FACEBOOK🏆
/ pommyinoz
💸 JOIN ME ON TWITTER💸
/ pommyin
💃JOIN ME ON TIKTOK💃
/ pommyinoz
📸JOIN ME ON THE GRAM📸
/ pommy.inoz
**SHOUT OUT TO THE MEMBERS!**
Deonie Rowe
Jeffrey McElhinney
David J Buck
JasNickSteve Baricevic
Ant
Con
wayne clough
Danny Finn
Matt Wethers
Mark Smithies
Lachyjack
Andrew Sassine
Aiden
Weeties
Alex Harris
James Farrell
Adam Gogsy
Lucinda Calabrese
BugsBell
Violet _playz
John Holden
Albert
Brian Feeney
StephenB
Alphatime
Attilio Cester
Bridgette W
Carlz Ramirez
Andy Craker
Chris Hadj
Lemonpop Animations
Paul Hill
THUNDERSTRUCK GOLDFIELDS
Kyle Simpson
Saltyaussie
Frankie Says Sax
andrew bakes
Michael C. Madden
Navyblue_Bec
Ugur Koken
Ben
Peter Hayward
STEWSEN
Maz
Chris m
Mathew Cox
Gavin Whelan
Andrew F
Benjamin Todd
Felix F
Kenny Roberts
zeecfc
Julie Simpson
David Kirkpatrick
Kate Wall
Sean Costello
Tim P
Herbatron
Lana Owens
Steven Kimonides
Andrew Smith
Hunter
Cameron
Chris Bresnan
Cob Loaf Records
Garth Bane
Chris Armstrong
Damian Hillas
MightyArd
Christopher Lang
Irene Connor
Priggy
bevtone
M Funky
Sarz1864
Ric Coldebella
Jason Warlond
Sandy Falcone
Wayne Daniell
DocLiving
Gllenn Hawkins
Mohamed Wazze
Andrew Scott
Matoula Neocli
Daniel B
Darren Bloomfield
richard_b_flat
Malcolm McIntyre
Jason Badger
Shaun Dux
LyndenH
AndoVocals
Odin Imaging
Bryon Issa
Mick Marcucci
Tim J Wilkes
Harry Lederman
Quenton Daniels
PeterV Bluebagger
Libbojrjr
need a bobble head of pommy
All in good time 🤣🤣🤣
Thank you for the Owies review Pommy. I re-watched the 2023 highlights reel from him, and 1/3 of his goals are stolen from Harry and Charlie.
He has plenty of good crumbs, but he also has plenty of moments where he is
a) Blocking the leading lane for the talls or
b) Outright standing infront of Harry and Charlie and taking their marks.
We need to to either sit in the goal square BEHIND charlie, or sit just outside of the 50 to swoop in after a ball is dropped.
He can be that guy! But right now he isn't.
Deffo no knock on him hes perfect if you have creative goal kickers but for me we need eggs in the out of nothing goal kicker and the pressure which we have
If Carlton want another senior list spot they should delist Fantasia and pick him up in the rookie draft. Can’t see many clubs that would grab him from us as a DFA or before our pick in the rookie draft
cant delist a contracted player as you pay them out, so it goes onto player payments, hence why you never see it, and when you do its early retirement as its a different methodology! so by doing that you have removed an ability to add a player as lets say 300k is Fantasia, now you are up for 300k and 150k for a draftee
@@PommyinOZ
I’m thinking of doing similar to what north did with Jarod Polec. I understand the money still remains on the salary cap but just like the idea of gaining an extra senior list spot. Would love two picks before the campo compo
Option 2. However sceptical in why durdin was given a contract instead of Owies. However the more the time flies by, the more of a chance that owies will probably be traded.
Well its how the contracts fall, Like 28 years old next year vs 22 so I think Durdin deffo has a higher ceiling, his formative years are done, get the body right! all the chips have to be in on inness as we cant trade out 20 players like most think
Do you think Voss's plan is to get Houston, then push Saad and Doctery Midfield and that will keep Williams up forward?
Genuinely don't believe it's a legit rumour. Doc I'd imagine stays wing forward as plan was pre season. Saad I can't see moving, history suggests you move behind the ball in your 30s, I'd say if it happens saad houston half forward Newman McGovern back pocket, cincotta boyd out of favour, cowan 7th on bench 😳
@@PommyinOZ Yeah now I see it, Voss might be becoming desperate with the Dan trade, They seem to have some good potential players already there as you listed.
@@azzaprime7257 I honestly do not believe its Voss etc its identical in wording to Sholl last year where they said the same rubbish, linked it, I think its he wants to leave and its opening the Vic clubs with Stock to trade for him
Thanks Pommy I love it!
I'm glad!
Absolutely love your work champ. luke trainor played backline in the vic metro, which means he's not as good a player as the key forwards, we need a quality keyback so the smart thing to do is get the best available key forward (because he's much better at catching), and play him keyback in the AFL. Hopefully jobe shanahan is available at pick 11, and get rosas jr from GC. Thats my opinion, but i haven't done anywhere near the homework you have pommy.
Thanks mate. I'm really hot on Luke, my issue with converting players is its always against the nature. Know we love doing it but model for mine in world sport is target skills you lack and back your development on skills they fall short in. While haynes is on the list find the closest carbon copy and go hard
Option2 great idea also POM MERCH
Coming soon!
Do you want Luke trainor to fill the hole left by Marchy, cunners and Martin? There will be a big hole in our recovery room 😂
Genuinely it would be after due diligence, still polling in the top 10 whihc makes me happy but obviously concerns, like injury wise aside from the concussion hes been fairly steady, just got to dot the i's but like in the example if he slid its a Curnow pick you cannot turn it down
@@PommyinOZ you know the draftees so much better than me. I would just love to see a mostly healthy list for a change and only gamble on talented injury prone players when we’re a genuine top 4 team
@FloydBassett-ys2mu I love trainor. If he is okay with concussion he's baby haynes so think it's great
Not sure how the numbers would work out, but could you
trade Jack Carrol,
get Dan Houston (pick 11, future 1st or 2nd)
Resign owies
Delist durdin
Get Haynes
And only take the camporeale brothers in draft
@@mattlang9045 knock Matt carroll out and could send haynes to rookie with a weighted deal off top my head 🤣🤣🤣
100% agree with you about owies pommy
Thanks mate
option 2 pommy lets do it!!!
Yesssss
Yay! 💙
💙💙💙
Makes sense with owies, carlton holding off so long he not solid in their minds, head of pack again pom, hope we can organize to keep him though. Plethora pom, had to grab the dictionary. Do we need suspect concussions players again. The players we have have to ,be the ones to get us there so we have to hope mots can improve Zak gets good year on park and the young blokes keep improving. Haynes fully fit pom how good have we been at that for years, option two for me. Where do we get to see the merch pom to have a brouse. Love your work mate Go pom Go blues.
It's a tough one with Luke, he plays that crash and bash type style, so I think it will put people off but..... will be something you work through. Be one of them if he's your price you bite the bullet types
Where can i see the jumper options Pommy?
Website having some fixes should be up tomorrow my friend
Overdue cuts and owies goes for a good pick❤
Yeah he's done a emery type clean u0
Option 2 Merch Pom💙💙💙
Yay
Option 2 pom
Love it
Pommy merch 😃, I'm in 🎉
I like option 2, interesting take on Owies and where his goals come from, so feeling better about trading him if we go that route.
Love that! and Cannot wait to see the modelling of the merch!
@@PommyinOZ be careful what you ask for 🤣🤣🤣
Already looking forward to it now 😀
You convinced me of how important goal kicking mids are, I wo7ld have thought that would be the way to go considering the supposed depth of this draft. They could potentially play the small forward early days. What's ur thoughts on Taj Hotton?
Love Taj, Also love Tom Gross! issue is List spots at this stage we would have to trade out again which again is tough to do
I'm not clear on ur strategy here. U want to use pick 11 on Joe Berry. Seems a waste to draft a small forward when there's a few mid forwards available around our pick if they're harder to draft. In a money ball situation I would have thought a mid forward should always be prioritised because they could become one or the other
@troystewart4746 think based on this strategy to follow Austin's. Generally takes out what he's lost and buys it in again. Think Lij with another year can be the goal kicking mid, and some outside time for Walsh would see the goal a game come from him ala last time he played more loose
Surely we’re trading runnings defenders are some point …Boyd Saad Docherty Newman Kemp Cincotta Cowan Williams Wilson M.Carrol …then recruit Houston …we need goal kicking mids & keep filling spots with back flankers …keep the ones that are hard to get a kick on …that leaves Cincotta 😂
🤣🤣🤣
no idea how dan Houston worth 2 first round picks we ever do that trade I’m never watching another foot ball game again
Them Feels
Option 2 pommy👍👍👍
💙💙💙
I think we need to put out at least 10 more players that not include Williams and didn't know why not used this player to get good player.
Unfortunatly all in contract though so would have to seek trades and its tough when the draft is so filled with role playing talent
Trainor will be long gone by 22. Come on Pommy.......too much warm beer?
We said trade into there with pick 22 and a future
@@PommyinOZ My apologies. I re-played the speel and you did add a "future 1st". 2024 Pick 22 and 2025 Pick 1 is probably overs for Trainor 🙂
@@mrgedavies hahahha all g didn't realise obs cut off the right hand side panel 🤣
Is there a way of getting Houston without giving away pick 11 pommy
Probably not the names thrown around are people see this draft as the squad builder so people want in
So's and kemp forward
Option 3 - does having Owies and Rosas make sense? Keep M Carroll instead of one of them?
I tried to make option 3 the bold throw your eggs at multiple baskets I like m Carroll to be fair
merch pom
💙💙💙
Bit surpised about Martin not even getting traded, but he's a free agent, and spent like Fantasia Pants. Owies is worth keeping, because all the others are complete garbage and Moir still raw.
Just zero value there. Freo or whoever won't want to give anything due to risk, now they can load his contract with pay as you play type bonuses so fairer to all parties.
Merch pomm
I see you hahahahha
When i get Google to translate your message, it says Merch Bomb lol
🤣🤣🤣
North want Luke Trainor and are willing to part with pick 2 in exchange for multiple picks. They have a heap of midfielders. Doubt Cal ton will have a chance.
Suppose depends on the concussion risk, I think he slides and north load up into mid teens personally. Pick 2 mental for trainor. But I suppose it is north
Hey Pom what do u think of trading 11 and 31 to Sydney for 19 and 20 or similar team who has picks in those areas trade 1st rd to port for Houston and a future first round pick
If it's for draft I'm in! Full Caveat 100% against houston for list management reasons! But would probably need a bit more as genuinely trading down requires overs from team trading up
@@PommyinOZ I would b happy to keep pick 11 or have 2 picks inside 20 or so I’ve heard u talk about Houston as similar to wat we have I’d b happy to back in our kids Boyd Wilson Holland camporealle I also like trading owned and carol for 3rds we have walker coming who sounds like a star I’m guessing going to b a high pick
@domonicsheridan5347 yeah fortunately we have 2026 to worry about that but.... we can use 3 picks one Windows from next year
Option 4- lose owies and get Houston and Rosa in? Maybe?
Would be an adoption of 3 so could keep durdin as depth rookie A
@@PommyinOZ I like the look of that. Balance looks a little better too. Sucks to lose owies but Rosa would be a good get.
Merch Pomm
💙💙💙
Bobby Hill went cheap and look how he turned out.
cant compare in that avenue, totally different types of forwards, and Bobby was 1) huge ceiling type player, 22 and publicly declared to move to Victoria, we have to compare apples to apples cant throw in a melon
Why not?
Small forward is a small forward, we fell asleep at the wheel on that one, and why would Owies want to be classified as a rookie as you mentioned, no one wants to be downgraded
@@AceF1910 Well again to point i just made, if no one has shown interest (been on table for a while North is the only option) hes 28 vs Bobby Hill who was a pup, It would be a case if the Value aint there for Carlton they wont do it and Rookie him (as shown cant bring everyone in i.e Pick 11 and Ben Camp without a senior going) Everyone is making out Owies (i like him) is Betts 2.0 crossed with Papley, Rookie deals arent different to Senior its the portion of wage off books, so it would be up to him, play for north 18th to 15th or play finals football at Carlton
@@PommyinOZ owies is all method and little forward craft/instinct. i like him but he doesn't threaten opposition. really motlop needs a fire lit under his tookers. williams looks like a true small/medium forward. having said that owies has proven to be a clutch kick which carlton sorely missed this year. i still think we need another key position back not another half back flanker. that seems to be carlton's fav past time
@leonsappl with ya brother hoping mitlop Williams having the prime role and responsibility makes them life
Houston dont need stupid! Owies best small forward we have and they want to trade him! Fantasia was not needed! Durdin only 22 but hasnt done much in three years. Injuries? Inness over to you! Voss doesnt get up to speed with the modern game. Overlap run and some! Means listening and or changing line coaches! Brad lyoyd were are you my friend! If you see same same next year we will finish 10- 14! There must be change coaching psyche etc etc. Peace out!
💙💙💙