I think rich hill deserves an in depth video about his odd career and having a lot of no hitters/perfect games robbed from him. I think you’ve already made a small video about him but I can’t find it
There are a lot of people who don’t even really follow baseball who just know Barry Bonds = steroids. I was that way for a long time. That video is a perfect antidote to that way of thinking.
Why Baseball Isn't Fair is the video I share with non-baseball fans to show them why Baseball rules. Most people walk away with at least a "hmmm, that's interesting"
Also I feel like we watched this video play out in real time 2019 world series game 7. Grienke pitched the game of his life, Scherzer had traffic all night, but...the astros lost
I always share the Tim Locastro video with non-baseball fans because the video is exciting and he doesn't fit the mold of what people think when they think "baseball" (mostly strikeouts and homeruns)
The funniest moment in any Baseball Bits was in the Bryce Harper video when talking about WAR expected for FA money, and you show the graphic of his value and say "Hey, wait a minute"
I noticed the "penultimate" comment. Don't stress too much about it. I have literally heard dozens of people misuse that word in the exact same way you did. I would venture to say that most of the time someone uses that word they think it means final.
Is there anyone who hasn't watched every single episode of Baseball Bits? I literally watch them all the day they come out. I watch all of Bailey's stuff. He's my favorite TH-camr. I selfishly want him to make a lot more episodes of baseball bits than he does. I'm sure they take too much time to make though.
"Up here with Willie Mays and Tim Locastro and Justin Verlander and Rob Barajas" was a sentence that truly only makes sense when talking specifically about baseball bits.
Baseball Bits that I'd personally rate higher are Bryce Harper, Joey Votto, and Jeff Mathis. I think the Jeff Mathis absolutely fits the mold of your best videos, in the sense of "here's a player you've never heard of before, and here's how they defy expectations." Bobby Wallace is basically the dead-ball era equivalent of that thought process and it worked really well. Incorporating a modern, statistically driven approach always keeps me interested and I think you're doing an excellent job with these videos
I think the Bonds episode was really well done because of the restraint you had in doing the video. You didn’t talk much about his personal choices but focused on what he meant to the game. One quote from that video that is haunting to me is: “It isn’t enough that the Angels won, the American public demands a loser whose heart has been ripped out.” One of the many quotes from that video that really encapsulates American sports culture in general. Bonds is not even recognized as the all time home run leader in MLB The Show. The leader is credited as “San Francisco Giants.” S tier for me. Love your work!!!!
2 years later so probably useless, but MLB the show has a rather unique reason for not using Bonds’ name. He broke away from the MLBPA to be ‘individually licensed’ and that is also why he was never featured in baseball games even when he was playing! Im not sure if records lists fall under his licensing; but I assume if not, the decision to not list his name stems from his refusal to be included in games while he was active. Part of his anti hero charm, imo.
Tim Locastro Vid is absolutely S - Tier. It's what I think of when I think baseball bits. Because of the vid he's on my bench on MLB the Show and I have won so many games because of him
100% agree on the Willie Mays video being S tier. I showed this video to some older baseball fans in my family and they enjoyed it. It bridges the gap between the traditional and modern eras very well!
The Willie Mays video is my favourite for sure. It's like watching a movie where you're in suspense the whole time, but the good guy wins in the end. Everyone's happy, tears in their eyes.
I can’t believe you didn’t talk about the most iconic line of baseball bits ever: WAIT WHO PUT THIS PICTURE OF BARTOLO COLON IN MY BOB WICKMAN CALENDAR?
honestly surprised that "The Future of Baseball is International" ranked that low. i think it sort of gave a different perspective that the another video, i really enjoy it!
Going through all the videos it’s pretty amazing to see how many Baseball Bits episodes have added something to the Baseball Fan’s lexicon or achieved meme status. I remember when Baseball Bits was starting to take off and many people were comparing Bailey to Jon Bois. The other day I was watching the Dorktown episode on Brandon Guyer and it was pretty cool to see how many people were in the comment section shouting out the channel and the Tim Locastro video. It says a lot to see the comparisons being thrown both ways and it’s a credit to how well produced and researched the videos are. And it shows how well the formula for the series is working when there are videos that get more relevant as time goes on. As well as the hands on approach that has certainly made the comment section a great place to have a good conversation about baseball. Just don’t rush into that magnum opus about Mike Trout too quickly!!!
I like this video. As an artist, I really like taking an honest look back on things you’ve made and seeing what didn’t work versus what did and why. It really helps you improve.
Honestly the Braves-Pirates one is probably my favorite, I've really enjoyed seeing the growth of the channel but I go back to that one by far the most. The bit at the end with Scott Proctor falling down is what made me love this channel (not to mention the rest of the video changing my mind on a call I thought was 100% wrong)
I think the video where Pujos broke that dude is A Tier. The show is called "Baseball Bits" and its a great bit of baseball. I didn't know about that story and it didn't need anything extra, but you told it very well and made it enjoyable. I don't think Baseball Bits needs stats or big brain to be A Tier
I think the Willie Mays video is your best work. It's awesome on the basis of the analytics and the detective work, but "catch probability of 2% like the freaking milk, baby!" just puts it over the top.
bonds in 4 has become my favorite episode of baseball bits by far, feel like it deserved to be S tier for the concept alone, one of the most interesting videos on bonds out there, S tier bonds video w the jon bois one
As a channel, Foolish Baseball is S tier for sure. I stop whatever I'm doing when a new Baseball Bits goes up. Same with Summoning Salt's content. But that's pretty much my entire TH-cam must-watch list.
Bailey, I've been around this channel for awhile and you even inspired me for my project where I analyzed the history of the Tampa Bay Rays, no matter what you ranked the Baseball bits, I enjoyed every last one of them.
Hey Bailey, I think a Gio Urshela baseball bits would be really cool. The bad start and the sudden uphill, it's very cool! Also, I love ALL of them, so they should all be S tier.
Not 100% sure why, but the Cleveland Spiders video is always the one I look back on as my favorite and the one that was most enthralling. Loved hearing your perspective on all these, Bailey!
S tier : Willie Mays catch, Justin Verlander perfect inning, Jeff Mathis, Tim Locastro, Larry Walker,Ichiro secret slugger,Pedro, astros cheating scandal, Barry Bonds,Juan Soto hitting machine, Bryce harper, Joey votto,most strikeouts,Big papi, Earl Weaver Moneyball A tier : everything else (other than 3 videos) B tier : Worst call ever, game of baseball is international, Kershaws prime is over.
My S tier is Tim Locastro Jeff Mathis Earl Weaver Bobby Wallace and Justin Verlander. Larry Walker, Yankees CF and Most Breakable Record were ones I think you slept on. The former for its impact and the latter two because I rewatch them a lot and think they're great topics. Rewatchability is a huge thing for me in Baseball bits
I think how to fix baseball is your best video. I’ve only ever walked away from 2 videos seriously impressed in a lot of years of watching TH-cam. That’s one of them
Hey Bailey, every video you've ever made is S tier for me! I literally fall asleep to baseball bits sometimes haha. I was just wondering if you could list out the track names of the songs you use in each video, in the description? I really love the music in your videos! Keep rocking it man!
He usually credits the tracks at the very end. Within the last 30 seconds of the video. I have entire playlist of my favorite baseball but songs. Also, one of the main artists he uses is Maxo. I found it in the Felix Hernandez episode.
If you ever do this again, one of my now all time favorite episodes is the one about the Royals video replay review guy, and how he is literally sabermetrically worth positive WAR. Such a sick video and a great idea that lends itself to how important non players or direct coaching staff is to each organization, in all sports for that matter.
The Cleveland spiders video should be S tier imo. It’s quintessential baseball bits bc it’s about an unusual topic and it might be your funniest video.
I really love the non-Pitcher, Defense-oriented Baseball Bits, so I'd personally put Mathis in S tier (my personal favourite) and Simba in High-A/Low-S range. Otherwise I'm almost in total agreeance with the tier list
Hey Bailey I know you don’t like suggestions all too much, but I just find it weird that the A’s, for as weird and interesting of an organization as they are, don’t have a single baseball bits video having to do with them. I feel like there are a ton of stories to tell over the history of their franchise whether it’s present day, early 2010’s, moneyball (probably overdone), the bash bros, rickey henderson, Charles Finley, the 70s dynasty, their stint in Kansas City, Connie Mack, Jimmie Foxx etc. there’s just so much there and I hope you’ll consider covering one of them soon :).
I don’t think you’ll see this Bailey but, I came to your channel when the Barajas vid was recommended to me. I then watched all the videos. Keep up the great work
Commenting before I watch....the Tim Locastro episode has to be up there for me. Same with the King Felix vid (but I'm biased on that one) edit: i keep getting jon bois and jomboy mixed up when you drop their names lol
I think the Jeff Mathis one should be Tier SS, this video is a Gem that shows how Fielding, that is the most under appreciated aspect of the game, can be important and exciting, I am Italian , I remember one day watching Giants vs Reds in the playoffs 2012 I told my father “Posey the catcher” is one of the best players in the world, he didn’t know the fielders also were hitters so he said “What? What does he do? He just catches a ball and he is the best player in the world and makes millions?” So Catchers as fielders seems like something easy to do, even baseball lovers don’t value the catcher as a fielder, and that video showed the vital importance of being a good fielder, I am a huge fan, but that was the video that made me fall in love with baseball even more
The Larry walker, Ichiro and strikeout videos are the ones I’ve rewatched the most. Would be very high on my list. Honestly though it would be hard for me cos I love all these videos. Coming from somewhere where baseball is never even mentioned, I started to watch because of a combination of foolish baseball videos and Javy Baez highlights.
great list! I fully agree with Tim Locastro's video being S. It is one of my all-time favorite videos, I love to go back and watch it every couple months Edit: Jeff Mathis isn't S tier booooo I love that video so much
I'm really glad you ranked the Earl Weaver video as an A. I've always felt like that was one of the most underrated episodes. Also feel like the Bobby Wallace one is underrated. It's just such a unique and weird story.
I’m a Giants fan so I’m biased for The Catch video, I think that’s how I found the channel, you did great work analyzing old footage. Reminds me a bit of Jon’s college basketball video.
my personal favorite was the one on Timmy and Tulo. I haven't been watching baseball for all that long and they are two players that I hadn't really heard about. I wanna thank you for presenting the careers of two phenomenal players with careers cut way too short.
Fun list. I don’t have much disagreements from your ranking, although I might personally bump Jeff Mathis to an S tier just from the memes that developed out of it. (Also it’s the video that led me to Foolish Baseball.) I’m also glad Rod Barajas got an S just because it’s the video where I got my Patreon shoutout. I’ll have to fill mine out after I get back from the Astros-Rangers game.
Timmy and Tulo was incredible looking back they were playing when I was a kid first getting into watching baseball and they were electric and they’re decline always made me sad but the video did bring me to that don’t be sad because it’s over smile because it happened
Not sure how good of a Baseball Bits this would be, but in a sense, catchers are player managers. They have so much they have to know: every pitchers pitches, opposing teams batters tendencies, counts, potential base stealers if on base, and just overall game management. They’re borderline coaches.
Forgot to comment when I first watched this video, but the Buehrle baseball bits was the first I ever watched and the idea behind it is definitely one of my favourites. After i watched that video it got me hooked on all the other baseball bits and I've enjoyed them all, but for me I would have Buehrle in A at least
Fun fact about how pujoles broke lidge. For some reason I never got a chance to watch that episode of baseball bits so I thought that breaking lidge was an actual phrase. So in an essay (btw I got a 99) I put “I really think the bald eagle broke lidge after the government banned DDT” my English teacher called me up and said what does breaking lidge mean and I said oh it’s a phrase. 2 weeks later I watch the video and I felt like and Idiot. but wait there’s more my English teacher actually ended using the phrase breaking lidge in an example for all of her classes... she was a strict teacher so I was worried about coming clean but, I did and she laughed it off. Now me, friend, and family all use breaking lidge as a phrase Thank you foolish baseball
Huge fan of the podcast Bailey, my favourite episode is Bonds in 4, closely followed by a couple, like Willie Mays, catcher who couldn't throw, Pujols broke Lidge,
Mark Buehrle and Tim Locastro are the two videos I use to pimp your channel. The only thing missing from the Buehrle video is mention of him drinking three beers before closing out the World Series; though one might argue that had absolutely nothing to do with the point of the video, I believe it is as inseparable from his career as Barry Bonds' healthy breakfast.
Horrible rankings wtf. I would’ve put them all in S
Right? 0/10. All these videos are classics, and I could rewatch them till I die, totally deserve more respect.
He’s gotta be humble
I really really like the Larry Walker video tbh. A tier at least.
Same
Dude, word. Anyone that says it didn't help LW even juuuust a little to get into the HOF is kidding themselves...
Yeah same
Larry walker doesn’t get into the hof if he doesn’t make the video, easily S
First video I saw. Still my favorite.
I think rich hill deserves an in depth video about his odd career and having a lot of no hitters/perfect games robbed from him. I think you’ve already made a small video about him but I can’t find it
Sports storm made a video on his 2 perfect games so
I agree
Ye
@@akauf2282 he can't get over the hill of having a no hitter (pun intendented)
Bonds in 4 has my favorite ending of any of these and I honestly think it’s an S for that reason alone
Bonds in 4 is one of my favorite videos on TH-cam. S+ tier honestly
My favourite as well
There are a lot of people who don’t even really follow baseball who just know Barry Bonds = steroids. I was that way for a long time. That video is a perfect antidote to that way of thinking.
Jose Altuve will follow his stead probably. He's only gonna start getting respect back quietly after he retires
favorite as well
Why Baseball Isn't Fair is the video I share with non-baseball fans to show them why Baseball rules. Most people walk away with at least a "hmmm, that's interesting"
Also I feel like we watched this video play out in real time 2019 world series game 7. Grienke pitched the game of his life, Scherzer had traffic all night, but...the astros lost
I always share the Tim Locastro video with non-baseball fans because the video is exciting and he doesn't fit the mold of what people think when they think "baseball" (mostly strikeouts and homeruns)
@@7371mojorisin and will Harris’s pitch to Kendrick was perfect but he hit a homer
I was going to riot if the catcher who couldn't throw wasn't S tier. Crazy how your D tier videos are better than most creators S tier videos.
When Pujols broke Lidge has always been my personal favorite. The story is just too interesting.
Saneee
"Some say the ball is now in space"
That’s what I’m sayin
Whether or not you’re serious, Bailey. You really are a genius.
The funniest moment in any Baseball Bits was in the Bryce Harper video when talking about WAR expected for FA money, and you show the graphic of his value and say "Hey, wait a minute"
i looooove how he sounds like a school teacher going over a students assignments.
dude the Larry Walker bits is actually A tier man. The writing was actually top tier to me.
Let’s goooo I just knew Tim locastro would be S tier
Same I had Jeff Mathis there too but it is what it is
@@frankschaefer8890 I had Mark Buehrle there too
The speed run video with Buehrle vid was my favorite
Same, perfect comedy and a cool story
I noticed the "penultimate" comment. Don't stress too much about it. I have literally heard dozens of people misuse that word in the exact same way you did. I would venture to say that most of the time someone uses that word they think it means final.
Is there anyone who hasn't watched every single episode of Baseball Bits? I literally watch them all the day they come out. I watch all of Bailey's stuff. He's my favorite TH-camr. I selfishly want him to make a lot more episodes of baseball bits than he does. I'm sure they take too much time to make though.
Jeff Mathis is not an A. That one is definitely S-Tier.
Lemony Snicket brah
I've seen the vid at least 3 times and I never noticed he misused it.
"Back when Old Hoss Radbourn was just a Young Hoss Radbourn" is one my favorite lines in the history of the internet. That one's S tier for me.
Larry Walker’s execution with the brainwashing is probably my favorite of all of the videos.
"Up here with Willie Mays and Tim Locastro and Justin Verlander and Rob Barajas" was a sentence that truly only makes sense when talking specifically about baseball bits.
Rob Barajas, Tim Locastro, Jeff Mathis and Old Hoss Radbourn are the mt Rushmore of baseball bits
Earl weaver was 100% my favorite episode. Absolute S tier
Definitely S. For how impactful and revolutionary Moneyball was I was shocked that someone was doing that in the 70s. Just a really great premise
Agree. My most rewatched Baseball Bits video, along with Pedro Martinez and Justin Verlander.
Baseball Bits that I'd personally rate higher are Bryce Harper, Joey Votto, and Jeff Mathis.
I think the Jeff Mathis absolutely fits the mold of your best videos, in the sense of "here's a player you've never heard of before, and here's how they defy expectations."
Bobby Wallace is basically the dead-ball era equivalent of that thought process and it worked really well.
Incorporating a modern, statistically driven approach always keeps me interested and I think you're doing an excellent job with these videos
I think the Bonds episode was really well done because of the restraint you had in doing the video. You didn’t talk much about his personal choices but focused on what he meant to the game. One quote from that video that is haunting to me is: “It isn’t enough that the Angels won, the American public demands a loser whose heart has been ripped out.” One of the many quotes from that video that really encapsulates American sports culture in general. Bonds is not even recognized as the all time home run leader in MLB The Show. The leader is credited as “San Francisco Giants.” S tier for me. Love your work!!!!
2 years later so probably useless, but MLB the show has a rather unique reason for not using Bonds’ name. He broke away from the MLBPA to be ‘individually licensed’ and that is also why he was never featured in baseball games even when he was playing! Im not sure if records lists fall under his licensing; but I assume if not, the decision to not list his name stems from his refusal to be included in games while he was active. Part of his anti hero charm, imo.
Tim Locastro Vid is absolutely S - Tier. It's what I think of when I think baseball bits. Because of the vid he's on my bench on MLB the Show and I have won so many games because of him
100% agree on the Willie Mays video being S tier. I showed this video to some older baseball fans in my family and they enjoyed it. It bridges the gap between the traditional and modern eras very well!
I agree. Young and old people could enjoy it very much. It might be my favorite
“Bonds in 4” is my favourite video of yours. He’s such an interesting player and you did an amazing job with it
Where’s arm punt ?
Damn, Bailey really making me watch all his videos to make this tier list.
Say no more, on it right now
The Willie Mays video is my favourite for sure. It's like watching a movie where you're in suspense the whole time, but the good guy wins in the end. Everyone's happy, tears in their eyes.
I can’t believe you didn’t talk about the most iconic line of baseball bits ever: WAIT WHO PUT THIS PICTURE OF BARTOLO COLON IN MY BOB WICKMAN CALENDAR?
honestly surprised that "The Future of Baseball is International" ranked that low. i think it sort of gave a different perspective that the another video, i really enjoy it!
I know what I’m doing for the next 37 minutes!
Mathis is a god-tier vid.
Going through all the videos it’s pretty amazing to see how many Baseball Bits episodes have added something to the Baseball Fan’s lexicon or achieved meme status. I remember when Baseball Bits was starting to take off and many people were comparing Bailey to Jon Bois. The other day I was watching the Dorktown episode on Brandon Guyer and it was pretty cool to see how many people were in the comment section shouting out the channel and the Tim Locastro video. It says a lot to see the comparisons being thrown both ways and it’s a credit to how well produced and researched the videos are. And it shows how well the formula for the series is working when there are videos that get more relevant as time goes on. As well as the hands on approach that has certainly made the comment section a great place to have a good conversation about baseball. Just don’t rush into that magnum opus about Mike Trout too quickly!!!
I like this video. As an artist, I really like taking an honest look back on things you’ve made and seeing what didn’t work versus what did and why. It really helps you improve.
Bonds in 4 is such an iconic video for this channel. the way it is presented and formatted is the best imo. Best Baseball Bits easily
I’m glad you really like the Tulo and Lincecum video. They were the stars when I was growing up, and it’s nice to see them get a light shone on them
You were a god send for me in 2020. I honestly watched each one about 3 times. Keep up the great work!
Seeing one of the biggest MLB TH-camr's open up about little mistakes in his videos that no one but himself notices is so relatable.
Honestly the Braves-Pirates one is probably my favorite, I've really enjoyed seeing the growth of the channel but I go back to that one by far the most. The bit at the end with Scott Proctor falling down is what made me love this channel (not to mention the rest of the video changing my mind on a call I thought was 100% wrong)
Am I the only one who would love to see Bailey do a MLB the show franchise mode?
He has done OOTP, which is a better franchise sim game!
Timmy and Tulo is definitely top 3 videos for me maybe the best you’ve ever done
I think the video where Pujos broke that dude is A Tier. The show is called "Baseball Bits" and its a great bit of baseball. I didn't know about that story and it didn't need anything extra, but you told it very well and made it enjoyable. I don't think Baseball Bits needs stats or big brain to be A Tier
Tim Locastro video is a master stroke, great video, excellent execution.
The Ortiz video introduced the Wickman calendar. Easy S
I think the Willie Mays video is your best work. It's awesome on the basis of the analytics and the detective work, but "catch probability of 2% like the freaking milk, baby!" just puts it over the top.
To be completely honest, every single video should be in S teir. Youre by far my favorite youtuber. Keep it up man!
bonds in 4 has become my favorite episode of baseball bits by far, feel like it deserved to be S tier for the concept alone, one of the most interesting videos on bonds out there, S tier bonds video w the jon bois one
As a channel, Foolish Baseball is S tier for sure. I stop whatever I'm doing when a new Baseball Bits goes up. Same with Summoning Salt's content. But that's pretty much my entire TH-cam must-watch list.
Personally my favorites are Verlander, Tim locastro, and Jeff mathis
I come back to these 3 all the time, but my favorite is the accidental hall of famer. That’s the most underrated video on his channel IMO
Bailey, I've been around this channel for awhile and you even inspired me for my project where I analyzed the history of the Tampa Bay Rays, no matter what you ranked the Baseball bits, I enjoyed every last one of them.
I can't believe "When Pujols Broke Lidge" didn't find its way into S! It was one of my firsts, and I come back to it so often.
Hey Bailey, I think a Gio Urshela baseball bits would be really cool. The bad start and the sudden uphill, it's very cool!
Also, I love ALL of them, so they should all be S tier.
Not 100% sure why, but the Cleveland Spiders video is always the one I look back on as my favorite and the one that was most enthralling. Loved hearing your perspective on all these, Bailey!
S tier : Willie Mays catch, Justin Verlander perfect inning, Jeff Mathis, Tim Locastro, Larry Walker,Ichiro secret slugger,Pedro, astros cheating scandal, Barry Bonds,Juan Soto hitting machine, Bryce harper, Joey votto,most strikeouts,Big papi, Earl Weaver Moneyball
A tier : everything else (other than 3 videos)
B tier : Worst call ever, game of baseball is international, Kershaws prime is over.
Bailey is too tough on himself... all your videos are fuego for different reasons.
My S tier is Tim Locastro Jeff Mathis Earl Weaver Bobby Wallace and Justin Verlander. Larry Walker, Yankees CF and Most Breakable Record were ones I think you slept on. The former for its impact and the latter two because I rewatch them a lot and think they're great topics. Rewatchability is a huge thing for me in Baseball bits
I think how to fix baseball is your best video. I’ve only ever walked away from 2 videos seriously impressed in a lot of years of watching TH-cam. That’s one of them
curious as to what the other was
Bonds is S tier and the best video on all of TH-cam
That Stephen Strasberg video is fantastic. It was amazing seeing him ball out in the playoffs just weeks after your video came out. Bravo
Definitely a few older videos I'm going to rewatch after seeing this list (specifically tim locastro)
Locastro video 100% deserves a tier of its own. One of the best videos on yt
Laughed out loud at you talking about how you used that word wrong, we’ve all been there, good on you for owning it and more importantly learning
I'm pretty disappointed this video wasn't 10 seconds long. ALL of Baseball Bits are S TIer. Chef's kiss.
Glad to see the Barajas video getting love, it’s the one I’ve sent to people to show your channel
Hey Bailey, every video you've ever made is S tier for me! I literally fall asleep to baseball bits sometimes haha.
I was just wondering if you could list out the track names of the songs you use in each video, in the description? I really love the music in your videos!
Keep rocking it man!
He usually credits the tracks at the very end. Within the last 30 seconds of the video. I have entire playlist of my favorite baseball but songs. Also, one of the main artists he uses is Maxo. I found it in the Felix Hernandez episode.
This cap they all s tier am I wrong?
You right
Ur not wrong
If you ever do this again, one of my now all time favorite episodes is the one about the Royals video replay review guy, and how he is literally sabermetrically worth positive WAR. Such a sick video and a great idea that lends itself to how important non players or direct coaching staff is to each organization, in all sports for that matter.
26:55 just in time for Devin Williams to show up with the new Nastiest Pitch in Baseball™
The Cleveland spiders video should be S tier imo. It’s quintessential baseball bits bc it’s about an unusual topic and it might be your funniest video.
My first episode was Bonds in 4. Absolutely loved it. It got me hooked on baseball bits immediately
I really love the non-Pitcher, Defense-oriented Baseball Bits, so I'd personally put Mathis in S tier (my personal favourite) and Simba in High-A/Low-S range. Otherwise I'm almost in total agreeance with the tier list
Hey Bailey I know you don’t like suggestions all too much, but I just find it weird that the A’s, for as weird and interesting of an organization as they are, don’t have a single baseball bits video having to do with them. I feel like there are a ton of stories to tell over the history of their franchise whether it’s present day, early 2010’s, moneyball (probably overdone), the bash bros, rickey henderson, Charles Finley, the 70s dynasty, their stint in Kansas City, Connie Mack, Jimmie Foxx etc. there’s just so much there and I hope you’ll consider covering one of them soon :).
I don’t think you’ll see this Bailey but, I came to your channel when the Barajas vid was recommended to me. I then watched all the videos. Keep up the great work
all of them are S tier in my book. love your videos bro, keep making em'.
Game 7 vid is S tier. It’s one of my favorites
smh where's arm punt
i honestly love your bonds in 4, such a great premise and tone for a video that could have been really lazy. and really told a great story.
The Mike Trout video is by far and beyond the best video you have ever made
Commenting before I watch....the Tim Locastro episode has to be up there for me. Same with the King Felix vid (but I'm biased on that one)
edit: i keep getting jon bois and jomboy mixed up when you drop their names lol
I think all of your videos are amazing.
I think the Jeff Mathis one should be Tier SS, this video is a Gem that shows how Fielding, that is the most under appreciated aspect of the game, can be important and exciting, I am Italian , I remember one day watching Giants vs Reds in the playoffs 2012 I told my father “Posey the catcher” is one of the best players in the world, he didn’t know the fielders also were hitters so he said “What? What does he do? He just catches a ball and he is the best player in the world and makes millions?”
So Catchers as fielders seems like something easy to do, even baseball lovers don’t value the catcher as a fielder, and that video showed the vital importance of being a good fielder, I am a huge fan, but that was the video that made me fall in love with baseball even more
The Larry walker, Ichiro and strikeout videos are the ones I’ve rewatched the most. Would be very high on my list. Honestly though it would be hard for me cos I love all these videos. Coming from somewhere where baseball is never even mentioned, I started to watch because of a combination of foolish baseball videos and Javy Baez highlights.
great list! I fully agree with Tim Locastro's video being S. It is one of my all-time favorite videos, I love to go back and watch it every couple months
Edit: Jeff Mathis isn't S tier booooo I love that video so much
I'm really glad you ranked the Earl Weaver video as an A. I've always felt like that was one of the most underrated episodes. Also feel like the Bobby Wallace one is underrated. It's just such a unique and weird story.
I’m a Giants fan so I’m biased for The Catch video, I think that’s how I found the channel, you did great work analyzing old footage. Reminds me a bit of Jon’s college basketball video.
This is sick plz do more content like this
my personal favorite was the one on Timmy and Tulo. I haven't been watching baseball for all that long and they are two players that I hadn't really heard about. I wanna thank you for presenting the careers of two phenomenal players with careers cut way too short.
As a Yankee fan, my favorite has always been Pedro Martinez. Just so well made. (Although that might be cuz it had undertale music)
Fun list. I don’t have much disagreements from your ranking, although I might personally bump Jeff Mathis to an S tier just from the memes that developed out of it. (Also it’s the video that led me to Foolish Baseball.) I’m also glad Rod Barajas got an S just because it’s the video where I got my Patreon shoutout.
I’ll have to fill mine out after I get back from the Astros-Rangers game.
I just really enjoy all your content man. My favorite though is “Kershaws prime” and “ Juan Soto “
All s teir
I think the Pujos and Larry Walker ones are the best but they are all really good
Timmy and Tulo was incredible looking back they were playing when I was a kid first getting into watching baseball and they were electric and they’re decline always made me sad but the video did bring me to that don’t be sad because it’s over smile because it happened
Catcher who couldn't throw is an amazing video and the one that made me subscribe.
I really loved the international baseball video
Not sure how good of a Baseball Bits this would be, but in a sense, catchers are player managers. They have so much they have to know: every pitchers pitches, opposing teams batters tendencies, counts, potential base stealers if on base, and just overall game management. They’re borderline coaches.
Forgot to comment when I first watched this video, but the Buehrle baseball bits was the first I ever watched and the idea behind it is definitely one of my favourites. After i watched that video it got me hooked on all the other baseball bits and I've enjoyed them all, but for me I would have Buehrle in A at least
Hearing you talk about the last episode hurt.
Really hope this ride goes on for a long, long time.
as a big fan of JV, the verlander breakdown was one of my best breakdown videos ever.
Fun fact about how pujoles broke lidge. For some reason I never got a chance to watch that episode of baseball bits so I thought that breaking lidge was an actual phrase. So in an essay (btw I got a 99) I put “I really think the bald eagle broke lidge after the government banned DDT” my English teacher called me up and said what does breaking lidge mean and I said oh it’s a phrase. 2 weeks later I watch the video and I felt like and Idiot. but wait there’s more my English teacher actually ended using the phrase breaking lidge in an example for all of her classes... she was a strict teacher so I was worried about coming clean but, I did and she laughed it off. Now me, friend, and family all use breaking lidge as a phrase
Thank you foolish baseball
That's hilarious. Your comment brought me much joy. My lidge remains unbroken.
Huge fan of the podcast Bailey, my favourite episode is Bonds in 4, closely followed by a couple, like Willie Mays, catcher who couldn't throw, Pujols broke Lidge,
Mark Buehrle and Tim Locastro are the two videos I use to pimp your channel. The only thing missing from the Buehrle video is mention of him drinking three beers before closing out the World Series; though one might argue that had absolutely nothing to do with the point of the video, I believe it is as inseparable from his career as Barry Bonds' healthy breakfast.