For people that already give/sell/use one of the books, you only need to hand Myrddin 3 books, then complete the quest with Trysha, equip the ring, then go to Myrddin, tell him that you are done only with three books, then again, speak to him, he will notice your ring, then some dialogue about Trysha. Rest a day, back to him, and then he will give you the spell.
There's at least 2 duplicate grimoires, and you only need 3 for each quest if you give them at once. So you don't have to duplicate any. Also, if you learn the meteor spell before you finish Myrddin's quest you won't be able to get receive the Maelstrom spell.
There are 3 that I found from using the thieves pilfer/plunder skill. - the guy that gives you towering earth has howling blizzard as well if you steal from him. - there is a beastren female trader named Elsa that wonders through Bakbattahl. She has a copy of towering earth that can be stolen. - 3rd one I can’t remember who but I believe it was 1 of the two traders that frequents Harve Village. I went around basically stealing from every NPC across all cities and towns, but I’m sure I’ve missed some and there might be enough copies to give both all 5 originals. My bet is someone like Phaesus (steal during masquerade) might have a copy but I’ll check This left me with 8 real copies. 5 I have to Trysha and 3 to Myrddin (there’s a bonus bit of story if you give books to Trysha first where you can almost lock yourself out of getting Maelstrom if you’re not wearing the ring she gave you - you have to tell Myddrin about Trysha teaching you meteordon).
@@humanpunchingbag1092 The Melve backpack vendor standing around after the first dragon attack sells Fulminous Shield. I got a makeshift gaol key for stealing.
It must’ve been a figment of my imagination but upon counting with the 2 pilfer / plundered books it makes up 8. If there was another one I haven’t found yet, it’d be 9 books. I’m also aware you can trade fulminous shield for another dupe in Nameless Village but I strongly recommend against it since there is only 1 Fulminous Shield in the game to my knowledge.
There are 3 that I found from using the thieves pilfer/plunder skill. - the guy that gives you towering earth has howling blizzard as well if you steal from him. - there is a beastren female trader named Elsa that wonders through Bakbattahl. She has a copy of towering earth that can be stolen. - 3rd one I can’t remember who but I believe it was 1 of the two traders that frequents Harve Village. I went around basically stealing from every NPC across all cities and towns, but I’m sure I’ve missed some and there might be enough copies to give both all 5 originals. My bet is someone like Phaesus (steal during masquerade) might have a copy but I’ll check This left me with 8 real copies. 5 I have to Trysha and 3 to Myrddin (there’s a bonus bit of story if you give books to Trysha first where you can almost lock yourself out of getting Maelstrom if you’re not wearing the ring she gave you - you have to tell Myddrin about Trysha teaching you meteordon).
Disregard Harve Village roaming vendors, my mind must’ve been playing tricks on me. I got 8 real copies, 2 are from pilfer/plunder and the rest as per the guides you can find online.
I followed your suggestion, then i've found howling blizzard in minister's pocket. But there's a problem i can't find this woman named Elsa. I've checked the streets north-west Bakbattahl and between two cities (Checkpoint rest town). She is disappeared, is not dead I've checked the morgue and nothing. Any missing location I have to be to met her?
@@eltiburongaming6631 1. She is a roaming vendor and follows the main road but doesn’t enter Bakbattahl (I usually find her in an area closer to the gate separating Venworth but never at the gate, just down the hill and along the main road. 2. She is an essential NPC (so if she dies she will respawn after 7 days). I killed her to test the theory. 3. She is hard to find, I spent today trying to find her to show another player and I didn’t find her until a few hours later just by luck.
In dragon's dogma wiki it is written that Elsa should be near the roads of Battahl ropeway station two. But if i watch interactive map she's not even shown in markers. I hope this is an oversight or is incomplete. This research is driving me crazy.
@@eltiburongaming6631 according to wiki pages she goes to Ropeway Station 2 but I never find her there so I feel like it’s misinformation. Better to just follow the path, try resting a few times and visiting at different times of the day.
The two grandmothers absolutely refuse to give me the rewards, anyone know a fix? I’ve tried giving them both flowers and I even did an escort mission for one and they still won’t give me shit
I got the two sorcerer spells but she wouldn't give me the mage one. I threw her off the mountain and revived her but she still didn't budge. So I gave her the eternal bond ring I got from the sphinx and slept a day. Then waited in the house for a bit and she came to me and gave it. I think you just need to raise her affinity more but not necessarily with the eternal bond ring. Just do escort quests with her and give her gifts she likes :)
If you didn't get the 2nd and 3rd spell, Equip the Eternal Bond ring and gift each NPC at least 3 flowers. Wait a couple days and come back. They will approach you and give you the spells once they have high enough favor. You don't trade the ring like people are claiming. You wear it and it boosts the points given with gifts.
there is a second copy of howling blizzard in the nameless village, just give the lady a dupe of the shield book she wants to trade for the blizzard book
I really wish you would’ve been more specific about the fancy attire. Like what quest, location, etc. just playing the story is so vague because not everyone is just doing that.
Ahh okay my bad, it was a super early main story quest so assumed everyone had it. Its from the main story, but I think you can buy it from a shop in the Merchant's Quarter in Vernworth , and it's also in a chest in Svens room in the Vernsworth castle.
You can carry Trysha outside to engage the quest, easier than two people. Not sure why it bothered me so much but it’s “nations death KNELL”-(the ringing of a church bell when someone dies)not “kneel”😅 - I love eggcorns
So is there 2 copies of “Let the be light” because I gave the guy it (Let there be light) without knowing about the copies. Can I get another another let there be light book
I need help ! I can’t unlock celestial paean, I’ve handed her the 5 books an got the others but I failed one of the escort quests , think I may need to build up affinity ???
2 gorevide tamamlamak zorundamıyım? mage gorevini yaptım 1 sahte 4 gerçek kitap verdim hiçbirşey açılmadı. oyunu silmeyi dşünüyorum. ben böyle saçma oyun görmedim. oyun mu oynuyorum işkencemi çekiyorum. en ufak hatada oyunu en baştan oynamak sıkıcı.
I gave the little girl the fake ones and the real ones to the tornado mage. I get the tornado but I didn't get rest... Is there any other way now or is it lost?
I feel terrible. I gave the sorcerer all the real books and the little girl all the fake ones. I got one sorcerer spell but completely locked me out of all the mage spells.
I got you homie. You need to visit his house wearing nice clothing. You can get the clothing by Exploring the rich houses in Vernworth Or by completing the quest where Sven Pays you back the money he owes you.
People in the comments are saying they have found duplicate books in some places. So might be worth checking out if there are other locations for originals, i havn't found any myself yet
There are 3 that I found from using the thieves pilfer/plunder skill. - the guy that gives you towering earth has howling blizzard as well if you steal from him. - there is a beastren female trader named Elsa that wonders through Bakbattahl. She has a copy of towering earth that can be stolen. - 3rd one I can’t remember who but I believe it was 1 of the two traders that frequents Harve Village. I went around basically stealing from every NPC across all cities and towns, but I’m sure I’ve missed some and there might be enough copies to give both all 5 originals. My bet is someone like Phaesus (steal during masquerade) might have a copy but I’ll check This left me with 8 real copies. 5 I have to Trysha and 3 to Myrddin (there’s a bonus bit of story if you give books to Trysha first where you can almost lock yourself out of getting Maelstrom if you’re not wearing the ring she gave you - you have to tell Myddrin about Trysha teaching you meteordon).
@@angelosantiago6155 too easy - like I said I’m sure there might be other copies. I would presume there is 2x of each book or something like that. Also if you’re going on a plunder rampage on NPCs like I did, they actually give some items like the platinum cards for the brothel. Easy 15k gold if you sell it haha. That amongst other items, lots of curatives. It’s not all amazing though but definitely if you’re in a city go switch to thief and go crazy.
You can resurrect them with a wake stone if it just happened. Or you can go back to a town, go to the morgue and resurrect them there with a wakestone :)
well i wait for over 50 days now to trysha complet to study her books. I gave here the same one as here. I wait for 50 days + of now. She never will get it i think 😒 bugged for me i think 🤮 someone can help out with copy ? /dupe
For people that already give/sell/use one of the books, you only need to hand Myrddin 3 books, then complete the quest with Trysha, equip the ring, then go to Myrddin, tell him that you are done only with three books, then again, speak to him, he will notice your ring, then some dialogue about Trysha.
Rest a day, back to him, and then he will give you the spell.
What ring
There's at least 2 duplicate grimoires, and you only need 3 for each quest if you give them at once. So you don't have to duplicate any. Also, if you learn the meteor spell before you finish Myrddin's quest you won't be able to get receive the Maelstrom spell.
You have the option to tell Trysha that you're only giving her 3 or 4 books, but doing so will not get you the rewards from her or Eina.
There are 3 that I found from using the thieves pilfer/plunder skill.
- the guy that gives you towering earth has howling blizzard as well if you steal from him.
- there is a beastren female trader named Elsa that wonders through Bakbattahl. She has a copy of towering earth that can be stolen.
- 3rd one I can’t remember who but I believe it was 1 of the two traders that frequents Harve Village.
I went around basically stealing from every NPC across all cities and towns, but I’m sure I’ve missed some and there might be enough copies to give both all 5 originals. My bet is someone like Phaesus (steal during masquerade) might have a copy but I’ll check
This left me with 8 real copies. 5 I have to Trysha and 3 to Myrddin (there’s a bonus bit of story if you give books to Trysha first where you can almost lock yourself out of getting Maelstrom if you’re not wearing the ring she gave you - you have to tell Myddrin about Trysha teaching you meteordon).
@@humanpunchingbag1092 The Melve backpack vendor standing around after the first dragon attack sells Fulminous Shield. I got a makeshift gaol key for stealing.
@@DNRDROID I miscalculated, there is no Harve vendor book. It’s just 2 from pilfer plunder (the magistrate and Elsa the roaming vendor).
It must’ve been a figment of my imagination but upon counting with the 2 pilfer / plundered books it makes up 8. If there was another one I haven’t found yet, it’d be 9 books. I’m also aware you can trade fulminous shield for another dupe in Nameless Village but I strongly recommend against it since there is only 1 Fulminous Shield in the game to my knowledge.
What do you do if you kill trysha? Cant find the body where she died and there is no body in the Vermund Charnel House
give up
There are 3 that I found from using the thieves pilfer/plunder skill.
- the guy that gives you towering earth has howling blizzard as well if you steal from him.
- there is a beastren female trader named Elsa that wonders through Bakbattahl. She has a copy of towering earth that can be stolen.
- 3rd one I can’t remember who but I believe it was 1 of the two traders that frequents Harve Village.
I went around basically stealing from every NPC across all cities and towns, but I’m sure I’ve missed some and there might be enough copies to give both all 5 originals. My bet is someone like Phaesus (steal during masquerade) might have a copy but I’ll check
This left me with 8 real copies. 5 I have to Trysha and 3 to Myrddin (there’s a bonus bit of story if you give books to Trysha first where you can almost lock yourself out of getting Maelstrom if you’re not wearing the ring she gave you - you have to tell Myddrin about Trysha teaching you meteordon).
Disregard Harve Village roaming vendors, my mind must’ve been playing tricks on me. I got 8 real copies, 2 are from pilfer/plunder and the rest as per the guides you can find online.
I followed your suggestion, then i've found howling blizzard in minister's pocket. But there's a problem i can't find this woman named Elsa. I've checked the streets north-west Bakbattahl and between two cities (Checkpoint rest town). She is disappeared, is not dead I've checked the morgue and nothing. Any missing location I have to be to met her?
@@eltiburongaming6631
1. She is a roaming vendor and follows the main road but doesn’t enter Bakbattahl (I usually find her in an area closer to the gate separating Venworth but never at the gate, just down the hill and along the main road.
2. She is an essential NPC (so if she dies she will respawn after 7 days). I killed her to test the theory.
3. She is hard to find, I spent today trying to find her to show another player and I didn’t find her until a few hours later just by luck.
In dragon's dogma wiki it is written that Elsa should be near the roads of Battahl ropeway station two. But if i watch interactive map she's not even shown in markers. I hope this is an oversight or is incomplete. This research is driving me crazy.
@@eltiburongaming6631 according to wiki pages she goes to Ropeway Station 2 but I never find her there so I feel like it’s misinformation. Better to just follow the path, try resting a few times and visiting at different times of the day.
The two grandmothers absolutely refuse to give me the rewards, anyone know a fix? I’ve tried giving them both flowers and I even did an escort mission for one and they still won’t give me shit
same i don't know what's wrong! same with the fighter ultimate.
I got the two sorcerer spells but she wouldn't give me the mage one. I threw her off the mountain and revived her but she still didn't budge. So I gave her the eternal bond ring I got from the sphinx and slept a day. Then waited in the house for a bit and she came to me and gave it. I think you just need to raise her affinity more but not necessarily with the eternal bond ring. Just do escort quests with her and give her gifts she likes :)
If you didn't get the 2nd and 3rd spell, Equip the Eternal Bond ring and gift each NPC at least 3 flowers. Wait a couple days and come back. They will approach you and give you the spells once they have high enough favor. You don't trade the ring like people are claiming. You wear it and it boosts the points given with gifts.
there is a second copy of howling blizzard in the nameless village, just give the lady a dupe of the shield book she wants to trade for the blizzard book
Do you only get the tornado from the sorcerer guy?
I really wish you would’ve been more specific about the fancy attire. Like what quest, location, etc. just playing the story is so vague because not everyone is just doing that.
Ahh okay my bad, it was a super early main story quest so assumed everyone had it. Its from the main story, but I think you can buy it from a shop in the Merchant's Quarter in Vernworth , and it's also in a chest in Svens room in the Vernsworth castle.
You can carry Trysha outside to engage the quest, easier than two people. Not sure why it bothered me so much but it’s “nations death KNELL”-(the ringing of a church bell when someone dies)not “kneel”😅 - I love eggcorns
So is there 2 copies of “Let the be light” because I gave the guy it (Let there be light) without knowing about the copies. Can I get another another let there be light book
I need help ! I can’t unlock celestial paean, I’ve handed her the 5 books an got the others but I failed one of the escort quests , think I may need to build up affinity ???
Myrddin tells me be gone and doesn't wanna talk to me :(
That foo wont open the door for me even in my formal wear
2 gorevide tamamlamak zorundamıyım? mage gorevini yaptım 1 sahte 4 gerçek kitap verdim hiçbirşey açılmadı. oyunu silmeyi dşünüyorum. ben böyle saçma oyun görmedim. oyun mu oynuyorum işkencemi çekiyorum. en ufak hatada oyunu en baştan oynamak sıkıcı.
If you do tryshas quest first you can't complete the other one right
I unlocked celestial paean bvut it dose'nt appear in my skills?
I gave the little girl the fake ones and the real ones to the tornado mage. I get the tornado but I didn't get rest... Is there any other way now or is it lost?
finish the game and replay it
i used the let there be light book ages ago, im screwed. Do you know where to find a second book?
You can get a friend to send you a forgery
What if Dudley won’t open shop for you?
I feel terrible. I gave the sorcerer all the real books and the little girl all the fake ones. I got one sorcerer spell but completely locked me out of all the mage spells.
You don’t have to give Trysha all the grinoires I passed it by giving her 4 books and I got everthing
The grand father won’t speak to me.
Your guide has been great
Now I need to figure out how to get the grand father to give me the reward
I got you homie. You need to visit his house wearing nice clothing. You can get the clothing by Exploring the rich houses in Vernworth Or by completing the quest where Sven Pays you back the money he owes you.
If you sell one of the books is there a way to get it back ?
You’re cooked you’re cooked you’re cooked Ggs until 2nd play though
Damned I forgot the mage meister skill. Lol
Eh gonna have to pass on this quest too much busy work.
i know but what if you had used all the books in battle😢
So by the time I figured out about the copies already gave Myrding three books... there's no way to get those books back? Right?
People in the comments are saying they have found duplicate books in some places. So might be worth checking out if there are other locations for originals, i havn't found any myself yet
There are 3 that I found from using the thieves pilfer/plunder skill.
- the guy that gives you towering earth has howling blizzard as well if you steal from him.
- there is a beastren female trader named Elsa that wonders through Bakbattahl. She has a copy of towering earth that can be stolen.
- 3rd one I can’t remember who but I believe it was 1 of the two traders that frequents Harve Village.
I went around basically stealing from every NPC across all cities and towns, but I’m sure I’ve missed some and there might be enough copies to give both all 5 originals. My bet is someone like Phaesus (steal during masquerade) might have a copy but I’ll check
This left me with 8 real copies. 5 I have to Trysha and 3 to Myrddin (there’s a bonus bit of story if you give books to Trysha first where you can almost lock yourself out of getting Maelstrom if you’re not wearing the ring she gave you - you have to tell Myddrin about Trysha teaching you meteordon).
@@humanpunchingbag1092 man you gave me hope I thought I was beyond redemption, figuratively speaking..thanks!
@@MedievalMarty thanks for answering me anyways my friend.
@@angelosantiago6155 too easy - like I said I’m sure there might be other copies. I would presume there is 2x of each book or something like that. Also if you’re going on a plunder rampage on NPCs like I did, they actually give some items like the platinum cards for the brothel. Easy 15k gold if you sell it haha. That amongst other items, lots of curatives. It’s not all amazing though but definitely if you’re in a city go switch to thief and go crazy.
I wish he said i would need to duplicate them sooner in the damn video 😢
I only got 2 spells from Trisha and eini
Eino the old man didn’t give me Jack
I had to give him something, he didn't seem happy with what I gave him but he then gave me his item.
Can you buy the books back from vendors? I sold them 😢
yes normaly you should. (the npc where you can make the fakes. also should sell it if your dropped or sold it
I killed trysha! Help!
You can resurrect them with a wake stone if it just happened. Or you can go back to a town, go to the morgue and resurrect them there with a wakestone :)
@@MedievalMarty can't find them at the morgue and I've rested for about 7 days. The quest is completed in my log and didn't get any items
Same what do we do?!😢@@alexplayle7754
ng+
Just too much for the likes of me
well i wait for over 50 days now to trysha complet to study her books. I gave here the same one as here. I wait for 50 days + of now. She never will get it i think 😒 bugged for me i think 🤮 someone can help out with copy ? /dupe