@@siphobanda1707 music taste is subjective, he should've been a little more objective comparing himself to actual the piano players, and number 2 really? Doesn't it seem a little narcissistic, unwilling to see the talent or hardwork of others?
The fact that the blue hair guy said himself that he started playing the piano a week ago, AND STILL HAD THE BALLS to rank the other pianists last place 😭
@Mighty Allan "weren't exactly original"?? Summer the piano girl said she wrote her piano piece. The blue haired guy doesn't know how to play any instrument, was generic, but didn't have as much vocal range and clarity as the singer girl. He was the least talented.
As an ex pianist- I am shocked Summer was ranked so low. In my opinion she was number one BY FAR. Not only did she nail the piece on technique (correct notes, dynamics, hand/wrist placement, posture) but her musicality was off the charts
@@hectorg362 probably don’t practice or perform nearly as often or at all because of career change or something in like that prevents them from doing the art like moving around a lot, working a lot, school, and children. I call myself an ex classical guitar player because I don’t play anymore. I choose to work and finish my masters degree.
The piano girl was BY far the best. I’m baffled she wasn’t ranked so - as someone who has played piano for 20+ years, you can tell she’s the most experienced in her craft by far.
@@SummerSweeSingh if you are the girl on the video let me tell you that as soon as you played the first few bars I knew you would be the number one. You have clearly put a lot of time and patience to your craft... keep it up! PS: where can I listen to your original music?
no SERIOUSLY i did piano for years when I was younger and it's been a while since i've watched or heard someone play but...... it's s o obvious she was the most amazing bruh instagram wtf........
As a pianist myself I got kinda offended when the Julius ranked the both pianists last. Like, do you even understand how many hours they put in to get to that level??? Certainly not just a week..😂
@Angelic Summer here, so figured I’d weigh in. In all honesty I think part of it had to do with 1. IG was asked to vote for their “favorite musician” (different metric than we were given-I made a response video about this and other notes) and also because 2. I played original compositions and Sèdo played covers -one being a tiny clip from a famous Chopin (classical) piece called Fantasie Impromptu-both pieces he played I’ve played in the past, but I decided to stick with showcasing original music instead (the piece you heard me play is my composition “JFN” - you can hear the full piece on Spotify, TH-cam, iTunes etc. under my name). That said, there’s a recognizability factor that likely went into ranking if for those who don’t know classical piano well (aka the general population, which would include their IG following) and what is considered “high skill” level on piano is likely not as obvious to an untrained ear; not to mention, unless someone has actually practiced Fantasie Impromptu before, he/she/they probably didn’t realize what it’s *supposed* to sound like vs. what he played, which wasn’t exactly accurate to what Chopin wrote (though, again, the metric we were supposed to rank by was talent and not skill which imho is much tougher to assess unless you are singing or have discussed who has perfect pitch or perfect time which none of us discussed). FYI there’s a “full performances” video on Jubilee’s secondary channel called Twobilee that I recommend you watch (it’s linked in this videos’s description if you look for it) for a better idea of what we all heard and saw in the studio.
@@SummerSweeSingh I guess you’re qualified to weigh in seeing as you are literally the person in the video lol. You were incredible. Was there an awkward atmosphere in the room when blue hair guy ranked himself so high and everyone else ranked him so low?
Drummers and percussion i feel have a vastly different view on music in comparison to others. They believe in rhythm, just make sure the music keeps them going and they will love it. And they want to listen to more pieces to find new ways of applying rhythm. At least thats how I see it.
I’m a 14 year old grade 8 drummer and I think he went a little over the top. He should’ve played something with more articulation in my opinion. Still great nonetheless
Summer is clearly a highly trained professional musician, everything about her performance exudes confidence, musicality, technicality, originality and connection to the music. By far and away number 1 IMO. Kudos to all the performers having the guts to put themselves out there and share their love for music with the world!
SAYS THE PIANO QUEEN HERSELF *heart eyes* thank you lovely! Adore you:) And for anyone asking, I performed an original composition titled “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh) on the keys. It’s on Spotify/Apple Music etc. if you want to listen.
@@shamaravind6195 I played part of my own classical crossover composition “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh). If you’d like to check it out, it’s on all the major music listening platforms :) I also recorded a music video for it which is on my TH-cam channel that I’m commenting from; the video is titled “JFN (with Prelude)” because I wrote a string trio prelude which precedes the main piece on piano (audio for this is also out on all platforms under my name as a single release). Hope you enjoy it!
As a pianist myself, it was also clear to me that Summer was a professional. I think Sedo saw it as well. It would be interesting to hear relative rankings of each instrumentalist from closer peers (although tough call on who the close peers are for a multi-instrumentalist like Michael.)
Summer was ranked 5th according to the audience, really???? She's definitely first, her technical skill and ability to emote are both astounding. I've been playing piano for a while but am not even close to her level, she's amazing.
Audience won’t know anything about music and the blue hair guy was getting crapped on for no reason. It’s a viral moment as well as subjective ranking.
I think number one just played a better song than summer from the clip on this video. Those of us who don’t know techniques couldn’t really pick them up
Piano girl in the purple easily wins. I dunno if people know how long it takes to become that talented if they've never played piano before. Every aspect of her piece was on point.
tysm! that's so kind. I do think it's pretty tough to rank musicians across different instruments and genres though. The piano piece I played is actually an original composition of mine titled "JFN" :) [it's out on iTunes/Spotify etc. under my full name: Summer Swee-Singh]. I was classically trained for 10-11 years (but never went to conservatory / didn't major in music). However, I'm now am a composer / arranger (piano and orchestra) and I'm also a studio+touring hired gun on keys/piano.
Sadly, people have become tone deaf to quality music. Screeching “I lost my mind” has become the pinnacle of quality music to these millennials. It only take a few weeks to learn how to strum and screech. The guy in blue probably spent his whole life... 3-4hrs a day...mastering 3 different instruments. People have no clue what it takes to master an instrument.
The instagram ranking is fvck!ng outrageous, majority are literally kids that are raised by tiktok, true musicians can see in their eyes that summer was the best of em all like bruh to pull off that piece with those emotion and dynamics is truly phenomenal.
Yeah as a drummer, its kind of obvious that i prefer the other drummer over the others but Summer was legendary. Instragram raniing was a straight up lie.
Thank you for the love, Angelica! Since you’re a violinist maybe you’ll enjoy the music video I released for that piece which I composed; it is on my TH-cam channel :) it’s titled “JFN (with Prelude)” (Summer Swee-Singh) and the prelude I wrote is for string trio :) which leads into the main piece which is mainly solo piano (until the recapitulation) :) I composed it all for my husband. The audio was also released on all major music platforms like Spotify etc. back in 2017, just search “JFN with Prelude Summer Swee-Singh” to find it if you so desire :) thanks for the support!
Thank you so much! Yeah, I composed it for my husband back in 2016 and made a video for it in 2017 - video on my yt channel :) It’s on Spotify/iTunes etc. titled “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh)
@@SummerSweeSingh I’ll definitely give the full a listen! You were so amazing and I hope you blow up one day! You are an extremely talented and well rounded individual! - Percussionist
@@rehtric3681 thank you so much! One of the reasons I chose to play an original is because I wanted feedback on my composition :) so seriously really appreciate you listening to it!!! And lol, wouldn’t mind blowing up as a composer some day too :) maybe someday…
The fact that both Mary and the audience ranked Sedo as a better pianist than Summer is absolutely mind boggling to me. He wasn't bad, but between the two of them? People really can't tell the difference between *"a more skilled musician"* and *"a musician who is playing a song that I like"* 💀
@@dillpickle5987 A few people here seem to share that perspective. I'm not really a fan of using the difficulty of the piece to assess skill over the quality of the playing. _Especially_ when he didn't actually play the piece, he played 4-6 bars then messed up which is significantly less impressive. Now about the quality: Summer clearly has better coordination, better technique, more musicality, more comfort. My sister has been a pianist for over 20 years and even won a competition in her day. She played Fantaisie Impromptu in high school. So if you'd like to take it from a pianist then she sees Summer is clearly more skilled regardless of what she played. If it helps, Summer confirmed in a comment that she can play Fantaisie but decided she wouldn't once Sedo had chosen it. I haven't heard it but I would bet on it being better and more complete than Sedo's rendition. Again, he's not bad, just clearly not as skilled.
@@dillpickle5987 I have to disagree with this. It's pretty easy to play a hard piece poorly and while Sedo managing to be able to do the rhythm is impressive, only being able to play the rhythm isn't as difficult if you aren't worrying about everything else in the song (the note, dynanics, etc)
Summer is the most skilled, no question about that. She's classically trained. Anyone who says otherwise simply doesn't know anything about classical piano 😭
No hate on blue hair guy. But this was about ranking "musicians" your musical ability not vocals or song writing, reason he came last. He even said so himself he just started playing piano a week ago.
Summer was definitely number one, she played an original piece and part of being a musician is applying emotion and passion to what you play and summer’s piece was incredibly full of emotion, she was done wrong for sure I also love how Blue hair guy gets ranked last by everyone
@@maraschneider8932 hi! Summer here. My piece was an original composition titled “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh). It’s on Spotify, iTunes, TH-cam, etc. if you’d like to hear the full piece!
Thank you so much! The piece they showed me play is an original composition titled “JFN” (on Spotify/Bandcamp/iTunes etc.) under my full name (Summer Swee-Singh).
It's interesting how people on Instagram ranked Summer 5th but here most seem to agree she's the most complete package or 'talented' as a musician. The only explanation must be the Instagram audience didn't even know they were voting and simply reacted to random clips but only those that immediately grabbed their attention which would also explain how Mary ranked 1st. She's easily the most listenable in this 'raw' state combining melody and vocals.
I think what happened is that musicians or music fans were drawn here by the tittle and in instagram it was mostly fans of the channel so it was more of a "I don't like piano" instead of actually trying to rank them properly.
IG did rate sedo first though. However, I think he (perhaps accidentally) played the audience. Even played poorly, who in this day and age can really match the genius of Chopin, even though he considered the Fantasie Impromptu not worthy of publishing. Also, non-musicians are way more impressed with speed and virtuosity than musicians.
Nah, I found her very boring like another TH-cam star that can't make it big because they're too damn unoriginal. So perhaps not "easily the most" anything..
Aww, this is so kind. It’s just a bizarre social experiment, but don’t worry I’m a professional studio/touring pianist + keyboardist as well as orchestral arranger and composer and just wanted to participate in this video out of curiousity :) The original composition I performed in this video is called “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh) and it is on Bandcamp, Tidal, ITunes, Spotify, etc. Also, everyone (all musicians) was really kind in person FYI!
@@sauravraj5271 I’m Summer, I didn’t sing-I’m the pianist. I performed one of my own compositions on piano (I’m wearing a purple shirt if that helps). Mary is the singer/guitarist. There were only two of us women there, so maybe that’s why you’re confused... Also, don’t forget that the voice is also an instrument and one that I personally think she uses beautifully.
@@SummerSweeSingh Firstly thank you that you took time to read my comment and responded to it... I'm actually very bad at names... I got confused your name to mary... I wanna say that piece you played was fabulous... Maybe i'm a not a musician so that's why I didn't considered vocals as an instrument... But it's nice to to know... She was also great her voice is very much soothing... And also nice strings... But the composition you played was just Amazing...
@@annaairahala9462 I think people who aren’t musicians are more impressed with people like multi instrument guy because they don’t appreciate or understand the piece she was able to play 😭
@@SummerSweeSingh No emo concerts have done me wrong hahaha. I came up with the username when I was an angsty teen my self. I was just trying to ironically play into the stereotype that emo people are dissatisfied with everything.
The blue haired guy doesn’t understand how technique and difficulty incorporate themselves into music. He ranked the three Classical musicians at the bottom probably because their music didn’t sound exciting to him when they were actually the most technically advanced and most practiced musicians there.
Coming from a musician that plays too many instruments lol, Summer 100% should've got the win - she's clearly a classically trained professional pianist, vs some guy (blue hair), someone that plays too many instruments to play them all REALLY well, a pro drummer, a great singer and decent guitarist, and a pianist who's probably been playing seriously for only 5 years or so. Summer, the drummer, and Mary were the only real competitors imho.
I'd say the drummer was solid but he got many tells of his intermediate level. Summer was by far the best musician. The multi-instrumentalist, as you say, plays too many instruments to play them well, but I'd rate him secobd overall, and after him Mary. Sedo is tricky, I'd probably rate the drummer avove him.
So what if he was a pianist for just 5 years?!? At least he’s consistent and did well. Guess it depends on taste cause I will rank the classically trained pianist Summer as 3rd.
As a member of (classical) piano gang, I'm so confused why anyone would rank piano guy higher than piano girl. Piano girl was a pro, you can just see it by how she moved and I'm not gonna talk about how AMAZING she played. Piano guy's Fantasie Impromptu was impressive but he messed up a bit and looked kinda awkward (I get it, playing on a new piano / keyboard can be awkward). It's also funny when nobody reacts to the first piece and when he started playing lalaland everyone's like YESSSS lol I mean yeah you can prefer modern music over classical but judging by talent, piano girl wins all the way.
It really wasn’t, though. He missed an enormous amount of notes in fantasie impromptu and strangely ended it after only one phrase. I wouldn’t call that impressive.
@@sedotossou wow I didn't expect to see you here ! I'm so sorry if my comment made you feel bad in anyway. I'm judging by just what was shown (which is like 15 secs) and it's not fair. And I'm sure I wouldn't survive playing under the pressure like that lol. Please don't be discourage in any way and lets keep on practicing 40 hours a day.
💜 thanks so much! The piece I played was an original composition; if you’d like to hear the full piece (on Spotify, Bandcamp, Tidal, iTunes, TH-cam etc.) it is called “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh). There are two versions-a solo piano version (“JFN”) and a version with a string trio prelude and strings at the recapitulation of the main theme (“JFN (with Prelude)”)
As a fellow pianist, I can tell that the piano girl is more musically mature because she performs with better expression and musicality. Although technique is important, it alone is insufficient.
@@kelvinmalidom5901 hi, I’m Summer (piano girl). I played an original composition titled “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh). I wrote it for my husband. It’s on Spotify, iTunes etc. if you want to hear it in full :)
My personal ranking would be 1. Multiple instrument guy 2. Piano girl 3. Piano guy 4. Drummer guy 5. Singer and guitar girl 6. Blue haired guy So sorry, I forgot their names LOL
Summer has clearly put the most work into her craft I was STUNNED when she came in 5th from the audience rankings, but my personal ranking would be; 1. Summer 2. drummer guy 3. tie between other piano dude and multiple instruments guy 4. singer girl 5. blue haired guy
It would take me a month to learn that same drum beat as the guy you ranked #2 and I'm not even a drummer. Mary's voice, songwriting and guitar playing? That's like 10 years of work on her craft and she sounds unique and great. And you ranked her #4.
@@axel.lessio This is my personal opinion though, Summer is undeniably the most professional, and blue haired guy the least, the rest for the most part are personal opinions and tastes from people. Mary's style is just really not my vibe, she sounds like a lot of other singer- songwriters to me, her guitar playing is nothing special, and her voice doesnt do much for me. Not saying shes not musical, loads of people disagree and think shes higher up in the ranking, thats also cool lol
From these performances, here's how I would rank them. 1. Summer: no doubt she has EXCELLENT experience. I could feel the emotions in her piece and it's was disappointing see that she was robbed. She expressed lots of dynamics. Really beautiful. 2. Daniel: I love the drums, he played it pretty well. I loved it. 3. Michael: He did great but there was some minor tunes that needed tweaking. I put him 3rd just because he played two different instruments. He just needed better hand placements and a correctly tuned cello. 4. Sedo: He played great but he lacks hand placements. Didn't feel much emotions but he still did a great job. 5. Mary: she has a great voice but there's something missing. 6. Julius: he honestly needs to be humbled and he only played basic chords.
Aw, thanks for this. I composed the piece you heads me play if you’d like to hear it in full - “JFN” by Summer Swee-Singh (on TH-cam, Spotify, iTunes, Amazon Music etc)
I think this series is the clearest demonstration of the Dunning-Kruger effect I have ever seen. It might just be audacity, but I feel like sometimes we really don't know enough about something to aptly rank our own skills
Sacrilegious! Classically trained pianists all just died inside. How did the butchered Chopin beat out someone who obviously put in her 40 hours. Beautiful job @Summer Swee-Singh
You are so kind, thank you so so much! The piece I played was an original classical crossover composition called “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh) in case you want to check it out :) it’s on all major music platforms and I have a music video for it on my TH-cam channel too x
But “putting in the most work” to learn others practice is only a way to view musicality. Does creativity have any part in being a musician? Or is it simply a mathematical equation.
Not necessarily obvious, the rankings don't reflect the work they put in at all imo. The piano girl was exponentially greater than any of the other people
I'd put Sedo below the cellist tbh, but other than that I agree. It is supposed to be a rating by talent, not which you would choose to listen to in your free time.
Pianist of 18+ years here: the pianist in the purple shirt is the best musician, and she should be ranked #1 because it's obvious she's been studying music for many years. Blue haired singer songwriter is def #6 LOL he was so arrogant. The other pianist attempted to play Chopin Fantasie Impromptu but he sounded like he didn't have it learned yet nor posses the technique for it (La La Land Piece is easy)... however, that's an advanced piece so if he can actually play it he's top 2-3. I think the girl ranked #1 has an AMAZING voice, but her musical talent isn't near the level of the multi instrumentalist or the other pianists. I'd vote her #1 for "Most Likely to Blow Up on Spotify" for sure, but not most musically talented. Great vid! :)
Yeah the piano guy choked pretty hard on the descending run on fantasie impromptu, but I noticed his hands were shaking, so he was looking very nervous. I can’t imagine he would attempt that piece without being at least somewhat confident that he could pull it off, but who knows. His dynamics were non existent and it sounded like he was just smashing the pedal the whole time, but it still requires some skill to play that piece poorly.
Hey! You can check my TH-cam channel and you’ll see yes I can actually play it, on a normal piano. Plus we had only 1 attempt and we had to play for only 10 seconds for Instagram audience (that’s what they used for the ranking, not the la-la land part. Summer played something different that what was shown in the video but they didn’t include it in the final cut. It was less representative of her skills, I actually told her that right after). Long answer to say, yeah she’s definitely number #1, that’s why I ranked her myself at that spot in the video. Peace !
the multi instrumentalist played quite a few wrong notes when he was trying to play the spongebob thing lol, though his guitar playing was pretty solid imo
@@startariot5648 fair! But I’d still rank him above the girl cause she played just a few chords. Again, her voice is AMAZING and I’d prefer to listen to her sing over the multi instrumentalist any day
@@sedotossou hey brotha! Just listened to all three performances on your channel. Sounds great. If I had heard that, I’d put you in a tie with the girl actually! Your performance of the C sharp nocturne was very well done! The fantasie impromptu was definitely much better than how it got portrayed in the vid. I play mostly jazz now but played classical for 12 years (Mozart Sonata in D Major K576 was my last major piece) so I understand the frustration of playing on that Nord, it’s definitely not the same. The best keyboard I’ve played that is the closest feel to a real piano is the Korg SV2. Continued success, Sèdo!
a reduced sugar probably has more than 0 calories HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
My personal ranking: 1. Girl pianist 2. Multiple instrument dude 3. Pianist guy 4. Drummer 5. Singer 6. Blue hair dude Edit: thanks for agreeing with me guys 😋
Fell in love with Daniel the moment he started playing the drums. Also Summer was absolutely incredible, I can't believe the audience didn't place her at 1 or 2
I have fewer than 1 friend in the World. That's right. Everybody disses me for making bad videos. I think they are perfect though. Who is right? My dissers or me? Which side are you on, dear do
If we were to translate their talent into human age, the blue hair guy would be an infant, fresh out of the womb, still wet behind the ears. The next 4 would be middle age adults. Summer would be an immortal goddess that has walked the earth for 400 years. There is no comparison. Blue hair guy needs a reality check if he really believes he belongs in the same conversation as any of the others.
Hi! Summer here:) Omfg, I am gonna definitely respond your comment in my response video (hopefully out by Friday or Saturday on my channel). Pretty please can you write a bio for me the next time I need one ? 😂 Fr tho, I’m pretty stellar at self-deprecating talk, so thanks for the ego boost :)
My ranking: 1. Piano girl 2. Drummer 3. Multiple instruments 4. Piano guy 5. Guitar girl 6. Blue-haired guy Personally, don't think the ability to play multiple instruments = better talent. All about quality over quantity. And while she sang really well and the guitar playing was a vibe, I feel like the guitar playing wasn't that impressive compared to everyone else. Lastly, Instagram voting should've been blind, smh.
Wow, that's exactly what I was saying for the ratings. It was supposed to be rated by talent but it's clear they were not doing that. Summer/piano girl was clearly the most talented there yet she got rated so low. And likewise, while Mary was entertaining, it was still pretty basic and doesn't require the same level of talent as the other instruments. The one I would be willing to move around is the drummer just because I'm not familiar with what's considered talented in drumming, for all I know what he played could have been super easy or more talented than everyone else
@@annaairahala9462 Yeah for sure, I think her voice showed that she has the foundations of vocal talent, but if we're talking difficulty and complexity, she didn't showcase anything spectacular.
I got the same answer. I'd personally put the multi instrument guy first. Its like having someone fluent in 2 languages, and having someone as a poliglot. At a1 standard.
Summer was by far the most talented musician in that room. There is a difference between enjoyability and talent. Daniel was amazing at drums, i have heard better, but he was great. Michael knows how an instrument with strings work, so he might have figured out how to play the cello by himself. Sedo was a great pianist, but he was outshined by Summer, Daniel and Michael. Mary had a great voice but her guitartalent was not amazing, she even fucked up right here 3:02 Julius can burn.
Ole dude wasn't even a pianist, picked up the instrument a week ago, played basic chords anyone can play (with improper finger positions), AND had the audacity to rank himself higher than the REAL pianists ?!
I'd move the drummer down 2 or 3 personally. It's flashy, but as another drum player I'm not sure if it would even be considered advanced, probably high intermediate
Summer is easily #1 overall...can't believe she didn't make it on top for either vote She showed a level of mastery far beyond what everyone else showed, amazed how other people didn't see that
It's kind of upsetting to me how impressed everyone was acting about Mary's performance. Cant help but wonder if their ranking of her had something to do with something other than her skills. 🤔
Not trying to bash anyone, but it was so obvious that the 2 pianists were the most talented in my opinion, so I was so confused when they got ranked pretty low in my opinion.
the piano girl was amazing and you could actually hear that she has a lot of experience especially since she made that piece herself. I could hear that the piano boy was really nervous in his playing, you can actually see his hands shaking. The first piece that he played is my favourite piece of all time so i could immediately hear that it was really messy but I think it was just the nerves. The second piece he played was really great!
@@milabosse9859 nerves definitely. Sorry I butchered your favorite song :( on my TH-cam channel I uploaded a longer version of my interpretation of Fantaisie-impromptu that I believe is way better that what I’ve done in this video.
SAME. And the girl singer getting ranked number 1 confused me a lot. She was great and she seems so nice but there were a lot of people who played their instruments better than her. She played really simple chords on guitar and it felt really similar to blue hair guys performance, but a bit more humble.
Thanks so much for having me, Jubilee team!! Shoutouts also to Mary, Michael, Sèdo, Daniel, and Julius :) y’all were some real ones! And since some people are asking, the piece I played was an original composition called "JFN". It's on iTunes/Spotify/Tidal/Bandcamp under my name full name (Summer Swee-Singh).
I agree , there should have been someone that is impartial to the different genres of music. Everyone was crazy about Mary and I see that she has talent but I hate the style of today's music.
Thank you so much Jubilee for having me (again haha)! Much love to the audience that ranked me 1. Shoutout to all the other artists who rocked! Peace to everybody 💛
Aw tysm, you’re too kind 🥺🙏🏽🤍 I def was feeling it though as that was an original composition I wrote for my husband which I titled “JFN” (full song is out on Spotify/bandcamp/iTunes under my name: Summer Swee-Singh)
as a classical pianist who has studied under a multitude of university professors for over a decade, i'd rank: 1. Summer (pianist in purple) 2. Daniel (drummer) 3. Mary (singer) 4. Michael (multiple instruments) 5. Sedo (pianist) 6. Julius (blue-haired guy) what stood out to me and the defining point of how i ranked these musicians was the use of nuanced expression and mature dynamics, which the top 3 demonstrated thoroughly. Michael's performance was enjoyable and was a close third, but ultimately Mary's artistic tone and style captured my attention slightly more (plus, i value quality over quantity, though that's a personal preference). imo, Sedo and Julius's performances lacked the technicality and dynamics that the others had, but they definitely weren't bad - just some more diligent practice and they'll be right there.
Classical guitarist here, Mary is very new to guitar, her singing is great but lyrics weren't that complicated, not that that's important, there just wasn't a lot of skill shown. So I'd definately put her 5, after the arrogant blue hair guy
I had the fortune to play with world-class drummers and I can guarantee you that none of them would think Daniel has a "use of nuanced expression and mature dynamics". He just showed off random chops.
First one I've agreed with. Sedu is held way too high. He needs to learn his limits, because he's clearly not ready for Chopin. I've a sneaking suspicion that people only voted for him because he played the score of their favourite movie.
Since everyone is doing this, here's my ranking: 1. Summer (Piano Girl) 2. Sédo (Piano Guy) 3. Daniel (Drummer Guy) 4. Michael (Multi-instrumentalist) Impressive and versatile, but not particularly exceptional in any of those instruments. Case of knowing a bit of everything. 5. Mary (singer/songwriter) 6. Julius (blue-haired guy)
My ranking 1)Summer: Definitely has a musical background and has a great sense of dynamics. 2)Daniel: Love the rhythms and the decrescendo. 3)Mary: Beautiful voice and great control over her voice. 4)Michael: Although has played 2 instruments, the cello was out of tune and could have better phrasing. 5)Sedo: Chose a difficult piece for his level. Has were a bit too flat, too much pedal and note were uneven in dynamics and length. 6)Julius: Not much musical technique. Used a basic chord progression. If he went for piano classes or practised a bit more then he could get better. This is my opinion, dont bash me if u disagree with my ranking. P.s. just because u can play multiple instruments doesn't necessarily mean you are a great musician. It definately takes time, skill, practice and a certain type of mentality to be able to master your instrument at a very high level.
As a drummer, I'm not impressed by Daniel. He's going wild which is cool but his tone quality and time aren't great. Reminds me of the metal drummers at the middle school battle of the bands. Still goes above Julius, but definitely bottom half.
How did sedo win?! The piano girl was so much better, from my perspective as a pianist. Her technique was on point, her pacing was better, the tone, I could go on. Sedo proceeded to play only a few lines of a well known piece and mess up at the end, yet Instagram probably only voted him better because of the piece he played.
cause it’s instagram and they don’t actually care about the skill they just voted for what piece they liked the most definitely. they liked sedo cause he played a la la land song, it was recognisable, and the other people had more charisma which made them more likeable to the audience. half of the people viewing in instagram have no musical experience so they wouldn’t get how amazing summer is
Being able to play multiple instruments decently doesn’t mean you’re better than someone who has mastered a single instrument. idk why everyone keeps ranking Michael first lol he’s decent on guitar, average on cello and was completely out of tune on the lap steel. I’d rank him more in the middle, but behind piano girl and drum guy at the very least. I once had a music director tell a fellow musician who was trying to learn every instrument that nobody wants someone who’s average on multiple instruments. It’s better to be outstanding and master one instrument first.
I thought the exact same thing, it really bothered me his cello and lap steel, I thought he was terrible in them, completely out of tune in the last one.
Yeah I’m not sure if it was his nerves or what but the lap steel was not in tune, and his cello playing would sound great to someone who hasn’t played in an orchestra, but as someone who has played, it was average. His versatility is impressive but I don’t think that’s what makes a great musician.
OK, I had to stop the video half way for this... This is nearly impossible to rank. I gotta try: Blue hair has some serious heart, and you have to love it. Navy button down, I'd go to his show after that Fleetwood piece. Hawaiian shirt, I'd want him to drum for my indie rock band. Curly hair girl absolutely set herself apart with that voice, but I don't think it's entirely fair to rank her higher or lower than the pianists. They all impressed me, and are great in their own ways. On shear talent: 1) Girl in purple shirt (pianist)- Her performance was gushing passion and emotion. High skill-level. 2) Girl w/ curly hair (singer/songwriter)- Her voice gave me chills, it was heavenly. Someone you'd like to write with. 3) Guy in beige outfit (pianist)- He is undoubtedly classically trained and has the dynamic touch. 4) Guy in navy button-down (multi-instrumentalist)- He's the guy you wanna start a band with because of his versatility. 5) Drummer- He's bringing the ruckus, I'd love to crank the distortion on some humbuckers beside this guy. 6) Guy w/ blue hair (singer/songwriter)- Touched my heart. Impressive despite being new at his instrument. Madd potential. Keep writing!
@@anoob6311 saying Sedo "has no idea how to play piano" is incredibly harsh and undermining. Did you factor in that it's a 10 sec snipped which he may have been nervous to play, knowing that it's being broadcasted? His talent is clear to see in his TH-cam videos. You can state your opinion without being objectively inaccurate and cruelly judgmental.
It's obvious that people who don't know music like in a profesional way had picked the song which they have played or sung... but the best musician is clearly Summer✌😊
From the perspective of 10 years of lessons in classical piano, I think Summer easily had the best technique of the 3 pianists (she was the only one to use her whole body to play, and I saw little to no wrist or arm movement from the others). I think Daniel maybe had the next highest degree of technical proficiency. I have a really hard time judging vocals with accompaniment, since it's kinda like playing two instruments at once, so perhaps Mary is better than my first impression. I'd probably rank Michael after Mary, but I honestly didn't get to see enough to get an accurate measurement of his ability. Sedo came off to me as a student who has studied classically for quite a few years, and Julius came off to me as a self-taught musician.
@@SummerSweeSingh Summer, you absolutely killed it. I don't need to be part of the "piano gang' (though I wish I was) to appreciate your talent. With only three years of middle school band (tenor saxophone and clarinet!), it was obvious to me that you have a mastery of the piano. I really appreciated your performance. You're a great artist that should be recognized as so
Mary has a beautiful voice and she also knows how to use it but, Summer is at another level, that girl is wonderful. Julius giving himself a 2 and summer a 5 was hilarious.😂😂😂
I think Summer should have been first, and Daniel second. You can tell they have both put so much time and effort into their music, and that they really understand their instruments on a really intrinsic level.
The purple girl was the second best, you could hear her experience and dynamics, wear as the seto guy was abit stiff, though he was nervous and shaking. In modern day music the Afro girl wins, I’m not much of a fan of singing but she sounds the most professional to me. The guitarist was great at guitar, I wish we had heard more of him playing guitar as his other instruments Wernt as strong.
@@nicholaso4302 not racist, definitely was a descriptive word. Where you should be upset is that so many women don’t wear their Afros because they think it reflects politics. So she stands out
Julius got balls going there with his own song and playing the keyboard in front of experienced musicians. They're all goated I vibed with the drums the most myself. Also Yann tiersen played well and such a touching piece.
As a drummer who's been playing for years,I cringed a bit when he started smashing the drums as hard as he could with so much echo in the room. In situations like this always go for smooth and groovy stuff
THIS! Cringed hard when he just started bashing the drums and playing as fast as he could. When the guitar singer girl said “you played in like 20 different time signatures” I burst out laughing because, even though she meant it as a compliment, he didn’t do that on purpose and it was just cause he wanted to show off his “chops” and played as fast and messy as he could😆
Blue haired guy really ranked the piano players last yet only showcased himself playing starter chords. Okay.
It wasn't his kind of music....I would have put them last too
I was thinking the same thing lmao like what
@@siphobanda1707 music taste is subjective, he should've been a little more objective comparing himself to actual the piano players, and number 2 really? Doesn't it seem a little narcissistic, unwilling to see the talent or hardwork of others?
"Blue haired"
People like this aren't really the type you should listen to.
i knew y’all were gonna roast him 😭😭😭
The fact that the blue hair guy said himself that he started playing the piano a week ago, AND STILL HAD THE BALLS to rank the other pianists last place 😭
He looked like he’d been slapped in the face after *everyone else* ranked him last… including IG.
I think he ranked them last, since their songs weren’t exactly original, and he wrote his own song, that he was probably proud of.
@Mighty Allan "weren't exactly original"?? Summer the piano girl said she wrote her piano piece. The blue haired guy doesn't know how to play any instrument, was generic, but didn't have as much vocal range and clarity as the singer girl. He was the least talented.
Seriously wtf was that???
Dunning-Kruger on display
Dude picked up the piano last week and puts himself above everyone except drummer boy. You can tell he was itching to put himself number 1 too
he rly needs to humble himself.
yea, and when he got ranked last by everyone you can see him get more and more mad, his expression at the end was scary even.
it's more the misinterpretation of his enthusiasm in his mind that happens with inexperience imo
As an ex pianist- I am shocked Summer was ranked so low. In my opinion she was number one BY FAR. Not only did she nail the piece on technique (correct notes, dynamics, hand/wrist placement, posture) but her musicality was off the charts
Yeah, I think a lot of people misinterpreted the intentional chaos of the piece as messy, but I definitely would have ranked her first too
Why do you consider yourself an ex pianst? :/
the drummer surprised me tbh, he was way to low
@@hectorg362 probably don’t practice or perform nearly as often or at all because of career change or something in like that prevents them from doing the art like moving around a lot, working a lot, school, and children. I call myself an ex classical guitar player because I don’t play anymore. I choose to work and finish my masters degree.
hand/wrist placement is irrelevant...
The piano girl was BY far the best. I’m baffled she wasn’t ranked so - as someone who has played piano for 20+ years, you can tell she’s the most experienced in her craft by far.
@@SummerSweeSingh do you have that piece in its entirety posted
@@evanswasabi it’s called JFN by Summer Swee-Singh because she composed it. i love it sm
@@SummerSweeSingh if you are the girl on the video let me tell you that as soon as you played the first few bars I knew you would be the number one. You have clearly put a lot of time and patience to your craft... keep it up!
PS: where can I listen to your original music?
no SERIOUSLY i did piano for years when I was younger and it's been a while since i've watched or heard someone play but...... it's s o obvious she was the most amazing bruh instagram wtf........
@@SummerSweeSingh do you practice 40 hours a day?
The blue haired guy really ranked himself high just to get ranked at the bottom by all of them 😭😭
He ranked backwards with the same intention
He was easily the weakest there
And in the mean time you have less talent than your cat😂😂
@@mrkhoros than your can?
Baffled by the drums at no. 1 too, haha. No offence to the drum guy.
As a pianist myself I got kinda offended when the Julius ranked the both pianists last. Like, do you even understand how many hours they put in to get to that level??? Certainly not just a week..😂
especially when he couldn't play piano, sing or write anywhere near a decent song himself 💀
I knowww like he didn’t even realise how talented they were!
West vurginia
Piano is quit eazy to get the basics but like there doing is realy hard if i chose they would be above blue haired guy and guitar singer girl
What they played sucked tbh
Coming from someone who’s learned piano for about 8 years, Summer’s skills are amazing!! It’s disappointing she was ranked so low
Because conformists prefer average singers over skilled instrumentalist. That's why mary got a really high ranking.
@Angelic Summer here, so figured I’d weigh in.
In all honesty I think part of it had to do with 1. IG was asked to vote for their “favorite musician” (different metric than we were given-I made a response video about this and other notes) and also because 2. I played original compositions and Sèdo played covers -one being a tiny clip from a famous Chopin (classical) piece called Fantasie Impromptu-both pieces he played I’ve played in the past, but I decided to stick with showcasing original music instead (the piece you heard me play is my composition “JFN” - you can hear the full piece on Spotify, TH-cam, iTunes etc. under my name). That said, there’s a recognizability factor that likely went into ranking if for those who don’t know classical piano well (aka the general population, which would include their IG following) and what is considered “high skill” level on piano is likely not as obvious to an untrained ear; not to mention, unless someone has actually practiced Fantasie Impromptu before, he/she/they probably didn’t realize what it’s *supposed* to sound like vs. what he played, which wasn’t exactly accurate to what Chopin wrote (though, again, the metric we were supposed to rank by was talent and not skill which imho is much tougher to assess unless you are singing or have discussed who has perfect pitch or perfect time which none of us discussed).
FYI there’s a “full performances” video on Jubilee’s secondary channel called Twobilee that I recommend you watch (it’s linked in this videos’s description if you look for it) for a better idea of what we all heard and saw in the studio.
@@SummerSweeSingh I guess you’re qualified to weigh in seeing as you are literally the person in the video lol. You were incredible. Was there an awkward atmosphere in the room when blue hair guy ranked himself so high and everyone else ranked him so low?
None had the gut to give a low rank to Mary so she ended up being at the top
what we’re the pieces that her and the guy just before initially played?
The drummer seems like the type who would listen to any and every recommendation you throw at him, no matter the genre or time period. I respect that.
Check out buddha trixie
Drummers and percussion i feel have a vastly different view on music in comparison to others. They believe in rhythm, just make sure the music keeps them going and they will love it. And they want to listen to more pieces to find new ways of applying rhythm. At least thats how I see it.
I’m a 14 year old grade 8 drummer and I think he went a little over the top. He should’ve played something with more articulation in my opinion. Still great nonetheless
Yup
Yup
He played piano like a second grader and rated himself second
😂😂
🤣
I really dont get how he could put himself there like CLEARLY he can see atleast 3 people there are better than him if not all 5
LMFAOOOOO
Omgg
Summer is clearly a highly trained professional musician, everything about her performance exudes confidence, musicality, technicality, originality and connection to the music. By far and away number 1 IMO. Kudos to all the performers having the guts to put themselves out there and share their love for music with the world!
SAYS THE PIANO QUEEN HERSELF *heart eyes* thank you lovely! Adore you:)
And for anyone asking, I performed an original composition titled “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh) on the keys. It’s on Spotify/Apple Music etc. if you want to listen.
@@SummerSweeSingh this is the type of support between 2 piano playing baddies that I love to see 😍🥺
What did she play????
@@shamaravind6195 I played part of my own classical crossover composition “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh). If you’d like to check it out, it’s on all the major music listening platforms :) I also recorded a music video for it which is on my TH-cam channel that I’m commenting from; the video is titled “JFN (with Prelude)” because I wrote a string trio prelude which precedes the main piece on piano (audio for this is also out on all platforms under my name as a single release). Hope you enjoy it!
As a pianist myself, it was also clear to me that Summer was a professional. I think Sedo saw it as well. It would be interesting to hear relative rankings of each instrumentalist from closer peers (although tough call on who the close peers are for a multi-instrumentalist like Michael.)
Summer was ranked 5th according to the audience, really???? She's definitely first, her technical skill and ability to emote are both astounding. I've been playing piano for a while but am not even close to her level, she's amazing.
Audience won’t know anything about music and the blue hair guy was getting crapped on for no reason. It’s a viral moment as well as subjective ranking.
@@baboon_baboon_baboonbro he was playing piano for a week and was clearly the weakest singer, there was definitely a reason
@@rohanbaste-bania6227that’s his alt account
I think number one just played a better song than summer from the clip on this video. Those of us who don’t know techniques couldn’t really pick them up
summer took first
julius was absolutely humbled to the highest degree
He needed it, how he rated Summer last was crazy.
Piano girl in the purple easily wins. I dunno if people know how long it takes to become that talented if they've never played piano before. Every aspect of her piece was on point.
tysm! that's so kind. I do think it's pretty tough to rank musicians across different instruments and genres though.
The piano piece I played is actually an original composition of mine titled "JFN" :) [it's out on iTunes/Spotify etc. under my full name: Summer Swee-Singh]. I was classically trained for 10-11 years (but never went to conservatory / didn't major in music). However, I'm now am a composer / arranger (piano and orchestra) and I'm also a studio+touring hired gun on keys/piano.
@@SummerSweeSingh Thats sick, Im a pianist too and you were easily the best.
Ye honestly. The only reason the piano guy won is cos people knew la la land
fr
Dor real!
You don't even have to be classically trained to see that the purple pianist was the best by far, her musicality was much higher than all the others
Don’t know about that
@@virtuesuzuya582 right? The other girl & the black dude were super badass
This is fact right here! She was absolutely amazing! The emotion, dynamic, and technique were all phenomenal!
I’ve never played any instrument before but even I could tell straight away that she was far more talented by the way she moved and help herself
Sadly, people have become tone deaf to quality music. Screeching “I lost my mind” has become the pinnacle of quality music to these millennials. It only take a few weeks to learn how to strum and screech. The guy in blue probably spent his whole life... 3-4hrs a day...mastering 3 different instruments. People have no clue what it takes to master an instrument.
The instagram ranking is fvck!ng outrageous, majority are literally kids that are raised by tiktok, true musicians can see in their eyes that summer was the best of em all like bruh to pull off that piece with those emotion and dynamics is truly phenomenal.
🤓
No i agree and im not a musician but you can just tell
Yeah as a drummer, its kind of obvious that i prefer the other drummer over the others but Summer was legendary. Instragram raniing was a straight up lie.
Just go based off of an oppression rating lol. You can use this with basically all competition shows on jubilee👍🏽
Summer, you were CLEARLY #1, through my eyes as a classically trained violinist. I was appalled at the audience rating!!
Thank you for the love, Angelica! Since you’re a violinist maybe you’ll enjoy the music video I released for that piece which I composed; it is on my TH-cam channel :) it’s titled “JFN (with Prelude)” (Summer Swee-Singh) and the prelude I wrote is for string trio :) which leads into the main piece which is mainly solo piano (until the recapitulation) :) I composed it all for my husband. The audio was also released on all major music platforms like Spotify etc. back in 2017, just search “JFN with Prelude Summer Swee-Singh” to find it if you so desire :) thanks for the support!
@@SummerSweeSingh OH MY GOSH ITS YOU!
Ooh gosh guess what! Next year I’m playing violin in Carnegie hall!
@@kadenpile-riley2170 haha it me!
@@Sanchlingernon that’s amazing! Wow! Congratulations 🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽 TwoSet would be proud too I’m sure! :)
dude. Summer’s performance was an ORIGINAL. I got chills.
Thank you so much! Yeah, I composed it for my husband back in 2016 and made a video for it in 2017 - video on my yt channel :) It’s on Spotify/iTunes etc. titled “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh)
@@SummerSweeSingh I’ll definitely give the full a listen! You were so amazing and I hope you blow up one day! You are an extremely talented and well rounded individual! - Percussionist
@@SummerSweeSingh Very cool! Wonderful playing.
@@rehtric3681 thank you so much! One of the reasons I chose to play an original is because I wanted feedback on my composition :) so seriously really appreciate you listening to it!!! And lol, wouldn’t mind blowing up as a composer some day too :) maybe someday…
@@johnnymoore5915 thank you so much :) really appreciate it!
The fact that both Mary and the audience ranked Sedo as a better pianist than Summer is absolutely mind boggling to me. He wasn't bad, but between the two of them? People really can't tell the difference between *"a more skilled musician"* and *"a musician who is playing a song that I like"* 💀
Literally I was shocked I still am
@@dillpickle5987 A few people here seem to share that perspective. I'm not really a fan of using the difficulty of the piece to assess skill over the quality of the playing. _Especially_ when he didn't actually play the piece, he played 4-6 bars then messed up which is significantly less impressive. Now about the quality: Summer clearly has better coordination, better technique, more musicality, more comfort. My sister has been a pianist for over 20 years and even won a competition in her day. She played Fantaisie Impromptu in high school. So if you'd like to take it from a pianist then she sees Summer is clearly more skilled regardless of what she played. If it helps, Summer confirmed in a comment that she can play Fantaisie but decided she wouldn't once Sedo had chosen it. I haven't heard it but I would bet on it being better and more complete than Sedo's rendition. Again, he's not bad, just clearly not as skilled.
@@dillpickle5987 No, he played a piece that he's not ready for.
@@dillpickle5987 I have to disagree with this. It's pretty easy to play a hard piece poorly and while Sedo managing to be able to do the rhythm is impressive, only being able to play the rhythm isn't as difficult if you aren't worrying about everything else in the song (the note, dynanics, etc)
Maybe I'm being unfair to the Jubilee followers, but in this case I think it might even have been "he played faster, which must mean he's better".
Summer is the most skilled, no question about that. She's classically trained. Anyone who says otherwise simply doesn't know anything about classical piano 😭
But i dont understand why they vote mary higher than that guy with navy shirt
The piano players are solid. As a classic singer I have to say playing an instrument is HARD
🤍 thank you!
@@SummerSweeSingh You were fantastic!!!! I'm a pianist and I was blown away by your piece, it was beautiful!!
@@samuelsteiner3854 tysm 💜
i have a sneaking suspicion that piano girl just knows that she’s better than everyone
I know right? She knows for sure but is nice
Anybody that plays that well isn't gonna be mean haha, she slayed it
she is tho lol
Uhm you cant say shes the best because they’re playing different instruments.
@@Someoneisinmyhead just my opinion lol. as a musician, i realize that the level shes playing at is really high, which is why i think she’s the best.
No hate on blue hair guy. But this was about ranking "musicians" your musical ability not vocals or song writing, reason he came last. He even said so himself he just started playing piano a week ago.
How are vocals and songwriting supposedly not a part of musical ability?
voice is literally considered an instrument lol
vocals definitely count, his vocals were just lacking tbh
@@tal3393 he still sucked lol
@@cakedup757 I legitimately skipped through his part but it's still an instrument
Summer was definitely number one, she played an original piece and part of being a musician is applying emotion and passion to what you play and summer’s piece was incredibly full of emotion, she was done wrong for sure
I also love how Blue hair guy gets ranked last by everyone
🤍
hi, do you know what summer's piece was called??
@@maraschneider8932 hi! Summer here. My piece was an original composition titled “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh). It’s on Spotify, iTunes, TH-cam, etc. if you’d like to hear the full piece!
@@SummerSweeSingh Ok, knowing that's an original composition, you are #1 BY FAR
Purple shirt girl you're a #1. I was so immersed in matter of seconds and the peace you transmit when you play is beautiful.
Thank you so much! The piece they showed me play is an original composition titled “JFN” (on Spotify/Bandcamp/iTunes etc.) under my full name (Summer Swee-Singh).
shes so epic
@@onemillionpercent 🥺🤍🙏🏽 ty!
@@SummerSweeSingh no problem it's true!! omg i am definitely going to add your composition to my playlist now
It's interesting how people on Instagram ranked Summer 5th but here most seem to agree she's the most complete package or 'talented' as a musician. The only explanation must be the Instagram audience didn't even know they were voting and simply reacted to random clips but only those that immediately grabbed their attention which would also explain how Mary ranked 1st. She's easily the most listenable in this 'raw' state combining melody and vocals.
I think what happened is that musicians or music fans were drawn here by the tittle and in instagram it was mostly fans of the channel so it was more of a "I don't like piano" instead of actually trying to rank them properly.
@@mugen012 Entirely possible. Probably, there's a number of factors, honestly.
IG did rate sedo first though. However, I think he (perhaps accidentally) played the audience. Even played poorly, who in this day and age can really match the genius of Chopin, even though he considered the Fantasie Impromptu not worthy of publishing. Also, non-musicians are way more impressed with speed and virtuosity than musicians.
Nah, I found her very boring like another TH-cam star that can't make it big because they're too damn unoriginal. So perhaps not "easily the most" anything..
Instagram is full of idiots.
Summer was 100% robbed from being #1. She was literally the best out of all of them in my opinion.
Aww, this is so kind. It’s just a bizarre social experiment, but don’t worry I’m a professional studio/touring pianist + keyboardist as well as orchestral arranger and composer and just wanted to participate in this video out of curiousity :) The original composition I performed in this video is called “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh) and it is on Bandcamp, Tidal, ITunes, Spotify, etc.
Also, everyone (all musicians) was really kind in person FYI!
She sings well but the title says ranking musicians...
@@sauravraj5271 I’m Summer, I didn’t sing-I’m the pianist. I performed one of my own compositions on piano (I’m wearing a purple shirt if that helps). Mary is the singer/guitarist. There were only two of us women there, so maybe that’s why you’re confused... Also, don’t forget that the voice is also an instrument and one that I personally think she uses beautifully.
@@SummerSweeSingh Firstly thank you that you took time to read my comment and responded to it... I'm actually very bad at names... I got confused your name to mary... I wanna say that piece you played was fabulous... Maybe i'm a not a musician so that's why I didn't considered vocals as an instrument... But it's nice to to know... She was also great her voice is very much soothing... And also nice strings... But the composition you played was just Amazing...
@@SummerSweeSingh Congratulations on your playing. Your musicality is what every musician should strive for.
seeing julius get humbled so hard was so satisfying
Purple shirt deserved to win in every ranking scenario.
ikr?? So confused how she got so low
absolutely
For sure.
@@annaairahala9462 I think people who aren’t musicians are more impressed with people like multi instrument guy because they don’t appreciate or understand the piece she was able to play 😭
i just found out she composed it herself like wtf it’s called JFN by Summer Swee-Singh
Much respect to all the musicians, there is a lot of talent here, but DAMN Summer got robbed by the audience score. Clearly a master of her craft.
💜💜💜 really appreciate this xx
Also the younger emo child within me wants to know what concert you went to that did you wrong lol
@@SummerSweeSingh No emo concerts have done me wrong hahaha. I came up with the username when I was an angsty teen my self. I was just trying to ironically play into the stereotype that emo people are dissatisfied with everything.
@@doogbazzard LOL I love it
The blue haired guy doesn’t understand how technique and difficulty incorporate themselves into music. He ranked the three Classical musicians at the bottom probably because their music didn’t sound exciting to him when they were actually the most technically advanced and most practiced musicians there.
I love how the blue hair guy ranked the other pianists at the bottom. He felt personally attacked by them.
Coming from a musician that plays too many instruments lol, Summer 100% should've got the win - she's clearly a classically trained professional pianist, vs some guy (blue hair), someone that plays too many instruments to play them all REALLY well, a pro drummer, a great singer and decent guitarist, and a pianist who's probably been playing seriously for only 5 years or so. Summer, the drummer, and Mary were the only real competitors imho.
I'd say the drummer was solid but he got many tells of his intermediate level. Summer was by far the best musician. The multi-instrumentalist, as you say, plays too many instruments to play them well, but I'd rate him secobd overall, and after him Mary. Sedo is tricky, I'd probably rate the drummer avove him.
To be fair, the multiple instrument guy did a pretty tough guitar song, but I agree for the other instruments
That's what I was thinking
@Krz Low right but when judged against people who are dedicated to a single one, you generally cannot keep up.
So what if he was a pianist for just 5 years?!? At least he’s consistent and did well. Guess it depends on taste cause I will rank the classically trained pianist Summer as 3rd.
As a member of (classical) piano gang, I'm so confused why anyone would rank piano guy higher than piano girl. Piano girl was a pro, you can just see it by how she moved and I'm not gonna talk about how AMAZING she played. Piano guy's Fantasie Impromptu was impressive but he messed up a bit and looked kinda awkward (I get it, playing on a new piano / keyboard can be awkward). It's also funny when nobody reacts to the first piece and when he started playing lalaland everyone's like YESSSS lol
I mean yeah you can prefer modern music over classical but judging by talent, piano girl wins all the way.
I’m the piano guy in the video. I agree 100% with your comment.
@@sedotossou Love your humbleness
It really wasn’t, though. He missed an enormous amount of notes in fantasie impromptu and strangely ended it after only one phrase. I wouldn’t call that impressive.
@@sedotossou you were amazing i personally prefer your song
@@sedotossou wow I didn't expect to see you here ! I'm so sorry if my comment made you feel bad in anyway. I'm judging by just what was shown (which is like 15 secs) and it's not fair. And I'm sure I wouldn't survive playing under the pressure like that lol. Please don't be discourage in any way and lets keep on practicing 40 hours a day.
Most impressive part? Summer actually knowing that everyone’s name wasn’t “you!” Bravissimo!!
Ikr
Summer's playing was so beautiful. There was no competition, it was her, long break, and the rest of them
💜 thanks so much! The piece I played was an original composition; if you’d like to hear the full piece (on Spotify, Bandcamp, Tidal, iTunes, TH-cam etc.) it is called “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh). There are two versions-a solo piano version (“JFN”) and a version with a string trio prelude and strings at the recapitulation of the main theme (“JFN (with Prelude)”)
You're genuinely the best one in this video Summer! I wanna listen to more of your music! It's awesome
Ok, but this would be really interesting with musicians who all graduated from a conservatory
PLEASE
Watch out for when two set violin does their own version of this.
@@natyinthehouse hahaha
YES LOL
@@natyinthehouse it’s already in the works 😂
As a fellow pianist, I can tell that the piano girl is more musically mature because she performs with better expression and musicality. Although technique is important, it alone is insufficient.
I mean we got to see like 10 seconds lol
@@mattlikespandas7019 the full 2 minute segment for each musician is up on Twobilee… (it’s linked in this video’s description).
What song did the piano girl play?
@@kelvinmalidom5901 hi, I’m Summer (piano girl). I played an original composition titled “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh). I wrote it for my husband. It’s on Spotify, iTunes etc. if you want to hear it in full :)
@@SummerSweeSingh omg so sorry for calling you "piano girl" 😭 I absolutely love your piece!
My personal ranking would be
1. Multiple instrument guy
2. Piano girl
3. Piano guy
4. Drummer guy
5. Singer and guitar girl
6. Blue haired guy
So sorry, I forgot their names LOL
Same
nailed it
EXACTLY my thoughts
This is the correct answer
I feel like Sedo (piano guy) could've shown more of his skill but was nervous. But from what he did show he's very talented.
NGL, instagram was smoking crack that day lol
Summer has clearly put the most work into her craft I was STUNNED when she came in 5th from the audience rankings, but my personal ranking would be;
1. Summer
2. drummer guy
3. tie between other piano dude and multiple instruments guy
4. singer girl
5. blue haired guy
This the true ranking fam
I would rank it 100% the same.
Best ranking
It would take me a month to learn that same drum beat as the guy you ranked #2 and I'm not even a drummer. Mary's voice, songwriting and guitar playing? That's like 10 years of work on her craft and she sounds unique and great. And you ranked her #4.
@@axel.lessio This is my personal opinion though, Summer is undeniably the most professional, and blue haired guy the least, the rest for the most part are personal opinions and tastes from people. Mary's style is just really not my vibe, she sounds like a lot of other singer- songwriters to me, her guitar playing is nothing special, and her voice doesnt do much for me. Not saying shes not musical, loads of people disagree and think shes higher up in the ranking, thats also cool lol
From these performances, here's how I would rank them.
1. Summer: no doubt she has EXCELLENT experience. I could feel the emotions in her piece and it's was disappointing see that she was robbed. She expressed lots of dynamics. Really beautiful.
2. Daniel: I love the drums, he played it pretty well. I loved it.
3. Michael: He did great but there was some minor tunes that needed tweaking. I put him 3rd just because he played two different instruments. He just needed better hand placements and a correctly tuned cello.
4. Sedo: He played great but he lacks hand placements. Didn't feel much emotions but he still did a great job.
5. Mary: she has a great voice but there's something missing.
6. Julius: he honestly needs to be humbled and he only played basic chords.
Aw, thanks for this. I composed the piece you heads me play if you’d like to hear it in full - “JFN” by Summer Swee-Singh (on TH-cam, Spotify, iTunes, Amazon Music etc)
Exactly my thoughts
julius's performance was so bad - just basic chords with a cringe song sung by a not even decent singing voice. why is he even in this video 😭
Y'all really over here acting like someone playing on 2 different instruments can't do both well, which is completely false
this is the best ranking ive seen
my rankings:
1. piano girl
2. piano guy
3. drummer
4. multi instruments guy
5. girl singer
6. blue haired guy
This person gets it!
Based
Yes! I think i might put switch 2 and 3, the drummer was underrated in this group but yes to the rest
Finally someone that i can agree with
piano guy isnt that great. I'd put him 3rd and put the drummer 2nd.
I think this series is the clearest demonstration of the Dunning-Kruger effect I have ever seen. It might just be audacity, but I feel like sometimes we really don't know enough about something to aptly rank our own skills
Sacrilegious! Classically trained pianists all just died inside. How did the butchered Chopin beat out someone who obviously put in her 40 hours. Beautiful job @Summer Swee-Singh
:0 tWOSET HECC YES
You are so kind, thank you so so much! The piece I played was an original classical crossover composition called “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh) in case you want to check it out :) it’s on all major music platforms and I have a music video for it on my TH-cam channel too x
@@SummerSweeSingh you were the most talented hands down
It only takes 40 hours to learn piano?
I guess I only have 280 to go.
@@sawyerbass4661 40 hours a day. Watch TwoSet to understand
Do this with professionally trained or college degree musicians! It's very obvious who has put in the most work here... Interesting rankings.
It is pretty obvious when you know what to look for, these ratings were unfortunately not representative of who put in the most work
that would be cool! they dont seem to repeat specific topics like this much but i wouldnt mind seeing another musician video :)
But “putting in the most work” to learn others practice is only a way to view musicality. Does creativity have any part in being a musician? Or is it simply a mathematical equation.
Not necessarily obvious, the rankings don't reflect the work they put in at all imo. The piano girl was exponentially greater than any of the other people
What would your ranking be ?
I’m sorry but the two piano players and the drummer are easily the most. The singers were kinda generic
Does anyone know the name of the piano pieces?
@@tj03297 The first one is from La la land, though I don't remember the name
@@tj03297 Sedo played Fantaisie impromptu (Chopin) and Mia & Sebastian's theme from La La Land! :)
Does anyone know what the Cello piece is called?
I'd put Sedo below the cellist tbh, but other than that I agree. It is supposed to be a rating by talent, not which you would choose to listen to in your free time.
Summer was absolutely amazing. Can't believe the Instagram people thought that the other pianist had more talent.
💜
Pianist of 18+ years here: the pianist in the purple shirt is the best musician, and she should be ranked #1 because it's obvious she's been studying music for many years. Blue haired singer songwriter is def #6 LOL he was so arrogant. The other pianist attempted to play Chopin Fantasie Impromptu but he sounded like he didn't have it learned yet nor posses the technique for it (La La Land Piece is easy)... however, that's an advanced piece so if he can actually play it he's top 2-3. I think the girl ranked #1 has an AMAZING voice, but her musical talent isn't near the level of the multi instrumentalist or the other pianists. I'd vote her #1 for "Most Likely to Blow Up on Spotify" for sure, but not most musically talented.
Great vid! :)
Yeah the piano guy choked pretty hard on the descending run on fantasie impromptu, but I noticed his hands were shaking, so he was looking very nervous. I can’t imagine he would attempt that piece without being at least somewhat confident that he could pull it off, but who knows. His dynamics were non existent and it sounded like he was just smashing the pedal the whole time, but it still requires some skill to play that piece poorly.
Hey! You can check my TH-cam channel and you’ll see yes I can actually play it, on a normal piano. Plus we had only 1 attempt and we had to play for only 10 seconds for Instagram audience (that’s what they used for the ranking, not the la-la land part. Summer played something different that what was shown in the video but they didn’t include it in the final cut. It was less representative of her skills, I actually told her that right after). Long answer to say, yeah she’s definitely number #1, that’s why I ranked her myself at that spot in the video. Peace !
the multi instrumentalist played quite a few wrong notes when he was trying to play the spongebob thing lol, though his guitar playing was pretty solid imo
@@startariot5648 fair! But I’d still rank him above the girl cause she played just a few chords. Again, her voice is AMAZING and I’d prefer to listen to her sing over the multi instrumentalist any day
@@sedotossou hey brotha! Just listened to all three performances on your channel. Sounds great. If I had heard that, I’d put you in a tie with the girl actually! Your performance of the C sharp nocturne was very well done! The fantasie impromptu was definitely much better than how it got portrayed in the vid. I play mostly jazz now but played classical for 12 years (Mozart Sonata in D Major K576 was my last major piece) so I understand the frustration of playing on that Nord, it’s definitely not the same. The best keyboard I’ve played that is the closest feel to a real piano is the Korg SV2. Continued success, Sèdo!
Bro Sedo is such a humble guy. And all he spoke was straight up, 0 calorie, reduced sugar, gluten free, non-gmo facts
🤎🤎
his fit was fire aswell
@@sedotossou yooo king
@@braydenguy907 wassuup!
a reduced sugar probably has more than 0 calories
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
My personal ranking:
1. Girl pianist
2. Multiple instrument dude
3. Pianist guy
4. Drummer
5. Singer
6. Blue hair dude
Edit: thanks for agreeing with me guys 😋
nailed it
Same ranking :)
Agreed
this this this
Perfect! I agree exactly
Fell in love with Daniel the moment he started playing the drums. Also Summer was absolutely incredible, I can't believe the audience didn't place her at 1 or 2
I literally had chills and goosebumps when Summer played. she def deserved a higher rank in the end!!!
Just going to call it that the musicians will underrank themselves
I have fewer than 1 friend in the World. That's right. Everybody disses me for making bad videos. I think they are perfect though. Who is right? My dissers or me? Which side are you on, dear do
***artists
But yeah lmaoo
@@swansonjoe7121 What are you trying to correct?
@@khanbw That artists in general are insecure
Not JUST musicians, but also painters, sculptures, dancers etc.
What do you not understand??
@@swansonjoe7121 You used asterisks when you could have just typed out the explanation you did right now. That's why the others were confused.
If we were to translate their talent into human age, the blue hair guy would be an infant, fresh out of the womb, still wet behind the ears. The next 4 would be middle age adults. Summer would be an immortal goddess that has walked the earth for 400 years. There is no comparison. Blue hair guy needs a reality check if he really believes he belongs in the same conversation as any of the others.
Hi! Summer here:) Omfg, I am gonna definitely respond your comment in my response video (hopefully out by Friday or Saturday on my channel). Pretty please can you write a bio for me the next time I need one ? 😂
Fr tho, I’m pretty stellar at self-deprecating talk, so thanks for the ego boost :)
@@SummerSweeSingh you did amazing in the video!
This was the most poetic description of the video, and I'm here for itttt
Fr blue guy needs a truckload of humility lmao
My ranking:
1. Piano girl
2. Drummer
3. Multiple instruments
4. Piano guy
5. Guitar girl
6. Blue-haired guy
Personally, don't think the ability to play multiple instruments = better talent. All about quality over quantity. And while she sang really well and the guitar playing was a vibe, I feel like the guitar playing wasn't that impressive compared to everyone else.
Lastly, Instagram voting should've been blind, smh.
Wow, that's exactly what I was saying for the ratings. It was supposed to be rated by talent but it's clear they were not doing that. Summer/piano girl was clearly the most talented there yet she got rated so low. And likewise, while Mary was entertaining, it was still pretty basic and doesn't require the same level of talent as the other instruments.
The one I would be willing to move around is the drummer just because I'm not familiar with what's considered talented in drumming, for all I know what he played could have been super easy or more talented than everyone else
💯 agree with your rankings
@@annaairahala9462 Yeah for sure, I think her voice showed that she has the foundations of vocal talent, but if we're talking difficulty and complexity, she didn't showcase anything spectacular.
exactly..i think its made up by jubilee😅🤣
I got the same answer. I'd personally put the multi instrument guy first. Its like having someone fluent in 2 languages, and having someone as a poliglot. At a1 standard.
Summer was by far the most talented musician in that room. There is a difference between enjoyability and talent.
Daniel was amazing at drums, i have heard better, but he was great.
Michael knows how an instrument with strings work, so he might have figured out how to play the cello by himself.
Sedo was a great pianist, but he was outshined by Summer, Daniel and Michael.
Mary had a great voice but her guitartalent was not amazing, she even fucked up right here 3:02
Julius can burn.
agreed
How did Mary mess up?
@@solarwinds5114 she didnt play the chord correctly
@@solarwinds5114 u can tell she looks at the guitar
Ole dude wasn't even a pianist, picked up the instrument a week ago, played basic chords anyone can play (with improper finger positions), AND had the audacity to rank himself higher than the REAL pianists ?!
1. Piano girl
2. Drummer
3. Multi instrument dude
4. Sedo
5. Singing girl
6. Blue hair dude
The correct ranking
Agreed! The drummer doesn't get enough credit.
Facts
I'd move the drummer down 2 or 3 personally. It's flashy, but as another drum player I'm not sure if it would even be considered advanced, probably high intermediate
the drummer definitely needs to go lower theres a ton more he shouldve shown
This really turned into “which musical talents do I enjoy the most” vs. “who I think is most musically talented”
Summers understanding of the musical elements was far beyond anyone else there, a definite first in my opinion
Summer is easily #1 overall...can't believe she didn't make it on top for either vote
She showed a level of mastery far beyond what everyone else showed, amazed how other people didn't see that
My ranking:
1. Summer
2. Drums
3. Piano Boy
4. Multi-instruments
5. Singer
6. Blue Hair
Thank you I never now their names
It's kind of upsetting to me how impressed everyone was acting about Mary's performance. Cant help but wonder if their ranking of her had something to do with something other than her skills. 🤔
Great take except switch multi-instruments and piano boy in my opinion
Same ranking here
This is probably the ranking ive seen that i most agree with, except id put the singer girl as number 2 and everyone shifts down a spot
that girl absolutely shredded the piano wow
Tysm! :)
She was my favorite and I think I would’ve liked the performance even more if it was on a grand piano
"There was like 20 differant time signatures"
- Me, A drummer: "Now hold on a minute...somethin aint right"
4/4 all the way through.
It’s crazy that she had a phenomal voice and can play some chords on the guitar really nicely but has no idea what time signature actually is 😂
@@thugtrippin also, I dont want to be a prick, the but the drummers technique is aweful.
Not trying to bash anyone, but it was so obvious that the 2 pianists were the most talented in my opinion, so I was so confused when they got ranked pretty low in my opinion.
the piano girl was amazing and you could actually hear that she has a lot of experience especially since she made that piece herself. I could hear that the piano boy was really nervous in his playing, you can actually see his hands shaking. The first piece that he played is my favourite piece of all time so i could immediately hear that it was really messy but I think it was just the nerves. The second piece he played was really great!
@@milabosse9859 nerves definitely. Sorry I butchered your favorite song :( on my TH-cam channel I uploaded a longer version of my interpretation of Fantaisie-impromptu that I believe is way better that what I’ve done in this video.
@@sedotossou it’s so much pressure to play in this setting! Anyone would be nervous. You did great
@@emmawhitwam3728 you have no idea haha. Thank you for the kind words 🤎
SAME. And the girl singer getting ranked number 1 confused me a lot. She was great and she seems so nice but there were a lot of people who played their instruments better than her. She played really simple chords on guitar and it felt really similar to blue hair guys performance, but a bit more humble.
Thanks so much for having me, Jubilee team!! Shoutouts also to Mary, Michael, Sèdo, Daniel, and Julius :) y’all were some real ones! And since some people are asking, the piece I played was an original composition called "JFN". It's on iTunes/Spotify/Tidal/Bandcamp under my name full name (Summer Swee-Singh).
🤎🤎🤎
YOURE THE BEST AND I CANT WAIT TO WORK WITH YOU❤️
You’re amazing!
You're amazing. I'm envious. But I was sent to study IT instead of music as a kid. fml
That was amazing! What’s the name of the piece you played?
You should have gotten trained musicians and teachers to rank them... not the audience, clearly. Such an interesting concept for this episode!
I agree , there should have been someone that is impartial to the different genres of music. Everyone was crazy about Mary and I see that she has talent but I hate the style of today's music.
especially when IG is full of black community lol
@@mobu6810what does that have to do with anything weirdo
@@m20047 because it's true lol
Isn't music meant for the audience?
My soul almost left my body when Summer was on the piano, just magical. I think we need a TH-cam re-vote coz Summer got robbed.
Thank you so much Jubilee for having me (again haha)! Much love to the audience that ranked me 1. Shoutout to all the other artists who rocked! Peace to everybody 💛
You gave one hell of a performance bravo!
@@scottinhell Merci 🙏🏾
Love your energy goodluck on your journey!
Not sure if it was just the nerves, but you gotta loosen up a little while playing the piano, you looked super stiff
you did awesome, totally deserved the nr 1 spot !!
also- what are the names of the music you played? such pretty pieces, would love to look them up!
* plays 4 chord loop *
* puts himself in 2nd *
I’VE BEEN SCROLLING LOOKING FOR THIS COMMENT THANK YOU!!
Summer is goated. Made me feel emotion and you could tell she really feels it
Aw tysm, you’re too kind 🥺🙏🏽🤍 I def was feeling it though as that was an original composition I wrote for my husband which I titled “JFN” (full song is out on Spotify/bandcamp/iTunes under my name: Summer Swee-Singh)
Summer was the best hands down! I got chills. You can tell she is a seasoned yet naturally musically gifted artist!
as a classical pianist who has studied under a multitude of university professors for over a decade, i'd rank:
1. Summer (pianist in purple)
2. Daniel (drummer)
3. Mary (singer)
4. Michael (multiple instruments)
5. Sedo (pianist)
6. Julius (blue-haired guy)
what stood out to me and the defining point of how i ranked these musicians was the use of nuanced expression and mature dynamics, which the top 3 demonstrated thoroughly. Michael's performance was enjoyable and was a close third, but ultimately Mary's artistic tone and style captured my attention slightly more (plus, i value quality over quantity, though that's a personal preference). imo, Sedo and Julius's performances lacked the technicality and dynamics that the others had, but they definitely weren't bad - just some more diligent practice and they'll be right there.
Classical guitarist here, Mary is very new to guitar, her singing is great but lyrics weren't that complicated, not that that's important, there just wasn't a lot of skill shown. So I'd definately put her 5, after the arrogant blue hair guy
I had the fortune to play with world-class drummers and I can guarantee you that none of them would think Daniel has a "use of nuanced expression and mature dynamics". He just showed off random chops.
First one I've agreed with. Sedu is held way too high. He needs to learn his limits, because he's clearly not ready for Chopin. I've a sneaking suspicion that people only voted for him because he played the score of their favourite movie.
What song did summer perform?
@@axel.lessio unfortunately playin like buddy rich don't pay the bills these days
Since everyone is doing this, here's my ranking:
1. Summer (Piano Girl)
2. Sédo (Piano Guy)
3. Daniel (Drummer Guy)
4. Michael (Multi-instrumentalist) Impressive and versatile, but not particularly exceptional in any of those instruments. Case of knowing a bit of everything.
5. Mary (singer/songwriter)
6. Julius (blue-haired guy)
My ranking
1)Summer: Definitely has a musical background and has a great sense of dynamics.
2)Daniel: Love the rhythms and the decrescendo.
3)Mary: Beautiful voice and great control over her voice.
4)Michael: Although has played 2 instruments, the cello was out of tune and could have better phrasing.
5)Sedo: Chose a difficult piece for his level. Has were a bit too flat, too much pedal and note were uneven in dynamics and length.
6)Julius: Not much musical technique. Used a basic chord progression. If he went for piano classes or practised a bit more then he could get better.
This is my opinion, dont bash me if u disagree with my ranking.
P.s. just because u can play multiple instruments doesn't necessarily mean you are a great musician. It definately takes time, skill, practice and a certain type of mentality to be able to master your instrument at a very high level.
💜💜💜
What about the blue hair guy?
@@unidentifiedx4319 thats julius
As a drummer, I'm not impressed by Daniel. He's going wild which is cool but his tone quality and time aren't great. Reminds me of the metal drummers at the middle school battle of the bands. Still goes above Julius, but definitely bottom half.
What song was Sedo performing?
How did sedo win?! The piano girl was so much better, from my perspective as a pianist. Her technique was on point, her pacing was better, the tone, I could go on. Sedo proceeded to play only a few lines of a well known piece and mess up at the end, yet Instagram probably only voted him better because of the piece he played.
cause it’s instagram and they don’t actually care about the skill they just voted for what piece they liked the most definitely. they liked sedo cause he played a la la land song, it was recognisable, and the other people had more charisma which made them more likeable to the audience. half of the people viewing in instagram have no musical experience so they wouldn’t get how amazing summer is
Being able to play multiple instruments decently doesn’t mean you’re better than someone who has mastered a single instrument. idk why everyone keeps ranking Michael first lol he’s decent on guitar, average on cello and was completely out of tune on the lap steel. I’d rank him more in the middle, but behind piano girl and drum guy at the very least.
I once had a music director tell a fellow musician who was trying to learn every instrument that nobody wants someone who’s average on multiple instruments. It’s better to be outstanding and master one instrument first.
I thought the exact same thing, it really bothered me his cello and lap steel, I thought he was terrible in them, completely out of tune in the last one.
YES EXACTLY
His cello playing made me cringe
Totally agree. I was not impressed by the lap steel playing
Yeah I’m not sure if it was his nerves or what but the lap steel was not in tune, and his cello playing would sound great to someone who hasn’t played in an orchestra, but as someone who has played, it was average. His versatility is impressive but I don’t think that’s what makes a great musician.
1. Female pianist
2. Multi-instrumental guy
3. Drummer
4. Male pianist
5. Female singer
6. Blue hair guy
Dislike every TH-cam video until the dislike button is back
@@silloweet
still isnt gone for me
the only right one
@@silloweet no, thats bringing down the creators who did nothing wrong
Exactly
i cant believe the female pianist got number 5 as the instagram rating! she was amazing, def woukd be 1 for me
OK, I had to stop the video half way for this...
This is nearly impossible to rank. I gotta try: Blue hair has some serious heart, and you have to love it. Navy button down, I'd go to his show after that Fleetwood piece. Hawaiian shirt, I'd want him to drum for my indie rock band. Curly hair girl absolutely set herself apart with that voice, but I don't think it's entirely fair to rank her higher or lower than the pianists. They all impressed me, and are great in their own ways.
On shear talent:
1) Girl in purple shirt (pianist)- Her performance was gushing passion and emotion. High skill-level.
2) Girl w/ curly hair (singer/songwriter)- Her voice gave me chills, it was heavenly. Someone you'd like to write with.
3) Guy in beige outfit (pianist)- He is undoubtedly classically trained and has the dynamic touch.
4) Guy in navy button-down (multi-instrumentalist)- He's the guy you wanna start a band with because of his versatility.
5) Drummer- He's bringing the ruckus, I'd love to crank the distortion on some humbuckers beside this guy.
6) Guy w/ blue hair (singer/songwriter)- Touched my heart. Impressive despite being new at his instrument. Madd potential. Keep writing!
My rankings (Based on instrumental skill, not vocals):
1. Piano girl
2. Piano guy
3. Multi instrument guy
4. Drummer
5. Guitar girl
6. Blue haired guy
no, the piano guy couldn't even get past 5 seconds of fantasie impromptu without screwing up like 10 notes. clearly he has no idea how to play piano
@hannah i'm just stating my opinion :Shrug:
@a noob oh, I don’t play the piano so it sounded ok to me lol.
The voice is an instrument
@@anoob6311 saying Sedo "has no idea how to play piano" is incredibly harsh and undermining. Did you factor in that it's a 10 sec snipped which he may have been nervous to play, knowing that it's being broadcasted? His talent is clear to see in his TH-cam videos. You can state your opinion without being objectively inaccurate and cruelly judgmental.
As someone who plays 4 instruments it's definitely Summer that's the best imo
🤍🤍🤍
It's obvious that people who don't know music like in a profesional way had picked the song which they have played or sung... but the best musician is clearly Summer✌😊
I ain't a professional but I can tell
🙏🏽🤍
i think everyone is drastically underrating the difficulty of playing never going back again, he played it so smooth
1 year late, but ikr?? He even sang along with it and that’s HARD
1. Purple shirt girl
2. Drummer
3. Piano guy
4. Navy shirt guy
5. Singer girl
6. Blue hair guy
From the perspective of 10 years of lessons in classical piano, I think Summer easily had the best technique of the 3 pianists (she was the only one to use her whole body to play, and I saw little to no wrist or arm movement from the others). I think Daniel maybe had the next highest degree of technical proficiency. I have a really hard time judging vocals with accompaniment, since it's kinda like playing two instruments at once, so perhaps Mary is better than my first impression. I'd probably rank Michael after Mary, but I honestly didn't get to see enough to get an accurate measurement of his ability. Sedo came off to me as a student who has studied classically for quite a few years, and Julius came off to me as a self-taught musician.
Exactly, 20 years of classical here. Sedo posture is very stiff and has no emotion to it.
He can absolutely become GREAT, he's just so Damm stiff :(
Thanks Qishi! Piano gang represent hehe :)
@@SummerSweeSingh Summer, you absolutely killed it. I don't need to be part of the "piano gang' (though I wish I was) to appreciate your talent. With only three years of middle school band (tenor saxophone and clarinet!), it was obvious to me that you have a mastery of the piano. I really appreciated your performance. You're a great artist that should be recognized as so
"music for me is not a competition it's an art form"
That won my heart.!
Mary has a beautiful voice and she also knows how to use it but, Summer is at another level, that girl is wonderful.
Julius giving himself a 2 and summer a 5 was hilarious.😂😂😂
I think Summer should have been first, and Daniel second. You can tell they have both put so much time and effort into their music, and that they really understand their instruments on a really intrinsic level.
🤍
Whaat? No I think they were all tied for number 6, except julius, he was so humble, he placed himself #2 and not #1!
The purple girl was the second best, you could hear her experience and dynamics, wear as the seto guy was abit stiff, though he was nervous and shaking. In modern day music the Afro girl wins, I’m not much of a fan of singing but she sounds the most professional to me. The guitarist was great at guitar, I wish we had heard more of him playing guitar as his other instruments Wernt as strong.
Mary (the Afro girl) lmaooo
The Afro girl is heavily racist!!!! CANCEL CANCEL CANCEL YOURE DONE!!!
@@nicholaso4302 not racist, definitely was a descriptive word. Where you should be upset is that so many women don’t wear their Afros because they think it reflects politics. So she stands out
@@giving7389 racist as hell cancel cancel cancel you should never be able to touch the internet again.
@@nicholaso4302 I’m assuming your not black nor a girl so why are you saying ‘cancel cancel cancel’?
u can tell by the way summer plays the piano, i could tell she has been playing for a long time
Piano girl was just amazing. She deserves the 1.
Julius got balls going there with his own song and playing the keyboard in front of experienced musicians. They're all goated I vibed with the drums the most myself. Also Yann tiersen played well and such a touching piece.
As a drummer who's been playing for years,I cringed a bit when he started smashing the drums as hard as he could with so much echo in the room. In situations like this always go for smooth and groovy stuff
I’m not even a drummer and I know that. I cringed
Dudes not the great.
THIS! Cringed hard when he just started bashing the drums and playing as fast as he could. When the guitar singer girl said “you played in like 20 different time signatures” I burst out laughing because, even though she meant it as a compliment, he didn’t do that on purpose and it was just cause he wanted to show off his “chops” and played as fast and messy as he could😆
He has chops but yeah, the acoustics of the room didn't suit that playing style.
Bossanova my ass, give me some Baiao and you win lol (jk)
My personal ranking:
1- piano girl
2- piano guy
3- multiple instruments
4- drummer
5- girl singin
6- blue hair guy
I’m the exact same
I agree with your ranking!
@@skrill500 fr lmao
"that was like 20 different time signatures" bru that was 1 time signature
The piano players were the most experienced and best straight up fact this ain't even a discussion
Also, this was probably the most wholesome episode I have watched of Jubilee, couldn't hate ANYONE. Beautiful stuff.
I thought the blue haired guy was a little full of himself, but overall they were all talented and sweet people
blue hair
yeah they were pretty chill, ngl I was shocked bc many artists are sensitive ab their craft leading to awkward situations but this wasn't that bad
How tf did Instagam rank piano guy 1st and piano girl 5th? He's not bad by any means but it's obvious that she is more skilled.
Lol I know they play the same instrument ent but she did it 10x better. The Instagram voters make no sense
for real. they need to do a recount
Piano guy is better though
@@silaswilbur how so??? He fumbled through the fast song and the slow one was muddy
@@silaswilbur Like i srsly don’t think you even watched her part, it was incredible.
Summer is by far the most talented.