I agree. If George Lucas had started with the prequels, I think we still would've seen Darth Vader, but he wouldn't have been Anakin Skywalker. It would've been someone else because I believe the master of Anakin would've been Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan would've died at the hands of Darth Maul
I can easily imagine how things would have changed if he survived and trained Anakin. I've read so many fanfics about this. Qui-Gon was a father figure to Anakin and that could have made a considerable difference as he knows what it means to love and lose after losing the girl he loved. . .Tahl (she was another Jedi who died tragically.) Jedi Apprentice showed this . .including just how close Qui-Gon turned permanently to the Dark Side. I love what ifs because of the changes it would make to the entire storyline.
Same here. Although I hate it when the narrator and channel creator says its unhappy ending for both Anakin and the Jedi Order😒. I mean what's the point of watching the what if story. If It's the same damn outcome as the Revenge of the Sith!?
Nice video, I like this scenario! Dave FIlioni said in an interview once that "the duel of the fates" was a duel for Anakin's fate. And that Qui Gon was the father figure Anakin would have needed to turn out "good". I also think that with Qui Gon, Anakin would not become so close to Palpatine as he is in the actual timeline. He is not dissatisfied with his jedi master, so he is not so open to other mentor-figures outside the jedi order. I like your addition of Count Dooku not siding with Sidious in this timeline. It makes sense as his relationship with Qui Gon was so strong, his survival would probably impact Dooku a lot. And with the whole clone army not falling under Sith control, there goes order 66 out the window lol
The voice acting on these videos is phenomenal. They are very convincing. I do wish these videos were longer. They often grab my attention and then, BAM, it’s over.
Qui Gon would of been the perfect master. I feel like Anakin would be the absolute god he is portrayed on Mortis if Qui Gon trained him as he would reach his full potential. If Prime Luke can pull a black hole, imagine what FP Anakin would be able to do.
@@x102reddragon Legends Luke was close to his potential, but he never truly reached it. Anakin WOULD have been able to reach it because he was trained at the age of 9, is an incredibly fast learner (faster than Luke), he already had experience fighting, and he is incredibly intelligent. Imo there is more than just the force at play, you have to bring a character's qualities into light as well and Anakin beats Luke when it comes to this so he'll likely beat FP Luke 3/5 times.
I love the voiceovers. Awesome story writing!!!! Loved how Anakin finished Sidious in the end and the cliff hanger and will be waiting steadfast for part 2
I wonder if it would be a viable option; have Qui Gon fake his own death (with the council/Anakin knowing) so that Palpatine could make his move on Anakin and catch him in a trap that way. I don't think with all the skill Sidious had of lying and hiding his force powers that even if the whole council were to focus on him, they likely wouldn't see the dark side or detect him lying
I loved that you added the voices of the characters in the video, you did a really good job on illustrating it and I’m looking forward to watching more
really liked another video showing how qui gon would've made anakin a better man. also the happy ending was a nice touch, with the jedi order surviving for once...
I really like this one it was a really good twist on it. You probably could have made this a hour long and everyone would have still watched. The voice actors were very good also. Keep up the good work
This is very great and very exciting and very interesting and very epic and very nicely well done. Thank You, Fantasy Folklore. I definitely look forward to Part 2.
I love this video some much! The confection is amazing. The fact you had a voice actor for mall is amazing and I just really love this video I can’t express how much I love this video and your one of the best TH-camrs I know!!
@@FantasyFolklore I don't mean to say this in an annoying way, but when are you going to contact the winner? I feel like you should announce the winner or something
Your take on Qui Gonn surviving is so satisfying, I've always wished there would be an alternate timeline where basically the prophecy of the chosen one happens without the twist of going to the dark side and all. Love it!
Came here from your "If Anakin was trained from birth" video. Really impressive script and voice acting. I enjoy the effort you put in your videos. Thoughts on doing a "what-if" video on if Mother Talzin became Sidious' apprentice?
I really like your videos, mostly because they aren’t biased but they’re great to listen to anytime I also think that part 2 should maybe focus on Anakin revealing to the council of his marriage with Padme Great video
Honestly I love cals lightsaber it’s very interesting design and all his stances are aggressive which makes him easy to roleplay as a fallen Jedi grey Jedi or just canon Jedi knight
A week has passed, just 3 more to go for the giveaway 🎉. I'm glad that everyone is checking in as it shows how passionate everyone is for the saber. I myself will be checking in every week. Just saying to let anyone know that I'm not trying to spam. Good luck guys 🎉🎉🎉. Also, CONGRATS ON ALMOST GETTING TO 11K QUICKLY.
This one is very fitting, Quigon is the best master Anakin should have. As Anakin will find true balance. I will salute you my best man. You did a great job with this one. And if we can get a part 2. Damn I will be here so quickly.
Fantastic, I train voice actors and I must say this is a master class! I hope to hear some good news about the lightsaber, I love the design of Kestus and I love his character, unfortunately a bit beyond budget. May the force be with you
Your 'What if' videos are the highlight of my daily TH-cam viewing. Qui-Gon would have been a better master than Obi-Wan as Qui-Gon has more of a father figure that Anakin needed - Qui-Gon in this video shows that Anakin would have been better prepared as a Jedi for anything that Sidious could do. Also interesting is 1. the absolute fear that Sidious has of Qui-Gon. 2. the way Sidious tries to persuade Dooku (who is a double agent) to betray the Jedi & Republic Dooku is many things but in this 'What if' he can see through Sidious & his manipulations. - you show that both Qui-Gon & Anakin IMO would have been a formidable pairing one mind & one heart - together they are unstoppable.
hi, I have always been a fan of you videos, you always seem to make my day whenever you upload, thank you on behalf of all you subscribers, may the force be with you
I love the work you do keep it up please it has inspired so many of my friends to get into Star Wars and it has given tons of people that same inspiration
Minor continuity error here: The Clone Army was initially thought of by Darth Plagueis who conjured up the money for the initial ordering of the army through his Banking Clan connections. Dooku impersonated Sifo-Dyas to order that army before TPM, when Plagueis was still around to provide the funding.
If Qui-Gon Jinn had survived and Darth Maul had died on Naboo, the events of the Star Wars universe would have unfolded in a very different way. Here are a few possibilities: 1. Anakin Skywalker Might Not Have Turned to the Dark Side: If Qui-Gon Jinn had survived, he might have been able to train Anakin Skywalker in the ways of the Force. Qui-Gon had a more compassionate and open-minded approach to the Force than the other Jedi, and he might have been able to prevent Anakin from turning to the dark side. 2. The Clone Wars Might Not Have Happened: If Darth Maul had died on Naboo, he would not have been able to serve as the catalyst for the Clone Wars. Without the Clone Wars, the galaxy might have experienced a more peaceful and stable period. 3. Qui-Gon Might Have Discovered Palpatine's True Identity: Qui-Gon was suspicious of Palpatine's motives, and he might have been able to discover his true identity as a Sith Lord. This would have prevented Palpatine from taking over the galaxy and creating the Galactic Empire. 4. An Alternate Jedi Council: If Qui-Gon had survived and returned to the Jedi Council, he might have been able to sway the other Jedi to his more compassionate and open-minded approach to the Force. This would have led to a very different Jedi Council and a different approach to the Force.
The Jedi would win the Clone Wars and there would be no Order 66. They would also follow through on finding Savage Opress. With the Sith defeated, they would then install for the first in over a millenia a Jedi Chancellor to fix the corruption in the Senate, ushering in a new golden age of the Republic. Good luck to all on the Saber give away. Outstanding video!
As always your videos are such a great watch. I am really glad I found your channel and subbed. I will enjoy watching your channel grow with popularity 😁
I tell ya a lot of things would've been different and better if Qui-Gon had actually survived the duel of the fates. Anakin would've had the rightful master and father figure he never had. He also would've supported Anakin's love for Padme like a father would his son.
Although Kenobi was a good mentor, I think Qui-Gon was the mentor Anakin truly needed.
George Lucas himself stated that Qui-Gon was the father figure Anakin needed.
Agreed. Things would have been so different to the storyline.
I agree. If George Lucas had started with the prequels, I think we still would've seen Darth Vader, but he wouldn't have been Anakin Skywalker. It would've been someone else because I believe the master of Anakin would've been Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan would've died at the hands of Darth Maul
@@ayakotami3318yeah, for instance Vader wouldn't be Anakin, he would be someone else
To be fair, there is a reason the song is called "Dual of the Fates"
I wish we got more of Qui Gon in the prequels. He was such a good character and would have been a great father figure to Anakin. Love the video!!!!
I couldn't agree more
Exactly!
Imagine Qui Gon, Ani, and Asoka together a true golden age for the order
I can easily imagine how things would have changed if he survived and trained Anakin. I've read so many fanfics about this. Qui-Gon was a father figure to Anakin and that could have made a considerable difference as he knows what it means to love and lose after losing the girl he loved. . .Tahl (she was another Jedi who died tragically.) Jedi Apprentice showed this . .including just how close Qui-Gon turned permanently to the Dark Side. I love what ifs because of the changes it would make to the entire storyline.
Yeah but it would have made for a much less compelling story.
Always love the idea of qui gon surviving
Same here. Although I hate it when the narrator and channel creator says its unhappy ending for both Anakin and the Jedi Order😒. I mean what's the point of watching the what if story. If It's the same damn outcome as the Revenge of the Sith!?
Same. He's my favorite character minus Obi-Wan and Anakin. 😊
@@ayakotami3318 Ditto, mine too!!!
Me too, he and Luke are my two favourite characters
Me too! Qui-Gon was a special type of Jedi who followed his own code and followed the will of the force.
Bro the "I hate you" scream give me chills everytime 😅
Nice video, I like this scenario!
Dave FIlioni said in an interview once that "the duel of the fates" was a duel for Anakin's fate. And that Qui Gon was the father figure Anakin would have needed to turn out "good". I also think that with Qui Gon, Anakin would not become so close to Palpatine as he is in the actual timeline. He is not dissatisfied with his jedi master, so he is not so open to other mentor-figures outside the jedi order.
I like your addition of Count Dooku not siding with Sidious in this timeline. It makes sense as his relationship with Qui Gon was so strong, his survival would probably impact Dooku a lot. And with the whole clone army not falling under Sith control, there goes order 66 out the window lol
The VA for Qui Gon did an amazing job, can’t wait to see more What ifs.
I truly think Palpatine himself would deal with Qui Gon like how he dealt with Maul. Qui Gon was too big of a threat for Palpatine
The voice acting on these videos is phenomenal. They are very convincing. I do wish these videos were longer. They often grab my attention and then, BAM, it’s over.
Qui gon is an awesome character, I would have loved to have a movie or a Disney+ show of his youth. Insane video as always.
Great content! It's a shame Qui Gon did not have more of a presence in the rest of the prequels and beyond.
Qui Gon would of been the perfect master. I feel like Anakin would be the absolute god he is portrayed on Mortis if Qui Gon trained him as he would reach his full potential. If Prime Luke can pull a black hole, imagine what FP Anakin would be able to do.
FP Anakin solos anyone including Revan
@@hamstey1603 i agree i mean george lucas said that also
They’d be the same. FP Anakin is what Luke pretty much was in legends.
@@x102reddragon Legends Luke was close to his potential, but he never truly reached it. Anakin WOULD have been able to reach it because he was trained at the age of 9, is an incredibly fast learner (faster than Luke), he already had experience fighting, and he is incredibly intelligent. Imo there is more than just the force at play, you have to bring a character's qualities into light as well and Anakin beats Luke when it comes to this so he'll likely beat FP Luke 3/5 times.
@@hamstey1603 Revan was a beast!
I love the voiceovers. Awesome story writing!!!! Loved how Anakin finished Sidious in the end and the cliff hanger and will be waiting steadfast for part 2
james_kleparek
Instagram
I was surprised when Anikan confessed his feelings for Padme, love the video!
❤️
I wonder if it would be a viable option; have Qui Gon fake his own death (with the council/Anakin knowing) so that Palpatine could make his move on Anakin and catch him in a trap that way. I don't think with all the skill Sidious had of lying and hiding his force powers that even if the whole council were to focus on him, they likely wouldn't see the dark side or detect him lying
This…wow, that is a practically spot ON Qui-Gon voice! 😍
IKR!!
I loved that you added the voices of the characters in the video, you did a really good job on illustrating it and I’m looking forward to watching more
really liked another video showing how qui gon would've made anakin a better man. also the happy ending was a nice touch, with the jedi order surviving for once...
I actually like your videos I use them as a podcast for when I'm bored and you have really helped me become a star wars geek
Thank you!!
@@FantasyFolklore Your Welcome!
@@FantasyFolklore if I win the giveaway somehow just read my bio to contact me
I think your individual characterization skills have improved quite a bit. Looking forward to the next part.
I really like this one it was a really good twist on it. You probably could have made this a hour long and everyone would have still watched. The voice actors were very good also. Keep up the good work
Qui Gon was always one of my favorites.
Honestly I just love that maul got some lines in the duel of the fates😂
I just recently found your channel and I really enjoy it I appreciate the deep dives they really does make you think “what if”
Great “what if”! I’m loving these videos! I think Qui Gon would have been a much better master for Anikin.
One of your best videos so far. Amazing story line. I would like to see a video of what if Rey joined Palpatine
This is very great and very exciting and very interesting and very epic and very nicely well done. Thank You, Fantasy Folklore. I definitely look forward to Part 2.
Thanks for your support as always master ❤️❤️
I often wondered what would've happened if Qui-Gon survived. Now I have some idea. Great video.
Love the videos man, an the alternate timelines in star Wars you make, their very well thought out and Amazing👍
I love your videos they're well thought through and i really can't thank you enough for that. Can't wait for more awesome content!!!
The best what ifs on TH-cam, these are awesome, keep up the good work!
Your Qui gon voice>>>>>>>>>>>>>
I love this video some much! The confection is amazing. The fact you had a voice actor for mall is amazing and I just really love this video I can’t express how much I love this video and your one of the best TH-camrs I know!!
And I don’t know if I should put my email in or not
That's ok, not many people are so it doesn't matter we'll pick regardless
@@FantasyFolklore thank you
@@FantasyFolklore I don't mean to say this in an annoying way, but when are you going to contact the winner?
I feel like you should announce the winner or something
@@enchantedmg3415 Great question, end of October. It will be announced in a video and mentioned in the title!
Your take on Qui Gonn surviving is so satisfying, I've always wished there would be an alternate timeline where basically the prophecy of the chosen one happens without the twist of going to the dark side and all. Love it!
Thank you!
Qui Gons voice is just so perfect
Came here from your "If Anakin was trained from birth" video. Really impressive script and voice acting. I enjoy the effort you put in your videos. Thoughts on doing a "what-if" video on if Mother Talzin became Sidious' apprentice?
Great video never consider Derek how much of an affect Qui Gonn survivor Cingular would have on the story
This had been one of the better fan fiction video’s I have watched. Very nice sir.
You have some of the best fan fictions out there! I’d say this is a surprise, a welcome one of course. Seriously though, keep it up!
I really like your videos, mostly because they aren’t biased but they’re great to listen to anytime
I also think that part 2 should maybe focus on Anakin revealing to the council of his marriage with Padme
Great video
Thanks!
Honestly I love cals lightsaber it’s very interesting design and all his stances are aggressive which makes him easy to roleplay as a fallen Jedi grey Jedi or just canon Jedi knight
A week has passed, just 3 more to go for the giveaway 🎉. I'm glad that everyone is checking in as it shows how passionate everyone is for the saber. I myself will be checking in every week. Just saying to let anyone know that I'm not trying to spam. Good luck guys 🎉🎉🎉.
Also, CONGRATS ON ALMOST GETTING TO 11K QUICKLY.
I like how many different TH-camrs do their own take on different what ifs
the vid was amazing u should have like 1 mil by now tbh
very underated
Qui-Gon was who Anakin needed
Darth Plagueis knew that Qui-Gon was "the key to everything for that boy"
This one is very fitting, Quigon is the best master Anakin should have. As Anakin will find true balance. I will salute you my best man. You did a great job with this one. And if we can get a part 2. Damn I will be here so quickly.
This is such an amazing video it’s honestly better than most what ifs I’ve seen I love how one thing can change the whole story
Also am I supposed to put my email here?
the voice actors are amazing 🤩
Do what if anikan stayed as a jedi and obi wan became a sith
I think a scenario where this could happen is when maul killed saltine
agreed
I'm going to write this soon!
@@austinwarford1569 defo
"It's over obi wan! I have the high ground!"
Fantastic, I train voice actors and I must say this is a master class! I hope to hear some good news about the lightsaber, I love the design of Kestus and I love his character, unfortunately a bit beyond budget. May the force be with you
this is a really cool episode with the awesome add on of the voice actors
great video! qui gon is super underrated. also great qui gon voice!!!
qui-gon was always the best teacher for anakin
Why?
@@filliiiii7 in obi-wan, he got a big brother. what anakin needed was a father.
Yes he was
This is a good one! you did forget that it was Darth Plaugis who paid for the clone army, but still. this was very good
Your 'What if' videos are the highlight of my daily TH-cam viewing. Qui-Gon would have been a better master than Obi-Wan as Qui-Gon has more of a father figure that Anakin needed - Qui-Gon in this video shows that Anakin would have been better prepared as a Jedi for anything that Sidious could do. Also interesting is 1. the absolute fear that Sidious has of Qui-Gon. 2. the way Sidious tries to persuade Dooku (who is a double agent) to betray the Jedi & Republic Dooku is many things but in this 'What if' he can see through Sidious & his manipulations. - you show that both Qui-Gon & Anakin IMO would have been a formidable pairing one mind & one heart - together they are unstoppable.
Been loving your what if's stubbled across them while watching other channels what ifs keep up the good work
Thanks man!
Great fanfiction, I liked the idea of Palpatine choosing Savage Opress as his apprentice
Nice voices, keep up the good work!
One of my favorite theories great work man
Love the voiceovers
This is the stuff I watch when I’m bored
Thank you
hi, I have always been a fan of you videos, you always seem to make my day whenever you upload, thank you on behalf of all you subscribers, may the force be with you
Qui gon would smoke anyone besides maul! This was a great episode. Will be coming back to watch more.
this is amazing way better than the other ones ive seen
Thanks man. That was great 🤘
this is a what if that has been done a few times by others, But still glad you guys did it.
That Qui Gon and Maul voice tho!
Loved the voice acting. Kinda incredible how much is changed by altering something early on. Can’t wait to see more!
Instagram
Chlester101
I was always partial to qui-gon jinn. My fav Jedi since he always believed in his own path
I love the work you do keep it up please it has inspired so many of my friends to get into Star Wars and it has given tons of people that same inspiration
Awesome video as always!
Damn those voice actors were insane
Great video…Greatest of all time. GOAT
Instead of Qui-Gon Jin dying, now it's Obi-Wan who died.
Star Wars needs to animate these what if’s! It’d be amazing
I love your content, keep up the good work. also a story relating to general grievous would be cool (what if grievous killed obi-wan on udapow)
Ive sen a lot of different takes on this but this is by far my favorite.
This was an excellent video which I would love to see more of. You really need to do more stuff with qui gon
I love these fan fics. Very cool!
This is really good. Looking forward to more.
Qui Gon be like:Are ya winning son?
Minor continuity error here:
The Clone Army was initially thought of by Darth Plagueis who conjured up the money for the initial ordering of the army through his Banking Clan connections. Dooku impersonated Sifo-Dyas to order that army before TPM, when Plagueis was still around to provide the funding.
If Qui-Gon Jinn had survived and Darth Maul had died on Naboo, the events of the Star Wars universe would have unfolded in a very different way. Here are a few possibilities:
1. Anakin Skywalker Might Not Have Turned to the Dark Side: If Qui-Gon Jinn had survived, he might have been able to train Anakin Skywalker in the ways of the Force. Qui-Gon had a more compassionate and open-minded approach to the Force than the other Jedi, and he might have been able to prevent Anakin from turning to the dark side.
2. The Clone Wars Might Not Have Happened: If Darth Maul had died on Naboo, he would not have been able to serve as the catalyst for the Clone Wars. Without the Clone Wars, the galaxy might have experienced a more peaceful and stable period.
3. Qui-Gon Might Have Discovered Palpatine's True Identity: Qui-Gon was suspicious of Palpatine's motives, and he might have been able to discover his true identity as a Sith Lord. This would have prevented Palpatine from taking over the galaxy and creating the Galactic Empire.
4. An Alternate Jedi Council: If Qui-Gon had survived and returned to the Jedi Council, he might have been able to sway the other Jedi to his more compassionate and open-minded approach to the Force. This would have led to a very different Jedi Council and a different approach to the Force.
The Jedi would win the Clone Wars and there would be no Order 66. They would also follow through on finding Savage Opress. With the Sith defeated, they would then install for the first in over a millenia a Jedi Chancellor to fix the corruption in the Senate, ushering in a new golden age of the Republic. Good luck to all on the Saber give away. Outstanding video!
Thanks!
This is such an amazing video! Love the plot!
I really like this saber, for Jedi Fallen Order is one of my favourite Star Wars games.
Really good video the voice acting was amazing👍
As always your videos are such a great watch. I am really glad I found your channel and subbed. I will enjoy watching your channel grow with popularity 😁
Kenobi just didn't have enough knowledge to keep Anakin content
Qui gon's voice is 🔥
great video great voice acting !!!!
❤️❤️❤️
I like the voices. Also here for the lightsaber.
Qui Gon Jinn only person who could stop Count Dooku to the dark side.
if only there were so many opportunities for the jedi to survive and the light to prevail but Palpatine with all of his odds destroyed everything
I tell ya a lot of things would've been different and better if Qui-Gon had actually survived the duel of the fates. Anakin would've had the rightful master and father figure he never had. He also would've supported Anakin's love for Padme like a father would his son.
Subscribed! Awesome cool vid. Love the ending!
Qui gon was the father anakin really needed and i feel it was better like this
Darth Maul is my favorite Sith because he can move so fast and is strong in the force
personally one of my fav vids
Thank you!
Great vid as always