This is the community tab post that lets you vote for the next group we do!: th-cam.com/channels/vZB_pSx7aPtfWLXVo01ttg.htmlcommunity?lb=UgkxaCg28iNQMLElWihF-nuJBnSsE89jfnIB
Yes!! The only reason why i dont hate such a ranking although my fav on F because they give a clear explanation about the song she didnt like, like why she hates it and why she love it and the way she explain it really OBJECTIVE, from the instrumental, vocals, arrangement, etc. It made me enjoy those rankings more. Ppl should make this as example to rank tbh
Not finished with the video, but I already like how your mother words her opinions, even on songs she dislikes. Despite seeing favorites of mine in F tier, I never once felt bad about seeing them there, because it made perfect sense why and was so clearly a matter of personal taste and opinion. "Bug" IS very chaotic and computery, and if you like that stuff you like it. If you don't like it then you don't. I never felt personally hurt by the placements no matter how "harsh" they were. Guess I'm saying this because many peer-made song rankings can actually be quite cruel to songs they dislike abd it can sting a bit AHA.
Oh I get that as a peer that ranks. I’m very “THIS COVER MAKES ME ANGRY” about my lowest of lows (my new ranking system has only 3 songs at 1/10 tho so at least I try to keep the amount I feel that way about small), but she’s extremely chill and occasionally even has a positive aspect to bring up about some of her F tiers like Mind Brand’s guitar and Bocca della Verita’s piano. She’s less invested and unfamiliar with any other versions of these songs so she doesn’t feel a need to be as scathing about her least favorites. She’s already inspired me to want to be more positive/less harsh for anything I would consider higher than a 1/10 (I can’t lie about those very few- sorry to anyone that likes them).
This was quite an experience to react to, seeing some of my fav songs on F tier (Give me your night and Kanadetomosusora) hurts a bit but kinda expected them to be in the low tiers after seeing the intro, but also seeing “It was a very beautiful June” in S tier is a win tbh. Also seeing the amount of songs in the negative tiers being the same as the positives ones is crazy, for some reason, I’m more interested in seeing her takes on Leo/need songs rather than the rest of the groups!!!
I think this is the first time i see hello/how are you in a high section of a tierlist. Your mom has really unique and good taste and i like how consistent her description is throughout the whole video so even when some of my favorite songs are on the below level, i'm not even mad because your mother put up a reasonable and understanable explanation for each songs
IT HURTS TO SEE MY BELOVED KANATOMOSORA BEING CALLED ZZZZ UE UE... 😭😭😭 It's expected w the intro but still hurts a lot since that song means a lot to me haha, sorry for being dramatic ;-; But i can only respect her taste though, slow songs maybe really doesn't click with a lot of people after all lol. But it genuinely surprised me to see how high 25ji jounetsu and Mushou Jishoku are, even I don't expect Engeki to be that high either :0 Her comment on Villain does really hits deep in heart too... Thanks for the vid and opinion! Wish you and your mom a nice day/night!
Unfortunately I can only get her to agree to keep doing these if I space them out by months because it takes many hours to listen to every song, take notes, and then sort them. I’m trying to keep them still relatively close together though because if spaced out too much the discographies are gonna get harder to get through due to size. It’ll probably be March, May, July or August.
@@MarceCloud39she can take as long she wants. Her reasons are good. Especially as she's much older than the target audience of pjsekai and different perspectives are always valuable.
SAMSA IS JUST THAT GOOD BABYYYYY!!!! I greatly enjoyed seeing your mom’s thought process, it’s evident that she really tries to give everything a fair shake and is trying to place exactly what she likes/dislikes about a song. Thank you for sharing and editing this all together!
As someone who’s favorite nightcord songs are bug I nan desu venom bitter choco decoration and totemo itai I don’t know how to feel (ni still respect her opinions!)
As someone that ranks Venom as their #8 for all songs in the game with Sekai versions it gave me psychic damage to see her put it there, but I'm okay. It's fine. She can feel that way. She didn't hear a peep out of me because I try not to influence her rankings whatsoever. (at least Gehenna, my #9, is in A rank. the W's outweigh the L's)
Your mom taste is absolutely AMAZING... cutlery on #18? Charles, It's just life, hello/how are you on top 10?? Also, IRONY ON #2? Some takes might be controversial, but she's still has absolutely nice picks!!1! 🔥🔥
She actually has but I don’t remember her opinion on it. She did say “I think I’ve heard this one before” after it though. I mainly remember how much she LOVED Love Ka because she uses it as an example of how interesting Japanese music is when describing it to friends/family.
It could go either way for any given song tbh. She actually liked Beyond the way when I was sampling songs from each group when we were deciding who to start with.
@@radiatingillumination noo omg i'll cry at kashika slander 😭 but marcemom wont slander like we've seen how she treats the songs she ranks low lol❤ But just imagining Kashika slander hurt lmao
I’m genuinely so curious about how she’s going to feel about those two, especially Fuel. They’re songs I think she could really put in any tier- a lot of VBS is like that actually.
I saw the first song and immediately knew how controversial the list would be 😂 you know the comments section is going to be bad when more than 1/4 of the songs are in F tier. Also, Infinitely Gray broke C tier, that’s the highest a Surii song has placed so far! I appreciate the Cutlery and Jishoumushoku love, and Samsa placing first… honestly it’s really funny lol. Your mom’s pretty based!
I actually find it especially funny that Bug is last and Samsa is 1st place considering how the songs are kinda linked. Bug is becoming computer bug, Samsa a literary reference to transforming into an insect. Two totally different takes on a similar-ish concept and they’re received on the polar opposite ends for her.
I love your mom‘s opinion, it‘s great that you add her personal reviews in, so that we can also relate to her opinion and I also like how she‘s judging the lyrics and instrumentals, not the vocals of the voice actors, bless her heart, I‘m excited for part 3 🫶🏼
What sticks out to me is how she’s mostly unbothered by the NT/SP voices and just accepts them if not actively enjoys their presence like with Niigo KAITO. The fact that she cares about the composition the most is really interesting and that occasionally leads to takes that aren’t necessarily popular (which is also interesting).
i love these videos!! its really interesting to see takes from someone with such a different taste, and i love all her commentaries. im excited for leoneed :D
DOKUZU AND HELLO HOW ARE YOU APPRECIATION LETS GOO!!! this was a fun video to watch! you and your mom put alot of effort into this ❤️ i hope to see boomer mom in future videos! (ranking songs or not)
Oh my god I love that. Don’t be afraid to try branching out a bit if he’s more receptive to slower/faster songs than my mom though (I don’t personally know how 1:1 his taste is with hers, you can probably make that judgement call if you want). I’ve found my mom likes knowing more about the music I listen to so I hope that goes as well for you!
My three fav song being all at least in the top 20 is all i needed to be happy (my favs are hated by life itself , it was a very beautiful june ans zamuza) , the way i very loudly said "OOOH" when zamuza came too
Seeing all my fav songs on F tier hurt me😭(Especially Bug, I Am You, Venom, reborn, AND SPECIFICALLY BLOOM IN THE MUD😭Yeah I can literally write so much more but then the list will be so long lmao😂 Though I really like how your mom actually gave reasoning to why she didn't like the songs💅)
So kinda a funny story, I actually went to family fun farm in my area the day Mizu5 dropped and brought a Mizuki plush I own for photos- because I wanted some happy content of her to share with friends (the photos are also a bit deep on my community tab I think). She knew some Mizu5 lore back then because I had to explain what I was doing, she just didn’t know Bake no Hana was the Mizu5 song at first. She’s been vaguely aware of Sekai for awhile, these videos are making her more actually aware of it.
These are pretty interesting takes. I’m almost worried for VBS but not so much for Leo Need. As for MMJ and VS they are fifty fifty based of these two, but it will be fun to see.
I’ll suggest it to her and hopefully I remember to reply again when she answers. Thanks for providing a possible comparison! I genuinely wasn’t expecting to get one so I appreciate it.
(Seems like I deleted my comment by accident, cuz I can't find it) I'm interested on her thoughts about some of the more "dark" or deppresive lyrics, like maybe Irony or Mind Brand (you already showed her thoughts about Kuyamu To Kaite Mirai and Jishou Mushoku, which I would have included). Aside from that, cool vid that's approved by Deci 🦉🌱👍
I only included what she reacted to in her notes. I do agree further in depth lyric analysis on some would have been nice. My best guess is she became somewhat desensitized listening to them all in a row, probably the biggest flaw with our current system. I would consider spacing it out over days for potentially better notes, but requiring that much obligation out of her is difficult and it’s much easier to book one specific day out of her plans and take long breaks between batches of songs.
So cool that she put zamza at 1, i feel like everyone loves that song and rightfully so it’s my favorite in the whole franchise!! It really can be enjoyed across every generation it’s awesome how both boomers and teenagers can share a love of this song
![BOOMER MOM Ranks ALL Wonderlands×Showtime Songs [AS OF 10/10/24]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/uW6iXy5R_b8/mqdefault.jpg)
![BOOMER MOM Ranks ALL Wonderlands×Showtime Songs [AS OF 10/10/24]](/img/tr.png)
This is the community tab post that lets you vote for the next group we do!:
th-cam.com/channels/vZB_pSx7aPtfWLXVo01ttg.htmlcommunity?lb=UgkxaCg28iNQMLElWihF-nuJBnSsE89jfnIB
i actually really like how your mom explained for each song her opinion on!! that's really nice and doesn't look really biased (??)
True
Yes!! The only reason why i dont hate such a ranking although my fav on F because they give a clear explanation about the song she didnt like, like why she hates it and why she love it and the way she explain it really OBJECTIVE, from the instrumental, vocals, arrangement, etc. It made me enjoy those rankings more. Ppl should make this as example to rank tbh
"I was glad when it was over" for Totemo... The irony...
Ouch.
I was sad it was F teir i like it :(
@@marymoocow7220 joke intended?
Not finished with the video, but I already like how your mother words her opinions, even on songs she dislikes. Despite seeing favorites of mine in F tier, I never once felt bad about seeing them there, because it made perfect sense why and was so clearly a matter of personal taste and opinion. "Bug" IS very chaotic and computery, and if you like that stuff you like it. If you don't like it then you don't. I never felt personally hurt by the placements no matter how "harsh" they were.
Guess I'm saying this because many peer-made song rankings can actually be quite cruel to songs they dislike abd it can sting a bit AHA.
Oh I get that as a peer that ranks. I’m very “THIS COVER MAKES ME ANGRY” about my lowest of lows (my new ranking system has only 3 songs at 1/10 tho so at least I try to keep the amount I feel that way about small), but she’s extremely chill and occasionally even has a positive aspect to bring up about some of her F tiers like Mind Brand’s guitar and Bocca della Verita’s piano. She’s less invested and unfamiliar with any other versions of these songs so she doesn’t feel a need to be as scathing about her least favorites. She’s already inspired me to want to be more positive/less harsh for anything I would consider higher than a 1/10 (I can’t lie about those very few- sorry to anyone that likes them).
marcemom says trans rights
TRANS RIGHTS!!!
YES WAY ❤
This was quite an experience to react to, seeing some of my fav songs on F tier (Give me your night and Kanadetomosusora) hurts a bit but kinda expected them to be in the low tiers after seeing the intro, but also seeing “It was a very beautiful June” in S tier is a win tbh.
Also seeing the amount of songs in the negative tiers being the same as the positives ones is crazy, for some reason, I’m more interested in seeing her takes on Leo/need songs rather than the rest of the groups!!!
17:29 notice how samsa is not hated by anyone
Comparing aishite aishite aishite to Mr. Rodger's neighborhood is absolutely diabolical work your mom is iconic
I think this is the first time i see hello/how are you in a high section of a tierlist. Your mom has really unique and good taste and i like how consistent her description is throughout the whole video so even when some of my favorite songs are on the below level, i'm not even mad because your mother put up a reasonable and understanable explanation for each songs
IT HURTS TO SEE MY BELOVED KANATOMOSORA BEING CALLED ZZZZ UE UE... 😭😭😭
It's expected w the intro but still hurts a lot since that song means a lot to me haha, sorry for being dramatic ;-;
But i can only respect her taste though, slow songs maybe really doesn't click with a lot of people after all lol.
But it genuinely surprised me to see how high 25ji jounetsu and Mushou Jishoku are, even I don't expect Engeki to be that high either :0
Her comment on Villain does really hits deep in heart too...
Thanks for the vid and opinion! Wish you and your mom a nice day/night!
I immediately want more of boomer mom! Her takes are so real!
Unfortunately I can only get her to agree to keep doing these if I space them out by months because it takes many hours to listen to every song, take notes, and then sort them. I’m trying to keep them still relatively close together though because if spaced out too much the discographies are gonna get harder to get through due to size. It’ll probably be March, May, July or August.
@@MarceCloud39she can take as long she wants. Her reasons are good. Especially as she's much older than the target audience of pjsekai and different perspectives are always valuable.
most interesting takes that ive seen but honestly respect some of the takes
I could start crying your mom sounds like such a sweet and caring person I can’t ☹️🙏🙏
SAMSA IS JUST THAT GOOD BABYYYYY!!!! I greatly enjoyed seeing your mom’s thought process, it’s evident that she really tries to give everything a fair shake and is trying to place exactly what she likes/dislikes about a song. Thank you for sharing and editing this all together!
6:57 them being next to each other is crazy
As someone who’s favorite nightcord songs are bug I nan desu venom bitter choco decoration and totemo itai I don’t know how to feel (ni still respect her opinions!)
As someone that ranks Venom as their #8 for all songs in the game with Sekai versions it gave me psychic damage to see her put it there, but I'm okay. It's fine. She can feel that way. She didn't hear a peep out of me because I try not to influence her rankings whatsoever. (at least Gehenna, my #9, is in A rank. the W's outweigh the L's)
15:55 ok we love your mom
Peak opinion
Your mom taste is absolutely AMAZING... cutlery on #18? Charles, It's just life, hello/how are you on top 10?? Also, IRONY ON #2?
Some takes might be controversial, but she's still has absolutely nice picks!!1! 🔥🔥
Rip Mafuyu that's all I have to say
8:32 I want her to hear the original, now. Niigo had the impossible task of matching Ado’s vocals
She actually has but I don’t remember her opinion on it. She did say “I think I’ve heard this one before” after it though. I mainly remember how much she LOVED Love Ka because she uses it as an example of how interesting Japanese music is when describing it to friends/family.
Man, now I'm really curious to how she'll react to VBS, especially their rap heavy songs
It could go either way for any given song tbh. She actually liked Beyond the way when I was sampling songs from each group when we were deciding who to start with.
@@MarceCloud39I’m praying she doesn’t slander kashika or fuel too hard 🙏😭
@@radiatingillumination noo omg i'll cry at kashika slander 😭 but marcemom wont slander like we've seen how she treats the songs she ranks low lol❤
But just imagining Kashika slander hurt lmao
I’m genuinely so curious about how she’s going to feel about those two, especially Fuel. They’re songs I think she could really put in any tier- a lot of VBS is like that actually.
@@MarceCloud39 I’m most scared of ultra c
I saw the first song and immediately knew how controversial the list would be 😂 you know the comments section is going to be bad when more than 1/4 of the songs are in F tier. Also, Infinitely Gray broke C tier, that’s the highest a Surii song has placed so far! I appreciate the Cutlery and Jishoumushoku love, and Samsa placing first… honestly it’s really funny lol. Your mom’s pretty based!
I actually find it especially funny that Bug is last and Samsa is 1st place considering how the songs are kinda linked. Bug is becoming computer bug, Samsa a literary reference to transforming into an insect. Two totally different takes on a similar-ish concept and they’re received on the polar opposite ends for her.
Yoka Ni Mitorete and KanaTomo.. my favorites. You hate to see it..
But in other news, apparently nobody can escape Samsa's clutches, haha.
Very pleased with where It Was A Very Beautiful June landed! Also I really enjoyed her commentary about some of the lyrics, based mom
I love your mom‘s opinion, it‘s great that you add her personal reviews in, so that we can also relate to her opinion and I also like how she‘s judging the lyrics and instrumentals, not the vocals of the voice actors, bless her heart, I‘m excited for part 3 🫶🏼
What sticks out to me is how she’s mostly unbothered by the NT/SP voices and just accepts them if not actively enjoys their presence like with Niigo KAITO. The fact that she cares about the composition the most is really interesting and that occasionally leads to takes that aren’t necessarily popular (which is also interesting).
When I saw THE BEST SONG IN THE WORLD (villain) on tier S and with such a detailed comment, I was ready to kneel before your mom🛐
I’m loving how this comment is accompanied by a Villain pfp
@@MarceCloud39 🙂
Yes, Zamza once again be the best song in N25. Love your mom.
Notice how mother said the high pitched notes in Aishite turned her off, that's def boomer behavior
Zamza never disappoints smh
I really like how your mom referred to Dokuzu as ‘scumbag’ 😄 it seems really funny to me for some reason
i love these videos!! its really interesting to see takes from someone with such a different taste, and i love all her commentaries. im excited for leoneed :D
im crying "donald duck quacks" from cutlery 😭😭
I think seeing Bug and Venom in F tier off the bat gave me whiplash, but big ups to your mom for doing this. Loved her justifications too
I love how admiring the flowers and bake no haha were right next to each other 😭
DOKUZU AND HELLO HOW ARE YOU APPRECIATION LETS GOO!!!
this was a fun video to watch! you and your mom put alot of effort into this ❤️
i hope to see boomer mom in future videos! (ranking songs or not)
I like these videos because now I know what songs I can show to my dad who shares the same music taste
Oh my god I love that. Don’t be afraid to try branching out a bit if he’s more receptive to slower/faster songs than my mom though (I don’t personally know how 1:1 his taste is with hers, you can probably make that judgement call if you want). I’ve found my mom likes knowing more about the music I listen to so I hope that goes as well for you!
Bro Bug, my fav Niigo comm, at the very bottom hurt so bad 😭 🙏🏼 but based on what you said abt her taste at the beginning of the video it made sense
IT WAS A VERY BEAUTIFUL JUNE IS SO UNDERRATED W MOM
Omgah yay!!!! Ive been waiting for this
Nbo and dokuzu in the top 4?? She's got taste! I also loved how she explained everything and showed sm interest
i was worried your mom would put heat abnormal low since she said she didn't like how some songs were too fast, but b tier is actually not bad !!
Iyowa’s compositions are just so good that it’s able to be one of those exceptions. I was worried for it going into this but was pleasantly surprised.
i guessed zamuza will be first before i clicked 🔥🔥
My three fav song being all at least in the top 20 is all i needed to be happy (my favs are hated by life itself , it was a very beautiful june ans zamuza) , the way i very loudly said "OOOH" when zamuza came too
BAKE NO HANA AND ADMIRING THE FLOWERS BEING RIGHT NEXT TO EACH OTHER AND EVEN BEING THE FIRST OF D TIER OMG 💔
Seeing all my fav songs on F tier hurt me😭(Especially Bug, I Am You, Venom, reborn, AND SPECIFICALLY BLOOM IN THE MUD😭Yeah I can literally write so much more but then the list will be so long lmao😂 Though I really like how your mom actually gave reasoning to why she didn't like the songs💅)
I ❤️ your mum she’s so wholesome and she likes Charles and non breath oblige we stan her
6:46 bro you gave your mom the mizu5 lore 😞 also i find it funny that the mizu5 and ena5 songs are right next to each other lol
So kinda a funny story, I actually went to family fun farm in my area the day Mizu5 dropped and brought a Mizuki plush I own for photos- because I wanted some happy content of her to share with friends (the photos are also a bit deep on my community tab I think). She knew some Mizu5 lore back then because I had to explain what I was doing, she just didn’t know Bake no Hana was the Mizu5 song at first. She’s been vaguely aware of Sekai for awhile, these videos are making her more actually aware of it.
I shared Samsa with my dad when it came out, he liked it so much that he put it in his playlist.. Samsa has no enemies
15:45 Wait a minute….. MarceMom is WOKE!?
We stand
Ignoring that my favorite niigo songs are at F, was Bake no Hana and Yoka ni Mitorete being next to each a coincidence lol
i closed the tab as soon as i saw the first song
These are pretty interesting takes. I’m almost worried for VBS but not so much for Leo Need. As for MMJ and VS they are fifty fifty based of these two, but it will be fun to see.
almost all of the songs i love were placed in the bottom 2 tiers😭😭
do vbs plsss!!!!!! ive been dying to see one of those
CHARLES AT A TIER... YOUR MOM IS SO BASEDDDDDD
Tiene todos sus pensamientos claros y decisivos
YOUR GRANDMA IS AMAZING
MARCEMOM HAS TASTEEEE!!
samsa irony and dokuzu being top 3 is SO REALL!??
Just have to say based mom for Samsa, and thank you for Hello how are you mention🗣‼️‼️
now i know how to write a song your mom will love 😁/j
samsa as first is so real
Some were shocking, some were very fair (It was a nice June is peak I'm telling you)
Kanade tomosu sora deichuu ni saku kimi no yoru o Kure and Saisei in “turn it off” yeah I’d never trust her with the aux
I can’t believe Mom doesn’t like Kitty… okay I can but still I love it to much lol
Indonesians when seeing Cat Loving is F tier: 😱
common pinocchiop w
(not gonna talk about how she put reincarnation apple at F...)
NOT SAMSA ALWAYS BEING #1.....(DESERVED.)
to me kanadetomosusora and jishoumushoku go hand in hand so how'd that happen
6:31 'the intro sounds like a computer' HELPP
your mom is goated ngl
help my two favs are first and last😭
The entire experience of watching her place songs was really “it’s so over” “we’re so back” because of things like that. I’m also a big fan of both.
You should do vbs next
15:48 can i hug your mom please
9:16 I always thought hitorinbo envy sounded like lovefool, so maybe that’s what your mom was thinking of?
I’ll suggest it to her and hopefully I remember to reply again when she answers. Thanks for providing a possible comparison! I genuinely wasn’t expecting to get one so I appreciate it.
@ no problem!
marcemom has some based takes ngl
I LOVE DOKUZU TOOO, MS
As someone who loves slow songs, not gonna lie, this list hurt a bit. But it was still interesting to watch nonetheless.
(Seems like I deleted my comment by accident, cuz I can't find it)
I'm interested on her thoughts about some of the more "dark" or deppresive lyrics, like maybe Irony or Mind Brand (you already showed her thoughts about Kuyamu To Kaite Mirai and Jishou Mushoku, which I would have included).
Aside from that, cool vid that's approved by Deci 🦉🌱👍
I only included what she reacted to in her notes. I do agree further in depth lyric analysis on some would have been nice. My best guess is she became somewhat desensitized listening to them all in a row, probably the biggest flaw with our current system. I would consider spacing it out over days for potentially better notes, but requiring that much obligation out of her is difficult and it’s much easier to book one specific day out of her plans and take long breaks between batches of songs.
Samsa wins YET AGAIN FUCK YES
15:48 based mother???
wait what does she mean by tech!!!
She seems like a nice women
your mother is absolutely foul but she's got some great picks. redeemed herself now please adopt me
Old people's type be like
this is literally me
Your mother is based
samsa peak
STOP CAN I BE YOUR DAD
WHAT
W MOM
w mom
So cool that she put zamza at 1, i feel like everyone loves that song and rightfully so it’s my favorite in the whole franchise!! It really can be enjoyed across every generation it’s awesome how both boomers and teenagers can share a love of this song