I personally would love to see a live action Batman trilogy that has Batman’s more fantastical villains. Villains like Man-Bat and Clayface. With todays CGI you can do these characters justice and make them really terrifying.
Seeing how the test screenings for Matt Reeves The Batman called the movie "a psychological horror", I think if in the sequel, a man who has a split personality will bring up the scare factor. Also, maybe throw in Professor Pyg and Hugo Strange for good measure. Also, since they're redoing Riddler, we need a Poison Ivy redo too, right? Make her plants through practical effects that when Batman is investigating them, they trap him in a jump-scare moment.
The ventriloquist honestly used to be one of my favorites because he was so different from all of batman's other villains and the dynamic between the two characters were interesting and make you think "does the puppet have a life of his own"
A nice Detail that I noticed with the Justice League show was in an alternate dimension where the Justice League where dictators known as the Justice Lords in Arkham asylum super man used his heat vision to perform lobotomies on the inmates to make them docile, with the Ventriloquist super man did not lobotomise the Ventriloquist himself but the Puppet Scarface, you can tell because only the puppet has Lobotomy scars.
In my opinion the puppet Scarface is supernatural. The world of Batman has many examples of people with anomalous gifts or powers. Salomon Grundy, Killer Croc, and Poison Ivy are examples of what I see in the Batman universe that allow me to believe Scarface is an anomalous being.
Well it's half and half it's was more so of the mental problems they had and two face was a man of justice then he was scared physically so bad that his mind made him think he was 2 people the ventriloquist was just some guy who always been push around so he made up a puppet to pet his anger into and what he wish he could be even posion ivy wasn't all magical she used the plants chemicals to her advantage she treated plants like crazy cats people she disconnected her self from humanity batman was best when he was just being a detective and instead of killing crazy people who needs help he sent them to the asylum he was grounded to the earth and reality-based problems
they used to always kinda imply that on the old animated series ..theyd make it out like hes just a crazy guy with a puppet then at the end of the episode something strange would happen after capturing him like the puppet would disappear or someone would get shot by the puppet even tho albert was already in custody ...always some weird happening that could only be explained by the puppet being alive somehow.
It would have been a great Easter egg to see the ventriloquist guy being led down the hallway by two ordelies using a white sock using his scarface voice at Arkham in the last scene of jaqiens Phoenix joker.
Scar face is easily one of the best villains from the Batman animated series. He's hilarious when constantly undermining his ventriloquist for not being good enough.
Yeah I was really disappointed that there wasn't a proper fight with him in the Arkham games. Well I mean more like a proper side-mission or story mission.
There was always a creepy almost unnatural undertone to scarface, for one the other inmate was weirdly protective and possessive of the doll while nothing supernatural offhand the guy seemed almost betrayed possibly why he attacked the puppet in the struggle as well as Wesker. To top off the weirdness scale the fact that the doll does eventually change hands to a new ventriloquist a couple of times after poor Wesker bites it, the doll seems to know things that the new "dummies" shouldn't know about like it has its own memories. Not sure if the comics covered it, but the cartoon pointed out that the voices coming out of wesker were as if they are two different people with no similarities, which was bizarre, and why batman thought wesker had some secret boss only to find a puppet. While wesker most definitely had his own issues that sadly never got addressed (mostly due to status quo writing sadly) scarface ended up being an enigma in of himself.
The ventriloquist has always been the creepiest and most frightening batman villain. I remember watching Batman tas and get so scared when something weird implied scarface was alive. Very underrated villain
My personal headcanon is that the puppet was not originally supernatural. It was all a form of alternate personality disorder. However after a prolonged time of Wesker using Scarface the puppet took on a life of its own. His alternate personality in some anomalous way infected the puppet and was able to live on after Arther
Theory: Arnold's multiple personality disorder may have an undertone of supernaturalism. Example: If the puppet was carved from the very same wood as when Calpone was hung from, his spirit could have been attached to the device/scaffolding. Then when a piece was used for the puppet, it coalesced into that one piece and emitted an aura that made his "creator/caretaker" want to protect him in every way and when he (spirit of Capone) found a weak willed but someone filled with hidden rage, he jumped to a new host. Used his new host to continue his criminal campaign.
Basically you say that both Arnold and Reiner (Rhino?) are mediums of considerable power who were influenced by some ghost inside of the wood that Scarface was carved out of? yeah, seems reasonable.
@@mrziiz6893 This does not exclude my theory. There is a precedent in fiction for powerful mediums falling prey to the ghost or spectre of something powerful.
@@alexs5814 Well it sounded like you were using that interpretation to justify saying that it is unreasonable, and I was simply offering an interpretation that isn’t unreasonable according to your interpretation
Batman lost most of his charm when he joined the other superpowered beings in the justice league. To make him a viable mainstay member of JLA they had to make him have some sort of superpower so now he was this super genius martial artist with answers to every question in existence. He could just look at a problem and come up with a solution. This took a lot out of the whole "great detective" part. And it also meant that Batman had power scaled way beyond most of his rogues gallery (who were normal humans or as close as they could be). Batman fought alongside superman punching aliens on the face now what is riddler compared to that. So he becomes a joke character rather than the dangerous trickster he was before. Penguin is no longer a kingpin of crime but a plot device. And it goes on and on...
After YEARS of seeing villains like the Joker, I loved the years of Don Newton & Norm Breyfogle. They introduced weird fresh villains like Killer Croc and the Ventriloquist.
I would love to see him, manbat and clayface make their way into a live action big budget movie/movies. It’s amazing that they haven’t been used at all yet!
I like the idea that Wesker's personality disorder and his desire to avoid accountability for his own evil thoughts and actions made him extra susceptible to subtle supernatural influences of the cursed doll, and that over the years of being a focus for his dark subconscious, it has grown strong and independent enough to take control of other weak-willed people and perhaps even manipulate fate in order to get into their hands.
He was always one of my favorites. While I didn't care for his aesthetic in The Batman, I did like that Wesker was formerly a skilled professional Ventriloquist before he snapped, casually drinking a glass of water while Scarface talked about his plans.
Gotham City is known for having the type of criminals that would often make you loose hope in Humanity, or make you question if they’re even Human at all.
He’s definitely one of my favorite minor Batman villains and I wish he showed up more often in things. I remember feeling bad for him in both of the different animated adaptations I saw as a kid.
I’d love for dc to bring this villian to life on the big screen. It can be soooo dark and even scary. It would be perfect for theatres, Nolan would’ve did him justice.
Batman has the greatest comic book villains, yet there's still some the go completely underutilized. The Ventriloquist is a pretty tragic character with SO MUCH potential, imagine a solo film about him like Joker (2019).
He's super interesting, but I don't think he would fit well as the main antagonist, having to carry the majority of a blockbuster... I see him as a very effective 2nd villain, like Harvey Dent in the Dark Knight.
Funny detail about the Ventriloquist In the Justice League arc featuring the Justice Lords, our heroes visit an Arkham Asylum where all of the Rogue's gallery have had lobotomies on their brains to make them tame, indicated by dots on their forehead. But when you see The Ventriloquist, it's Scarface that has the telltale signs of a lobotomy.
We dont call it multiple personality disorder anymore, we use dissociative identity disorder. He doesnt have mutiple personalities, his trauma forces his subconscious to dissociate his identity as a result of this particular conversion disorder.
I think it was a slight mixture of both. I think that Capone's soul wasn't in the doll. But since it was from the gallow that killed him (and likely many others) it had the ability to absorb souls. And since Albert poured so much of himself into it as Scarface, that's what it absorbed. Becoming it's own entity, albeit one that needs a host/puppet.
You forgot to mention that, in the continuation of BTAS it was proved that Scarface was just a puppet and wasn't supernatural, + the ventriloquist was redeemed in the end when Batman caught the guy who was messing with the puppet.
I always thought that Wesker might've been a little Scizophrenic, as well potentially having the dummy be a sort of personality that manifested from some deep reaches of his mind. Especially when in a lot of iterations, he seems to genuinely believe that Scarface is a sentient being of sorts.
When hes quiet and all souless,and the doll is doing the madness thats when its the most terrifying in my eyes... because you see an old nice man with an angry doll,and you know all that crazy shit comes from that nice looking man
What if he started as a non-Supernatural, but through time developed into a Tsukumogami (Object based Yokai)? With a long enough infusion of Arthur's bad Psyche, he became a creature all his own.
For the longest time i am convinced that the Ventriloquist and dummy are completely separate individuals. Whenever they run, shoot, or do any outrageous stunts; Scarface would not even flinch, and the Ventriloquist would often brace, or tremble in fear, even though he is supposedly doing them on his own.
Scarface could be something that started as natural and became supernatural over time. Wesker imbued the doll with personality to the extent that others viewed it as alive (rhino is a good example) so it could be that it became 'haunted' in a way
Can’t help but note that if the Ventriloquist, with just a dual personality gives Batman trouble, imagine how he’ll feel if he ever crosses paths with Marvel’s Moon Knight, who has 3! (5 if we account for Moon Knight as another persona, and when Khonshu opts to Personally control MK to take matters in his hands.)
This was so well done on the Gotham Series. So many of these origin stories finally had the time to breathe. You got to know the characters before they became big-time villains and in some cases before they became villains at all.
There is no supervillain as bizzare as the Ventriloquist? Really? What about Condement King? He has a gun that shoots ketchup and mustard. Or The Kangaroo? A villain with the power to jump slightly higher than a normal person?
Or the eraser, a guy who dresses in a pencil colored striped suit, wears pointy graphite shoes, and an eraser helmet that removes all forensic evidence of crime. Not gonna lie I kinda love his gimmick and want him to make a comeback. Make him the next kite man.
I think my favorite scene with him is in Justice League during Justice Lords ark. We see all Batman's enemies have been rounded up to Arkham, and have all been lobotomized by Superman. Scarface has the markings while the Ventriloquist doesn't. Both are sitting as well behaved as other inmates.
In the Telltale Batman Series there was an interesting take on The Ventriloquist where Scarface was a sock Puppet and was hinted at as the Ventriloquist's reaction to bullying and abuse at a young age, where Scarface would be a sort of bodyguard to scare off people who would want to hurt him. It would be interesting to have a Scarface that genuinely cares about The Ventriloquist, too bad they only got a small amount of screentime
Kind of looks like the ambiguity of supernatural or just a delusion is a cool part of the character. Maybe best kept as an unopened Schroeder's Cat, where it is both simultaneously.
I would LOVE to see a live-action adaptation of Scarface. The mystery of not knowing whether the ventriloquist was actually controlling Scarface or if Scarface was supernatural made the whole character creepy and unnerving. I don't think I'd want a definitive answer if the character was brought to the screen.
John Lithgow, Sean Penn, and Martin Short Would made Great and Brilliant Academy Award Nominated, Oscar Nominated, And Tony Award Winning Actors to Bring The Character Of Arnold Wesker to life in live Action Batman Movie series while Mark Hamill, John Vickery, and John Noble would made Great Emmy Award winning Voice Actors for Scarface
Same thing with calendar man, he actually goes through a death and rebirth process depending on the seasons of the year effectively making him immortal. He also exhibits a number skills that make him dangerous like a high level, near genius intellect, and has exceptional hand to hand combat skills.
hey just to shout out that ventriloquist is featured in a brazilian batman fan movie called in the pshychosis of the ventriloquist, u can find it with english subtitltes online and is a really phylosopy driven history with pretty good tone, something that we dont see that much specially in fan things, this movie has a full short movie lenght also
You mentioned him not having powers and honestly I really like that. I hate how much superheroes nowadays are compared to god's. I'm much more like the down to earth pulp type of characters where they have a gimmick, and they're definitely fantastical, but they're not necessarily superhuman.
All the villains in this series are so much better than any movie can portray them. They all have an epic soundtrack played by a full orchestra. I think the penguin has maybe the best soundtrack of all in this series.
Imo it would make sense if Wesker's backstory was one were he was the heir of a mob family, not only for the theme of Scarface but to explain how he has the know-how to conduct a life of crime, I prefer to rely on a psychological explanation who is more in line with the Batman's rogue gallery than a supernatural one.
I think the point is we don't know whats going on. Honestly it would make for a sad character for this weak guy to be forced into crime by a magic puppet and everyone thinks he is lying even he isn't sure.
So my opinion is that Scarface is supernatural. Being carved from gallow's wood and retaining the spirit of a once powerful gangster makes sense in storytelling and makes for a more compelling plot device. Scarface primarily operates with people who are mentally unstable because they are probably easier for him to control/manipulate or are somehow more prone to witnessing/encountering/interacting with the supernatural.
Growing up I thought the dummy was controlling him which I thought was cool but as I grew up I understood that Batman villains are basically demented people which made it super interesting and got into learning phycology
Dunno but I think he is supernatural/possessed because in the Animated Series: when Scarface returns and stalks Arnold - doesn't he call Arnold from a phone booth? He talks to Arnold and you can clearly hear the typical phone-static noise and Batman listens to this conversation (hearing this as well). Is Arnold THAT good with the voice that he imitates the phone static noise?
Great video! I hope to see more of this character in future Batman projects. Btw You were saying penguin and Oswald but Oswald is the penguin. The other guy was the riddler.
Imagine a cyberpunk or more supernatural version of him where he either like has creepy cybernetic scarface like puppet he uses via cybernetics that are like intrusive and stuff or him being like a creepy entertainer/carnival worler like dude who would just uses his physic or supernatural powers to animate the scarface puppet and like while he does he just kinda floats and twitches
In some of the comics they hint at Scarface being a haunted puppet but they leave it really vague, and i think that the the possibility of either it's the most unsettling part
As much as I like the Joker; other villians need to appear in a Batman live action movie. Even Poison Ivy and Catwoman have been done to death and brought back in the Lazarus pit. In the next Batman sequel Scarface would be perfect in th Pattinson version. Keep with the detective style and mix it up with Batman going against the mafia crimelords and use a redhood story that leads to a young Joker taking the hood. Jump a few years in a third film and we now see Jason Todd wearing it taking on the Black Mask.
13:36 you must mean he went to meet Penguin aka Oswald and Riddler aka Edvard, not "Penguin and Oswald" :) Thank you for the video ! PS: Watching Gothama as finnish and having big nose i imagined i was penguing the series, the 1 true time Penguin was about to die was in hands of Ventriloquist
Batman separated a recording of their voices and he couldn't match them. The Ventriloquist is so supernaturally far off himself when being Scarface that even his voice masking basically is just a different voice that he can somehow reproduce throught the puppet.
What the video doesn't seem to mention is that we've seen two main versions of the scarface puppet. One is based in the 1930s movie and modelled after Paul Muni and Edward G. Robinson. The other is based on the 1980s movie and is modelled after Al Pacino.
Another interesting character in Batman universe. Is the blind psychic from Dark knight: Blink comic. As far as I know, that's been his only appearance.But, he a worth while character that should be brought back.
I like this villain simply because I enjoy the psychological stuff way, way more than the paranormal. Plus puppets. I love puppets. So the combination of the two (with mild theoretical supernatural elements) is just such a perfect combination for me.
It was pretty funny in the original animated series when Batman threw his voice to sound like Wesker insulting Scarface, and Scarface asked Wesker what did he say? Wesker said he didn't say anything because his lips didn't move. Scarface said "so what? You're a ventriloquist!" That's why Batman has the best villains.
I like it when Scarface is just a puppet. If it had some supernatural thing going on it just takes merit from the ventriloquist. When it's just his talent it makes you think how seriously messed up that is.
Every time I hear “Arnold Wesker” all I can think of is “Albert Wesker” from Resident Evil. The idea of Albert having a puppet of himself is extremely hilarious considering how serious he is despite talking exactly like a comic book villain
I kept waiting for him to show up in Nolan's Batman Trilogy. The character was practically built for his style and take on characterization. He's a walking psychological thriller.
The ventriloquist is a character foil of Batman If Batman has a hold on Bruce Wayne’s life The same can be said for the dummy who has a hold on the dummy
Ventriloquist is a cold killer - no guilt, no remorse. TOTALLY detached from his behavior, no matter how dangerous, murderous, destructive, or just plain gangsta it is. He got that smoke if you want it, and will act like he aint did a thing when its all over...smh.. CERTIFIED CRAZY
I think this would be one of my favorite villains if it weren't for the whole DID thing. I've found some people with it, and they all hate the trope and the reputation it left on them.
I personally would love to see a live action Batman trilogy that has Batman’s more fantastical villains. Villains like Man-Bat and Clayface. With todays CGI you can do these characters justice and make them really terrifying.
I've been wanting clay face forever.
Yes!! The ventriloquist, Clayface, manbat. All dark sinister villians that would kill if they were brought to life on the big screen
Seeing how the test screenings for Matt Reeves The Batman called the movie "a psychological horror", I think if in the sequel, a man who has a split personality will bring up the scare factor. Also, maybe throw in Professor Pyg and Hugo Strange for good measure.
Also, since they're redoing Riddler, we need a Poison Ivy redo too, right? Make her plants through practical effects that when Batman is investigating them, they trap him in a jump-scare moment.
Just write them well is all I ask
I would kill for the continuation of the Dark Knight trilogy
The ventriloquist honestly used to be one of my favorites because he was so different from all of batman's other villains and the dynamic between the two characters were interesting and make you think "does the puppet have a life of his own"
Robin Williams would have been the perfect Ventriloquist
@@HistoriaenCeluloide True
A nice Detail that I noticed with the Justice League show was in an alternate dimension where the Justice League where dictators known as the Justice Lords in Arkham asylum super man used his heat vision to perform lobotomies on the inmates to make them docile, with the Ventriloquist super man did not lobotomise the Ventriloquist himself but the Puppet Scarface, you can tell because only the puppet has Lobotomy scars.
Woah 😧
here is the clip th-cam.com/video/3LxCbgTdSCU/w-d-xo.html
Such a creepy scene. Poison Ivy cutting the bushes out front.
I watched the episode and I noticed there were dots on their foreheads but I had no idea that Super Man did that to them like holy shit man
In my opinion the puppet Scarface is supernatural. The world of Batman has many examples of people with anomalous gifts or powers. Salomon Grundy, Killer Croc, and Poison Ivy are examples of what I see in the Batman universe that allow me to believe Scarface is an anomalous being.
Well it's half and half it's was more so of the mental problems they had and two face was a man of justice then he was scared physically so bad that his mind made him think he was 2 people the ventriloquist was just some guy who always been push around so he made up a puppet to pet his anger into and what he wish he could be even posion ivy wasn't all magical she used the plants chemicals to her advantage she treated plants like crazy cats people she disconnected her self from humanity batman was best when he was just being a detective and instead of killing crazy people who needs help he sent them to the asylum he was grounded to the earth and reality-based problems
they used to always kinda imply that on the old animated series ..theyd make it out like hes just a crazy guy with a puppet then at the end of the episode something strange would happen after capturing him like the puppet would disappear or someone would get shot by the puppet even tho albert was already in custody ...always some weird happening that could only be explained by the puppet being alive somehow.
So dude is possessed?
That makes no sense and it's better having him with a split personality hence the ventriloquist
@@jasonsamons6700 dude there's no supernatural all those instances were his thugs getting him back or hugo strange doing his thing.
The Ventriloquist is a very underrated character, and I’d love to see him appear in a movie one day.
Wont mind seeing him in the batman 2.maybe a smaller role like the penguin in this one.
I remember him from the Batman animated series from the 90’s.
It would have been a great Easter egg to see the ventriloquist guy being led down the hallway by two ordelies using a white sock using his scarface voice at Arkham in the last scene of jaqiens Phoenix joker.
If the Robert Pattinson/Matt Reeves film does well, I think The Ventriloquist would fit well in a potential sequel.
*spoiler alert*
The Ventriloquist is teased in Season 3 Episode 5 of "Titans"
Scar face is easily one of the best villains from the Batman animated series. He's hilarious when constantly undermining his ventriloquist for not being good enough.
Bro this was the best thing on after school
You just wait til they join forces with the Puppet King, Mojo Jojo, Fuzzy Lumpkins, Him, and Princess Morbucks
Even Batman's unpopular villains are cool..that's why he's got the best rogue gallery of all time
Kite man And crazy quilt
True
Condiment King is absolutely legendary
Spawn villains....
Very underused , underestinated and brilliant villain that needs to be used more in batman games, films etc
Yeah I was really disappointed that there wasn't a proper fight with him in the Arkham games. Well I mean more like a proper side-mission or story mission.
And I was upset that they killed him of in Titants for no reason.
There was always a creepy almost unnatural undertone to scarface, for one the other inmate was weirdly protective and possessive of the doll while nothing supernatural offhand the guy seemed almost betrayed possibly why he attacked the puppet in the struggle as well as Wesker. To top off the weirdness scale the fact that the doll does eventually change hands to a new ventriloquist a couple of times after poor Wesker bites it, the doll seems to know things that the new "dummies" shouldn't know about like it has its own memories. Not sure if the comics covered it, but the cartoon pointed out that the voices coming out of wesker were as if they are two different people with no similarities, which was bizarre, and why batman thought wesker had some secret boss only to find a puppet. While wesker most definitely had his own issues that sadly never got addressed (mostly due to status quo writing sadly) scarface ended up being an enigma in of himself.
enigma* ... like the riddler's name = e. nigma
There's a story in which a dying Wesker and a smashed Scarface have a conversation without Wesker's hands on the puppet.
The puppet also kills some people at one point without being attached, so it's implied to actually be possessed or something.
The ventriloquist has always been the creepiest and most frightening batman villain. I remember watching Batman tas and get so scared when something weird implied scarface was alive. Very underrated villain
When was it implied he was alive
My personal headcanon is that the puppet was not originally supernatural. It was all a form of alternate personality disorder. However after a prolonged time of Wesker using Scarface the puppet took on a life of its own. His alternate personality in some anomalous way infected the puppet and was able to live on after Arther
Theory: Arnold's multiple personality disorder may have an undertone of supernaturalism.
Example: If the puppet was carved from the very same wood as when Calpone was hung from, his spirit could have been attached to the device/scaffolding. Then when a piece was used for the puppet, it coalesced into that one piece and emitted an aura that made his "creator/caretaker" want to protect him in every way and when he (spirit of Capone) found a weak willed but someone filled with hidden rage, he jumped to a new host. Used his new host to continue his criminal campaign.
Basically you say that both Arnold and Reiner (Rhino?) are mediums of considerable power who were influenced by some ghost inside of the wood that Scarface was carved out of?
yeah, seems reasonable.
I like that. I feel like it’d play best always leaving that part ambiguous. Leaving us to wonder if Wesker is a schitzo or if Scarface is supernatural
@@alexs5814 more like the puppet is haunted by the spirit of Calpone is the case in this theory
@@mrziiz6893 This does not exclude my theory. There is a precedent in fiction for powerful mediums falling prey to the ghost or spectre of something powerful.
@@alexs5814 Well it sounded like you were using that interpretation to justify saying that it is unreasonable, and I was simply offering an interpretation that isn’t unreasonable according to your interpretation
Batman lost most of his charm when he joined the other superpowered beings in the justice league. To make him a viable mainstay member of JLA they had to make him have some sort of superpower so now he was this super genius martial artist with answers to every question in existence. He could just look at a problem and come up with a solution. This took a lot out of the whole "great detective" part. And it also meant that Batman had power scaled way beyond most of his rogues gallery (who were normal humans or as close as they could be). Batman fought alongside superman punching aliens on the face now what is riddler compared to that. So he becomes a joke character rather than the dangerous trickster he was before. Penguin is no longer a kingpin of crime but a plot device. And it goes on and on...
I don't know why DC didn't think of a gang war story of him with Two-Face and Black Mask. They are all ruthless crime lords with identity crises.
They did, they all ran different gangs during "no man's land arc"
@@chrismorel8613yeah but everyone did in no man's land
It's no war of jokes and riddles
Alright one of Batman's underrated villains! We need this villain in a video game or movie
After YEARS of seeing villains like the Joker, I loved the years of Don Newton & Norm Breyfogle. They introduced weird fresh villains like Killer Croc and the Ventriloquist.
I would love to see him, manbat and clayface make their way into a live action big budget movie/movies. It’s amazing that they haven’t been used at all yet!
Clayface was scary in the animated series
I like the idea that Wesker's personality disorder and his desire to avoid accountability for his own evil thoughts and actions made him extra susceptible to subtle supernatural influences of the cursed doll, and that over the years of being a focus for his dark subconscious, it has grown strong and independent enough to take control of other weak-willed people and perhaps even manipulate fate in order to get into their hands.
He was always one of my favorites. While I didn't care for his aesthetic in The Batman, I did like that Wesker was formerly a skilled professional Ventriloquist before he snapped, casually drinking a glass of water while Scarface talked about his plans.
Neither did I, but if it helps, I think he's supposed to be based on the Al Pacino version of Scarface.
It's a shame the TV show Gotham didn't do more with his character especially how they set him up so well.
Ikr or the pyg
Gotham City is known for having the type of criminals that would often make you loose hope in Humanity, or make you question if they’re even Human at all.
Or: They show the ugly the bad side of Humanity.
He’s definitely one of my favorite minor Batman villains and I wish he showed up more often in things. I remember feeling bad for him in both of the different animated adaptations I saw as a kid.
The Ventriloquist is my favorite Batman villain! He’s such an amazing and creative character! I really hope they show up in a movie! ❤️❤️🤞🤞
I’d love for dc to bring this villian to life on the big screen. It can be soooo dark and even scary. It would be perfect for theatres, Nolan would’ve did him justice.
Rated R
Those Nolan movies are so overrated and boring
@@JesseVenturaHat sorry I don’t speak wrong
I like how he was cured in the DCAU. He reappeared as a cameo in the Justice League episode where they're abducted by the Justice Lords.
I think the Ventriloquist should appear in one of Batman's movies!
Batman has the greatest comic book villains, yet there's still some the go completely underutilized. The Ventriloquist is a pretty tragic character with SO MUCH potential, imagine a solo film about him like Joker (2019).
DC should make a bunch of solo villain films
He's super interesting, but I don't think he would fit well as the main antagonist, having to carry the majority of a blockbuster... I see him as a very effective 2nd villain, like Harvey Dent in the Dark Knight.
Funny detail about the Ventriloquist
In the Justice League arc featuring the Justice Lords, our heroes visit an Arkham Asylum where all of the Rogue's gallery have had lobotomies on their brains to make them tame, indicated by dots on their forehead.
But when you see The Ventriloquist, it's Scarface that has the telltale signs of a lobotomy.
We dont call it multiple personality disorder anymore, we use dissociative identity disorder. He doesnt have mutiple personalities, his trauma forces his subconscious to dissociate his identity as a result of this particular conversion disorder.
Exactly.
Problem is that it’s comics and mental health. Not the best pairing.
It's always been bs either way.
I think it was a slight mixture of both.
I think that Capone's soul wasn't in the doll. But since it was from the gallow that killed him (and likely many others) it had the ability to absorb souls.
And since Albert poured so much of himself into it as Scarface, that's what it absorbed. Becoming it's own entity, albeit one that needs a host/puppet.
You forgot to mention that, in the continuation of BTAS it was proved that Scarface was just a puppet and wasn't supernatural, + the ventriloquist was redeemed in the end when Batman caught the guy who was messing with the puppet.
Interesting character, I'd never heard of the Ventriloquist before. I'd love to see him in a live action movie and the v.o. 'voices' in his head.
I always thought that Wesker might've been a little Scizophrenic, as well potentially having the dummy be a sort of personality that manifested from some deep reaches of his mind. Especially when in a lot of iterations, he seems to genuinely believe that Scarface is a sentient being of sorts.
When hes quiet and all souless,and the doll is doing the madness thats when its the most terrifying in my eyes... because you see an old nice man with an angry doll,and you know all that crazy shit comes from that nice looking man
I would like to see him used the same way Nolan used Dr. Crane (Scarecrow). A secondary villain in a movie that keeps showing up in subsequent movies.
What if he started as a non-Supernatural, but through time developed into a Tsukumogami (Object based Yokai)? With a long enough infusion of Arthur's bad Psyche, he became a creature all his own.
Seeing how they made a amazing movie out of the Joker and his whole background. What about scarface? Maybe they could do something like that with him.
For the longest time i am convinced that the Ventriloquist and dummy are completely separate individuals. Whenever they run, shoot, or do any outrageous stunts; Scarface would not even flinch, and the Ventriloquist would often brace, or tremble in fear, even though he is supposedly doing them on his own.
Scarface could be something that started as natural and became supernatural over time.
Wesker imbued the doll with personality to the extent that others viewed it as alive (rhino is a good example) so it could be that it became 'haunted' in a way
This “guy” used to give me the creeps when I was a kid
Can’t help but note that if the Ventriloquist, with just a dual personality gives Batman trouble, imagine how he’ll feel if he ever crosses paths with Marvel’s Moon Knight, who has 3! (5 if we account for Moon Knight as another persona, and when Khonshu opts to Personally control MK to take matters in his hands.)
Or Crazy Jane lol 😆 even tho Bats is aware of her.
It's fine, Batman probably has Bat-Ketamine in his utility belt for just such an occasion.
Moon knight started as marvels batman k/o and with his last couple reboots has become marvels ragman.
This was so well done on the Gotham Series. So many of these origin stories finally had the time to breathe. You got to know the characters before they became big-time villains and in some cases before they became villains at all.
A live action Batman movie with the Ventriloquist as the main villain would be amazing if done right.
There is no supervillain as bizzare as the Ventriloquist? Really?
What about Condement King? He has a gun that shoots ketchup and mustard.
Or The Kangaroo? A villain with the power to jump slightly higher than a normal person?
Mr banjo... weasel. Actually most the people that has been in the suicide squad
What about Big Wheel
Or the eraser, a guy who dresses in a pencil colored striped suit, wears pointy graphite shoes, and an eraser helmet that removes all forensic evidence of crime.
Not gonna lie I kinda love his gimmick and want him to make a comeback. Make him the next kite man.
dogwelder is batshit insane
If they are gonna do villain movies like joker then they should definitely do one for this guy
I think my favorite scene with him is in Justice League during Justice Lords ark. We see all Batman's enemies have been rounded up to Arkham, and have all been lobotomized by Superman. Scarface has the markings while the Ventriloquist doesn't. Both are sitting as well behaved as other inmates.
I always found this character very disturbing but also oddly empathetic. I always felt sorry for his puppeteer.
In the Telltale Batman Series there was an interesting take on The Ventriloquist where Scarface was a sock Puppet and was hinted at as the Ventriloquist's reaction to bullying and abuse at a young age, where Scarface would be a sort of bodyguard to scare off people who would want to hurt him. It would be interesting to have a Scarface that genuinely cares about The Ventriloquist, too bad they only got a small amount of screentime
The batman is so underrated it's criminal. It had different designs for it's characters, and the music was on point.
This is what I have been saying for years! This villain deserves a movie spot!
I remember watching an episode of this villain in Batman the animated series and it creeped me the hell out.😨😰😱
which Batman series specifically? I would love to see it
@@kai-cv9ws batman the animated series
Kind of looks like the ambiguity of supernatural or just a delusion is a cool part of the character. Maybe best kept as an unopened Schroeder's Cat, where it is both simultaneously.
I would LOVE to see a live-action adaptation of Scarface. The mystery of not knowing whether the ventriloquist was actually controlling Scarface or if Scarface was supernatural made the whole character creepy and unnerving. I don't think I'd want a definitive answer if the character was brought to the screen.
John Lithgow, Sean Penn, and Martin Short Would made Great and Brilliant Academy Award Nominated, Oscar Nominated, And Tony Award Winning Actors to Bring The Character Of Arnold Wesker to life in live Action Batman Movie series while Mark Hamill, John Vickery, and John Noble would made Great Emmy Award winning Voice Actors for Scarface
This guy needs to be in the next The Batman movie. Perfect villain, if you're trying to stay away from the fantastical.
Same thing with calendar man, he actually goes through a death and rebirth process depending on the seasons of the year effectively making him immortal. He also exhibits a number skills that make him dangerous like a high level, near genius intellect, and has exceptional hand to hand combat skills.
hey just to shout out that ventriloquist is featured in a brazilian batman fan movie called in the pshychosis of the ventriloquist, u can find it with english subtitltes online and is a really phylosopy driven history with pretty good tone, something that we dont see that much specially in fan things, this movie has a full short movie lenght also
You mentioned him not having powers and honestly I really like that. I hate how much superheroes nowadays are compared to god's. I'm much more like the down to earth pulp type of characters where they have a gimmick, and they're definitely fantastical, but they're not necessarily superhuman.
I dont know id say The Ventriloquist, Scarecrow, Professor Pig, Doll maker and The joker are all warped.
1:51
Stockinged foot.
All the villains in this series are so much better than any movie can portray them. They all have an epic soundtrack played by a full orchestra. I think the penguin has maybe the best soundtrack of all in this series.
Imo it would make sense if Wesker's backstory was one were he was the heir of a mob family, not only for the theme of Scarface but to explain how he has the know-how to conduct a life of crime, I prefer to rely on a psychological explanation who is more in line with the Batman's rogue gallery than a supernatural one.
I think the point is we don't know whats going on. Honestly it would make for a sad character for this weak guy to be forced into crime by a magic puppet and everyone thinks he is lying even he isn't sure.
I mean..if you look at the history of the mafia there are a lot of non italian and nob-mob family people in it lol...
So my opinion is that Scarface is supernatural. Being carved from gallow's wood and retaining the spirit of a once powerful gangster makes sense in storytelling and makes for a more compelling plot device. Scarface primarily operates with people who are mentally unstable because they are probably easier for him to control/manipulate or are somehow more prone to witnessing/encountering/interacting with the supernatural.
Finally someone who enjoys and appreciates the Ventriloquist as much as i do .. Thanks for the vid
My favourite line from scarface "Who you calling dummy dummy!"
Ventriloquist is a character you can do a ton with. I'd argue good enough to be a character study in a standalone film, similar to The Joker.
Growing up I thought the dummy was controlling him which I thought was cool but as I grew up I understood that Batman villains are basically demented people which made it super interesting and got into learning phycology
You should also make a Video about DCs Professor Pyg or Dollmaker
Dunno but I think he is supernatural/possessed because in the Animated Series: when Scarface returns and stalks Arnold - doesn't he call Arnold from a phone booth? He talks to Arnold and you can clearly hear the typical phone-static noise and Batman listens to this conversation (hearing this as well). Is Arnold THAT good with the voice that he imitates the phone static noise?
Great video! I hope to see more of this character in future Batman projects. Btw You were saying penguin and Oswald but Oswald is the penguin. The other guy was the riddler.
I notice most of Batman's top villian's suffer from some form of insanity. That's why their in Arkham Asylum instead of normal prison's.
Imagine a cyberpunk or more supernatural version of him where he either like has creepy cybernetic scarface like puppet he uses via cybernetics that are like intrusive and stuff or him being like a creepy entertainer/carnival worler like dude who would just uses his physic or supernatural powers to animate the scarface puppet and like while he does he just kinda floats and twitches
In some of the comics they hint at Scarface being a haunted puppet but they leave it really vague, and i think that the the possibility of either it's the most unsettling part
As much as I like the Joker; other villians need to appear in a Batman live action movie. Even Poison Ivy and Catwoman have been done to death and brought back in the Lazarus pit. In the next Batman sequel Scarface would be perfect in th Pattinson version. Keep with the detective style and mix it up with Batman going against the mafia crimelords and use a redhood story that leads to a young Joker taking the hood. Jump a few years in a third film and we now see Jason Todd wearing it taking on the Black Mask.
Keep it up on your work and this channel
13:36 you must mean he went to meet Penguin aka Oswald and Riddler aka Edvard, not "Penguin and Oswald" :) Thank you for the video ! PS: Watching Gothama as finnish and having big nose i imagined i was penguing the series, the 1 true time Penguin was about to die was in hands of Ventriloquist
One of my favorite villains cus it's grounded in reality
I want to see the ventriloquist and THe MAD HATTER in a Batman movie!
I can see John Lithgow playing the Ventriloquist...
The way I see it, Scarface was a persona created by Wesker as well as an only friend.
This channel is underrated
Batman separated a recording of their voices and he couldn't match them. The Ventriloquist is so supernaturally far off himself when being Scarface that even his voice masking basically is just a different voice that he can somehow reproduce throught the puppet.
What the video doesn't seem to mention is that we've seen two main versions of the scarface puppet. One is based in the 1930s movie and modelled after Paul Muni and Edward G. Robinson. The other is based on the 1980s movie and is modelled after Al Pacino.
Another interesting character in Batman universe. Is the blind psychic from Dark knight: Blink comic.
As far as I know, that's been his only appearance.But, he a worth while character that should be brought back.
I like this villain simply because I enjoy the psychological stuff way, way more than the paranormal. Plus puppets. I love puppets. So the combination of the two (with mild theoretical supernatural elements) is just such a perfect combination for me.
It was pretty funny in the original animated series when Batman threw his voice to sound like Wesker insulting Scarface, and Scarface asked Wesker what did he say? Wesker said he didn't say anything because his lips didn't move. Scarface said "so what? You're a ventriloquist!" That's why Batman has the best villains.
I like it when Scarface is just a puppet. If it had some supernatural thing going on it just takes merit from the ventriloquist. When it's just his talent it makes you think how seriously messed up that is.
Every time I hear “Arnold Wesker” all I can think of is “Albert Wesker” from Resident Evil. The idea of Albert having a puppet of himself is extremely hilarious considering how serious he is despite talking exactly like a comic book villain
Lol I love how in Justice League animated scarface got lobotomized by Justice lord Superman but not the ventriloquist.
I love how most Batman villains suffer from some sort of disorder. In my opinion, it’s what makes them so evil and such great villains
The Ventriloquist? I only knew him as Scar face.
I wouldn’t say he’s the most underrated, but he’s definitely the most underrated
i love how the version with the earrings (The Batman) is just Dan Castellaneta doing Krusty the Clown's voice
Was so badass on Gotham he should've been the main villain of the season
Could you do more videos on lesser known villains this was a fun video.
I kept waiting for him to show up in Nolan's Batman Trilogy. The character was practically built for his style and take on characterization. He's a walking psychological thriller.
The ventriloquist is a character foil of Batman
If Batman has a hold on Bruce Wayne’s life
The same can be said for the dummy who has a hold on the dummy
I'm surprised he didn't become Albatrossman.
Ventriloquist is a cold killer - no guilt, no remorse. TOTALLY detached from his behavior, no matter how dangerous, murderous, destructive, or just plain gangsta it is. He got that smoke if you want it, and will act like he aint did a thing when its all over...smh.. CERTIFIED CRAZY
I think this would be one of my favorite villains if it weren't for the whole DID thing. I've found some people with it, and they all hate the trope and the reputation it left on them.