Jaguar XKR vs Corvette C5 - V8 Muscle Shootout! (2003 X100 4.2 & 2000 C5 Roadster Road Test)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ค. 2024
- WIN With Lancaster Insurance: bit.ly/3BUKBKb
Come the 1990s, both Chevrolet and Jaguar had powerful coupes that were due for replacement. The C5 Corvette retained a pushrod V8, but the new aluminium 5.7-litre LS1 offered more power and less weight, combined with the Corvette now sporting improved fuel economy and good enough handling to take on the Europeans. The X100 Jaguar XK8, meanwhile, belied its XJ-S underpinning ti offer an all-new experience with retro-modern styling and almighty performance and power in supercharged XKR guise. Both took on the Porsche 911 and both make tempting modern classic purchases, but which V8 muscle car is best?
Thanks to Stone Cold Classics for loan of the Corvette : www.stonecoldclassics.com/
Proudly supported by Lancaster Insurance - get a quote on YOUR classic car insurance here: www.lancasterinsurance.co.uk/...
Classics World is a family of brands that includes ten classic publications plus many souvenir bookazines. Check out great offers on these and more on shop.kelsey.co.uk/magazines/c...
More classic car news and reviews online. Stay up to date with our weekly newsletter - register today at classicsworld.co.uk/
• Facebook: / classicsworlduk
• Instagram: @classicsworlduk
• Twitter: @ClassicsWorldUK
- Music -
• Noir Et Blanc Vie - TrueArtRealAffectionPart4: • Video
• Patiño - Stoner Things: • Video
All content on this channel is - unless otherwise stated - the opinion of the given party and any offence caused is severely apologised for. Any and all third-party content is credited and referenced to the best of our ability and all externally-created content is entirely the legal property of its original and rightful owner/s. All rights respected.
Chapters
0:00 90s V8s!
1:01 Jaguar XKR
4:48 Corvette C5
9:27 Which Is Best? - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
I think the XKR is one of the most beautiful cars ever made. It has aged incredibly well and now turns more heads than other much more expensive exotica
They are nice looking..but terrribly unreliable better know a good mechanic and be prepared to pay $$....thats been my Jag ownership over the decades
This one has been very reliable!
@@lutomson3496 A friend of mine has used his one as daily transport for the last decade and I can’t recall a single occasion where it’s let him down. Mind you, he does service it properly
I want one
Had my 2004 XK8 for 8 years, never broken down, beautiful car and great to drive. Expensive maintenance though, but it's all preventative.
I'm a biased C5 owner, but I have to say, that XKR is GORGEOUS. I immediately went on facebook market place to see if there were any for sale.
Happy buying! 😉
I have two Vette one convertible and one SRC( solid roof construction) both limited edition special construction from GMC.. One X100 (2002) 4.2 supercharger.. once brought never selling.. except when I cannot drive anymore.. two for one for the Vette.. Now days it's $125,000 for new Vette ahhhhhh and $155,000 for New Jaguar XF 😮 ahhhhhh
Have owned a 2005 XKR since 2014 and the only problem I have encountered is a burned out instrument panel light. I never get tired of looking at those curvaceous, drop dead, gorgeous lines. In the US Corvettes, which are great cars, are a dime a dozen. Very rarely see another XK8 or XKR. A thing of beauty is a joy forever.
The XKR has to be seen in reality to appreciate it's presence and elegance.
XKR for me. I had an XK8 conv as a daily for over 6 months @ 100 miles a day up mountains and through backroads. Took it to the track and drag raced it many times (we won!). Never had a single issue. Google an XKR with an aftermarket exhaust..because they sure do sound amazing when you remove the 3 out of 5 mufflers. Some crackles and pops and refined growling but no drone or loudness at normal cruising speeds. The XK8 was rear ended and totaled..but I just bought an XKR!
I just got myself a 03 XK8 (189k km mileage) - still a beautiful car!!!
I remember when I had my 02 xkr, a stock c5 pulled up on me on the highway. We raced on 3 and were dead even. It was so cool. He's lighter but I had more power. I know I now have a crazy tuned ftype V8s, but I damn sure miss that xkr. I'm in search of one to use as a daily again.
Jaaaaag all the way for looks for me, although I don't like the red part of the interior, but that corvette v8 sound.....oh man is awesome. 👍😎
Gotta love it!
Ive literally owned both, i had a Yellow 2002 C5 owned it for 11 years..and 2 years ago bought an 01 XKR, the corvette was awesome but i find the XKR to be a better ride, the 'Eaton' Supercharger is super responsive and i love the whine along with the growl of the Borla exhaust, both handle equally in slaloms but the Jag just feels superior overall, the X100 (1997-2006) Jags were built right.
Jag for me. Utterly timeless design that is still unique today. Actually better looking than it's contemporary Aston DB7 (which was stunning in itself). The new Jags and Aston's design are so forgettable I can't even recall if they look like fat Hondas or over the top Mercedes...
Totally agree. Compared to the Jaguar X100s, most modern sports cars look like they come from the "angry toaster" school of automotive design. From a styling viewpoint I have always seen the X100 as a reincarnation of the iconic E-Type. Gorgeous curvaceous and sensual lines that will forever look beautiful.
What really distinguished Jaguar from other brands, was that they made the lowest Sport Sedans.
The X300/X308 has a height of 1,31M, the X350 has a height of 1,44M.
Same with that J-Gate, no other Super Sedan brand offered the driver, the option, to switch, from automatic transmission to manual.
@@skelejp9982 truthfully not something I, or anyone I have known has ever commented on before; and looking at the C5 and XK above, they seem to be about the same height. Nevertheless - if that's what distinguishes them for you, then I certainly can't argue; for me it's definitely the design, which in a world of cars that all look the same - is unusual. Sadly I think the replacement for the X100 (the X150?) was really a slightly blocky clone of the DB7 - which was a shame and undoubtedly impacted DB7 sales; and the new Jaguar sports car, whilst a performer, looks like a Japanese clone from Fast and Furious with American styling queues for good-sales. Great performer but that's all; I'll take the XK100 design every time...
The X100 really is the modern E-Type, the X150 looks too much like a fish, and the F-Type looks too round and chunky. The pre-facelift F-Type does look good on it’s own but next to an X100 you will notice how fat it looks perhaps F-Type stands for Fat-Type 😂
Just bought a 2008 XKR Coup and I'm in heaven!! When the supercharger revs up I feel giddy, plus if you remove fuse 19 in the middle back seat fuse box it opens the butterfly valves in the exhaust and you get that low growl. This car is amazing!
The X150 is a quite different car in character than the X100, but also excellent. I got an X100 just because it is SO pretty, but I often wonder if I made the wrong choice.
@@iainbagnall4825 The X100 is a better looking car than the X150- it has definite E-Type styling cues, which the X150 doesn't. The X150 is too bulky in my opinion, it's corpulent and lacks grace. The X100 is the optimum size- without appearing to be a huge lump like the X150- the front end of the 150 just isn't right either- the headlights don't sit well in design terms I feel.
I am a Jaguar Fan, own an X308 XJ SC, also love the looks of the X100.
For me, the X100 has sort of the same lines as the XJ220.
These X100 4,2 Liters are slightly unique, most were 4,0.
Now for the Corvette, this C5 beats all the others, that were build after the C1 and C2.
Love the looks of the C5, especially the rear side, that is so impressive, and wide.
Wouldn't mind owning them both, but I cannot imagine, using the C5 as a daily driver.
Because of the firmer ride, the louder pipes, and the higher fuel consumption.
Thank You, for the nice Video!
One big advantage of the Corvette is the reliability and repairability, especially if you live in the US. The LS1 is super reliable and very cheap and easy to fix. Plus, you can get the Corvette with a 6-speed manual, which makes it even better: more fun, faster, and more fuel efficient. Corvette for me! (and I got one!)
2006 C6 convertible owner with a Procharger. Love the XK but they aren’t in the same time zone as the Vette.
With the taking over by Ford in the nineties, the reliability-problems of Jags were in the past. I daily drive a xkr (2001) more than 6 years, no isues or big problems, love it, hope to drive it another 6 years.
I own an 03 XKR, and will also own a C5 soon. I know that Corvettes are more known for their reliability compared to other sports cars, but the XK is not unreliable. I daily drive the car in the summer and its gets me to and from everywhere I need to be reliably. There are some Jag things you need to keep up on, but overall reliability and cost of ownership is no more expensive than that of the C5.
Corvette has much more interior room. Both great cars. It's cool to hear British guys loving the Corvette.
Well now, the stock X100 exhaust note with its five silencer boxes is really hobbled in an exhaust sound-off. With three of those boxes removed, like mine (shameless plug), you'll get a proper exhaust note worthy of that R badge.
Definitely the C5 ❤️. As a C7 Z06 Owner i can tell that the feeling in a corvette is indescribable. Especially in yellow (mine is all black - looks like a batmobile). In the end of the day, I want to have fun while driving and don't want to remember how under the radar i was :)
The interior from that older Jaaaags are beautiful hands down but the C5 took a big step forward. Not that noble but really well build 👌🏻. And trust me, you don't even noticed anything inside after coming back from a ride 😎
Both of them represent a glory time of car culture ❤️
My daughter owns a C4, I've got an XK8. We're greatly enjoying this review.
Apart from the obvious sir william lyons era, the ford era is by far the best time ever for jaguar cars.some of the best styled and best quality cars they have ever made.the modern jags since xf just dont do it anymore.much prefer the smooth refinement of the jag.i just dont understand the fascination with noisy exhausts.
I have a 2001 XKR and as a Detailer I would say the Jag is so much more elegant feeling and looking but if you like the attraction and sound Corvette is the way to go
Nice video!
Be a lovely problem to have to have to chose between the two. Another fantastic video chaps.
Thanks Neil!
Has to be the Jag….I got the XK8 convertible and have had for 10 years. No way would I would consider a plastic Yank regardless of its V8. Jaguar’s V8 is much better in my book!
Don't count out the Corvette, Doug!
When you mentioned LT1 you emberdded a pic of the L98 350cui engine. And also forgot to mention LT4(1996) C4 wasn't outdated performance wise when they launched the C5. Of course the C4 was old and needed a replacement after 12years of production run, there is no question about that. Anyway great video guy, I loved to see these 2cars next to each other. Hard choice to be honest. If I needed a daily I would go for the XKR but If I liked something for weekend like a short joyride on curvy roads I would definitely take the C5
C4 had also adaptive dampers called FX3
xkr is the best!
Brits are best at reviewing automobiles 👍😃
Your conclusion is right. Drive the Jaguar as a daily driver and save the Corvette for the weekend and special occasions, both brilliant cars. Perhaps borrow the company Visa card and grab the Corvette lol.
I prefer the Jaguar. It's better looking. And English.
JAAAGGGG.For sure
XKR all day long (not that I'm biased in any way). That Corvette looks naff, dreadful interior, but sounds great!
I take both.🙂
Only the Z06 C5 hit 60 in 4 seconds, the rest of the range were closer to 5. I believe the C5 convertible was 5.1.
Another good video lads 🚘🚙🚗⭐️⭐️⭐️👍👍👍👍👍
Thanks Jimmy!
The Chevrolet Camaro / Pontiac Firebird would have been closer to the Jag for an comparison
Neither was available in the UK officially, whereas the Corvette was, as mentioned in the video :)
@@ClassicsWorldUK ok, makes sence then!
Hard not to like the Corvette- it's very American- in your face looks and sounds fantastic. I own an XK8 and wouldn't swop it for daily use, but the Corvette would make a superb weekend car to go for a blast in. Really, the XK8 is a luxury GT, whilst the Vette is more sports orientated. If I was going on holiday to Italy and driving across France and through Switzerland, the XK8 would win hands down- for sheer fun and thrills, the Vette would win- they both excel at their intended roles. I'd far sooner have the Vette than a soulless German BMW or Audi.
Agreed! The Corvette is undoubtedly the more exciting, but some would struggle to daily drive it...
I’m going to take the Corvette
Jag 5 times over. I spent 21 years in the USA til' last year. The corvette is nothing to write home about.
Shorts and t-shirts! Either filmed a while ago or you’re a lot tougher than I am 😂
Alas, this was in peak summer 2022 - remember the heatwave...? 😅
I am lucky to own an 03 XKR so I'm not particularly impartial. I think Corvettes are common and a dime a dozen (over here on the North American continent). So the Jag is more special. It's refined and beautiful.
I'm not sure on the performance specs quoted in the video. All my sources state that the supercharged 4.2 litre Jag does 0-60 in 4.9 secs. Still slower than the Corvette but way more classy.
both
Both please.
Was the xj220 not a production car, surely jags fastest at this point? Understandably not anywhere near the high volume of the xkr.
The build quality on the c5 was so bad it would have to go after a few week, but the Jag is just quality.
Put an Adamesh exhaust system on the XKR to make the ultimate sound.. however, just for the beauty, the reliability, the refinement. XKR even XK8 ...every day..
We sense you're a Jag man, Kevin ;)
@@ClassicsWorldUK XK8/xkr man yes. Became my favourite car when I first saw one 95/96. Prior to that a Jensen interceptor 72/95
And before that 64/72 DB5/6
What years were Lotus, responsible for the design and development of the New Corvette. All Lotus under the covers, engine, suspension, breaks etc
I considered a corvette but A) I live in the US and I am a Brit, and I feel like I should keep the british end up B) Regular car reviews really have done a good job on corvette owners C) I already have an outrageously modified mx-5 that my girlfriend absolutely will not travel in unless I put the original seats back in, so I wanted a pure GT/comfortable cruiser than eats freeways, and thats the jag. If I HAD to replace BOTH cars - I dont think I could refuse the obviously sensible choice that is the corvette. Tho Ive always said the only thing Id sell the Miata/mx-5 for would be a lotus elise or evora, and the GF might just be able to tolerate an evora.
Yobbos = Corvette, Wrinklies = Jaguar. 😋👍
Do a bird test.they always go for a jag.
You need to get the white New Balance shoes and the all denim Jay Leno or Jeremy Clarkson outfit to drive the Vette properly. And if you get a Mustang, you must learn how to crash it when leaving Cars and Coffee. Minimum requirements!
Something about the XKR just does it for me. The Corvette, not so much. It's still a nice car for sure, but if I had to pick, the Jag wins hands down.
No denying the Jaguar is a classier way to arrive...
"You can use an XKR as your daily drive..." Really, I don't think I could.
I do 😊.... that very same xkr
Sound of thunder... Corvette for me..
Great choice!
the dash and the red leather do not work
Ford saved Jaguar from collapsing- End of. It's ironic that when the DB7 was launched, motoring hacks criticised the use of Ford switchgear. Fast forward to now, and the Ford components are still working well in DB7's- whilst the Aston parts are letting go. DB7 interior materials are cheap and not durable. The XK8 interior is far better quality than that of the Aston. It's a shame that Ford aren't running Jaguar today, the company is on the brink of collapse with poor sales and the cars they build don't have the traditional Jaguar aesthetic appeal- eg the XF looks like an Audi!
Wouldn't the XJ220 be a little quicker than the XKr?
Xj220 alot faster than the xkr and the corvette.
comparing an XJ220 to a corvette is insane
I will say, one of the unexpected benefits of a fully plactic interior is when you go through the drive-thru and you are eating your Hamberger🍔 , Fries 🍟 and Coke, while driving to visit the mistress, and you hear the news that Biden won the Presidency... the plastic cleans up with a garden hose.
😂😂😂😂😂
Yea the Jag looks the best to me aye?
A Zr-1 corvette would have been a more fair comparison
We only got the "normal" C5 in Europe, not to mention the performance of that car is more than a match for the XKR :)
The XKR is a beautiful Car. What or who is Corvette ? 😎😎
Who thought the red bits in the jags interior were a good idea? Looks awful, love the rest of the car though and has always been on my to buy list
What's the purpose of a expensive car that needs high maintenance after 75thousand Miles
the JAG is way better ... specially XKR from 2007 to 2015
Great review. But the red accents in the jag are awful