Gardener's visit to the old church in PomSen is particularly significant because it represents the most authentic historic location, one that hasn't suffered restoration where we can safely look back in time and feel Bach's presence within the church's inner and outer environment. Absolutely fascinating. Gardener's spoken German is very proficient too. An outstanding documentary, in fact the best I've seen! Gosh I could watch this for hours!
well i turned on german subtitles because of that and because i thought to understand the german language somehow better than that kind of english. [i was born just between britain and deutschland.] now what we got then was, well, readable rather well when english was spoken, and an even funnier kind of german when both persons spoke german on the audio. really lots of laughing loudly. by the way, mr. gardiner seems to be very very good at german.
Has there been any thought given to stitching these TH-cam talks of John Eliot Gardiner together as an accompaniment to his book Music in the Castle of Heaven? They are excellent and very revealing of Bach's brilliance in music and of his life generally.
Sir Gardiner thanks In the poufoud heart of certains aveyronnais. Thanks to have a choise this land Nice of you I present you The prd of Beaux Arts Accademie Pr Francois Bernard Michel Great encontrance Im sure. Jph Teyssedre from Rodez.. ? Thank's for all JhT
I read that those running Bach's school were malevolent; chosing bad singers to annoy him. Bach's work is still underappreciated as we will never understand his interest with numerology. In the 3 Lutheran hymnals I used, only a couple were by J.S. Bach. I imagine that Martin Luther would be disappointed that most Lutheran Pastors make a lot more than Roman Catholic Priests. I was raised Catholic aned worked for a Lutheran Church. The Pastor's car allowance was about the same as my salary for about the same amount of work. The Pastor also owned 2 houses and several other pastors were reported to be "double-dipping": requesting user fees on top of their generous salary, housing and car allowance. I've never heard of a Catholic priest owning anything, not even a car. Many catholic priests, monks and nuns take vows of poverty. Everyone at the Lutheran church I worked at was very well off. Getting a raise was impossible so I quit.
Jess Nob or could there be another cantata which some of the choral parts are also being performed here too? because I didn't find what I am looking for yet
oh it's like heaven, finally. thanks! that is exactly what I am looking for. I can't express in words how excited I am now to find it. I really like that choral very much, I don't understand each time I listen to it I get so emotional :')
Fine video. I personally do not think Bach would have been a great opera composer, fortunately for music history we have Handel who was Bach`s equal but in the realm of opera. Of the 40+ operas he wrote are absolutely hidden treasures still to be discovered.
That is true. His oratorios had a dramatic element, but they are not operas. However, in a commentary on contemporary composers, Handel ended by writing, "And then there is Herr Bach, the master of us all."
You're right, it's pure poetry! (It just needs a little punctuation.) 17:12 "Oh, sweet invasion Jennifer; but this is all to think about, as you angry. Poet, here you see sectional nzt are poor. I can district elder. I see this Anna-Heineken-songs-organ at La Femme, and from this section, your hundreds of meters exchanges young elusive things in here. As you view this, niched with your hair and your physiology, (as you get better, I mean), THAT'S why he comes here. That's the mixture. That's a mixture!" 👏👏👏
A wonderful thing to do, but perhaps what would have been more appropriate for the pilgrimage is the presentation of all of the cantatas in their proper liturgical context - i.e. within Gottesdiesnt / Lutheran worship - rather than in concerts. They are not concert performance works.
Gardener's visit to the old church in PomSen is particularly significant because it represents the most authentic historic location, one that hasn't suffered restoration where we can safely look back in time and feel Bach's presence within the church's inner and outer environment. Absolutely fascinating. Gardener's spoken German is very proficient too. An outstanding documentary, in fact the best I've seen! Gosh I could watch this for hours!
The Bach pilgrimage done by Eliot Gardiner and his group was incredible.
Brings special memories of our visit❤ 🇨🇦 Danke schön!
Wunderbar, really.. I love this. To us whose German is not quite there, subtitles would be helpful, and a playlist of the snippets.
There's a version with subtitles. The user meinhardo has it on their channel
Thanks, but I meant translations into English.
Hi Daniel, thanks for watching. I'm currently looking into it and will update you as soon as possible - Thore (Social Media Team)
@@Euroartshave you gotten the subtitles yet and the playlist? Thanks!
How wonderful!
Really interesting - so glad I got this set.
Fantastic!
Turn on English subtitles for hilarious results
I did, of my own accord, one part of which ended with “bit incoherence.” 😑😆
well i turned on german subtitles because of that and because i thought to understand the german language somehow better than that kind of english. [i was born just between britain and deutschland.]
now what we got then was, well, readable rather well when english was spoken, and an even funnier kind of german when both persons spoke german on the audio. really lots of laughing loudly. by the way, mr. gardiner seems to be very very good at german.
22:46 "...an unfortunate bassoon..."
Is there any other kind?
Documentário maravilhoso!!!
Choral 11:25 => Original Melodie des Franz-Lied "Une jeune fillette" (Jehan Chardavoine ) - - - hier Schlusschoral des BWV 73.Wunderschöne Melodie
Has there been any thought given to stitching these TH-cam talks of John Eliot Gardiner together as an accompaniment to his book Music in the Castle of Heaven? They are excellent and very revealing of Bach's brilliance in music and of his life generally.
You are always WELCOMED HERE:)
Sir Gardiner thanks
In the poufoud heart of
certains aveyronnais.
Thanks to have a choise
this land
Nice of you
I present you The prd of
Beaux Arts Accademie
Pr Francois Bernard Michel
Great encontrance Im sure.
Jph Teyssedre from Rodez..
?
Thank's for all
JhT
I read that those running Bach's school were malevolent; chosing bad singers to annoy him. Bach's work is still underappreciated as we will never understand his interest with numerology. In the 3 Lutheran hymnals I used, only a couple were by J.S. Bach. I imagine that Martin Luther would be disappointed that most Lutheran Pastors make a lot more than Roman Catholic Priests. I was raised Catholic aned worked for a Lutheran Church. The Pastor's car allowance was about the same as my salary for about the same amount of work. The Pastor also owned 2 houses and several other pastors were reported to be "double-dipping": requesting user fees on top of their generous salary, housing and car allowance. I've never heard of a Catholic priest owning anything, not even a car. Many catholic priests, monks and nuns take vows of poverty. Everyone at the Lutheran church I worked at was very well off. Getting a raise was impossible so I quit.
could anyone please tell me what the title of the choral being sung at 13:17 and 24:37 I will be so much grateful
It's from Cantata BWV 65 played throughout the video
Jess Nob oh many thanks for the answer. It really means a lot to me :)
Jess Nob or could there be another cantata which some of the choral parts are also being performed here too? because I didn't find what I am looking for yet
yup, you're right! it's bwv 123 in fact , sorry
oh it's like heaven, finally. thanks! that is exactly what I am looking for. I can't express in words how excited I am now to find it. I really like that choral very much, I don't understand each time I listen to it I get so emotional :')
May all the jhon's be blessed by Jesus nd his holy spirit. They really are gifts of god.
ESPLENDIDO
22:59 Schumann as a sound engineer
Fine video. I personally do not think Bach would have been a great opera composer, fortunately for music history we have Handel who was Bach`s equal but in the realm of opera. Of the 40+ operas he wrote are absolutely hidden treasures still to be discovered.
That is true. His oratorios had a dramatic element, but they are not operas. However, in a commentary on contemporary composers, Handel ended by writing, "And then there is Herr Bach, the master of us all."
The 'English' captions are hilarious 'gasti from ponzi nobody be ethical' etc.
You're right, it's pure poetry! (It just needs a little punctuation.) 17:12
"Oh, sweet invasion Jennifer; but this is all to think about, as you angry. Poet, here you see sectional nzt are poor. I can district elder.
I see this Anna-Heineken-songs-organ at La Femme, and from this section, your hundreds of meters exchanges young elusive things in here.
As you view this, niched with your hair and your physiology, (as you get better, I mean), THAT'S why he comes here. That's the mixture.
That's a mixture!"
👏👏👏
Needs more microphones
Oof. My german isn't good enough but I really enjoyed the rest of it.
A wonderful thing to do, but perhaps what would have been more appropriate for the pilgrimage is the presentation of all of the cantatas in their proper liturgical context - i.e. within Gottesdiesnt / Lutheran worship - rather than in concerts. They are not concert performance works.
gosh, you know honestly
I just don't think Bach could have done it all by himself
its just too impossible
he left stuff to his son friedeman which was lost.
traducción al Español por favor
Gardiner is a genius, almost the seize of J.S. Bach
agree
His book _Bach: Music in the Castle of Heaven_ is simply excellent.
If I may...size, not seize.
What if he seized Bach for his own?
He was good in the 80s but in the last 15 years has become very eccentric.
I imagine Bach got better at doing 'stuff'. Lean manufacturing in music! #liebsterimmanuel
WHO IN THE NAME OF BACH DECIDED IT WAS FUNNY TO SET THE SUBTITLING TO ENGLISH IF THEY'RE SPEAKING NORTHERN GERMAN ?
German. But your point still stands, I agree.