Pamiętam czasy, jak w latach 90-tych dużo ruskich przyjeżdżało do Polski i na straganach mieli swoje produkty. Wszystko, ale to wszystko było toporne, jednokolorowe, brzydkie i bez smaku, estetyki. Nic nie potrafili zrobić porządnie. Tak jest do teraz, więc nie ma co się dziwić, że z grą jest podobnie.
I think it is unfair to compare a game like witcher 3 to smuta (budget and developer experience difference). But I still think it is funny smuta was directly sponsored by russian government and still "works" like this 😅
It's not funny or surprising. Any government-sponsored entertainment is dogshit. Government-sponsored memes are not funny, government-sponsored games are not fun. it is what it is.
@@kamilszadkowski8864they received government HELP, but they were already established. There's a difference between some random company popping up and sucking on its government' tit and a company thats been around for many years and once its succesful receiving government subsidiaries.
На работе в одной из контор висел самодельный плакатик "Кто работал на откатах - стал счастливым и богатым", начальник посмеялся тогда, но сказал снять. Думаю, разработчики "Смуты" стали немного счастливее. Да, бюджеты у игр разные, но судя по другим роликам, здесь и вменяемого повествования и интересных диалогов не подвезли.
@@GameLight You don't understand how crazy people are in our government. They just want to throw hats at them, just bragging. Sick idiots who plundered the Soviet Union and disgraced the entire nation by driving it into loans and credits.
Bez przesady pan Jacek Rozenek jako geralt jest zajebisty do tego,fabuła super nawet jak za każdym razem przechodze wieska 3 zadanie z baronem sprawy rodzinne to zadanie poboczne,a napisane jak wątek główny 🎉💥👑🔥⚔️🧝🗡️🍺🍻🧐⚜️💪🏆🎇🇵🇱🇵🇱🇵🇱
As a person from Russia, I will say: most people are ashamed of the developers, and absolutely do not support this position, the game and hate it. I'm ashamed of this and offended by GOOD games that are overshadowed by such crap.
In Poland, there's a popular saying, a riddle: what is it? It doesn't shine light and doesn't fit in the arse? The Russian instrument to shine light in the arse. And it pretty good sums it up.
So they released an unfinished game basically. The parts that worked looked really cool. So is it really the full game or a demo, cause I haven't seen any full walkthroughs at all on youtube.
What's the first step? This is not the first Russian game. Hastily assembled from purchased models, there is nothing different from the same as from the Russian THE Day Before
@@foxshiron5139 bro i said "Great first step" for the team of this game. Not all the Russian developers but if u want good example of a Russian game and the potential. Just go and play "Atomic Heart" and then you can talk.
Black Book, Atomic Heart, Escape From Tarkov, это отличные игры, они заслуживают внимание. A lot of people still play Tarkov, and Atomic was popular for a couple of months after its release. Atomics has good optimization for Russian developers, although the trophies were completely broken. I advise everyone to try these games, as well as other numerous indie projects!
A handful of whackos announced that they would make a AAA pseudo-historical game that would show a historical narrative according to Putin regarding a historical period that propaganda calls great sorrow (Time of Troubles). Putin was very happy and lavishly subsidized the creators. The creators were also pleased and decided to plow on with further production of the game. The problem was that the Russian public really wanted to see a Russian game about how Russians bravely fought the Polish occupiers, and they didn't let the creators get away with the money. So they finished the game just enough so that someone couldn't say they took money for nothing. P.S.. For those who wonder why I called the game pseudo-historical I already explain. According to Putin's propaganda, after the death of Grand Duke Ivan the Terrible (the founder of Russian imperialism), an interregnum prevailed in the Principality of Moscow, leading to many years of civil war. This was taken advantage of by the evil Poles, who first wanted to install the usurper on the throne, and when that failed, they seized Moscow themselves. However, the Muscovites fought valiantly against the occupiers and eventually exiled the Poles regaining their independence. In fact, the Russian Civil War was exploited by Ukrainian magnate Adam Korybut Wisniowiecki, after one of his servants tried to lie to him that he was the miraculously surviving son of Ivan the Terrible. Adam decided to show his servant to his acquaintances at the Moscow court, who personally knew Ivan the Terrible and his son. They confirmed that he was not Ivan's son, but actually resembled him and imitated him perfectly. So together they hatched a conspiracy to install the servant on the throne, in return the servant would enable his patrons to expand their political and economic influence. However, a handful of Ukrainian and Russian nobles were too few to carry out such a plan. So they went to the court of Poland before King Sigismund III Vasa himself. Sigismund was not Polish, but Swedish, and refused to help in the plot, as did the rest of the Polish and Lithuanian nobility. The exception was one minor Polish nobleman, who was willing to marry his daughter to the usurper for his assistance. The conspiracy was also supported by the Franciscan Order, who wanted the right to spread Catholicism within the Muscovite state in exchange for financial assistance. The usurper (Dimirta) was supported by many Russian nobles, and they seated the usurper on the throne in Moscow. Everyone knew about it was usurpator. However, it did not matter. In the history of Russia and Russia, many times the throne was taken by people born of the treachery of the ruler's wife, as genetic studies confirmed a few years ago. Dimirta was liked by everyone because he refused to fulfill his obligations to his patrons in the west. He turned out to be a patriot and looked after the interests of his people. However, the problem arose when he began to reform the court (and later wanted to reform the state). Western behavior, such as wearing velvet clothes, shaving the beard, taking daily baths, eating with cutlery, and liberalizing the law, proved too subversive for the Russians and they decided to get rid of the ruler who “introduces Polish customs.” After this, another civil war began, and several attempts were made to settle more “surviving sons of Ivan the Terrible.” This time the Russians and Ukrainians were joined by Belarusians (Lithuanians). The Russian civil war turned into a great war between the Ruthenian nobility from three different kingdoms (four if you count the Novgorod Republic, which was conquered by Moscow). At the time, Ukraine (Ruthenia) and Belarus (the Grand Duchy of Lithuania) formed a union with the Kingdom of Poland and the Kingdom of Sweden, so the King of Poland, who was Sigismund III Vasa, finally had to intervene, since the war was reducing the state's income. He assembled an army consisting of, starting with the most numerous nationalities: Ukrainians (Ruthenians) Lithuanians (Belorussians), Poles, Cossacks, Swedes, Russians, Germans and Lithuanians (Samogitians). His troops reached Moscow, which was all made of wood, so it burned down (Sigismund's army claimed that the Muscovites themselves set the city on fire intentionally, or unintentionally. Muscovites to this day believe that it was done by the aggressor's troops. We will never know the truth again). Only the brick castle (Kremlin) survived. This one was besieged for 2 weeks, after which.....Russians themselves let the aggressor's troops in, because they made a deal with Sigismund III Vasa. The capture of Moscow and the castle never happened. How did they get along with Sigismund? Sigismund said he was a Swede just like Ruryk (founder of the state of Rus). In addition, he was King of the Polish-Lithuanian-Swedish Union ruling a huge state covering almost the entire Baltic Sea. He agreed that he would still accept the Duchy of Moscow into the Union, creating the most powerful state in Europe. Moscow would become the capital, and the immediate ruler of Moscow would be his son, who would adopt Orthodoxy. It later turned out that Sigismund wanted to take the Moscow throne himself and rule the entire Union from Krakow. He also did not want to change his religion. One of the Russian nobles who helped besiege Moscow gathered the commoners and together they blockaded the Moscow castle, blocking food supplies. Sigismund's governors in office there, along with a small army, eventually agreed to leave Moscow. A new Romanov dynasty took power in the country, forcibly introducing Western reforms that the first usurper had been unable to introduce. The Romanovs brought Russia out of the Middle Ages, introducing first the Polish pattern of civilization and then the German, which was more developed than the Polish. It was the Romans who transformed the Grand Duchy of Moscow into the Russian Empire. They gained huge colonies in Europe, Asia and even North America. What Putin believes, for the greatest tragedy in the history of Russia (just after the disintegration of the USSR) in fact was the beginning of the Russian Empire and its power. It's a great story, but in Putin's Russia hardly anyone knows the truth and instead of celebrating the great reforms of the Russian state, they celebrate that 500 years ago they were trampled by the Poles.... which never happened, ,but thanks to this Putin's propaganda can show Russians who is their historical third enemy right after Ukraine and the USA. :)
@@loafiusale po "Smuta" tez widac ze tworzyli ja ludzie z pasja. Tylko ze widac tez ze ludzie ktorzy po prostu chcieli ukrasc ile sie da pieniedzy od rządu I wydac byle gowno mieli wladze w firmie ktora to wydala. I to, o ironio, jest jak wielki skrot historii Rosji... (z mojej Polskiej perspektywy). Wspaniali ludzie gotowi pracowac I zrobic wszystko by osiagnac cel, I 1% rządzących ktorzy rozkradną wszystkie zasoby I kaza tym wspanialym zbudowac palac z gowna... I tak w kolko od tysiaca lat
It's was born from a Russian meme, that mostly have grown out of goofy neo-pagan mythology "Lizzards" are basically "reptiloids" from the classical period of ufology
У меня в ведьмаке 3 более 500 часов, и мне очень хотелось бы поиграть во что-то подобное, с похожим антуражем. Но с самого начала было понятно, что смута это просто распил государственных денег, это даже не игра... Даже если бы разработчикам дали бюджет сопоставимый с Ведьмак 3, они бы сделали плохо, им дали мало времени, и у руля были люди совершенно незаинтересованные.
They had a budget of like 5 million whilst CDPR had like 50 so hardly comparable, but CDPR achieved such budget by releasing translated games as a publisher, then making pretty messy Witcher 1, then very good Witcher 2, then AMAZING Witcher 3. They didn't just appear out of nowhere and begged for government money... and even tho both countries on paper are capitalistic, I swear Russia is still stuck in its Soviet era to this day... (BTW don't get me wrong, CDPR did get support from Polish government but only when they were a proven publisher and gamemaker, and that makes... a world of a difference)
@@aw2584 Я не имею ничего против правительственной поддержки, если взамен она не дает разработчикам какие-то определенные задачи связанные с интересами политических лиц и партий. Смута это хороший пример разгильдяйства, и изначально поставленной высокой недостижимой планки, стоило создать более мелкую игру, более проработанную, со строго линейным геймлпеем, как условная A Plague Tale Innocence
@@aw2584Если бы Россия действительно застряла в советской эпохе, смуту бы явно доделали по нормальному. Вот чего-чего, но подобную халтуру ни один советский цензор не прошёл бы. Не в похвалу советскому режиму, просто рассуждаю о вещах трезво.
Everything involving culture governments touch, tends to turning into shit. Smuta is no exception here. No govt should ever be allowed to get involved into a creative processes
To be fair, The Witcher 3 had 10 times bigger budget than this game. And even if you do not like the Russians you should compare games of the same budget size, otherwise it's just an unfair comparison. Also this Smuta game has just appeared, and probably still needs a lot of work, while The Witcher 3 is out long ago and is considered as well polished. Also even though I personally like the Witcher 3 very much, and I played it through 2 times, it's far from perfect when it comes to gameplay and graphics, it had some graphic bugs even in the final version. I did not played the Smuta yet, and maybe it is a bad game, but here is just to much anti Russian bias for me.
Że co wiedźminowi daleko do ideału 🤦On jest perfekcyjnie dopracowany inaczej nie dostałby tyłu nagród. Po drugie widać że nie masz pojęcia o grach.Jak ci nie pasuje to spadaj do Rosji bi tam siedź
Have you seen Cyberpunk 2077 when it was released in 2020? The game was a mess. Now ofc, it turned out to be good because of constant updates. And it was made by polish game devs as well. With Smuta, but if they do constant updates & fixes (and don't abandon it). The game will eventually turn out to be good. Though, it is getting annoying having titles being released unfinished, broken and unplayable. No matter what country the game comes from.
@@violentkrabs5548 what the fuck are you talking about? Cyberpunk, or any other game from CDPR had an interesting gameplay, plot and open world from the beginning, the only problem of their games is bugs, but Smuta have ONLY bugs, there is no interesting story, gameplay or open world. Developers just can't fix this mess, only if they rebuild game from the zero point, but they need money for it, and where are they going to get them? Government won't give it, other people especially.
Ok so the main mistake is that they just straight copying witcher. Maybe if they just cut the open world and make it somewhat linear epics of a Rusian soldier, it will work well
The devs have only said that Witcher's battle system sucks and Smuta won't be like that, which became a meme. And their lead was previously only developing for Alawar studio (specialised on veeeeery low-budget and relatively simple games) But there, seems to me, was a government's tender(or how it's called in English. Like auction, but you name the lowest reward and do the task) on making a video game. They've got around $5mln, plus around the same on PR, and lacked _any_ practical understanding on how to spend these money For example, they promised to make their own engine (only to use Unreal and stock 3d models). And for PR, used Radio Tapok (yes, Russian Sabaton. Very good choice), some TV personalities... And a literal "game streaming" camwh0re. Yeah.
так то да, но в любом случае с такими деньгами можно было бы сделать игру получше. а так разрабы просто скомуниздили часть государственных денег и были таковы.
Там из хорошего только движок, unreal engine 5 реально хорош, но это не их заслуга. Их заслуга это сделать игру на государственные деньги, которая плоха во всём, и дело не в деньгах. Буквально недавно вышел инди проект Indika который реально очень хорош. В Смуте же просто ужасный и сюжет, и геймплей, и боёвка, и вообще всё. И продаётся она по цене того же Ведьмака 3
It makes you laugh because you don't know the history of vodka. Vodka was created precisely as a medicine and is still used today for health purposes. Let's start the name itself. Wódka in Polish literally means small water. This word was used in the Middle Ages to describe the rocky outlets of mineral waters . It was believed that the water from such streams has medicinal properties (it is still believed so today), so over time vodka began to be called medicinal elixirs. Among them was “booze”, which over time took the name “vodka” just for itself. Vodka came to Russia precisely during the events shown in the game, but it was only in the decades following that it was popularized in the country. P.S. You may be wondering what vodka can cure. It is an alcohol, so it has disinfecting properties. By soaking your feet in it, you can get rid of ringworm. By washing your head in it, you can get rid of dandruff. By knocking your teeth in it, you disinfect your mouth. You can clean wounds with it, and by mixing it with pepper and honey you can cure colds and sore throats.
Looks is the best way to describe it. Imagine playing Assassins Creed but only the fetch quests on the same small map over and over and over and over again. It's horrifically boring. Had potential, the setting is AMAZINGLY interesting... but it's TERRIBLY boring.
Тут нечего сравнивать. Ведьмак3 это шедевр. Недостижимый уровень для всей индустрии. Смута же убогое поделие, созданное только что бы украсть бюджетные деньги.
Gothic 1 & 2 are better than most games of that kind, yea they are buggy as hell but have great story, characters, world and ideas. Its better than TES V Skyrim, especialy that Skyrim is great game only with mods, couse community achieve more than devs in term of combat, visuals, story, enemies and all other aspects. Gothic inspired such games like Witcher 3 so depicted it as some kind of trash is insulting and just stupid.
Prawdziwa "smuta" 🤣 ... Troszkę im się czasy pomyliły i jak chcieli zdyskredytować Wiedźmina, to faktycznie, zdyskredytowali, ale siebie 😂. Najlepszy jest ten koń i chodzenie po ogniu 🤣 Gra mogłaby robić wrażenie jakieś 15 lat temu 😂
Both games are RPGs and you didn't even compare the voice acting or dialogue camera. This is a strong point for the witcher too. But what games are we comparing anyway, on of the most important games of 2010s with a cheap Russian government sponsored unreal engine propaganda game ? 😂
It's a game funded by the Russian government to promote the Russian government's propaganda historical narrative. That's like saying you're not a fan of the Russian government, but you like the Russian military.
I've heard that it is anti-Polish. But I really want to play good games. It doesn't matter that they are Russian... That's why I'm asking if this title is worth recommending? Players from all over the world are a completely different target audience. A good example is the game Kingdom Come: Deliverance. You can really see the heart and soul of the developers in it, and I'm eagerly awaiting the second part...
Смута это конечно даже близко не ААА проект, потому сравнение не очень уместно, но справедливости ради когда вышел Ведьмак 3 в 15-м году он был супер забагованный, где-то через год он стал только вполне себе играбельным. логично было бы сравнивать первые версии Ведьмака 3 со Смутой (появление лошади в которой уже пофиксили кстати)
Индика это инди проект и бюджеты у неё были в разы меньше, но игра получилась ахуенной. А Смута плоха не столько в технических составляющих, сколько в своей основе, в сюжете. Игра была сделана чтобы отмыть 1 лярд рублей и даже с этим они не справились.
there are a lot of good Russian games that are not shitted in propaganda: space rangers, for example. But all everything the government touches turns to crap.
Smuta are a failure. Although not complete, the game is terrible, both the dialogue scenes between the characters, the optimization, the gameplay, etc. How did you get this game? It’s only sold on VK Play for rubles. In general, Russian developers have plenty of good games - Black Book, Beholder, Atomic Heart, and I'm sure there are more. Greetings from Russia!
Don't forget Pathologic, it's a masterpiece. I'm guessing the russian government is trying to boost its domestic industries due to the economic decoupling from the west, so they tried to rush the development of a AAA game but failed from mismanagement.
@@ChuckPalomo Yes, Russian developers also want to make AAA games, but so far only Atomic Heart has turned out like this. But they have enough good indie games
@@snappi139 It's weird cause I remember a huge controversy over Atomic Heart and how it was probably a scam run by gangsters. It was a surprize when it not only came out but was pretty good too. I really hope Russians manage to grow their industry.
You just didn't list good Russian games , but maybe in Russia they have a cult status :) I like: Arcanum, Heroes V, Age of pirates, Age of Sail 2, Alien Shooter, I am a dragon (it was a very bad game, but it is a memory from my childhood), Crossout, War thunder, Loop hero and snow runner. You can find the full list on Wikipedia. Russians make mostly fantasy games, especially classic RPGs, si-fi with robots and aliens, racing and puzzle games. However, by far the dominant theme in Russian games is war. Usually World War II, less often modern war. Russians have created a great many games about military aviation and surprisingly many about Caribbean pirates. If I were to create an ideal game for the Russians based on this, it would be a fantasy game set in World War II, where you can fly a plane, drive a tank, or a big killer truck. There would be references to sex and to the USSR everywhere. Accompanying us would be boob women, even if they weren't human. , In a break from gutting enemies we would relax with puzzles :D I don't know yet how I would throw pirates in there, but they would also have to be in this game. P.S. If you thought of Warhummer 40,000, the games in that series the Russians also made. ;)
@@orkako That's right, I didn't mention a lot of games, because I just didn't know that they were made by Russians. If you want to make a game for Russians, then my advice to you: you shouldn’t overdo it about sex, but it’s worth adding some jokes. There is no point in mentioning the USSR if you do not want to create Atomic Heart 2, because the USSR appears there exclusively as a setting. You can make some references, for example, wood stoves in houses, people doing housework, etc. Make either a village atmosphere with Russian mythology (like the Witcher), or a dark atmosphere, in the entrances of multi-storey buildings there are dicks on the walls, like in Metro Exodus, and decorate with obscenities :D
Comparé un jeu fini qui a eu un départ catastrophique alors qu'il été fini a sa sortie, avec un jeu avec moins de moyen qui est en EA et qui n'est pas fini mmmmh, dit moi que tu n'est pas un gamer sans me dire que tu n'est pas un gamer 🤣
Somes lies in the video. For example the water has clearly a better physics in the Russia game and it's NOT rare to see identical faces in The Witcher.
I would still rather play Smuta than “Assassins Creed: We Wuz Samurais,” or whatever they’re calling the new one. Pass the vodka and controller, comrade 😂
Как вообще можно было сделать настолько плохою игру 1 миллиард рублей это самая большая сумма за такую сумму можно было б сделать качественную игру в которою инрали б по всему миру
That horse came straight from the depths of hell 💀
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Boa 👏🤣👏🤣
🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂
Говорят, что Смута это убийца ведьмака. И это правда! Ведь от такой картины, Геральт умер бы со смеху.
calling it a Russian Witcher is insulting to the Witcher
slavic, gerald is slavic man
@@87890- gerald who?
Полностью согласен
Pamiętam czasy, jak w latach 90-tych dużo ruskich przyjeżdżało do Polski i na straganach mieli swoje produkty. Wszystko, ale to wszystko było toporne, jednokolorowe, brzydkie i bez smaku, estetyki. Nic nie potrafili zrobić porządnie. Tak jest do teraz, więc nie ma co się dziwić, że z grą jest podobnie.
Ale lutownice mieli zajebiste. Ojciec kupił w latach 80 i ja jej używam do dziś xd
The Audacity to compare this to the Witcher 3
Well, at least having NPCs passed out on the ground in broad daylight is authentically Russian.
I like how in Smuta the bear just slaps you.
I think it is unfair to compare a game like witcher 3 to smuta (budget and developer experience difference).
But I still think it is funny smuta was directly sponsored by russian government and still "works" like this 😅
It's not funny or surprising. Any government-sponsored entertainment is dogshit. Government-sponsored memes are not funny, government-sponsored games are not fun. it is what it is.
@@CaptainFynx Every single Witcher game received government funding. Same with Dying Light and Frostpunk.
@@kamilszadkowski8864Polish Government is good at using potential of developers
@@kamilszadkowski8864 Cyberpunk too
@@kamilszadkowski8864they received government HELP, but they were already established. There's a difference between some random company popping up and sucking on its government' tit and a company thats been around for many years and once its succesful receiving government subsidiaries.
Smuita still is better and more complete than their military
Witcher 3 at home
This is like breaking bad vs metastasis
Yea)
Looks like all testers has gone abroad or vacationing on the frontline...
9 years differenxe.
На работе в одной из контор висел самодельный плакатик "Кто работал на откатах - стал счастливым и богатым", начальник посмеялся тогда, но сказал снять. Думаю, разработчики "Смуты" стали немного счастливее.
Да, бюджеты у игр разные, но судя по другим роликам, здесь и вменяемого повествования и интересных диалогов не подвезли.
Лучше бы сделали бы законченную инди-игру ! (Translated)
@@GameLight You don't understand how crazy people are in our government. They just want to throw hats at them, just bragging. Sick idiots who plundered the Soviet Union and disgraced the entire nation by driving it into loans and credits.
"it's rare to see identical faces" In witcher? REALLY RARE?
Witcher 3 is pretty good about unique voices, but so many faces are copy and pasted
Bez przesady pan Jacek Rozenek jako geralt jest zajebisty do tego,fabuła super nawet jak za każdym razem przechodze wieska 3 zadanie z baronem sprawy rodzinne to zadanie poboczne,a napisane jak wątek główny 🎉💥👑🔥⚔️🧝🗡️🍺🍻🧐⚜️💪🏆🎇🇵🇱🇵🇱🇵🇱
I agree with you, The Witcher series are a masterpiece
Я не играл в смуту, но я уверен, что каер морхен более проработанный и начинен интересными квестами, чем весь открытый мир в смуте
Там даже не открытый мир, там небольшие локации с невидимыми стенами.
Одна из них - ты БУКВАЛЬНО идешь по дороге от одной точки загрузки к другой.
В Вызимском замке из третьего ведьмака контента больше, а ты уж замахнулся на каэр морхен, ну ты даёшь
As a person from Russia, I will say: most people are ashamed of the developers, and absolutely do not support this position, the game and hate it.
I'm ashamed of this and offended by GOOD games that are overshadowed by such crap.
Space Rangers 2 is fantastic both gameplay and writing wise :)
Fuck these games, you should be ashamed of the war you started lol
Обалдеть, сравнивать фекалии с конфеткой.
6:00 I guess he has a restraining order due to some previous sex offence felony
xD😂 ☝🏻
In The Witcher the guy attack a group of soldier to show the combat. In the Russian stuff the guy attack a homeless drunk man...What a comparison
That's where the real russianness comes in
@@WostryFerenc I downloaded the game..The amount of eurojankyness is crazy, I WANT to play it but it's only in Russian 😅
-Mom, mom, can we have Witcher at home
-We have Witcher at home
Witcher at home:
Wow the Smuta dude looks like a Soviet Red Cavalry man! And tats some handsome horse riding animations yeah!
In Poland, there's a popular saying, a riddle: what is it? It doesn't shine light and doesn't fit in the arse? The Russian instrument to shine light in the arse.
And it pretty good sums it up.
So they released an unfinished game basically. The parts that worked looked really cool. So is it really the full game or a demo, cause I haven't seen any full walkthroughs at all on youtube.
This is a completed game, with a budget of 1 billion rubles.
@@NyanJan I mean like, it seems rushed and empty, like a wedding cake with no topping.
Technically, it was half a billion ($5mln), plus around the same on PR
But how much of it was spent on the actual game is another question
@@NyanJan 1 billion rubles? So like... 200$?
@@CREATERpl 10000000$ not 200$
Smuta and Russian developers have potential bro. I know that they can do a lot with more money and time. Great first step in my opinion.
Agree
What's the first step? This is not the first Russian game.
Hastily assembled from purchased models, there is nothing different from the same as from the Russian THE Day Before
@@foxshiron5139 bro i said "Great first step" for the team of this game. Not all the Russian developers but if u want good example of a Russian game and the potential. Just go and play "Atomic Heart" and then you can talk.
Гонишь? Российских игр очень много, и давно выходят! Atomic Heart например! А эта Смута говно!
Black Book, Atomic Heart, Escape From Tarkov, это отличные игры, они заслуживают внимание. A lot of people still play Tarkov, and Atomic was popular for a couple of months after its release. Atomics has good optimization for Russian developers, although the trophies were completely broken. I advise everyone to try these games, as well as other numerous indie projects!
Is this comparison supposed to be a joke or something?
did smuta is completed game?
and already to play?
or just a footage that mean its not yet finished game?
They officially released the unfinished game. I think the developers are tired of making the game.
A handful of whackos announced that they would make a AAA pseudo-historical game that would show a historical narrative according to Putin regarding a historical period that propaganda calls great sorrow (Time of Troubles). Putin was very happy and lavishly subsidized the creators. The creators were also pleased and decided to plow on with further production of the game. The problem was that the Russian public really wanted to see a Russian game about how Russians bravely fought the Polish occupiers, and they didn't let the creators get away with the money. So they finished the game just enough so that someone couldn't say they took money for nothing.
P.S..
For those who wonder why I called the game pseudo-historical I already explain. According to Putin's propaganda, after the death of Grand Duke Ivan the Terrible (the founder of Russian imperialism), an interregnum prevailed in the Principality of Moscow, leading to many years of civil war. This was taken advantage of by the evil Poles, who first wanted to install the usurper on the throne, and when that failed, they seized Moscow themselves. However, the Muscovites fought valiantly against the occupiers and eventually exiled the Poles regaining their independence. In fact, the Russian Civil War was exploited by Ukrainian magnate Adam Korybut Wisniowiecki, after one of his servants tried to lie to him that he was the miraculously surviving son of Ivan the Terrible. Adam decided to show his servant to his acquaintances at the Moscow court, who personally knew Ivan the Terrible and his son. They confirmed that he was not Ivan's son, but actually resembled him and imitated him perfectly. So together they hatched a conspiracy to install the servant on the throne, in return the servant would enable his patrons to expand their political and economic influence. However, a handful of Ukrainian and Russian nobles were too few to carry out such a plan. So they went to the court of Poland before King Sigismund III Vasa himself. Sigismund was not Polish, but Swedish, and refused to help in the plot, as did the rest of the Polish and Lithuanian nobility. The exception was one minor Polish nobleman, who was willing to marry his daughter to the usurper for his assistance. The conspiracy was also supported by the Franciscan Order, who wanted the right to spread Catholicism within the Muscovite state in exchange for financial assistance.
The usurper (Dimirta) was supported by many Russian nobles, and they seated the usurper on the throne in Moscow. Everyone knew about it was usurpator. However, it did not matter. In the history of Russia and Russia, many times the throne was taken by people born of the treachery of the ruler's wife, as genetic studies confirmed a few years ago.
Dimirta was liked by everyone because he refused to fulfill his obligations to his patrons in the west. He turned out to be a patriot and looked after the interests of his people. However, the problem arose when he began to reform the court (and later wanted to reform the state). Western behavior, such as wearing velvet clothes, shaving the beard, taking daily baths, eating with cutlery, and liberalizing the law, proved too subversive for the Russians and they decided to get rid of the ruler who “introduces Polish customs.” After this, another civil war began, and several attempts were made to settle more “surviving sons of Ivan the Terrible.” This time the Russians and Ukrainians were joined by Belarusians (Lithuanians). The Russian civil war turned into a great war between the Ruthenian nobility from three different kingdoms (four if you count the Novgorod Republic, which was conquered by Moscow). At the time, Ukraine (Ruthenia) and Belarus (the Grand Duchy of Lithuania) formed a union with the Kingdom of Poland and the Kingdom of Sweden, so the King of Poland, who was Sigismund III Vasa, finally had to intervene, since the war was reducing the state's income. He assembled an army consisting of, starting with the most numerous nationalities: Ukrainians (Ruthenians) Lithuanians (Belorussians), Poles, Cossacks, Swedes, Russians, Germans and Lithuanians (Samogitians). His troops reached Moscow, which was all made of wood, so it burned down (Sigismund's army claimed that the Muscovites themselves set the city on fire intentionally, or unintentionally. Muscovites to this day believe that it was done by the aggressor's troops. We will never know the truth again). Only the brick castle (Kremlin) survived. This one was besieged for 2 weeks, after which.....Russians themselves let the aggressor's troops in, because they made a deal with Sigismund III Vasa. The capture of Moscow and the castle never happened. How did they get along with Sigismund? Sigismund said he was a Swede just like Ruryk (founder of the state of Rus). In addition, he was King of the Polish-Lithuanian-Swedish Union ruling a huge state covering almost the entire Baltic Sea. He agreed that he would still accept the Duchy of Moscow into the Union, creating the most powerful state in Europe. Moscow would become the capital, and the immediate ruler of Moscow would be his son, who would adopt Orthodoxy. It later turned out that Sigismund wanted to take the Moscow throne himself and rule the entire Union from Krakow. He also did not want to change his religion. One of the Russian nobles who helped besiege Moscow gathered the commoners and together they blockaded the Moscow castle, blocking food supplies. Sigismund's governors in office there, along with a small army, eventually agreed to leave Moscow. A new Romanov dynasty took power in the country, forcibly introducing Western reforms that the first usurper had been unable to introduce. The Romanovs brought Russia out of the Middle Ages, introducing first the Polish pattern of civilization and then the German, which was more developed than the Polish. It was the Romans who transformed the Grand Duchy of Moscow into the Russian Empire. They gained huge colonies in Europe, Asia and even North America. What Putin believes, for the greatest tragedy in the history of Russia (just after the disintegration of the USSR) in fact was the beginning of the Russian Empire and its power. It's a great story, but in Putin's Russia hardly anyone knows the truth and instead of celebrating the great reforms of the Russian state, they celebrate that 500 years ago they were trampled by the Poles.... which never happened, ,but thanks to this Putin's propaganda can show Russians who is their historical third enemy right after Ukraine and the USA. :)
@@GameLight Работа над Смутой ещё идёт
@@GameLight Поэтому попрошу не пиздеть лишний раз
@@haronister9710 waste of time
Dude in Smuta moves like CJ from San Andreas.
Trzeba też zaznaczyć że the Witcher jest z 2015 roku, stare rozwiązania gdyby powstał dziś, byłby jeszcze lepszy.
Ведьмак 2015 года не был создан только ради освоения бюджетных средств, люди делали игру.
@@loafiusale po "Smuta" tez widac ze tworzyli ja ludzie z pasja. Tylko ze widac tez ze ludzie ktorzy po prostu chcieli ukrasc ile sie da pieniedzy od rządu I wydac byle gowno mieli wladze w firmie ktora to wydala.
I to, o ironio, jest jak wielki skrot historii Rosji... (z mojej Polskiej perspektywy). Wspaniali ludzie gotowi pracowac I zrobic wszystko by osiagnac cel, I 1% rządzących ktorzy rozkradną wszystkie zasoby I kaza tym wspanialym zbudowac palac z gowna... I tak w kolko od tysiaca lat
The more honest comparison would be between Witcher 3 and Russians vs Lizzards 💪🏻
I don’t understand the hype around Russians vs Lizards !
@@GameLight I guess it’s just very absurd as a concept, that’s all
It's was born from a Russian meme, that mostly have grown out of goofy neo-pagan mythology
"Lizzards" are basically "reptiloids" from the classical period of ufology
Can you please make movie Smuta vs Wicher 2
I think the game has potential, they need to put more work on it, they are already into a good path
У меня в ведьмаке 3 более 500 часов, и мне очень хотелось бы поиграть во что-то подобное, с похожим антуражем.
Но с самого начала было понятно, что смута это просто распил государственных денег, это даже не игра...
Даже если бы разработчикам дали бюджет сопоставимый с Ведьмак 3, они бы сделали плохо, им дали мало времени, и у руля были люди совершенно незаинтересованные.
They had a budget of like 5 million whilst CDPR had like 50 so hardly comparable, but CDPR achieved such budget by releasing translated games as a publisher, then making pretty messy Witcher 1, then very good Witcher 2, then AMAZING Witcher 3. They didn't just appear out of nowhere and begged for government money... and even tho both countries on paper are capitalistic, I swear Russia is still stuck in its Soviet era to this day...
(BTW don't get me wrong, CDPR did get support from Polish government but only when they were a proven publisher and gamemaker, and that makes... a world of a difference)
@@aw2584 Я не имею ничего против правительственной поддержки, если взамен она не дает разработчикам какие-то определенные задачи связанные с интересами политических лиц и партий.
Смута это хороший пример разгильдяйства, и изначально поставленной высокой недостижимой планки, стоило создать более мелкую игру, более проработанную, со строго линейным геймлпеем, как условная A Plague Tale Innocence
@@aw2584Если бы Россия действительно застряла в советской эпохе, смуту бы явно доделали по нормальному. Вот чего-чего, но подобную халтуру ни один советский цензор не прошёл бы. Не в похвалу советскому режиму, просто рассуждаю о вещах трезво.
Smuta looks good as well physics aren't important in such games but the story is.
Smuta has the realistic animation but its unfinished
damn the game is as wonky as th erussian governement itself
Everything involving culture governments touch, tends to turning into shit. Smuta is no exception here. No govt should ever be allowed to get involved into a creative processes
The Witcher 3 is so much better in every way
To be fair, The Witcher 3 had 10 times bigger budget than this game. And even if you do not like the Russians you should compare games of the same budget size, otherwise it's just an unfair comparison. Also this Smuta game has just appeared, and probably still needs a lot of work, while The Witcher 3 is out long ago and is considered as well polished. Also even though I personally like the Witcher 3 very much, and I played it through 2 times, it's far from perfect when it comes to gameplay and graphics, it had some graphic bugs even in the final version. I did not played the Smuta yet, and maybe it is a bad game, but here is just to much anti Russian bias for me.
Że co wiedźminowi daleko do ideału 🤦On jest perfekcyjnie dopracowany inaczej nie dostałby tyłu nagród.
Po drugie widać że nie masz pojęcia o grach.Jak ci nie pasuje to spadaj do Rosji bi tam siedź
witcher: i kill monsters!
russian witcher: я убиваю медведей
well like in real life Poland is better same in gaming industry Polish games are better :D
Have you seen Cyberpunk 2077 when it was released in 2020? The game was a mess. Now ofc, it turned out to be good because of constant updates.
And it was made by polish game devs as well.
With Smuta, but if they do constant updates & fixes (and don't abandon it). The game will eventually turn out to be good.
Though, it is getting annoying having titles being released unfinished, broken and unplayable. No matter what country the game comes from.
@@violentkrabs5548 Do you seriously think that a new unknown studio will be able to fix it after releasing such a bugged game?
@@violentkrabs5548 Cyberpunk sold 25+ milion copies, smuta sold about 25.
@@violentkrabs5548 what the fuck are you talking about? Cyberpunk, or any other game from CDPR had an interesting gameplay, plot and open world from the beginning, the only problem of their games is bugs, but Smuta have ONLY bugs, there is no interesting story, gameplay or open world. Developers just can't fix this mess, only if they rebuild game from the zero point, but they need money for it, and where are they going to get them? Government won't give it, other people especially.
@@Danickas0You have to pay for this game???
Ok so the main mistake is that they just straight copying witcher. Maybe if they just cut the open world and make it somewhat linear epics of a Rusian soldier, it will work well
I would say Smuta is already on par with big developers like Bethesda. Only difference is one deserves the budget
Да это не баги это обычные будни в России 😂
Ain’t no way this is actually real
And u keep saying that Russia is better than Poland? Or that Poland is part of Russia? Well... good job, get another brain
Who saying this?
@@Lagushka_uwua lot of braindead vatniks xD trying to cope with reality
Is they made visual circle ⭕ effect that would be perfect
Попытаться сделать копию игры которая вышла 9 лет назад, при этом провалится. Так могут только российский разработчики
The devs have only said that Witcher's battle system sucks and Smuta won't be like that, which became a meme.
And their lead was previously only developing for Alawar studio (specialised on veeeeery low-budget and relatively simple games)
But there, seems to me, was a government's tender(or how it's called in English. Like auction, but you name the lowest reward and do the task) on making a video game.
They've got around $5mln, plus around the same on PR, and lacked _any_ practical understanding on how to spend these money
For example, they promised to make their own engine (only to use Unreal and stock 3d models).
And for PR, used Radio Tapok (yes, Russian Sabaton. Very good choice), some TV personalities... And a literal "game streaming" camwh0re. Yeah.
Смысл сравнивать, если на ведьмак больше 30 миллионов потратили, а на смуту чуть больше 5, и это первый опыт создании игры у разработчиков
Согласен бюджет у двух игр разная, но могли же сделать как Atomic Heart, доделать и выпустить, окупили бы игру с полна ! (Translated)
@@GameLight деньги там бюджетные, по этому никто не заморачивался
так то да, но в любом случае с такими деньгами можно было бы сделать игру получше. а так разрабы просто скомуниздили часть государственных денег и были таковы.
Думаю, если бы эти "разработчики" потратили на смуту больше денег, то вышло бы такое же говно, просто большее по размеру)
@@GameLight В Атомик Харт бюджет на производство не меньше 25млн
Although it can't beat Witcher it still got me interested. The atmosphere is nice.
Pozdrawiam Ruskich braci! Отлично игра 😉
Нет друг мой, игра реально говно, и это факт
Там из хорошего только движок, unreal engine 5 реально хорош, но это не их заслуга. Их заслуга это сделать игру на государственные деньги, которая плоха во всём, и дело не в деньгах. Буквально недавно вышел инди проект Indika который реально очень хорош. В Смуте же просто ужасный и сюжет, и геймплей, и боёвка, и вообще всё.
И продаётся она по цене того же Ведьмака 3
этоже Смута 🤣😂
2:33 healing Vodka😂 hahaha
It makes you laugh because you don't know the history of vodka. Vodka was created precisely as a medicine and is still used today for health purposes. Let's start the name itself. Wódka in Polish literally means small water. This word was used in the Middle Ages to describe the rocky outlets of mineral waters . It was believed that the water from such streams has medicinal properties (it is still believed so today), so over time vodka began to be called medicinal elixirs. Among them was “booze”, which over time took the name “vodka” just for itself. Vodka came to Russia precisely during the events shown in the game, but it was only in the decades following that it was popularized in the country.
P.S. You may be wondering what vodka can cure. It is an alcohol, so it has disinfecting properties. By soaking your feet in it, you can get rid of ringworm. By washing your head in it, you can get rid of dandruff. By knocking your teeth in it, you disinfect your mouth. You can clean wounds with it, and by mixing it with pepper and honey you can cure colds and sore throats.
@@orkakoInteresujące!
Студееееная🥶🥶🥶
Is Smuta available on xbox? Looks interesting..
only pc
interesting? why
Looks is the best way to describe it. Imagine playing Assassins Creed but only the fetch quests on the same small map over and over and over and over again. It's horrifically boring. Had potential, the setting is AMAZINGLY interesting... but it's TERRIBLY boring.
i think smuta need more time to develope
Тут нечего сравнивать. Ведьмак3 это шедевр. Недостижимый уровень для всей индустрии.
Смута же убогое поделие, созданное только что бы украсть бюджетные деньги.
Вы бы еще с рдр2 сравнили)
про рдр2 этим бездарям на разрабах смуты хватило мозгов не вякать)
Smuta is such a trash. Smuta is comparable with old Gothic game and gothic wins
Gothic had less bugs.
That comparison is downright insulting to Gothic.
Gothic 1 & 2 are better than most games of that kind, yea they are buggy as hell but have great story, characters, world and ideas. Its better than TES V Skyrim, especialy that Skyrim is great game only with mods, couse community achieve more than devs in term of combat, visuals, story, enemies and all other aspects. Gothic inspired such games like Witcher 3 so depicted it as some kind of trash is insulting and just stupid.
@@huberttarnowski4980 Agreed. However, Gothic 3 is also a great game.
Гойдаааа!!
Prawdziwa "smuta" 🤣 ... Troszkę im się czasy pomyliły i jak chcieli zdyskredytować Wiedźmina, to faktycznie, zdyskredytowali, ale siebie 😂. Najlepszy jest ten koń i chodzenie po ogniu 🤣 Gra mogłaby robić wrażenie jakieś 15 lat temu 😂
Arent witcher an a lot older game? This russian game looks bad and unpolished. Probably developers lay in mud somewhere around donbas.
Ну Смута проект для отмыва бабла не более. Кстати в Ведьмаке тоже клонов нпс дофига, особенно детских
What a perfect representation of the state of russia in 2024. If that was the propaganda aim it was successful.
Both games are RPGs and you didn't even compare the voice acting or dialogue camera. This is a strong point for the witcher too. But what games are we comparing anyway, on of the most important games of 2010s with a cheap Russian government sponsored unreal engine propaganda game ? 😂
Not a fan of Russian government but the game actually has potential.
It's a game funded by the Russian government to promote the Russian government's propaganda historical narrative. That's like saying you're not a fan of the Russian government, but you like the Russian military.
The setting? Yes, but the game is shit.
I've heard that it is anti-Polish. But I really want to play good games. It doesn't matter that they are Russian... That's why I'm asking if this title is worth recommending? Players from all over the world are a completely different target audience. A good example is the game Kingdom Come: Deliverance. You can really see the heart and soul of the developers in it, and I'm eagerly awaiting the second part...
Trust me bro there are way better story games that you’ve still haven’t tried yet
@@mostrowski ok
there are a lot of good Russian games that are not shitted in propaganda: space rangers 1 abd 2, for example
8:48 lol
Смута это конечно даже близко не ААА проект, потому сравнение не очень уместно, но справедливости ради когда вышел Ведьмак 3 в 15-м году он был супер забагованный, где-то через год он стал только вполне себе играбельным. логично было бы сравнивать первые версии Ведьмака 3 со Смутой (появление лошади в которой уже пофиксили кстати)
не обременённые интеллектом некоторые разрабы Смуты позволяли себе нехорошие комментарии в сторону Ведьмака 3, чем это сравнение на себя и навлекли.
Индика это инди проект и бюджеты у неё были в разы меньше, но игра получилась ахуенной. А Смута плоха не столько в технических составляющих, сколько в своей основе, в сюжете. Игра была сделана чтобы отмыть 1 лярд рублей и даже с этим они не справились.
In smuta "i love minors"
Russian games - only propaganda
there are a lot of good Russian games that are not shitted in propaganda: space rangers, for example. But all everything the government touches turns to crap.
2013-2024
u should compare it to witcher 1 not witcher 3 nor even witcher 2
He should rather compare it to the game "Vivat Slovakia".
As a Russian, Smuta is just a trash. Better play to Assassin than that. Or indie game like Disco Elysium (masterpiece for me).
Smuta are a failure. Although not complete, the game is terrible, both the dialogue scenes between the characters, the optimization, the gameplay, etc. How did you get this game? It’s only sold on VK Play for rubles. In general, Russian developers have plenty of good games - Black Book, Beholder, Atomic Heart, and I'm sure there are more. Greetings from Russia!
Don't forget Pathologic, it's a masterpiece. I'm guessing the russian government is trying to boost its domestic industries due to the economic decoupling from the west, so they tried to rush the development of a AAA game but failed from mismanagement.
@@ChuckPalomo Yes, Russian developers also want to make AAA games, but so far only Atomic Heart has turned out like this. But they have enough good indie games
@@snappi139 It's weird cause I remember a huge controversy over Atomic Heart and how it was probably a scam run by gangsters. It was a surprize when it not only came out but was pretty good too. I really hope Russians manage to grow their industry.
You just didn't list good Russian games , but maybe in Russia they have a cult status :) I like: Arcanum, Heroes V, Age of pirates, Age of Sail 2, Alien Shooter, I am a dragon (it was a very bad game, but it is a memory from my childhood), Crossout, War thunder, Loop hero and snow runner. You can find the full list on Wikipedia. Russians make mostly fantasy games, especially classic RPGs, si-fi with robots and aliens, racing and puzzle games. However, by far the dominant theme in Russian games is war. Usually World War II, less often modern war. Russians have created a great many games about military aviation and surprisingly many about Caribbean pirates. If I were to create an ideal game for the Russians based on this, it would be a fantasy game set in World War II, where you can fly a plane, drive a tank, or a big killer truck. There would be references to sex and to the USSR everywhere. Accompanying us would be boob women, even if they weren't human. , In a break from gutting enemies we would relax with puzzles :D I don't know yet how I would throw pirates in there, but they would also have to be in this game.
P.S. If you thought of Warhummer 40,000, the games in that series the Russians also made. ;)
@@orkako That's right, I didn't mention a lot of games, because I just didn't know that they were made by Russians. If you want to make a game for Russians, then my advice to you: you shouldn’t overdo it about sex, but it’s worth adding some jokes. There is no point in mentioning the USSR if you do not want to create Atomic Heart 2, because the USSR appears there exclusively as a setting. You can make some references, for example, wood stoves in houses, people doing housework, etc. Make either a village atmosphere with Russian mythology (like the Witcher), or a dark atmosphere, in the entrances of multi-storey buildings there are dicks on the walls, like in Metro Exodus, and decorate with obscenities :D
Смутный распил бюджета
Comparé un jeu fini qui a eu un départ catastrophique alors qu'il été fini a sa sortie, avec un jeu avec moins de moyen qui est en EA et qui n'est pas fini mmmmh, dit moi que tu n'est pas un gamer sans me dire que tu n'est pas un gamer 🤣
Somes lies in the video. For example the water has clearly a better physics in the Russia game and it's NOT rare to see identical faces in The Witcher.
Well... id hope it does SOMETHING better, considering Witcher 3 came out 9 years ago...
I would still rather play Smuta than “Assassins Creed: We Wuz Samurais,” or whatever they’re calling the new one. Pass the vodka and controller, comrade 😂
even new AC will be better than this piece of shit.
at konusunda benı etkıldı gerısı onemlı değil
Непосредственно Смута
Можно было и не сравнивать))) Тут и так понятно. Смута конечно слабовата. Её делат и делать
Со смутой уже ничего не сделаешь, ее надо было задушить в зародыше и никогда не вспоминать про нее!
You russian🤨????????????
игра 2024 года хуже игры 2015 года
It´s funny how TW3 NG has so many bugs jaja. The original version is still better!
Witcher 💪🏻
Как вообще можно было сделать настолько плохою игру 1 миллиард рублей это самая большая сумма за такую сумму можно было б сделать качественную игру в которою инрали б по всему миру
😂😂😂смута
Russian boyar on hell horse :D :D :D
Smuta jest smutna. :(
Сравнение хера и пальца)
I would like the game if it wasnt propaganda😢
We would all like it, but what the government pays for is mediocre shit propaganda in most cases.
Ridiculo kkkkkkk
Lol like W3 wins all russian game suck
Smuta 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
cccp production 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
we're going to need another Witcher verse , since CD Project red is going gay
Смута даже первому ведьмаку проигрывает, какое нахрен сравнение с 3 частью!
Ахаххаха, это пиздец