@@chickenwings6745 Except Eren doesn't talk to world leaders or have the talking ability to convince them to change sides or even turn them agains Marley, which Erwin would have the ability to do
@@revvin7624 there's no way, eren did right because even if the paradisers walk around people would still not agree on that no matter government accepted that or not. He has to remove everyone from this world and again start the humanity with equality and freedom
Yep, because Eren would be long dead. There's no way Erwin stands by and allows Eren to endanger Paradis for the sake of protecting Krista. Or Eren and Erwin become enemies in a civil war.
@@jackslater4152 You bring up a very interesting point. Eren and Erwin clashing dynamics would have been far more interesting than Armin standing about doing nothing
I love Erwin but let's not pretend he's a Saint he willingly led so many of his own men to their deaths and while he does regret it and show remorse he also realizes that being the Commander of the survey corps he needed to become a monster and throw away his humanity to lead himself forward to proving his father right
I realize later. It was actually pretty cruel of Levi to give Armin the colossal Titan. Armin was the gentliest character and he gave him the most destructive power.
I think it was fitting to have a titan holder with a certain level of restraint which can be seen in Armin and Bertholdt. Although Erwin would be a good candidate as well, he's smart enough when to do it
On the other hand, it would have been cruel to give Erwin the injection. Erwin had already done so much, and he deserved to rest. To be honest, both decisions were cruel in their own ways and neither one was better than the other.
@@joshyyy2596 no, it’s dancho, Taichou means “captain” and Dancho means “commander”, and Erwin’s military rank is that of a Commander, also if u watch attack on titan properly, then literally everyone calls Erwin a Dancho
okay but jokes aside i really love this. if there was an alternate reality where Erwin had the Colassal Titan, this is how I’d want it to be delivered. excellent video.
If Levi chose Erwin both Erwin and Eren would have packed up the entire season in just in part 1. isayama had to nerf eldian side so they killed him Damn_the likes😳
Unironically it should had been Erwin. Dude would had given an epic speech and convinced the entire world to not attack Paradis, with his words alone lmao
Kinda the main reason why Levi let him rest, coz putting this many expectations and pressure ona single man is unfair. Not that it is very fair to put that pressure on Armin, but I do believe Levi decided here with his heart and let live the one he liked less...Erwin could try and he d inevitably fail and it d cost too many lives....we all know the author, he likes to torture his characters as long as they breathe.
@raikage4173 raikagesan Agreed, but also the story is written so none of the accomplished d be possible without Armin either. On the other hand , if we are results oriented none of them really accomplished much, they just have different enemies now..the cycle is still ongoing.
@@othernerd3841 I don’t know. She was never really the commander type. She was bad at socialising and much more interested in invention and research. When she lost that and was forced to learn diplomacy, global politics etc, on top of losing so many people and the massive full scale revelation of there being another world out there, it’s understandable she’d become depressed and drained, and almost a shadow of her former self.
I’ve never been the biggest fan of the fandom making Reiner wanting to die a joke. But I definitely let out a chuckle at his face, You perfectly animated his expression, you can just see him thinking: “ohohohh, yes, my time has finally come, baby”
Armin: Marley fleet gets taken out Erwin: Kills everyone in range including Magath, Warriors possibly die depending on if Yelena sticks to trapping Pieck and Porco or not. Blimp can pick up Erwin and have him transform a 2nd time to wipe out fleet. Marley would have no warriors and no military commander being left in a complete state of disarray Excellent strategy commander
@marius andrei no its not valid because Armin did do this, he picked the bare minimum with destroying Marley's fleet. They had their shifter and with Magath still had a chain of command. Literally Erwin taking this route provides more options and a larger time frame for Paradise since Reiner would die in the explosion and be unable to suggest raiding Paradis after 3 days Edit: And you cant even use the excuse "If Armin did what Erwin did" because he didnt in canon. We can speculate on what Erwin *would do* but not Armong who's lazy ass did nothing for 4 years.
Big cap. Enemies were always there even when Erwin was alive. There's no way the Marlian government would've stopped the attack, because to them, they were devils. And they needed resources, divert the attention of other countries to the island of paradis. What could've been interesting to watch was how Eren would've dealt with these delicate political situations, his gambles and the way he displayed courageous attitude which sometimes is very scary but cool.
I would disagree and say Armin is Smarter but Erwin has the balls to do whatever it takes without regrets unlike Armin. Erwin is a better leader and Fighter with no regrets but isn't as quick minded like Armin. Erwin still should've been picked
@@jatinchanchlani8982 Not only this, but Eren and maybe Mikasa would likely defect from the Scouts due to Armin's death. They were already hostile towards Levi for waiting until he received news about Erwin's condition. Eren would most definitely leave if he got the chance.
And on this AU, it's certain to say that not even Hannes' death or the temporary mental, emotional and psychological breakdown Eren had on the Reiss Caves were comparable to the sorrow and grief he endured after Armin died, It surely was WAY worse than Historia's emotional breakdown and grief after Ymir left her!
For the people that say Erwin wouldn't be capable of killing his enemies across the sea think of this, Erwin was capable to sacrifice his own people for the cause, and Armin is supposed to be the pacifist yet he was capable of using the colossal titan to destroy his enemies in Marley. Imagine what Erwin would have done to save Eldia. I would love to see that happen ☹️
Erwin sacrificed his own people for his own dream of proving his father right. It was never about saving the people of Paradise, he just wanted to find out if his dad was right
@@lowresolutionbunnyfeng3919 It's not like he's gonna do the genocide thing right away. I can imagine him doing diplomacy and talking to world leaders to change their view of paradise and make Marley the common enemy if enough exposure, I mean it's pretty easy to make Marley the bad guy since they start war with other countries and abuse their dominant powers. Erwin could probably enjoy talking to people in banquets and discuss world problems with politicians than facing titans and watching your men get eaten. In either way Erwin isn't gonna lose his drive to protect his race, he'll probably just become depressed like every characters in season 4 but he'll still do whatever it takes for the survival of his people
Okay but is no one gonna talk about the animation quality and drawing details? Like damn- this is a masterpiece! And the touch of humor makes it even better.
Makes sense that Erwin would go nuclear right in the center of world leaders. Without commanders and anyone to lead the Marley forces, they're weak. And Erwin would gladly take the role of devil if it meant success. If Erwin told you to stay in the blast zone, you'd stay in the blast zone
I don't think he would have done it actually. Maybe I don't have such a deep understanding but I believe Erwin really valued human life. Knowing there is more humans, even if they are enemies he wouldn't have wanted war.
@@javigd96 not particularly. He just died together with tons of soldiers. He sent them in a suicide mission against the Beast. Erwin is such a badass, and of course fights for humanity's sake. But he's also so determinated he could do such a thing. This video has NOTHING wrong in my opinion
We all are forgetting how armin's death would have changed eren, and how it would have affected mikasa too That choice might have had major impact in everything. Eren's drive has always been to save mikasa and armin.
well it cant get any worse actually it would be better cause eren would have just killed 100% of humanity outside the walls and this time around value his friends lives more to the point were he would have restricted their powers when they came to stop him.
@@oldcat1790 one punch man is comedy about superhero stereotypes not meant to be taken seriously about man who is overpowered AOT is about war if Erwin just bodied everyone there is no more conflict
He’s like “there he is the commander of the scouts, Erwin Smith,” I wonder if he’ll make me an officer yet. And starts to walk up too him with this little happy goody good look on himself;
Predicting Erwin’s choices if he were chosen is hard. First, we consider his ambition and the reason he fought: the basement. If we assume Erwin has the will to continue fighting after reaching the basement, and after confirming humanity’s secrets, we can continue this hypothetical. However it gets messy very quickly. 1. Erwin said he’d take precautions against the enemies beyond the walls to ensure safety for Paradis, however, Erwin doesn’t know the scope or severity of the situation, it’s not as simple as he might’ve thought. It’s the entire world against the island. 2. Hange says Erwin wouldn’t have agreed with the rumbling. It’s true that Erwin sacrificed his comrades in the past, but does it mean that he’s willing to put all of humanity at stake? Consider the circumstances as to why Erwin sacrificed the scouts, it was for his selfish dream, so after achieving his dream and going to the basement, we would have to see some major character development from Erwin, possibly unthinkable development either way. Speaking of unthinkable development, there’s the Jaegerists. S4 as a whole would look entirely different with Erwin. Would there be a reason for the Jaegerists to band together behind the backs of Commander Hange and the scouts? They did so in the first place because they found the scouts to be incompetent, but with Erwin, it’s unlikely anyone would think this. Even so, Erwin would have suspected a group to form behind the scenes. There’s just too much to consider when it comes to Erwin’s survival, I don’t think we would’ve gotten anything remotely similar to what we have had he been saved. I think that’s the point too, Armin surviving would mean the decline of the scouts with Hange as commander. None of what happened in S4 would’ve happened if it weren’t for Armin’s survival. Eren had to move forward so the ends justified the means, ensuring Armin received the colossal was definitely part of this timeline. Nonetheless, this was a fun video, I just wanted to point out that there’s no real prediction for what AoT would even look like if Erwin received the colossal.
I absolutely agree, All dynamics would have changed had Erwin been chosen, and more scenarios and conflicts would arise, But one thing that's definitely clear is the Island could have used his leadership during the turmoil of the yeagerists and such. He would have had a way bigger role in controling the situation than Armin did. I don't think Erwin would want agree to the rumbling either, since if he spent his life trying to prove that there's an entire world out there, he'd want to explore it not destroy it
@kanesh sharma TL;DR… there are too many things that would change if Erwin was chosen, we likely wouldn’t see anything remotely similar the the s4 we saw, at least on the scouts end
What I like about Erwin the most, is that he himself chooses what's right and what's not. Nobody would ever order him what to do. Erwin knew that at that time there would be no future inside the walls without Eren and he convinced people to give up their lives to save him. If Erwin had decided otherwise, that wouldn't have happened. The story would've been much more different with Erwin surviving because he wouldn't have accepted Eren, Zeke or Floch as his leaders. I like to think that he would've chosen the most effective solutions to problems like he always does and would've united eldians with the rest of the world because even his worst enemies would've listened and cheered to his astonishing speeches.
This. A lot of people say he would side with Eren but I don't think so, Erwin would definitely be a more capable leader that would give Paradis a lot more options than violence
yeah but there's also the bullshittery of isayama's writing that eren, since he can apparently changed things from the future onto the past with the attack titan, could always make levi choose armin. or, eren could do something or make something/someone kill erwin since erwin seems like he wouldn't entirely go along with eren
@@Adrastus_ I mean no he can only speak with past users of the attack titan so unless he convinced grisha to kill erwin which he probably couldn’t do and survive to give the attack titan to eren in the first place so he can’t just time travel and have whatever he wants happen with no repercussions
I don't think Erwin would have been on board for Eren's plan to utterly annihilate all life beyond Paradise Island, but he would have been completely on board with everything else including using a full powered Rumbling to reduce Marley and their allies to rubble. Hell, he would have planned out the attack on Marley before Eren even thought of it (visions of the future aside of course). The main difference him being alive would make is that he would be the leader of the Jeagerists instead of Eren. Also, there wouldn't have been a need for a coup since Levi, Hanji, Pixis, and Zachary would have done whatever Erwin wanted.
@@mirrorzone5224 We can't be sure how he would act. Killing titans and blowing up an entire town with civilians are two different things. We haven't seen Erwin attack normal humans. I'm thinking that he would've been more defensive and peaceful than Eren.
he actually did choose Erwin, it was in last moments before injection, when he realised its better to let Erwin go, for sake of his friend. He said something similar to Armin too I think. He didnt choose Armin to become Colossal, he chose to not return Erwin into that hell of life. If situation was somehow better, like its final battle or something, he would still choose Erwin to live. It was circumstances of their going into more fights, that made him turn Armin. Not preference.
That's right, he wanted to let his friend rest after all he's done for humanity. But that sentimentality cost humanity dearly as in season 4 things get out of hand on Paradis because it needed Erwin's leadership to keep everything under control
@@revvin7624 I thought so too, but one coment months ago under some amv, dont remember anymore the video, pointed out to me that Erwin´s dream was to find out if there are humans beyond walls and he would have fullified that dream. Meaning, would he really want to destroy anything beyond walls? /not that I dont like the idea of him destroying Willy :D/ But yeah, leadership was nonexistent in season 4. I like Hange, but she was right, she wasnt cut for it, she wasn´ ready to be a leader in such terrible times and unfortunatelly didnt have time to become one. Its the lack of leadership that gave Eren space to decide on his own.
@@Trissana281 I think Erwin wouldn't want to destroy the world or anything, but to ensure the sacrifices his people made he would ensure Paradis' safety and victory by destroying maybe enemy armies and military, maybe sacrificing some citizens as well. He strives for the truth of the world so He wouldn't want to destroy that curious place
@@revvin7624 not only that, Levi choose Erwin because he didn't know that inside the basement, after Erwing learning it will he be still fighting, what kind of info is there, he didn't know. Armin on the other hand dreams of freedom, and he believed he made right decision, and I agree with him. Everything is clear and poetic but the 4 season came out and Isayama said let's ruin this story, and he made Armin side character, niiiice Isayama 👍 then everyone wanting Erwin to be alive
@@garri5108 Armin is truly useless in season 4, thats true. Like he died inside little bit. I dont blame hin, he saw shit like all of them, but he was kind of slow right before finish.
I now realize how efficient it would have been to use the collosal near the stage. It would actually take out all the military generals, diplomats of other countries and the titan shifters all at once. They would have had to work a little more in order to find the new shifters but it would work well in the end.
The shifters probably will be born on Paradise, because there are like one million of Eldians, and in the internment zones there are only few thousands
I actually think tat this would make Eren the antagonist losing his best friend he's going to be more depressed and he would actually won't care about his friends except Mikasa beacouse she tried to save Armin Eren would achieve freedom he won't have mercy and kill the entire population outside paradis And probably would kill some of his friends too And Reiner would live beacouse...why not
I mean using the colossal where the speech was held would get rid of all of the other titan shifters and almost all of the military instantly, so it would work really well
No, only the 5 enemy titans would die. Armor, beast, hammer, jaw, cart. And the titan abilities get reassigned to newborn eldians, most of whom are on paradis, so they wouldn’t be lost, in fact paradis would win a few of them.
@@user-td1jj8ll8y well there are still eldians being born outside of the walls, who’s to say those newborns don’t end up somewhere completely random, outside of paradis or even Marley
the fact that reiner's just smiling realizing burrito disappeared that day, so seeing erwin alive and well tells me that he's never been so happy that he gets to be in one of the closer seat to erwin's suicide bomb
I'm pretty sure Aot season 3 part 2 would be rated at least 9.5 scores if Levi choose veteran commander Erwin Smith instead of 15 years old newbie soldier Armin Alert
@@nihilisticboi3520 The reason stated in the anime is that Erwin needed to rest after fighting so long for humanity, but I think it's just a cop out because the author wanted the story to go with Armin, it makes no sense
@@bruhfunny8123 thats right. But Isayama had to kill Erwin on the field. That choose scene was so stupid. It ruined my aot love. And last 60 chapters finally kill it.
I just really love the scene at 1:28, where Erwin pulled himself out of the Colossal Titan's body. He looked very handsome with his messy hair blowing in the wind. You did a great job animating everything! Just like you, I also love Erwin and believe that he should've survived. ❤️
The decision to kill Erwin is literally so Eren could do this. So the focus is on Eren cuz he's the main protagonist. Otherwise, why would anyone rely on Eren once it's Marley arc when there's still commander Erwin?
The anime doesn't make sense in the beginning either. If collosal titan could be Marleyan's impending doom why they would send amateur titan shifters to paradis island knowing the collosal might fall to the wrong hands in the first place? If they just wanted to break the wall reiner alone could do that
@@friedcalamari4929 Reiner could have destroyed the wall alone, but aren't u forgetting that their real mission was to retrieve the Founding? The move to destroy the wall was basically to cause chaos and nothing spells chaos better than a Titan towering above the walls that are supposed to protect the people of Paradis..... PS: Although I agree that making kids warriors, is a bit dubious. I assume that it is to ensure that they achieve the peak of their powers in their early 20s but late 20s or even early 30s seem fine imo
@@arpitanand4693 The reason is simple. When they become adults, there's a chance that they might change their views while as children you know for a fact that they'll follow your every command. Sure, there's a chance that doesnt work but that point failure is even greater in adults. What is dumb is that they sent 4 kids alone to retrieve the Founder's power and it doesnt seem like they were taught how to enter aside from being responsible for the deaths of atleast 200000 people. Imagine you have to commit an unprecedented amount of genocide just to enter the country. An adult supervisor might have guided them in terms of strategy. Not consulting the Tyburs about the Founder's retrieval mission is also dumb as that would have actually given them useful Intel on the founder itself. Even if you dont know about the pacifist vow, the ancestor of the Tyburs according to propaganda helped take down the Founder before this, you'd think you would consult someone who might have memories of how the King was first defeated And why didnt they give them enough supplies? That's your goddamn warrior unit and you expect to give them such little resources that they end up in the situation which actually happened? With them losing the Jaw even before the mission started
@@rupeniugavule3479 Yes. Maybe he would've gone rogue earlier if Erwin was chosen, sabotaging the scouts and moving forward all by himself, and with Mikasa probably.
I love this version of the Declaration of War scene where Mr. Tybur actually witnesses the Titan appearing. Just a quick, frightening "oh crap, the enemies are RIGHT HERE" moment
Not to mention, Erwin would have kept eren correctly. He wouldn't have gone on his own. Erwin kept eren correctly so he wouldn't go off on his own, But since he passed eren went on his own. And the ending of AOT would be completely different.
I wouldn't doubt that Eren would do everything he could to go against Erwin (and Levi) every chance he got, he's very close minded, and holds grudges, he wouldn't just let Erwin keep him in check so easily if Armin died because of the choice
@@annaleeee Thats true. However lets put in consideration that Erwin also wanted to do the same thing as eren. Imagine the attack On marley but with better directive and more planning. Chances are the outcome would have been a lot better and sasha most likely wouldn't have die for many reasons mostly relating to the factor that it was planned more. Following with this if Erwin was on Eren's side he would have never became a prisoner/detained. This would mean yeagerists would never even become a thing or very rare story wise.
Willy: tries to perform a speech that will likely cause everyone who agrees with the motives of the speech to die in a horrendous fashion Erwin: and I took that personally....
Eren looking down from the blimp, "Commander doing the dirty work I would've done for the sake of Paradis, the future of our race and freedom"(one devil to another)
This is really beautiful. I' m not sure why, but I think this animation has a peaceful aura. I liked the face expressions so much. Especially Zeke's blank face and Eren's sadness. The music choice is great. I love this animation!
Would Erwin agree with the rumbling? Maybe Would Erwin renounce Eren and fight with the alliance? Maybe The fact is Levi decision wasn’t in the interest of humanity.
I love how you can just do an insanely well animated shitpost that also tugs at my heart strings just for long enough to forget that it's a shitpost - only to come full circle and have a colossal titan slamdunk some warships. :D I love your work dude, never stop. You're getting better and better and it looks like you really enjoy doing it. :)
But imagine the outcomes of erwin still being alive. It would cost armin’s life if levi chose erwin, but if erwin was still alive, they would basically have better leadership and a this mess the scouts are in wouldn’t be a thing if erwin was also here. Maybe choosing commander erwin was probably the better choice. Edit: Bro there is a war in the comments
Dude, why do people act like Armin is the only human whenever we talk about who should have lived? Erwin is human too, his death has an effect on people too, he has loved ones too (especially Levi). He is worth more than just his leadership skills. If he is the one who survives it should be for more than just his skills. This is exactly why Levi choose to let him die. Because everyone hated him and treated him as a tool for war and winning. Meanwhile Armin is the uwu softboi who has to be saved because he has fwiends. It's not really about Armin, Levi cared way more about Erwin, he barely new Armin. It's to spare Erwin from further suffering and being used as a convenient monster for the people.
I kept thinking when I saw scene where Levi resurrected Armin that he should split the injection in half to make Erwin feed Reiner. I always think it will be epic if Erwin became the armoured titan
I don't think splitting might have worked out. Because, there wouldn't be a point of putting much more than necessary fluid to make a titan. At least I doubt that
@@patrickgardner321 that's a very apt and logical point or observation. Didn't think of that. Yeah, it might be true that all it requires is a lil drop or.. it might be those situations that this contradiction skipped the artist mind or... It could be those fast forwarded situations in movies or cartoons. for example; in Ben 10 when he transforms, they show all the transformation sequence Nd at times they just skip to the end result in 1 sec. I don't know if you get what I'm saying. But yeah, you're very right about that observation. The smallest drop might be enough to change people. But that doesn't really make sense if they had as much in the injection shot.
I love this series is a great foundation for theories and "what ifs". The fact that people theorize Erwin would do what Eren did himself is in character.
God I'd love if there was an alternate universe written by Isayama showing what would've happened if Erwin was the inheritor. I guess it wouldn't work from a "time travel" as it currently stands in the main series but man- I would love to see how Erwin would've dealt with Marley.
No. The whole point behind Levi choosing Armin even though he wanted to revive Erwin is due to the fact that after finally confirming his dad's theory Erwin would simply lose his motive to keep on defending humanity. Hence Levi's constant flashback to Kenny saying that we all need to be drunk on something to keep moving forward.
No, you talk like Erwin was a sort of spoiled brat, he would keep moving forward of course he will lose some motivation, but he wouldn’t let the death of his comrades be in vain just because he fulfilled his dream.
Really believe the main reason Levi chose armin is because he wanted Erwin, basically his only friend (or closest friend), rest and not have to resort to becoming more evil than evil itself just to save everyone. This video actually kind of shows exactly what Levi didn’t want Erwin to have to end up doing.
I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS!!! XD Your style is so like the official one, but with an original spin to it! Nice touch adding humor, too! Reiner being broken and mindf*cked was incredibly appropriate, and then there's that ending itself. Just perfect, freaking perfect.
Honestly, Erwin would probably be the best choice. He has more control over Levi than Hanji as in the position of Commander and could control and outsmart Eren in a battle. Not only that but he would be able to convince most of the yeagerists to stay loyal to the military government.
@@revvin7624 exactly, I have always believed this, it is so frustrating to see ARMIN chosen to live over the literal commander. I suppose it would alter a good bit of the rest of the plot if Armin did die but realistically it made no sense
it is stated that armoured titan can withstand the colossal titan transformation (even if it is nuke transformation), but it depends on the willpower. Knowing reiner he won't miss the chance to die
Erwin was always the right choice, change my mind
You're right.
Bro did you see new trailer?
@Yassine I love you too😍
Yeah man Glad they didn't pre-animate it like last time lol
@@revvin7624 yes I am excited also love you😂😂😂 like yassin 😂😂
Levi: Erwin, we need a plan to attack
Erwin: i have plan, attack
Why erwin don't have an hand
@@pn1pna his hand got bitten by an abnormal titan in Season 2
@@rishin7852 he should have it regenerated right away after becoming a titan.
@@taskmaster9891 welp...There goes the plot hole
@@rishin7852 LMAO
Everyone: *Terrified of getting killed*
Reiner: Finally my dreams are becoming true
Ya I was looking for a comment that noticed his smile too lol
Who the fuck are you?
Isayama SIKE BOI
I think they were confused rather than terrified. None of them except for Reiner would've known who Erwin was.
“Oh god yes I’m going to die so fucking hard😩”
-Reiner, probably.
As much as Erwin would hate to kill all those innocent people, he would do it if it was absolutely necessary to save his people.
Exactly, he would try to win first by talking to world leaders or diplomacy and leave this as a last choice
Just like EREN. I see no difference.
@@chickenwings6745 Except Eren doesn't talk to world leaders or have the talking ability to convince them to change sides or even turn them agains Marley, which Erwin would have the ability to do
Erwin wouldn’t hate killing innocent people. He would go along with eren. He doesn’t care as long as his people win.
@@revvin7624 there's no way, eren did right because even if the paradisers walk around people would still not agree on that no matter government accepted that or not. He has to remove everyone from this world and again start the humanity with equality and freedom
The real reason Levi chose Erwin is beacuse Isayama realised how hard it would be to write Erwin in s4
Oh really?
i agree. the same way he nerfed levi for the final season
@@gloriasomma4036 fr, I wouldn't want to see a nerfed Erwin
Yeah, or maybe because Levi was ashamed that Zeke got away despite of his promise with Erwin. Imagine when Erwin wakes up? 😅
it was hard for him to write armin in s 4 too
Now imagine this scene.
Erwin looks at Willie and says
"We accept your declaration" and then he turns into a colossal titan.
Parabellum
Could have been one of the most epic scenes of 🤯
u write fanfics don’t you
shits cringe af
@@merki8290 no cap
I love how the comments just agreed that if Erwin didn't die, he'll be the protagonist.
The season will end in 12 episode
Too bad he's dead, not saying Armin is wrong pick... Just saying everything will be much better with Erwin plan
bro erwin would low key join eren
He was the protagonist since his first appearance
@@kayden2119 How? That doesn't make any sense, he is closer to Levi's and Hange's beliefs.
@@raymax_1071 i kinda doubt erwin would not be down for killing all the people trying to kill him
If Levi choose Erwin, AoT final season part 2 just wouldn't exist
Erwin would solo Marley's asses and win the war😂
@@revvin7624 Erwin the True Chad !!
@@AM-nz6pn Always has been😎
Yep, because Eren would be long dead. There's no way Erwin stands by and allows Eren to endanger Paradis for the sake of protecting Krista.
Or Eren and Erwin become enemies in a civil war.
@@jackslater4152 You bring up a very interesting point. Eren and Erwin clashing dynamics would have been far more interesting than Armin standing about doing nothing
The fact that from Erwin's death onwards, things just slowly got worse and worse, just showed how great a man he was.
I love Erwin but let's not pretend he's a Saint he willingly led so many of his own men to their deaths and while he does regret it and show remorse he also realizes that being the Commander of the survey corps he needed to become a monster and throw away his humanity to lead himself forward to proving his father right
@@noriakikakyoin1423 nobody's calling him a saint just the best leader they could've had and a better candidate for the colossal titan
@noriakikakyoin1423 you don't need to be a Saint to be a good leader.
I agree so much with that. As soon as erwin died i saw a decrease in the quality or writing. Just shows how powerful of a character he is…
Imagine being so epic that the show becomes worse when you’re no longer alive
Reiners reaction is so accurate and funny because hes the only one there who recognizes Erwin 😂
The sweet embrace of death has finally arrived.
Pieck also recognize him
@@melodica5407 I don't think she did. Back on Paradis, Pieck only saw Erwin for a brief time when he charged in with the rest of the survey corps.
@@Matihood1 Oh yeah could be.
She just recognize the ODM gear.
Reiner is smiling cause he is going to finally die. 🥲
I realize later. It was actually pretty cruel of Levi to give Armin the colossal Titan. Armin was the gentliest character and he gave him the most destructive power.
I think it was fitting to have a titan holder with a certain level of restraint which can be seen in Armin and Bertholdt.
Although Erwin would be a good candidate as well, he's smart enough when to do it
@@TheWatcher1009 yeah but I don't think Erwin has less restraint either. Now imagine Eren with colossal
@@muanilunga he got it in the manga kind of
It's always the gentle one gets the colossal titan
On the other hand, it would have been cruel to give Erwin the injection. Erwin had already done so much, and he deserved to rest. To be honest, both decisions were cruel in their own ways and neither one was better than the other.
Why is nobody talking about “AND HIS NAME IS!!! ERWIN DANCHOOOOOOOO!!!”
Lol first
HAHAHAHAHA wth you got me
🤣🤣🤣
taichou not dancho but still very funny
@@joshyyy2596 no, it’s dancho, Taichou means “captain” and Dancho means “commander”, and Erwin’s military rank is that of a Commander, also if u watch attack on titan properly, then literally everyone calls Erwin a Dancho
"To rise above mosters, u have to abandon humanity " - Erwin Smith to Eren Yeager
Wryyyyyyyy
@@alexcsr6450 yamerooo diooooo !!
thought this is JJK or smt
Thats what fucking armin said you dumb fuck
thought this was MLK or smt
okay but jokes aside i really love this. if there was an alternate reality where Erwin had the Colassal Titan, this is how I’d want it to be delivered. excellent video.
Thanks! I really hope they make a ''What If'' OVA where Erwin is chosen but that will probably never happen lol
There should be "what if" series for attack on titan
It will be allot cool
Then the eldians would win the war XD imagine if that was true instead of putting the colossal titan on armin a.k.a the one who's astolfo 2.0
@@freedom5925 Fr lol
Eren makes the what ifs, so in no timeline he would let Armin die 😂
Renier be like - what a beautiful light that lead him to his dead 😂😂
He's finally going to realize his dream😂
@@revvin7624 😂😂you just give a good plan, they can done this with Armin than everything will end
@@Kp2k24 I guess Armin wouldn't be ready to sacrifice so many innocent lives with his titan explosion, especially Eldian civilians
@@revvin7624 yes good one
How are you still alive Reiner? 😳
"When people tell you to abandon your dreams and die, but your dream is to die"
-Rainah Braum 0:56
Underrated comment
Jean : Stop smelling the letter from someone's wife, you sick pervert.
Rainah : So Historia... Another reason to kill myself.
U mean Reiner broom
I am dying of laughter
Plot Twist: Reiner still survived
Let’s not forget that with Erwin alive, Zoe also wouldn’t be depressed anymore and that’s always a huge positive
Yeah but every friend of armin would be
@@fennic3391that’s like the entire cast
@@expertarcher8542 ik
Who is zoe
@@zhakeebogabong8269 Hange
If Levi chose Erwin both Erwin and Eren would have packed up the entire season in just in part 1. isayama had to nerf eldian side so they killed him
Damn_the likes😳
Absolutely🤣
Fax yo!
Erwin choose armin instead of him
Levi did choose Erwin, it was Erwin who chose Armin
Erwin was done, after checking the basement he was probably going to lose all his motivation
Unironically it should had been Erwin. Dude would had given an epic speech and convinced the entire world to not attack Paradis, with his words alone lmao
@raikage4173 raikagesan gotta nerf him for the plot to survive tbh
Implying armin wouldn’t do the same
Kinda the main reason why Levi let him rest, coz putting this many expectations and pressure ona single man is unfair. Not that it is very fair to put that pressure on Armin, but I do believe Levi decided here with his heart and let live the one he liked less...Erwin could try and he d inevitably fail and it d cost too many lives....we all know the author, he likes to torture his characters as long as they breathe.
no he’s if manipulative and doesn’t care that his soldiers are dying
@raikage4173 raikagesan Agreed, but also the story is written so none of the accomplished d be possible without Armin either. On the other hand , if we are results oriented none of them really accomplished much, they just have different enemies now..the cycle is still ongoing.
Galliard" "Who dat?"
Pieck: "Huh?"
Reiner: "YESSSS! PLEASE END THIS!"
Reiner the Suicidal Titan
When the show was armored on titan
**Reiner survives cause moves his conscience to Isayama toe nail**
let's face the fact. Reiner will probably wait....nah he will definitly survived that attack just because Isayama likes him.
@@hattori8807
He'd probably turn into the armour titan accidentally protecting him from the blast and surviving again
0:56 Reiner knowing he is about to die, finally happy.
Reiner: Finally now I can rest in peace in the afterlife
Plot twist: He was the only one to survive Erwin explosion
haha lol
plot armor
@@dantdmfangamingrich9802considering if he transformed there armored titan is the only one to withstand the explosion anyway lol
Erwin's death in S3 proves that the lack of a good leader only causes disasters. He was my favorite.
Yeah, that’s really when shit went down the drain. Because it was happening before sure, but Erwin kept everything together.
not really hange was just dumbled down for the sake of the plot moving forward but ehh
trash ending unfortunately
@@othernerd3841 honestly. And they did the same thing to admin, he suddenly became a whole lot dumber in S4.
@@othernerd3841 I agree with a lot of what y'all said
@@othernerd3841 I don’t know. She was never really the commander type. She was bad at socialising and much more interested in invention and research. When she lost that and was forced to learn diplomacy, global politics etc, on top of losing so many people and the massive full scale revelation of there being another world out there, it’s understandable she’d become depressed and drained, and almost a shadow of her former self.
I’ve never been the biggest fan of the fandom making Reiner wanting to die a joke.
But I definitely let out a chuckle at his face,
You perfectly animated his expression, you can just see him thinking: “ohohohh, yes, my time has finally come, baby”
Lmao same
He is a joke
same, reiner was sacrificed to eren, zeke was sacrificed to levi.
@@sastaassh1112 Nah you’ll start liking Reiner once part 2 comes out
@@TypeMJ yh I hated him but after I read the manga I felt bad
if erwin was chosen shit would have never gone so out of hand.
He's probably the best commander in humanity's history so yeah he wouldn't let the situation get so messed up lol
that probably why Isayama chose not to have Levi choose him. season 4 would either be cut way short or a whole different timeline would happen
And Ereh would've never been an underdog psycho as the majority of the fanbase sees him. I really would've taken him in Arumih's place
It still would’ve
It depends. Probably would've been a psycho, but not an underdog
2 years later this is still the hardest thing to come out of the aot community
Armin: Marley fleet gets taken out
Erwin: Kills everyone in range including Magath, Warriors possibly die depending on if Yelena sticks to trapping Pieck and Porco or not. Blimp can pick up Erwin and have him transform a 2nd time to wipe out fleet. Marley would have no warriors and no military commander being left in a complete state of disarray
Excellent strategy commander
sasuga Commander Erwin
good ending for now 🐤
@Julius Yeah he can just stomp on the fleet or make Zeke transform and destroy it
@Julius we dont know its limitations. It's never actually been stated.
@marius andrei no its not valid because Armin did do this, he picked the bare minimum with destroying Marley's fleet. They had their shifter and with Magath still had a chain of command. Literally Erwin taking this route provides more options and a larger time frame for Paradise since Reiner would die in the explosion and be unable to suggest raiding Paradis after 3 days
Edit: And you cant even use the excuse "If Armin did what Erwin did" because he didnt in canon. We can speculate on what Erwin *would do* but not Armong who's lazy ass did nothing for 4 years.
Erwin having Colossal Titan powers, damn that would have been crazy, Erwin's intelligence & Colossal's powers = No more enemies
Big cap. Enemies were always there even when Erwin was alive. There's no way the Marlian government would've stopped the attack, because to them, they were devils. And they needed resources, divert the attention of other countries to the island of paradis.
What could've been interesting to watch was how Eren would've dealt with these delicate political situations, his gambles and the way he displayed courageous attitude which sometimes is very scary but cool.
I would disagree and say Armin is Smarter but Erwin has the balls to do whatever it takes without regrets unlike Armin. Erwin is a better leader and Fighter with no regrets but isn't as quick minded like Armin. Erwin still should've been picked
@@jatinchanchlani8982 Not only this, but Eren and maybe Mikasa would likely defect from the Scouts due to Armin's death. They were already hostile towards Levi for waiting until he received news about Erwin's condition. Eren would most definitely leave if he got the chance.
@@Alanlopez-do1rz armin went from an ok character to the most useless in aot real fast
@Knee Ger Bruv he s the smartest char in the AOT universe. His brain is speed
Is no one gonna appreciate how well made the animation is
Glad you appreciate it man❤
@@revvin7624 ❤
@@revvin7624 🗿🔥
No one, so shut up
@@revvin7624 ur so underrated dude ,keep doing this
The scene where you showed Eren's silhouette before showing his sad expression.....that just broke my heart-
And on this AU, it's certain to say that not even Hannes' death or the temporary mental, emotional and psychological breakdown Eren had on the Reiss Caves were comparable to the sorrow and grief he endured after Armin died, It surely was WAY worse than Historia's emotional breakdown and grief after Ymir left her!
armin: just destroyed marine
erwin: BEST PLAN KILL THEM ALL
I like how their names are similar
But some words in upside down
When Eren does its bad but when Erwin does its great 😂😂
You can’t have enemies if they’re all dead
Susumeeeeeeeee
@@sastaassh1112 pls
For the people that say Erwin wouldn't be capable of killing his enemies across the sea think of this, Erwin was capable to sacrifice his own people for the cause, and Armin is supposed to be the pacifist yet he was capable of using the colossal titan to destroy his enemies in Marley. Imagine what Erwin would have done to save Eldia. I would love to see that happen ☹️
Erwin would have started the rumbling if it meant saving paradis
Erwin sacrificed his own people for his own dream of proving his father right. It was never about saving the people of Paradise, he just wanted to find out if his dad was right
@@lowresolutionbunnyfeng3919
It's not like he's gonna do the genocide thing right away. I can imagine him doing diplomacy and talking to world leaders to change their view of paradise and make Marley the common enemy if enough exposure, I mean it's pretty easy to make Marley the bad guy since they start war with other countries and abuse their dominant powers. Erwin could probably enjoy talking to people in banquets and discuss world problems with politicians than facing titans and watching your men get eaten. In either way Erwin isn't gonna lose his drive to protect his race, he'll probably just become depressed like every characters in season 4 but he'll still do whatever it takes for the survival of his people
@@hunterofdarkness8329 agreed
@@hunterofdarkness8329 That would be interesting. The show would’ve found a better ending for Eldia instead of the mass genocide thingy.
I just realized it, your drawing is getting better and better now
It was always the drawing quality that needed improving😂 Glad you like it!
@@revvin7624 can you link the beginning music? I can't find it
@@BackBeater It's from Kuroko:
th-cam.com/video/CN7rzwtAIjw/w-d-xo.html
it starts at 1:04 but slowed down
@@revvin7624 thanks
@@BackBeater No problem♥
Okay but is no one gonna talk about the animation quality and drawing details? Like damn- this is a masterpiece! And the touch of humor makes it even better.
Makes sense that Erwin would go nuclear right in the center of world leaders. Without commanders and anyone to lead the Marley forces, they're weak. And Erwin would gladly take the role of devil if it meant success.
If Erwin told you to stay in the blast zone, you'd stay in the blast zone
Exactly
All warriors would die in an instant , all their enemies would be killed in a second .
I don't think he would have done it actually. Maybe I don't have such a deep understanding but I believe Erwin really valued human life. Knowing there is more humans, even if they are enemies he wouldn't have wanted war.
They wouldve killed the founder titan if they did this and wouldve to again locate the new founder holder.
@@javigd96 not particularly. He just died together with tons of soldiers. He sent them in a suicide mission against the Beast. Erwin is such a badass, and of course fights for humanity's sake. But he's also so determinated he could do such a thing. This video has NOTHING wrong in my opinion
We all are forgetting how armin's death would have changed eren, and how it would have affected mikasa too
That choice might have had major impact in everything.
Eren's drive has always been to save mikasa and armin.
Well by that time his only thoughts would drift into a general idea of protecting his people more.....was that clear to understand?
@@mrsung9720 never moreso than those 2
We dont care its war boi thay soldiers. Would either break them or motivate them to not waste their colleagues death
well it cant get any worse actually it would be better cause eren would have just killed 100% of humanity outside the walls and this time around value his friends lives more to the point were he would have restricted their powers when they came to stop him.
He would still want to save Mikasa
after watch the final season of aot. Now i realise this is why we really need HIM
Yeah but hero is too overpowered the show won't be as interesting anymore
@@TotalAnalyst2 tell it to OPM and Mob Psycho
@@oldcat1790 one punch man is comedy about superhero stereotypes not meant to be taken seriously about man who is overpowered AOT is about war if Erwin just bodied everyone there is no more conflict
Omg THE ENDING LMAOO. I can’t praise your skills enough. Very, very well done, your improvement in character design from just a year ago is amazing.
A year ago we were using stick figures lol, glad you like it bro👊
What do you mean "character design"
This characters were already designed, he didn't invent them.
Why is Erwin still missing his left arm? If he was turned into the Colossal titan his arm would of grew back.
The left arm is behind his back, his right arm which was bitten off in season 2 has grown back, He's holding the helmet with it
Lol you missing the left arm this is style of position drawing lmao. The left arm is behind back because pose erwin like that hahaha
@@revvin7624 haha it doesnt matter for me, after all this scene would be awesome if this happened instead
Even if he did, It’s like Eren. Strategy to stay in Marley.
@@dablazingbryan5559 I think it's a bad strategy if he "disguises" as a Marleyan soldier without an arm. That raises suspicions. But it'll look cool.
0:53 Reiner knows exactly what's about to happen
Reiner: I welcome the sweet release of death
Reiner knowing they lost Bertholdt and seeing Erwin with both arms would definitely know exactly what's going to happen.
His face without the actual context is making me dizzy
Reiner's face means that he will be free
Man, Reiner's reaction says it all.😂😂
I just love how Reiner smiled
When Erwin came in front...😇
Isayma plot armor boi
He’s like “there he is the commander of the scouts, Erwin Smith,” I wonder if he’ll make me an officer yet. And starts to walk up too him with this little happy goody good look on himself;
There were no survivors expect for vice chief Braun the armored titan
Brooo plot armor do be doing reiner dirty
The Colossal Titan jumping in the air is an absolute fever dream
Predicting Erwin’s choices if he were chosen is hard. First, we consider his ambition and the reason he fought: the basement. If we assume Erwin has the will to continue fighting after reaching the basement, and after confirming humanity’s secrets, we can continue this hypothetical. However it gets messy very quickly. 1. Erwin said he’d take precautions against the enemies beyond the walls to ensure safety for Paradis, however, Erwin doesn’t know the scope or severity of the situation, it’s not as simple as he might’ve thought. It’s the entire world against the island. 2. Hange says Erwin wouldn’t have agreed with the rumbling. It’s true that Erwin sacrificed his comrades in the past, but does it mean that he’s willing to put all of humanity at stake? Consider the circumstances as to why Erwin sacrificed the scouts, it was for his selfish dream, so after achieving his dream and going to the basement, we would have to see some major character development from Erwin, possibly unthinkable development either way. Speaking of unthinkable development, there’s the Jaegerists. S4 as a whole would look entirely different with Erwin. Would there be a reason for the Jaegerists to band together behind the backs of Commander Hange and the scouts? They did so in the first place because they found the scouts to be incompetent, but with Erwin, it’s unlikely anyone would think this. Even so, Erwin would have suspected a group to form behind the scenes.
There’s just too much to consider when it comes to Erwin’s survival, I don’t think we would’ve gotten anything remotely similar to what we have had he been saved. I think that’s the point too, Armin surviving would mean the decline of the scouts with Hange as commander. None of what happened in S4 would’ve happened if it weren’t for Armin’s survival. Eren had to move forward so the ends justified the means, ensuring Armin received the colossal was definitely part of this timeline.
Nonetheless, this was a fun video, I just wanted to point out that there’s no real prediction for what AoT would even look like if Erwin received the colossal.
I absolutely agree, All dynamics would have changed had Erwin been chosen, and more scenarios and conflicts would arise, But one thing that's definitely clear is the Island could have used his leadership during the turmoil of the yeagerists and such. He would have had a way bigger role in controling the situation than Armin did. I don't think Erwin would want agree to the rumbling either, since if he spent his life trying to prove that there's an entire world out there, he'd want to explore it not destroy it
@kanesh sharma TL;DR… there are too many things that would change if Erwin was chosen, we likely wouldn’t see anything remotely similar the the s4 we saw, at least on the scouts end
Nerd 😂😭
@@samuelpaz3218 we both watch anime, we’re in the same boat bro
@@soggyfan123 “we’re in the same boat bro” he said seconds before collosal Erwin body slammed it.
Oh God I love how Reiner is Just smiling knowing he'll finally die 😂😂😂😂
Isayama PLOT ARMOR BOU
What I like about Erwin the most, is that he himself chooses what's right and what's not. Nobody would ever order him what to do. Erwin knew that at that time there would be no future inside the walls without Eren and he convinced people to give up their lives to save him. If Erwin had decided otherwise, that wouldn't have happened. The story would've been much more different with Erwin surviving because he wouldn't have accepted Eren, Zeke or Floch as his leaders. I like to think that he would've chosen the most effective solutions to problems like he always does and would've united eldians with the rest of the world because even his worst enemies would've listened and cheered to his astonishing speeches.
This. A lot of people say he would side with Eren but I don't think so, Erwin would definitely be a more capable leader that would give Paradis a lot more options than violence
yeah but there's also the bullshittery of isayama's writing that eren, since he can apparently changed things from the future onto the past with the attack titan, could always make levi choose armin. or, eren could do something or make something/someone kill erwin since erwin seems like he wouldn't entirely go along with eren
@@Adrastus_ I mean no he can only speak with past users of the attack titan so unless he convinced grisha to kill erwin which he probably couldn’t do and survive to give the attack titan to eren in the first place so he can’t just time travel and have whatever he wants happen with no repercussions
I don't think Erwin would have been on board for Eren's plan to utterly annihilate all life beyond Paradise Island, but he would have been completely on board with everything else including using a full powered Rumbling to reduce Marley and their allies to rubble. Hell, he would have planned out the attack on Marley before Eren even thought of it (visions of the future aside of course). The main difference him being alive would make is that he would be the leader of the Jeagerists instead of Eren. Also, there wouldn't have been a need for a coup since Levi, Hanji, Pixis, and Zachary would have done whatever Erwin wanted.
@@mirrorzone5224 We can't be sure how he would act. Killing titans and blowing up an entire town with civilians are two different things. We haven't seen Erwin attack normal humans. I'm thinking that he would've been more defensive and peaceful than Eren.
"AND HIS NAME IS ERWIN DANCHO"!!
This had me dead🤣🤣🤣
just an opinion : Erwin should've been the protagonist
Unpopular opinion: Veterans deserve better
My opinion:Mikasa was the protagonist all along
i support this
@@praveenroy7379 deserved a movie like levi's we needed more of nanaba hange and mike
Nah I like Eren but Erwin should’ve lived instead
Everyone: oh sh** we are gonna die
Reiner: oh yeah i am gonna die
he actually did choose Erwin, it was in last moments before injection, when he realised its better to let Erwin go, for sake of his friend. He said something similar to Armin too I think. He didnt choose Armin to become Colossal, he chose to not return Erwin into that hell of life. If situation was somehow better, like its final battle or something, he would still choose Erwin to live. It was circumstances of their going into more fights, that made him turn Armin. Not preference.
That's right, he wanted to let his friend rest after all he's done for humanity. But that sentimentality cost humanity dearly as in season 4 things get out of hand on Paradis because it needed Erwin's leadership to keep everything under control
@@revvin7624 I thought so too, but one coment months ago under some amv, dont remember anymore the video, pointed out to me that Erwin´s dream was to find out if there are humans beyond walls and he would have fullified that dream. Meaning, would he really want to destroy anything beyond walls? /not that I dont like the idea of him destroying Willy :D/ But yeah, leadership was nonexistent in season 4. I like Hange, but she was right, she wasnt cut for it, she wasn´ ready to be a leader in such terrible times and unfortunatelly didnt have time to become one. Its the lack of leadership that gave Eren space to decide on his own.
@@Trissana281 I think Erwin wouldn't want to destroy the world or anything, but to ensure the sacrifices his people made he would ensure Paradis' safety and victory by destroying maybe enemy armies and military, maybe sacrificing some citizens as well. He strives for the truth of the world so He wouldn't want to destroy that curious place
@@revvin7624 not only that, Levi choose Erwin because he didn't know that inside the basement, after Erwing learning it will he be still fighting, what kind of info is there, he didn't know. Armin on the other hand dreams of freedom, and he believed he made right decision, and I agree with him. Everything is clear and poetic but the 4 season came out and Isayama said let's ruin this story, and he made Armin side character, niiiice Isayama 👍 then everyone wanting Erwin to be alive
@@garri5108 Armin is truly useless in season 4, thats true. Like he died inside little bit. I dont blame hin, he saw shit like all of them, but he was kind of slow right before finish.
0:56
Reiner be like: finally, i can die in peace
The smile of a winner🤣
XD
What a beautiful smile that Reiner has
Reiner's face when he saw Erwin.
I know this is a month late but his face says fucking funaly
@@xderrodecki8905 He greeted death with a smile
@@grayski3324 yea since he wants to die
He's like : oh shit, fuck! We're so screwed... If Erwin's here than the fucking ninja is not far away... Ah shit.
Reiner: "Oh no! Anyway..."
@0:16 When AOT meets South Park
I now realize how efficient it would have been to use the collosal near the stage. It would actually take out all the military generals, diplomats of other countries and the titan shifters all at once. They would have had to work a little more in order to find the new shifters but it would work well in the end.
@PeanutButter_Destiny The navy without its command and morale is a headless chicken, and even then colossals wouldve melted them apart.
@PeanutButter_Destiny With the power of the Colossal, it would be fast, the fleet would simply not have time. Yes, and Commander Magath would be dead.
The titan shifters would just regenerate
@@Bigunz Shifters can`t regenerate if they are turned to dust
The shifters probably will be born on Paradise, because there are like one million of Eldians, and in the internment zones there are only few thousands
That ending Tho!
*"And his name is *ERWIN DANCHOO!!"*
I ROLFED SO HARD!! 😂😂😂😂
The “AND HIS NAME IS” gets me all the time, be it Eren or Erwin 😂
JOHN CENAAAAAAAAAAAA
zhong xina
Zeke is like I don't give a f***
I love that ending and how Eren didn’t become the antagonist
I actually think tat this would make Eren the antagonist losing his best friend he's going to be more depressed and he would actually won't care about his friends except Mikasa beacouse she tried to save Armin
Eren would achieve freedom he won't have mercy and kill the entire population outside paradis
And probably would kill some of his friends too
And Reiner would live beacouse...why not
Eren is never an antagonist
@@okami9039 he isn't but he does what an antagonist would do
A hero sacrifices a person for the world and a villain the world for that person
@@marulaS3X that doesn't make him an antagonist lol there are ton of characters who are good guys but done terrible things worse than eren
@@marulaS3X Reiner would live because he can never be killed, man even failed to kill himself
The zoom in on Erwin’s face as everybody else has no idea what’s about to happen is just amazing.
Except for Reiner, he's smiling for he can die in peace
Except rinah
Except for Rinah Broom
Reiner clearly knows what's about to happen lol
I mean using the colossal where the speech was held would get rid of all of the other titan shifters and almost all of the military instantly, so it would work really well
Yea it would be perfect, the only problem would be the 7 titan shifters would be obliterated and would be lost by both sides
@@liltachanka9913 6 titan shifters
@@senuzul yea ur right, forgot about Annie
No, only the 5 enemy titans would die. Armor, beast, hammer, jaw, cart. And the titan abilities get reassigned to newborn eldians, most of whom are on paradis, so they wouldn’t be lost, in fact paradis would win a few of them.
@@user-td1jj8ll8y well there are still eldians being born outside of the walls, who’s to say those newborns don’t end up somewhere completely random, outside of paradis or even Marley
i like how reiner is smiling while porco and pieck is terrified and staring at the good ol' erwin
Reiner just wanted to die and he is finally happy that he is going to die
the fact that reiner's just smiling realizing burrito disappeared that day, so seeing erwin alive and well tells me that he's never been so happy that he gets to be in one of the closer seat to erwin's suicide bomb
Isyama again SAVE HIM
BURRITO LMAOOO
You can see the sadness in Eren's eyes because he lost Armin...
We didn’t see eren eyes 😂
We did see eren eyes 😂
No, hes sad because he wanted to play wrestling with Zofia and friends
@@left1776 we saw him at 1:39
Most people don't identify it as Eren first of all. I thought that's Sasha considering the title
I'm pretty sure Aot season 3 part 2 would be rated at least 9.5 scores if Levi choose veteran commander Erwin Smith instead of 15 years old newbie soldier Armin Alert
It would make sense at least
@@nihilisticboi3520 The reason stated in the anime is that Erwin needed to rest after fighting so long for humanity, but I think it's just a cop out because the author wanted the story to go with Armin, it makes no sense
@@revvin7624 If they just let Erwin live that whole "Give up on your dreams and die" conversation would have had a lot less weight.
@@bruhfunny8123 thats right. But Isayama had to kill Erwin on the field. That choose scene was so stupid. It ruined my aot love. And last 60 chapters finally kill it.
@@печенье-д2ы bad take
I just really love the scene at 1:28, where Erwin pulled himself out of the Colossal Titan's body. He looked very handsome with his messy hair blowing in the wind. You did a great job animating everything! Just like you, I also love Erwin and believe that he should've survived. ❤️
The decision to kill Erwin is literally so Eren could do this. So the focus is on Eren cuz he's the main protagonist. Otherwise, why would anyone rely on Eren once it's Marley arc when there's still commander Erwin?
The anime doesn't make sense in the beginning either. If collosal titan could be Marleyan's impending doom why they would send amateur titan shifters to paradis island knowing the collosal might fall to the wrong hands in the first place? If they just wanted to break the wall reiner alone could do that
@@friedcalamari4929 Reiner could have destroyed the wall alone, but aren't u forgetting that their real mission was to retrieve the Founding?
The move to destroy the wall was basically to cause chaos and nothing spells chaos better than a Titan towering above the walls that are supposed to protect the people of Paradis.....
PS: Although I agree that making kids warriors, is a bit dubious. I assume that it is to ensure that they achieve the peak of their powers in their early 20s but late 20s or even early 30s seem fine imo
@@arpitanand4693 The reason is simple. When they become adults, there's a chance that they might change their views while as children you know for a fact that they'll follow your every command. Sure, there's a chance that doesnt work but that point failure is even greater in adults.
What is dumb is that they sent 4 kids alone to retrieve the Founder's power and it doesnt seem like they were taught how to enter aside from being responsible for the deaths of atleast 200000 people. Imagine you have to commit an unprecedented amount of genocide just to enter the country.
An adult supervisor might have guided them in terms of strategy. Not consulting the Tyburs about the Founder's retrieval mission is also dumb as that would have actually given them useful Intel on the founder itself. Even if you dont know about the pacifist vow, the ancestor of the Tyburs according to propaganda helped take down the Founder before this, you'd think you would consult someone who might have memories of how the King was first defeated
And why didnt they give them enough supplies? That's your goddamn warrior unit and you expect to give them such little resources that they end up in the situation which actually happened? With them losing the Jaw even before the mission started
@@arpitanand4693 Their lifespan is only 13 years bro
@@arpitanand4693 prob more for indoctrination at an early age.
What if they made an ova what if? It would be neat to see what would happen if Erwin survived
I would definitely love to see that, would be better if Wit did it to show a different style
@@revvin7624 pls dude part 2
@@revvin7624 would eren still be alive if erwin lives?
@@rupeniugavule3479 Yes. Maybe he would've gone rogue earlier if Erwin was chosen, sabotaging the scouts and moving forward all by himself, and with Mikasa probably.
"Attack on Titan's What If..."
I can’t stop laughing at Reiner’s smile 🤣😭
I love this version of the Declaration of War scene where Mr. Tybur actually witnesses the Titan appearing. Just a quick, frightening "oh crap, the enemies are RIGHT HERE" moment
Not to mention, Erwin would have kept eren correctly. He wouldn't have gone on his own. Erwin kept eren correctly so he wouldn't go off on his own, But since he passed eren went on his own. And the ending of AOT would be completely different.
Ur dumb but I’ll led it slide 😝😝
😂
I wouldn't doubt that Eren would do everything he could to go against Erwin (and Levi) every chance he got, he's very close minded, and holds grudges, he wouldn't just let Erwin keep him in check so easily if Armin died because of the choice
@@annaleeee Thats true. However lets put in consideration that Erwin also wanted to do the same thing as eren. Imagine the attack On marley but with better directive and more planning. Chances are the outcome would have been a lot better and sasha most likely wouldn't have die for many reasons mostly relating to the factor that it was planned more. Following with this if Erwin was on Eren's side he would have never became a prisoner/detained. This would mean yeagerists would never even become a thing or very rare story wise.
not really, Eren is the way he is rn cause he saw the future so nothing Erwin would've said would change him
Willy: tries to perform a speech that will likely cause everyone who agrees with the motives of the speech to die in a horrendous fashion Erwin: and I took that personally....
Watching this again why didn't Erwin regrow his arm lizard style guess he liked the look lol
Eren looking down from the blimp, "Commander doing the dirty work I would've done for the sake of Paradis, the future of our race and freedom"(one devil to another)
Eren would be proud. Floch would be cheering
Porco: what the hell.
Pieck: Oops.
Reiner: ah yes, the sweet embrace of death.
This is really beautiful. I' m not sure why, but I think this animation has a peaceful aura. I liked the face expressions so much. Especially Zeke's blank face and Eren's sadness. The music choice is great. I love this animation!
whats the song
@@mango_loco it’s in the description
That explosion on the end was incredibly well animated
0:49 Erwin: "Ive been trying to reach you regarding your cars extended warranty."
No cars in aot😂
"I've been trying to reach you regarding your odm gears extended warranty"
@@cc-yetti"I've been trying to reach you about your life's extended guarantee... It has ended now"
Would Erwin agree with the rumbling? Maybe
Would Erwin renounce Eren and fight with the alliance? Maybe
The fact is Levi decision wasn’t in the interest of humanity.
Unpopular opinion : erwin should have been saved instead of armin
I only see truths😂
@@revvin7624 me too
It's not unpopular, lmao.
yeah f- armin, garbage character got everything served on a silver plate
@@alansraj5078 glad to hear that :)
I love how you can just do an insanely well animated shitpost that also tugs at my heart strings just for long enough to forget that it's a shitpost - only to come full circle and have a colossal titan slamdunk some warships. :D
I love your work dude, never stop. You're getting better and better and it looks like you really enjoy doing it. :)
I really enjoy it because you appreciate it😘 Thanks bro!
But imagine the outcomes of erwin still being alive.
It would cost armin’s life if levi chose erwin, but if erwin was still alive, they would basically have better leadership and a this mess the scouts are in wouldn’t be a thing if erwin was also here.
Maybe choosing commander erwin was probably the better choice.
Edit: Bro there is a war in the comments
and then the rest of the world will attack paradis island while they only have 1 collosal and 1 attack titan. in the long run they will be defeated
Dude, why do people act like Armin is the only human whenever we talk about who should have lived? Erwin is human too, his death has an effect on people too, he has loved ones too (especially Levi). He is worth more than just his leadership skills. If he is the one who survives it should be for more than just his skills. This is exactly why Levi choose to let him die. Because everyone hated him and treated him as a tool for war and winning. Meanwhile Armin is the uwu softboi who has to be saved because he has fwiends. It's not really about Armin, Levi cared way more about Erwin, he barely new Armin. It's to spare Erwin from further suffering and being used as a convenient monster for the people.
i don't really like armin in this last season, i would pay 10million dollars to remake the story with erwin but i don't have 10 mil. lmao
I mean if we were there as a side characters that doesn't know who is armin are, pretty sure we would choose our commander rather than unknown soldier
@@grasu6668 with Armin they only have 1 collosal and 1 attack ya bum
Someone said, if floch had the power of the founding titan, he will make wall titan run😂
lol this part made me laugh XD 1:42
And his name is ERWIIN DANCHIOOOOOOOO
I can't get over Reiner's face 😂😂
I kept thinking when I saw scene where Levi resurrected Armin that he should split the injection in half to make Erwin feed Reiner. I always think it will be epic if Erwin became the armoured titan
I mean the armours appearance would stay almost the same lol
I don't think splitting might have worked out. Because, there wouldn't be a point of putting much more than necessary fluid to make a titan. At least I doubt that
I think there is a certain amount of serum you need to turn into titan otherwise it won't work.
@@oyebolaopeyemi8590 rod reiss just had to lick some off the floor though
@@patrickgardner321 that's a very apt and logical point or observation. Didn't think of that. Yeah, it might be true that all it requires is a lil drop or..
it might be those situations that this contradiction skipped the artist mind or...
It could be those fast forwarded situations in movies or cartoons. for example; in Ben 10 when he transforms, they show all the transformation sequence Nd at times they just skip to the end result in 1 sec. I don't know if you get what I'm saying.
But yeah, you're very right about that observation. The smallest drop might be enough to change people. But that doesn't really make sense if they had as much in the injection shot.
"We accept your declaration of war"
"And because of our respect,we decided to launch the first attack"
As always, a masterpiece
this video has classic internet vibes to it. it feels like something that would be made if this season aired in 2009
Holy shit you improved a lot!
Glad my practice is showing, Thanks😘
I love this series is a great foundation for theories and "what ifs". The fact that people theorize Erwin would do what Eren did himself is in character.
What would eren do
If armin died?
Thats the real question
Ngl Eren with Anti personnel gear looks awesome
I saw many fan arts with Eren in the new ODM gear and he looks awesome in it, thought I'd draw him in one as well XD
And I'm sure that he wouldn't cry like Armin 😃 actually, I think he would have fun XD
He would be badass
God I'd love if there was an alternate universe written by Isayama showing what would've happened if Erwin was the inheritor. I guess it wouldn't work from a "time travel" as it currently stands in the main series but man- I would love to see how Erwin would've dealt with Marley.
Same, I'm hoping he goes back and he writes the story if Levi choose to go in the other direction.
Bruh reiners face was like: YES IM GOING TO DIE
1:35
eren: “DAMN IT, he beat me to it…”
No. The whole point behind Levi choosing Armin even though he wanted to revive Erwin is due to the fact that after finally confirming his dad's theory Erwin would simply lose his motive to keep on defending humanity. Hence Levi's constant flashback to Kenny saying that we all need to be drunk on something to keep moving forward.
No, you talk like Erwin was a sort of spoiled brat, he would keep moving forward of course he will lose some motivation, but he wouldn’t let the death of his comrades be in vain just because he fulfilled his dream.
Really believe the main reason Levi chose armin is because he wanted Erwin, basically his only friend (or closest friend), rest and not have to resort to becoming more evil than evil itself just to save everyone. This video actually kind of shows exactly what Levi didn’t want Erwin to have to end up doing.
@@ezelegui7901 pretty sure he said he would
damn I had never thought of this
He let Erwin die so that he finally gets a rest from the living hell they're living. Said by Levi himself
I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS!!! XD Your style is so like the official one, but with an original spin to it! Nice touch adding humor, too!
Reiner being broken and mindf*cked was incredibly appropriate, and then there's that ending itself. Just perfect, freaking perfect.
Glad you like it and thanks for the kind words!😘
@@revvin7624 You're welcome~
Imagine if this was in the anime and Erwin come front and says to Willy tyber "ALL RIGHT THEN WE BRING THIS WAR TO YOU" and transforms
Armin was a mistake and this is absolutely KINO!
kino? doesnt that mean cinema bro
Armin is more merciful thats why hes needed for season 4
go back to reddit
@@anhminhpham1746 Armin is naive and a simp.
@Arthur the plot is garbage.
Galliard: "I don't remember that soldier"
Pieck: "Yeah, strange..."
Reiner:
*fuc*
Honestly, Erwin would probably be the best choice. He has more control over Levi than Hanji as in the position of Commander and could control and outsmart Eren in a battle. Not only that but he would be able to convince most of the yeagerists to stay loyal to the military government.
And he has more experience and his achievements is what brought humanity so far, Choosing Erwin would have been a no brainer
@@revvin7624 true.. Thinking of saving Armin I mean they lost tons of people already.. To make a difference was the only sane choice left
@@revvin7624 exactly, I have always believed this, it is so frustrating to see ARMIN chosen to live over the literal commander. I suppose it would alter a good bit of the rest of the plot if Armin did die but realistically it made no sense
@@revvin7624 Armin's achievements > Erwin's achievements
@@JR-Weh Which achievements exactly?
it is stated that armoured titan can withstand the colossal titan transformation (even if it is nuke transformation), but it depends on the willpower.
Knowing reiner he won't miss the chance to die