You have pointed out the precise nature of the problem. Judges make lofty statements but these issues remain as orphans and quite a few individuals find themselves in a Catch22 situation. The vast majority of citizens carry on with their daily life, undisturbed and unaware of these issues. I hope this article will be a gentle reminder to the sacred institution called the judiciary, to rise and perform it's primary role of upholding our constitution and citizens' rights to life and liberty.
The Supreme Court of India totally failed its people by its indifference in most of the important cases i.e., ED cases, CBI cases, IT cases, PMLA, Hindenburg case, Rafael case, Sanjiv Bhat cases. It follows BJP/RSS dictates.
Thanks to the "Wire" for this video. It looks like some Judges have very conscious effect of political repurcissions, on many judgements, which may look coloured due to certain circumstances. When circumstances change, they conveniently change their stance. Thus causing confusion in the minds of many advocates, or rather, making room for different interepretations. Jai Hind ! .
Judges seem to be fuelled by this innate desire to provide this sort of vigilante-esque justice, without nipping the problem at an institutional level, something which an institution of SC’s standing demands. They want to be batman, but don’t want to fight the joker.
Excellent comments on ED the ED and CBI are made by the rulers who were thinking themselfs that they are eternal in this world alone no one touch them if ED and CBI dare enough to touch the ruling party almost 90% are thrown in the Jails why the SC doesn't interfered what about Electoral Bond issue is it vanished please there are many issues to be discussed. Your speech is marvelous and topics which has raised excellent. I appreciate your humble approach.
At least Gogoi and Lalit were not pretentious. This CJI talks big, appears to be righteous but his actions, very often, lack that righteousness and courage.
Excellent, informative video!! It is historical fact that authoritarians have always gained (& retained) power through the use/abuse of the judiciary; by controlling the courts...be it in fascist Italy, Nazi Germany, or modern day Trump's/MAGA's USA... Just like in the Emergency of the 1970s, the judiciary was not just a mute spectator but an active participant, today too, the judiciary is not just an innocent by-stander, but an active participant in the backsliding of democracy... The judges' words vs actions have huge, glaring discrepancies, and the hypocrisy is plain to be seen by one & all... And just as history has condemned the pusillanimity of the Judiciary in that era's Emergency, I am sure history shall equally harshly judge the craven timorousness of today's Judiciary in this modern day 'Emergency-lite'...perhaps even more so, cuz we had the lessons from the first one, and apparently followed Georg Hegel's maxim: "The only thing we learn from history is that we learn nothing from history."
What you narrating is absolutely right and every conscious citizen can sense it abundantly. Not only in this CJI's time but for quite some time we are noticing the massive deterioration in the standard of the judiciary , servility to to rapacious executive being it's most abominable feature. It is time not only to narrate facts of brazenness and indifference bordering on putting the constitution to a joke, but time has come to seriously think about the remedy for this dysfunctional justice system that is going downhill with passing time.
I am a lay person and not a lawyer.I can't understand how any court of Law could endorse PMLA.How can judges stand by while modi and his ED, CBI make a mockery of the law. PMLA is no law to deliver Justice but a legalized way of Delivering injustice to people who dissen😢.. Shame on the protectors of the law for their cowardice and their indifferenc😢
What is actually the use of SC or the lower courts if it cannot protect its innocent citizens and ensures justice as per guaranteed by the Constitution. People have completely lost faith in the judiciary. What is preventing the SC in reigning up the ED, CBI and IT. Who has became a rogue and not a mandated law agencies. If the SC cannot do that it doesn't have any moral right to hold offices.
CJI isn't very different from Modi or BJP, Hindutva allies, speaking too much here and there but doing what and how he likes, probably fearing the consequences, of course either doesn't feel the pain or didn't have courage, I don't sense this CJI or previous CJIs who transferred the case to coming judges, it seems everyone is passing the bucks to others or being silence is best practice. We are living in drama and jumla era, where Modi or Bhagwat is supreme, even if they are dumb but who cares, when judiciary is failing and falling apart.
It takes 6 months to 4 years for ED and CBI to give bail to innocent incarcerated opposition members. But to bulldoze a house ,24 hours. How do they find out the guilt for bulldozing immediately. Why can’t the same process be used for humans???
It proves that no man is fit enough to dispense Justice. There might be some judges who are known for honesty and integrity but justice doesn’t end there. Anyone who is entrusted with power and duties and responsibilities of upholding justice have to act even when they see injustice done to someone. All judges I would request to study the justice system in Islam, if he or she is really committed to justice, before occupying the position of judges in the Courts.
The system of government should change from parliamentary democracy to presidential democracy. So the PRs can not involve in scams for money or other activities.
What is actually the use of SC or the lower courts if it cannot protect its innocent citizens and ensures justice as per guaranteed by the Constitution. People have completely lost faith in the judiciary. What is preventing the SC in reigning up the ED, CBI and IT. Who has became a rogue and not a mandated law agencies. If the SC cannot do that it doesn't have any moral right to hold offices.
CJI also give Lecture in line with Politicians like Mr. Modi Ji and his Team. We see great Difference in Speech & Work Done
You have pointed out the precise nature of the problem. Judges make lofty statements but these issues remain as orphans and quite a few individuals find themselves in a Catch22 situation. The vast majority of citizens carry on with their daily life, undisturbed and unaware of these issues. I hope this article will be a gentle reminder to the sacred institution called the judiciary, to rise and perform it's primary role of upholding our constitution and citizens' rights to life and liberty.
Excellent work by wire 🎉
Good Job Journalist.. this was a very well done video. I was stuck watching it and listening to you till the end.
Wow…big big fan of these courageous young reporter.
Thank you Dear for making the legal issues to be clearly understood even by a Common Man.
Excellent analysis...
Well said. Thanks.
Thank you for making this series. please continue making these kind of series.
Super series
It's disappointing to see the helplessness of the SC. All bark and no bite
Very true….each looking for their own after-retirement benefits perhaps? They have failed Citizens totally…a Sham!
Excellent coverage
The Supreme Court of India totally failed its people by its indifference in most of the important cases i.e., ED cases, CBI cases, IT cases, PMLA, Hindenburg case, Rafael case, Sanjiv Bhat cases. It follows BJP/RSS dictates.
All talk no action is a very good summary of him.
saurav das
good job... keep it up man, looking forward more of such content from you and the team working with you
Thanks
Excellent description and clear explanation from this knowledgeable person.
Very well anlysed
Shame on the Supreme Court
Wow I’m happy to see Saurav reporting this … I’m glad that he has grown to great heights … proud of you bro
If judges are feared to pass judgment they should resign
Thanks to the "Wire" for this video. It looks like some Judges have very conscious effect of political repurcissions, on many judgements, which may look coloured due to certain circumstances. When circumstances change, they conveniently change their stance. Thus causing confusion in the minds of many advocates, or rather, making room for different interepretations. Jai Hind !
.
Good piece
Nice and really informative episode. Please continue this serious and bring the episodes on a regular basis.
Judges seem to be fuelled by this innate desire to provide this sort of vigilante-esque justice, without nipping the problem at an institutional level, something which an institution of SC’s standing demands. They want to be batman, but don’t want to fight the joker.
So informative..thank you for this.we commoners don't really get all these informations by media otherwise
We should remember Judges have families and they remember Judge Loya
ha tension nat bhot jaldi sarkar giregi aur amit shah ke lag jaayenge.😇
Good analysis
👌✌✊
Excellent comments on ED the ED and CBI are made by the rulers who were thinking themselfs that they are eternal in this world alone no one touch them if ED and CBI dare enough to touch the ruling party almost 90% are thrown in the Jails why the SC doesn't interfered what about Electoral Bond issue is it vanished please there are many issues to be discussed. Your speech is marvelous and topics which has raised excellent. I appreciate your humble approach.
👌 video
No one is above suspicion in our Country….
Its very sad to see the sorry state of affairs in the judiciary in last so many years now.
Great
काले कानूनों पर निरंतर श्रंखला बनाइए जो आम लोग समझ सकें कि कहां ह्रास-हनन हो रहा है मानव-नागरिक मूल अधिकारों का
Thanks
Majority of Citizens EXPECTED lot of Fair and Free decisions from HONOURABLE C J I
At least Gogoi and Lalit were not pretentious.
This CJI talks big, appears to be righteous but his actions, very often, lack that righteousness and courage.
CJI shd be strong enough to fight the BJP bullies
Supreme court should asked Ed and CBI that why only cases on Opposition?? Is't coincidence or wel plan actions
Not "finish" off bur "clear blackmail" whike the judiciary looks helpless and people know how vulnerable the lower courts are!
Excellent, informative video!!
It is historical fact that authoritarians have always gained (& retained) power through the use/abuse of the judiciary; by controlling the courts...be it in fascist Italy, Nazi Germany, or modern day Trump's/MAGA's USA...
Just like in the Emergency of the 1970s, the judiciary was not just a mute spectator but an active participant, today too, the judiciary is not just an innocent by-stander, but an active participant in the backsliding of democracy...
The judges' words vs actions have huge, glaring discrepancies, and the hypocrisy is plain to be seen by one & all...
And just as history has condemned the pusillanimity of the Judiciary in that era's Emergency, I am sure history shall equally harshly judge the craven timorousness of today's Judiciary in this modern day 'Emergency-lite'...perhaps even more so, cuz we had the lessons from the first one, and apparently followed Georg Hegel's maxim: "The only thing we learn from history is that we learn nothing from history."
👏💯👏👏💯👏
Supreme court is supreme disappointment. Chandrachud talks loftily and does the opposite exactly like Modi govt.
What you narrating is absolutely right and every conscious citizen can sense it abundantly. Not only in this CJI's time but for quite some time we are noticing the massive deterioration in the standard of the judiciary , servility to to rapacious executive being it's most abominable feature. It is time not only to narrate facts of brazenness and indifference bordering on putting the constitution to a joke, but time has come to seriously think about the remedy for this dysfunctional justice system that is going downhill with passing time.
I am really surprised why ed doesn't knock ruling party members
Democracies means money ,business etc???? Is it good for the poor, honest, skilled,people?????
CJI should stop preaching and start doing some real work.
I am a lay person and not a lawyer.I can't understand how any court of Law could endorse PMLA.How can judges stand by while modi and his ED, CBI make a mockery of the law. PMLA is no law to deliver Justice but a legalized way of Delivering injustice to people who dissen😢.. Shame on the protectors of the law for their cowardice and their indifferenc😢
👍👍👍
our courts turning extra extreme right while our people queuing for subsidy dole & mnrg 😢
Shame !
Hi Saurav,
I'm not finding previous 2 episodes, please add link in the same video when you refer.
Thank you
It's on the channel's playlist.
It’s more concerning that the leader of opposition didn’t raise this issue in his first speech as LoP
What is actually the use of SC or the lower courts if it cannot protect its innocent citizens and ensures justice as per guaranteed by the Constitution. People have completely lost faith in the judiciary. What is preventing the SC in reigning up the ED, CBI and IT. Who has became a rogue and not a mandated law agencies. If the SC cannot do that it doesn't have any moral right to hold offices.
It's travesty of justice
Omg the anchor is so cute handsome ❤❤
Free Umar Khalid and all political prisoners.
Modis power will vanish but people's power will prevail
Very disappointed and disillusioned by the SC our only hope against despotism.
# Just Ice @ frozen shoulder ⛄️⚖️⛄️
The Saurav das❤❤❤❤❤
Really, unbelievable until pointed out 🤔🤭
CJI isn't very different from Modi or BJP, Hindutva allies, speaking too much here and there but doing what and how he likes, probably fearing the consequences, of course either doesn't feel the pain or didn't have courage, I don't sense this CJI or previous CJIs who transferred the case to coming judges, it seems everyone is passing the bucks to others or being silence is best practice.
We are living in drama and jumla era, where Modi or Bhagwat is supreme, even if they are dumb but who cares, when judiciary is failing and falling apart.
❤❤🎉🎉
Judges become unconstitutional. 😂
Koi baat nhi lekin nyay hona chihiye
Ed, CBI was bais towards opposition leader encourage by judiciary, judiciary was in greed of chair after retirement,
Its NDA 3.0 under PM Modi.
Freedom is scary deal with it.
It takes 6 months to 4 years for ED and CBI to give bail to innocent incarcerated opposition members.
But to bulldoze a house ,24 hours.
How do they find out the guilt for bulldozing immediately.
Why can’t the same process be used for humans???
This guy is darn cute❤
#PMLA Down Down 👇👇
#UAPA down down 👎👎
It proves that no man is fit enough to dispense Justice. There might be some judges who are known for honesty and integrity but justice doesn’t end there. Anyone who is entrusted with power and duties and responsibilities of upholding justice have to act even when they see injustice done to someone. All judges I would request to study the justice system in Islam, if he or she is really committed to justice, before occupying the position of judges in the Courts.
You should present this in hindi so that reach is higher
Next episode of justice brief???
Supreme court is is. Under modi😂😢😮
भाई यहा कुछ नही हो सकता, सत्संग में 120 लोग मर गए। यूरोप में इसे Bomb Blast माना जाता। आपकी बात अच्छी है but जनता अभी बच्ची है।😊
Kahne ko bahot kuchh hai, lekin,
Kuchh kahte hooe jee darta hai,
KaheeN PMLA mujh ko bhee ...........
Yes narrative is Narendra modi 😁😃😀
Hái frindes justices my following sensitivity like Balaji raju
The system of government should change from parliamentary democracy
to presidential democracy.
So the PRs can not involve
in scams for money or other activities.
It is difficult to understand Wire is more funny or Indian Express. Both are competing in anti Modi episodes.😮
This guy was on Grindr: Gay dating app😂
Who told you this?
What is actually the use of SC or the lower courts if it cannot protect its innocent citizens and ensures justice as per guaranteed by the Constitution. People have completely lost faith in the judiciary. What is preventing the SC in reigning up the ED, CBI and IT. Who has became a rogue and not a mandated law agencies. If the SC cannot do that it doesn't have any moral right to hold offices.
I am really surprised why ed doesn't knock ruling party members