Let's not forget, there was no "screen used" helmets for the phase 2 until OWK. So what MR had, were simply computer generated schematics, which if actually used for actors, wouldn't have worked real well. There now are screen used full suits so I would be interested to see how the black series compares to that. The one thing that really throws me off on the accuracy of the BS is that visor. It's the wrong shape, and it also does not have the detailing found around the "eyes."
I've got a Black Series phase II helmet and prototype Mandalorian helmet, I had to take the harness out of both to make them fit, but I could see a more average sized head fitting in the phase 2 with the tighter skullcap and deeper cheek wells just fine. The Mandalorian helmet brushes against my eyebrows when I put it on, but the BS phase ii helmet slips right on and is actually a little too loose for me. The MR sort of version would probably sit better with those changes.
Black series ALL DAY LONG!. Forget about those digital files. Hasbro is knocking those things out of the park. It’s not a case of well for the money, they look amazing regardless of the price. Great comparison man. Your room looks amazing as always
Great Video as always Gabe! Thank you for your comparison. It’s really nice that your collection allows you to make these videos for us. I’m not super familiar, as I’m more of an OT fan, but I wonder how the black series differs from the first live action clone troopers in the OBK series and The Mandalorian? Overall, I do agree that the Black Series are just getting better and better for their price. Looking forward to your Black Series Scout Trooper comparison!
So awesome! Congrats on getting the last one. Hasbro erratic shipping of these helmets is frustrating. You never know where they are going to show up first. For the money and look, I love it
Informative video comparing the old master replicas clone trooper helmet and the new Hasbro helmet. I can't remember what year these came out but it was definitely over a decade and a half ago.
Kinda like the Hasbro better, my opinion, everyone has one. The groves side slots vs painted did it for me and my tv they are definitely bright white. But both great
I have the Denuo Novo version of the Phase 2, which looks closer to the MR version. I am excited about Hasbro doing the Ahsoka version of the Phase 2, which I will definitely pick up!
@@riley8099 During the Hasbro Pulse Star Wars Fanstream that was 1-2 months ago, at the very end of the video, when they were talking pipeline, they mentioned it. It may have been the very last thing they talked about in the video so you can FF to the end to hear it.
I bought one at my local mall. The store is called (The Star Wars Store). They have all new and old collectible stuff. When I’m in the store, I’m in heaven lol. I’m glad Hasbro did these Clone Trooper helmets. They should had done these when Revenge Of The Sith was released. Nobody was making them at the time. Not even cheap costume company’s like Rubies. There were replica company’s a year later but were very expensive.
The Black Series helmet looks kind of like a prototype Stormtrooper helmet because of the bright white colour, it makes sense for it to look like that while its being transformed into the Stormtrooper helmet. The Master Replicas helmet is definitely the accurate helmet though, but both of them look nice!
Great review! I have a couple of black series helmets myself and, for the price, I think they’re great. I’m hoping that Hasbro makes a Captain Rex replica at some point.
@@Robeygames likewise. I’m actually pretty excited that hasbro is coming out with a Rogue One Storm Trooper helmet. I’ve always loved the storm trooper helmets from the original trilogy, this is the closest thing I can get lol
in my memory the helmets have always been whiter. but looking back i can see the cream color. still i like the hard white feels like its fresh off the factory on kamino
Not to mention it’s great for cosplay. And it’s pretty easy to customize it for any legion you want. Although I do hope we get an official 501st Legion helmet in the future.
'Accurate' is a very loose word. No helmet was made for the prequels. Yes, the digital files are a great thing but as we saw with Rogue One, Andor or The Mando, the designs can be tweaked from movie to movie. Maybe the Hasbro one is accurate to some specific production or was adapted for comfort and packaging.
I meant accurate to the original 3D files from ROTS. The Hasbro is a kid’s toy, a very well made kid’s toy. The Master Replicas is a limited edition collectors item that was made around the time of ROTS.
Thanks for a fascinating and informative video. One thing you didn't mention (I think) was how they fit if you put them on. Another review video I saw mentioned that if you put the Hasbro one on, it is clearly too big, out of proportion for body size, even for a six foot tall, fairly well-built guy. Now I know many (perhaps most) would only be displaying it, not cosplay (as would I), and it clearly looks great for that. But it would just irk me I think to know it was over-sized just to fit in a silly voice changer, amazing as it looks. I think the color would irk me too. What say you?
That’s a great point. I don’t think it’s oversized in relation to the rest of the armor but you definitely want to add some padding in there to make it more snug on your head. Especially to be able to see out of it properly. But I don’t believe it’s that much oversized compared to the screen accurate ones.
Well no helmet, armor or droid that was painted white in the movies was ever just true white. But also you might have to adjust your computer screen if you’re seeing a dirty yellow color, because all of them are off white.
Excited to add a clone helmet next to my boba fett, bo Katan, and mando helmets 😁😁 would love to eventually add a stormtrooper and Luke’s helmet as well
Hasbro’s visor is completely off. Too squinted and not rounded enough. The mouth is also higher up on its face on the Hasbro one making the chin bigger and nose shorter.
@@gabesstarwarscollectionthe expensive one is more accurate to the movies, and the black series is a mix of clone wars and live action. So your really comparing it to apples and oranges
Looks great! Thanks for the review. I just won this helmet from maxon zbrush May the 4th stream giveaway with Hasbro. Im afraid to open it. I might have to buy another one so I have one new one and one my kids can play with.... and then start collecting the whole series. Lol.
The side profile at 7:18 says it all. Really wanted to love the hasbro helmet but it’s just too big - it’s almost silly to wear. Lots of other great replicas out there in the same price range.
I bought a cheap one off of Amazon that looks more like the accurate one in shape and colour than the hasbro one. I like the hasbro one but I don't love it. It's rather space balls in scale as well. Quite comical really. I bought it to learn from it but I won't be keeping it. I don't think hasbro tries to get things right so they can do slightly better each time. It's the toy version of planned obsolescence. Instead of getting it right the first time and selling the same artwork for 250 years they'd rather play that game instead.
Hopefully you didn't pay 1000 for that phase 2 helmet,that paint is poorly done and for that price the inside should be decked out with internal pieces, not just padded especially that sloppy of a job if it was a grand...not trying to be a hater or dick but it is one of several ive seen you show that were spendy and have had the same flaws and quality issues..I am also curious as to where if they got the specs from a game or online or from Lucas film because there was never a made helmet as they were all cg and being how temura has a big ass head I don't see that "master replica" fitting his head..idk maybe it's just me but that black series is better than the other one,even with the goofy over sized part on the back that has the speaker
yeah those small differences don't make it worth 10x the price. Hasbro actually did really well here.
Very close, definitely going for the black series
It’s definitely good enough as a toy but I just can’t get over that ugly visor shape
Let's not forget, there was no "screen used" helmets for the phase 2 until OWK. So what MR had, were simply computer generated schematics, which if actually used for actors, wouldn't have worked real well. There now are screen used full suits so I would be interested to see how the black series compares to that. The one thing that really throws me off on the accuracy of the BS is that visor. It's the wrong shape, and it also does not have the detailing found around the "eyes."
I've got a Black Series phase II helmet and prototype Mandalorian helmet, I had to take the harness out of both to make them fit, but I could see a more average sized head fitting in the phase 2 with the tighter skullcap and deeper cheek wells just fine. The Mandalorian helmet brushes against my eyebrows when I put it on, but the BS phase ii helmet slips right on and is actually a little too loose for me. The MR sort of version would probably sit better with those changes.
Black series ALL DAY LONG!. Forget about those digital files. Hasbro is knocking those things out of the park. It’s not a case of well for the money, they look amazing regardless of the price. Great comparison man. Your room looks amazing as always
You go ahead and tell yourself that. It’s OK that you think the BS looks just as good. Still, some of us are a little more fussy.
@@iamanisland I sure will! ALL DAY LONG
The visor part looks more like the clone wars version so in my opinion it is accurate not to the movies but the clone wars
Great Video as always Gabe! Thank you for your comparison. It’s really nice that your collection allows you to make these videos for us. I’m not super familiar, as I’m more of an OT fan, but I wonder how the black series differs from the first live action clone troopers in the OBK series and The Mandalorian? Overall, I do agree that the Black Series are just getting better and better for their price. Looking forward to your Black Series Scout Trooper comparison!
The Hasbro may be based on the live action version of the helmet instead of the cgi helmet the Master Replicas was based on.
True
So awesome! Congrats on getting the last one. Hasbro erratic shipping of these helmets is frustrating. You never know where they are going to show up first. For the money and look, I love it
Thanks bro. Yeah it’s always hit or miss with Hasbro. It’s like the Lola animatronic and how Amazon got it first
Great review and comparison Gabe! For the money, those black series helmets are awesome!
Informative video comparing the old master replicas clone trooper helmet and the new Hasbro helmet. I can't remember what year these came out but it was definitely over a decade and a half ago.
Kinda like the Hasbro better, my opinion, everyone has one. The groves side slots vs painted did it for me and my tv they are definitely bright white. But both great
It’s a good looking helmet!
Master replica helmets should be battle ready for their prices!
Lol
They are much more durable. You can sit on these fiberglass helmets.
I have the Denuo Novo version of the Phase 2, which looks closer to the MR version. I am excited about Hasbro doing the Ahsoka version of the Phase 2, which I will definitely pick up!
Where did you hear they’re doing the 332nd?
@@riley8099 During the Hasbro Pulse Star Wars Fanstream that was 1-2 months ago, at the very end of the video, when they were talking pipeline, they mentioned it. It may have been the very last thing they talked about in the video so you can FF to the end to hear it.
@@ransolmcasterfo8864 that is so awesome - I was thinking of picking up the plain one but the 332nd will definitely be my first helmet now!
No you won’t
I want to see what the deal is with the new stormtrooper helmet from denonov
Master Replicas or nothing! 🥳
Another awesome fantastic clone trooper helmet looks excellent has always keep collecting your helmets 🇬🇧🇬🇧👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
I bought one at my local mall. The store is called (The Star Wars Store). They have all new and old collectible stuff. When I’m in the store, I’m in heaven lol. I’m glad Hasbro did these Clone Trooper helmets. They should had done these when Revenge Of The Sith was released. Nobody was making them at the time. Not even cheap costume company’s like Rubies. There were replica company’s a year later but were very expensive.
The Black Series helmet looks kind of like a prototype Stormtrooper helmet because of the bright white colour, it makes sense for it to look like that while its being transformed into the Stormtrooper helmet. The Master Replicas helmet is definitely the accurate helmet though, but both of them look nice!
Great review! I have a couple of black series helmets myself and, for the price, I think they’re great.
I’m hoping that Hasbro makes a Captain Rex replica at some point.
A Rex would be awesome!
a rex helmet would be awesome
We need Rex , I’m telling you of it’s ever gonna be released I’m going to be the first one to buy it
@@Robeygames likewise. I’m actually pretty excited that hasbro is coming out with a Rogue One Storm Trooper helmet. I’ve always loved the storm trooper helmets from the original trilogy, this is the closest thing I can get lol
@@kuya_timmy is there a difference too a normal storm trooper (sorry I haven’t watched all of route one yet! 😂
Thanks for this excellent comparison.
The visor definatley looks closer to the animated version
in my memory the helmets have always been whiter. but looking back i can see the cream color. still i like the hard white feels like its fresh off the factory on kamino
Can you get phase one clone trooper helmets? I haven’t seen one before
I was going to skip this one, thought the scaling was all wrong, but this has changed my mind!
It’s a great helmet for the price!
Honestly I do like the side profile of the Hasbro version a ton more. Really happy I got the 332nd Ahsoka variant for just 139 bucks.
Have you done a comparison of the Denuo Novo to the Master Replicas?
I got this yesterday for £47 ($57)! An absolute steal
We need a black series phase 1 helmet!!
Not to mention it’s great for cosplay. And it’s pretty easy to customize it for any legion you want. Although I do hope we get an official 501st Legion helmet in the future.
Great vid mate. Yeah it's very good for the price I've preordered one but gutted I've got to wait till may
Thank you for the comparison. I think the black series is an amazing product for its price.
The white color is not a mistake. IRL helmets are as white as the Dark Series is but once filmed, on screen they looks more yellowish.
'Accurate' is a very loose word. No helmet was made for the prequels. Yes, the digital files are a great thing but as we saw with Rogue One, Andor or The Mando, the designs can be tweaked from movie to movie. Maybe the Hasbro one is accurate to some specific production or was adapted for comfort and packaging.
I meant accurate to the original 3D files from ROTS. The Hasbro is a kid’s toy, a very well made kid’s toy. The Master Replicas is a limited edition collectors item that was made around the time of ROTS.
Can you drop the link to the stands? Thanks keep up the good work 👍👍
Thanks for this great review!
Glad it was helpful!
Overall the helmet looks amazing and the quality is top notch.
However the voice changing does little to no effect like it advertised.
What brand is the Boba jetpack?
I just start to watch the Star Wars series and it’s INSANE i really like it and now I’m looking for stuff to collect and I really like the helmet
I cannot wait to compare it to my MR. How does it compare to the Denuo Novo phase 2?
That’s a good question! I’ll have to do that comparison some time!
Thanks for a fascinating and informative video. One thing you didn't mention (I think) was how they fit if you put them on. Another review video I saw mentioned that if you put the Hasbro one on, it is clearly too big, out of proportion for body size, even for a six foot tall, fairly well-built guy. Now I know many (perhaps most) would only be displaying it, not cosplay (as would I), and it clearly looks great for that. But it would just irk me I think to know it was over-sized just to fit in a silly voice changer, amazing as it looks. I think the color would irk me too. What say you?
That’s a great point. I don’t think it’s oversized in relation to the rest of the armor but you definitely want to add some padding in there to make it more snug on your head. Especially to be able to see out of it properly. But I don’t believe it’s that much oversized compared to the screen accurate ones.
Why do all the fiberglass helmets you have turn out to be a dirty yellow color?
Well no helmet, armor or droid that was painted white in the movies was ever just true white. But also you might have to adjust your computer screen if you’re seeing a dirty yellow color, because all of them are off white.
Very helpful, thank you.
Ordering my black series now
It’s a beauty!
Nice
Excited to add a clone helmet next to my boba fett, bo Katan, and mando helmets 😁😁 would love to eventually add a stormtrooper and Luke’s helmet as well
Везет вам
@@EsiMax_YT work hard enough and you can have a nice little collection like myself
У Нас в России не продается , поэтому будет в два раза дороже
@@EsiMax_YT I guess you better start making plans to move out of Russia
Found mine at GameStop yesterday
Hasbro’s visor is completely off. Too squinted and not rounded enough. The mouth is also higher up on its face on the Hasbro one making the chin bigger and nose shorter.
it’s accurate
@@Ghost-rx4yt the expensive one is accurate
@@gabesstarwarscollection they both are
@@gabesstarwarscollection just because one is a little less accurate doesn’t mean it isn’t accurate at all
@@gabesstarwarscollectionthe expensive one is more accurate to the movies, and the black series is a mix of clone wars and live action.
So your really comparing it to apples and oranges
i need this in my life
Ngl, I like the pure white than the cream white one.
Thanks as always for the great share and compare! MTFBWY
The circle on the back of the helmet- the Reese's cup- is actually correct on the Hasbro helmet. The smooth Master Replicas is not accurate.
Looks great! Thanks for the review. I just won this helmet from maxon zbrush May the 4th stream giveaway with Hasbro. Im afraid to open it. I might have to buy another one so I have one new one and one my kids can play with.... and then start collecting the whole series. Lol.
Congratulations! It’s a very cool helmet! I’ll be doing a paint up tutorial soon!
@@StarWarsReplicas Thanks! Cool! Paintover would be awesome!
The side profile at 7:18 says it all. Really wanted to love the hasbro helmet but it’s just too big - it’s almost silly to wear. Lots of other great replicas out there in the same price range.
Missed oppertunity there is no review out on youtube with the voice changer
Animated visor is the biggest issue. IMO.
Me, a Fender Strat player:
*Hasbro: Artic white
*Master replica: Olympic white 🤭🤭🤭🤭
Love that reference!
I'll stick with my SamoilovArt helmets.
The 1k helm looks like the 187th helm lol
Not excited about that specific phase 2 helmet 😕
Master replicas is old and it has yellowed from age.
I bought a cheap one off of Amazon that looks more like the accurate one in shape and colour than the hasbro one. I like the hasbro one but I don't love it. It's rather space balls in scale as well. Quite comical really. I bought it to learn from it but I won't be keeping it. I don't think hasbro tries to get things right so they can do slightly better each time. It's the toy version of planned obsolescence. Instead of getting it right the first time and selling the same artwork for 250 years they'd rather play that game instead.
Could you send me the link to that helmet you got?
The one thing that turns me off is the fact that the cheeks are to shallow. It just throws me off.
I think the BS is better..
hi
Hopefully you didn't pay 1000 for that phase 2 helmet,that paint is poorly done and for that price the inside should be decked out with internal pieces, not just padded especially that sloppy of a job if it was a grand...not trying to be a hater or dick but it is one of several ive seen you show that were spendy and have had the same flaws and quality issues..I am also curious as to where if they got the specs from a game or online or from Lucas film because there was never a made helmet as they were all cg and being how temura has a big ass head I don't see that "master replica" fitting his head..idk maybe it's just me but that black series is better than the other one,even with the goofy over sized part on the back that has the speaker
Lol na if you don’t know about Master Replicas and what they did back in the day you wouldn’t understand. Hasbro one is all you!
The master replica one looks goofy af not even gonna lie. Looks like whoever wears it has a head the shape of a french fry. Tall and squished 💀
😂 The Master replicas is the French fry and the Hasbro is the wide hamburger
@@StarWarsReplicas exactly 😂