Have both and have used both in LE for over 30 years. You can't go wrong with either. With either, you are well armed. With that said, I have switched from the 870 and now prefer the 590a1. Excellent comparison!
We share the exact same opinion. I'm a Mossberg guy and still feel very comfortable with running a 500/590. Heck I've owned Maverick 88s I'd say are on par and preferable for the absolute steal they are sold for. But SOMETHING about that 870 man. I had an Express tactical 18 inch years ago and was expecting to favor the Mossberg, but when I got some range time with it I fell in love too. They just FEEL that extra bit better. Like 10% better than the Mossberg 500. You can't really exolain why. Personally I think the reciever being steel helps weight balance and shootability when every Mossberg I've owned is front heavy especially with heat shields and heavy walled barrels. That and the action is just butter smooth. It just pointed and shot better basically. I just found the 870 to be a smoother operating shotgun in terms of actually using it. That's not to say the 500/590 isn't smooth, because they are very smooth especially when compared to that crap coming from Turkey, but I just felt the 870 was 10% better. Lol That was the only way to describe it. Now it seems the 870 barely has any more fans since the Freedom Group troubles. If Remington could get their QC in line with Mossbergs, I do believe some Mossberg fans would flock to 870s. They are just amazing shotguns in design. Time will tell if they can be that good in quality again though.
I am excited to have Remington back! My dad raised me on his 870 Express Magnum made in 2001. It looks just like your 870 here, but it has a synthetic stock. We still have it today. I have a 500 and an 88, but I went ahead and got this same gun with the 4 round tube. It feels good to be able to buy an affordable pump gun that employs American workers and supports the American economy. I'll report my findings on my channel when I get some rounds thru it.
I own and love both Remingtons and Mossbergs. I like the 870 better personally but I like the 590 almost just as much. You really can’t go wrong with either gun. Get one of each so you have something to hand to a buddy when they forgot their gun. If you have both, you truly have the better one.
I feel the same way. I bought my Mossberg to be my go too shotgun and a Remington as a beater. But I ended up loving the look, and feel of the Remington much more.
Thanks for a great video ! The more skilled you are the more appealing the Remington 870 becomes. The 870 runs smoother and the select slug technique, with a fully loaded magazine, is more efficient. For a solid fighting shotgun, the M590 A1 with the 18.5 inch barrel and the Van Comp modifications is my choice.
The new Remington HD 870 is not the same as previous Express 870... It's FAR better! Broke one in recently shooting clays and I'm seriously impressed. Perfect function and beautiful to boot! Looks like the old school Big Green quality is back!
👍 Good comparison of two excellent shotguns. A couple of years ago I looked at both and went with the 590 retrograde because I liked the location of the controls better and thought the fit and finish was better.
Just purchased the 870 [R81197] a few hours ago, it was $670 CAD. The 590A1 retrograde was double the price from this supplier, after being marked down $100. Going to pick it up tomorrow, feeling very excited, it's my first firearm.
Now i started with a Winchester 1897 12 GA i like the Mossberg pump handed,s i have thrre Mossbergs now 1 500 12GA 18.5 inch barre 6 shoot 1 590 20 GA18,5 inch 7 shoot for the girls.& 1 590 12 GA 7 shoot 18'5 inch barre .being a left hand shooter i really like the safet on the Mossbergs , now i had a Mossberg 500 20 GA but when one of my girls move out & she got it ,
Ive seen the 590 going around 500 to 600. If you dont mind plastic you can get a 590 for around 450. 700 is way to much. This is how i see the 2. 590 for self defence 870 for hunting. I think the 870 design just makes for a better hunting gun. Fits/feels better in the hand, smoother action and swings better. The 590 like the 500 just feel beefier more solid in the hand. Thing i dont care for in the Mossberg is how dam thick the stock is where you grip it. It feels like your holding a 2x4 and the action is stiff compared to alot of other pump guns. Both guns will work in both rolls but i think because the way they were designed that the mossberg is better as a defence gun and Rem is better for a hunting gun. I have both guns so this is just my 2 cents.
I'd take rem870. Steel reciever - lasts +500.000 shots. Bought in '60 for 100$ ~900$ now, Get a slightly used, or a new on (police mag/wingmaster). Change springs, extractor to a Non-MIM, maybe ejector to a Non-MIM. Better coating and use the xtra $ for training.
Ran my 870 in a shotgun class had a few double feeds where I think I may have short stroked it. Empty shell behind one in chamber or something stuck on the loading ramp. I had to fish it out or maybe it was the challenger 7.5 handicap shotshells
Having used neither, I like the Mossberg more. I think it looks better and on paper, has better features. But once you get them in hand and put rounds through them, opinions tend to change, I'm sure.
It's funny. I actually just sold my 870 not too long ago and picked up a 590 retrograde. While I think the overall quality of the 590 is better, I do miss just how smooth the action of the 870 was right out of the box. That being said, I don't think you'd go wrong buying either gun
I don’t own either shotgun but I have experience with both of them. The Mossberg had extremely stiff action right out of the box that was a major deterrent immediately. The idea that you have to shoot a couple hundred rounds to loosen the action is absurd. This was never the case with Remington Or the great American made Winchester model 1300 which is extremely smooth. I’m really surprised Mossberg never resolved this problem in their manufacturing process.
The more neutral color of the wood version may make it more suitable for hunting. One thing I can tell you for certain is the short 4 round tube version makes the gun a delight to point and handle. Without that extended tube weighing the muzzle down, the gun is way easier for me to snap on target and swing between targets or after a moving game animal. If you can get by with 5 rounds, you gotta at least feel one of the 4+1 versions and see what you think.
WIth the right spring and follwer you can also get 7 into the 18 inch version. And theoretical with a 21 barrel und flush tube it should be able to hold 8 like the Mossberg 590.
I OWN REMINGTONS (870 EXRESS & WINGMASTER ) WINCHESTERS (M12 M1897) AND A MOSSBERG 500 .... THE 500 IS COLLECTING DUST 3 YEARS NOW ALTHOUGH I FIND IT A DECENT PUMP......
Have both and have used both in LE for over 30 years.
You can't go wrong with either.
With either, you are well armed.
With that said, I have switched from the 870 and now prefer the 590a1.
Excellent comparison!
We share the exact same opinion. I'm a Mossberg guy and still feel very comfortable with running a 500/590. Heck I've owned Maverick 88s I'd say are on par and preferable for the absolute steal they are sold for.
But SOMETHING about that 870 man. I had an Express tactical 18 inch years ago and was expecting to favor the Mossberg, but when I got some range time with it I fell in love too. They just FEEL that extra bit better. Like 10% better than the Mossberg 500. You can't really exolain why. Personally I think the reciever being steel helps weight balance and shootability when every Mossberg I've owned is front heavy especially with heat shields and heavy walled barrels. That and the action is just butter smooth. It just pointed and shot better basically.
I just found the 870 to be a smoother operating shotgun in terms of actually using it. That's not to say the 500/590 isn't smooth, because they are very smooth especially when compared to that crap coming from Turkey, but I just felt the 870 was 10% better. Lol That was the only way to describe it.
Now it seems the 870 barely has any more fans since the Freedom Group troubles. If Remington could get their QC in line with Mossbergs, I do believe some Mossberg fans would flock to 870s. They are just amazing shotguns in design. Time will tell if they can be that good in quality again though.
Some great points I couldn’t agree more, thank you so much for watching and taking the time to comment man!
@@FirearmFreedom No need for the thanks brother great content! 👍
I am excited to have Remington back! My dad raised me on his 870 Express Magnum made in 2001. It looks just like your 870 here, but it has a synthetic stock. We still have it today.
I have a 500 and an 88, but I went ahead and got this same gun with the 4 round tube. It feels good to be able to buy an affordable pump gun that employs American workers and supports the American economy. I'll report my findings on my channel when I get some rounds thru it.
I own and love both Remingtons and Mossbergs. I like the 870 better personally but I like the 590 almost just as much. You really can’t go wrong with either gun. Get one of each so you have something to hand to a buddy when they forgot their gun. If you have both, you truly have the better one.
I feel the same way. I bought my Mossberg to be my go too shotgun and a Remington as a beater. But I ended up loving the look, and feel of the Remington much more.
Thanks for the review. Been out of the loop on Remington for a long time. They had a hell of a lot of ups and downs.
(To the theme of the ol’ Black & Yellow music ...)
🎶 you know what it is ...
Woodland Camo 🎶
Woodland Camo 🎶
Woodland Camo 🎶
Woodland Camo 🎶 ...
Thanks for a great video ! The more skilled you are the more appealing the Remington 870 becomes. The 870 runs smoother and the select slug technique, with a fully loaded magazine, is more efficient. For a solid fighting shotgun, the M590 A1 with the 18.5 inch barrel and the Van Comp modifications is my choice.
The new Remington HD 870 is not the same as previous Express 870... It's FAR better! Broke one in recently shooting clays and I'm seriously impressed. Perfect function and beautiful to boot! Looks like the old school Big Green quality is back!
Nice! Can’t beat that I am pretty impressed with mine
👍 Good comparison of two excellent shotguns. A couple of years ago I looked at both and went with the 590 retrograde because I liked the location of the controls better and thought the fit and finish was better.
Just purchased the 870 [R81197] a few hours ago, it was $670 CAD. The 590A1 retrograde was double the price from this supplier, after being marked down $100. Going to pick it up tomorrow, feeling very excited, it's my first firearm.
As an owner of remington 870 i just want to say BOTH ARE F AWESOME. Cheers to all mossberg fans out there
Now i started with a Winchester 1897 12 GA i like the Mossberg pump handed,s i have thrre Mossbergs now 1 500 12GA 18.5 inch barre 6 shoot 1 590 20 GA18,5 inch 7 shoot for the girls.& 1 590 12 GA 7 shoot 18'5 inch barre .being a left hand shooter i really like the safet on the Mossbergs , now i had a Mossberg 500 20 GA but when one of my girls move out & she got it ,
Ive seen the 590 going around 500 to 600. If you dont mind plastic you can get a 590 for around 450. 700 is way to much. This is how i see the 2. 590 for self defence 870 for hunting. I think the 870 design just makes for a better hunting gun. Fits/feels better in the hand, smoother action and swings better. The 590 like the 500 just feel beefier more solid in the hand. Thing i dont care for in the Mossberg is how dam thick the stock is where you grip it. It feels like your holding a 2x4 and the action is stiff compared to alot of other pump guns. Both guns will work in both rolls but i think because the way they were designed that the mossberg is better as a defence gun and Rem is better for a hunting gun. I have both guns so this is just my 2 cents.
These are some very solid points I totally agree
I also have read that with the right spring and follower you can get 7 into the 870 with 18 inch barrel.
I will have to take a look into that thanks for the heads up!
I prefer 870s but unless their qc issues get fixed and the company has some stability, then mossbergs are the better choice as of right now imo
I'd take rem870.
Steel reciever - lasts +500.000 shots. Bought in '60 for 100$ ~900$ now, Get a slightly used, or a new on (police mag/wingmaster). Change springs, extractor to a Non-MIM, maybe ejector to a Non-MIM. Better coating and use the xtra $ for training.
I would have to agree with you at this point they seem to have the slight edge
I agree. I pick up worn police magnums, change a few springs out and you are all set. 250-450$
Ran my 870 in a shotgun class had a few double feeds where I think I may have short stroked it. Empty shell behind one in chamber or something stuck on the loading ramp. I had to fish it out or maybe it was the challenger 7.5 handicap shotshells
Great video! Is the Remington from the new RemArms company?
Having used neither, I like the Mossberg more. I think it looks better and on paper, has better features. But once you get them in hand and put rounds through them, opinions tend to change, I'm sure.
It's funny. I actually just sold my 870 not too long ago and picked up a 590 retrograde. While I think the overall quality of the 590 is better, I do miss just how smooth the action of the 870 was right out of the box. That being said, I don't think you'd go wrong buying either gun
I don’t own either shotgun but I have experience with both of them. The Mossberg had extremely stiff action right out of the box that was a major deterrent immediately. The idea that you have to shoot a couple hundred rounds to loosen the action is absurd. This was never the case with Remington Or the great American made Winchester model 1300 which is extremely smooth. I’m really surprised Mossberg never resolved this problem in their manufacturing process.
Now I’m more confused than ever. I guess I’ll have to do what you did and buy both!
Maybe the price of the 590 was higher before... i see them at stores around me between $540-575.
What sling is that on the 870? Where did you get it? Thanks.
We need a complete shotgun collection video.
870 riot gun.
590 trench gun
WTF does that even mean lol. You're a weekend shooter at best, don't live in fantasy land about civil war, riots, trench lol
@Nortwich he's talking about ww1 dough boy trench shotguns. Dummy
@@JasonNortwichlol
@@JasonNortwich well said, just more dumb labels pushed by media.
Where'd you get that sling?
I own both really great shot guns!🇺🇸👍 i prefer the older 870
Still needs bayonet 🗡
I can’t decide between that 870 home defense or the Marine Magnum
The more neutral color of the wood version may make it more suitable for hunting. One thing I can tell you for certain is the short 4 round tube version makes the gun a delight to point and handle. Without that extended tube weighing the muzzle down, the gun is way easier for me to snap on target and swing between targets or after a moving game animal.
If you can get by with 5 rounds, you gotta at least feel one of the 4+1 versions and see what you think.
You need to find an early Remington combat magnum 21" with a 7 shot tube and rem chokes.
WIth the right spring and follwer you can also get 7 into the 18 inch version. And theoretical with a 21 barrel und flush tube it should be able to hold 8 like the Mossberg 590.
Where my Rem-Rust at??? 😎
Gotta love plastic wood on the Remington. What a joke
870 law enforcement. 590 military
Is the Mossberg retro have a aluminum receiver or steel receiver?
Aluminum
Yes as the other comment said it is an aluminum receiver
Mossberg Aluminum Receiver vs Remington Steel?
steel .
It's a pump shotgun. Not a target rifle. Good god
Noice!
I OWN REMINGTONS (870 EXRESS & WINGMASTER ) WINCHESTERS (M12 M1897) AND A MOSSBERG 500 .... THE 500 IS COLLECTING DUST 3 YEARS NOW ALTHOUGH I FIND IT A DECENT PUMP......