Thanku Sir...i read on a group..3child norm not applicabme to CHS...i was shocked but im glad u explained it soo very well i also read about Catholic Syrian Bank Manager lost his job for his 3rd child falling in this CHS Catergory...WELL DONE. WELL SAID HON.SIR CA PRABHU...IT'S A,DELIGHT 2HEAR YR CLARIFICATIONS IN MEGHA HSG CONF.
Very nicely explained about 3 children issue in a CHS which most of the people doesn't know about this rule, with regards to contesting Managing committee elections in cooperative housing society.
Great!!! Now my father has got arsenal and he will try his tooth and nail to get that person's disqualified. He will be happy. If possible please send your address we will send you the gifts. 👏👍😁
Yes this is urgently reqd. We had a Secy for 7 years refused to resign as he was taking commission from works carried out refused to resign or hold Elections who had 3 kids .He had only 3 meetings in SEVEN years....armed wt this clause v personally met DDR@Palghar4clarification..he told us he is debarred wt immd.effect cant stand for elections etc then advised us to meet Dy.Regr.Tam Talao Vasai who called Secy for personal clarification at this hearing he confessed & confirmed 3rd child was born after 2001. He was immdly axed debarred,from this post but refused to resign saying he was now ACTING SECY..So I suggest the 3rd child Birth certificate, details be filled & handed over 😮to Socty...CHS Laws need 2b adhered to avoid confusion/ confronta tion...
Congrats. We too sailed in the same boat as the Secy ruled the roost for Seven years knowing how much money he cud earn with flat transfers.. Wrong NOC for Electric Bill to non-nember now she had proof of residence address (flat standing in missing person which she occupied) so she made a Passport.. Aadhar, PAN card, as proof of residence..now demanding flat to be transferred on her name..thus address was used as pepl going for Haj used her address for Passport to attend Haj .She refuses pay4 bldg repairs/maintenance coz Socty is not transferring flat in her name..outstanding almost 2 lakhs..today she is standing for Elections her Election Banners are hung all over..she has no Agreement/docs..so this SECY did illegal dealings against CHS so uts good to redress problems encountered to our Humble Brilliant HON. SIR CA PRABHU who hits the nail on the head..WELL DONE KEEO UP YR GOOD TIMELY ADVICE & GUIDANCE😂❤😂
This means it is clear if you have more than two children before 7 sept 2001, then you are eligible to contest and if children increases after the cut off date 7.9.2001, then you are eligible in certain cases only.
Sir yeh batayen 7sep 2001se pahile three children hain but 7sep 2001 ke bad till date tak koi bachcha nahin woh qualified hai ya nahin please batayen 2/aur agar socity me 98% 2001ke bad 03bachche hain aur socity sabhi member yeh rule lagu mat karo hame es per objection nahin to phir kya explain karain🎉
Our cooperative society does not has occupation certificate from authority, builder gives possession of flight to flat owner, is this legal? Member of our cooperative housing society registered cooperative society before 15 years in which majority of the managing body or office bearers have more than two children. Is registration of this cooperative housing society is legal? All the Descission taken in these periods were legal or illegal, plz inform in this matter.
Our Chairman as well as Secretary have 5 and 6 children respectively. Can they become the Chairman and Secretary of chs? If both are holding same post, Is this chs is legal chs or not? Plz let me know. Thanks
Respected Sir More than two Children. 154B-23(1)(v) Disqualification of Committee & its Members (1) (v) if he incurs any of the disqualification similar to that mentioned in the provisions of clause (vii), (viii) or (ix) of clause (f) of sub-section (1) of section 73CA. Please can you send us the explanation of 154 B 23 (v) if he incurs any of the disqualifications similar to that mentioned in the provisions of clause (vii), (viii) or (ix) of clause (f) of sub-section (1) of section 73CA.
When under section 154B2 states that section ,73CA is not applicable to housing societies, then How section 154B23;states that 73 CA is applicable. There is anamoly You should take up this issue with Govt.,instead of giving long lecture to common people and adding confusion in the minds and makingit more complicated I hope youdo the needful as MSWA
सर ये बात रजिस्टर र मानता नही उसके बाबू लोग भी लोगो को घुमरा करते है ऐसे मे क्या किया जाये सर रास्ता बताये और जो इसके से रिलेटेड है दो दो बीबी या रखते है और बोलते है सिद्ध करो करो इसका रास्ता क्या है सर इस किसको चॅलेंज कहा किस तरह से करे मैने कमिशनर पुणे को भी लिख चुका पर कोई दा देता नही और अब दुसरा इलेक्शन आ रहा है
Sir very complicated issue explained in simple language. Thanks sir
Thanku Sir...i read on a group..3child norm not applicabme to CHS...i was shocked but im glad u explained it soo very well i also read about Catholic Syrian Bank Manager lost his job for his 3rd child falling in this CHS Catergory...WELL DONE. WELL SAID HON.SIR CA PRABHU...IT'S A,DELIGHT 2HEAR YR CLARIFICATIONS IN MEGHA HSG CONF.
Very nicely explained about 3 children issue in a CHS which most of the people doesn't know about this rule, with regards to contesting Managing committee elections in cooperative housing society.
Such clarity should be shared with respect to nomination and transfer of property to legal heirs
very good information on law point
Great!!! Now my father has got arsenal and he will try his tooth and nail to get that person's disqualified. He will be happy. If possible please send your address we will send you the gifts. 👏👍😁
Did you father succeed because I was trying the same thing but the deputy registrar wants proof birth certificate then only he will disqualify
Yes this is urgently reqd. We had a Secy for 7 years refused to resign as he was taking commission from works carried out refused to resign or hold Elections who had 3 kids .He had only 3 meetings in SEVEN years....armed wt this clause v personally met DDR@Palghar4clarification..he told us he is debarred wt immd.effect cant stand for elections etc then advised us to meet Dy.Regr.Tam Talao Vasai who called Secy for personal clarification at this hearing he confessed & confirmed 3rd child was born after 2001. He was immdly axed debarred,from this post but refused to resign saying he was now ACTING SECY..So I suggest the 3rd child Birth certificate, details be filled & handed over 😮to Socty...CHS Laws need 2b adhered to avoid confusion/ confronta tion...
Congrats. We too sailed in the same boat as the Secy ruled the roost for Seven years knowing how much money he cud earn with flat transfers.. Wrong NOC for Electric Bill to non-nember now she had proof of residence address (flat standing in missing person which she occupied) so she made a Passport.. Aadhar, PAN card, as proof of residence..now demanding flat to be transferred on her name..thus address was used as pepl going for Haj used her address for Passport to attend Haj .She refuses pay4 bldg repairs/maintenance coz Socty is not transferring flat in her name..outstanding almost 2 lakhs..today she is standing for Elections her Election Banners are hung all over..she has no Agreement/docs..so this SECY did illegal dealings against CHS so uts good to redress problems encountered to our Humble Brilliant HON. SIR CA PRABHU who hits the nail on the head..WELL DONE KEEO UP YR GOOD TIMELY ADVICE & GUIDANCE😂❤😂
Great information sir
Very Nice Information 👌👍🙏
This means it is clear if you have more than two children before 7 sept 2001, then you are eligible to contest and if children increases after the cut off date 7.9.2001, then you are eligible in certain cases only.
Very good explanation sir !
Our IPC also have too many these type of confusion...
Sir if any member is disqualified for having more than 2 child.can he appoint associate member for election
Thank you it was very helpful
If the office bearers is certified Rera broker can he be disqualified under 154 B (23) 1
Can i consult Mr. Prabhu
Can we ask to get cctv footage of society office as document
Sir you are requested to reply the viewrs quiry .about more than two children its very cunfusion please clear it in shortly.Tnks for information.
🙏 छान माहिती दिलीत सर 🙏
If I have 4 children and 2 born after 2001 can I contest elections. I am 74 years now.
Sir can we get this book can you share the name of the book
Sir yeh batayen 7sep 2001se pahile three children hain but 7sep 2001 ke bad till date tak koi bachcha nahin woh qualified hai ya nahin please batayen
2/aur agar socity me 98% 2001ke bad 03bachche hain aur socity sabhi member yeh rule lagu mat karo hame es per objection nahin to phir kya explain karain🎉
Can an adopted child become associate member n then become office bearer ?
Our cooperative society does not has occupation certificate from authority, builder gives possession of flight to flat owner, is this legal? Member of our cooperative housing society registered cooperative society before 15 years in which majority of the managing body or office bearers have more than two children. Is registration of this cooperative housing society is legal? All the Descission taken in these periods were legal or illegal, plz inform in this matter.
a member who is an active realty broker , can he be disqualified
?
Thanks for information can he vote
E- Type सोसायट्यांना हा नियम लागू होतो का
Our Chairman as well as Secretary have 5 and 6 children respectively. Can they become the Chairman and Secretary of chs? If both are holding same post, Is this chs is legal chs or not? Plz let me know. Thanks
It's not legal but without proof nothing can be done
Mera 3rd child born 30th October 2001 kya mai election ladh sakta hoon co.op.hsg society .
Yes
Please explain if my father has 2 flats in society is he eligible 2 votes and Please attach supporting document
No
Respected Sir More than two Children. 154B-23(1)(v) Disqualification of Committee & its Members
(1) (v) if he incurs any of the disqualification similar to that mentioned in the provisions of clause (vii), (viii) or (ix) of clause (f) of sub-section (1) of section 73CA. Please can you send us the explanation of 154 B 23
(v) if he incurs any of the disqualifications similar to that mentioned in the provisions of clause (vii), (viii) or (ix) of clause (f) of sub-section (1) of section 73CA.
I have 3 child out of which 2 are twins. Can i contest
yes👍
When under section 154B2 states that section ,73CA is not applicable to housing societies, then
How section 154B23;states that 73 CA is applicable.
There is anamoly
You should take up this issue with Govt.,instead of giving long lecture to common people and adding confusion in the minds and makingit more complicated
I hope youdo the needful as MSWA
A person got disqualified as secretary for having 3 kids then can he appoint his son as associate member...
For election and can he become secretary..please reply
According to me 73CA is not applicable
Send no sir
सर ये बात रजिस्टर र मानता नही उसके बाबू लोग भी लोगो को घुमरा करते है ऐसे मे क्या किया जाये सर रास्ता बताये और जो इसके से रिलेटेड है दो दो बीबी या रखते है और बोलते है सिद्ध करो करो इसका रास्ता क्या है सर इस किसको चॅलेंज कहा किस तरह से करे मैने कमिशनर पुणे को भी लिख चुका पर कोई दा देता नही और अब दुसरा इलेक्शन आ रहा है
इंग्लिश मे नाम लिखने के बाद पिछले 24 घंटे से मराठी ट्रांसलेट नहीं हो रह है
पहले आटोमेटिक हो जाता था
क्या किसी और के साथ आएसा हो रह है
Very confusing me.....
If any member have more than 2 children and one these children having birthdate after 2002 then he is disqualify to attend CHS election..
@@tatyasutar
He can attend the meeting/elections of the CHS but cannot contest the Managing committee Elections.