Which is Best to Propagate Plants - Soil, Water, or Moss?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ค. 2024
- ✩Liquidirt - www.liquidirt.com/product-pag...
USE CODE Harlig_25 for 25% off your order!
✩✩CHECK OUT MY PLANTY MERCH✩✩
harli-g.creator-spring.com
✩✩ SOCIAL MEDIA ✩✩
Second channel th-cam.com/channels/gjA.html...
Instagram / harli_g_
Twitter @harli_g_
✩ ✩ PLANT PRODUCTS I LOVE!✩ ✩
*Pest Prevention Products*
Mosquito Bits - amzn.to/38oNaFd
Mosquito Bits refill - amzn.to/3sZuJR5
Captain Jacks Bug Brew Concentrate - amzn.to/2WzZ2Bw
Neem Oil Concentrate - amzn.to/38m9W0o
Diatomaceaous Earth - amzn.to/3kCZO97
*Fertilizer & Soil*
Liquidirt - www.liquidirt.com/product-pag...
USE CODE Harlig_25 for 25% off your order!!!
Miracle Grow Plant Food Mist - amzn.to/3kBIhyf
Coco Coir - amzn.to/2WBILwm
Pumice - amzn.to/3kBICB1
Orchid Bark - amzn.to/2WugbNx
Horticultural Charcoal - amzn.to/3jsNnxj
Worm Castings - amzn.to/3jr33Ba
Sphagnum Moss - amzn.to/3zwt87s
*Miscellaneous*
Grow Lights - amzn.to/3mKpQdp
Grow Tent (I have the 10x10ft one) - amzn.to/3ysvm6O
Plastic Saucers - NO LONGER AVAILABLE :( :(
Cafeteria Tray - amzn.to/3sYVZiu
garden chores plant chores houseplant chores houseplant updates do plant chores with me diy propagation station wet stick propagation
Fascinating! I was expecting the moss to do better. I'm interested in a follow-up on all of these once they're moved to their permanent substrate. I wonder if the moss props might catch up with the water props once the water props are in soil and need to build more complex root systems.
Great video! I’d also like to see how the react when potting in substrate. Do you water propagated plants have a pause in growth as the switch to taking in moisture. Different way?
🤣💖🥴🌻I fight with this all the time , lol my fave is water because I like to watch the progress 🌹🌱🪴☺️
Hi there! I've been doing water propagating for fifty+ years. My personal favorite. Although, I've used perlite and sphagnum moss also. Definitely depends on the plant and root system. Interesting video, to see the results together. Loved it!
Awesome to see this experiment! I prefer water only propagation, it's given me a 99% success rate, plus I love that using pothos helps stimulate other plant cuttings to root as well. I throw a lot of different types of plant cuttings in large mason jars together. When I tried soil propagating pothos before, I had a 50% success rate, won't do that again haha!
does putting pothos really help stimulate rooting? i’ve heard that before but i’ve never heard that explained!
I've Been Propping Multiple Ways Too...By Soil...Perlite...Water And Sphagnum. TODAY, I Am Celebrating The Successful Prop To Pots Of My 2 Painted Lady Cuttings I Got Back In November. I Rooted Them In Water Until February Because Their Leaves Were Quite Large And I Was Afraid I Would Lose Them Using Anything Else. BOTH Are Producing New Leaves!!! 🥳🥳🥳
Wow this was great! I would love to see a comparison for other plant families like hoya, monstera, philodendron, begonia etc 🌻🤓
And like someone else mentioned, it would be really interesting to see how they different prop methods take to soil when they’re potted up!
Yessss !!!
All the ones you mentioned I am growing in water. Took them out of soil and moss because they were rotting and dying.
I usually exclusively use water. I’ve tried sphagnum, but I think I tend to keep mine too wet. I do use soil for a few things, but water wins for me most times 💚
Nothing I love more than a good time-lapse video where I don't have to wait to see the results! Also really loved your side by side, mulit-view comparisons. Next prop video suggestion - air layering 😁
Very well done experiment! I am a retired science teacher so I really appreciated how you controlled the variables so you, and us, could evaluate the results. I was not surprised by the results either. I would be interested in which permanent substrate would be best from here. Super fun video, Harli! I appreciate your time and effort.
Really interesting experiment, thank you! I actually learned the moss prop box technique from one of your older videos and that was a 100% game changer for me! I've never had much luck with water, and way too many failures with soil to persist with that, so the moss prop boxes have changed my world lol, with outdoor hardwood cuttings as well as indoor plants!
I do think it needs the enclosed box humidity though.
I also think a massive downside with water prop (apart from it not working very well for me!) is that you then just get water roots, which then have to adapt to soil / substrate and the transplant shock of that can set them right back. Super interesting video though thanks for taking the time to do that!
I've always propagated in water. Never in wet soggy soil. Just started in moss. They've done great.
I’m so glad you did this. It shows the realness of propagation. I think so many times the plant community doesn’t shine light on problems that can be encountered….even with something as simple as propagating.
This is such a great video! I would love to see more experiments like this. Also feeling very validated as someone who swears by water prop hahaha! I only use sphagnum for wet sticks, peperomia leaf cuttings, etc (aka things that have a hard time standing up in water). Another perk of water prop for me is that you can often catch issues early and remedy them. I've had cuttings start to rot in water, but mostly been able to save them by trimming the rot, rinsing the cutting, letting it dry and popping it back into clean water. I've also never had an issue acclimating the water props to soil once the roots are well-established, sometimes they slow down for a bit, but they always bounce back!
What a great video! I love that you took cuttings from different plants. I've seen these types of videos, but they nearly always took just pothos for the experiment. Thank you for taking the time! 💜
Great video! I have used three methods so it’s great to see them side by side.
Literally playing your videos out loud at work ... I work at a plant boutique/shop, so it's fitting 😅🥰
How do they propagate were you work?
This was fascinating seeing side by side. I do a lot of my propagations in water but I do have a bunch of alocasia corms at the moment rooting in perlite which is also showing a lot of success and last week I did my own little experiment with peperomia, perlite, soil and water so we'll see. Thanks for putting in the work for this! Your propagations always fascinate me.
I like that you mentioned that top cuttings root faster. I had no idea until now. Thank You.
I liked this!! I’d love to see an experiment where you look at water props vs. water props with nutrients/liquidirt or superthrive or something like that. Just to see the real difference it makes.
I second, third and fourth this idea!!!
Agreed!!!
Awesome video! Thanks Harli 🤗
I love experiments like this. We all want our plants to grow as best as they can, and there's a lot of misinformation out there. Thank you for the accurate information!
Loved this! Thanks for the long-form filming!
❤️❤️ I was JUST searching for this! PERFECT timing!
Awesome video!! Thanks so much for taking the time to do this.
This is so interesting, thanks for doing this! I've been wanting to chop up my peperomia entirely to propagate for a fuller plant, but I was nervous since I haven't propagated peps before. This helped me decide to do it in moss!
Yes I love this type of video! I get disappointed when I watch a propagation video that only shows you how to set it up and then never shows the "after" footage, so I totally appreciate the time you put into this, thank you!
This was fun to watch. I never considered rooting in sphagnum until recently, so seeing this demo was really interesting.
This was an awesome comparison video! Thank you!
This was so cool! I would love as many of these videos as you want to make! It would be fascinating to see comparisons of all different styles of plant care for different props and mature plants too. You have a wide variety of plants and a great setup so it seems like a perfect opportunity to show a wide variety of comparisons!
Very interesting!! Thanks for the great video Harli!
I absolutely love videos like this - I appreciate them extra cause I can only imagine how difficult it is to keep track of the videos and which order and … all the things. Thanks Harli ♥️♥️
I literally was just looking for a video on moss propagating vs water vs soil and this was perfect!
I loved it and you did an amazing job!
I like using moss to propagate in greenhouse cabinet or grow tent, using water in ambient.
Excellent video! Love the side-by-side visual presentation!
This was fun!! Especially the comparisons at the end!
Yay! Been waiting for this video since you mentioned it in one of your earlier vlogs. Don’t worry Harli, I’m sure a lot of us enjoy these type of videos. I really appreciate the time and effort you put into prop videos ✨🤩
Incredible! Wow! Loved to see the progress and the results. Thank you!
I absolutely love this experiment. I’m definitely team sphagnum moss but I often find myself water propagating from time to time.
I love this content. I would like to see more of these videos. Great job.
I appreciate all the time & effort you put into this Harli, I love your TH-cam channel, one of my favorites. I thought this experiment was very insightful, water propagation is my favorite. Thankyou for all your hard work for the plant community, very much appreciated. Charlene, New York
Before I watch it, I’m going to say it depends on the plant. I find my pothos do much better in water propagation. I found my Hoya to do better in sphagnum moss.
Great experiment to try! Can’t wait to see the results.
Yes! Great video great idea I appreciate your work! 👍🏼👍🏼
My whole life I’ve seen my mom just plunk any clipping/cutting she would find or get into a glass of water. EVERY PLANT EVER.
It’s just been over the last 15 years when I became a plant mom that I learned different plants need different things to grow. I’ve tried to tell her. Lol- she said “leave me alone- it works” lol!!
Loved this video!! Very interesting!
This was fantastic! Thank you for taking the time to do the progress updates. I really enjoy videos that do it this way. Very rewarding as a viewer. I like old school water prop vs anything else. I rarely stick anything straight into dirt. I find, and you confirmed, that it is the slowest way to get roots and often leads to rot. I like moss for very specific things like single leaf peperomia props or chonk props. I also use moss when I've tried water with no results. I find making that switch after a month or two in water will active the props.
Love this!! This was so much time and effort and it really shows! Beautifully done!
I LOVE THIS VIDEO! This is fascinating and something I’ve always wondered about! Thanks for taking the time to experiment for us! ❤️
This was a very cool video!!! Loved it. Well worth the time!
I Love love love videos like this, Thankyou for taking the time to make it! :D
Love love love how perfect the timing for this video is🤞
Thank you for this! And yes, it was super helpful! 😊
I really love to propagate..🌱🌿
I enjoy watching it grow,and the fact that you can create new life ..is sooo super cool!🌱🌿
Great video friend💖💕⚘💖💕⚘💖
What an awesome experiment! It reminds me of my kid’s science experiment. I love how you explained all the detail as well as the results. Great visual!!!
Awesome, thank you for the video! I’d love to see more content like this- so interesting!!
Worth it! My favorite type of video (growth comparisons over time)! Thanks!
Love these types of videos!
How fun! I loved this!
Love this type of video. Perfect for right before spring when I am going to start propagating and or repotting. Thanks for taking the time to create this video :)
Thank you for doing this video! I feel like now I’m going to use this as a guide to customize my propagations!
Thank you! That was done so well, very thorough.
LOVING this style of video!! Informative yet fun but most of all, different!!
Yaaay I’ve been looking forward to this since you teased it a few videos ago! Very excited to watch!!! (After this 5 minute add lmao)
Hope to see more of these :)
Great video Harli
Thank you for sharing Harli and just in time!! I want to propagate some of my plants for before Spring gets here!!🌱🌻🥰
Learned much from this video! Great timeline on progress...thanks so much!
Been binge watching YOUR videos on propagations and what nots and GIRL THESE HAVE BEEN SO HELPFUL! I used to be terrified to chop my plants up but YOU have encouraged me to JUST DO IT!!! And guess what?? New growths are incredible!
GOTTA RISK IT FOR THE BISCUIT!
Omg thank you so much for this!!
Thank you for working so hard on this video and for so long! Was really expecting the moss to pull way ahead into the lead so this was a very interesting watch x
Absolutely brilliant Harli! I was so looking forward to this video!
Thanks for all your hard work and effort 👌
Very through and cool concept! Good old water prop never lets me down either!
Very interesting experiment, thanks a lot! I think the only difficulty with water propagation is planting into substrate eventually, that sometimes causes roots to rot.
How cool Harli! It's interesting how each variety kind of had it's own preferred substrate.
For context i live in northern england, but everything i put in water rots, and moss works for me everything has roots started within a week/ 10 days so crazy to see the difference! I would say the biggest difference between what you’ve done and my method is that i use tiny plastic shot glasses rather than cups, and i pack moss in there and keep in a big prop box, this works really well for me rather than bigger cups! ☺️
Defo enjoyed this! I'm always unsure which medium to use and I guess water is still the best 😊 I'd love to see how other plants fare out in this competition!
I am just now getting back into plants. I have always rooted in water but seeing so many videos of different ways to root plants I have been trying different ways. Very helpful video.
Thank you! As a beginner plant parent, I only ever did water props and given the results I’ll definitely keep doing water :)
I loved this. I am in the desert. I’m finding spag moss propagations work best for me with water being a very close second. This was fun to watch! Thank you for taking the time to do this. 😀
Really interesting video - thank you for going through the effort xx
Thank you Harli very interesting!
I loved the experiment. Great job Harli! 🎉
Completely loved this! Very well done! Would love to have seen with a perlite comparison as well. Thanks, Harli!
Super high quality video! Can really appreciate the time it takes to make these types of videos
Excellent video! Thanks!
Thanks for sharing this! Extremely interesting 💚🪴🌿🌱
I always propagate with water and perlite. In the beginning I just used water and that was great, but I had even better results when I started adding perlite. Definitely recommend!
Enjoyed searching your experiment Harli! Thanks for all the effort! I really don't like spagnum moss because I really hate picking it off afterwards. I tend to do water, perlite, or leca propagation depending on the type of plant. 🌱
This is one of the most helpful videos I've watched!!!
This is so cool to see !! Thank you for this experiment and the effort put in this video 😍😍 ♥️
tons of good & interesting info, yay!
Love it! Make another one!
Harli, I know how much time and effort you put into this one. Thank you for it!!!
My favorite propagation method bounces back and forth between perlite and water.. depending on the plant.
The only reason it’s not sphagnum is because I don’t like the feeling of touching it 🤣
Thank you for this video Harli, the timing is perfect! I have a couple of erythrophyllum that I want to propagate but I’ve heard numerous times that it is difficult to do. I do wonder how they’d do with perlite now. I might have to give it a try.
Interesting! Thanks for the experiment
I think it was definitely worth it! You did the work for us and now we know ☺ I tried the sphagnum moss and I think I put too much water and it got mushy. I prefer water alone because I can actually see the progress. Thank you for the video!
Love this type of content and now I want to perform my own experiment with propagation or just observing how my plants grow and perform in different mediums, great video as always ❤️
Loved this video! Would love to see this done again with different semi-hydroponic substrates!
Hey Harli! I’ve been watching your videos for about 5 months and now I’ve watched every video! I love your content and you seem so nice❤️
This was so cool!
Worth it, thank you.
100% Sphagnam moss! Thats the only way I prop. I have came up with a special mixture of nutes to add to my prop mix as well as exact lighting and temp and I often get roots starting to pop out as little as 3 DAYS!! I am documenting the whole process, the results have been SPECTACULAR!!! ANyway love your videos!