SINDHI in India - Declining? or Thriving? (URDU/HINDI)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ก.ค. 2024
- The case of Sindhi Language in India is not a straighforward one. Scholars and Academics say one thing, but the numbers paint a totally different picture. So what is going on with SINDHI in India?
#sindhi #sindhihistory #indiansindhi #sindhilanguage #pakistan #india
Sindhi In Pakistan Video: • Is SINDHI thriving?
Sindhi Resource: learn.sindhila.edu.pk
Implosive Sounds: learn.sindhila.edu.pk/grammar...
Support the Channel:
/ tareekhitales
/ @tareekhitales
Research Sources:
learn.sindhila.edu.pk/grammar...
Iyengar, A., & Parchani, S. (2021). Like Community, Like Language: Seventy-Five Years of Sindhi in Post-Partition India. Journal of Sindhi Studies, 1(1), 1-32. doi.org/10.1163/26670925-bja1...
“The Acculturation of Indian Sindhi to Hindi” by Lachman
Khubchandani.
Sociolinguistic Survey of Indian Sindhi by Chander Daswani and Sundri
Parchani..
“Changes in Sindhi in the Indian Context” by Sundri Parchani.
“Sindhī Multiscriptality, Past and Present” by Arvind Iyengar.
I'm Sindhi Hindu banya, proud to be sindhi, جيئي سنڌ
اسان جي پنهنجي سنڌي الفابيت آھي جيڪا عربي کان ورتل آھي ۽ اھا ئي رھندي سنڌي ٻولي گھڻي وسيع ۽ آسودي زبان آھي اھا قيامت تائين قائم ۽ دائم رھندي انشااللھ
شما از زبان عربی نگرفتید از زبان پارسی گرفتید
اسان پنهنجي انهي سنڌي زبان تي ناز ڪيون ٿا جيڪا اسان جي وطن سنڌ ۾ ڳالهائي پئي وڃي. اسان ان جي عربي رسم الخط سان محبت ڪيون ٿا. اسان کي نه ڪنهن ٻاهر رهندڙ ماڻهو سان ڪو واسطو آ نه ئي وري اها ڳڻتي آ ته اهو سنڌي ڪيئن ڳالهائي ٿو، ان کي اصلي سنڌي اچي به اٿي يا نه.
@@irfankhoso4015
پس لطف کن برو مطالعه کن و ببین این رسم الخط که شما می گویید عربی از چه زمانی استفاده می شود و چطور بوجود آمده
چون قرآن را به آن نوشتند دلیل نمی شه
Good v.log
انشاءالله.... سائين منھنجا 🙏
I'm M. A. Soomro , though an Arab descendent but a loyal Sindhi, retired from Civil service/Joint Secretary. You are doing good work. Kindly accept my greetings and appreciation. To understand Sindhi language we must understand the geography of it. In medieval past, not remote past, there were Sindh on north western side of present day subcontinent and Hind on South Eastern side. Sindhi is derived (taken birth) from Sanskrit language along with it's sister languages Hindi, Sinhali (Sri Lanka) and Gujarati, Siraiki etcetera are it's child languages means taken birth from Sindhi language as Sindh was geographically comprised of those regions. Religion of Sindhis affected politics and politics affected it's boundaries.
Windh at least since 18th century is used as double word windh windh means unnecessary one sided arguments becoming cause of headache to the other party. I've not heard of windh meaning as battle or war.
While being here or even today, Hindos in some areas used to convey ک Khh (کھ) into خ and vice versa like in Panjab some people pronounce Karim as Kirem and Cream as Karem. Secondly since a significant majority were Muslims, Hindos tried to differentiate themselves by putting different theories which may or may not be necessarily right. I can quote an example A Histrion by profession a ڊڪ منشي Shamsuddin Rukunuddin Qureshi wrote Aaena-e- Qadeem Sindh wherein he gave references of Toorat etc relating Sindh History to narrations of Abrahmic religions and after one year a Hindo Income tax officer Historian wrote Qadeem Sindh relating Sindh History to Hindo mythology. So there had been a competition mode. So some Hindos, not all, converted خ and ک into each other.. I would love to see links you might have added so that I can learn more on the subject. Though you are of my daughter's or grand daughter's age, I'm grateful to you on behalf of all Sindhi nation for you intellectual service to Sindhi language. Thank you very much and kindly keep it up. My Humble Regards.
A very well researched analysis. As a linguist learning about Sindhi Phonetics and Phonology was an amazing experience.
Keep up the good work. 🎉🎉
Im sindhi person , madam you have done agreat analysis , your knowledge is super , yes nazalization was and also to some extent is the core part of language which we are losing
Madam you did a good research, but it's not DEVAN-GARI as you said, it's DEVNAAGARI (دیوناگری).
بلڪل سائين
@@pawankumarbissa8956
دیوان و دیوانه تفاوت زیاده
مطلب دیوان لایک ادمینستری
دیوانه یعنی عقل نهی
@@pawankumarbissa8956 Yes that's right
With due respect to the sindhi community and sindhi language, the main reason seems to be no single platform on national or state level is where this lovely community come face to face which can increase bond among the community members.
Si dhi language is dying in India, and the reason is India's first PM Nehru. When Hindu Sindhis migrated from Pakistan in 1947 onwards, Nehru scattered them all over India and most Sindhis lost contact with one another, and that is the reason why Sindhi is dying.
Loved it!
مشا جي بهت بهترين تجزيہ.
ماشاءﷲ آپ اس سندهي اجرڪ کي سوڻ مين بهت خوبصورت نظر آئين زبردست.
وڊيو ته بھترين ۽ ڄاڻ سان ڀرپور آهي. اسان کي ھن وڊيو جي زريعي سنڌي ٻولي جو ھندستان ۾ مستقبل جي خبر ملي. سنڌي ٻولي لاء اسان ٻنھين سرحدن جي طرف کن ڪوششون رڻيون پونديون.
Among all the depressing news out there you bring knowledge and good feelings to your followers. Thanks for the effort.
I salute your hardworking and very impressive study.
Really appreciate your research, your presentation skill is amazing.
Nice Informtive research based video for Non Sindhis as well as for new generation of Sindhis as well.I am Living in Sindh. Yrs you r right still issues with this Language while writing electronic text messages;whatsapp etc.
The Good thing of any language is to adopt ot create new words time to time as in English to spread. And its compulsory for the parents to transfer their Language on maximum level and create importance in social life and in daily use.
Thank you ma'am
Mumbai Pune m cmein bahut Sindhi rahte hain aur vah khud Ko Sindhi kahane mein sharm mahsus nahin karte Balke fakhar se kahate Hain ke ham Sindhi Hain Sindhi ko Bhartiya language ki bhi Manata Mili Hui hai Indian currency per bhi Sindhi mein likha rahata hai Mumbai ke kuchh down bhi Sindhi Hain Aisa novelon mein pada hai Sindhi Shayad gharon mein hi Sindhi padhte Hain kyunki unke Kai dharmik Granth Sindhi mein hote Hain jo ke Urdu Jaisi hai jyadatar sindhiyon ke surname ke piche, ni, lagta hai Jaise keshwani Advani vagaira vagaira
Sindhis India now can't pronounce some alphabets.
❤❤
Good research
ଅନେକ ସିନ୍ଧି ସମ୍ପ୍ରଦାୟ ଏଠାରେ ଡେଲିରେ ରୁହନ୍ତି | ତାଙ୍କର ପିତୃପୁରୁଷମାନେ 1947 ମସିହାରେ ସିନ୍ଧରୁ ଦିଲ୍ଲୀ ଯାଇଥିଲେ। ହଁ ସେମାନେ ସିନ୍ଧି ଭାଷା ମଧ୍ୟ ଜାଣିଛନ୍ତି , କିନ୍ତୁ ସେମାନେ devnagari ଲିପିରେ ଲେଖନ୍ତି। ଏଥିସହ ସିନ୍ଧି ମଧ୍ୟ ଭାରତର 22 ସରକାରୀ ମାନ୍ୟତା ପ୍ରାପ୍ତ ଭାଷା ମଧ୍ୟରୁ ଅନ୍ୟତମ। ମୁଁ ଓଡିଶାର, ଭାରତର ଏବଂ ମୁଁ ଓଡିଆ ଭାଷାରେ ଗର୍ବିତ! ଓଡ଼ିଶା, ଭାରତରୁ 🇮🇳ଆପଣଙ୍କ ଅନୁସନ୍ଧାନିତ ଭିଡିଓକୁ ବହୁତ ପ୍ରେମ ☺❤👍🏻!!
Zabadas 👍
I am Sindhi from shikarpur village jamra irshad jamro
Very Informative, even for our Sindhis
Great work
Thanks
Appreciated
nice research
Madam sindh men konsi official language Sindhi hy? sindh men bhi wahi hashar hy india men Hindi or Sindh men urdu official language hy
Goooood janu
Indian Sindhis are proud Sindhis and they try their best to preserve their language. The minor changes into their language was inevitable. Which is fine, as even such differences occur within different dialects of a language, Sindhi also has such differences in its dialects.
Sindhis (all over the world) should agree on one script which is derived from Arabic (but Arabs can't read it) as most of the linguistic work, literary work is done by using this script. Moreover, Sindhi is being patronized by Provincial government of Sindh hence it's future is bright.
Punjabi was being written in Persian Script (Shah Mukhi) since long but then Gurmukhi was also incorporated, Devnagri was also there which confused Punjabis hence people from different religious backgrounds are unable to write or read other script. Punjabi's major literary work (pre partition) was done by using Shahmukhi Script. Religious beliefs aside, people should unite on One script for One language.
@@ImmranKhalid1 right, having single script can help the language grow and prosper.
Beautiful sindhi❤❤
What's this lady's first language ? and / or mother tongue ?? ,( i don't think that it's Urdu )
I think one biggest point you missed is other tangible languages with Sindhi. Sindhi peoples mostly settled in Gujarat and Maharastra where there was already thriving Gujarati business community. So just like how Urdu speakers can understand and mostly speak Hindi, similarly Sindhi speakers would understand Kutchi, and some Gujarati. So it was natural that those Sindhis who grew up in Kutchi/Gujarati neighborhood their grammar and speaking style became more like these languages. I can say because I met few Pakistani SIndhi people, earlier I thought they were from my district in Kutch but after conversation I came to know they were Pakistani but we hardly had any problem I was speaking Kutchi and they were speaking Sindhi and yet we could understand each other.
Kutchi is a dialect of Sindhi language ❤
Kutchi is actually is a variant of Sindhi
Kutchi is a dialect of Sindhi language
Because Kachi also Sindhi.
کچھی ایک قوم ہے جو دنیا کت مختلف خطوں میں آباد ہے،کچھی زبان ایک مختلف زبان ہے،اس کے بےشمار لہجے ہیں،ان کی ایک الگ شناخت ہے،ان کی ایک الگ ثقافت ہے،جو اور کسی قوم سے نہیں لی گئی۔کچھی زبان کی ایک الگ گرامر ہے ،کچھی کسی دوسری زبان کا لہجہ نہیں یہ بذات خود ایک زبان ہے جس میں بیسیوں لہجے ہیں اور یہ ماہریں لسانیات ثابت کرچکے ہیں کہ جس زبان میں ایک سے زیادہ لہجے ہوں وہ ایک الگ زبان ہوتی ہے سو ہم ثابت کرسکتے ہیں کہ کچھی زبان میں بیسیوں لہجے ہیں۔جو اسے ایک مکمل زبان ثابت کرتے ہیں۔اب تو الحمد للہ کچھی رسم خط اور کچھی کی بورڈ بھی تشکیل پاچکا جس میں ہم لکھ پڑھ اور کمپیوٹر سے ٹائپ بھی کرسکتے ہیں۔
Mashallah sister hum AP ko full support kregy may Allah almighty blessing you ❤
My ancestors were from Sewani Gatti (Street), Hyderabad ( Sindh) now in Pakistan.
Anyone from there?
Yes bro here i am from Hyderabad sonarki Bazar 😊 sewani devano ka ilaqa hai 😊me jata rehta hu mery bhut dost hai wah abi bhi kafi Hindus hai wah Hindus ki hawelis hai bhut us side
Yani tu sindhi ahe ae hyderabad kan hijrat kary wiyo tohan ki hek bar pakistan ki saraf karan ki zarorat ahe.
Love from karachi (sindh) basically meray rishtedar waha rehtay han.baki ap ao kabhi apnay sindh bhai.
Asan Tohan ki suagat kary.well i am urdu speaker but i can speak sindhi
@@pawankumarbissa8956 sewani giti*
Hyderabadi bha bhenno twha khy salam n namaste
Shehwani galli/Gatti Fakeer Jo pir Hyderabad still exist there an old area of Hyderabad where historical buildings of Sindhi Hindus still exist. Am Sindhi speaking from Hyderabad have many friends living in Shehwani Gatti/Galli ❤❤
Madam you are very good personality❤
I ❤ love my sindh and sindhi
Nice Work.
Kindly Make A perfect Research video About Sariki ( سرائیکی زبان ) language.
Because Sariki speaking area is very Big in Pakistan and also Indiana people use this language too
Hey Mesha, first of all, I want to appreciate your conten and the work you put into your research.
I really looked out for an urdu essayist youtuber and was really glad to bump into your channel.
I am currently trying to learn urdu as best as I can and your videos really help me to expand my vocabulary. Great work! 👏
Thank you
Great efforts.
A deep research in very interesting style.
❤❤❤❤❤zabardast
Highly Appreciated your content ❤🎉😮
Medam arabi farsi style me language hai jo sahi hai kyun k me sindhi hu muslim or sindh me jo non muslim sindhi hen wo b apne khas kitab document wagera enhi language me likhtay hen or purane time se or kuch imformetion apko dun k angrezon ne b es zuban ko pasand kiya tha unho ne qanon banaya tha yan nhi ye to nhi pata par jo angrez england se ata tha ya jo yahan se wahan jata wo sindhi sekhta or sikhata tha or bolty thy jo yahi paida hue unko b sekhaya unho ne ye language pasand ki ap espe ek vedio banao plz thank you
MD apni zabardst kam kia h uski lia thanks per kuch batain jo apni nahi batain
Sindh m sindhi bolni wali 50 MN s b ziyada h sindhi tv channel sindh 8 hain fm radio har district m h akhbar choti bari daily 27 sindhi m nikalti h computer p b ap sindhi m type kar sakti h dunya ki 50 jo bari language h un m aik sindhi zuban h ap gogal b check kar sakti h or pakistan urdu k bad wahid sindhi zuban h likhi or parhi jati h Balochistan m b sindhi boli jati h or south panjab m b boli jati h
India m kutchi zuban b sindhi ka aik lahja h rajistsn or kuch m sindhi h boli jati h india s kafi akhbar sindhi m nikalti h or india m tv chanel b sindhi h singapore m b 2nd largest community sindhi h thanks
Sahi taw chawo Bha ma bhi google kayam sab ❤
@@hussainsiddiqui1بهترين ڪارڪردگي جو مظاهرو ڪيو اوهان
@@MuhammadGabol-hx5re G piyara
Best nice
Walaikum Salam
Miss Mesha
First of all, i want to say,
I'm proud to be Sindhi.
After that,
Sindhi Language is increasing day by day as you said, "If Sindhi speakers ratio is increasing so definitely Sindhi Language is getting stronger"
مس ميشا،
سڀ کان پهرين، مان چوڻ چاهيان ٿو، مونکي سنڌي هجڻ تي فخر آهي.
هن کان پوءِ،
جيئن توهان فرمايو ھو،
سنڌي ٻولي ڏينهون ڏينهن وڌندي پئي وڃي، جيڪڏهن سنڌي ڳالهائيندڙن جو تناسب وڌندو ته پوءِ يقيناً سنڌي ٻولي مضبوط ٿيندي.
U r best I like
Ap is sindhi ka part 3 banaio please bahan🙁
In india sindhi language has constitutional protection.Thereare sindhi schools in india but now a days sindhi people used to speak sindhi among their community.Because English,Hindi and other religious languages have more importance in education and employment
GREAT job sister.New thing.knowledgeable content. I appreciate you dear.thank you so much.
I am from Deccan region aur hamare yaha ek Sindhi bazar hai and i observe one thing about them they mutually intelligible with KUTCHI and GUJARATI languages they people communicate eachother easily and all these three communities highly business minded.
I am Deccani btw and yaha k sindhis deccani aur regional languages such as Marathi language and other like Telugu language Kannada language k asar dikhte hai aur aisa har region k Sindhis k saath hoga hi i think in my opinion.
Hmm sahi taw chawo 😊
@@hussainsiddiqui1 Mai sindhi nahi hoo bhai i am Deccani urdu speaker you can search about our language also known as DAKHNI.
@@The_Cricket_Crazy_
Do you live in India bro
@@engr.a.d2850 Yes.
@@The_Cricket_Crazy_ ohh! Good I just searched some of dakhni speaking Muslims lives in Karachi after partition I know one of them
Nice research!
Nice content!
Research❤
Koi bhi culture bacha ke nahi rakh sakte. Kabhi na kabhi end hona hi hai.
خ اور کھ Wala topic interesting
Very good informative video. Its a phenomenon of the world if part of the nation migrate to any world corner their languages seem changed like urdu is also a LASHKRI language . I am giving u a great example of GUJRATI N KATHIAWARI etc persons migrated to Pakistan were actually belongs to Thatta Sindh Pakistan. They were the followers of Abdullah Shah Ashabi n at that time they were called MOMIN. During drought season at that time they requested A S Ashabi grant permission to migrate other areas n pray for us for their business n he granted their request. They went to different villages n towns of Gujrat territory of India. When tbey reached in said areas the MUKHEES (leaders of the areas) placed some demands that if u r living here u will follow our culture n language n they accepted their demands. With the passage of time they absorbed the words of local language resulting they created a mix language of Sindhi n Gujrati. Still this communities language base is Sindhi.. (Reference from Book written by Pir Hissam udin Rashdi) . However Indian Sindhi alive Sindhi language allover the world.
Great work madam. keep it up. I like your style
Thank you Sir 💕
Tum bahut piyariho
ہندوستان میں سندھی زبان کو سرکاری قومی زبان کا درجہ حاصل ہے
@@user-lv3tx8eo8b But the younger generation of Sindhi Hindo emigrants to India I mean Urban Sindhis in India doesn't speak much. I don't include native Sindhi speaking people in Rajasthan and Gujarat with them. Though they may not be economically well off but they may be well connected to their society and culture.
Mere khyaal se Devnagri hi script honi chahiye Bharat mein
Sister ap ik video sindhudesh pa banaio
I am Sindhi but only Pakistan 🇵🇰♥️
I’m Amir Rafi I was born and raised in Lahore Pakistan I was passed on a mechanical engineering company from my late father.
Anyway I am tired of living as a single person life …..I have dual citizenship born and Raised in Lahore Pakistan i have Pakistani plus American citizenship.i am looking for an educated lady for matrimony…
Good Reasearch on our language, basically sindhi Hindus were more educational intellectual and business minded rich people living in sindh and preserve language as a market language even British era it was shown govt documented language but at partition this rich educational class atonce migrated in whole India as scattered on big earth with surviving stage so collective wisdom of sindhi language was erased but slightly when they settled in good condition now they think about language but it is too late.
Languages like Plants 🌴.Thanks ji .
MD apni aik zabardst Koshish ki india m kuch ki zuban b sindhi ka lahja h or india k qoumi zuban b h india m sindhi chanel or akhbar b hain sindhi apni zuban or sakafat s bht piyar karti h
Bilkul meray hisab say yaha Sindhi ko aen mai qanoni protection milni chaiye
Love from shikarpur sindh
Sindh ko divide karna thha 50% sindh should have been part of Bharat
#sindhi
❤❤Sindhi🚩🚩
What about Baloch language
This lady is beautiful
Bahan ik our video Jo sindhi soudi ma rehty hai
Khudabadi is the real script for Sindhi.. agar India me Pakistan ki tarah ek perticular area hota Sindhi ka to aap dekhte ki yaha Sindhi ka pura ek cinema hota...jese yaha 13 ke around languages ka apna ek cinema h
Blkl sahi kaha, without territory k becharey Sindhiyon ko India m 4 languages bolni parti h. Sindhi, Hindi, English and regional language.
@@monsterousLad lakin Pakistan me sabkuch h fir bhi progress nahi h Sindhi language ki
@@rajeevganeshgarh Bhai Yahan pr Kisi bhi language ki progress nahi hai. Bas ek ghulamana soch hai angrezi ( English ) ko le kr . hr koi issi k peechay bhagh Raha hai . Slaves ki Tarah . Slavery mind people. Apne Aaqao ( owners/masters ) ki boli bolne main proud feel krte Hain sala sabhi log .
@@rajeevganeshgarh Pakistan Sindh me Sindhi progress kr rhi hai, Sindhi purey Pakistan ki languages m se sbse ziada preserved and intact hai. Even though Pakistani government hemsha se urdu ko local logo pr force krna chahti h. Also purey Pakistan m urdu bolne wale Indian Muslims Sindh m hai, jis se bhi aik influence hone ka threat kahi na kahi hai, lkn in sb ke bawajood bhi Sindhi Sindh m progress kr rhi ha, hope ye or bhi progress kregi.
💐💐💐💐💐💐💐
Sindhis in India now can't pronounce certain alphabets like daal dedar
They can if they focus 😅
Main kar pata hun par meri wife nahin bol pati hai
Main kai baar unko bolta hun chao "Dedar Dadhi Dingo aa"
@@sph8483 dedar daho dhingo ah ☹️ ap NY bhi Galat likho hai me Sindhi hu shikarpur sy oldest city jha sy trade route guzarta tha bhut Si historical jaghaye hai or bhut sy ourany books ki libraries
ap hein barri pyari....
Channel ka Naam tareeki tales Urdu h or baat dekho kis ki kr Rahi hu
Good Sindhi
You don't have another topic to discuss.only Sindhi,Punjabi,Hindi urdu.no benefits at all . choose public welfare topics are countless,which can be discussed for nation building.
I appreciate to your research.
With profound best wishes, respects and regards.
Dr. Captain Sohrab Shaikh
Medical Superintendent R
Pano Aqil/ Karachi
The correct pronunciation of Devnagari is not Devan- Gaari. But rather it is Dev - Naag - Ri.
I want to see one India all language of India wonder, but i love Hindi(urdu) it is vast all other are part of it
So much learning in just a few minutes 👌🏻
Sindhi language ab itne ni boli jati m sindh s ho mujhe sindh k history ka pata h
It is Dev Nagri not Devengari
انڊيا ۾ سنڌي ٻولي ترقي ڪري رھي آھي بنسبت پاڪستان جي
Your Hindi is too good 👍
Bhai woh urdu hai😂!!
@@sayed-mohammed-akbarboth are same just script are different
@@shinchan-pt9rn Yes, script is different. But after the british🇬🇧 fingering🤞🏽 in 19th century Urdu became for Pharshised(Pharsi) & hindi became more sanskritized(sanskrit)! That's why it's lesson for whole world that not to let brits 🇬🇧 finger 🤞 in your country's matter, otherwise................moye moye 😂!
@@sayed-mohammed-akbar hindi itself is a farsi word word sindhi and urdu is a turkish word for army , there was nothing like hindi and urdu earlier there was a language which was spoken around the Delhi region which was neither more sanskritized nor persianized but whatever was language spoken around delhi it has more prakrit word not sanskrit if u know about languages then u cannot understand what prakrit is nothing but distorted manner of sanskrit , which has different pronunciation of sanskrit word or it has own word ,urdu is just stuffed with loanwords from turkish , persian , arabic and prakrit
@@shinchan-pt9rn Nice 👍👏😊explanation! Got it👍🏽! Thank you for copy pasting exact detail of video from the channel "India in pixels" 🤣! I know from where you've copy pasted details here😄😂!!
الله اڪبر 💝
سائين سدائين ڪرين مٿي سنڌ سڪار، دوست مٺا دلدار عالم سڀ آباد ڪَرِين.
سنڌي ٻوليءَ ڳالھائيندڙ ماڻھون کي قرآن مجيد سڄو عربي سميت سنڌي ترجمي سان ضرور پڙھڻ گھرجي ❤️
Bilkul bha tohan ki sahi galh farma thindo munjho laye dua kary.asan lay kal wado umeed ka din ahe.bha dua karen na bholye wiyo
ڇو قران کان علاوه ٻيو به گھڻو مواد پيل آھي سنڌي عربي ۾ اسين ڇو گھڻو عرب جاھلن ۽ انھن جي لپي کي ترجيح ڏيون
Mashaallah Nice video love from Bihar
Mesha I love you
💚🇮🇳🙄🙄👍👍💚💚
devnagri & not devngari
Original script of Sindhi language is khudabadi and
Yar tum to wawi beautifull ho or nice bi ❤❤❤Barcelona spain se from Gujrat pakistan ❤️
Is sindhi is the syriki
No Sindhi is ancient and proper standard language, while Saraiki is young language or at least young recognized language, previously its role was kind of dialect continum of Sindhi and Punjabi, just like Haryanvi and himachali Pahari.
Masha Allah Allah Pak ne aap ko ser leker pao tak bohot haseen jameel aur khubsoorat banaya hai mai to fidha hogaya
Mesha you have very beautiful teeth.
This video is like an Indian making a video about status of bhojpuri (Bihari Pakistani) in Pakistan
Sindhudesh banega to vo government karachi ko capital banayenge our officei language banega (sindhi language) sindhudesh me
( Bangladesh ka tah full development desh banegi)
I'm Sindhi boy 😅😅😅😅
4:44 Yes, here in India 🇮🇳 every language speaker feels proud 💪☺❤ to speak their native languages👄💬, unlike Pakistan.There In pakistan even dominant group, Punjabi felt ashamed to speak their native language punjabi 🤷🏻♂️!
2 reasons, British rule banned Punjabi after occupying Punjab. 2ndly UP migrant bureaucracy carried this policy after 1947. Punjab lost its independence in 1949, still struggling to cope up the damage.
@@ImmranKhalid1 Then why you still inherit that brits legacy & UP muhajirs legacy inferiority complex🤷🏻♂️!? Write letters to your political leaders or protest or elect leader of your choice to change that colonial inferiority mindset & give each provinces their official languages status. Just as Official Punjabi language for Punjab, official Balochi for Balochistan, official pasthun for KPK, official sindhi for Sindh. & use Urdu & English for federal level works. That's it! 😀