@@Ahmed24-tt9owyeah, but it's not as good as a native implementation, you can see the shading behind transparent particles and the UI. It's a shame Rockstar didn't bother to add the option
Yo tb, igual me borro del canal..un saludo. tengo un portatil viejito y no puedo apreciar bien los detalles. aunque se lo curra el tio.pero esto de quitar la descripcion es una decepcion.
Most of mods are just trainers to mess around, some sounds and weapon mods... I'm affraid that it's going to be just like rdr 2 and other Rockstar's games lower your expectations to avoid disappoiment... We have a "Undead Nightmare II" mod that has never been updated since it came out, a Mexico mod that never has been updated and which is really basic.
In retrospective, even if it's an open world game, it IS STRANGE that a 2010 AAA game launched without ambient occlusion, given AO launched on PC in 2007, consoles got AO with Unreal Engine 3 in 2008 and most other proprietary game engines also had AO by 2009.
PS5 is pushing 60fps at 4K (not native but still) and you have to remember it's on par with RTX 2070, while on PC it's possible to have 4090. I'm not a PS hater or anything, it's just 4 years have already passed since PS5 launch and the most expensive modern PC parts are more powerful of course.
No es un remastered, no hay mejoras mas alla de la resolución y el rendimiento, y aún así ponen a $50 un port que debio salir como mucho hace 14 o 13 años, probablemente ya hay muchos que van a bajarlo desde steamunlocked
En ningún momento se menciona que sea un remaster, ni siquiera Rockstar lo cataloga de esa forma. Es solo un port con ciertas mejoras (soporte para 4K 144Hz, soporte para monitores ultrawide, soporte para DLSS y FSR 3, incremento en la calidad de las sombras, incremento de la distancia de dibujado y poco más) para que se acomode con el hardware más moderno. Eso si, que te lo vendan a 50 dólares me parece un *robo* total.
"there are no improvements beyond resolution and performance" This is simply false. Yeah maybe there isn't much difference to the PS5 version above. But compared to the PS3/X360 this is not a straight port, it gained a completely new shadow system and foliage and draw distance were increased but the main attraction is the better AA and better shadows. Even if you upscale on emulators, this PS4 and PC port has way better shadows.
@@renato898 Even the PS4 should be able to match the PC settings (lower resolution ofc), theres plenty of PS4 titles that look better and are more demanding imo
I love your videos and appreciate your work, but it really would be better if you stopped mixing up video sections in random order. Like you'll have multiple 'Draw Distance' and 'Shadows' and 'Resolution' demonstrations, but they are all over the place throughout the video. Why don't you just put all the same demonstrations together. Like all the 'Draw Distance' segments should be together, one after the other, for example. Not scattered throughout the video. The way you structure your videos really doesn't make any sense, no offense.
It keeps your attention span for longer, long parts of same thing is too boring. Also, if it's organized people will skip every time to next section, causing the time people watch his video to drop drastically, implying on reduced earnings.
@@crestofhonor2349 Steam reviews are still at Very Positive, guess many PC folks have double standards when it comes to grading a game's price especially when it's one their most requested port that came out like a decade late.
What we noticed is that the shadows in the PC version are less accurate than the PS5 version, and I blame Bouble 11 for not paying attention to this important detail.
The PC shadows are more accurate as there is soft shadowing. Shadows aren't universally sharp like that. Most games don't even use sharp shadows like that
PC version has improved draw distance and detail distance and has soft shadows, PS5 version is using old outdated shadows. Other than that the game look the same on both
La comparativa correcta es la versión original ejecutándose en una series x que la remasteriza por la propia consola va la versión de ps5, la de PC es obvio que siempre será mejor
I have it on my Series S (Picked up some years ago for like $8 or something like that) and Switch (physical) No plans to buy this Steam version, I am fine with the Switch version But I am happy for those folks who only have a PC to play, finally can play a native version, because emulation sucks
On the PS5, shadows are rendered with a standard shadow technique. However, on PC, shadows use Contact-Hardening Soft Shadows (CHSS), a more advanced method. CHSS dynamically adjusts the softness of a shadow based on the distance between the shadow-casting object and the surface where the shadow falls. This means shadows appear softer as the distance increases and sharper closer to the object, adding a more realistic depth effect.
Z mojego punktu widzenia to ps5 ma bardziej ostre tekstury na blisko ale na dalszym planie traci sporo. Pc w przeciwieństwie do ps5 ma odrobine słabsze tekstury na blisko ale na daleko ma bardziej widoczne i wyostrzone.
@@Jona-909Las sombras son peores en PS5. En PC se utiliza un suavizado de sombras bajo el nombre de CHSS (que puedes desactivar) y es la que las hace suaves. Y técnicamente en PC son superiores porque son de mayor resolución y tienen mejores LODs. Si no te gusta el como se ven, puedes simplemente desactivar el suavizado y se ven igual que en PS5.
No es que gane, las sombras de la PS5 consumen menos recursos en ese tipo, yo lo tengo en pc y puedo poner las sombras como las de PS5 pero prefiero que sean suaves
@@allstarcom0615 It isn't for one switch version is pretty much a locked 30FPS at 1080p. When compare to 720p at 20-30FPS on the 360 and worse at PS3 at 640p with drops going even lower... As well both 360 and PS3's framerate can crumble in Undead Nightmare too while Switch version runs far smoother.
They are not. On the PS5, shadows are rendered with a standard shadow technique. However, on PC, shadows use Contact-Hardening Soft Shadows (CHSS), a more advanced method. CHSS dynamically adjusts the softness of a shadow based on the distance between the shadow-casting object and the surface where the shadow falls. This means shadows appear softer as the distance increases and sharper closer to the object, adding a more realistic depth effect. Sharper shadows doesn't always equals more realistic.
@@SweetFlexZ Waiting 2 more years for a PC release of GTA 6, a game that has been the most anticipated for over a decade is a bit sad, don't you think? Lol. Also, consoles have been doing 60fps for 3 years now it's just that the devs have to put up a patch for earlier PS4 games, so no.
para lod que dicen que el ps5 gano por las sombras mas osbcuras vean las diferentes tecnologias de sombreado y despues hablen la mayoria son fanboy que hasta le brillan los ojos cuando ven que algo se ve un poco mejor pero lo es que sea mejor 😂
![Red Dead Redemption 2 : Brutal Mafia killing in Wild West Vol.15 [4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ObNmaN-1bMk/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Dead Redemption 2 : Brutal Mafia killing in Wild West Vol.15 [4K]](/img/tr.png)
I miss when you used to put technical report here, it’s a big letdown that you’ve stopped.
Same, one of the main supporting pieces of info I came to these videos for. Real shame
Maybe because people just read that instead of watching the video.
All he does now is "Bera bee, odjo odjo bee"
Jajajaajajajaja@@JvanEdits
@@JvanEdits😂😂😂😂😂😂
This game doesn't have a Ps5 version.
It's a Ps4 game running through BC.
Correct, this needs to be pinned.
It’s not even a Ps4 version, it’s the same game as the 2010 one, Ps3 version, just a port and different resolution.
@@theFedHDand that's a good thing, when rockstar is lazy, it means at least they aren't ruining their masterpieces of yesteryear.
@@brightbluesmurf it doesn't matter. PC version is the same too
Yes and no. RDR1 is a PS4 game with PS5 enhancements. It runs at 1440p60 (I don't think it was 4K) on PS5, 1080p30 on PS4 and 1440p30 on PS4 Pro.
This game doesn't have Ambient Occlusion in any version.
lol
yeah damn. everything look flat without ambien occlusion
I think SSAO can be injected with shaders?
@@Ahmed24-tt9owyeah, but it's not as good as a native implementation, you can see the shading behind transparent particles and the UI. It's a shame Rockstar didn't bother to add the option
This is a PS360 game, AO was something new and demanding for those consoles.
However, they were able to make the effort to add it.
Echo de menos cuando escribías una descripción
Lo que sí podría poner es el peso de los juegos en cada una de sus versiones. Algunos solo ven la resolución+FPS y se van del video
@@joellynch7722 Ni idea de cuanto pesa en ps4 y ps5, pero en PC no supera los 10.4GB de espacio.
Yo tb, igual me borro del canal..un saludo. tengo un portatil viejito y no puedo apreciar bien los detalles. aunque se lo curra el tio.pero esto de quitar la descripcion es una decepcion.
@@JorgeDimtonen playstation 5 igual pesa 10 gb
@@JorgeDimton Así es, 9,23 GB en PC
Qué pasó mi Analista no pusiste mucha información técnica. Faltaste ahí
I play games both on PS5 and PC, glad it came to PC though, PC mods are going to take this game to a whole new level.
Most of mods are just trainers to mess around, some sounds and weapon mods... I'm affraid that it's going to be just like rdr 2 and other Rockstar's games lower your expectations to avoid disappoiment...
We have a "Undead Nightmare II" mod that has never been updated since it came out, a Mexico mod that never has been updated and which is really basic.
@@goblindeter8258game came out in the past 48 hours.. and there's plenty of mods not just trainers.. in few months in gonna really shine
In retrospective, even if it's an open world game, it IS STRANGE that a 2010 AAA game launched without ambient occlusion, given AO launched on PC in 2007, consoles got AO with Unreal Engine 3 in 2008 and most other proprietary game engines also had AO by 2009.
There’s literally no reason the draw distance on ps5 can’t be the same as on pc for a ps3 game… what a joke.
That's because it's the PS4 version played on PS5 via backwards capability. It's limited by the PS4 pro code. There's no native PS5 version.
PS5 is pushing 60fps at 4K (not native but still) and you have to remember it's on par with RTX 2070, while on PC it's possible to have 4090. I'm not a PS hater or anything, it's just 4 years have already passed since PS5 launch and the most expensive modern PC parts are more powerful of course.
@@3a43mkaIt is Native 4K. FSR Native AA (similar to DLAA) is used instead of the original AA from PS3/X360.
This is the PS4 version running on PS5. There is no native PS5 version of this game.
Ahh yes you are right. But yeah, horizon forbidden west has better draw distance than this.
Welcome to 2024, where a 2009 game costs $60
*2010, $50. But yeah
Rockstar🤑
yup, great port but not worth $50, $25~$30 would have been a reasonable price and I'm waiting for the discount later this year.
Nintendo and its games from 2007 to 60😈
@@HaronFuroze same, waiting for Christmas sales
So why exactly at 7:40 the 4080 super loses in terms of frame rate to 4070 and 4070ti super?
It’s not at 100% usage
CPU...
Because Nvidia Support 🇮🇱
Cpu botttle neck, the 4080 is not at 100% , if not...
@@sammyflinders It's not, it's bottlenecked by the CPU.
No es un remastered, no hay mejoras mas alla de la resolución y el rendimiento, y aún así ponen a $50 un port que debio salir como mucho hace 14 o 13 años, probablemente ya hay muchos que van a bajarlo desde steamunlocked
For sure 😂
En ningún momento se menciona que sea un remaster, ni siquiera Rockstar lo cataloga de esa forma.
Es solo un port con ciertas mejoras (soporte para 4K 144Hz, soporte para monitores ultrawide, soporte para DLSS y FSR 3, incremento en la calidad de las sombras, incremento de la distancia de dibujado y poco más) para que se acomode con el hardware más moderno. Eso si, que te lo vendan a 50 dólares me parece un *robo* total.
I got it from fitgirl
"there are no improvements beyond resolution and performance" This is simply false.
Yeah maybe there isn't much difference to the PS5 version above. But compared to the PS3/X360 this is not a straight port, it gained a completely new shadow system and foliage and draw distance were increased but the main attraction is the better AA and better shadows.
Even if you upscale on emulators, this PS4 and PC port has way better shadows.
Si, juegos así deben obligatoriamente ser pirateados
Crazy how console cant match the pc settings, the pc settings dont even look that crazy, the ps5 should easily be able to match that
No, ps5 is slow, rdna is garbage
@@OmnianMIU You are garbage. It's PS4 Pro version running in back compat on PS5. There's no native PS5 version of RDR.
The PS5 could obviously match the PC settings but it does not have a PS5 version only a PS4 version. It's running under backwards compatibility.
@renato898 no it can't do. Stop spreading stupid bull💩 as a demential person
@@renato898 Even the PS4 should be able to match the PC settings (lower resolution ofc), theres plenty of PS4 titles that look better and are more demanding imo
I love your videos and appreciate your work, but it really would be better if you stopped mixing up video sections in random order. Like you'll have multiple 'Draw Distance' and 'Shadows' and 'Resolution' demonstrations, but they are all over the place throughout the video. Why don't you just put all the same demonstrations together. Like all the 'Draw Distance' segments should be together, one after the other, for example. Not scattered throughout the video. The way you structure your videos really doesn't make any sense, no offense.
It keeps your attention span for longer, long parts of same thing is too boring. Also, if it's organized people will skip every time to next section, causing the time people watch his video to drop drastically, implying on reduced earnings.
@@ileonhart I never thought of it like that. That makes sense.
Technical report???
Debieron de poner la versión original de ps3 en la comparativa para ver la evolución completa
The Resolution on PS5 is misleading.
It runs at Native 4K with FSR Native AA but video seems like it’s being upscaled with FSR 2.
PS3 Textures for all.
You could have just said it has FSR Native AA at 4K which it does, not "With FSR 2" just giving ammo to fanboys
Pirate now then buy at cheaper price later
Again no comment description regarding resolution, graphical differences in assets, framerates and such. This channel has become complacent
Xbox One X and Xbox Series X users doesn´t see the point for this "remaster". They´ve had it for years for free...
Xbox owners get a worse version because of it though
When will we get Rdr 2 update for ps5?
When the ps6 is out lol
PC stays winning, I just pirated it today and it's running so good on my PC, thanks for the free game rockstar
Imma bout to do the same 😂
Guys...
yeah i just download it last night and shi it run so good 😂
That's why pc don't deserve games
@@gamerpro1558 nah i won't pay for it cause i already bought it on Nintendo
El Analist didn’t put many descriptions bc it’s a rockstar game. If they want, they can take this video down bc simply yes
I'm looking forward to future graphics mode and realism features as mod
Name of the music ?
Va a haber comparación con el resto de las versiones?
Ya están ahí.
Ps5 movements are smoother, like no frames are missed
It's needs a real PS5 version that matches PC settings
Good luck, on PC you can play it in 8K with upscaled textures everywhere.
@@SweetFlexZ what a dumb comment
More conslowgirls crying
@@OmnianMIU how old are you? Imagine fighting over games 😂😂😂
Ultra vs Low and X360 vs PC pls
This seems so disappointing compared to the Zero Dawn Remake which also came out today
Yet people complained about HZD remaster with the option to upgrade for $10 yet, the PC folks rejoiced at the 10-year too late RDR port at $50 lol.
@@barebarekun161 Most PC gamers hate that this costs $50
HZD remaster, not a remake. It's not the same
I mean this is an upgraded port of 2010 game whereas horizon is an remastered version of a game which came out after rdr1
@@crestofhonor2349 Steam reviews are still at Very Positive, guess many PC folks have double standards when it comes to grading a game's price especially when it's one their most requested port that came out like a decade late.
The game looks equally good on both 👍🏻
Porqué ya no pones los textos tan detallados qué siempre solias poner 😢
Ojalá GTA IV en PS5 🥹❤️
Never before GTA VI
Now that they launched a PC version they could release a PS5 version with the increased settings like PC.
La PS5 tiene colores naturales
when will the test be on xbox one fat or slim?
Shadows on pc are much better, but ps5 could handle that too
It could, but it's PS4 Pro version runnning in backwards compatibility on PS5.
No, ps5 shadow is better
@@Muhammad-Barznji Why?
Pc: 49.99
Ps5: 49.99
Switch: 49.99
Xbox: metes tu disco que tenias guardado o si no 14.99
It’s the 360 version with no updates or fixes
free en PC
Pc: ElAmigos
Ps5: 49.99
Switch; 49.99
Xbox: No hay disco guardado ni consola Xbox :V
@@Jean_Christhian If buying is not owning, pirating is not stealing.
@@chrisbrown113096at least the xbox 360 version got a free resolution patch on Xbox One X/Series X instead of charge you $50 dollars
What we noticed is that the shadows in the PC version are less accurate than the PS5 version, and I blame Bouble 11 for not paying attention to this important detail.
I also did not notice a significant improvement in the PC version in terms of image quality within the game, except for the login menu
No pc version have pcss shadows, better techno than ps5, more soft. Like in le real life
@@SaintMichel. I don't know, I think the shadows in the PC version are a little blurry
The PC shadows are more accurate as there is soft shadowing. Shadows aren't universally sharp like that. Most games don't even use sharp shadows like that
@@crestofhonor2349 So this means that the shades of the PC version are better!، Well, excuse me, I am not an expert in some techniques
Hola harás una comparación de la versión de PC ultra contra la original de 360 o PS3?
Could you compare Metaphor ReFantazio in ps4 and ps5? Or if someone could tell me how many differences are there between the two versions...
PC version has improved draw distance and detail distance and has soft shadows, PS5 version is using old outdated shadows. Other than that the game look the same on both
PS5 version is just the PS4 Pro version
por qué en donde la 4080 super está usando tanto procesador comparado con las otras 3 gráficas? Está usando el 15%, qué demonios.
Its the sme for me, at the same place with 4090 my 12700k is 20% irs because there is a cpu bound in armadillo
Ps5 Just 500$ and give you this graphic, but pc 3000$ give you litter more clear graphics hahaha@@SaintMichel.
Solo compraré la versión de PC cuando ya haya mods de gráficos ultra así cono los de RDR2
Increíble que un juego de PS3 para correr en PS5 requiera FSR para correr en 4k
Es un port cutre y caro, no es una remasterizacion q es lo q deberían haber hecho, este juego debe ser pirateado si o si
They didn't even improve it, despite having the ready map from RDR 2. This is disrespectful and disgraceful!
La comparativa correcta es la versión original ejecutándose en una series x que la remasteriza por la propia consola va la versión de ps5, la de PC es obvio que siempre será mejor
PC Master Race 💪
En realidad no existe version de rdr para ps5 ... Es de ps4
I have it on my Series S (Picked up some years ago for like $8 or something like that) and Switch (physical)
No plans to buy this Steam version, I am fine with the Switch version
But I am happy for those folks who only have a PC to play, finally can play a native version, because emulation sucks
Insert identify which picture is different meme from the office
ps3 vs pc
Are shadows better on PS5??
hell no
On the PS5, shadows are rendered with a standard shadow technique. However, on PC, shadows use Contact-Hardening Soft Shadows (CHSS), a more advanced method. CHSS dynamically adjusts the softness of a shadow based on the distance between the shadow-casting object and the surface where the shadow falls. This means shadows appear softer as the distance increases and sharper closer to the object, adding a more realistic depth effect.
😂
um no
Yes
AMAZING Graphics Comparison RDR1 THE BEST PC AWSOME
Z mojego punktu widzenia to ps5 ma bardziej ostre tekstury na blisko ale na dalszym planie traci sporo. Pc w przeciwieństwie do ps5 ma odrobine słabsze tekstury na blisko ale na daleko ma bardziej widoczne i wyostrzone.
Voy a esperar que saquen mod grafico y que usen el mismo motor que el 2.
Again, the PC version is always the best.
For a higher price, that should be obvious, as for anything else.
Shadows are way sharper on *PS4 version.
Nice Video😊❤🎮
La versión de ps5 es nativa de la ps4 o tiene algún upgrade?
Solo mejora la resolución y los 60fps, todo lo demás es igual
@@loconeitor50no mira bien y las sombras de ps5 gana y reflejos
@@Jona-909Las sombras son peores en PS5. En PC se utiliza un suavizado de sombras bajo el nombre de CHSS (que puedes desactivar) y es la que las hace suaves. Y técnicamente en PC son superiores porque son de mayor resolución y tienen mejores LODs. Si no te gusta el como se ven, puedes simplemente desactivar el suavizado y se ven igual que en PS5.
Hola, el red dead 1 usa los adaptive triggers ?
yes
No, este juego no tiene soporte nativo para DualSense, solo para controladores de Xbox, necesitarás usar programas como DSX o DS4Windows.
I've bought my 4090 2200€, but hell nah I would not pay 50€ for a ps3 game
do yakuza kiwami switch vs ps4 vs ps3
2:25 ahí la ps5 gana las sombras
No es que gane, las sombras de la PS5 consumen menos recursos en ese tipo, yo lo tengo en pc y puedo poner las sombras como las de PS5 pero prefiero que sean suaves
Te equivocas, en PC si quieres esa calidad de sombras tienes que ponerlas en medio, en ultra se ven más difusas, como en la vida real.
@ son ciegos o quee mo ven las comparacion de la sombra de ps5 se ve mejor
More Importantly need the music
Monster hunter wilds beta test plis? 🙏
Make comparison PS3 and PC
This game runs choppy on my PC, not sure why because I have a 4080.
Name song???
It's called "one of the most annoying and worst beats ever made".
@SOTVT xdddd
“Rdr1 ps5” doesn’t exist.
No veo ninguna diferencia
este men hace trampa en las comparaciones.
Cadê teste do Black ops 6 ?
Can´t wait for the Mods to make the Game even better 😏
I want Path Tracing here 😍😍😍
Hace comparacion de la version de pc vs xbox 360 vs xbox series x
Dónde está black ops 6 series x vs one?
Should have included the Switch as well because we all need a good laugh sometimes.
No need, the ps5 version is already in the video
Honestly if you want a good laugh PS3 version would be perfect for it since Switch version is pretty much better then the 360 and PS3 versions.
@@Killersnake432Stop the cap the Switch version is worse than PS3 and 360
@@allstarcom0615 are u kidding? the switch version runs at 1080p 30fps constant and ps3 runs at badly 640p and 25-28fps most of the time lol
@@allstarcom0615 It isn't for one switch version is pretty much a locked 30FPS at 1080p. When compare to 720p at 20-30FPS on the 360 and worse at PS3 at 640p with drops going even lower... As well both 360 and PS3's framerate can crumble in Undead Nightmare too while Switch version runs far smoother.
Lol how tf the shadows r better on the ps5?!
They are not.
On the PS5, shadows are rendered with a standard shadow technique. However, on PC, shadows use Contact-Hardening Soft Shadows (CHSS), a more advanced method. CHSS dynamically adjusts the softness of a shadow based on the distance between the shadow-casting object and the surface where the shadow falls. This means shadows appear softer as the distance increases and sharper closer to the object, adding a more realistic depth effect.
Sharper shadows doesn't always equals more realistic.
"666k sub" what the devil
I don't like this graphic, stay RDR 2 PC is best decision
Don’t tell Rockstar or any of my friends but I would pay full price for a Rdr2 60 frame rate update for ps5.
It’s on pc already
@@9v918He said PS5 not PC
@@Electrifize Begging for something that has been on PC sin release is a bit sad, don't you think?
@@SweetFlexZ Waiting 2 more years for a PC release of GTA 6, a game that has been the most anticipated for over a decade is a bit sad, don't you think? Lol. Also, consoles have been doing 60fps for 3 years now it's just that the devs have to put up a patch for earlier PS4 games, so no.
@@9v918No one talked about pc
PC win
i need rdr 2 60fps patch comon rockstar no body asked rdr 1 patch 60fps for red dead
Call of Duty Black ops 6 PS4 vs Xbox one Please
para lod que dicen que el ps5 gano por las sombras mas osbcuras vean las diferentes tecnologias de sombreado y despues hablen la mayoria son fanboy que hasta le brillan los ojos cuando ven que algo se ve un poco mejor pero lo es que sea mejor 😂
Bueno al menos Grove Street games no estuvo involucrado 😁😁
Esse jogo não tem muito pra onde ir!!!
Shadows on PC look blurry
Pc annihilates it
Ps4 pro vs pc
No HDR, no buy
hdr is there
There’s native HDR10 on pc
monster hunter wilds open beta ps5 & xsx,plz⋯
La versión de Nintendo Switch Gana! Porque me la puedo llevar al baño mientras cago 😂
Do it with bo6 in all platforms (including ps4 and xbox one)
por suerte compre el rdr a medio dolar en la x360, la verga voy a comprar el rdr por 60 dolares
Is me or ps5 look better?
It's you, PC is better in everything. Performance, graphics, resolution, etc.
It's you
I need mods for see one big difference xD
Puedes hacer el de Minecraft ps5
Rockstar 😂😂😂