ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 มิ.ย. 2024
- Israel's offensive in Rafah has put relations with its neighbor Egypt under severe strain. Egypt has for decades cooperated on security arrangements along its border with Gaza - but Cairo suspended that cooperation when Israeli troops took over the Gazan side of the Rafah border crossing.
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
2:15 Shani Rozanes, DW Middle East Analyst
6:08 Karim El-Gawhary, Journalist
8:39 Aya Ibrahim
Subscribe: th-cam.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#israel #egypt #rafah
So you interview two former IDF soldiers without disclosing their past and call this journalism?
wasnt sure why she was saying what she is saying. Until she said rafaKHH xD
It's interesting why Egypt built such a high wall in Rafah after October 7.
Western Journalism in a Nutshell.
Hiring the former Media coordinator at the Consulate of Israel in New York is really unbiased….
every other news outlet is biased against Israel, so this is fair.
So unbiased you are anti semetic if you comment on it.
😂😂
DW “expert” was a former media coordinator at the Consulate General of Israel in New York and IDF soldier…what an unbiased credible commentator 😂
😂😂😂 Germany
good one! thanks for pointing that out!
When I heard her say "K-hamas" I knew I could ignore every other word out of her mouth.
Her accent gave her away, the way she pronounced Hamas and Gaza exposed her.
And she spoke the IDF talking point that Rafah is the last Hamas stronghold. Meanwhile fighting has flared up in the rubble of North Gaza. The genocide is going perfectly to plan
Germany should ask the Egyptian ambassador to explain
Too little, too late.
This Middle East Analyst sounds a lot like any other Hasbara employee.
DW, please stop disrespecting the intelligence of your audience.
Inviting a guess that is fully adapting the Israeli view put the whole program in doubt
That’s what you want to believe
DW is a German channel, that is why they invited pro Israel commentator (the woman).
@@DynamictvcHe is saying the reality.
Israeli president said in the beginning that there's no uninvolved civilians in Gaza
Israel finance minister said that returning the hostages is not a priority
It was never about the hostages it's just meaningless revenge
Stop crying in the media. You wanted this war and you got it. Stop being cowards and crybabies.
Of course the hostages aren't a priority. There are maybe a few tens of hostages left alive in Gaza. I'm sure some people in their government said it was about hostages just because that's what their people want to hear. The reality is that it's about disabling Hamas to prevent an attack like that in the future. That's the only thing that really matters.
The fact is if Hamas released hostages, the IDF kills them anyways
@@Bob-ly4dy It's about destroying Gaza and making it impossible for Palestinians to ever return and stealing the land to develop for Israeli settlers.
It's expanding Israel to the sea. Like the US expanded to the pacific. Israel is in a manifest destiny stage. Also why the US is building a port there, not for aid, but a shipping lane for future export import business. Nation building.
Money has blinded the politicians to see the differences between genocide, war crimes, brutal colonial occupation, trasprent Apartheid and self defense.
You have 0 clue as to what any of those words mean. But use them none the less due to its popularity.
@@Joe-pc3hs genocide is committed because purposeful displacement of a nationality from their lands is genocide under the UN charter; apartheid because the Palestinian authority(West Bank) sends all Palestinians to a military court without jury for any crime while Israelites get civilian court; 1967-2005 Israel occupied Gaza and illegal settling of Gaza occurred prior to withdrawal in 2006; and the scale of collateral and denial of aid is war crimes. All his points are merit, speak on the definition of those words and explain how any of the stated above facts are false or lies if you have issues understanding things you don’t understand yourself.
@@Joe-pc3hs genocide is committed because purposeful displacement of a nationality from their lands is genocide under the UN charter; apartheid because the Palestinian authority(West Bank) sends all Palestinians to a military court without jury for any crime while Israelites get civilian court; 1967-2005 Israel occupied Gaza and illegal settling of Gaza occurred prior to withdrawal in 2006; and the scale of collateral and denial of aid is war crimes. All his points are merit, speak on the definition of those words and explain how any of the stated above facts are false or lies.
@@jakebhenry2228 right, and thanks for the short summary !
@@eddastrohmayer251 👍🤘
United States questioning if Israel has an exit policy ... let that sink in.
You know she is a Israeli apologist when she says KHamas
What does Khamas mean ?
@@eddastrohmayer251 Violence in hebrew but that is also how you pronounce hamas in hebrew.
RafaKHHHH 😂
@@Sam_Guevenne Thank you very much !
@@eddastrohmayer251 From what I can tell it is a blanket term used to justify the murder of anyone they don't agree with.
What a shame to bring IDF personnel to this show as a journalist
Germany is on the wrong side of history again.
Natural talent at work!😉
Since the roman empire, and probably before that. They were named "barbarians", and ironically claim to be the heirs of the "western world", lmao.
A leopard never changes its spots.
Don't think that would be Germany as such - unfortunately they have a "woke", uneducated and undiplomatic Foreign Minister yet ...
Unfortunately they have an uneducated, undiplomatic Foreign Minister yet ...
Egypt has fallen from grace many years ago.
Is this after or before the war where Israel defeat Egypt and the other silly countries that decide to join in the loser club?
@@S0ULJA006 After depending on what you consider fallen, at present a dictator rules Egypt and undid the only democratic election in Egyptian history back in 2011: rest in peace Morsi, you are missed beyond measure.
@@jakebhenry2228 Nobody needs warloving Muslimbrothers !
What is grace?
The lady analyst doesn't know what she is talking about. She has no understanding of how smuggling works and also seems unaware that the manufacture of weapons occurs inside Gaza. The only issue is gaining enough high explosives for the bombs either by smuggling in the precursors or high explosive itself and enough precursors for low explosives or gun powder for rockets , mortars and bullets. Reason you can't smuggle low explosives in is they are to unstable and packing them safely would stand out too much. The only way major smugglers of drugs for example get caught is by following the money and Israel is incapable of doing that in the case of Gaza. Also we are talking about relatively small sums of money.
It as if the Palestinians aren’t supposed to have the own defence weapons. Why do we call it smuggling when they purchase weapons but we don’t call it that for Israel? That is hypocrisy.
was a former IDF soldier and worked for the Israeli consulate soo....
Palestians have the RIGHT TO DEFEND THEMSELVES.
Israel's control of the Sinai Peninsula is key to cutting off arms smuggling and drugs via the tunnel system never fully cutoff by Egypt who turns a blind eye.
RafaKH and KHamas was so telling that I had to check who this was, how are you literally presenting a former IDF soldier as some sort of a neutral expert? Utterly shameful!
Gaza is like that of a fourth world country now.
My bedroom
Is that an independent analyst can’t stand the Khhaaaa
Germany, Britain and Japan were rebuilt
It has never been a country.
More like back to Stone Age but nonetheless they still have some of the best doctors in the world
So you interview fmr IDF soldiers for a comprehensive view of what is happenning? LOL
Very balanced view point from the israeli spokesperson . 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Shame on DW .
No it has no plan.. there is no food.. she is incompotent.
War is between two armies not between army and civilians, this is a textbook example of GENOCIDE.
A civilian that has the capability to make rockets 🚀 bombs and fire these rockets 100km away? You’re just not true to yourself because you’re naïve
Your are not civilian if you firing a weapons or capturing hostages. Besids using a civilian clothes when fighting is a crime.
Armd terror organization armed with billions by Iran in the Civil population
When “citizens” cooperate with and harbor terrorist, they are no longer citizens
Well said@@Dynamictvc
beginning of the war ''hamas strong hold is South of gaza'', middle of war ''hamas last strong hold is North of gaza'', now ''Last strong hold is Rafah crossing'', this is a pattern and if you watching closely even loosely its easy to spot whats going on.
Your guest assumes that Hamas got its weapons through the Rafah crossing which nothing/nobody substantiated anything like that. A terrible mistake from your expert
🙄👆🏼🤣🤣🤣🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
@bobbenjy6426 There are many master and journeyman level gunsmiths in Gaza. She's either ignorant or mendacious.
Israel has had sky surveillance on every inch of Gaza Strip for decades, it's been something Gazans have openly complained about for decades. They definitely know that that's exactly what happened man.
@@dooley8746 There seem to be very few people out there who realize that there are many excellent gunsmiths and not a few weapons designers in Gaza. The Israeli government absolutely knows this, but consistently refrains from mentioning this fact.
That important bit of info doesn't give Israel the excuse it needs to fire missiles and drop bombs on over a million civilians in Rafah. The fairy tale about weapons smuggling *does,* as well as placing Egypt diplomatically on the defensive. It also allows them to invoke Iran in a way that keeps Palestinians from looking competent and resourceful. Otherwise they'd mention the smuggling of raw materials and tools in the past, which IS the truth.
well thats were the tunnels are
Total silence from Germany on this genocide???
Did Germany instruct Hamas to attack Israel? Did the rest of the world instruct hamas to do it? Why do people like you feel so entitled to think that the rest of the world has to feel sorry for them? People should take responsibility for their own actions rather than dragging outsider into the mess.
@@bigd386It has nothing to do with Hamas, it has to do with atrocities committed by the IDF.
@@jakebhenry2228 but what is the motive behind the attack? Did the IDF and Israelis government simply decided to wake up and choose violence?
@@bigd386 Yes that is a good line of reasoning, have you asked yourself the same question in regards to Palestine?
Israeli government and Hamas are very similar - they have the same extremist positions and the same cruelty!
Is she really comparing the revenue the egypt generates from the suez canal to what she claims egypt is making from Rafah crossing? Rafah crossing is mostly for individuals while suez canal is for massive ships.
The Rafag crossing brings in ungodly prices by the agents who control transport buses for entrance by Palestinians who pay thru the nose, especially during a war.
Hamas burned their bridges with Egypt back in 2014-2018 with all the attacks on Egypts border patrol.
The genocidal countries of Europe and the U.S should bear responsibility on this disaster and human crimes they committed.
Unlike the totaly not genocidal arabs
Thank you Egypt
So they speak fluent English but the letter H is problamatic
Egypt sent 100 tanks to the border, and before them 40 combat armored vehicles. This is a dangerous development
Egypt sword rattling is hollow. Their a welfare state with lackluster military 🪖 barely able to sustain its own economy.
God bless Egypt and South Africa
Why is she pronouncing Rafah as Rafakh and Hamas as Khamas?
Shame Gaza’s Arabs neighbours.
Kuwait, Jordan, Egypt, Lebanon and such know the dangers of those people
Kuwait expelled 300k of them from their country in 1990
Saudi Arabia banned only them for applying for citizenship by law, they’re the only ones banned
Jordan had to fight the PLO, they attempted to overthrow the Jordan king, Jordan PM taken out, etc.
It goes on and on, the Arab countries know well about those people, so don’t be surprised when they don’t want anymore of those people. It really is like that
Huh? What's the Suez Canal have to do with the Rafah Crossing? Those are two completely different routes for two completely different goods.
Welp, there goes the neighborhood.
No more dancing and cheering? What happened?
Right, both sides prefer now fighting to dancing ... extremists on both sides are now prevailing
Abdul is realizing shouting allahu akbar does nothing against 500lb JDAMS
butbutbut... Egypt played a key role creating the situation Gaza's in, right?
what a joke with an ex idf soldier
Who is blocking the aid.....the big question????
Israel. It has always been Israel. It is not the first time.
Israel controlling rafah crossing now why would egypt block aid lol?
You are very honest!
It's interesting why Egypt built such a high wall in Rafah after October 7.
Egyot stands with brics and international justice against apartheid israel .
LOL brics you mean russia and China the country with a actual concentration camp for the Uighur people.
Very sad Egypt, Miser, Jordan, turkey did nothing in protecting the precious lives of Palestinians and attacking Israel which is involved in genocide of helpless Palestinians
There's no genocide in FalseTin
You are being ridiculous Turkey owes nothing to Pallies they are not even Arabs and no country goes to war with another because of another. country no matter what
Turkey can’t do anything when bordering countries aren’t interested because they been very selfish . And now At least Turkey cut trade ties . But Egypt and Jordan can now enjoy the reality of dealing with US & Israel.
War only makes more war and losing more precious lives...
IDF leak a vedio which show the terrorist talkibg with UN member.
So aid to Gaza are through israel
Lolz, did you see the latest report on that, they trashed the aid trucks, Aid through Israel, lol 😂🤣😃
Hamas keeps firing at the crossings.
She has no clue
And you do?
DW have no shame 😃
Doesn't matter, Israel is not playing around. Egypt is starving Palestinians. Egypt should open his border if it wants to prove to be against genocide.
I see, you want Egypt to be complicit with Greater Israel project ...
@@eddastrohmayer251Stop with the conspiracy theories my guy
They are not conspiracy theories, it's what your citizens have been saying out loud in media!!
@@Sam_Guevenne their not conspiracies when their plain as daylight 3 generations of kids are eventually going to be in those seats what are the boomers going to do when they arent around anymore.
Biased much?????
The US news barely covers any of this. WTH?
They ignore the non voter, who is opposed to both political parties.
They can't report it more often or the people would turn on all the leaders sooner than it looks like they will, again.
Also, happy, I'm not buying the "you aren't a Chinese spy" routine.
First and last time I watch DW news. But I'll help these struggling 'journos' answer one of their many deliberately dumb questions 1st.
Q: What's preventing aide from entering Gaza?
A: Israel.
Hermers members worried about their future. They wish they played camel racing on 10/ 7.
Peace & LOVE Upon ONE & ALL
shame on Egypt’s silence
Firstly shame on Germany and its support of the Israeli crimes.
First shame on Israel and Hamas, both for their cruelty. Second on USA and Germany for their Support !
Egypt is not silent. But you obviously want war between Egypt and Israel... and sorry, but that's nothing else but crazy thinking !
Shame Sisi, not Egypt; majority of Egyptians are pro-Palestine with an unpopular dictator at the helm.
@@eddastrohmayer251 IfYour land is gradually occupied your house demolished your son arrested at dead of night will you remain silent and blame fate? Don’t point finger at Palestinian resistance Hamas
Egypt finally standing up and saying no more 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Egypt lackluster army couldn't afford a war with Israel.
Their economy barely sustaina itself without IMF support.
Egypt bravery is a political ploy to sustain its US aid.
Israel will support Ethiopia to take out Egypt so they better be careful.
They didnt have cooperation either
They had it if not Egypt would fighting like Lebanon
@@ranchgreen2497
They decide to be passive,I do believe 3 quarter of hamas fighting resources pass through Rafa border via underground tunnel
Salute to Egypt No to Genocide 🗣️🗣️🗣️‼️‼️
i think its unlikely 😮😮 maybe its just a game to not escalate
She is pure evil she doesn’t know what she is talking about
Where jared canal is going😮
Firstly shame on Hamas and Israel, both for their political standings and their cruelty ! Secondly shame on USA and Germany for their negative role in this genocide and severe threat to regional peace!
Blinken was stating that the Israelis need a plan for the “day after”. I wonder which one of the U.S. models-Iraq, Libya or Afghanistan-Israel would regard as the model best suited for them. 😂
You seem to be making the case that you aren't trying to make. The US made horrible missteps in Iraq and Afghanistan, and repeating that is probably not the best idea.
Why will Israel be concerned? End of the day it will be all funded by American taxpayer anyway.
jordan, qatar, and the UAE took part in the libyan campaign, which was nato-led and brought through the UNSC with no veto votes. But sure, just pretend it was america alone
@@Bob-ly4dy I’m making the case that the U.S. is in no position to be acting sanctimonious.
This time you have crossed the red line. There’s a new model incoming for your nation. Bad luck.
DW, Yall should be ashamed of yourselves
The DW Analyst have been stammering and avoiding the thorny issue of why Aid is not entering the Gaza strip.
Germany as a whole has done that.
@@sabinehahn9774
Moral bankruptcy of a nation
they are entering more than a 100 trucks a day
Sort of odd, isn't it. Egypt has done nothing to help their Palestinian neighbors.
Egypt doesn't offer security to the Israel, so it doesn't affect Israel's security but politically
Well, considering all the arms that came across the Egyptian border I'd say the security agreement wasn't doing anything.
The Independence Day movie was about mankind against aliens. In the real world it's mankind against Israel.
This didn’t age well.
Poor journalism. Not objective
To the Egypt government, too little too late...
2024(Gregorian) “Respect and dignity.” Furthermore:
IMO Israel has to be sure that the crossing are secure.
Ask Egypt getting Gaza for free. Not
Shammed on Egypt.. shammed..
The Egyptians took $5000 for each Gazan who wanted to get out of Gaza. Over 80 thousand people escaped through this crossing. That's over 400 million dollars. Egypt doesn't want its cash flow to stop.
Also makes you contemplate their intentions, when their response to Israel securing the border crossing is halting all humanitarian aid's entry to the Strip. Do they protest Israel's actions by starving the Gazan population?
u live in a bubble...
@@KeinKommentar-je8yq Do elaborate
Take sinai back😊
Egipt ???????
Israel can get to the Suez canal in matter of days, Egypt knows that
No
Ouch ! Israelies are asking for more.
As Egyptian we are beyond prepared for Israel and all our hearts r filled with the images of Palestinians dead children.. they all will be avenged...
Sounds pretty much what is expected. "Avenged".....
Khamas khamas Khamas
So predictable
Please ask her to say Harry
Kkhhaarryy
@@ceekay5267 I knew it!
After the war Palestineans need to rebuild Gaza and Rafah they should have enough aid from neibouring countries
Free 🇵🇸
A little too late
Why would you send Aden to terrorist?
SISI working Netanyahu
Long overdue.
❤
She’s a liar
Are the sons of David, Goliath now?
Were I concerned with who I might offend or how, I'd be lying.
Instead, I choose to lie in front of the fence you are erecting.
So you don’t think our border should be secure ? While I believe immigrantion is necessary it must be done in a controlled way as it had done by every other admin in the past. Biden has literally opened the border to 5,000 plus every single day for over 3 years. You will see when we are witnessing the next sept 11 or our kids can no longer find jobs. Go live in Gaza if you like anarchy. Dems…you make zero sense
Was there security? How did all those weapons get into Gaza.
Both, Egypt and Israel, have closed their eyes for many years! Egypt in order to "help" Palestinians, Israel to foster Hamas in order to weaken Palestinian Authority and to can blame afterwards whole of Palestinians for their "militancy". The whole issue is full of hypocrysy!
The weapons are manufactured by Palestinians in Gaza. There are *many* master and journeyman level gunsmiths there, as well as some talented weapons designers. It's a genuine industry.
The Israeli government seems very reluctant to mention this important fact, despite knowing about it. That fact doesn't give them the excuse they need to shoot missiles at and drop bombs on a million civilians, but their new Rafah fairy tale does. It also puts Egypt diplomatically on the back foot and gives an excuse as to why Israel has YET AGAIN violated another sovereign nation's territory.
It also allows them to invoke the bogeyman Iran, but in a way that doesn't make Palestinians look resourceful, competent, and talented. The smuggling of raw materials, tools, and machines IS the actual truth.
Not watching this ‘expert’
when she said Khamas.....we all knew who she works for and which lies she was going yo spew. This woman is an ex-IDF soldier.....not an independent expert!
What does Khamas mean ?
@@eddastrohmayer251 Violence
Ukrayna gibi filistin ve hamasa da dünyadan silah yardımı gelse israilin sonunu düşünemiyorum
They could have dug their own tunnel from their own land along the border of Gaza and Egypt decades ago and stopped the flow of weapons… if they wanted to.
It was over once she said Khamas
"Egypt's substantial army"...what a bad joke on Muhammad.
The brave Egyptians are coming in force wearing robes 😂😂
They can get it too if they want some