Diff size speakers for diff markets really tho. Sure I could get the Eds on my desk next to the PC screen but then I could also a set of floor standers. I mean the AE HD3 are designed for that specific scenario primarily and listening to moderate volumes only at nearfield distances, circa (2-3ft) . Hence the volume control and headphone socket access etc. the Eds are active bookshelf speakers and will always sound better with those bigger drivers and cases. Irrespective of sound its a David and Goliath match here (not saying which is with) maybe in costs alone then !
Also the Eds are better placed to the microphone than the HD3. He should have used the DS1 stand for the HD3 speakers. Also the HD3 have two bass settings, one for more bass, and one for more clear voice.
Need help please, Very confused between Swan M200mkiii Audio engine a2+ Audio engine HD 3 Q acoustics BT3 They're all similarly priced in my country. I'm looking for clarity especially in the vocals, bass doesn't need to be too strong to rattle my bones. Any help please?
@@rdolle990 To be fair to my comment, I was previously listening to the video off my phone with a single earbud in ;-) but I did notice the guitar difference on that track. Now that I'm at home, the AudioEngine's do sound hollow on most of the tracks. I love the size of the AE's, it's what I need for my desk but those Edifier's sound much better. Any idea's for something the AE size but sounds good?
@@pauld4238 iLoud MTM. That's the one I'm wishing to get. Compact and even better than anything at the price especially when using ARC to calibrate for the room acoustics.
@@pauld4238 Get a bigger desk :) Like Vlad is mentioning, iLoud MTM or iLoud Micro perhaps. I think the AE's are highly overpriced for what they deliver.
I am unable to decide if I want to use my Edifier R1700BT or my Logitech G560 in the living room, I want the better sound, I am also using an extern sound card called Sound Blaster X3. Which speaker do you guys recommend ?
Depends on the use. JBL has no optical, coax or Bluetooth connections. Also no tone control, DSP, remote or different EQ's. I believe this model JBL is designed to be a near field monitor which means you have to sit up front of them to receive the sound as it's meant to be. S2000MKIII can be used at further distance , has all the connectivity, DSP, remote and sound great with a lot of detail and clarity. I believe the JBL has a small hiss when no music is playing.
After watching and reading so many reviews about R1700BT I finally bought a pair for $85 (used for 4 months). Seriously the boomy bass is really too much for my ears, have to use equalizer apps on both laptop and phone to get rid of those annoying boomy bass...
![[Show and Tell] Small but mighty Audioengine a2+](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AUqSYJnjH5A/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#2024MAMA] ROSÉ (로제), Bruno Mars - APT. | Mnet 241122 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dgGqD28J6aQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Buy me a coffe: www.buymeacoffee.com/dsaudio.review
Instagram - instagram.com/digitalstereophony/
Facebook - facebook.com/DigitalStereophony/
Happy owner of this particular Edifier model! Its fun watching a head to head comparison to another set of speakers listening through them! :P
Diff size speakers for diff markets really tho. Sure I could get the Eds on my desk next to the PC screen but then I could also a set of floor standers. I mean the AE HD3 are designed for that specific scenario primarily and listening to moderate volumes only at nearfield distances, circa (2-3ft) . Hence the volume control and headphone socket access etc. the Eds are active bookshelf speakers and will always sound better with those bigger drivers and cases. Irrespective of sound its a David and Goliath match here (not saying which is with) maybe in costs alone then !
Also the Eds are better placed to the microphone than the HD3. He should have used the DS1 stand for the HD3 speakers. Also the HD3 have two bass settings, one for more bass, and one for more clear voice.
for me the audioengines, more natural sound
Despite the harsh treble, I would choose the 1700 over the boxy and near death sounding HD3 at over twice the money....
Need help please,
Very confused between
Swan M200mkiii
Audio engine a2+
Audio engine HD 3
Q acoustics BT3
They're all similarly priced in my country.
I'm looking for clarity especially in the vocals, bass doesn't need to be too strong to rattle my bones. Any help please?
Audioengine hd3 amazing
Would love to see Klipsch THE FIVES vs AUDIOENGINE HD6. Would be epic I think
love you guy. waiting for KH120 and shape twin
The difference on the Man On Fire track was very noticeable in the guitars. The AudioEngine sounded muddy. Otherwise they sound really similar.
Similar? Not at all!
@@rdolle990 To be fair to my comment, I was previously listening to the video off my phone with a single earbud in ;-) but I did notice the guitar difference on that track. Now that I'm at home, the AudioEngine's do sound hollow on most of the tracks. I love the size of the AE's, it's what I need for my desk but those Edifier's sound much better. Any idea's for something the AE size but sounds good?
@@pauld4238 iLoud MTM. That's the one I'm wishing to get. Compact and even better than anything at the price especially when using ARC to calibrate for the room acoustics.
@@pauld4238 Get a bigger desk :) Like Vlad is mentioning, iLoud MTM or iLoud Micro perhaps. I think the AE's are highly overpriced for what they deliver.
However, the HD3's drum sound is sometimes distorted
Did you test already R1600TIII?
Simply awesome....
Kindly review sonodyne DNM Norge soundking torvind speaker amps also
I am unable to decide if I want to use my Edifier R1700BT or my Logitech G560 in the living room, I want the better sound, I am also using an extern sound card called Sound Blaster X3. Which speaker do you guys recommend ?
Absolutely no "air" on the Audioengine's along with the nonexistence of bass...
Edifier R1700BT THE BEST.
what's the name of the music at Deep? I can't Shazam.
Bit More base then hd3 and high are tad bit harsh in 1700 bt.
Prefiero audioengine. Me suena mas limpio.
Por el precio es mejor Edifier
Hi bro! Edifier S2000MKIII vs JBL 305MKII?
Depends on the use. JBL has no optical, coax or Bluetooth connections. Also no tone control, DSP, remote or different EQ's. I believe this model JBL is designed to be a near field monitor which means you have to sit up front of them to receive the sound as it's meant to be. S2000MKIII can be used at further distance , has all the connectivity, DSP, remote and sound great with a lot of detail and clarity. I believe the JBL has a small hiss when no music is playing.
After watching and reading so many reviews about R1700BT I finally bought a pair for $85 (used for 4 months). Seriously the boomy bass is really too much for my ears, have to use equalizer apps on both laptop and phone to get rid of those annoying boomy bass...
I prefer the Audio engine sound. The Edifier is ok, but the bass is a bit boomy. The masses will of course reason bigger bass = better sound.
hd3 sound boxy. 1700 for the win
Edifier Way Better and less expensive.
Audioengine has boxy sound
1700 is better
I think 1700 wins in motion and HD3 wins in restore
Audioengine win!
HD3 is more compressed through the board. Neither has any bass
DEEP, the audioengine HD3 are dead
Эдифайр лучше
Neither represent the original