@@QuranTalk Thank you for your videos. Although Im not a quranist, Your videos have changed so much of my life for the better. May God bless you accordingly.
Please make a video about naafi the mawla of ibn umar and ikrama and aamish.. just read their bio and their age of birth and death do not overlap with following narrators....
Very good video brother...I notice that the Tafseer that speaks about the creation and the whale nun is also from an ancient Egyptian fable which they used to tell their religious followers. Then to see it included in Christianity and then Sunni Islam is definitely NOT. A coincidence. Paganism is always working behind the scenes to mislead mankind just as Shaytaan promises in the Qur'an.
More evidence of the first hadith narraration being a lie according to the Qur'an. When Jibreel came down and the Prophet saw him in the horizon descending: 53:9 - And was at a distance of two bow lengths or nearer. This implies Jibreel never squeezed and frightened the Prophet. He was simply in front of him speaking/delivering inspiration.
That surah has nothing to do with the first revelation, it was at miraaj. You literally proved why we need hadith to understand the tafsir of the Quran
@WaqasAli-ct7ly you obviously don't read the Qur'an. Read the first 15-20 ayat of Surah Najm. It says he also saw Jibreel another time in the heavens. If anything that would be Miraaj. The 2nd time.
@cardndmch you don’t know what you’re talking about. Less than 2% of all Hadiths explain verses of the Quran. And let’s not talk about bad science from Hadith
@@helpmeplz5525 no, are you saying Hadith teaches how to pray? Let’s see, bring 1 Sahih Hadith that explains the full salat from A-Z. Let’s see if you’re right
There are so many prophet sent by ALLAH not all are mentioned may be caedmon was a prophet before Muhammad similarities does not prove that Hadith is just copied although it's right that all Hadith is not correct
First of all it's not Alla , it's Allah .Ah at the end please I am sure you can work on it if you are not AI generated. There were no Hadiths for at least first 150 years following the death of the prophet (pbuh). 'We have made the Quran easy for you to understand'.
But the question is Why did it take over one hundred thirty years to have the biography of a powerful man to be written They had political power,money,learned men and all the good will.shy didn't the swahabas care to get it written.tbe ummayads .some thing wrong. Then the likely story appears fishy You are honest man. Muslims keep telling us of isnad but who created it? We have a problem. I have asked any Muslim to show me a verse which says an angel appeared to Mohamed by then Quthum bin Abdullah and told him to recite. Non.
Thats not true either, Abu Hurayrah and Abdullah ibn Amr and Ali ibn Ali Talib wrote the hadiths down while the Prophet SAW was alive, and the students of the companions also wrote it down
@ Let me rephrase it. Verbal statements attributed to the prophet ( pbuh) were compiled 150 years later in the court of the ruling leader for their own political agenda. Yes Bokhari and others were on the payroll of these rulers. Of course more or less 70% Hadiths were written by Abu Huraira . Only Allah knows what he heard and others who quoted him later on. I don’t know much about Ali (ra) Hadith collection but I do know Abu Bakr wrote 33 or so and then he stopped it . I guess he was the wisest of them all. Bottom line is as along as the Hadith is in the light of the Quran it will be scrutinized. Unless you are telling me that Allah revealed something to the Prophet (pbuh) outside of the Quran. Allah knows best.
@@WaqasAli-ct7ly We don’t have a problem with you choosing to obey Abu Hurayrah or Abdullah Ibn Amir along with Allah, that’s between you and Allah. But we have a problem with you not being honest with yourself and trying to say things about Allah that aren’t true. We were created by the same Creator, if you fail to recognize the Creator someone else will not, that’s the beauty of diversity.
It won't look anything remotely like the known ways of reading salaat. So you will conclude that it is wrong. Because your way is right. This is a really bad argument to be honest.
@Monavah you have no idea what you're talking about. Salaat has largely been the same for 1400 years based on these hadith which layout exactly how to read it. Read a book.
Brilliant presentation. Your efforts will speak for you on the day of judgement God willing.
brother always put sources in the descriptions thats more professional
God bless you
Peace - the link to the article with the sources is always in the description
@@QuranTalk Thank you for your videos. Although Im not a quranist, Your videos have changed so much of my life for the better. May God bless you accordingly.
Please make a video about naafi the mawla of ibn umar and ikrama and aamish.. just read their bio and their age of birth and death do not overlap with following narrators....
Good work brother mashallah. If you want sahi hadith, you should go to the actual source that is in fiq e jafferi.
Very good video brother...I notice that the Tafseer that speaks about the creation and the whale nun is also from an ancient Egyptian fable which they used to tell their religious followers. Then to see it included in Christianity and then Sunni Islam is definitely NOT. A coincidence.
Paganism is always working behind the scenes to mislead mankind just as Shaytaan promises in the Qur'an.
Bible doesn't have that story of whales
More evidence of the first hadith narraration being a lie according to the Qur'an. When Jibreel came down and the Prophet saw him in the horizon descending:
53:9 - And was at a distance of two bow lengths or nearer.
This implies Jibreel never squeezed and frightened the Prophet. He was simply in front of him speaking/delivering inspiration.
That surah has nothing to do with the first revelation, it was at miraaj. You literally proved why we need hadith to understand the tafsir of the Quran
@WaqasAli-ct7ly you obviously don't read the Qur'an. Read the first 15-20 ayat of Surah Najm. It says he also saw Jibreel another time in the heavens. If anything that would be Miraaj. The 2nd time.
This is pure GEM!
Praise God.
Do you think the original Cadimun story itself may even be copied or influenced from the Vedas?
Hadith fails again and again
@cardndmch😅😅so
According to u emeritus : God needs help from bukhareye and abuhoor???? Etc…etc…???
@cardndmch yes I know Arabic now what? Your scholars know Arabic, yet they don’t know Quran 😂😂👍
Does the Quraan teach you how to pray?
@cardndmch you don’t know what you’re talking about. Less than 2% of all Hadiths explain verses of the Quran. And let’s not talk about bad science from Hadith
@@helpmeplz5525 no, are you saying Hadith teaches how to pray? Let’s see, bring 1 Sahih Hadith that explains the full salat from A-Z. Let’s see if you’re right
مصادر جيدة...
Praise God!!
There are so many prophet sent by ALLAH not all are mentioned may be caedmon was a prophet before Muhammad similarities does not prove that Hadith is just copied although it's right that all Hadith is not correct
With respect, "hymn" is pronounced "him"
Salam
First of all it's not Alla , it's Allah .Ah at the end please I am sure you can work on it if you are not AI generated. There were no Hadiths for at least first 150 years following the death of the prophet (pbuh). 'We have made the Quran easy for you to understand'.
But the question is
Why did it take over one hundred thirty years to have the biography of a powerful man to be written They had political power,money,learned men and all the good will.shy didn't the swahabas care to get it written.tbe ummayads .some thing wrong.
Then the likely story appears fishy
You are honest man.
Muslims keep telling us of isnad but who created it?
We have a problem.
I have asked any Muslim to show me a verse which says an angel appeared to Mohamed by then Quthum bin Abdullah and told him to recite.
Non.
He said Allah
Thats not true either, Abu Hurayrah and Abdullah ibn Amr and Ali ibn Ali Talib wrote the hadiths down while the Prophet SAW was alive, and the students of the companions also wrote it down
@ Let me rephrase it. Verbal statements attributed to the prophet ( pbuh) were compiled 150 years later in the court of the ruling leader for their own political agenda. Yes Bokhari and others were on the payroll of these rulers. Of course more or less 70% Hadiths were written by Abu Huraira . Only Allah knows what he heard and others who quoted him later on. I don’t know much about Ali (ra) Hadith collection but I do know Abu Bakr wrote 33 or so and then he stopped it . I guess he was the wisest of them all. Bottom line is as along as the Hadith is in the light of the Quran it will be scrutinized. Unless you are telling me that Allah revealed something to the Prophet (pbuh) outside of the Quran. Allah knows best.
@@WaqasAli-ct7ly We don’t have a problem with you choosing to obey Abu Hurayrah or Abdullah Ibn Amir along with Allah, that’s between you and Allah. But we have a problem with you not being honest with yourself and trying to say things about Allah that aren’t true. We were created by the same Creator, if you fail to recognize the Creator someone else will not, that’s the beauty of diversity.
Try reading Salaat without looking at hadith. Good luck.
It won't look anything remotely like the known ways of reading salaat.
So you will conclude that it is wrong.
Because your way is right.
This is a really bad argument to be honest.
@Monavah you have no idea what you're talking about. Salaat has largely been the same for 1400 years based on these hadith which layout exactly how to read it. Read a book.
this is begging the question
Please give reference of hadith showing how to pray salat from start to finish.
Try reading Salat looking at Hadith. Good luck. You know why, coz there's no single Hadith that details the ritual gymnastics that you guys do.