Russia is vast and diverse. Even in the very far east the last patches of true wilderness are threatened by pollution and environmental impacts. When our crew was out in the wild filming the last Siberian tigers, it became quite clear that hunting & poaching is not their main threat anymore.
@@miles-thesleeper-monroe8466 in Russia there's no such thing like election, there are only ordinary people and bandits which took power, hire police and army, and pursue anyone who is against
"Sometimes he treats himself to clean drinking water" ... let that sink in...clean water is to him what expensive vacation is to western middle class....unbelievable that this regime still hangs on to power.
just think of what Russia could have been and can be in the future if it was actually governed responsibly. That country has more land and resources then the entire eu combined but its a relatively poor shithole in comparison.
@@moniranik5674 I mean ye before they did, but now its really just Russian leaders themselves doing it to be fair. Like in the colonial times britain tended to side against anyone who got to powerful on the continent and ally with everyone else, they then stopped when Russia got beat by Japan and britain got more scared of Germany. And then it fired back up in soviet times, but now a days Russia could easily cooperate with the west if it wanted to just look at china you don't have to be best friends to not leave your own country in decline economically. So Russia doesn't even have to properly conform to western ideals if it would just focus on its economy instead of fighting its neighbours and having no value added industry, the only thing Russia does nowadays is dig stuff out of the ground which if they use it themselves it literally loses value, Russia is so terribly inefficient right now that if it used its own oil and gas to try and make value added products it would be better to not even take it out of the ground.
@@moniranik5674 yes... it’s the west’s fault... (face palm) and how long did you wipe your ass with your hand before someone told you, you can use paper?
You are not offensive, Russia after the collapse of the USSR is full of abandoned buildings and factories, outside the big cities, it is full of these buildings, in fact if you look for abandoned buildings here on youtube, many results will show you Russian scenarios.
You have to understand how big the USSR was, there's a reason why the west didn't go fight the east and only ended up with a Cold War. When something that massive collapses, the ruins left are also massive.
Factory owners, greedy oligarchs don't live in Russia. Oligarchs live in countries with warm climates and sail on their mega-yachts, they are not interested in environmental pollution problems. Moreover, investments in the modernization of factories are losses, and losses need to be reduced. The proceeds from the sale of resources are invested in the purchase of estates in England, villas in Spain and penthouses in California.
It seems counterintuitive not to make investments in modernization of factories because upgrades can improve the efficiency of the work being done and replacing people with automated machines has been on the rise to reduce costs. If anything, making investments to modernize factories and similar industries is actually good for cutting costs in the long run because you have less employees to pay and only have to worry about maintenance and utilities expenses. Please explain what you mean because I don't understand.
Oligarchs don’t have the long term mind. They think short term, flashy, coke and hot broads are what gives you life. and don’t forget the gold chain. they couldn’t give two shits about the people they hurt. which is why they don’t live in Russia. they’d be killed.
And yet Russia allows it. I dont see what your trying to get at here. Russia doesn't give a shit either. It's up to them to regulate it. They make a fuck tons of money off of it to. Stop trying to place the blame on other countries when it's Russia incompetence that's the problem.
Our sons struggled with lung problems. We moved from St.Petersburg to the middle of EU. Not suddenly, but in 2 years they almost fully recovered.. If you think that ecological situation in Moscow and SBb is better- bad news for you.... The air is so polluted- if you put on an white jacket in the morning - it will turn to grey to the end of the day
The best thing you could do for your family was to move to another country. Your home country's leaders failed you as they're doing to others still in Russia. I wish you and your family good health, wealth and much happiness.
And Volgorod and the city near the Black sea Forgot it's name... And Vladivostok is okey-ish and the Moscow and St.Peterburg metropolitan, but the rest is garbage.
@@SamsRussianAdventures Idk... I live in the EU and I was driving from Berlin to St.Petersburg and when I entered Russia the roads were horrific some towns only had muddy roads the homes looked like they are about to collapse and the soviet apartments hadn't seen any maintenance in decades. Although the prices are EXTREMELY low. Only the St.Petersburg metropolitan felt more European, although even there I found some problems.
I am from Kuzbass, I has been growing up there for 20 years. However, I am living now in Saint-Petersburg. Although, I remember the time, when my grandfather was living in Prokopievsk, situated near Kiselevsk. It was happy time from childhood, nonetheless, there were myriads of dust from coals on the cars and windows, mining in that region. My grandpa kicked the bucket in 2005 from cancer in his lungs.
Well done DW awareness is key to even starting to help with these environmental issues regardless of where in the world they are. By exposing the various problems to other people & places & Highlighting where & what the issues are hopefully this will show some of the agencies meant to be in command just how inept they actually are when it comes to the environment.
@Chishio Chishio No country is innocent of crimes against Nature so what is your point? Even in New Zealand where i live we come across as clean & green scratch the surface & the reality is quite different. Everyone could & should be doing even the most minimal to help with environmental destruction just using a car is adding to the problem but nobody is going to give up their ride any time soon for the sake of air clarity. I don't own a vehicle i walk or use public transport i recycle & reuse to the point where people think i am hoarding rubbish. Germany is no different to any other country but i applaud DW for making this film what are you going to do to help other than fire out questions without offering any solutions?
The irony of the governor calling them traitors to their hometown is just shocking. The people are trying to save their town and the people that live there from total environmental destruction and sickness. I hope the best for the people of Kuzbass.
When the Governors family start dying from pollution related illnesses then he will realize. But assholes like him are many in all of the former Soviet states.
It's a no win situation. The people want to live in a clean, healthy environment and ask the government for help. The government ignores them, but then labels them as traitors when they move to a country with a clean, healthy environment.
@Drone Strike when you're willing to so quickly turn something into a political battle rather than work problem, that's why nothing ever gets done. Democrat, Republican, they don't care about you. Both parties are bought and paid for by the same people, if you don't understand that, you really are clueless. Being against private corporations was never even a republican ideal, so that fact that now people think that they are Republicans when they are against private corporations is hilarious. Doesn't even matter though, corporations are the ones that Lobby, so unless you actually spend your own lobbying dollars which you obviously don't, you're not going to get any of your own wishes done. You newbies don't even know Republican ideas and you completely dilute the party
Russia isn't really developed as you can clearly see in the video. They rely on soviet era machines which are obviously not working as intended... Their whole infrastructure is outdated and the government isn't even concerned.
Just move to Dzerzhinsk if you’re tired of living and don’t want to end it all by your own hands 😎 Life expectancy is 42 years for men and women get 5 more to a whopping 47! That’s the same as the 1200s where the black death killed half of Europe 👍
And guess what... You can't drink tap water even in Moscow or St. Petersburg. Also I remember Sochi during 2014 Winter Games, where all tap water came out brown.
@@2girls1cup36 the Russians in the video had Apple devices so no and also they don't seem to care. I know people from Russia they don't care about the enviorment at all
Because we are not afraid of our governments we would rise up if we had to put up with that. Rise up and tell your government that you want change. If you don’t then It’s your own fault.
Remember when they had the Olympics in Sochi and none of the hotels or brand new buildings had drinkable tap water?? How the hell did they expect to impress foreigners like that?
Afterwards: both drinking vodka. At least politicians ;) Within all fairness, DW is becoming more biased than BBC - and you have to watch something, so...
everything will be fine. look, I live in Russia and you can say anything you want about Putin, or bad conditions you're living in. red line is antigovernment activities. c'mon, folks, we don't have censorship, all major internet resources are available (atleast for now xD) and you can protest and demand stuff. sometimes this even works =) we're not China.
@@tearforall You can't help people who have been brainwashed by Western propaganda, they still think that people in Russia ride bears and drink vodka all day.
@@TheSecerko Well, DW will not make a film about the Polish coal areas and cities and what the winter air is like there.And this is a member of the European Union!Krakow,Poznan and so on still use coal as fuel in the cities!
@@frankrenda2519 I am not saying you don't. However Russia is mainly Moscow and St-Petersburg. Outside of these 2 cities Russia is literally dead with nothing to show for.
@@chriskelleher349 Actualy America is worse than Russia in some ways. But Russia is worse in some ways. But America is worse in some ways. But Russia is oe
It's always said that Russia is the largest country in the world. I'm curious how much of it is actually habitable. Between nuclear disasters and waste problems making land unusable, it has to knock off a lot of the country's size.
Come on now DW, you are so on point most of the time, why then is Crimea dark grey coloured like Russia on the map and not light grey like Ukraine? What's that about?
I'm not going to demonize Russia as an American we definitely need to work harder at the environment. I hope they are ok and don't suffer from any environmental damage.
I had to do a 15 page essay on plastic pollution and Russia was one of the worst countries and America was one of the better countries for management of plastic. Which I was honestly surprised I thought America would be the worst but it wasn’t!
Nah, buying another set of gold claded toiled brushes made in Italy for the yougest mistress is clearly more important than those useless particle separators.
I am Canadian over 50 yrs. Even here land fill dumps are even closer to residential homes in some areas and the smell of methane is strong so we are not perfect either. This story makes me sad because I love Russia and its people. They are strong and smart people and I hope they rise above this
Interesting that the map shows the Crimean peninsula as crosshatched. I realize Russia sees it as theirs, but the Ukraine, the United Nations, and most other countries agree it belongs to the Ukraine, despite Russian occupation.
Yes, in particular Germany talking about sanctions meanwhile constructing Nord Stream 2. Biggest hypocrite pro-Russian CDU. DW bowing to Russia with Crimea crosshatched. Sorry but that's how it really is. Disgrace
Crimea belonged to Soviet Russia till 1954, when Khruschev transferred it to Ukraine as a gift to a friendly soviet republic. The latter became -NATO-sided country. No friendship, no Crimea. Once big brother presented it than took it away. Russia is too powerful and mighty even with all its weaknesses and you know this owing to Stalingrad. As for the UN, you probably mean western countries and former soviet satellites which became anti-Russian to the extent of animal hatred. The rest of the world hardly ever interfere with Russian internal affairs and claims its sovereignty over Crimea.
@@vicdor1031 yeah, gift… Let’s also recall that, before, Crimea didn’t have any adequate access to fresh water, therefore after the transfer to Ukraine, Crimean canal was built to bring Dnipro’s water to desalinate soils and to develop the region. And for years it was presented as “gracious” gift to Ukraine, although, now we can see that Ukraine can exist without Crimea, but it is a matter of time how long Crimea will last without Ukrainian water resources.
@@jackvermont88 if Crimea lasted for thousands and thousands years before the canal was built so, then where do you see any problem? Crimea after all is not a desert and even now during summer time water supply is though sometimes restricted but stable.
@@vicdor1031 of course, but let’s not forget the fact that population of the peninsula one thousand years ago and now is different, as well as infrastructure and agriculture development. You can say it will last for years, but I would rather say it will deteriorate to what it was before. As water demand is critical, people already started to complain of water shortages and realize the 2014 consequences.
Residents of Kuban and Krimea already feel a lack of water. Water in the South of Russia has been disappearing for a long time. Add here intensive agroculture, increasing number of newlycomers and tourists and you get a black future for those parts of Russia. It's gonna become a desert.
@@OscarMariadella Yeah for Crimea that is true. But he is also right. Southern Russia, and the region as a whole, have been having water shortages. Even the Dnepr river that feeds Crimea (when under Ukraine control) is seeing less water. With Russia's expanding agriculture sector due to sanctions, the Aral sea catastrophe may well, in some ways, repeat itself.
@@bigounce1292 Maybe i know a little more than you. I am from Russia, but most of information that i consume is in English. And it is 90% lies when they talk about Russia.
I noticed this same culture in all of the former Soviet states. It doesn't matter if it's Slavic, Turkic or Circassian. They all have certain people who once they achieve certain levels of wealth .They begin to behave like they are Feudal Lord's. They become entitled and apathetic to their fellow community members. All it's takes is for them to get a little money and they in exchange screw over their fellows. They want to drive the latest Mercedes, wear Gucci and use iPhones. Corruption is ingrained in many of these former Soviet states.
@@grimgoreironhide9985 problem is that most people who actually care and want to make a difference, not just profit, leave coz they know they can do nothing, nothing changes and thus cycle continues
6:45: so this poor man's monthly pension is less than 90 dollars a month... 3rd world country. Oh well, Putin has just poisoned another dissident so it is time for us to start clapping. 🤣
it is said that he has to spend 75$ a month on water that is almost 1/3 of his pension. So his pension is around 225-250$. On pension in Russia you also get free transport card within the region of living and some subsidies for medicine. But anyway that's not too much.
wtf haven't you ever heard about lots of russian great scientists, poets and even war figures who were an order of magnitude better than other people , but who have been oppressed by these system, eh?
@@gabarite_0.5 Fake Western propaganda. There was a brief period before WW2 like that. Just like United Snakes had slavery and Democratic party supported it (slavery).
I'm sorry but it sounds like to me these people need to stop waiting on the Government to solve their problems. But it pretty obvious that complaining isn't going to fix the problem. Build your own large settling tanks and charcoal filters for the water. Do something. The Government is not the answer.
Individual action plans for reducing impacts that cause said environmental issues: 1. Take responsibility for your own garbage, for example doing 3R or zero waste 2. Rely less on industrial/manufactured products
I heard someone say once, and it made perfect sense, about people in Soviet bloc countries. Soviet people are absolutely awesome people, ruled over by some epic assholes.
Not so black and white, many of these awesome people will vote for Putin next time and blame west for all their problems, because TV state propaganda said so. This reality i’m living.
The main problem with Russia is our NIMBY mentality. We want change, but "you do it first and I will follow, maybe". Also Soviet leftovers in older generations of entrusting everything to the government without holding it accountable doesn't help either
I enjoy visiting Russia and the Russian people. However, the water problem isn't just outside big cities. In St. Petersburg, everyone boils the tap water before drinking due to critters in the water that will cause diarrhea. In Moscow, washing my white cotton clothes caused the fabric to turn sepia. Upon returning home (US), I tried re-washing then bleaching my whites but to no avail. How do Russians keep their white cotton clothes white when the water from the pipes are full of rust?!
I live in Moscow and just use regular washer and regular washing powder (without any whitening stuff), do not have any problems with whities. You can drink tap water and won't get sick but we boil it just to be safe. Though I would not recommend to drink tap water in Moscow since Moscow is a huge city and the water can not be as good as in small towns in the mountains :) However, rust water do may occur especially during short time after central water system was shut of and swittched on back again (if there were maintainance works for example), then the "first flow" is very rusty usually.
@@justinfilipovic8939 I don't know a single person who makes kvas by themselves. However, many people do drink it and during summer there are many street places to but it in addition to bottled kvas sold in grocery stores all year around
but then you won't be able to make DW Documentary :) Tap water is relatively clean, in the video they show it and say that there is problem with pressure. But that pressure is enough to fill it in for cooking. Having a shower or bath is a problem though.
Because capitalism is truly evil, it's all about exploiting workers and destroying environment. Earth of the future will have communism, just like in popular American TV show Star Trek.
@@Alec72HD The level of brainwashing your mind has been subjected to is beyond any rational belief, even among most hardcore Putin supporters in Russia... 😂🤣😁
People in post-Soviet countries have used to government acting like a parent, fairly providing them everything, free of charge. They weren't properly educated on their newly acquired political and financial rights and RESPONSIBILITIES of market economy and democracy. Many rural communities still don't have a proper government due to lack of contenders (no salary, part-time and only for locals) and thus unable to manage their problems or even officially request financial aid from federal budget.
Find one of the most polluted places in Russia and make a video about it and leaves the audience with an impression that the whole Russia is like that. Russian could’ve easily done the same by finding the most polluted areas or the most impoverished neighborhood in Germany and make a video about it and slap on a title like DW’s.
Regardless, of the bias you’re implying. You think this particular place is managed well? Does it look right to you? And DW doesn’t shy away from speaking about issues in Europe either by the way
It’s important to recognize the double standards at play with certain Washington-aligned environmental organizations. These groups often use environmental issues as a pretext for anti-Russian campaigns, turning legitimate environmental concerns into tools of political pressure and unfair competition. This approach not only hinders genuine global cooperation on environmental protection but also undermines trust and the chance for constructive dialogue on shared challenges.
You're a lier, the most air polutet Russian city is on the 35th position, even not close to China and India. Even the US's Los Angeles's or Korean Seoul's air quality is worse, than Russia's Krasnoyarsk, due to the international AQI index. India's Delhi is on the 11th position and its air is almost twice more unclean, than in the most poluted Russian city.
It’s so bad there no sensor on earth can truly measure how fucked up Delhi’s Air is. Moscow’s average yearly AQI is between 50 to 70. Delhi is a giant šhithole compared to Moscow. And also women do not get raped there.
Flint Michigan and many other places in the United States are still deprived of clean drinking water this is not a Russian problem this is a world problem
The title seems to suggest all of Russia has environmental issues, but the documentary only describes the experiences of a single town and provided no evidence to extrapolate to all of Russia. It's a shame DW is exaggerating. Side note, cigarettes in the mouths of those speaking about pollution issues doesn't really add up.
Yes, the irony of Germany complaining about the environment in another country. They've done their level best to change the environment of virtually every country in Europe and certainly their neighbours. That human and ecological disaster will probably take another 100 years to rectify.
![ค้างคืนโรงเก็บกระสวยอวกาศร้างกลางทะเลทราย [Around The World Ep. 3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/E5bWZQhABJE/mqdefault.jpg)
Russia is vast and diverse. Even in the very far east the last patches of true wilderness are threatened by pollution and environmental impacts. When our crew was out in the wild filming the last Siberian tigers, it became quite clear that hunting & poaching is not their main threat anymore.
Cool story bro
People like this goof up here treat it lika joke
@rutv wim you been to Russia?
@@FuckTheFedMayne that's our joke. We basically view Moscow and every thing else as separate countries
17 million People are at health risk due to garbage in Russia according to latest statistics..wake up
It's so sad to see such beautiful countries have such corrupt and lazy Governments.
Don't think they are lazy, I think they just don't care and are busy with clinging to power stuff
@@TheCHWDP They need their 2 billion dollar palaces...
Yeah they need to follow the German example and elect a leader that GETS THINGS DONE!
@@miles-thesleeper-monroe8466 elect?? Haha good one
@@miles-thesleeper-monroe8466 in Russia there's no such thing like election, there are only ordinary people and bandits which took power, hire police and army, and pursue anyone who is against
"Sometimes he treats himself to clean drinking water" ... let that sink in...clean water is to him what expensive vacation is to western middle class....unbelievable that this regime still hangs on to power.
Well, whoever has tried to go against Putin's regime is either dead or in prison.
@@argh6666
Well he's "standing up to the West" so all is forgiven i guess
It's the lining of Putin's pockets that is a slight to the Russian people
@Andy Mills he/she was being sarcastic I suppose...
@Andy Mills that's sarcasm.
just think of what Russia could have been and can be in the future if it was actually governed responsibly. That country has more land and resources then the entire eu combined but its a relatively poor shithole in comparison.
You are absolutely correct
russia has enormous potential, but western countries constantly trying to destroy that potential
@@moniranik5674 I mean ye before they did, but now its really just Russian leaders themselves doing it to be fair. Like in the colonial times britain tended to side against anyone who got to powerful on the continent and ally with everyone else, they then stopped when Russia got beat by Japan and britain got more scared of Germany. And then it fired back up in soviet times, but now a days Russia could easily cooperate with the west if it wanted to just look at china you don't have to be best friends to not leave your own country in decline economically. So Russia doesn't even have to properly conform to western ideals if it would just focus on its economy instead of fighting its neighbours and having no value added industry, the only thing Russia does nowadays is dig stuff out of the ground which if they use it themselves it literally loses value, Russia is so terribly inefficient right now that if it used its own oil and gas to try and make value added products it would be better to not even take it out of the ground.
@@moniranik5674 yes... it’s the west’s fault... (face palm) and how long did you wipe your ass with your hand before someone told you, you can use paper?
@cera ten you shut up nonsense..nonsense shouldn't comment..
I don't wanna sound rude but there's something about Russia that gives me a post Apocalyptic vibes😳😳😳
Its because its stuck in time almost..everything is rundown and falling apart.
You are not offensive, Russia after the collapse of the USSR is full of abandoned buildings and factories, outside the big cities, it is full of these buildings, in fact if you look for abandoned buildings here on youtube, many results will show you Russian scenarios.
That's also, because most people never leave the city ......if we look around the counties in north America haha it does not look much better
You have to understand how big the USSR was, there's a reason why the west didn't go fight the east and only ended up with a Cold War. When something that massive collapses, the ruins left are also massive.
Your media perhaps?
Factory owners, greedy oligarchs don't live in Russia. Oligarchs live in countries with warm climates and sail on their mega-yachts, they are not interested in environmental pollution problems. Moreover, investments in the modernization of factories are losses, and losses need to be reduced. The proceeds from the sale of resources are invested in the purchase of estates in England, villas in Spain and penthouses in California.
It seems counterintuitive not to make investments in modernization of factories because upgrades can improve the efficiency of the work being done and replacing people with automated machines has been on the rise to reduce costs. If anything, making investments to modernize factories and similar industries is actually good for cutting costs in the long run because you have less employees to pay and only have to worry about maintenance and utilities expenses. Please explain what you mean because I don't understand.
@@happykiwi It's a long term investment. Oligarchs don't think that way
No penthouses in Cali. Sheesh
Oligarchs don’t have the long term mind. They think short term, flashy, coke and hot broads are what gives you life. and don’t forget the gold chain. they couldn’t give two shits about the people they hurt. which is why they don’t live in Russia. they’d be killed.
And yet Russia allows it. I dont see what your trying to get at here. Russia doesn't give a shit either. It's up to them to regulate it. They make a fuck tons of money off of it to. Stop trying to place the blame on other countries when it's Russia incompetence that's the problem.
In mother Russia, environment solves you.
Vodka and Omon gonna fix everything
Hello
In corrupted Russia environment dissolves you.
Here, I fixed it for you.
@@智春夏木 Fax 😭🙌
Our sons struggled with lung problems. We moved from St.Petersburg to the middle of EU. Not suddenly, but in 2 years they almost fully recovered.. If you think that ecological situation in Moscow and SBb is better- bad news for you.... The air is so polluted- if you put on an white jacket in the morning - it will turn to grey to the end of the day
The best thing you could do for your family was to move to another country. Your home country's leaders failed you as they're doing to others still in Russia. I wish you and your family good health, wealth and much happiness.
God damn it’s true
Cheers from Siberia
Unfortunately, Russian Federation has much worse problems. I used to live in Russia, in Western Siberia.
@Hawk Watch If you live in a city, you don't know what clean air is
@Hawk Watch Nope. Most of America's air is polluted these days. If you live in a city then you are lieing to yourself.
@Hawk Watch america is also polluted? Don’t shove it in his face
@@anna-if8fi we just spray it over w a pretty bull shit lie lol
This is a problem that deserves more than 12 minutes. Please continue. Well done DW.
If You stay more than 12 mts in Russia you will die of victim of some violence.
This explains at least why there are so many alcoholics in Russia
they were all alcoholics before the first factory ever opened.
It's depressing
Alcoholism is the least problem of Russia!
This is Russia outside Moscow and St.Peterburg
And Volgorod and the city near the Black sea Forgot it's name...
And Vladivostok is okey-ish
and the Moscow and St.Peterburg metropolitan, but the rest is garbage.
@@Yassified3425 sochi i think u mean thats where putin does it dirty deals lol
C’mon. It’s not true. There are many other nice towns and cities outside of Moscow
@@SamsRussianAdventures Idk... I live in the EU and I was driving from Berlin to St.Petersburg and when I entered Russia the roads were horrific some towns only had muddy roads the homes looked like they are about to collapse and the soviet apartments hadn't seen any maintenance in decades.
Although the prices are EXTREMELY low. Only the St.Petersburg metropolitan felt more European, although even there I found some problems.
@@SamsRussianAdventures Watch the videos on "Bald and Bankrupt", you'll see the rest of Russia
I am from Kuzbass, I has been growing up there for 20 years. However, I am living now in Saint-Petersburg. Although, I remember the time, when my grandfather was living in Prokopievsk, situated near Kiselevsk. It was happy time from childhood, nonetheless, there were myriads of dust from coals on the cars and windows, mining in that region. My grandpa kicked the bucket in 2005 from cancer in his lungs.
how old was he?
Great share and sounds like great people your grandfather and family and you too mate;):) all ❤️
"society grows great when old men plant trees whose shade they know they shall never sit in"
who said that? wonderful
"Unless it goes against my greed and my own descendants' wealth."
@@dalegamburg8995 It is a Greek proverb!
Did you plant that tree?, if not, your words are worthless
@@algernonis69 character is what you show when no one’s watching.
Meanwhile Putin is installing an underground ice rink in his palace !
And two water discos... 😶😶
Yeh right
@@kabzaify Sure, absolutely right!
Disgusting man
Sure he is a hard working honest man jajajaja.
stopping the corruption is most likely the key to end such disaster
The nation is on its course of self-termination. They admire Putin and Putin does great progress on the job.
@@alexandersuvorov2002 then why hasn’t he fixed the pollution problems yet if is so “great”?
Stopping the corruption in Russia is equal to stopping it's existence as a country
that tells us how much Putin really cares for his people 😢
We knew it even 10 years ago. But... he simply rewrote constitution and stayed at power.
Then explain me why does more then 60% of russian citizens support putin?
@@pietnaalden4641 You really think elections are fair?
@@pietnaalden4641 tv zombies
And the western media call this gangster president Putin!
Love your documentaries, DW.
My comment on this love fest was deleted for some democratic reason?
That black snow looks just like when the Fire Nation attacked the Southern Water Tribe. #NeverForget
XD
@@thelightsilent what? Germany is bad for the enviorment actualy.
🤣🤣🤣 nice
Aboriginal nation live all over the world , clean environment and water and air and health
I really appreciate all documentaries from DW documentary. It is such an eye opener.
Hi @Alex Trafalgar, thank you for the positive feedback and for watching :)
Are you DW's mum?
@@DWDocumentary do i get a thanks for negative feedback? Or only people who agree with you?
@@DWDocumentary DW when will you stop being russophobic and neutral? it is natural for germans to hate Russia?
@@DWDocumentary Crimea is Ukrainian territory not Russian. Please use right maps
I have some friends from those regions who decided to come to Poland. Even today one of my students was talking about how tough life is there.
You ever lived with 6 months of -60?
plus everything around you is gray
In Poland you have to work in order to survive. Clever Poles are already in Germany or UK as work is less tough there ;)
Well done DW awareness is key to even starting to help with these environmental issues regardless of where in the world they are. By exposing the various problems to other people & places & Highlighting where & what the issues are hopefully this will show some of the agencies meant to be in command just how inept they actually are when it comes to the environment.
@Chishio Chishio No country is innocent of crimes against Nature so what is your point? Even in New Zealand where i live we come across as clean & green scratch the surface & the reality is quite different. Everyone could & should be doing even the most minimal to help with environmental destruction just using a car is adding to the problem but nobody is going to give up their ride any time soon for the sake of air clarity. I don't own a vehicle i walk or use public transport i recycle & reuse to the point where people think i am hoarding rubbish. Germany is no different to any other country but i applaud DW for making this film what are you going to do to help other than fire out questions without offering any solutions?
Now they are haha...coal can be used with minimal effects in upgraded plants.
@Chishio Chishio Im not sure what your point is, but those power plant's will all be closed by 2030
Infact 9 were closed last year.
@Chishio Chishio Since when is exporting garbage a problem?
We in Sweden buy that and burn it as cleanly as possible for energy to heat our nation.
no, this happens everywhere stop being so gullible
The irony of the governor calling them traitors to their hometown is just shocking. The people are trying to save their town and the people that live there from total environmental destruction and sickness. I hope the best for the people of Kuzbass.
When the Governors family start dying from pollution related illnesses then he will realize. But assholes like him are many in all of the former Soviet states.
It's a no win situation. The people want to live in a clean, healthy environment and ask the government for help. The government ignores them, but then labels them as traitors when they move to a country with a clean, healthy environment.
Slav means :"slave".
Russia will never change.
Russia's news piece on Flint's water:
@Drone Strike when you're willing to so quickly turn something into a political battle rather than work problem, that's why nothing ever gets done. Democrat, Republican, they don't care about you. Both parties are bought and paid for by the same people, if you don't understand that, you really are clueless.
Being against private corporations was never even a republican ideal, so that fact that now people think that they are Republicans when they are against private corporations is hilarious. Doesn't even matter though, corporations are the ones that Lobby, so unless you actually spend your own lobbying dollars which you obviously don't, you're not going to get any of your own wishes done.
You newbies don't even know Republican ideas and you completely dilute the party
Couldn't believe that a developed country like Russia would have such problems. What to expect in third world country
Russia isn't really developed as you can clearly see in the video. They rely on soviet era machines which are obviously not working as intended...
Their whole infrastructure is outdated and the government isn't even concerned.
Developed.😂 Probably only 2 cities in the massive Russia.
only 2 city is devoloped, others are slave for that 2 city
Just move to Dzerzhinsk if you’re tired of living and don’t want to end it all by your own hands 😎
Life expectancy is 42 years for men and women get 5 more to a whopping 47!
That’s the same as the 1200s where the black death killed half of Europe 👍
@Mikkel Thybo it's a shame that Russia's citizens are powerless in that regard.
Please make one about Mexico's environmental problems too, they're no joke either and I bet it's the same for many places in the world...
But Mexico isn't an adversary to DW masters in US, so DW doesn't care.
DW is American based and America's government makes it illegial to talk about Mexicos pollution.
And guess what... You can't drink tap water even in Moscow or St. Petersburg. Also I remember Sochi during 2014 Winter Games, where all tap water came out brown.
Why a country would spend a fortune on weapons when its own people are hurting for the most basic needs is beyond me.
Human stuoidity bro
Why does United Snakes borrow a trillion dollars every year for War Department ??
Why do they tyrannize the world ?
Just because they can ??
Communism
@@h3egypt
Communism NEVER existed.
But you can observe Communism in the original TV show Star Trek
@@Alec72HD I come from a former socialist country... are you joking.. leave this b.s to the commies
I feel for the Russian people. Sad.
Russian people also don't care about the enviorment. They all use Apple and they all wear clothing that kills endangered animals.
@@insectbite1714 of course there are people who care. some of them appeared in the video. russian people don't care? what a broad statement.
@@insectbite1714 what does their clothing have to do with anything?
@@insectbite1714 You can see apple products in any city of the world.They have bigger problems than this.
@@2girls1cup36 the Russians in the video had Apple devices so no and also they don't seem to care. I know people from Russia they don't care about the enviorment at all
You in the West do not even realise how holy your government's is, compared to that in Russia.
Because we are not afraid of our governments we would rise up if we had to put up with that. Rise up and tell your government that you want change. If you don’t then It’s your own fault.
Pennsylvania is really corrupt.
Remember when they had the Olympics in Sochi and none of the hotels or brand new buildings had drinkable tap water?? How the hell did they expect to impress foreigners like that?
Well, I’m pretty sure they succeeded in impressing foreigners with level of corruption involved in building those facilities.
Just imagine what kind of leaders they have if they call citizens traitors when they complain about pollution.
RT: Germany’s issues DW: Russia’s issues
Afterwards: both drinking vodka. At least politicians ;) Within all fairness, DW is becoming more biased than BBC - and you have to watch something, so...
😂
Putin will probably disappear these poor folks for speaking out against that filthy water.
That's a fact probably. Sad
everything will be fine.
look, I live in Russia and you can say anything you want about Putin, or bad conditions you're living in.
red line is antigovernment activities.
c'mon, folks, we don't have censorship, all major internet resources are available (atleast for now xD)
and you can protest and demand stuff. sometimes this even works =) we're not China.
@@tearforall You can't help people who have been brainwashed by Western propaganda, they still think that people in Russia ride bears and drink vodka all day.
@@TheSecerko Well, DW will not make a film about the Polish coal areas and cities and what the winter air is like there.And this is a member of the European Union!Krakow,Poznan and so on still use coal as fuel in the cities!
There is a special hell for Putin and his cronies for what he has done to his country and her people.
you know there is lead poisoned water in the usa.
@@frankrenda2519 I am not saying you don't. However Russia is mainly Moscow and St-Petersburg. Outside of these 2 cities Russia is literally dead with nothing to show for.
@@gotfan7743 thats bull i have been to russia and your talking bs
@@frankrenda2519 Yes , there's lead , but we heard it in on our news. Our living standards are higher. If you want to live in Russia , go ahead.
@@chriskelleher349 Actualy America is worse than Russia in some ways. But Russia is worse in some ways. But America is worse in some ways. But Russia is oe
This will haunt human kind for a long time🥺
Russia & environmental
Two words that doesn't sit right in the same book never mind the same page.
@Drone Strike and heads to Siberia to cut some timber
It's always said that Russia is the largest country in the world. I'm curious how much of it is actually habitable. Between nuclear disasters and waste problems making land unusable, it has to knock off a lot of the country's size.
This was a awesome video Thankyou xo
3:15 When IRL looks like a poor contrast video your old phone from 2008 would make.
Fifty shades of grey Putin!
Filthy shades of Putin.
I am just shocked and speechless!
All lies.
Can we have the rest of the documentary please
Censored by putins agents
no because its propaganda to make russia look bad
@@davidanalyst671 nah! It's propaganda to Kremlin bots but for us it's real.
Come on now DW, you are so on point most of the time, why then is Crimea dark grey coloured like Russia on the map and not light grey like Ukraine? What's that about?
Disputed territory, not to coz too much crap storm in comments
I'm not going to demonize Russia as an American we definitely need to work harder at the environment. I hope they are ok and don't suffer from any environmental damage.
tell that to china
It has to be inefficient when the cities are so far away. Geopolitic decides if a country is successful. Russia does have very bad conditions.
Putin’s Russia. Lol
RT's Russia too.
To be fair this was Soviet's Russia too for half a century. Nothing has changed.
@8:35 in soviet union under planned economy at least factory water went rudimentary cleaning.
I had to do a 15 page essay on plastic pollution and Russia was one of the worst countries and America was one of the better countries for management of plastic. Which I was honestly surprised I thought America would be the worst but it wasn’t!
Poor children..
That is a shame.i am so sorry for you good folks.
Complains about polluted air. Proceeds to litter the cigarette thru the window 😂
this is russians in their essence haha
When things are bad you do things worse to feel better. Addictions. Drugs.Alcohol.Smoking.
and people in iceland show how grateful they are to have the cleanest air in europe by being the #1 biggest smokers on earth
can you please tell the Russia's approach to environmental issues
Please 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Environmental problems there are terrible such as other Russian problems (high criminal rate, corruption, poverty, inequality, conscription etc.)
Russia looks pretty third world!!!
@@cristinataliani5619 Fourth world...
@@alexandersuvorov2002 Fifth world.
"You will never survive"..Russian "Hold my Vodka"
Can the government take action to address this hazardous matter that affects people and young children health
Nah, buying another set of gold claded toiled brushes made in Italy for the yougest mistress is clearly more important than those useless particle separators.
Water is dirty, but vodka is clean.
Very sad😔
Thanks for good video.
Thank you for watching! Be sure to check out our channel for more content. :-)
They should seek help from USA’s EPA agency their research is phenomenal on pollution control. Almost all cities have AQI under 50.
Russia don't seek help from others. The leadership would rather let their people die.
Remember Kursk?
I am Canadian over 50 yrs. Even here land fill dumps are even closer to residential homes in some areas and the smell of methane is strong so we are not perfect either. This story makes me sad because I love Russia and its people. They are strong and smart people and I hope they rise above this
Interesting that the map shows the Crimean peninsula as crosshatched. I realize Russia sees it as theirs, but the Ukraine, the United Nations, and most other countries agree it belongs to the Ukraine, despite Russian occupation.
Yes, in particular Germany talking about sanctions meanwhile constructing Nord Stream 2. Biggest hypocrite pro-Russian CDU. DW bowing to Russia with Crimea crosshatched. Sorry but that's how it really is. Disgrace
Crimea belonged to Soviet Russia till 1954, when Khruschev transferred it to Ukraine as a gift to a friendly soviet republic. The latter became -NATO-sided country. No friendship, no Crimea. Once big brother presented it than took it away. Russia is too powerful and mighty even with all its weaknesses and you know this owing to Stalingrad. As for the UN, you probably mean western countries and former soviet satellites which became anti-Russian to the extent of animal hatred. The rest of the world hardly ever interfere with Russian internal affairs and claims its sovereignty over Crimea.
@@vicdor1031 yeah, gift… Let’s also recall that, before, Crimea didn’t have any adequate access to fresh water, therefore after the transfer to Ukraine, Crimean canal was built to bring Dnipro’s water to desalinate soils and to develop the region. And for years it was presented as “gracious” gift to Ukraine, although, now we can see that Ukraine can exist without Crimea, but it is a matter of time how long Crimea will last without Ukrainian water resources.
@@jackvermont88 if Crimea lasted for thousands and thousands years before the canal was built so, then where do you see any problem? Crimea after all is not a desert and even now during summer time water supply is though sometimes restricted but stable.
@@vicdor1031 of course, but let’s not forget the fact that population of the peninsula one thousand years ago and now is different, as well as infrastructure and agriculture development. You can say it will last for years, but I would rather say it will deteriorate to what it was before. As water demand is critical, people already started to complain of water shortages and realize the 2014 consequences.
I couldnt imagine living like that, i guess its what you are used to but it is so terribly sad.
Residents of Kuban and Krimea already feel a lack of water. Water in the South of Russia has been disappearing for a long time. Add here intensive agroculture, increasing number of newlycomers and tourists and you get a black future for those parts of Russia. It's gonna become a desert.
Crimea is not a part of Russia
Crimea - stolen land of Ukraine, not part of Russia!
This is not the main point of my message and video. You'd better focus on water
@@gregoriyrogerg6296 it is a main point. There is enough water in Crimea as long as it belongs to Ukraine.
@@OscarMariadella Yeah for Crimea that is true. But he is also right. Southern Russia, and the region as a whole, have been having water shortages. Even the Dnepr river that feeds Crimea (when under Ukraine control) is seeing less water.
With Russia's expanding agriculture sector due to sanctions, the Aral sea catastrophe may well, in some ways, repeat itself.
Depressing.
The vodka is cleaner than the water in russia
This is so sad.
This is so fake.
🇷🇺👍
@@Alec72HD drinking the koolaid like a real patriot
@@bigounce1292
Maybe i know a little more than you.
I am from Russia, but most of information that i consume is in English.
And it is 90% lies when they talk about Russia.
This has been going on since the Czars, the Soviets perfected it, the Russian government carries on the tradition.
I noticed this same culture in all of the former Soviet states. It doesn't matter if it's Slavic, Turkic or Circassian. They all have certain people who once they achieve certain levels of wealth .They begin to behave like they are Feudal Lord's. They become entitled and apathetic to their fellow community members. All it's takes is for them to get a little money and they in exchange screw over their fellows. They want to drive the latest Mercedes, wear Gucci and use iPhones. Corruption is ingrained in many of these former Soviet states.
@@grimgoreironhide9985 problem is that most people who actually care and want to make a difference, not just profit, leave coz they know they can do nothing, nothing changes and thus cycle continues
Truly an unmatched superpower!
Stuffy, dirty, turbid... That was she said
@DW Documentary When are you going to do a documentary on Pollution in Germany 🇩🇪?
6:45: so this poor man's monthly pension is less than 90 dollars a month... 3rd world country. Oh well, Putin has just poisoned another dissident so it is time for us to start clapping. 🤣
actually my grandmother in India gets 12000 rs a month which is like 200$ so worse than 3rd world, and food in INdia is dirt Cheap.
it is said that he has to spend 75$ a month on water that is almost 1/3 of his pension. So his pension is around 225-250$. On pension in Russia you also get free transport card within the region of living and some subsidies for medicine. But anyway that's not too much.
So sad...
So fake.
Sovient System was much better for these people
wtf
haven't you ever heard about lots of russian great scientists, poets and even war figures who were an order of magnitude better than other people , but who have been oppressed by these system, eh?
@@gabarite_0.5
Fake Western propaganda.
There was a brief period before WW2 like that.
Just like United Snakes had slavery and Democratic party supported it (slavery).
I'm sorry but it sounds like to me these people need to stop waiting on the Government to solve their problems. But it pretty obvious that complaining isn't going to fix the problem. Build your own large settling tanks and charcoal filters for the water. Do something. The Government is not the answer.
All is true😭 and there is no daylight in the tunnel till 2036 at least.
And what is going to happen in 2036 that may change all this?
@@arkadybelsky4256 Putin and some ministers can not be re-elected. If he won't rewrote constitution. Again.
Individual action plans for reducing impacts that cause said environmental issues:
1. Take responsibility for your own garbage, for example doing 3R or zero waste
2. Rely less on industrial/manufactured products
I heard someone say once, and it made perfect sense, about people in Soviet bloc countries. Soviet people are absolutely awesome people, ruled over by some epic assholes.
Not so black and white, many of these awesome people will vote for Putin next time and blame west for all their problems, because TV state propaganda said so. This reality i’m living.
That's what I thought, but where do all those shitty governors come from?
The main problem with Russia is our NIMBY mentality. We want change, but "you do it first and I will follow, maybe". Also Soviet leftovers in older generations of entrusting everything to the government without holding it accountable doesn't help either
Just more evidence, that balance is needed..... left and right ways of thinking...working together...not against each other
Save Our Planet
I enjoy visiting Russia and the Russian people. However, the water problem isn't just outside big cities. In St. Petersburg, everyone boils the tap water before drinking due to critters in the water that will cause diarrhea. In Moscow, washing my white cotton clothes caused the fabric to turn sepia. Upon returning home (US), I tried re-washing then bleaching my whites but to no avail. How do Russians keep their white cotton clothes white when the water from the pipes are full of rust?!
I live in Moscow and just use regular washer and regular washing powder (without any whitening stuff), do not have any problems with whities. You can drink tap water and won't get sick but we boil it just to be safe. Though I would not recommend to drink tap water in Moscow since Moscow is a huge city and the water can not be as good as in small towns in the mountains :) However, rust water do may occur especially during short time after central water system was shut of and swittched on back again (if there were maintainance works for example), then the "first flow" is very rusty usually.
@@alexl7559 do a lot of people still make kvass?
@@justinfilipovic8939 I don't know a single person who makes kvas by themselves. However, many people do drink it and during summer there are many street places to but it in addition to bottled kvas sold in grocery stores all year around
Can we just talk about that kids drip in the beginning of the documentary
Canada has places like this too which the federal government neglects.
Bullshit!
1:00 that kid clean af though. Js.
Imagine being Russian or Belarussian and defending Putin on the internet...
That's what Russian hackers do on a coffee break.
I pity them.
Yeah I'm imagining it, what now?
if you acctualy belive that changing power will solve these problems, you haven't read anything
yes imagine how much they're getting paid
It seems like the water issue could be solved relatively easily with water purifiers and filters in people's homes.
Yep, ask the Flint Water Corporation to help!
but then you won't be able to make DW Documentary :) Tap water is relatively clean, in the video they show it and say that there is problem with pressure. But that pressure is enough to fill it in for cooking. Having a shower or bath is a problem though.
They prefer to buy Apple tablets instead and watch their “great leader” talk about nukes aimed at the west.
The communists had clean water, and the capitalists have dirty water.
@Andy Mills There is way more oppression in the USA.
Because capitalism is truly evil, it's all about exploiting workers and destroying environment.
Earth of the future will have communism, just like in popular American TV show Star Trek.
@@Alec72HD The level of brainwashing your mind has been subjected to is beyond any rational belief, even among most hardcore Putin supporters in Russia... 😂🤣😁
@@jazzypoo7960 Actually brain dead
@@jazzypoo7960 Oppressed in the USA ? Hardly. Its a fantasy put forward for power . The real oppressor are the addictions of the individual.
People in post-Soviet countries have used to government acting like a parent, fairly providing them everything, free of charge. They weren't properly educated on their newly acquired political and financial rights and RESPONSIBILITIES of market economy and democracy. Many rural communities still don't have a proper government due to lack of contenders (no salary, part-time and only for locals) and thus unable to manage their problems or even officially request financial aid from federal budget.
Find one of the most polluted places in Russia and make a video about it and leaves the audience with an impression that the whole Russia is like that.
Russian could’ve easily done the same by finding the most polluted areas or the most impoverished neighborhood in Germany and make a video about it and slap on a title like DW’s.
Regardless, of the bias you’re implying. You think this particular place is managed well? Does it look right to you? And DW doesn’t shy away from speaking about issues in Europe either by the way
Lord - The West is brimming with hypocrisy.
It’s important to recognize the double standards at play with certain Washington-aligned environmental organizations. These groups often use environmental issues as a pretext for anti-Russian campaigns, turning legitimate environmental concerns into tools of political pressure and unfair competition. This approach not only hinders genuine global cooperation on environmental protection but also undermines trust and the chance for constructive dialogue on shared challenges.
Yes..it's true Russia is No.1 in poor air quality index..
2. Is New Delhi..India
You're a lier, the most air polutet Russian city is on the 35th position, even not close to China and India. Even the US's Los Angeles's or Korean Seoul's air quality is worse, than Russia's Krasnoyarsk, due to the international AQI index.
India's Delhi is on the 11th position and its air is almost twice more unclean, than in the most poluted Russian city.
It’s so bad there no sensor on earth can truly measure how fucked up Delhi’s Air is. Moscow’s average yearly AQI is between 50 to 70. Delhi is a giant šhithole compared to Moscow. And also women do not get raped there.
@@B1sher Los Angeles's air pollution is related to the surrounding hills . And on windy days you get forest fires.
@@chriskelleher349 The same as in Syberia you get a lot of forest fires. It's literally one of the most forest-rich places on earth.
I wish I could buy that old man a water purifier.
Flint Michigan and many other places in the United States are still deprived of clean drinking water this is not a Russian problem this is a world problem
Why aren't these folks using P&G water purification pouches in the meantime ? :(
Because 99.9% of Russians have plenty of clean water
Who cares about some paid actor working for DW fake news.
@@Alec72HD do you live in russia?
All Country Have Same Like This Maybe Switzerland, German, Sweden, Can Help With Problems Like This?
Thats worst than flint Michigan
Authorities doing everything possible.... Ha! C’mon in says the spider 🕷
The title seems to suggest all of Russia has environmental issues, but the documentary only describes the experiences of a single town and provided no evidence to extrapolate to all of Russia. It's a shame DW is exaggerating.
Side note, cigarettes in the mouths of those speaking about pollution issues doesn't really add up.
Yes, the irony of Germany complaining about the environment in another country. They've done their level best to change the environment of virtually every country in Europe and certainly their neighbours. That human and ecological disaster will probably take another 100 years to rectify.