ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ย. 2024
- In this video Chris and I join @ToolBoxBuzz to help out comparing some of the newest professional grade top handle battery powered chainsaws on the market today!
@echousa @greenworkstools @husqvarna @MakitaToolsUSA @MilwaukeeTool @stihlusa
The saws we compared were:
1. Echo DCS-2500T / 56V eFORCE 2.5 Ah Battery
2. Greenworks Commercial 2013702 / 48V Dual Volt 4.0 Ah Battery
3. Husqvarna T540i XP / 36V BLi200X 5.2 Ah Battery
4. Makita XCU08 36V / (2X) 18V LXT 5.0 Ah Batteries
5. Makita XGT GCU03 / 40V Max 5.0 Ah Battery
6. Milwaukee 2826 / 18V FUEL 12.0 Ah Battery
7. Stihl MSA 161T / 36V AP 300S 8.8 Ah Battery
8. Stihl MSA 220TC / 36V AP500S 8.8 Ah Battery
EASTONMADE WOOD SPLITTERS: www.eastonmade...
RUGGEDMADE LOG SPLITTERS: bit.ly/3UoeIkT
KUBOTA USA: www.kubotausa....
BIG TOOL RACK: www.bigtoolrac...
Promo Code: DUDERANCH5
SURE-TRAC TRAILERS: sure-trac.com/
#cormidi #kubotausa #stihl #suretractrailers #woodmaxx #ruggedmade #bigtoolrack
Check out the official Dude Ranch DIY Merchandise!!
www.bonfire.com/duderanchdiy
Product Links:
VANPOWERS PORTABLE POWER STATION: www.vanpowers....
NOCO BATTERY JUMPER: amzn.to/3DVKK12
MILWAUKEE HACKZALL: amzn.to/3PDjyao
ACCUSHARP KNIFE & TOOL SHARPENER: amzn.to/3BVLNdQ
5 ELEVEN DESIGNZ BRUSHGUARD: www.5elevendes...
LED SOLAR SPOTLIGHTS: amzn.to/3qxYGH6
HEAVY DUTY CASTER WHEELS: amzn.to/3GLmAVX
VODA HEAT POWERED STOVE FAN: amzn.to/314l9lP
GALAFIRE MAGNETIC THERMOMETER: amzn.to/3Emykgn
RUTLAND LIQUID STOVE POLISH: amzn.to/3GsJxOn
LARGE EQUIPMENT FUNNEL: amzn.to/2NuMFlT
4’X20’ HEAVY DUTY IBC TOTE FIREWOOD TARP: amzn.to/3tVIUql
FISKARS 8LB SPLITTING MAUL: amzn.to/3ptDMqx
ACC-U-MARK FIREWOOD MEASURING STICK: acc-u-mark.com...
ACCU-STICK PRO FIREWOOD MEASURING STICK: www.baileysonl...
STIHL 2 IN 1 EASY CHAINSAW SHARPENER: amzn.to/3oJJFj2
SNO-SEAL WATERPROOFING: amzn.to/3pu51RL
KINCO 1938 GLOVES: amzn.to/34IOGAK
GENERAL MOISTURE METER: amzn.to/3mGaWBb
FISKARS HOOKAROON: amzn.to/2WBtrMy
MINGO MARKER FIREWOOD MEASURING TOOL: amzn.to/3mVGymC
3M WORKTUNES: amzn.to/3se8zJL
Check us out on Instagram and Facebook! @duderanchdiy
Email us Questions! duderanchdiy1@gmail.com
Featured Equipment at the Dude Ranch:
- Kubota L3901
- Cormidi C-1500 Mini Loader
- Erskine Industrial Grapple
- Big Tool Rack Tractor Carry All
- Everything Attachments 55” Wicked Root Rake Grapple
- WoodMaxx MX-8800 Chipper
- Land Pride RCR-1260 Rotary Cutter
- RuggedMade RS-737 Log Splitter with Auto Cycle and Hydraulic Wedge Lift
- Stihl MS 192 T
- Stihl MS 200 T
- Stihl MS 201 T
- Stihl MS 290 Farm Boss
- Stihl MS 362
- Stihl MS 500i
- Husqvarna 455 Rancher
- Husqvarna 580 BFS Backpack Blower
- Milwaukee Hatchet Handheld Chainsaw
- Mingo Marker Firewood Measuring Tool
- Accu-Mark Magnetic Firewood Marking Stick
- Polaris Sportsman 500 H.O.
- International 4700LP Hook Lift Truck
- Sure-Trac 7'x14' Low Profile HD Dump Trailer w/ Custom Built Log Arch & Winch
At around the 17:49 mark, the narrator asked whether or not the ambient (outdoor) temperature will have an effect on the battery used to power the saw under test, which, in this case, was the Stihl MSA 220 TC saw with the AP 500 S battery installed. This question is a very good question that gets to one of the main downsides of battery-powered motors of any kind. Outdoor temperatures have a definite physical effect on how electricity flows. In general, higher temperatures increase the resistance to electron flow, and as the resistance increases, current flow decreases, which, in this case, means that the saw's motor will not spin as efficiently as it would under ideal conditions. Battery performance is also impacted by very cold conditions. It is widely known that electronic circuitry performs more efficiently under cooler conditions, but this is only true to a certain extent. The general rule is that electron flow will be adversely impacted by temperature extremes: be it high ambient temperatures or very low ambient temperatures. In short, modern battery tech performs very well under ideal conditions, but not so much when it comes to use in harsh weather conditions.
Very well said!
I know a lot of people here talk down on Ryobi, However as a upcoming arborist on a budget I bought the Ryobi 40v 12 inch top handle saw and replaced the bar with a 14 inch and I’ll tell you what that sucker is a beast. Not too many things it won’t cut through. I would like to see how it compares to other brands.
I’m sure it works well, they have come a long way
Arborist here. Ive got the echo and it's joy to use in the tree. And will say the stock echo chain on them is dog crap and its like a safety chain think thats why its chattering a lot probaby be better with a better 3/8 low pro . That saw runs great on 1/4" chain and will power through 12-14inches no problem and is probaby the lightest here. I found the battery to last ages too, obviously it doesn't match those bigger saw for power but they are quite a bit heavier.
I really enjoyed the echo for a pruning saw.
Did you put a panther kit on it?
@Johnnyreengo yeah here in uk. I bought from the maker of those bars. At the moment, I've got a 10", but also got a 12" 1/4. Seems to handle that fine, not sure if 14" would be overkill for it. But it's not designed to do massive cuts, really, and chogging down big stems🤷🏻♂️
Absolutely awesome video! I appreciate the effort you guys put into it. 28:40 None of these saws are meant for full take downs. Echo + panther kit= Winner, IMHO
if you add cost into the equation i went with the milwaukee. only $350 for just the tool if you already have batteries for milwaukee tools then that's got the best cutting power for the price IMO. i have ran it on the 12.0 but also have ran it on my 8.0s and even 6.0s and had surprisingly long runtime while using it in a commercial setting while on job sites on the ground and up in the tree and it performs great. there is a clear window to see how much bar oil is left in the tank which helps remember to fill it when it gets low. it is a little heavy but for the price etc i cannot complain. nice video guys. take er easyyyy
I really enjoyed using the Milwaukee and I already have the batteries
If you are 8.0 and below this is for limbs only I have found. Any kind of chunks requires the 12. The oiler is also insufficient in that not ENOUGH oil is discharged I have found and the oiler is NOT adjustable which means you and I dear sir are screwed. I oil the bar before going up and it cuts MUCH better and now have to use expensive store bought oil instead used engine/transmission/gear oil. Another grip is any kind of greenery and the stupid idiot who made the bar attachment cover has it NARROW down and it JAMS full of leaves and it also jams with chips. Another gripe is Milwaukee PURPOSEFULLY made their bar slightly longer so one cannot just buy normal STiHL/ECHO chains theirs are 1 link longer and the saw comes with the pathetic safety chain which required MASSIVE filing to make it function decently instead of full chisel.
Enjoyed the video (although a little bias towards Stihl). I have both the Echo and the Husky. When it comes to limbing out a tree I go for the Echo. Light, well balanced and batteries last (I do have two batteries, but rarely have to go to my second battery). It carries so nice on my harness and works great with the petzl caritool (one hand in and out). I switch to the Husky for topping and chunking down aways...and then go to a more powerful rear handle. For me, the Echo DCS-2500T is the go to electric chainsaw for limb work.
Tried not to be biased, the Stihl was powerful but heavy and had some annoying safety features. My favorites were the makita, Milwaukee, and echo
@@DudeRanchDIYwhich Makita? I own the 2x18V version. The stalling and power from zero can be a pain. In the video also the 40V version stalled. But would you think it could be worth switching?
I not know about all those model's I have the Stihl 161T for over 3 years change I change the 25 cm bar for 35cm, have used and abused this little saw way over manufacturers recommendation so far it never fail.
Cool collaboration, I’m always on the lookout for their vans and trucks whenever I’m working in the Boston suburbs. Small world man
One of the advantages of battery top handle saws is that you don't have to start with a cord while you are up in the tree.
Correct
Is that why they're called cordless tools?
If you are going to include Milwaukee and greenworks, you needed Ryobi's 40v top handle.
Yes! Ryobi is looked down on
Oh boy do I want one of these! 😍 Great test!
They sure are sweet! Thanks for watching Andrew!
Being only a gardener, I don't use chainsaws that much. Most of my tools are Husqvarna, with a few Stihl's in the mix. I currently use a 455 Rancher for logging, and the odd felling. I also have a Milwaukee M12 Hatchet for limbing, which I find great. Having one tool that could do both would be nice. For me, the Husky looked the best all round!
The Stihl 220 seems like plenty of power, but the ergonomics and price are horrible. I'm a fan of the Echo 2500 for pruning and small removals. A narrow kerf bar and chain helps a lot.
Yeah they are pretty expensive, the echo was an awesome little saw
Loved the review. That Stihl 220 TC and the Milwaukee seem to be the best overall. Happy 4th.
They were all pretty impressive, battery technology has come a long way
I own a Stihl and love it! You can operate it with one hand, it's great for the deer lease!
I really liked the Stihl but they are quite the investment!
I'd love to see a chain comparison 12" bars comparing cut speed between, narrow kerf 043 (1.1) 1/4 .325 and 3/8 and standard kerf 050(1.3)
Full chisel
Basically I'm just thinking there has to be a chain that is the most efficient for battery saws in terms of cut speed, stall prevention, battery drainage etc, people rave about 1/4 panther but the oregon/husqy .325 is suppose to be the new innovation and Stihl has there narrow kerf 3/8 for battery saw
That would be interesting to see!
Uh, you are utterly confused. NONE of what you typed is KERF(cutting width in the wood). 1/4, .325, 3/8, .404 are LINK LENGTH! NOT kerf! O43 or 051 are NOT KERF, this is chain bar guide width for the TEETH fro the chain in the bar...
What's your point these sizes come together and effect the kerf, they produce a narrow kerf compared to the regular sized counter parts
Why did you edit out the cutting with the Makita around 32:20?
Has the data been put online yet? I can't find the numbers.
Great video with real users. Thanks guys!
I don’t believe they have posted it yet.
@@DudeRanchDIY Thanks.
Most of them have bms
and bms are the area they heat up and needed to cool down
cells can handle heat more than BMS
Great review guys, very informative. If I might add it’s time for some new shades Jake. You look like you’re wearing a 4ft x 8ft bathroom mirror on your face. Lol
In my opinion, safety glasses can never be too big. I don’t care what they look like, they’re ANSI z87+ rated, polarized, and have replaceable lens. They do a hell of a job keeping sawdust out of my eyes, that’s all I’m worried about.
@@DudeRanchDIY I agree after having cataract surgery. Cause I'm old, safety glasses are a MUST!! Send me the link again, please!!
heatwavevisual.com
Promo code: DUDERANCH10
😂
The two hooks on the back of the husky saw: one for the saw lanyard the other for the hook on the saddle. Made more room to easily hang it.
Why does no one evaluate the Kobalt 80-volt brushless 18" chainsaw with a 5-ah battery? - - I have (2) Kobalt 80-volt 18" Bar Chainsaws and use (2) 5 AH Batteries. Using it on a Southeast LA farm that was devastated by a Hurricane and has been working absolutely great even cutting huge logs and trees. For oil, I like to use Ryobi Bar and chain oil. We have cut 20"+_ logs and it works like a charm. And NO more pulling and pulling to start a gas-powered chainsaw. My first 80-volt 18" Bar Chain saw with a 5-AH Battery and charger was $400 in Jul 2021
Because it’s not a commercial grade top handle arborist saw like all of the others evaluated in this comparison.
@@DudeRanchDIY - Thats true. I just don't see this saw being tested against others in its range of power and size. Would just like to be able to hear those kind of pros and cons about it and how it stacks up. (No pun intended) 🙂
Every single time I see any sort of comparison video with a Milwaukee power-tool in it, the Milwaukee either wins easily or once in a very rare while it'll come up as a *very* close 2nd place. Each and every single time! Yeah, I'm going to standardize on Milwaukee's 18volt battery platform. I'm not a contractor, I don't work for one. I don't make money off of my tools. But I just want power-tools that'll last. I'm not interested in DIY homeowner Budget brands (we all know which ones I'm talking about), that are made from the cheapest components on the inside, no lube inside either, designed to work great when new; turn to garbage with use and time. Go out, buy another one. I despise disposable power-tools!
Milwaukee makes some really great products, very happy I chose their battery platform from the get go!
Awesome review 👌🏻🔥🇨🇦
Much appreciated!
Woww...keren boss
Please, Dewalt Dccs674B review 🥺
No Dewalt in your test ? Most people have extra batteries and chargers already ?
I don’t believe their current top handle saw on the market is targeted towards professional commercial arborists which is why it wasn’t included in this test.
I have 3 and they work well and having extra batteries and chargers really keep you working with no waiting .
Sorry I did not understand the assignment, the price to a climber a cheaper climbing saw and they may already have batteries, I also bought a Ego 16” rear handle saw because I have extra batteries and chargers lots of power with a very big battery . A lot of times You have to start with less than you would like because of the Dollars until you can afford . But your show was pro battery top handle saws .
There seems to be a big performance difference with the Makita batteries.
I believe he said one is newer technology and 40v
Great Review! 🪵👍🏼🇺🇸
Thanks 👍
Sorry the little chain. Def dont hit the rakers or catch all day. Thanks
Sorry battery only. But 540 hard to beat. Great vid thanks'
Forgot the ego
I believe they reached out to ego but they didn’t want to play ball
I like my ego. It’s a good little saw. I have even dropped a couple of 8” trees with it. And loads of saplings. Ego won me over because of the Ego trimmer and blower I bought. So same battery drove my decision. Price was head to head with the Milwaukee. I only looked at Stihl, and Husqvarna on line.
I got the Ryobi 40V due to being able to find a kit with a 4Ah for ~159$ new with carrying case. There are a few things I don't love about it (no captive nut, the sight glass is too opaque to see the oil level)... but it rips, so I'd imagine it has some mechanical influence from its M18 brother.
th-cam.com/video/APoMixxMbDk/w-d-xo.html
I’ll check it out
No!
Very weak battery chain saws not work! My Stihl 880 and 171 more better
Saw another video on the Husqvarna saw Steele Loop as for the lanyard have a plastic one is to hook on your belt
Ah that makes sense
I have the small Makita, it stalls easily!! Thanks for showing us these tests!! Im still not convinced on batteries for top handle saws!! Have a Great 4th of July Y'all!! Stay Hydrated and Have a Safe Day
They definitely have their place, I’d love to use the stihl for a removal
Agreed on the Echo. I like it but it has limits. That's my small tree/pine saw. Love the Husky except for the back weight, makes it hard to hold to make a notch on the opposite side of a limb or top. The safety switch never bothered me.
You guys did a good job on the video. As far as the saws go... i am not accepting less of a product for more money. I'll stick with dinosaur juice.
The boost mode on the 18Vx2 Makita isn’t so much a different speed, it just (temporarily) bypasses the battery protection, allowing you to draw max power from the batteries. Meaning you can push it harder without it stalling. Especially useful when you need to cut some larger diameter wood. You can only run it in that mode for short periods of time before it switches back to normal mode.
Good to know! Thanks for watching
I don’t think it changes speed at all. Just gives more torque but really don’t notice much difference in the modes.
@@danielreynolds6498 indeed, chain speed (without any load) remains the same as far as I know, but it doesn’t drop in RPM / cut out as fast when under load as it is allowed to draw more current from the batteries. I have a video on my channel that compares the 2 modes, it does make a significant difference.
@@frankv84 iv been using makitia hedgers and chainsaws in my business I think there great tools.
Good review, thorough handling review. Did not notice you sharpening the chains though or discussing kerf setup. Very important in battery powered saw. Nor any mention of oiling adjusability(though briefly) as you never were able to have enough hands on time with all of them. Can't have everything... =)
I bought the Milwaukee and you guys missed a few negative things. Cover plate gets jammed easily as the idiot who designed it made the opening where twigs/leaves/chips go in LARGER than the exit for the chips, leaves... Pure genius, along with leaving nice big RIDGES inside the cover to block the chips. I haven't even had it in wet conditions and it is jamming. Likewise back ramp holds chips like mad. Its oiler is substandard leaving to HIGH friction and battery draining. Hand oiling helps quite a bit and you can hear the difference as well, MASSIVELY. Comes with garbage safety chain requiring MASSIVE sharpening and eliminating of the safety bumps to get it to cut fast. Literally cuts 2X as fast after filing. It is embarassingly slow out of the box.
I61 fast only cos got small chain. A 151 with little muff mod faster than them all. I think
The other part of this test can be found here: th-cam.com/video/uVUbjq91W5c/w-d-xo.html
Rekon some the teeth to big for the chain speed. Jumpy' not smooth like the little pci
Too bad you guy's didn't have access to the new 60v dewalt top handle. That one looks like a beast and comes kitted with two 9ah batteries.
Yeah I don’t think that was out at the time we filmed this
Love the sunglasses, style and safety in one package!
Yeah I love them!
I thought that looked like Scott A, then I remembered who your neighbors are....
You know all my friends…
what if you rigged up a belt pack of battery power? more for the bigger elec saws?? no batt in saw just a few on belt pack and a real nice flexible cord , twist lock 1/4 turn connector for quick disconnect. Neutrik makes them. i have tons of connectors and cable from doing live sound. if you want to build i have the parts to donate . i think the echo is the big dog of elec chainsaws?
I suppose that’s a possibility, although for this commercial arborist application a belt or backpack battery would get in the way of ropes and harnesses
How absurd is that statement? I do not know about you, but my saw is always on a lanyard and I have NEVER seen anyone in a tree without their saw on a lanyard... Do you honestly NOT have your saw on a lanyard in the tree????@@DudeRanchDIY
Great vid. Thanks
I bought the new Rigid Battery Chainsaw and it works great. I even upgraded the bar from the stock 12" to a 16" and I do not see any battery differences.
Haven’t seen that one!
That isn't a top handle though.
Wonder if milwaukee's new pouch cell batteries will give it a boost.
The big 12 amp hour batter gave it lots of power and runtime!
Milwaukee doesn’t have pouch cell yet
the most powerful Milwaukee battery are actually the High Output 6.0
those Samsung 30T cell can discharge at 50Amp easily with 2P - 100Amp
@@TranTek yet. They're in the works. They're calling them "forge" batteries.
Well, the pouch cells are MUCH cheaper is why as the High amperage cells are VERY limited in availability and high price due to high amount of cobalt required. @@jake-mv5oi